Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Indian Standard
CRITERIA FOR BLAST RESISTANT DESIGN
OF STRUCTURES FOR EXPLOSIONS
ABOVE GROUND
( Third Reprint AUGUST 1993 )
0 Copyright 1969
Gr g September 1969
IS : 4991 - 1968
Indian Standard
CRITERIA FOR BLAST RESISTANT DESIGN
OF STRUCTURES FOR EXPLOSIONS
ABOVE GROUND
Chairman Representing
DR JAI KBISENA School of Research & Training in Earthquake
Engineering, University of Roorkee, Roorkee
Members
DB A. S. ABYA ‘&boo1 of Research & Training in Earthquake
Engineering, University of Roorkee, Roorkee
S~nr KAMLESWAR BABIJA Public Works De artment, Government of Assam
Saar B. S. BWALLA Bhakro & Baas Ipesigns Organization, Nangal
SHRI-A. S. CHATBATH ( Alternate)
DR 5. M. K. CRETTY Cent;Lrfrilding Research Institute ( CSIR ),
( Continued on page 2 )
Convener
DR A. S. ARYA School of Research & Training in Earthquake
Engineering, University of Roorkee, Roorkee
Members
DR A. R. CIIANDRA~EKARAN School of Research & Training in Earthquake
Engineering, University of Roorkoe, Roorkee
Sanx C. I?. GHO~H Engineer-in-Chief’s Branch, Army Headquarters,
New Delhi
Ds SAMPOORAN SINGH Terminal Ballastics Research Laboratory,
Chaudiaarh
SHBI P. K. MISR~ ( AIrernate )
SARI K. K. SUIJ Ministry of Defence, New Delhi
IS : 4991- 1968
Indian Standard
CRITERIA FOR BLAST RESISTANT DESIGN
OF STRUCTURES FOR EXPLOSIONS
ABOVE GROUND
0. FOREWORD
0.1 This Indian Standard was adopted by the Indian Standards Insti-
tution on 17 November 1968, after the draft finalized by the Earthquake
Engineering Sectional Committee had been approved by the Civil
Engineering Division Council.
0.2 Structures designed to resist blast loads are subjected to completely
different type of load than that considered in conventional design.
Here they are hit with a rapidly moving shock wave which may exert
pressures many times greater than those experienced under the greatest
of hurricanes. However, in blast phenomenon, the peak intensity lasts
for a very small duration only.
0.3 The blast wave loads the exposed surface of the structure and then
the load is transmitted to the other elements. Thus, the response of
each individual element is important unlike the ground motion where-
in the whole structural system is simultaneously causing inertia effects
on all parts.
0.4 To design a structure capable of resisting these intense but short
duration loads, members and joints are permitted to deflect and strain
much greater than is allowed for usual static loads. This permitted
deflection is, ordinarily, well into the plastic range of the material.
Large amounts of energy are absorbed during this action, thus reduc-
ing the required design strength considerably below that required by
conventional design within elastic range. Moreover, under higher rates
of loading the strength developed by the material, increases with the
rate of loading, and may often be adequately described as a function of
time within a certain range.
0.5 Whereas, if the location of the ground zero ( see 2.8 ), and the size
of bomb are known,. the corresponding blast loading for an existing
structure may be found by the methods explained in this standard.
However, it will never be possible to have exact data for specifying the
expected ground zero and bomb size. Therefore, three different
3
IS : 4991 - 1968
1. SCOPE
1.1 This standard covers the criteria for design of structures for blast
effects of explosions above ground. This standard does not cover the
design for blast effects of nuclear explosions.
*Rules for rounding off numerical valuea ( re,?jsed).
4
IS:4991- 1968
2. DEFINITIONS
2.0 For the purpose of this standard, the following definitions shall
apply.
2.1 Blast Wind - It is the moving air mass along with the over-pres-
sures resulting from pressure difference behind the shock wave front.
The blast wind movement during the positive phase of the overpressur-
es is in the direction of shock front propagation.
2.2 Clearance Time -This is the time in which the reflected pressure
decays down to the sum of the side on overpressure and the drag
pressure.
2.3’ Decay Parameter - It is the coefficient of the negative power of
exponent e governing the fall of pressure with time in the pressure-time
curves.
