Professional Documents
Culture Documents
h i g h l i g h t s
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: The paper presents results of an investigation conducted to study the feasibility of use of Copper Slag (CS)
Received 18 September 2018 as aluminosilicate material for developing Alkali-activated Cementitious Material (ACM). The effect of
Received in revised form 15 March 2019 addition of mineral admixtures such as Fly Ash (FA) and Metakaolin (MK) on the performance of
Accepted 18 March 2019
alkali-activated CS was also investigated. In addition to a control mix which was prepared using 100%
CS; two other mixes were also prepared by replacing CS with 30% FA and 30% MK respectively. These
mixes were activated using alkali content of 5% and 7% by weight of binder. Sodium hydroxide and
Keywords:
sodium silicate were used as alkali-activators. Compressive strength tests were performed on alkali-
Alkali-activated Cementitious Material
Compressive strength
activated cement mixes at different curing ages. The pore-size distribution, mineralogy and microstruc-
Copper Slag ture of selected alkali-activated cement mixes were determined using Mercury Intrusion Porosimetry
Microstructure (MIP), X-ray Diffraction (XRD) and Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) with Energy Dispersive X-ray
Porosity Spectroscopy (EDS). Test results indicate that CS has great potential as aluminosilicate material for devel-
oping ACM. Further, the addition of mineral admixtures in alkali-activated CS cement improves its per-
formance; however, the addition of MK was found to be more effective than FA in terms of compressive
strength and microstructure development.
Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2019.03.233
0950-0618/Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
74 J. Singh, SP Singh / Construction and Building Materials 211 (2019) 73–79
of ACMs and supplementary cementitious materials lead to the After that the final concrete mix will be evaluated in terms of cost,
consumption of significant amount of GGBFS and FA. According energy suitability and environmental sustainability.
to a rough estimate, the use of GGBFS and FA in cement production
was of the order of 43.7 million tons and 39.8 million tons respec- 2. Experimental programme
tively in the year 2015 [10]. As cement consumption increases
rapidly, these materials are expected to fulfill approximately 20% 2.1. Materials used
requirement of total cement production by 2050 [11]. So, there is
Copper Slag obtained from Rajasthan, India was used in the investigation. To
a need to identify the new aluminosilicate materials such as Cop- enhance the performance of alkali-activated CS, FA and MK were added as addi-
per Slag (CS), which may be used as a precursor for the develop- tional source of alumina and silica. The chemical composition of CS, FA and MK
ment of ACM. was determined using X-ray fluorescence and is shown in Table 1. Commercially
Copper Slag is metallurgical waste generated during the available MK was used, which is supplied as MetaCem 85C and has calcining tem-
perature of 600–800 °C. It can be seen from Table 1 that there is significant amount
extraction of copper from copper ores. During smelting phase
of Fe2O3 in CS. The role of Fe2O3 in the geopolymerization process is vague. Other
reducing agent (Silica) separates the sulphides and oxides, which than CS, Fe rich slags have been thoroughly studied as potential precursors,
are present in the Copper ores. The sulphides do not make any although it remains yet unclear exactly how it participates at the atomic level in
anions and develop matte phase (Copper rich) and reducing geopolymerization. The Standard sand conforming to IS 650 [24] was used to pre-
pare alkali-activated cement mortars. Locally available Sodium Hydroxide (SH) and
agent combines with oxide to form slag phase (Impurities rich).
Sodium Silicate (SS) was used as alkali-activators. The SH was supplied in pellet
The water quenching of slag produces glassy, amorphous and form with 98% purity, whereas SS was supplied in solution form with Ms = 3.3
granulated slag. Copper Slag has a specific gravity in the range (Si2O = 26.5%, Na2O = 8%, H2O = 65.5% by weight). Only CS was ground in Laboratory
of 3.4–3.7 and consists of Fe (30–40%), SiO2 (35–40%), Al2O3 Ball Mill using 20 mm and 25 mm stainless steel balls for 2 h to attain its fineness
(<10%), CaO (<10%) and Cu (0.5–2.1%) [12]. It was estimated that equal to FA. As such there in no standard available regarding specification of CS for
use as cement. However, the specification of FA for use with cement is given in
in the smelting process, 2–3 times more CS is generated than
Indian Standard 3812. According to this standard, FA particles retained on 45 mm
copper and approximately 24.6 million tones of CS is generated IS sieve should be less than 34%. Therefore, to attain equal and more fineness than
annually worldwide [12]. Copper slag usually dumped at sites, FA, CS was sieved through 45-mm sieve.
