You are on page 1of 92

THE

AUTOMOTIVE
INDUSTRY
AS A DIGITAL
BUSINESS
NT T INNOVATION INSTITUTE, INC.
DR RAINER MEHL

1 NTTI3.COM
This is a time of both great opportunity and great challenge software – have crushed traditional barriers to entry and
for the global auto industry. expansion, and have accelerated the speed of change
within markets.
Historically, few companies can rival this global industry for
the way that it has reflected and been shaped by important In this always-on, always-connected digital world, it is
social, cultural, and economic trends. critical for the industry to reexamine its approach to the
entire value chain using the lens of delivering customer-
Economic recession and recovery. Conflict and peace.
defined value at every touch point. Only with that fresh
Energy crisis and demographic shifts. The space race and
approach can the business be informed and prepared to
startup culture. All have had a role in the way the industry
successfully evolve to face new possibilities, challenges,
thinks about and has approached design, production,
and competitors.
distribution, partnerships, and customer interaction.
Auto companies need to embrace digital technologies
Today, the industry is facing a powerful new shaping force
as part of their core DNA. Only then can they take full
that is moving nearly every aspect of modern business
advantage of the opportunities it gives them to think
from analog to digital. We are experiencing the birth of a
smarter by sensing and predicting opportunities, act
new era of digital business unlike any we have ever seen
faster through true business agility, and create a flexible
before.
approach to business to quickly take advantage of new
As technology drives the transformation to digital business, circumstances. The rise of new competitive threats from
the opportunities for disruption increase, both from within companies born outside the rules of the traditional auto
the industry and from new and often unexpected external industry makes this need for digital change even more
threats. Technology trends such as the rise of mobile and imperative.
pervasive connectivity, data and machine learning, 3D
printing and the Social Network of Things, the cloud and
virtual systems, APIs and open

NTT Innovation Institute, Inc.

2 NTTI3.COM
TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 1
The Evolution of the Auto Industry: Past, Present and Future 6
• From Auto 1.0 to Auto 4.0
• Why the Industry Has Struggled to Change

CHAPTER 2
Trends Driving Structural Change in Business 16
• Digitization
• The Rise of Millennials and Digital Natives
• Apple-ization
• The Sharing Economy and “Asset-Light” World

CHAPTER 3
The Drivers of Digital Business Transformation 27
• Technology and Digital Transformation
• The Social Network of Things
• Robotics, Autonomous Control, and 3D Printing
• The Connected Car, Connected Driver, and Mobility Customer
• Data, Machine Learning, and Cyber-Security
• Open Source Patents and APIs
• The Changing Nature and Sources of Competition

3 NTTI3.COM
TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER 4
Auto 2.0: The Current State of the Industry 44
• Industry 4.0
• Manufacturing Technology
• Redefining the Supply Chain
• The Connected Car Version 1.0
• The Birth of Mobility Services

CHAPTER 5
Learning from Today’s Cutting-Edge Leaders 56
• Tesla
• Google Self-Driving Car Project
• BMW iSeries and Consumer Mobility Initiatives

CHAPTER 6
Auto 3.0: Building the New Value Chain of Customer-Centered Innovation 69
• Rethink Value
• Re-imagine the Customer Experience
• Reconsider Culture
• Reorient Processes and Operations
• Re-Engineer IT

4 NTTI3.COM
TABLE OF CONTENTS APPENDIX 83
• About NTT Innovation Institute Inc.
• About the Authors
• Collaborator and Contributor Bios
• Other Books from NTT Innovation Institute Inc.
• Photo Credits

5 NTTI3.COM
CHAPTER 1

The
evolution
of the auto
industry:
past,
present,
and future

FROM AUTO 1.0 TO 4.0

WHY THE INDUSTRY


HAS STRUGGLED TO CHANGE

6 NTTI3.COM
FROM AUTO 1.0 TO 4.0
“I will build a car for
the great multitude…
constructed of the
In the past 130 years, there have aimed at the American consumer.
best materials, by
been very few businesses that can In 1908, Ford created the Model T, the best men to be
rival the automotive industry for the first car aggressively marketed
hired, after the
the unmistakable way that it has to appeal to the experiential
both reflected and been shaped aspirations of the average family. simplest designs that
by significant global social, cultural Ford not only began the articulation modern engineering
and economic changes. And now, of auto marketing, but also
digital technology is becoming addressed the former limitations of
can devise… so low
an important way in which those the business side of the industry. in price that no man
changes are addressed – from He introduced and put into practice
making a good
understanding customer values and mass production efficiencies, early
defining the consumer experience, lean manufacturing techniques, salary will be unable
to re-engineering the systems that and vertical supply chain integration to own one…”
impact design and manufacturing. (coal and iron mines, timberlands,
rubber plantations, a railroad, – Henry Ford, 1913
Auto 1.0 freighters, sawmills, blast furnaces,
Most historians credit the a glassworks).
German inventor Karl Benz with Fast forward to the start of the
creating the first modern Great Depression, car companies
production automobile in 1886. were largely small and specialized.
For two decades, the automobile By the end of the decade, they
was considered to be a novelty had been consolidated into the
item because they were expensive larger corporate brands that would
and time-consuming to produce. dominate the industry for the
Between 1904 and 1908, 241 next half century.
different firms began producing cars

7 NTTI3.COM
“We at BMW do not
build cars as consumer
objects, just to drive
Auto 2.0 from A to B. We build
Today, the majority of the practices manifest decades old perspectives mobile works of art.”
of mainstream automobile on the relationship between
companies in Auto 2.0 mirror the distribution efficiencies – Chris Bangle, noted automobile
cultural and economic forces that and consumer experience. designer and former
Chief of Design for BMW
shaped the industry over the past
The integration of technology
half century. The result is that the
into vehicles has been
historic differentiators of quality
largely invisible to the consumer,
and reliability have become
focused more on performance
mere table stakes in the industry.
and dealer diagnostics
The post WWII emotional love systems. The advent of the
affair with the car still drives connected car, with the
much of car design decisions. provision of basic infotainment
Mainstream hybrid explorations systems, is just beginning to
are informed by the echoes of change the role of technology
the 1970s oil crisis that first forced for most manufacturers.
the industry to consider factors
other than design and performance.
The globalization of car production
and focus on lean manufacturing
has its roots in Toyota’s approaches
in the 1980s. Capital-intensive
dealer networks and showrooms

8 NTTI3.COM
“Your car should drive itself. It’s
amazing to me that we let humans
drive cars... It’s a bug that cars
were invented before computers.”
– Eric Schmidt, Google Chairman Auto 2.5
Most of the automobile industry via OTA software updates that
examplifies the focus on internal repair problems, bring new levels of
processes with the vehicle design optimization, and even new features
and manufacturing value chain of without ever going to a dealer.
Auto 2.0. There are, however, new
“Connected technology” is having a
intrapreneurial labs from established
significant impact both on customer
major auto OEMs (such as BMW
expectations about experience
iSeries) and new aggressive entrants
and also on how forward-thinking
(such as Tesla) that seek to redefine
auto OEMs are re-prioritizing and re-
the industry by addressing digitally-
engineering their end-to-end value
defined niches that may quickly
chain. For the Auto 2.5 company,
become mass. This is where the
this is about the design of business
cutting edge of cars is to be found
that fully reflects the value of the
today.
customer over the efficiencies
For the digital leaders in the auto and financial ROI of car production.
industry, the Auto 2.0 concept
of “connected car” is evolving into
the Auto 2.5 “connected driver.”
Software functionality is no longer
limited to infotainment delivery,
but can now offer consumers the
ability to transform their vehicles

9 NTTI3.COM
Auto 3.0
In this near future, the next phase of
evolution of the auto industry will be
defined by more consumer-centric
approaches to cars and mobility that
are reflected throughout the entire
value chain. Auto OEMs will need
to begin to find ways to derive and
drive value from technology-fueled
social forces such as the Sharing
Economy and Social Network of
Things – or risk rapidly becoming
irrelevant within a decade.

The long emotional love affair with


cars may be supplanted by, or at
least matched with, a world in which
“mobility customer” decisions are
driven by a need for utility and
flexibility, as well as for sexy design
and power.

The model of the “car as digital


app” combined with pervasive
electric charging networks,
autonomous driving capabilities,
and urban on-demand services (e.g
Uber and Lyft) will have significant
impacts not only on car ownership,
but on the industry’s historical
infrastructure and economics and
related industries such as insurance.

10 NTTI3.COM
Auto 4.0
The technological, social, and And “roads” – how might they
economic forces of Auto 3.0 will evolve as well? It’s too soon to
become mainstream in Auto 4.0. know what might happen with
With this may well come the final the Hyperloop project – “a cross
and definitive change in redefining between a Concorde, a railgun,
the industry as one of “mobility” and an air hockey table.” Among “For crowded cities,
as opposed to “automobiles.” others, there is already a team
they (flying cars) are
of engineers working on this
Within 20 years, there will be tens
at Hyperloop Technologies, a godsend. But for
of millions of autonomous vehicles.
The ability to call for a vehicle (with
a company founded by venture places like Africa which
investor Shervin Pishevar and
or without a driver) on demand
former SpaceX Engineer Brogan
has no passable roads
may create a new model of shared
Bambrogan. (especially during rainy
ownership or access to vehicles
and services that take the current What would the world look season), these future
utilization of cars from 5-10% to like if you could take an on- Transporters are the
75% of the hours in a day. demand autonomous vehicle to
a Hyperloop station? equivalent of Africa
We might even see the flying car
long promised in science fiction.
skipping the copper-line
Perhaps it will look more like a phone system and going
grown-up version of the quadcopter straight to wireless.”
drones that we see today.
Developments in battery, navigation – Peter Diamandis, entrepreneur,
and lightweight, high-strength founder of the X Prize Foundation
materials are making this more and Singularity University
possible today than ever before.

