Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. Mild downgrade in growth expectations 3. Technology companies continue to expand rapidly 5. Tourist arrivals and hotel room rates continue to grow
The IMF downgraded global growth expectations for 2019 in Southeast Asia In 2018, tourist arrivals across Southeast Asian cities grew
to 3.5% from 3.7% previously, as advanced economies are We estimate that technology companies leased about 15- 9% yoy, with international tourists visiting Vietnam and
expected to expand slower and trade challenges escalate. 20% of total gross office space in 2018 in Southeast Asia, Indonesia rising 20% yoy and 16% yoy respectively. Upscale
Southeast Asia is expected to grow by 4.8% in 2019-2023, compared to 5-10% just three years ago. We continue to hotel revenue per available room also grew by 5% yoy in
down from 5.0% previously, as the outlook for Indonesia expect these firms to potentially take up 15-25% of annual 3Q2018, after rising 6% in 2017. More hotel investment sales
and Philippines are scaled back. Higher oil prices will weigh office leasing volume for the next decade. In 2H2018, office were observed in Singapore, with capital values significantly
on fuel importers but benefit Malaysia, a net exporter. take-up surprised on the upside in Singapore and Bangkok, above expectations.
growing by 6% yoy, while demand moderated in Manila
2. Rising trade barriers dampen exports in near term and Jakarta after rapid growth in the prior few quarters. 6. Changes to our view
but benefit mid-tech countries in medium term Downsizing in Kuala Lumpur led to a shrinkage in occupied We upgraded our prime office rents forecasts for Singapore
Higher trade tariffs on China exports could impact imports office space in the city. after accounting for the higher-than-expected take-up in
of components by China from Southeast Asia in the short 2H2018. We now expect rents to rise 15% over 2019-2020.
term. However, in the medium term, manufacturers are 4. Global retailers expand in Southeast Asia, Office rents are expected to decline in Kuala Lumpur in
likely to expedite the relocation of operations to Southeast integrate online and physical points of sale 2019-2021E. Our Jakarta office rents forecasts for 2019-
Asia. This process has already started in the last five years Domestic consumption continues to grow in Southeast 2021E are now 6% lower than our previous estimates as
as wages in China rose. For Vietnam, its exports to the Asia due to urbanisation and higher incomes. Global the city’s vacancy rate remained above 30% by 4Q2018. We
United States accelerated in 2H 2018, and the number of FDI retailers such as Uniqlo, IKEA and Apple continue to expect rents in Jakarta to compress further but stabilise
projects from China, Korea, Singapore and Japan grew 17- expand their footprints. E-commerce companies such as beyond that. We have also mildly downgraded our Jakarta
37% yoy in 3Q2018. We also expect countries with mid-tech JD.com and Alibaba are collaborating with local groups to retail rents for 2019-2021E as rents grew just 1.8% yo in
skills such as Thailand and Malaysia to benefit. We expect integrate online and physical points of sale to tap on young 2018, down from 4% yoy in 2016-2017.
higher demand for industrial property in Southeast Asia. consumers who are both tech-savvy and continue to prefer
shopping as a leisure activity. The World Bank has raised
the rankings for the logistics sectors in Vietnam, Indonesia,
Philippines and Thailand significantly in the last two years.