which creates environmental issues and utilizes the valuable The ratio of stainless steel balls (kg) to CS (kg) was 2. The parentage passing
through 45-mm sieve for CS, FA and MK was 95%, 82% and 100% respectively. The
land. As per National Green Tribunal, around 3.52 lakh tonnes
specific gravity and BET surface area of used materials is given in Table 1.
of CS has dumped at Thoothukudi (Tamil Nadu, India), which The X-ray Diffraction patterns of CS, FA and MK are shown in Fig. 1. The XRD
affecting the surrounding agricultural land and water ways patterns show that CS is a fully amorphous material with minor peaks of crystalline
[13]. Copper Slag can be used as an abrasive material, manufac- mineral i.e. Fayalite (F) and Clinoferrosilite (C) and slags with a high degree of amor-
turing of floor tiles and glass-ceramic [14–16]. Copper slag has phous content reflect higher reactivity towards alkali-activation [5]. Strong devia-
tions of crystalline minerals; Quartz (Q) and Mulite (M) were detected on 2h
been used in construction industry as aggregates [17,18] and
range of 15° to 40° in MK and FA and some peaks of Magnetite (MT) and Sillimanite
also cementitious materials [19,20]. The presence of alumina (SM) were also detected. Except these crystalline peaks, MK and FA were observed
and silica in the CS makes it suitable as precursor in the to be partially amorphous materials.
alkali-activation [21–23]. Ahmari et al. [21] developed the ACM
using CS and mine-tailing (MT) as source of aluminosilicate. It 2.2. Mix proportions of alkali-activated cement mortars
was found that ACM synthesis using 100% CS and cured at
90 °C for 7 days exhibits the maximum compressive strength Alkali-activated cement mortars were prepared using CS, MK and FA as a binder
with standard sand in the ratio of 1:3. In addition to a control mix which was pre-
up to 50 MPa. Nazer et al. [22] studied the effect of curing time pared using 100% CS; two other mixes were also prepared by replacing CS with 30%
and curing temperature on the performance of alkali activated FA and 30% MK respectively. These mixes were activated using alkali content of 5%
CS cement matrices. The performance of heat cured specimens and 7% by weight of the binder. Sodium hydroxide and sodium silicate were mixed
at 65 °C for 3 days was similar to ambient cured specimens at to prepare the alkali activator solution of modulus Ms = 1.25 (Ms = Si2O/
Na2O = 1.25), which was constant for all the mixes. A water-to-solid ratio of 0.3
20 °C for 90 days. Qianmin et al. [23] studied the effect of
was fixed for all the mixes. Mix proportions of different mixes for 1000 g of the bin-
elevated temperature on the mechanical properties of alkali- der are given in Table 2.
activated CS. The optimum elevated temperature for alkali-
activated CS was 200 °C, above this mechanical properties of 2.3. Mixing, casting and curing
alkali-activated CS was reduced due to the decompositions of
hydration products. To prepare alkali activator solution, sodium hydroxide flakes were dissolved in
From above literature, it can be observed that heat curing of water and then sodium silicate was added in this solution and stirred constantly.
make it more suitable as cementitious material. The alkali- Si2O 37.6 56.6 58.1
activation process of CS was evaluated through compressive Al2O3 11.5 31.5 39.1
Fe2O3 42.4 4.72 1.21
strength tests conducted on mortar specimens with different per-
CaO 3.80 1.10 0.23
centages of CS and mineral admixtures. The results of microstruc- Na2O 0.74 0.10 0.08
ture analysis, porosity and reaction products of different mixes K2O 0.76 0.35 0.09
were also evaluated and compared. TiO2 0.37 1.62 0.83
SO3 0.01 0.32 0.13
It is mentioned here that the work reported in this paper is part
MgO 0.57 0.36 –
of a larger investigation on the strength and durability properties MgO 0.62 0.02 –
of alkali-activated copper slag concrete. First, the optimum synthe- P2O5 0.13 – –
sis parameters for alkali-activation of copper slag such as alkali MnO 0.01 – –
content, type of alkali, curing regime and mineral admixtures will Loss on ignition (%) 1.50 3.3 0.23
Specific gravity 3.21 2.34 2.62
be selected. The effects of these synthesis parameters on the
BET surface area (m2/kg) 503 465 1055
mechanical and durability properties of concrete will be evaluated.