11 NTTI3.COM
WHY THE INDUSTRY
HAS STRUGGLED TO CHANGE

Misaligned Design Cycles


The mainstream auto industry still isolated from each other. The lack
struggles with long and misaligned of standards also continues to be
design cycles. While many of the an additional burden to change.
industry majors have been able to
As innovation-driven technology
shorten their cycles from 5-7 years
companies move more aggressively
down to 2-3 years, this still does
into the auto industry, the hard-
not keep pace with the meteoric
ware-software design integration
speed of change in the software and
cycle becomes even more complex.
electronics components that evolve
This is particularly true given
every 6-12 months. As software
auto OEMs’ limited relationships
becomes an increasingly important
with companies such as Google,
part of the mobility equation, this
Microsoft, and Apple.
means that manufacturers may
well choose to continue to build If the auto industry fails to readdress
more premium cars with software- the design cycle issue, it is open
electronics integration that is to significant disruption from
outdated as soon as they roll off initiatives outside the industry.
the assembly line. Effectively aligning and compressing
design cycles would enable
The strategies that the industry
OEMs to provide more timely and
has chosen to pursue in order to
improved integration of electronics
address this issue have had little
and software technology into
significant impact. Using agile and
their vehicles, create a stronger
system engineering methodologies
relationship with the customer, and
may yield some improvement within
open new revenue opportunities
individual teams, but the needle will
from ongoing services and software-
not move as long as mechanical
driven customization.
and software teams remain relatively

12 NTTI3.COM
Configuration Complexity
Premium OEMs in particular have are largely engineering and
pursued a strategy of allowing for manufacturing-driven decisions that
consumer customization of their do not strongly tie back to economic
products by providing an increasing and consumer considerations.
number of options and variants.
Tesla’s approach to customer
The result has been very complex
choice is built around identifying
product structures, often with
the customization options of
hundreds of thousands of possible
greatest importance and value to
combinations. At those numbers,
their customer - as opposed to
there are real limits to the economic
offering a large volume of options.
sense of this approach in providing
The company offers limited choices
“consumer choice.” Additionally,
relating to issues that impact
too many choices can result in
manufacturing (number of models,
confusion, and effectively no con-
colors, and options packages), and
sumer choice at all.
focuses more on customization
Rather than asking the question of and value driven by software after
what the most important elements purchase.
of choice are to the customer
If the auto industry cannot
and concentrating only on those,
reframe the current approach to
the industry has focused on
configuration complexity – which is
various business and engineering
growing with more options coming
processes to more effectively
from world of software – many
manage the large numbers of
of their key processes of product
possibilities it is creating. Product
development, manufacturing
structure management with Boolean
engineering, production, and
expressions, variant management,
logistics will be negatively impacted.
modularization, and platforms

13 NTTI3.COM
Capital Intensive
Manufacturing Legacy
Change is expensive. The New entrants into the market,
auto industry faces the dual such as Tesla, have been able
difficulties of writing off past to start with a relatively clean
manufacturing investment, slate. They have no legacy
while simultaneously incurring systems to evolve or outdated
significant new investment, physical plant investment to
if it is to move toward operations write off. In order to compete,
with more flexible production the major auto OEMs will have
processes. to carefully weigh the economic
risk of when and how to move
Billions of dollars have been
to manufacturing systems that will
invested over decades into the
enable them to evolve production
factories and manufacturing
faster and for far fewer dollars.
processes of established auto
companies. Business practices
require these sizeable costs to
be amortized over long periods
of time, making it very expensive
to quickly write off any of these
in order to move on to other
more flexible processes. Then
building those new manufacturing
capabilities will require their
own significant capital investment.

14 NTTI3.COM
Dealer Network Commitments
Today’s dealer networks are the
result of the optimization of an
old value chain. Dealerships are
quickly becoming an inflexible
link in the new customer value
chain – unable to respond to
evolving needs and behaviors.

Dealerships have traditionally


been positioned as the front line of
communication and engagement
with customers, and yet few
customers look forward to going
to an auto dealership. Dealerships
must evolve or be completely
rethought so that they provide
unique, valuable, self-moderated
experiences for customers. This
must go far beyond investments
in data management, customer
care technologies, and website
development. The fundamental
question must be about the
kind of relationship the customer
values and how to deliver that, as
opposed to how to optimize the
existing distribution infrastructure.

15 NTTI3.COM
CHAPTER 2

Trends
driving
structural
change in
business

DIGITIZATION

MILLENNIALS

APPLE-IZATION

THE SHARING ECONOMY


AND “ASSET-LIGHT” WORLD

16 NTTI3.COM
Moore’s Law Cheap, Fast Storage Millennials

Miniaturization 3D Printing and Scanning Eco-friendly

Mobile Apple-ization Immigration

Computer Aided Industrial Design IoT and Sensors Longevity

COMPUTING CONNECTIVITY DIGITIZATION ECONOMIC DEMOGRAPHIC

Universal Connectivity Rise of Asia as an Economic Power

Personal Area Networks Slow Growth in EU

Great Recession of 2008


Broadband and Wireless
Sharing Economy
LAN/WAN
Globalization

17 NTTI3.COM
DIGITIZATION

As nearly every aspect of modern and values around mobility and The reason why it is
business that was once analog transportation. The need to
so difficult for existing
moves to digital, the opportunities respond to the new mobility
for disruption increase. Market customer compels the consideration firms to capitalize on
boundaries become permeable. of changes in internal business disruptive innovations
The technical and talent resources processes, manufacturing,
required to mount a legitimate distribution and supplier partnerships
is that their processes
challenge to an established leader to effectively respond and compete. and their business
become easily accessible.
model that make them
Digitization of the world means that good at the existing
no one approach to a market or
innovation is competitive for long. business actually make
Established and once stable industry them bad at competing
leaders now face challengers from
for the disruption.”
outside the traditional industry
boundaries - companies such as
- Clayton Christensen,
Google, Apple, and an army of Harvard Business School
well-funded and nimble technology professor and author “The
startups. Innovator’s Dilemma”

Digitization of the formerly analog


world of the automobile is forcing
companies to face unprecedented
change in customer expectations

18 NTTI3.COM
MILLENNIALS

Millennial
Generally defined as the generation
born 1981-1996. There are more than
70M in the US, a group that is now The Rise of Millennials
larger than either Gen X or boomers. and Digital Natives
They currently represent more than
Both the sheer size and digital year olds being out of workforce,
$170B in purchasing power in the US,
technology savvy of the Millennial with many “boomeranging”
expected to grow to $1.4T by 2020. and Digital Native make them back into the homes of their
Globally there are 2.5B Millennials or important forces for the automotive “helicopter parents”
1/3 of the world’s entire population. business to understand and engage.
• Significant changes in
Detached from traditional institutions
Digital Native attitudes toward privacy and
while intimately attached to their
A phrase coined in 2001 by author trust in government and
mobile devices, they are creating
Marc Prensky, this term does not business, with Edward Snowden
their own social and economic
and Julian Assange as icons
refer to any specific generation. networks of friends, partners, and
It is a “catch-all” for individuals brand relationships. • Increasing globalization of the
who are indigenous to the use of work force with jobs leaving
Millennials have been shaped from
technology, such as the Internet, traditional powerhouses like
their earliest days by significant
computers, and mobile devices – the US
social and economic factors that
both at home and in school. It is
have had an undeniable impact on While these events would be
assumed that their early and constant
how they see, operate, and engage expected to have decades long
exposure to technology has provided with the world. These include: negative consequences on
them with a personal understanding their views of human nature and
and social relationship with it that is • Fifteen years of conflict in the
economic futures, this group still
unlike any other group.
Middle East and a new age
exhibits a generational personality
of terrorism born out of 9/11
that demonstrates confidence, multi-
• The 2007-2009 Great Recession modal self-expression, flexibility,
and the anemic recovery that and connectedness to technology
followed, resulting in 1/3 of 18-29 and social groups.

19 NTTI3.COM
Compared to
previous generations,
Millennials are:

Millennials have a unique Tracking to be Not unexpectedly, the behaviors 35-54? Will their behaviors
relationship with how they the most educated of Millennials are leading changes be the same as they are today,
choose, use, and advocate generation ever in many areas of mobility. In the or will they revert to traditional
brands, products, and services. US, Millennials are driving less than patterns of ownership and use?
More detached from
Products must provide utility major institutions such
previous generations in America
Regardless of which scenario
with quality, and design married as political parties, with a 23% decline in 2009 from
proves to be true, the amount
with function. And they no organized religion, the 2001. Additionally, the percentage
of driving is likely to be lower
longer see ownership of a military, and marriage that hold driver’s licenses is at its
than recent years. This will have
product as required for access lowest level in 50 years (67% in
Linked and defined by significant implications for auto
to the service it provides. 2011). This may be the result of
technology and the kind manufacturers, adjacent industries,
several interrelated trends: growth
of relationships it the demand for different types of
enables with business
in preference for walkable urban
mobility, and even public policy
and social groups neighborhoods, economic recession
and transportation infrastructure.
making car ownership difficult, and
Low on social access to on-demand car sharing
trust, but upbeat services fueled by the pervasiveness
about the future
of smart phones.
Dealing with economic What will happen in the decade
hardships of student loan
starting in 2030 when this group
debt and unemployment
reaches what has historically been
More racially diverse considered the peak driving ages of

20 NTTI3.COM
APPLE-IZATION

Apple has been at the forefront There are several key lessons
of the companies that have about both consumer value and
consistently and inventively enterprise operations (and their
launched products and services relationship to each other) that
that are deeply personal, can be taken from Apple’s success
meaningful, and intuitive. They and applied to the auto industry:
have conditioned their customers
• Balance of Design
to expect useful and powerful
and Utility
The Apple iPhone is a study in a company truly understanding technology delivered with a deep
what is core to the user experience of a product, where to understanding of the desired • Rise of Mass Customization
provide customization, when to remove complexity from user experience and a distinctive
• Importance of the
minimalist design. The company
distribution, and how to deliver value at every step of the game. Supporting Ecosystem
has designed its value chain to
The iPhone is available in four models. For all models except reflect those philosophies - from • Abundance of
the choice of materials to the in- Consumer Choice
the iPhone 5c, only three metallic finishes are available. These
store and online “fan” experiences.
limited choices define the majority of the manufacturing process. • Consumer Expectation
Everything else is essentially an accessory from Apple or a third Other companies inside and far of Product Obsolescence
party in a well-orchestrated partner ecosystem. outside the world of consumer
technology are studying the • Product and Business
Customization and personalization are delivered largely though Apple phenomena, what we call Amortization Cycles
apps. This approach provides needed variety “Apple-ization,” as one of the
without injecting undue complexity that leads to roadblocks ultimate learning opportunities for
within distribution and even consumer choice. the digitally-driven business.

21 NTTI3.COM
Balance of Design and Utility Rise of Mass Customization Importance of the Ecosystem
With an Apple product, form and Apple limits the configuration choices Dating back to the days of the Apple
function naturally go hand-in- available to consumers to reflect II, the company has excelled at
hand. There is a well-established those aspects of the experience that building and supporting a robust
customer expectation that the benefit the most from personal choice.
ecosystem of third party developers.
brand delivers human-centered Strategic limitations on configurations
This success results from the
design with elegance and value. also lead to manufacturing and supply
chain efficiencies. Within the world of company’s emphasis on delivering a
hardware, Apple is clearly on the side reliable, well-designed foundation on
that more choice is not always best, top of which others can create value.
and may actually lead to inaction from Apple’s customers benefit from
an overwhelmed customer. greater personalization of products
without Apple having to shoulder the
business burden.

lesson: lesson: lesson:


Utility wrapped in human-centered Balance product personalization with Keep the core product straightforward
design is today’s baseline expectation standardization of manufacturing and and simple, and then add physical
from the digitally-savvy customer. predictability of delivery. customization through an ecosystem
of well-informed and collaborative
partners.