2.8 Ground Zero - It is the point on the earth surface vertically below
the explosion.
2.10 Mach Number - It is the ratio of the speed of the shock front pro-
pagation to the speed of sound in standard atmosphere at sea level.
2.11 Overpressure - It is the rise in pressure above atmospheric pres-
sure due to the shock wave from an air blast.
3. NOTATIONS
3.1 For the purpose of this standard, the following notations shall
apply.
a Velocity of sound in air
B Span or width of structure across the direction of shock
wave propagation
Cd Drag coefficient
E Modulus of elasticity of material
H Height of the structure
I Moment of inertia of member
j Number of concentrated load points
K. Coefficient of earth pressure
KLM Load mass factor
Kt Load factor
KU Mass factor
k Ratio of resistance required to peak overpressure
6
IS : 4991 - 1968
Ductility ratio = %
(I
4. GENERAL CHARACTERISTICS OF BLAST AND EFFECTS ON
STRUCTURES
4.1 The Source - The conventional chemical charge is considered
spherical. The shock front at the ground surface from a contact burst
7
IS:4991-1968
8
IS ; 4991- 1968
5. BLAST FORCE
5.1 Maximum Values for Reference Explosion - The maximum values
of the p0sitiv.e side-on overpressure pso, reflected over pressure pso and
dynamic pressure qo, as caused by the explosion of one tonne explosive
at various distances from the point of explosion, are given in Table 1.
The duration of the positive phase of the blast t, and the equivalent
time duration of positive phase rd are also given in Table 1.
9
IS : 4991 - 196%
NOTE 1 -The value of pa the ambient air pressure may be taken as 1 kg/cm*
at mean sea level.
NOTE 2 -One tonne of explosive referred to in this table is equivalent to
1’5 X 10s calories.
NOTE 3 -Velocity of sound in m/s may be taken ( 331’5 f- 0’607 T ) where
T is the ambient temperature in centigrade.
10
IS : 4991- 1968
5.3 Scaling Lnws- For any explosion other than the reference explo-
sion, the peak pressures and time durations may be found from the
peak values given in Table 1 by the cube root scaling laws as given
below:
Actual distance
Scaled distance x = .. . . .. (1)
w1/s
Actual time
Scaled time t, . .. . .. (2)
= ---WT. .**
where
W = yield of explosion in equivalent weight of the reference
explosive measured in tonnes,
x = scaled distance for entering the Table 1 for reading
peak values, and
to = scaled time read from Table 1 against scaled
distance.
NOTE - Aotuel distsnce is messured from the ground zero to the point
under cousiderstion. Actual time is the time for 8ctuel explosion.
Pm+ 7 PO
where
p. = the ambient atmospheric pressure. Taking
pa;12 Ikg/cm2, the value of pro are given in
11
IS:4991-1968
6.2.1.1 The ,net pressure acting on the front face at any time t is
the reflected overpressure p,. or ( ps + C, 4 ), whichever is greater:
where
Cd = drag coefficient given in Table 2, and
p7 = the reflected overpressure which drops from the peak
value p,. to overpressure (ps + Cd q)‘in clearance time
t, given by:
where
S = H or B/2 whichever is less (see Fig. 2 )
U = shock front velocity = M.a
where
a = velocity vf sound in air which may
be taken as 344 m/s at mean sea
level at 2O”C, and
M = Mach number of the incident pulse
given by d-p-. The
values of M for various conditions
are also tabulated in Table 1.
6.2.2 Rear Face - Using the pressures for the actual explosion, the
average loading on the rear face (B x H in Fig. 2 ) is taken as shown
in Fig. 4 where the time has been reckoned from the instant the shock
12
3 IS : 4991- 1968
first strikes the front face. The time intervals of interest are the
following:
L
.---E the travel time of shock from front to rear face, and
u
4s
- = pressure rise time on back face.
u
( Clause 6.2.1.1 )
6.2.3 Roof and Side Walls - As for rear face in 6.2.2, the average
pressure versus time curve for roof and side walls is given in Fig. 5A,
when fd is greater than the transit When tt is greater
time ft =
4i-
than td the load on roof and side walls may be considered as a moving
triangular pulse having the peak value of overpressure ( p,,+ C,. q0 ) and
time ta as shown in Fig. 5B.