Fig 1: 2019 GDP growth forecasts Fig 2: GDP forecasts for 2019-2020 Fig 3: Indonesian Rupiah vs US dollar Fig 4: Current account surplus as % of GDP
8.00% 8.00% 14,800 54
14,400
6.00% 6.00% 52
14,200
5.00% 5.00% 51
14,000
4.00% 4.00% 50
13,800
3.00% 3.00% 49
13,600
2.00% 2.00% 48
13,400
Q4
20 Q1
20 Q2
20 Q3
20 Q4
20 Q1
20 Q2
20 Q3
20 Q4
20 Q1
20 Q2
20 Q3
20 Q4
20 Q1
20 Q2
20 Q3
20 Q4
20 Q1
20 Q2
20 Q3
20 Q2
20 Q1
20 Q2
20 Q3
Q4
20 Q3
20 Q4
20 Q1
20 Q2
20 Q3
20 Q4
20 Q1
20 Q2
20 Q3
20 Q4
20 Q1
20 Q2
20 Q3
20 Q4
20 Q1
16
16
16
16
17
17
17
17
18
18
18
18
19
19
19
19
20
20
20
20
16
16
16
16
17
17
17
17
18
18
18
18
19
19
19
19
20
20
20
20
20
20
2Q18 4Q18 2018 2019E 2020E
Southeast Asia expected to grow 4.8% annually in 2019-2023 Limited downside to currencies after sharp corrections in 2018 Fig 5: Current account surplus as % of GDP
The IMF downgraded global growth expectations for 2019 In 2018, Indonesia raised its policy rates six times and by 200bps 25
to 3.5% from 3.7% previously as advanced economies are as it sought to stabilise the rupiah, which depreciated c.10%
expected to expand slower and trade challenges escalate. against the US dollar in the first three quarters of 2018. Similarly,
20
Southeast Asia is expected to grow by 4.8% in 2019-2023, Philippines tightened monetary policies to protect the Peso as
Exports to US US$bn
average tariff rates on both imports and exports of ASEAN Chamber of Commerce in Shanghai undertook a survey in 12 50%
goods to China to 0.1-0.6%. The ACFTA is the third largest by September 2018 to gauge the impact of new US tariffs on 10
40%
trade volume after the European Economic Area and the North American companies in China. Of the 430 companies who 8
30%
6
American Free Trade Area. responded, 61% are in manufacturing-related industries. 20%
4
Around 70% of the companies expect a negative impact 10%
2
Today, China is Southeast Asia’s largest trading partner, making on their profits, production costs and reduced demand for 0 0%
up 14% of ASEAN’s exports in 2017. 48% of Southeast Asia’s products. Most respondents are adjusting their supply chains
en s/
ar
hi l
pa s
uc d
ni d
uc e
du d
ot re
d ne
od ur
od n
tro an
ro an
pm ie
we
ng
rts
ts
cs
ts
s
Cl ppa
exports to China are in electronics, machinery and mineral in response to the tariffs, seeking to source components and
pr d a
ui er
pr cult
ct
an pho
ec r
l p el
ot
eq hin
el ute
od Woo
ee Ste
A
Fo
ua
le
p
fuels. Trade tensions between the US and China may impact assembly outside of China and delaying investment decisions.
Ma
Aq
bi
m
d
Mo
Co
an
wo
Southeast Asia’s exports in the short term. As intermediate While 64.6% of respondents are not considering relocating their
st
2017 2018 yoy change
goods make up over 50% of China’s imports from Southeast manufacturing facilities out of China, 18.5% of respondents are
Asia, a decline in China’s exports is likely to reduce China’s considering relocating these to Southeast Asia. Source: Vietnam Customs
demand for such exports from Southeast Asia in the short term.
US
UK
an
da
re
sia
nd
ia
a
an
di
re
in
pa
xic
es
po
na
iw
na
la
y
Ch
In
Ko
m
la
Ja
n
Me
ai
et
a
Ta
Ca
do
r
Ma
ng
Th
h
Ge
Vi
ut
In
Si
So
United States 2016 2020 Change in rank (RHS)
Europe
Amongst the countries in Southeast Asia, Vietnam has already Outside of Vietnam, we also see Malaysia and Thailand as
seen an acceleration of exports to the US as well as the number potential net beneficiaries in the medium term. According to
East Asia of FDI projects in 2H2018, potentially due to the trade tensions Deloitte’s Global Manufacturing Competitiveness Index, CEO
between the US and China. Vietnam’s exports to the US grew respondents were asked to rank nations in terms of current and
17% yoy in 2018, including substantial growth in machineries/ future manufacturing competitiveness. The 2016 study found that
Latin America equipment, steel and steel products and wood and wood Vietnam, Malaysia, Indonesia and India are expected to become
products, where new tariffs by the US have been imposed. The more competitive over the next few years while countries such
number of FDI projects registered in Vietnam also started to as China and South Korea could become less competitive.