22 NTTI3.COM
Abundant Consumer Choice Consumer Expectation of Amortization Cycles
Product Obsolescence
The world of the iTunes and Even with the ability to upgrade
Apps Stores has given the Apple The rhythm of new hardware and change functionality through
customer a nearly endless world announcements and software software, product and business
of choice to add functionality to upgrades has accustomed amortization cycles have changed
their product. Barriers to switching customers to expect various levels in response to the speed of
to a different app and vendor in of obsolescence in products. technology change. Different levels
those environments are virtually Some of the “Apple fans” must have of performance and function are
non-existent. every new product at the moment now expected every 18 months as
of launch, and end up replacing opposed to 3-5 years.
products every 18 months or less.
Others wait for a new product to
become more established and to
prove its value.

lesson: lesson: lesson:


Understand what is important for user Products will have varying levels Business must respond to ever
customization to deliver the most value. of “obsolescence” depending on shrinking cycles of consumer value.
Don’t touch anything else. Too much the ability to add value and function A 5-year development cycle doesn’t
choice can become no choice. through after-market software. work if the product is essentially
technologically obsolete at release.

23 NTTI3.COM
Apple has demonstrated that the elements
of choice, flexibility, transparency and
consumer-defined experience are now critical
dimensions that businesses cannot ignore.

The “Apple-ization” of the auto industry could


help drive the business and their IT organizations
to look beyond technology as an end in itself -
and to focus on the experience and value
provided to customers by their technology-
enabled products and services.

24 NTTI3.COM
THE SHARING ECONOMY
AND “ASSET-LIGHT” WORLD

Mary Meeker, a partner at the The meteoric growth and valu-


venture capital firm Kleiner, Perkins, ations of some of the Sharing
Caufield, & Byers, has identified Economy’s most famous “unicorns”
a growing generation of consumers has resulted from their ability
as the “Asset-Light Generation.” to take full advantage of:
These individuals have embraced
• Digital representation and
preferences for utility and
transfer of physical assets
simplicity along with a new model
owned by others
of consumption that is motivated
by their desire to save resources, • Ability to quickly and
money, and time. Their preferred intelligently identify excess
social engagement and on- capacity and then aggregate
demand consumption models are mass audience around intent
dramatically changing the business
• Cultural zeitgeist,
landscape, and have already
economic concerns, and
lead to the emergence and growth
values of Millennials
“I want to be able to go to any city and be
of the Sharing Economy.
able to get around that city for less than the
The Sharing Economy’s models
That Sharing Economy is a vibrant,
of operations and growth may cost of owning a car and with the ease of a
culturally-driven economic system
built around the sharing of human
permanently change the rules of car without actually having to own a car. I
some of the most asset-intensive
and physical assets. It redefines
industries in the world, including
want to be able to consume transportation
economic flexibility to make it
easier for people to get what they
the auto industry. as a service.”
want, when and how they want
– Logan Green,
it. And it has created new, and CEO and co-founder of Lyft
still controversial, ways of making
additional money, if not a full living.

25 NTTI3.COM
What do the behaviors and rules of
the Sharing Economy mean for the
auto industry and related markets?

• As Millennials age into their prime • Customers are evolving


driving years, the average driver’s into relationships with
need for a car or multiple cars companies that are more similar
(at least in the US) may decline to collaborative partnerships
rapidly given their experience with versus extractive consumerism.
on-demand mobility.
• Public policy and discussion
• New levels of trust and rapport around appropriate regulation
are developing for members of that enable the delivery of
the “asset-light” economy and consumer-desired mobility types
the on-demand mobility service in urban environments may gate,
providers they interact with up but not stop, expansion.
to several times per day.
• Insurance liability is shifting
• Value is noted and rated from the individual user or driver
“What we maybe should’ve realized sooner immediately and directly. to the service provider (Uber,
Positive experiences relayed via Lyft, ZipCar), or even to the
was that we are running a political campaign
social channels trumps traditional manufacturer for future self-
and the candidate is Uber. And this political advertising for users who want driving cars. This provides both
race is happening in every major city in the to hear about new products a challenge in terms of new
and services from their friends business risk, but also provides
world. And because this isn’t about a democracy, and trusted influencers. an opportunity for expansion into
this is about a product, you can’t win 51 to 49. the adjacent insurance market.
You have to win 98 to 2.”
– Travis Kalanick,
26
CEO and NTTI3.COM
co-founder, Uber
CHAPTER 3

The drivers
of digital
business
transformation
TECHNOLOGY AND DIGITAL
TRANSFORMATION

THE SOCIAL NETWORK


OF THINGS

ROBOTICS, AUTONOMOUS CONTROL,


AND 3D PRINTING

THE CONNECTED CAR, CONNECTED


DRIVER, AND MOBILITY CUSTOMER

DATA, MACHINE LEARNING, AND CYBER-


SECURITY

OPEN SOURCE PATENTS


AND APIS

THE CHANGING NATURE AND


SOURCES OF COMPETITION
27 NTTI3.COM
If we believe that all businesses
now need to become technology
first digital businesses,
then how do we define that?

Digital Business:

• Provides customer-centric,
seamless, and context- Key Attributes of
a Digital
aware experiences that result
Business Technology
in a sustainable competitive
advantage. Flexibility
Scalability
• Requires technology, but Interoperability
demands a vision and plan
beyond the latest technology
in order to deliver on a Human Relationships
new value proposition. Empathy and Relevance
Respect
• Moves beyond the “value
extraction” model of a “consumer”
to an approach built around
“reciprocal exchange” of value
with customers.

• Operates in ecosystems where


the focus of competition has
shifted from product features to
individualized experiences.

• Delivers experiences designed


to play to a firm’s strengths by
leveraging people, processes,
data and the Social Network
of Things across the entire
value chain.

28 NTTI3.COM
TECHNOLOGY AND DIGITAL
TRANSFORMATION

Technology is a necessary, but • Act faster by lowering barriers Interoperability


not sufficient, component of digital to entry and enabling their Today’s customers expect seamless
transformation. When it does employees to experiment quickly experiences that blend individual
come to technology, businesses and cheaply with prototypes and transactions and engagements into
need to focus on, understand, and pilot programs a larger context across all of their
implement systems that follow three touch points with a company or
• Adapt business and operational
critical characteristics of flexibility, product. Digital businesses focus
models to changing customer
scalability, and interoperability. on interoperability and its standards
desires and market dynamics
in order to create and deliver:
Flexibility
Scalability
Digital businesses are built to • Customer experiences that easily
In order to build a truly flexible and travel across all platforms and
achieve sustainable competitive
adaptive system, companies must networks, from a desktop in an
advantage by being agile, resilient,
know how to start small and quickly office, to a smartphone on the go,
and responsive. They understand
experiment with solutions. This to an embedded system
the importance of flexible enterprise
allows them to test effectiveness
architectures and build efficient, • Highly integrated and intelligent
before choosing to scale to meet
reliable back-end systems. Digital manufacturing facilities and
high demand - or - ramp down to
businesses use technology flexibility supply chains
reduce costs. Digital businesses can
to enable them to:
use scalability to help them design:
• Think smarter through the
• Flexible enterprise architectures
intelligent and effective use of
that can be expanded across
predictive and real-time analytics
the company
at all critical touch points of the
data value stream • Partnerships with cloud, SaaS,
and security providers, so that
internal teams can focus on code
and users

29 NTTI3.COM
THE SOCIAL NETWORK
OF THINGS

Evolving from the Internet of Things Phase 2: The Transition to Greater “In the twentieth century, computers
to the Social Network of Things Integration and Intelligence
were brains without senses—they only
Since the phrase was first coined Today, industry evolution has
in 1999 by the British entrepreneur taken us to somewhere between knew what we told them. That was a
Kevin Ashton, much has been the Internet of Things and the huge limitation… In the twenty-first
written and debated about the near future possibilities of the
potentially game-changing impact Social Network of Things. Last
century, because of the Internet of
of the Internet of Things as it year’s isolated products with Things, computers can sense things for
relates to the evolution of consumer attached sensors are being
themselves… In the imminent future, it
experiences and enterprise replaced with greater levels of
processes. network power, social connectivity, will enable things like self-driving cars,
systems interoperability, and which will give us back the 20 days a year
Phase 1: Internet of Things robotic hardware. In the car, this
The first phase of IoT largely is experienced in the evolution of
we spend doing nothing but driving, will
focused on adding sensors to navigation from old GPS systems save 40,000 lives a year in the U.S. alone,
devices designed for relatively to the socially-driven Waze app
will reduce traffic and pollution, and will
isolated purposes, with the and community. In the smart factory,
data generated primarily used this is about machines that can allow cities to grow without devoting as
for reporting purposes. This is predict maintenance needs and much land to roads.”
still the case for the majority order their own replacement parts.
of companies and applications. – Kevin Ashton in The Smithsonian, January 2015
Look at Fitbit in the consumer
space, most smart meters
in the utility industry, and
on-board data recording or
navigation systems in cars.

30 NTTI3.COM
Imagine a driving environment in which there are
three kinds of “cars.” Some will be fully automated,
others will have simple systems for accident
avoidance and traffic routing, and still others will Phase 3:
be little different than today’s average cars. In such The Social Network of Things
a complex landscape of old and new, cars and The Social Network of Things How will we look at a world in
networks will need to be built to be adaptable, is predicted to mark a time when which it is becoming less possible
self-aware, and able to communicate in real-time devices, machines, and people to decouple human from machine
between each other and with humans. are deeply connected through social networks?
pervasive computing, rich networks
How will we build interfaces and
with highly integrated sensing
networks that enable us to interact
capabilities, advances in machine
with machines that make key
learning and cognitive computing,
decisions for and about other human
robust APIs and equally important
beings—such as two driverless
– significant cultural changes.
cars coordinating with each other to
This evolution of connectivity,
avoid an accident?
integrated standards, and
intelligence will enable most of our How will we need to evolve IT
personal devices and industrial platforms and systems to be able
machines to increasingly interact, to respond to the needs and
collaborate and coordinate with demands of billions of connected
each other – if that is the human devices that can easily impact the
design choice. This is what safety and health of humanity?
distinguishes the Social Network
How will we define and ensure the
of Things and its evolution from
level of cyber-security needed to
today’s Internet of Things.
protect someone’s life in a vehicle,
An auto industry that is integrating which far exceeds that needed
the Social Network of Things will for today’s e-commerce and mobile
be faced with some fascinating and wallet transactions?
fundamental questions.