J. Singh, SP Singh / Construction and Building Materials 211 (2019) 73–79 75
Table 2
Mix proportions for 1000 g of binder (By weight).
Mix CS (g) FA (g) MK (g) Sand (g) SH (g) SS (g) Water (g) Alkali content W/S ratio
1 1000 – – 3000 40 236 181 5% 0.3
2 700 300 – 3000 40 236 181 5% 0.3
3 700 – 300 3000 40 236 181 5% 0.3
4 1000 – – 3000 56 330 135 7% 0.3
5 700 300 – 3000 56 330 135 7% 0.3
6 700 – 300 3000 56 330 135 7% 0.3
W/S ratio = Water/Solid ratio, where water is water in activator and extra water; Solid is solid part of activators and binders.
The alkali activator solution was prepared 24 h prior to mixing to cool down the 2.6 Microstructure and mineralogy
temperature of the solution. First, dry materials such as CS, FA, MK and standard
sand were weighed in the required quantity and put into the mortar mixture and The microstructure of alkali-activated samples was observed using high-
mixed for 5 min. Subsequently, alkali activator solution was added in the mixer resolution field emission Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) with Energy Disper-
and mixed for another 2 min. After the mixing, the mortar was poured into cube sive X-ray Spectroscopy (EDS). Samples for SEM were put in ethanol to stop the
specimens of size 50 50 50 mm and sealed to prevent any moisture loss. reaction and then dried in an oven up to constant weight and for better observa-
Though expected, the authors did not observe any significant loss in workability tions; all samples were gold-coated. Mineralogical study of alkali-activated samples
on account of addition of MK. It can be seen from literature that the performance was carried out using X-Ray Diffraction (XRD). The XRD patterns were obtained
of heat cured alkali-activated CS specimens was better than ambient cured speci- using a Cu-Ka radiation under conditions of 45 kV and 40 mA. For SEM and XRD
mens [21–23]. Keeping this in view, the authors selected heat curing for the tests, samples were collected from broken cubes after conducting compressive
alkali-activation of CS. After the casting, the cube specimens in sealed condition strength tests at 28 days of curing of some of the mixes made with an alkali content
was placed into oven and heat cured for 24 h at 80 °C along with moulds. The spec- of 5%. The XRD test was also performed on raw aluminosilicate materials such as CS,
imens de-moulded and placed in laboratory conditions at a temperature of 25 ± 3 °C FA and MK.
and relative humidity of 50 ± 5% until testing. The specimens were cured in labora-
tory conditions for 3, 7 and 28 days until testing.
3. Results and discussion
2.4. Compressive strength test
3.1 Compressive strength
The compressive strength tests on alkali-activated CS cement mortars were
conducted as per IS 516 [25]. The compressive strength was determined using com-
pression testing machine of capacity of 2000 kN at a loading rate of 0.6 kN/s. The compressive strength results of different mixes of alkali-
activated CS cement mortars with different alkali contents and cur-
2.5. Pore-size distribution and porosity ing ages are shown in Fig. 2. The 28 days compressive strength of
alkali-activated CS mortars for 5% and 7% alkali content was
Pore-size distribution and porosity of alkali-activated CS cement mortars were 27.56 MPa and 34.12 MPa respectively, which seems to be suffi-
determined using Mercury Intrusion Porosimeter (MIP) at a pressure range of 0.2– cient for structural applications in various construction works.