13
IS : 4991- 1968
STRAIGHT LINES
0 'c ‘d
.T IME
TIME
38
0 I C.5 h + td
u u u
TIME
14
SHOCK
?F
0 c
2u
c
u
-I-ttd
2u
TIME
Fig. 6 where Cd is the drag coefficient depending upon the shape of the
structural element given in Table 2 and t, is given as follows:
cd90
5
2
z
a.
TIME
16
IS : 4991- 1968
7.2.2 The pressure versus time diagrams for the various faces of the
structure are shown in Fig. 8. The values of the coefficient of earth
pressure K, appearing in Fig. 8 are given in Table 3.
F SLOPE
L-----L-I
Fm. 7 BURIED RECTANGULAR STRUCTURE
17
c.
w
..
TIME ‘d
TIME
8A FRONT FACE 8B REAR FACE
8C ROOF
V-L
FIG. 9 BURIED ARCH OR DOME STRUCTURE
19
IS : 4991- 1968
7.4.3 The loading on the earth berm surface may be computed as for
the above ground structures.
IOA IO 6
FIG. 10 IDEALIZED PRESSURE TIME DIAGRAMS
20
IS : 4991 - 1968
yin ye ym
DEFLECTION DEFLECTION
\?rhere
Rm = the required resistance, and
k,, k, = the values of ratios k for ductility ratio TVand
time ratios tallT and haIT respectively.
21
lS:4991- 1968
IS : 4991- 1968
KL.W = &I&
M, = concentratedmass at point r,
23
IS : 4991- 1968
9.4 For elastic analysis ( ductility ratio ~~~1.0 ) of structtues, the effec-
tive stiffness kE and load mass factor KL.Ware to be used as given in
Tables 4 to 6. For elasto-plastic analysis kE is SO be used as given in
Tables 4 to 6 but value of KL,~Imay be chosen in between the elastic and
plastic cases depending upon the ductility factor.
24
IS:4991- 1968
i!E
f?ln _B __ .- .- _
Concentrated at mid- Elastic 1.0 0’49 kwp: L 48EI/L3 0’78R, - o’28Pt
spar,
PC = P Plastic 1.0 0.33 4M,lL - 0’75R, - 0’25Pt
6 _- _-
.
0
Concentrated at third Elastic 0’87 0430 BM,!‘L O.BZR, - 0’12P~
points P ‘2 each
Simply Supported
Pt = P Plastic 1.0 0’56 6M,‘L 0’5ZR, - O’O?P,
- -
B’ C
bYI
Rm
a 8 - 0’36R, + O’14Pt
Rl Uniform Elastic ( 0.77 lZM,,:L 384EI:LJ
/I
Pat = pL Elastic OB’ ) - 0’78 (3/L) (Mps f Mm) 307EI/LJ 03QR, + O*llP,
/I
Plastic - 0.66 (8/L ) ( Mm + Mpm ) - 0,38R, T 0’12Pt
s
0
Fired at both ends
-
Concentrated at mid- ‘&tic ( OB ) 1'0 0.37 (4/L) (Mps + Mpm) lQ2EI/L= 0’71R, - O’?lPt
span
I
Pt = P Plastic 1’0 0.33 (4/L)(M,, LMmt) 0.75R, - O%P,
- -
Concentrnted nt mid- Elastic ( OA ) 1.0 0’43 ( 16/3L) Mrrs 107EIiL3 ( V, = 0.54R, A- 0.14Pt )
span ( V, = 0’25R, + 0’07P1 )
P4 =P Elastic ( OB’ ) 0.4Q ( S/r.) ( Mp, t 2~47nn) I06EIILJ 0’78R, - 0’28P 1 * Mpli L
Plastic ;:; 0’33 (2/L)(Mps -2M,,J - 0*75R, - O%P, * M ml L
- -
*Taken from ’ Design of structures to reaiat the effect of atomic weapons *, U.S. ~rrny Corps of Engineers Msn~l ‘FM5-856.3, 1967.