31 NTTI3.COM
Evolving from the Internet of Things to the Social Network of Things

INTERNET OF THINGS TRANSITIONAL PHASE SOCIAL NETWORK OF THINGS

Introduction of basic networks


Purposes for devices Devices are highly networked
and social aspects
OVERVIEW are still relatively isolated Devices and systems that can predict,
Basic augmentation of human
Information focused on reporting negotiate, and impact outcomes
capacity

THE SEARCH
Efficiency Efficiency Transformative experiences
FOR

Access to recent info Near real-time on-demand Real-time data from


DATA
from individual devices data access multiple sources

Device data to human Limited machine learning


INTELLIGENCE Autonomous decision making
feedback loop driven by humans

Privacy Privacy v. Functionality Safety conflicts


Security Network security v. Innovation Cyber-security
CHALLENGES
Interoperability Interoperability Social and technology complexity
Limited Networks Dumb Networks Legacy systems

Products dominate Adaptive and resilient platforms


Cloud platforms
systems and networks Little Data
Data
Analytics and Big Data Cognitive computing
TECHNOLOGY Proximity Tools
Machine learning Rich APIs
Sensors
Smart products Proliferation of robotics
Robotic toys
Robotic manufacturing and intelligent devices

Waze app and crowd


EXAMPLE Web-enables GPS and maps Self-driving cars
sourcing community

32 NTTI3.COM
COGNITIVE ROBOTIC SYSTEMS,
AUTONOMOUS CONTROL,
AND 3D PRINTING

Auto manufacturing processes have To achieve this, the industry has


largely been limited to assembly focused on developing smarter
within one single factory. Technology internal devices and processes.
and consumer value demands The ripples through the enterprise
are already in play that will soon have been largely about the
result in the elimination of the impact on a financial ROI metric.
boundaries of individual factories.
Production will be based around In the unfolding world of Auto
virtually interconnected facilities 3.0, manufacturing is more about
and labs in multiple geographical software and hardware systems
regions. The world of production will standards that facilitate deep
become increasingly networked until integration that turns real-time
“everything is intelligently connected data into intelligence and
with everything else.” This means autonomous action. The focus
that the complexity of production on intelligence will be on both FUTURE SCENARIO
and supplier networks will grow autonomous cognitive machines
In the near future, Industry 4.0 and the
enormously, before they eventually and more advanced human-
machine collaboration. This Social Network of Things may lead
become simpler.
cycle of evolution will enable us to fully autonomous manufacturing
Evolution of the Integrated Value mass customization and greater facilities and production plants. A
Chain of Manufacturing responsiveness to customer production plant could exist in any
To date, the strategic focus on values. The new metric of success location in the world, and be run
change in manufacturing has will no longer just be ROI, but from another location. When needed,
been on increasing the speed and the customer value attributed engineers could be dispatched to
flexibility of production and how to transparency, accessible make repairs or perform maintenance,
that determines how effectively and relationships, and a “bespoke-like” knowing exactly what to expect and
efficiently a car can be produced. product. which parts or tools to bring.

33 NTTI3.COM
The coming evolution of the
auto factory will be defined
by “advanced cyber-physical
systems” that include:
Cultural Changes Required for
Next Generation Manufacturing • Human-machine interfaces
and “collaborative robotics”
Cultural change will be required
for the next evolution of auto • Self-aware machines with
manufacturing. This will be autonomous control
especially true in relationship to the
need for increasing acceptance • Networked systems that
of information technology and can directly influence their
collaborative systems outside the environment
company’s own controlled factory • Flexible and small batch
environments. manufacturing systems
In an industry where there is • Condition monitoring and
increasing dependence on suppliers predictive maintenance
to provide just in time delivery,
wouldn’t it help the production line • Intelligent self-organizing
to know exactly where the truck logistics
is with those materials, or if it is in
a traffic jam? That kind of timely
information would enable the
production line to be automatically
and autonomously adjusted for any
schedule change.

Consumer technology companies


such as Amazon, Airbnb, and
Uber have shown that this
kind of transparency can be a key
competitive advantage.

34 NTTI3.COM
Traditional car manufacturers spend
about $3B to bring a new car model
to market. Startup manufacturer Local
Motors now claims to be able to bring
a model to market for $3M, albeit not
at the same production scale. That’s
a 1,000X improvement. Open-source 3D Printing Goes Mainstream
motor vehicle designs, design co- 3D printing technology can have one easily accessible. Using locally
creation, the use of micro-factories, significant impact on several deployed 3D printers and creating
and 3D printing are among the key touch points in the auto value a “print parts on demand” service
technology and process drivers for chain including the design cycle, business could change not only
this company. replacement parts for customer the customer experience, but
service, and even customer co- also the whole supply chain and
  design of their vehicles. warehousing infrastructure.

As cars and processes have For the car enthusiast, what might
become increasingly digital in the be more intriguing than being able
auto industry, one of the challenges to be the co-designer of part of their
has been in the misalignment of own vehicle? There are companies
hardware-software design and today that can print the outside of
development cycles. What if the a car. That creates a new kind of
cycle for hardware could look more mass customization for the industry.
like its accompanying software,
and be compressed to under
a year? This could be possible
with the use of 3D printers to create
prototypes in the design cycle.

For the car owner, one of the


greatest annoyances is in needing
a replacement part and not having

35 NTTI3.COM
THE CONNECTED CAR,
CONNECTED DRIVER
AND MOBILITY CUSTOMER

When “cars become apps”


and on-demand mobility doesn’t
require owning a vehicle

The evolution of the connected car Connected Car Connected Driver Mobility Customer
presents new requirements and The connected car has largely With the connected driver, there Mobility customers look across a
challenges for the auto industry. been focused on delivering content is a deeper integration of the variety of platforms and options for
While the connected car has been a from infotainment networks and customer-car-service relationship. their transportation needs, which
part of the language of the industry enabling dealers to access black The “car functions as an app” are often on-demand. Their choices
for over a decade, the rise of the boxes for diagnostics. enabling the vehicle to obtain new may be the result of a practical and
connected driver and the mobility functionality and service repairs emotional rethinking of how they
customer is relatively new – and will via OTA software uploads. The relate to their once beloved cars.
be game-changing for those who driver experience discussion They may see all options as equally
are prepared. evolves beyond the tradeoffs of likely: car ownership, two-way car
the distracted driver and their sharing, one-way ride sharing, app-
infotainment systems. New facilitated car pools, long distance
business models around “renting” buses, and even bike sharing.
downloadable capabilities in the
car versus permanently purchasing
them become possibilities.

CONNECTED CONNECTED MOBILITY


CAR DRIVER CUSTOMER

36 NTTI3.COM
What will facilitate the ability
to address the evolving
needs of the connected driver
and mobility customer?

In today’s most cutting edge Technology Capabilities Product Development Cycles


versions of the connected car, New technical capabilities will Processes, systems, and
we are already seeing a reflection need to reside inside auto OEMs technologies will need to be
of the consumer expectations or by means of close strategic implemented to more closely
of services in an on-demand, partnership. Many of these sync the development cycles
everywhere accessible world. skills are in areas that have not of software and hardware,
Decreasing costs of connectivity; traditionally been strengths for and to meet the “I want it now”
understanding the tradeoffs the industry - including software demands of customers.
between tethered, embedded, development, telecommunications
and hybrid systems; and the engineering, user experience
ubiquitous presence of smart design, and IT automation. Data Integration
phones have framed the discussion
Front-end systems will need
and development.
Driver Experience and to be able to seamlessly address
That which has slowed or even Embedded versus Tethered greater data volumes and
prevented the development of or Hybrid Systems integration, always-available
certain kinds of services in the past Will customers continue to be connectivity, and countless apps.
- will be diminished or removed reluctant to pay the cost of With the reliance on data to drive
in the world of Auto 3.0 where embedded systems vs. those on customer experience and car
the connected driver and mobility their smart phones? What kind functionality, backend systems
customer will rule. of relationship with the customer and technologies around analytics,
can and should auto OEMs have data privacy, and cyber-security
in a world where Apple CarPlay will be as important as the design
and Google are moving into the of the physical driver experience.
driver’s cockpit?

37 NTTI3.COM
BIG AND LITTLE DATA,
MACHINE LEARNING,
AND CYBER-SECURITY

Data is core to understanding Big Data Little Data


and delivering on both the The unprecedented growth in Little Data includes information
new customer experiences volume, variety and velocity of Big about the activities and actions
and manufacturing processes Data that is generated moment- of an individual person including:
demanded by Auto 3.0. The to-moment by both driver/car in-car infotainment preferences,
automotive industry is projected and manufacturing activities patterns of travel, and social media
to be the 2nd largest generator provides new opportunities to auto engagement. Small data can yield
of data in the world in 2015. companies. That will be true if the deep understanding about both
To take advantage of the new right systems and expertise can be micro and macro trends. The
data-driven business opportunities, put in place that are in alignment key to unlocking these insights is
auto OEMs will need to under- with the customer value chain. Big not just about technology, but
stand and address IT infrastructure, Data is being generated from: the also social and legal contracts.
technology expertise, and car itself, manufacturing processes, Companies must not only get “Data science is the
business and policy systems
in relationship to the issues of:
supply chain, content and permission from someone to collect next hurdle. Information
technology partners, and customer their data (opt-in vs. opt-out),
interactions. but also clearly set expectations
is trivial unless you
• Big Data
for its use and how it will deliver can make sense of it,
• Little Data Using Big Data requires intelligent
value to the consumer, and not just
data warehouses, advances in and we’re working on
• Machine Learning and to the business.
real-time analytics, and well- machines that can do
Cognitive Computing designed business intelligence
dashboards. Big Data analytics this for us.”
• Cyber-Security
have value across the entire value
– Kevin Ashton, journalist who
• Consumer Privacy chain including: product design
coined the phrase “Internet of Things”
and performance, preventive and
predictive maintenance, and supply
chain forecasting.

38 NTTI3.COM
Machine Learning and Cognitive
Computing
Machine learning based on data
inputs and outputs within specific
contexts is a key force in the
evolution of both autonomous
robotic manufacturing and self-
driving vehicles.

In the case of vehicles,


cameras, sensors, and specially
designed computers create 3D
representations of the world that
are used to navigate safely through
unpredictable traffic. The rule set
and ability to make complex split-
second decisions is the result
of both man-made and machine
learning in the systems.