50,000 psia. For MIP, samples were collected from broken cubes after conducting
compressive strength tests at 28 days of curing of some of the mixes made with
The amorphous nature of CS helps in the dissolution of silicates,
an alkali content of 5%. Prior to testing, the samples were dried in an oven at a tem- which promotes the alkali-activation process and improves com-
perature of 100 °C until constant weight was achieved. pressive strength [22]. The amorphous materials are structurally
76 J. Singh, SP Singh / Construction and Building Materials 211 (2019) 73–79
decreased. However, the addition of MK was found to be more Fig. 5. XRD patterns of alkali-activated CS, CS + FA and CS + MK mixes, 5% alkali
effective in reducing the porosity than FA. The reduced porosity content.
of mix containing MK may be attributed to the finer particles of
MK compared to FA, which is responsible for better particle pack- lite. The crystalline peaks of quartz and mulite were initially pre-
ing and results in the dense microstructure. The pore-size distribu- sent in MK and FA (Fig. 1), which were also reflected after alkali-
tion of different mixes is shown in Fig. 4, where the pores are activation in Fig. 5. The alkali-activated CS mix also shows the crys-
separated into mesopores (<50 nm diameter) and macropores talline peak of quartz and mullite, which may be due to non-
(>50 nm diameter). It has been found that MK-based mixture con- reactive silicate species. It was observed that new hydration prod-
sists of macropores, however the macropores compared to FA and ucts formed during alkali-activation process were not detected in
CS mix were negligible. The alkali-activation of MK produces NASH XRD patterns may be due to their amorphous nature. However,
type gel, which fills most of the macropores and gives more refined the MK mix contains very small peaks of zeolite X, which is alumi-
structure than mixes containing FA and CS. The porosities have a nosilicate mineral and represents the existence of aluminosilicate
direct relationship with the compressive strength of ACM. Lower gel.
porosity gives the refined structure and a more refined structure
of ACM can acquire uniform stress distribution, which leads to a
3.4. Microstructure
higher compressive strength [29–31]. The mix containing MK hav-
ing least porosity shows better compressive strength than mixes
Micrographs of alkali-activated CS, CS + FA and CS + MK mixes
containing FA and CS.
with 5% alkali content were detected using SEM and are shown
in Fig. 6. It can be observed that alkali-activated CS mix shows
maximum micro-cracks as seen in Fig. 6(a). Some micro-cracks
3.3. Mineralogy
were also observed in alkali-activated CS + FA mix as can be seen
in Fig. 6(b), but alkali-activated CS + MK mix shows most compact
X-ray diffraction patterns of mixes activated with 5% alkali con-
and dense microstructure in Fig. 6(c). In addition to this, some
tent are shown in Fig. 5. The XRD patterns of various mixes tested
geopolymer gel phase was also detected as a brightened portion
in this investigation indicate crystalline peaks of quartz and mul-
in the alkali-activated CS + MK mix. Microstructure analysis
reflects that alkali-activated CS mix has most porous structures,
but the addition of FA and MK makes its structure dense due to
the formation of geopolymer gel and smaller particle size of FA
and MK also helps in solidification of the microstructure of
alkali-activated CS mix. Due to the densest microstructure of
alkali-activated CS + MK mix, it demonstrates the highest compres-
sive strength amongst all mixes.
Test results of EDX analysis of alkali-activated mixes are also
shown in Fig. 6. The Al/Si ratio is most important factor in alkali-
activated materials for determination the behavior of geopolymer
gel. The increase of Al/Si ratio indicates more dissolved aluminum
in alkaline medium and which enhances its contribution in forma-
tion of geopolymer gel [32]. In Fig. 6(f), alkali-activated mix CS
+ MK shows maximum Al/Si ratio, which indicates its well-
formed geopolymeric matrix. Some atoms of Fe are shown in
EDX of alkali-activated mixes of CS and CS + FA in Fig. 6(d) and
(e) respectively. The lower compressive strength of alkali-
activated CS and CS + FA mixes is due to presence of Fe in these
Fig. 4. Pore size distribution of alkali-activated CS, CS + FA and CS + MK mixes mixes. The existence of Fe in alkali-activated mixes provides resis-
indicating Mesopores and Macropores, 5% alkali content. tance to discharge of Si and Al in an alkaline environment, which
78 J. Singh, SP Singh / Construction and Building Materials 211 (2019) 73–79
Fig. 6. SEM micrographs of alkali-activated mixes (a) CS (b) CS + FA (c) CS + MK and EDX analysis results of alkali-activated mixes (d) CS (e) CS + FA (f) CS + MK, 5% alkali
content.