0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 12% 14% 16% 18% 20% pick up in 3Q2018, with China FDI projects growing 37% yoy,
Korean FDI projects growing 21% yoy and Singapore and Japan
Source: American Chamber of Commerce, Shanghai, Sep 2018
growing 17% yoy.
Fig 9: Manufacturing wages in Southeast Asia compared to China Chart 11: Office net absorption in Southeast Asia (yoy)
0.90 10.0%
0.80 9.0%
Manufacturing wage as % of China wage
0.70 8.0%
0.60 5.0%
0.50 6.0%
0.40 5.0%
0.30 4.0%
0.20 3.0%
0.10
2.0%
0.0
1.0%
Malaysia Thailand Vietnam Indonesia
0.0%
2010 2018 2023 2011 2011 2012 2012 2013 2013 2014 2014 2015 2015 2016 2016 2017 2017 2018 2018
Fig 10: Exports growth in Malaysia, Thailand to grow faster than China Chart 12: Office net take-up in Southeast Asia (yoy)
40 18%
16%
30
14%
12%
20
10%
10 8%
6%
0
4%
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018E 2019E 2020E 2021E
-10 2%
0%
-20 1H2016 2H2016 1H2017 2H2017 1H2018 2H2018
-2%
4% 9% 16%
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Five years ago Three years ago Last 12 months
Technology companies have been expanding swiftly in In the last two years, investments into e-commerce companies
Southeast Asia and have become a key office occupier group in Southeast Asia accelerated. For instance, Singapore-based
in the region in the last five years. We estimate that these Sea, which operates Garena gaming and e-sports platform
companies leased around 15-20% of total gross office leasing and Shopee e-commerce site, just raised over USD 1 billion
volumes in Southeast Asia, compared to 5-10% just three years in 2017 through an initial public offering and a further USD
ago. We expect technology companies to continue to expand in 575m in June 2018. Tencent, China’s largest video games and
Southeast Asia, potentially taking up 15-25% of annual gross social media operator has been investing in Garena for several
office leasing volume for the next decade. years. In early 2018, Alibaba increased its investment in Lazada
by USD 2billion, bringing its total investment to date to USD
Technology hardware manufacturers such as Dell, Intel, 4billion. This was in addition to its USD 1billion investment
Apple, Ericsson and Siemens have been operating in the region in Tokopedia, which operates in Indonesia. As gaming and
for decades and new players are investing in the region. In e-sports markets grow in Southeast Asia, we think gaming
Bangkok, Huawei opened its Southeast Asia Research and companies such as Garena, Ubisoft, Quest Drop and Blizzard
Development centre in 2017 and is now the largest technology will start to expand quickly. The number of PC and mobile
occupier in Bangkok, taking up more than 15,000 sqm of space, gamers in Southeast Asia is projected to reach 400 million by
up from just 1,000 sqm in 2013. 2021, according to Niko Partners.
In the last ten years, internet companies such as Google, Both international and local coworking companies are also
Amazon and Facebook started to operate in Southeast Asia. rapidly increasing their presence in Southeast Asia, at pace
For instance, Google started its Singapore office with just 24 with the global trend. WeWork acquired Spacemob as part
people in 2007 but this Asia Pacific headquarters had grown to of its entry into Southeast Asia in August 2017 and has been
over 1,000 employees by 2017. As of 2018, Google is the largest expanding at breakneck pace since then. Justco started in
corporate occupier in Singapore, taking more space than any Singapore in 2015 and expanded into Bangkok and Jakarta.
financial institution.