In the factory, robots can have the “I like the word ‘autopilot’ more
capability for both autonomous and
human-collaborative modes as a
than I like the word ‘self-driving.’
result of the intelligence imparted ‘Self-driving’ sounds like it’s
by machine learning that evolves going to do something you don’t
them into “cognitive computers.”
In time, cognitive computing may want it to do. ‘Autopilot’ is a
expand from individual robots and good thing to have in planes,
processes to entire factories or
factory networks.
and we should have it in cars.”
- Elon Musk, CEO Tesla

39 NTTI3.COM
“We intend to protect our
customers against the abuse
of their data. I clearly say yes to
Big Data, yes to greater security
Cyber-Security
and convenience, but no to
As the volume of computers, networks and code grow both
paternalism and Big Brother.”
in the connected car and in “smart factories” there is a
– Martin Winterkorn,
growing need to understand and address the technology and Chairman of the
policy issues around cyber-security. Board of Directors of
Volkswagen AG

In Manufacturing In the Connected Car


What happens when someone What protections need to be
hijacks a factory, or even one in place to prevent the hijacking
element of a highly integrated of a car, or even to provide a
production line? warning that there is tampering
underway within a single system?
What kind of significant business
While we focus on the drama
damage, both in terms of
of a hijacked vehicle, what about
economics and brand reputation,
the economic impact of adversely
could result form undetected
hacking a vehicle’s performance?
“digital product tampering”?
As the environment around a car
become more infused with sensors
that supply real-time data to
the vehicle, what happen if those
systems are attacked?

40 NTTI3.COM
Open Source Patents and APIs
The ability to create ecosystems
of complimentary products and
services built upon the IP and APIs
of others has been a key driver
in the exponential growth of the
technology industry over the past 5
years. The auto industry has been
one that has closely guarded its
secrets in the past, so this kind of
“free market” experimental product
system has never existed. As cars
and the auto industry become
more technology-driven, might this “Tesla Motors was created to
change in the not too distant future?
accelerate the advent of sustainable
transport. If we clear a path to the
creation of compelling electric
vehicles, but then lay intellectual
property landmines behind us to
inhibit others, we are acting in
a manner contrary to that goal.”
– Elon Musk
from 6/12/2014 blog post

41 NTTI3.COM

THE CHANGING NATURE AND


SOURCES OF COMPETITION
As digital businesses are evolving, the nature and source of competition
is changing with them – often in dramatic and unexpected ways.

Technology enables competition Intermediaries and rules of Competition is Changing


from outside the industry arbitrage are no longer relevant
With technologies that lower the costs Companies and industries that have • Technology enables new
of entry into the market and that also built significant portions of their sources of competition from
enable rapid scaling on demand, competitive advantage around serving outside the industry
new entrants unburdened by legacy as gatekeeper or intermediary are
infrastructure and practices will seeing their core value propositions • Intermediaries and rules of
challenge established industry leaders. eroding and their competitive arbitrage are no longer relevant
This same dynamic may also enable advantage crumbling. Data-driven
challengers to move into adjacent technologies, the cloud, and social • Access to alternative capital
markets that expand their economic platforms are enabling challengers
sources (venture, angels,
opportunity. to quickly aggregate and understand
the crowd) inspires “little bets”
disperse sources of information, and
digital future: convey that to an audience with which
• Customer advocacy and
Will new entrants such as Tesla that it can directly communicate.
initially focus on “niche” markets
behavior is an even bigger
become the mainstream leaders of digital future: factor in competitive success
tomorrow? Will the on-demand utility- Will Google with its long held mission
driven models of app-based ride to “organize the world’s information,” • The tenure for leading
sharing services replace a significant not only help consumers make better companies becomes shorter
portion of urban auto ownership, and insurance comparison decisions, but
force a multi-platform redefinition get into the business of providing or
of mainstream mobility? Will Tesla’s brokering product itself? Will the Tesla
move into energy for homes fuel future “no dealer” model succeed, dislodging
success in cars? the traditional auto dealership structure
as industry intermediary to customers?

42 NTTI3.COM
Access to capital from the venture Customer advocacy and behavior The tenure for leading companies “Innovation
community, angels and the crowd will be an even bigger factor in a becomes shorter and is no longer
inspires “little bets” business’ competitive success guaranteed distinguishes
If the barrier of access to needed Customers are increasingly in Looking at the changes in the between
levels of capital can be lowered or the driver seat as a result of their composition of the S&P 500 over
provided through non-traditional nearly unlimited access and choice the past 60 years shows this to
a leader and
sources, challenger strategies for about information, products, and already be true. In 1958, the average a follower.”
targeting initially niche markets within services. Millennials in particular tenure of a company in this index
an industry may scale quickly to a have an innate understanding was 61 years. By 1980 this had - Steve Jobs
mass-market opportunity. Companies of marketing and of their value as dropped to 25 years, and in 2011
that pursue markets where they no consumers. They’re significantly it was but 18. At the current churn
longer need to own all of the assets more likely than older generations rate, 75% of the current firms
of “production” naturally have to believe they have the capacity to will be replaced by companies first
lower fixed financial requirements. help a brand succeed or fail. entering the index in 2027.
Challengers can also target markets Technology is accelerating this fact of
that incumbents do not see as digital future: the impermanence of business life.
returning the financial ROI required to Will customers be making decisions
support their massive infrastructure. that boards and executives are making
today? digital future:
digital future: Will size matter in the future or will
Will Tesla evolve from its initial status agility determine the leaders to follow
of “fan boy toy” to “mainstream and their tenure at the top of a new
darling” in 2017 with a $30k kind of index?
electric vehicle tied into a network of
Supercharger stations?

43 NTTI3.COM
CHAPTER 4

Auto 2.0 :
the current
state of the
industry

INDUSTRY 4.0

MANUFACTURING
TECHNOLOGY

REDEFINING THE
SUPPLY CHAIN

THE CONNECTED CAR


VERSION 1.0

THE BIRTH OF
MOBILITY SERVICES

44 NTTI3.COM
INDUSTRY 4.0

Industrial Revolution Meets Internet


Evolution
Industry 4.0 is designed to evolve
the world of manufacturing by
bringing together the machines, Interoperability and Connectivity
facilities, factories, and networks Humans, machines, and factories
can connect and communicate via the
of the Industrial Revolution
Industrial Internet of Things.
with the digital information and
communications technologies of Autonomy
Internet Revolution. Systems can make decisions
autonomously based on data, analytics,
Over the past 250 years, manu-
and past successful behaviors.
facturing has moved from a series
of “revolutions” to the current Real-Time Decision-Making
“meaningful evolution.” No longer is Technology and systems collect and
manufacturing just about isolated analyze data to provide insights that
automation via IT and isolated drive decisions from humans and/or
intelligence. It is about a new level machines.
of organization and control with fully
Process Modularity
digital and networked models of
Manufacturing is not bound by a single
product development, supply chain,
physical construct, but can adapt by
production, delivery, and service.
changing individual modules.

Service Orientation
Software enables post purchase
services to deliver additional
customization, capabilities, and
extension of the product lifecycle.

45 NTTI3.COM
By using deeply integrated With Industry 4.0 we have the The Challenges of Standards
hardware and software to birth of smart factories, products, and Security
connect machines, processes, services, and businesses. Technology always brings with it hijacks a factory, or even one
systems, and humans – both big promises and potential element of a highly integrated
Smart Factory dangers. This is no exception production line? What kind of
Intelligent networks can be
for Industry 4.0 in which both the significant business damage -
created along the entire product Data-driven networked
lack of IoT standards and cyber- both in terms of economics and
design and manufacturing value manufacturing systems with
security impact the extent to brand reputation - could that
chain - both autonomous control
and human-machine interaction. which the manufacturing elements do to a company if undetected?
These networks can constantly of the auto industry value chain If security is not effectively
inform and control each other Smart Product can evolve digitally. Without addressed, there may well be
autonomously - Customizable, technologically standards, communication between the potential for the creation
advanced, and intelligent products software solutions, machines, of “digital product tampering.”
Via real-time decision-making enabled by sensors, networks, and IT systems are difficult.
systems informed by data, communications interfaces,
analytics and machine learning. embedded software, and apps. If and when standards enable the
meaningful connection of machines,
Smart Service processes and humans - security
Physical products linked with and the potential for sabotage
software-delivered services to will need to be addressed. In the
provide customers with evolving near future auto industry, security
added value versus obsolescence.
concerns are not limited to the idea
Smart Business of hackers hijacking a connected
car. What happens when someone
New models for collaboration,
partnership and measuring
success across the value chain
of manufacturing.

46 NTTI3.COM
Industry 4.0:
Elements, Technology, and Participants

INDUSTRY 4.0 TECHNOLOGY PARTICIPANTS TECHNOLOGY


ELEMENTS INFRASTRUCTURE ENABLERS

SMART FACTORY DATA & ANALYTICS COMPANY BIG & LITTLE DATA 11
SMART PRODUCTS CLOUD SERVICES CUSTOMERS ANALYTICS

SMART SERVICES CYBER-SECURITY SUPPLIERS CLOUD

SMART BUSINESS ARCHITECTURE PARTNERS & MOBILE DEVICES


& APPLICATION EXPERTS
INTEGRATION
THE CROWD ROBOTICS

47 NTTI3.COM
MANUFACTURING
TECHNOLOGY

Building on Lean Processes


with Robotics
Much of auto production process Issues of mass customization
efficiencies and cost management are different than those of
continue to be based around mass production’s assembly
principles of lean manufacturing line speed.
with their origins in the “continuous
Industrial robots are also
flow” assembly lines of Henry
becoming an integrated part
Ford and the “Just In Time”
of the evolving lean process.
manufacturing methods of Toyota.
Their value is increasing as
With its concentration on reducing
they become more intelligent,
and avoiding inefficiencies and
collaborative and autonomous
minimizing waste, lean has defined
as a result of the Industrial
and driven the industry’s current
Internet of Things with
level of flexibility for responding to
technologies of embedded
changing output needs.
sensors, big data, real time
New ways of building on analytics, and machine learning.
lean manufacturing processes
are needed as software, and
not physical resources,
become more important in the
customer-centric process.

Tesla vs. Ford


Manufacturing Volumes

Tesla produces 110 vehicles/day


Ford produces 8,110 vehicles/day

48 NTTI3.COM
The Data Chain -
Where the auto industry excels
in manufacturing today
As an industry, today’s auto the assembly line means that the with both autonomous control and
manufacturers excel in three right information gets to the human-machine interaction will
main areas: right machine, down to the level be the standard, not the exception.
of calling out which screwdriver
• Vertical systems integration This will be the new production
and what level of torque needs
baseline in order to create the
• Automation of machines and to be applied against a particular
highly flexible factory ecosystems
production component and step. More
needed for both mass production
recently, with some machines
• Delivery of individual and mass customization.
having the ability to both send
production information from
and receive data, this new stream
orders to the assembly line
is being integrated into the
In the area of vertical systems manufacturing process, assisting
integration, the auto industry in areas such as predictive
has been a role model for other maintenance.
manufacturers. Integrating data
The most cutting edge factories of
from ERP to planning optimization
today are beginning to be positioned
to shop floor scheduling and
for the world of Auto 3.0 where
execution has been an area of
they will need to be able to respond
technical and business process
more effectively to consumer
focus. The ability to digitally
demands. Data-driven and highly
have configuration information
networked manufacturing systems
travel with every vehicle down

49 NTTI3.COM
Only a few years ago, when there
was a problem with a machine, an
engineer would be dispatched to
see what was wrong. Upon diagnosis,
they may not have the right tools
or parts and would then have to go
back to the central office to acquire
them. In a worse case scenario,
the needed parts would not even
be in stock.