opposes the alkali-activation process and thus results in reduced (c) Alkali-activated CS mix activated using 7% alkali content
compressive strength [21]. exhibits compressive strength of the order of 34.12 MPa,
which seems to be sufficient for structural applications in
4. Conclusions various construction works.
(d) The compressive strength of alkali-activated CS was
Following conclusions can be drawn from the present study: increased by more than 11% and 32% with addition of FA
and MK respectively. The microstructure of alkali-activated
(a) All alkali-activated mixes achieved 80% of 28 days compres- CS was also improved with addition of FA and MK.
sive strength within 3 days due to heat curing. (e) In general it can concluded that CS can be used as alumi-
(b) The compressive strength of all alkali-activated mixes was nosilicate in the development of ACM. The addition of FA
increased by more than 11%, when alkali content was and MK in alkali-activated CS makes it more suitable as
increased from 5% to 7%. cementitious material in construction industry.
J. Singh, SP Singh / Construction and Building Materials 211 (2019) 73–79 79
Acknowledgments newindianexpress.com/states/tamilnadu/2018/sep/23/ngt-panel-visits-sterlites-
copper-slag-dumping-site-in-thoothukudi-1875888.html (accessed 22.01.2019).
[14] W. Szyrle, K. Wozniak, The place of copper in the family of abrasive materials,
The authors acknowledge financial assistance in the form of a Powloki Ochronne 16 (1988) 16–19.
fellowship to the first author from the Ministry of Human Resource [15] V.K. Marghussian, A. Maghsoodipoor, Fabrication of unglazed floor tiles
containing Iranian copper slags, Ceram. Int. 25 (1999) 617–622.
Development (MHRD), Government of India. The authors also
[16] Z. Yang, Q. Lin, S. Lu, Y. He, G. Liao, Yi Ke, Effect of CaO/SiO2 ratio on the
acknowledge the help from the staff of Concrete Technology and preparation and crystallization of glass-ceramics from copper slag, Ceram. Int.
Structures Testing Laboratories at Dr B R Ambedkar National Insti- 40 (2014) 7297–7305.
[17] K.S. Al-Jabri, S.K. Al-Oraimi, A.H. Al-Saidy, M. Hisada, Copper slag as sand
tute of Technology, Jalandhar during the experimentation work.
replacement for high performance concrete, Cem. Concr. Compos. 31 (2009)
483–488.
Conflict of interest [18] K.S. Al-Jabri, A.H. Al-Saidy, R. Taha, Effect of copper slag as a fine aggregate on
the properties of cement mortars and concrete, Const. Build. Mater. 25 (2011)
933–938.
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interests regard- [19] R. Tixie, R. Devaguptapu, B. Mobasher, The effect of copper slag on the
ing the publication of this article. hydration and mechanical properties of cementitious mixtures, Cem. Concr.
Res. 27 (1997) 1569–1580.
[20] A.M. Arino, B. Mobasher, Effect of ground copper slag on strength and
References toughness of cementitious mixes, ACI Mater. J. 96 (1999) 68–73.
[21] S. Ahmari, K. Parameswaran, L. Zhang, Alkali activation of copper mine tailings
[1] A. Purdon, The action of alkalis on blast furnace slag, J. Soc. Chem. Ind. 59 and low-calcium flash-furnace copper smelter slag, J. Mater. Civ. Eng. 27
(1940) 191–202. (2015), https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)MT.1943-5533.0001159.
[2] J. Davidovits, Synthetic mineral polymer compound of the silicoaluminates [22] A. Nazer, J. Pay, J. Monzo, Use of ancient copper slags in Portland cement and
family and preparation progress. US Patent, 1981. alkali activated cement matrices, J. Environ. Manage. 167 (2016) 115–123.