Fig 14: Where are the largest technology companies in Southeast Asia? Chart 15: Flex space penetration in Southeast Asia
100% 4.5%
90%
4.0%
80%
3.5%
70%
3.0%
60%
2.5%
50%
40% 2.0%
30%
1.5%
20%
1.0%
10%
0.5%
0%
Facebook Google Alibaba Sea Wework
0.0%
Singapore Kuala Lumpur Bangkok Jakarta HCMC Manila Singapore Bangkok HCMC Manila Jakarta Kuala Lumpur
We find that the largest global technology companies in E-commerce companies such as Sea (which operates
In Southeast Asia, flexible work spaces have grown by c.40%
Southeast Asia currently take up between 20,000 sqm and Garena, Shopee and Airplay) and the Alibaba group (which CAGR in the last three years and now take up 2% of the office
50,000 sqm in total, spread amongst three to five cities: operates Lazada, Alipay and UC Web) are operating out of stock, from 0.5-1.0% in 2015. Singapore enjoys the highest
All of them have some presence in Singapore, Bangkok and more locations in Southeast Asia and take up substantially penetration rate, with flexible work spaces taking up 4.2%
Jakarta. more office space in Jakarta than Singapore, followed by of JLL island-wide office stock. The growth of flexible work
Bangkok. We believe these companies are set up to serve spaces in Southeast Asia is in line with the rapid growth in
In many cases, the companies have grown their headcount
the large and growing domestic markets of Indonesia, Asia Pacific, where flexible space stock recorded a compound
by 30-50% CAGR over the last 5-10 years.
Thailand and Vietnam where personal consumption annual growth rate of 35.7% in 2014-2017, much higher than
Internet companies Google and Facebook have most of expenditure is growing by over 6% annually. in the United States (25.7%) and Europe (21.6%) over the
their office footprint in Singapore, which acts as a regional same period. JLL predicts that as much as 30% of corporate
headquarters and a base for marketing, sales, and research Flexible office space operator WeWork has expanded rapidly portfolios could be flexible space by 2030. What initially began
and development operations. in the last two years and now take up over 50,000 sqm across as a platform for freelancers and startups, flexible space
the region. providers are now tailoring their offering to accommodate
corporate users.
Domestic consumption continues to grow in Southeast Asia from a vending machine. Modern grocers can provide in- be the largest IKEA in the world. Apple has opened its second tertiary students in Thailand. Alibaba currently has a presence
due to urbanisation, rising employment in the manufacturing store chefs that cook a shopper’s groceries on demand, with retail store in Southeast Asia in Bangkok, and is considering in all six countries in Southeast Asia and targets to open high-
and services sectors and growth in the middle-income deliveries made in under two hours from initial order. Jakarta and Vietnam next. It is also planning additional stores tech stores in the near term. The company is collaborating
household population. While online retail makes up 30% of in Bangkok and Singapore. with Malaysia and Thai governments on logistics hubs and
retail sales in China, it is currently just 5% in Southeast Asia One example of a retailer that is expanding in Southeast Asia is e-commerce parks.
where shopping is still seen as a leisure activity, as customers Uniqlo, which said it would double its Southeast Asia network E-commerce companies from China, such as Alibaba and
have a strong preference to touch and feel the product. Due over the next four years to 400 stores by 2022 and treble sales JD.com, continue to expand in Southeast Asia. Potentially, We expect the transformation of the retail business to spill
to the young and tech-savvy population in Southeast Asia, to USD2.7 bn from USD 0.9 bn in 2017. Uniqlo has opened there are several similarities between China and Southeast Asia over into higher demand for industrial and logistics space in
global retailers see the region as an ideal place to expand and its first store in Thailand and is targeting suburban stores in in terms of consumption growth rates and technology adoption Southeast Asia. In Philippines, Lazada doubled its plant in
integrate online and physical retail points of sale. Thailand, Malaysia and Philippines. It will also start to open by youths. JD Central, a joint venture between JD.com and Cabuyao, Laguna to 60,000 sqm in 2018. Zalora plans to move
stores in Vietnam, Laos and Myanmar. IKEA, the Swedish Thailand’s largest retail firm Central Group, aims to provide to a four-storey warehouse facility in Cavite in 2019 that can
For example, some outfit retailers in malls have created ‘virtual furniture maker, is currently operating in Singapore, Malaysia, e-commerce and fintech services and accelerate omni-channel accommodate 5 million product inventory, or five times more
shelves’ that allow customers to order the items they want for Indonesia and Thailand. It targets to double its business and retail growth in Thailand. The two firms will also collaborate to than the 1 million product inventory capacity of its existing
delivery, if the store does not have the items in stock. Other enter new markets in Southeast Asia in the next few years. The provide IT solution services for supply chain development for warehouse. JD Central targets to increase the number of
retailers use ‘magic mirrors’ that allow users to try new makeup new IKEA store in Manila (in partnership with SM Group) will small businesses and developing e-commerce skills among warehouses in Thailand to five in early 2019.