In the world of the Smart Factory,


when there is an issue with a
machine, engineers receive digital
alerts about problems along with
a list of the tools and parts needed.
Tablets and GPS trackers guide
them to the exact location of the
problem and also provide visual
information to aassist in the repair.

In some factories, machines


are beginning to be able to self-
diagnose and predict problems, then
autonomously order the needed parts.

50 NTTI3.COM
REDEFINING THE
SUPPLY CHAIN

Horizontal and Vertical


Integration
Horizontal integration has been will be something else. There
the supply chain strategy of the is no permanent advantage
past in the auto industry when a here. There is only a persistent
company’s survival was defined by need for evolution and integration
its ability to quickly gain economies of the supply chain through
of scale and scope. In preparation investment and partnerships.
for the future, vertical integration
Case in point: Tesla produces 95
across all points of the value chain
percent of its parts in-house. That
is becoming a tactical and strategic
is truly massive vertical integration.
priority with increasing competitive
needs to integrate multiple stages The Tesla Gigafactory
of production, as well as to create
The Tesla Gigafactory will
individual components for the final
produce lithium-ion batteries at a
product.
rate to support the manufacture
Vertical integration has of 500,000 electric cars per year.
historically been fueled by the By 2020, the plant will be capable
vulnerability of complex global of producing as many lithium-
supply chains to economic ion batteries as the entire world
downturns. Now it is increasing produced in 2013. The company
in importance as companies expects that volume manufacturing
jockey for access to and control of its mass-market vehicle will
of new technologies and cutting- drive down the cost-per-kWh of
edge materials. Today the focus its batteries by 30 percent within
may be on batteries and carbon the first year.
fiber. In the next few years when
those become commodities, it

51 NTTI3.COM
THE CONNECTED CAR
VERSION 1.0

Connected cars are not anything Now connected cars are: Many of today’s “connected cars” have more
new. They have been around for
over a decade.
• Becoming a mobile node in lines of code than a Boeing 787. The Tesla S
a huge computer-controlled
is thought to have more than 30 million lines of
It’s what they can now do and in transport network.
the near future that is truly code, with the Chevy Volt having 10 million.
• Morphing into mobile
revolutionary. They are dramatically
data centers
changing consumer expectations
and behaviors, as well as the Connected cars are no longer a
need for IT reinvention in the premium car offering limited to
enterprise. The connected car Tesla, Mercedes Benz, BMW,
may be the exception today. By the and Audi. They are now a part
end of the decade it will be the rule. of mainstream brands such as
Ford, VW, Toyota, and Nissan.
Connected cars started out
to provide auto-generated Connected cars can deliver
emergency roadside calls for highly desired consumer benefits
help. (Remember OnStar?) of convenience, safety, energy
efficiency, entertainment, and
Then came Internet radio and
information.
streaming music via connected
smart phones and connectivity For the auto OEM, they are
adaptor kits. driving the exploration of new
services and revenue models, the
formation of innovation units and
strategic partnerships, and greater
technology complexity needing to
be addressed by the IT practice.
Currently (2015) connected cars are 10% of new cars,
rising to 90% by the end of the decade (2020).

52 NTTI3.COM
It’s All About the Data
(and Networks)
Data is the basis for all connected This kind of built-in and networked
car services, whether it is broadcast data power is beginning to drive not
to the vehicle or collected from the only truly revolutionary consumer
various built-in sensors or devices services, but also the need for
in the car and even its surrounding the enterprise to re-engineer its IT
environment. systems, teams, and partnerships
around responsiveness.
With the connected car, data
is both received and transmitted, Concerns about data use and
as well as collected and stored privacy are also beginning to be
locally. raised and will be a critical part
of the evolution of the connected
• Receive information:
car. Manufacturers will be under
Streaming media services,
increasing pressure to make
directions and road conditions,
money from data and will hence
remote service, predictive
be motivated to own it. Consumers
diagnostics, and software
will be rightly concerned about
updates.
what auto companies are learning
• Transmit information: and sharing about them as they
Location based information, drive, whether it is with insurance
requests via the Internet, and companies or government agencies.
booking appointments.

• Collect and store information:


Record trips, driving behavior,
car status.

53 NTTI3.COM
The Strategic Importance of the
Connected Car
The evolution of the connected
car from its current base state
is strategically important for
established auto OEMs. Already
several brands are working to
evolve their century old brands
from “car manufacturer” to “mobility
provider.” No one wants to loose
access to an important part of
the customer value chain, and be
relegated to the role of a commodity
“data pipeline” with Apple and
Google moving in as expert service
and user experience providers.

If the connected car continues to


evolve its capabilities and become
omnipresent in the next 10 years,
the auto industry needs to prepare
now to address some significant
parts of the customer value chain.

• Service design, distribution,


revenue channels, partnerships

• Support and interconnection


between multiple forms of
connectivity

• New ways of looking at


car usage and ownership

54 NTTI3.COM
THE BIRTH OF MOBILITY
SERVICES

Silicon Valley Upstarts and Auto


Leader Initiatives
In the US, the number of “zerocar have responded by establishing
families” has been growing since startups, divisions, partnerships and
2007, and now accounts for nearly investments to address the needs
10% of households. of this rapidly growing customer
segment. Highly successful startups
This has resulted in the emergence
such as Uber and Lyft have used
of a new class of transportation
technology to create a new market
services that is being called
and have been rewarded with multi-
“Mobility Services”. These services
MARKET CAP # COUNTRIES # CITIES
# VEHICLES / billion dollar valuations.
DRIVERS offer on–demand, utility-driven
choices in transportation that are Leaders in the automotive industry
tailored to meet specific customer such as BMW, Daimler, and Ford
UBER $42 B 58 300 162,000 needs. have also ventured into the mobility
“active drivers”
services marketplace with services
A number of economic and social
such as BMW Drivenow and Ford
$500 M factors have contributed to the
ZIP CAR 7 100 +
10,000+ Getaround.
(when sold to
Avis in 2013)
vehicles rapid growth of mobility services,
including the 2007-2009 recession, With its open platform, Moovel,
increasing urbanization, and the Daimler is establishing a leadership
BMW 4
2400 influence of Millennials and their position by combining different
$81 B (US, Germany, 8
DRIVENOW vehicles
Austria, UK)
digitally-driven social preferences. mobility options from public
Technology plays a major role, by transportation over car, and bike-
FORD
1 700 with providing minimum efficient scale to sharing to taxi or even private
NA 6
GETAROUND (US only) 200,000 “users” those companies with flexible value transportation options from which
chains and agile technology. Silicon the customer can choose.
Valley and large auto manufacturers

55 NTTI3.COM
CHAPTER 5

Learning
from
today’s
cutting-
edge
leaders

TESLA

GOOGLE SELF-DRIVING
CAR PROJECT

BMW iSERIES AND


CONSUMER MOBILITY
INITIATIVES

56 NTTI3.COM
TESLA
Tesla Teaches Us That

• There is power in
niche vs. mass

• The connected
This Is Not Your Father’s The Challenger Brand Finds That car evolves to an
Automobile Company Niche versus Mass is an Advantage “app on wheels”

Tesla has challenged the market Tesla has found that niche can • Customers should be
dynamics and practices of the trump mass when moving into part of movements,
established auto industry, leading an established product category not transactions
the shift from analog to digital by with large dominant players. By
• Bespoke products
creating a car defined by software focusing on a digitally-savvy
can be created by
and the user-experience. Starting customer set with desires for a
mass manufacturing
with the goal of developing a great high design, high tech, all electric
product—a sexy high-performance vehicle, the company crafted a • Open IP platforms
electric car—the company has product offering and end-to-end can stir innovation
relentlessly focused on reinventing value chain unencumbered by past
• The network
every aspect of the value chain practices. Larger players were not
effect can meet a
(sales, manufacturing, mechanics, immediately incentivized to move
commitment
service, and business model) with into the space of this challenger
to social good
the customer always in mind. This brand as it represented such a small
is a company that does not see any percentage of their current sales,
element of the industry as sacred; and appeared to many almost as
all are subject to harnessing the a Silicon Valley novelty. The billions
disruptive forces of digital business of dollars of assets in infrastructure,
to its advantage. Tesla has also manufacturing and supply chain
been successful not only in relying that historically make the leaders
on its own intellect and creativity, successful now function as an
but has successfully engaged both anchor to the past, while serving
generous government incentives as an advantage to the new entrant
and the exceptional enthusiasm of who is building from a clean slate.
its customers.

57 NTTI3.COM
The Next Evolution of the Connected
Car Is Really an “App on Wheels”

For Tesla, the “connected car” entertainment, driving directions, to predict issues and software
and how it relates to their customer and calls for emergency services. downloads to address problems
has been at the center of their Because the company owns the or even provide new features –
design, business, and manufacturing car operating system and driver has provided unprecedented
“If something is
decisions. Consumer-focused interface, and sees the car as a consumer convenience while important enough,
(versus dealer-focused) software generator and receiver of data, minimizing vehicle obsolescence. even if the odds
is at the core of the “car as app there are real-time insights into both This kind of remote software
model.” Long-established OEMs car functionality and the customers’ download capability might be are against you,
will have the challenges of driving experience. Services the way that an autonomous- you should still do it.”
addressing the issues of “software have been crafted to address both driving feature is eventually
as add-on” to vehicles evolving of these. provided for purchase, as well – Elon Musk,
from a mechanical past. as opportunities for drivers to CEO of Tesla
While the competition might have
“rent or test drive” new high
Data connectivity and software over the air map upgrades, there
performing driving modes for
architecture are as central to Tesla is still the need to go to the dealer
special trips.
as is the physical design of their to plug-in onboard computers
vehicles. Its concept of connectivity to access diagnostic data. With
services was never limited to Tesla, the use of the network

58 NTTI3.COM
Make the Customer Part of a Bespoke Product Can Be Created
Movement, Not a Transaction By Automated Mass Manufacturing
Tesla understands that its core Tesla vehicles are built-to-order
customers are hungry for more bespoke products, and yet
than a unique driving experience. they are produced in a highly
Tesla drivers want to be co-creators automated robotic manufacturing
of their vehicle, and have purchase environment. The company has
and service experiences that built its own IT solutions to drive
eliminate complexity. The company’s both automated production volumes
direct to consumer model means and close linkages with its ERP
that “dealerships” are actually and e-commerce platforms, both
playful and informative showrooms of which its IT team built within 4
where the focus is on engagement months.
and learning rather than backroom
With more limited production
sales negotiation. Touch screens
runs than what established car
and kiosks in the physical world
manufacturers would need to reach
serve as compliments to online
to meet their ROIs, Tesla focuses on
user forums and community groups
optimizing each stage of its vertically
that make the customer part of a
integrated value chain as opposed
movement, not part of a transaction.
to optimizing production volume.
Co-creation of a Tesla car extends
Currently, the most important
beyond selecting the model and
elements in the value chain relate to
color to the owner being able to
consumer confidence about “driving
customize their dashboard interface
distance,” so battery production and
after purchase.
accessible charging networks are
a priority over production volume.