[3] J.L. Provis, J.S.J. Deventer, Geopolymerisation kinetics. 1. In situ energy [23] M. Qianmin, D. Haiyun, Z. Xintao, H. Kecheng, L. Zhiwei, Y. Feng, H. Liping, G.
dispersive X-ray diffractometry, Chem. Eng. Sci. 62 (2007) 2309–2317. Rongxin, Performance of copper slag contained mortars after exposure to
[4] J.L. Provis, J.S.J. Deventer, Geopolymerisation kinetics: reaction kinetic elevated temperatures, Constr. Build. Mater. 172 (2018) 378–386.
modelling, Chem. Eng. Sci. 62 (2007) 2318–2329. [24] IS 650, Specification for Standard Sand for Testing of Cement, Bureau of Indian
[5] C. Shi, P.V. Krivenko, D. Roy, Alkali-Activated Cements and Concretes, Taylor & Standards, New Delhi, 1991.
Francis, London, 2006. [25] IS 516, Methods of tests for strength of concrete, Bureau of Indian Standard,
[6] J.L. Provis, S.J. Jannie, Alkali-Activated Materials: State-of-The-Art-Report New Delhi, 1959.
RILEM TC 224-AAM, Springer, 2014. [26] A. Palomo, M.W. Grutzeck, M.T. Blanco, Alkali-activated fly ashes-a cement for
[7] F. Pacheco-Torgal, J.A. Labrincha, C. Leonelli, A. Palomo, P. Chindaprasirt, the future, Cem. Concr. Res. 29 (1999) 1323–1329.
Handbook of Alkali-activated Cements, Mortars and Concretes, Woodhead [27] Z. Xi, Y. Xi, Hardening mechanisms of an alkaline-activated class F fly ash, Cem.
Publishing, Elsevier, 2015. Concr. Res. 31 (2001) 1245–1249.
[8] L.K. Turner, F.G. Collins, Carbon dioxide equivalent (CO-e 2 ) emissions: a [28] K. Gao, L. Kae-Long, W. De-Ying, H. Chao-Lung, S. Hau-Shing, C. Yu-Min, C. Ta-
comparison between geopolymer and OPC cement concrete, Const. Build. Wui, Effects SiO2/Na2O molar ratio on mechanical properties and the
Mater. 43 (2013) 125–130. microstructure of nano-SiO2 metakaolin-based geopolymers, Const. Build.
[9] P.N. Lemougna, W. Kai-tuo, T. Qing, U.C. Melo, C. Xue-min, Recent Mater. 53 (2014) 503–510.
developments on inorganic polymers synthesis and applications, Ceram. Int. [29] Y. Ma, J. He, G. Ye, The pore structure and permeability of alkali activated fly
42 (2016) 15142–15159. ash, Fuel 104 (2013) 771–780.
[10] GNR Database, World Business Council for Sustainable Development, Cement [30] J.L. Provis, R.J. Myers, C.E. White, X-ray micro tomography shows pore
Sustainability initiative, 2016, https://www.wbcsdcement.org/GNR-2016/ structure and tortuosity in alkali-activated binders, Cem. Concr. Res. 42
index.html (accessed 4.04.2018). (2012) 855–864.
[11] S.A. Miller, M. Vanderley, A. Sergio, H Arpad Paccac, Carbon dioxide reduction [31] Y. Ma, J. Hu, G. Ye, The effect of activating solution on the mechanical strength,
potential in the global cement industry by 2050, Cem. Concr. Res. (2017), reaction rate, mineralogy, and microstructure of alkali-activated fly ash, J.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cemconres.2017.08.026. Mater. Sci. 47 (2012) 4568–4578.
[12] B. Gorai, R.K. Jana, M. Premchand, Characteristics and utilization of copper [32] N. Toniolo, A.R. Boccaccini, Fly ash-based geopolymers containing added
slag-a review, Resour. Conser. Recycl. 39 (2003) 299–313. silicate waste. A review, Ceram. Int. 43 (2017) 14545–14551.
[13] Indian Express, NGT panel visits Sterlite’s copper slag dumping site in
Thoothukudi, Press release, 2018, Retrieved from http://www.