25
As in the Original Standard, this Page is Intentionally Left Blank
TABLE 5 TRANSFORMATION FACTORS FOR TWO-WAY SLABS - FOUR SIDES,
SIMPLE SUPPORTS UNIFORM LOAD
L!r
span section parallel to short edge
---I
Ll
h!f,fb = Tot81 poeitjve ultimate moment C8p8City 8lOng mid-
span section parallel to long edge
J = Moment of inertia per unit width of slab, Pt = Dynsmio a
load b
5 VA = -81 dynamic reaction SlOIig 8 short edge
0 = Total dynamic reaction along 8 long edge
VB
-
STRAIN a/b Zo~i MASS MAXIXUM 1 SPBINQ , I)YNA~~I~ HEA~TIONS
RANQE F ACTOB RESXSTANCE CONSTANT ____--h____-l,
__
I Kn b
(1) I (2)
I’0
KLM
(3)
0’68 12 ( Mph
(4)
+ Mea )/a
I (6)
252 Ella’ 0*07Pt +
VA
(61
0*18R,
I (7)
0’07Pt +
VB
0’18R,
8:;
I 0’70 ( 12Mefo + 1lMpfa )/a omPt + O’lBR,,, 0.08Pt $ 0’20R,
Elestic 0.7 1 ( lIMpfa + l@&t!f,fb )/a %g:f$ 0*06Pt + 0’14R, 0.08Pt $ 0.22R,
(OB) 0.7 0’73 ( 12Mpfc + 9*8M,fb )/a 201 El/a’ 0*05Pt + 0’13R, 0’08Pt + 0’24R,
0.6 0’74 ! 12Mo + 9*3Msfa )/a 197EZla’ WO4Pt + WllR, 0*09Pt + 0.n
- -y,
0.5 0’75 ( l&Me + g’OMpf,ta )/a 2OlEIla’ 0’04Pt + O.O9R, O*09Pt + 0*28R,
._ I- 0*09P* +
1-o ---izr-- 12 ( Mpfa + Mpfb )/a wowt + 0.16R, 0*16R,
0’9 0.51 ( 12Mpfo + 11Mm )/a - O.O8P* + 0*15R, w09P; + 0.18R;;;
Plastic 0.8 0’54 ( 12Mpfo + 10%‘kfpn )/a - 0’07P; + 0’13R, O.lOPt + 0’20R,
(BC) 0’55 ( 12Mpf. + 6’6Mpfb )/a - 0*06Pt + 0*12R, O.lOPt + 0’22R,
8:;: 0.58 ( 12Mpfa + 9%!fnfb )/a - O*05Pt + O’lOR, O’lOP, + 0’25Rm E
0’5 0.59 ( 12Mm + 6*OMpfa )/a-- - 0’04Pt + 0.08% O.llP; -i- O-272; **
- L
*Taken from ‘Design of structures to resist the effects of atomic weapons’, U. S. Army Corps of 7
Engineers Manual TM 5-856-3, 1957.
G
-- s
As in the Original Standard, this Page is Intentionally Left Blank
As in the Original Standard, this Page is Intentionally Left Blank
IS:4991-1968
31
IS :4991- 1968
Minor damage
where
10.4.1 The dynamic flexural strength of plain brick and stone masonry
m -1 be assumed to be the same as the corresponding static strength.
The compressive strength shall be taken 25 precent higher than the
corresponding static strength.
10.4.2 For unreinforced brick work the ductility ratio may be limited
to 1.5.
10.4.3 For reinforced brickwork, with not less than 0.05 percent steel
on each face and not more than balanced percentage, the ductility
factors as for reinforced concrete may be used.
Granular soil Static load per unit area for 4.0 cm settle-
ment of the structure
32
.
IS : 4991 - 1968
10.5.3
For raft foundation, the raft area need not be more than the
roof area.
33
IS :4991- 1968
APPENDIX A
( Clause 6.2.5 )
AN EXAMPLE OF CALCULATION OF PRESSURE-TIME
CURVES ON A RECTANGULAR ABOVE GROUND
BUILDING
A-l. EXAMPLE
A-l.1 Blast parameters due to the detonation of a O-1 tonne explosive
are evaluated on an above ground rectangular structure, 3 m high, 10 m
wide and 8 m long, situated at 30 m from ground zero.
M= 1+6’” = 1’14
d 7 Pa
a = 344 m/s U = 392 m/s = 0.392 m/millisecond
= 20.4 milliseconds> td
34
IS : 4991 - 1968
4s 4x3
rr= -=- =1 30.6 milliseconds>td
u 0.392
As t,>ta no pressure on the back face are considered.