59 NTTI3.COM
Markets that initially looked
separate, can after some time,
appear as a coherent business
Open IP Platforms Can Stir opportunity. At one time MP3
New Innovation players and mobile phones
Partnerships play a key role in homeowners, businesses, and utility were seen as separate market
Tesla’s game plan, and initially companies. Its existing position of opportunities. That is no longer
focused on serving the needs of the excellent in batteries, and its sister the case.
connected car with telco operators company Solar City’s focus on home
and content providers. With the solar energy, may provide a jump-
company’s announcement to open start to success in new spaces with
up its patents, the opportunity to new revenue sources.
create an even more robust set
of business partnerships, markets, The Network Effect Meets a
and co-created products is Commitment to Social Good
now on the table. While this may In the electric vehicle market,
be new in the auto industry, this whoever creates the best charging
kind of co-innovation model network experience married with the
already exists in other industries. right car and business model, will
GE and its relationship with startup shape the future of mobility. Tesla’s
Quirky in the connected product Supercharger network may well
space is an important example of be its version of iTunes or Google
co-creation from non-traditional Play, serving as the ecosystem that
sources with the involvement of a extends the use and value of the
Fortune 500 company. product for the consumer. And it
is not a bad thing either that the
By securing the opportunity to have
network serves as a flagship symbol
others in the industry building off its
for the company’s commitment to
specs, Tesla gains a new revenue
social good, which has become an
source to sell batteries, super
important buying criteria not only
charging stations, and other services
for Millennials, but for boomers and
not only in the auto industry but to
Gen X alike.

60 NTTI3.COM
GOOGLE SELF-DRIVING Google’s vehicles have driven
CAR PROJECT over a million autonomous
miles to date. That’s equal
to 75 years of driving for the
typical American adult.
Exploring What It Means to Have
an Autonomous Vehicle
Google’s self-driving vehicles have
been on the road for years, starting
with modified Lexus and Prius cars.
Now the technology that powered
those models is in Google’s first
purpose-built custom cars that hit
the road in July 2015.

Why would one of the biggest


technology companies in the
world - known for search, Internet
advertising, and a smart phone
OS - get into the car business?
If you think about the company’s
extensive experience with making
sense of vast amounts of real-time
data, along with its penchant for
putting some stakes in the ground
with socially relevant moonshot
initiatives – then it makes a lot of
sense.

61 NTTI3.COM
What would be possible These are very different questions Google’s Self-Driving Car
than those about sexier design, Teaches Us That
if a vehicle could be built better mileage, or more premium
• The ability to capture and
that could shoulder the options. And with different
translate data may be the
questions, will come different
entire burden of driving? most important driver of
results.
mobility in the future
Could a vehicle that
There are some important premises
takes anyone from point about mobility (as opposed to
• For an important group of
customers, mobility is about
A to point B at the push just cars) that are the foundation for
utility over design
Google’s exploration.
of a button, transform
• Car ownership may no
• S
 afety:
mobility for everyone? longer be required to get on-
What if you could reduce the
demand mobility for anyone
94 percent of accidents that are
caused by human error? • Rapid experimentation and
prototyping within a niche of
• Human productivity and creativity:
unaddressed customer need
What if you could reclaim the
may change the trajectory of
billions of hours of human
an industry more quickly than
potential wasted in traffic?
ever before
• Accessibility:
What if everyone could be
mobile, with everyday destinations
and new opportunities within
reach of those who might
otherwise be excluded by
economics or disabilities?

62 NTTI3.COM
In the World of Technology,
Form Follows Function
Why design a self-driving vehicle the creature comforts and luxury “We’ve been bolting
from the ground up? If the concept finishes are absent, the functional
things onto cars for a
of safety is the starting point of needs of passengers (two seats),
the investigation, then re-imaging safety (seatbelts), urban cargo long time and started
what a vehicle should look like (space for passengers’ belongings), to realize that that’s
in relationship to how it needs to and user interface (start-stop
perform when it’s built for self- button and a screen that shows
very limiting when you
driving – is essential. The result is the route)—are what’s included are working within the
a rounded-shape prototype vehicle beyond the extensive built-in
constraint of an existing
with an unobstructed 360 field of network of technology.
view for sensors that can capture vehicle. We wanted to
While this is a very Google
visual data from two football fields
approach to consumer-product rethink a vehicle from
away. That’s essentially the distance
required to safely stop an average
experimentation, it may not be a fresh sheet of paper,
that far off from what the new
car going 60 mph.
mobility customers, particularly
and what that vehicle
When Experimenting, Learning is those in urban environments, are needs to look like
More Important than Luxury demanding. Basic utility is gaining when it is custom built
priority over the value of envy-
Google’s design aesthetic has
inducing design. Given that trend, for self driving.”
always been on the side of
Google may know more about
minimalism. So it is not unexpected – Jaime Waydo,
the new mobility customer than
that its approach to prototyping Systems Engineer,
the auto industry may have given Google Self-Driving Cars
and experimenting with autonomous
them credit.
mobility is about designing for
learning and not luxury. While

63 NTTI3.COM
“The opportunity for
people to move around
and not worry about it.
It’s going to be incredibly
empowering and
Technology Must be Married
powerful to people.” with Purpose

– Chris Urmson, Director, Like Tesla with its software for non-owners, or even insurance
Google Self-Driving Cars approach to the car, everything in premiums paid by car manufacturers
the Google project is custom- and not riders.
made. Nothing is borrowed from
other uses or purposes, which Security and Privacy -
can result in limitations. Since it’s the Two-Headed Monster
the software that makes the car With data and safety at the core
self-driving, and it must therefore of the functionality of Google’s self-
function flawlessly with handshakes driving car project, cyber-security
between sensor and software, is a more critical issue than in
Google created their own computer. your “normal” connected car with
Designed to withstand the specific functionality focused on navigation
vibrations and temperatures and entertainment. Having your
of the driving environment, it’s streaming media interrupted is a
fundamentally very different very different concern than hackers
from someone’s office desktop. taking control of your vehicle.
And with greater concerns around
With this kind of technology in
data and security often comes
place – other form-function issues
increased discussion around
are resolved such as no need
privacy. If you don’t own the car
for a steering wheel or the kind of
you are driving in, who has access
brake pads that a conventional
to the information about your various
vehicle requires. And then extend
destinations? Who will own the
that to what kind of insurance
data from the many thousands of
models this needs – such as lower
riders associated with a single
rates and pay as you go insurance
on-demand autonomous vehicle?
64 NTTI3.COM
What if the Future is Only 3-5
Years Away?
If self-driving cars quickly become
mainstream, what might this mean
not only for auto manufacturers,
but also supply chain partners and
service providers?

• What happens to the suppliers


of safety equipment
such as airbags if accidents
become mitigated by sensors
and software?

• What happens to the revenues


from parking garages and meters
when you never need to park?

• What happens to the number


of cars that need to be
manufactured each year if car
utilization rises from its current
5-10% up to 75%? And if
fewer people decide to own
cars versus calling for an always
available self-driving vehicle?

• How and who gets


charged for insurance and
do “premiums” fall?

• What happens to the energy


industry if most self-driving
cars are electric?

65 NTTI3.COM
BMW iSERIES AND
CONSUMER MOBILITY
INITIATIVES BMW’s Initiatives Are Exploring Questions:

• Is the traditional performance car customer of the past


the same as the mobility customer of the future?
Exploring Next Generation Mobility
within an Established Industry • Can a hybrid value chain work with startup prototyping
Leader and traditionally-oriented manufacturing and distribution?
As an automobile brand with a • Are there separate roles for software to play in providing
100 year history, BMW carries Start-up Prototyping Meets
infotainment to consumers and maintenance data to
with it all of the advantages and Established Manufacturing and
dealers - or - should there be a unified software model
Distribution Models
disadvantages of an industry leader designed to provide transparency and extensibility of the
during a time of growing digital BMW has placed its digital bets on car functionality directly to the consumer?
disruption. Billions of dollars of two major initiatives: the i-Series of
manufacturing assets, deep supply cars and mobility initiatives focused • Can a design and manufacturing company transform into
chain relationships, and industry- on the delivery of services outside a business that balances product ownership with on-
specific talent may have given it the realm of car ownership. The demand mobility service “rental?”
the ultimate edge at one time. Can company established a separate
• What is the best way to respond to government
they be rethought and restructured business unit and hired talent from
mandated directives around CO2 emissions in concert
to the company’s advantage outside the industry. Acting like
with the sustainability demands of consumers?
today and in the future? Or will the a startup through the exploration
burden of past excellence place an stage, the company then brings
irreparable drag on the company’s products and services in-house
need for digital transformation? for go-to-market with its established
manufacturing and distribution
channels. Will this hybrid value
chain work and provide a product
with appeal at all touch points to
the emerging mobility customer?

66 NTTI3.COM
Project i: BMWi8 and BMWi3
In 2011, BMW unveiled the first
concept cars from its BMWi BMW i8 –
sub-brand - the small i3 urban Materials and Vertical Integration
electric car and the i8, a high- In order to meet its goal of fuel
performance plug-in hybrid luxury efficiency without giving up
sports vehicle. With both models, horsepower, the BMWi8 uses a
the company chose a business carbon fiber composite. This
strategy to build around the choice has led to other changes
traditional BMW values of “sheer in the value chain including vertical
driving pleasure” matched with integration via an investment in
its new agenda of “efficient batteries and in FGL Carbon (for
dynamics” focused on fuel-engine carbon fiber pre-press to create
efficiency. These two strategies parts that can be taken directly
have driven the company’s decisions to the factory for assembly).
around traditional factors of Manufacturing techniques have
design and performance, materials also been modified as a result
and supply chain, the extent of the new material. The production
and functionality of software, and site for the i8 in Leipzig Germany
pre/post customer experience. is part test laboratory, part robotic
assembly. The challenge and
learning is around the difficulty in
integrating carbon fiber into the
production process at speed and
volume, since it must be baked
or glued versus bolted or welded.
This requires human labor.