looks with the help of Augmented Reality, and then buy items
Singapore 5 7
25.00%
Japan 5 12
20.00%
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
5.00%
Fig 17: Logistics Performance Index – Competence and quality of logistics services (global ranking)
0.00%
Philippines 69 77 2016 2017 2018E
-5.00%
Indonesia 44 55
Malaysia 3536 Vietnam Indonesia Philippines Thailand Singapore Malaysia
2016 2018 0%
1Q16 2Q16 3Q16 4Q16 1Q17 2Q17 3Q17 4Q17 1Q18 2Q18 3Q18
Source: World Bank
-10%
Southeast Asian countries continue to improve the The index measures six components including (1) efficiency of
-20%
performance of their logistics sectors. According to World customs and border clearance; (2) quality of trade and transport
Bank’s Logistics Performance Index (LPI), Vietnam’s logistics infrastructure; (3) ease of arranging competitively priced
-30%
performance is now ranked 32nd globally compared to 64th in shipments; (4) competence and quality of logistics services;
Jakarta Bangkok Kuala Lumpur Singapore Manila
2016 and now is just slightly behind Thailand. Indonesia also (5) ability to track consignments and (6) frequency where
moved up to 46th from 63rd rank. Singapore, Japan and Hong shipments are delivered on schedule. Vietnam and Indonesia Source: JLL estimates
Kong are still the most efficient logistics hubs. improved the most on their logistics quality and competency.
Chart 20: Office rental compound annual growth rate (%) Regina Lim Veena Loh
6%
Head of Capital Markets Research Head of Research
4% Southeast Asia Malaysia
Regina.lim@ap.jll.com Veena.loh@ap.jll.com
2%
0%
2016-2018 2019-2021E
4.0%
Trang Le
2.0%
Head of Research
0.0% Vietnam
-2.0% 1Q15 2Q15 3Q15 4Q15 1Q16 2Q16 3Q16 4Q16 1Q17 2Q17 3Q17 4Q17 1Q18 2Q18 3Q18 4Q18 trang.le@ap.jll.com
-4.0%
-6.0%
-8.0%
-10.0%
Bangkok Jakarta Kuala Lumpur Singapore
Singapore prime office rents rose 22% over 2017-2018 and we However, after 2019 supply volumes are expected to be more
now expect rents to continue to rise 15% over 2019-2020, slightly manageable and as vacancy rates come down from their current
higher than our previous forecast. The upgrade to our Singapore level we are likely to see some stability in rents.
office rents forecasts was made on the back of stronger than
expected office take-up in 2018 and the withdrawal of some In 2018, retail rents across Southeast Asia continued to increase
aging stock expected in 2019. Our Jakarta office rents forecasts slightly by 2.8% yoy on average. Bangkok rents rose the fastest,
for 2019-2021E are now 6% lower than our previous estimates as rising 3.4% yoy. Singapore retail rents finally grew yoy after three
vacancy rate in the city remained above 30% despite strong net years of decline. We have mildly downgraded our Jakarta retail
absorption in 2018. Despite improving office demand over the rents for 2019-2021E as rents only grew just 1.8% yoy in 2018,
past couple of years, we expect Jakarta office rents to compress down from 4.0% yoy in 2016-2017. We expect Jakarta retail rents
further in 2019, extending the downward trend since mid-2015. to grow 3% yoy in 2019.
JLL
© Copyright 2019 JLL. All rights reserved. All information contained herein is from sources deemed reliable; however, no representation or warranty is made to the
accuracy thereof.