For roof and sides C, = -0.4
pSO+ Cd go = 0.35 - 0.4 x O-042 = 0.33 kg/cm2
The pressure diagrams are as shown below:
041
-E
vm
25
c-4
ZE u I2
0.33 I& ;
;a
mzl
a
--trz
n
13.15 13 is
rh4E MILLISECONDS TIME MlLLlSECONDS
APPENDIX B
( Clause 9.2.1 )
where the deflettion at the free end has been taken as uniti.
IS : 4991- 1968
y"+Y ; 0 (x) = ;
kM =+- [m,l+2{m,(X)ldx]
t 0
36
IS : 4991- 1968
where m, and m, are the masses per unit length (along the
frame ) of the roof and walls respectively.
APPENDIX C
( Clause 12.3 )
GENERAL RECOMMENDATIONS FOR PLANNING BLAST
RESISTANT BUILDINGS
C-2. CORRIDORS
C-2.1 Long narrow corridors should be avoided as they tend to increase
the extent of damage along the length of the corridors because of ‘mul-
tiple reflections’.
C-3. PROJECTIONS
C-3.1 All slender projections like, parapets and balconies specially
those made of brittle materials should be avoided as far as possible.
C-4. CHIMNEYS
C-4.1 Masonry chimneys on ftictory buildings and boiler houses are a
potential hazard and should be avoided.
31
IS:4991- 1968
C-9. DOORS
C-9.1 Doors should be designed for the front face load.
38
BUREAU OF INDIAN STANDARDS
Headquarters:
Manak Bhavan, 9 Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, NEW DELHI 110002
Talephones : 331 01 31, 331 13 75 Telegrams : Manaksanrtha
( Common to all offices )
Regional O#?ces; Telephones
Central : Manak Bhavan, 9 Behadur Shah Zafar Marg, II 331 01 31
NEW DELHI-l 10002 3311375
*Eastern : l/14 C.I.T. Scheme VII AA, V. I. P. Road 36 24 99
Maniktola, CALCUTTA 700054
Northern : SC0 445-446, Sector 35-C, 21843
CHANDIGARH 160036 [ 31641
41 24 42
Southern : C. I. T. Campuo, MADRAS 600113 41 25 19
41 29 16
twestern : Manakalaya, ES MIDC, Marol, Andheri (East), 6329296
BOMBAY 400093
Branch Ofices:
‘Pushpak’ Nurmohamed Shalkh Marg, Khanpur, 26348
AHMEDABAD 380001 [ 26349
SPeenya Industrial Area, 1 st Stage, Bangalore Tumkur Road 38 49 55
BANGALOR E 560058 [ 38 49 56
Gangotri Complex, 5th Floor, Bhadbhada Road, T. T. Nagar, 66710
BHOPAL 462003
Plot NQ. 82/83, Lewis Road, BHUBANESHWAR 751002 63627
53/5, Ward No. 29, R. G. Barua Road, 5th Byelane, 3 31 77
GUWAHATI 781003
6-8-S6C L. N. Gupta Marg ( Nampally Statlon Road), 231083
HYDERABAD 500001
6 3471
R14 Yudhlster Marg, C Scheme, JAIPUR 302005 E69832
21 68 76
1171418 B Sarvodaya Nagar, KANPUR 208006 [ 21 82 92
Patliputra Industrial Estate, PATNA 800013 62305
T.C. No. 14/1421, University P.O., Palayam 6 2104
TRIVANDRUM 695035 1621 17
lnspecflon Ofice (With Sale Point) :
Pushpanjali, 1st Floor, 205-A West High Court Road, 2 51 71
Shankar Nagar Square, NAGPUR 440010
Institution of Engineers ( India ) Building, 1332 Shlvajl Nager. 52436
PUNE 411005
*Sales Office In Calcutta is at 5 Chowringher Approach, P.O. PrlncrP 27 65 00
Strrrt, Calcutta 700072
tSalee Offlce In Bombay I8 at Novelty Chambere, Grant Road, 59 65 26
Bombay 400007
SSalrr Omce In Bangalore ie at Unlty BulldIng, Narrrlmherala Square 22 35 II
Bengalorr 560002
Prlntrd lt Slmoo Printing Prom. Dolhl. Indlo