67 NTTI3.COM
BMW’s View of the Connected Car
Both the i3 and i8 reflect the cycle and a more integrated
company’s current viewpoint on digital mobility experience into
the role of software, driver and the company – be it experiences
the connected car. Consumer in the car, on the Web, or with
accessible services focus on mobile apps.
infotainment and simple functions
BMW mobility experiences range
such as remote unlocking or
from the owned car and beyond
controlling the climate of the car.
to ride sharing, parking services,
Software that accesses vehicle
bikes, and buses. Car specific
diagnostics is dealer-focused. There
services include:
are no remote software or feature
updates as in the case of Tesla. • DriveNow – locate, reserve and
access a vehicle.
BMW Mobility
• ParkNow – locate and paying for
Separate from vehicle projects,
parking spaces
BMW digital services group has
been experimenting with alternative • ChargeNow – locate and using
mobility service offerings for several public charging stations in cities
years. This has been with a still for the i3.
historic brand-aligned approach
of “premium car sharing.” With
a team from industries outside the
world of autos – Internet, mobile,
communication and IT - they are
looking to inject a shorter innovation

68 NTTI3.COM
CHAPTER 6

Auto 3.0 :
building the
new value
chain of
customer-
centered
innovation

RETHINK VALUE

REIMAGINE THE
CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE

RECONSIDER CULTURE

REORIENT PROCESSES
AND OPERATIONS

RE-ENGINEER IT

69 NTTI3.COM
As we move into the next stage • How do we build a more
of evolution of the auto industry – customer-centric approach
a time that is expected to be to cars and mobility that
unlike any that has preceded it – is reflected throughout the
there are important questions entire value chain?
that the established industry
• H
 ow do we begin to derive
leaders need to be considering.
value from the growing
For individuals and companies Sharing Economy, rather
to begin to explore their own than be disrupted and
strategies and answers to these made irrelevant by it within
questions, we suggest a model the next decade?
for looking at the digitally driven
• H
 ow do we look ahead
forces reshaping the auto industry.
and see what non-traditional
companies may become
disrupters in the world
of autos, as well as how we
might be disrupters in
other adjacent industries?

RETHINK REIMAGINE RECONSIDER REORIENT RE-ENGINEER IT


VALUE CUSTOMER CULTURE PROCESSES
EXPERIENCE AND
OPERATIONS
70 NTTI3.COM
RETHINK VALUE

The Innovation Spectrum


With the exception of a few recent economic and social leaders will Full-Spectrum Innovation and the
newcomers and skunk works teams be organizations that are effective Auto Industry
in established companies, the at tapping the entire spectrum Full-Spectrum Innovation is an
traditional concept of innovation in of innovation. They will be those important concept in framing new
the auto industry has historically that are able to leverage their own value propositions for the auto
been relatively narrow in its view ‘native genius’ while simultaneously industry. At its core is the idea
of the world. If the industry is to collaborating with other firms, of creating value in every possible
evolve into a truly digital business, leveraging major cultural trends place, at any defining moment,
there must be a pairing of a new and entering into more value-driven and during all critical touch
view of innovation and the delivery relationships with their customers. points—from culture and society
of value. This pairing must generate to government to partners to end
discussion and progress that Understanding Value and Innovation
users. By rethinking what value
goes beyond the boundaries of the If we are to rethink value as a means should mean today and in the future,
industry’s current base product, the to drive innovation, then this new auto manufacturers can let go of
car – and into examining the values viewpoint must be one focused on long held assumptions, practices,
that can jumpstart the bigger and a fully reciprocal exchange of and metrics - and create the
more dynamic concept of mobility. value with customers and partners. next generation digital systems
Value-driven relationships must and experiences that will not
Digital Business Drives Innovation break out of the boundaries of more only lead to new products, but
As technology and cultural changes traditional models of extraction with jump start a new mobility industry.
continue to shift the way business is the ‘consumer.’
done on a global scale, companies What will it mean for the
A digital auto industry will flourish
can no longer thrive simply by auto industry to rethink, create,
only when the nature of competition
being the best at delivering one and measure value with
has shifted from a focus on product
form of value. No one approach customers, partners, suppliers,
features to delivering individualized
to innovation is competitive for channels, influencers,
consumer experiences.
very long anymore. The new and government agencies?

71 NTTI3.COM
The Innovation Spectrum
- Framing new value propositions and digital experiences

When social and


economic forces shift Technology changes
and begin to change Digital business both large and small
the way we see and strategy moves the companies’ ability Understanding
relate to individuals focus from individual to quickly concept, customer value and
and the world around products to the prototype, pilot, engaging in customer-
us – the time is creation of platforms manufacture, and centric activities
ripe for innovation. and networks. launch products. defines innovation.

BUSINESS
GOVERNMENT MODELS, DISTRIBUTION PRODUCTS RELATIONSHIPS BRAND &
CULTURE MARKETS
& LEGAL PLATFORMS & & PROCESSES & OFFERINGS & COMMUNITY EXPERIENCE
LEADERSHIP

Without the right Markets ignored by Products can Brand and


legal frameworks, traditional companies morph and add experience
balancing the needs often become fertile additional innovation reflects
of the commons ground for disruptive functionality overtime - customers’
and the capacity for players. through software, values, desires,
innovation can come partnerships and world views.
to a standstill. or complimentary
services.

72 NTTI3.COM
The Innovation Spectrum in the Auto Industry

Dealerships redefined
or obsoleted

Software-defined car  ustomer kiosks vs.


C
as app dealership sales floor Owners’ clubs
Social media
OTA updates for Charger networks  rowdsourcing information
C
Globalization service and functions and design
Mobile apps
Millennials and
Rise of new and decline Socially-sourced maps
Digital Natives Social networks
of old revenue sources and traffic
Eco-consciousness Vertical integration
Size and speed  ew technology and
N
Sharing Economy as success metrics Smart Factories carrier partnerships

BUSINESS
GOVERNMENT MODELS, DISTRIBUTION PRODUCTS RELATIONSHIPS BRAND &
CULTURE MARKETS
& LEGAL PLATFORMS & & PROCESSES & OFFERINGS & COMMUNITY EXPERIENCE
LEADERSHIP

Public Policy Affluent eco-customers  odular software


M Accessible
and tech enthusiasts intensive products UI/UX
Privacy and Security
Utility driven Ease of configuration I ndividualized
Open Source
mobility customers experiences
Patents and IP Bespoke and built
vs. status drivers
to order Experiential
Dealership Regulations
Niche trumps mass marketing
Continuous updates
Insurance Regulations to enter new markets
High tech
Fuel-charger network
New forms of high touch
marketing and PR

73 NTTI3.COM
REIMAGINE THE
CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE

“The mission of design


thinking is to translate
The Need to Embrace Design observation into insights
Thinking and Human-Centered
Processes and insights into
Innovation is about quickly Teams need to embrace traits products and services
transforming ideas into action. of creativity, collaboration,
that will improve lives.”
Successful companies of all experimentation, left and
sizes embrace small experiments right brain thinking, and user- – Tim Brown, CEO, IDEO
and make “little bets” to create centeredness. This enables: in “Change By Design”
speed and reveal insights around
• Fostering empathy with
the innovation they need to
the people for whom you
stay ahead of disruptive trends
are designing
and have a chance to
lead change in their industry. • Generating volumes
of ideas
Design thinking is a human-
centered process that frames • Building multiple iterative
an approach to innovation seen prototypes
through the eyes of the people
• Sharing work in process
who need and will use it. This
with the people
is a multi-disciplinary team sport
you’re designing for
that brings together elements
of art, engineering, business, • Shepherding new
anthropology, and technology innovative solutions out
in the service of solving problems to test in the world
that matter.

74 NTTI3.COM
Moving from Questions
About the Function of a Car to
What Mobility Enables
Leaders in design thinking are as that from Google) may create
reframing questions and discarding a world in which at least some
the current architecture, structure vehicles no longer require
and design of cars. They are taking a steering wheel and the various
a more systems-wide view to dials and controls of today’s
how mobility might fit into human cars. The question about driver
lives in the future. Questions ergonomics might then be reframed
are then naturally reframed from: into one around the values of
multi-functional personal space in
“What can the car do?”
a mobile environment. Discussion
- to –
about streaming media services
“What does the car enable
may no longer be about a balance
me to do?”
of media access with driver
- to –
distraction, but be reframed into
“What does mobility enable
one about making the mobile
people to do?”
experience more like the in-home
New technology investigations experience.
can also drive new ways of framing
explorations about the nature of
the customer-driver experience and
cars. What if you believe that new
autonomous car technology (such
“The beauty of design is
being able to look at the
bigger picture.”
– Geoff Wardle,
director of advanced mobility
research at Art Center College
of Design in Los Angeles CA
75 NTTI3.COM
Human Relationships and Digital
Transformation

Digital business requires a and by whom—in order to create “Empathy is the mental habit
fundamentally different and a design that meets the demands
transparent relationship with of today’s customer.
that moves us beyond thinking
customers and partners. Old of people as laboratory rats or
At the core of understanding
ways of defining relationships as
the human-centric user experience standard deviations. If we are
“360 degree views” or “share of
is the concept of design to “borrow” the lives of other
wallet” need to be replaced with
thinking. Design thinking focuses
an emphasis on a model that helps
on concepts of empathy and people to inspire new ideas, we
customers get the value they desire
from their relationship with the
relevance—asking questions to need to begin by recognizing
reveal how the product or service
company. This relationship needs that their seemingly inexplicable
provides value to the customer.
to be built upon characteristics of
behaviors represent different
empathy, relevance, and respect. Respect for the Customer
strategies for coping with
Empathy and Relevance Digital businesses must know
their customers, understand their
the confusing, complex, and
Digital business’ relationship to the
customer experience represents a
preferences, and act on their contradictory world in which
behalf. The digital-savvy individual
shift from focusing on what’s best they live.
has very little time or patience
from an enterprise’s viewpoint to
for the exploitative tendencies – Tim Brown, CEO of IDEO
the end user’s perspective. Today’s
of traditional companies – intent in “Change By Design”
customers value personalization,
on extracting value from them.
customization, and even co-creation
Digital companies need to
of their experiences. Companies
acknowledge the importance
must start by deeply understanding
of earning customers’ trust
the context in which their product or
and the difficulty of regaining it.
service is used— why, where, how,

76 NTTI3.COM
RECONSIDER CULTURE

Nurturing Cultures of Innovation


and Sustainability
Culture change is one of the most Embracing a culture of innovation Sustainability Culture “We love big bets.
difficult things to effectively define and sustainability might entail • M
 oves the discussions Our company
and generate in an organization - broadening efforts from focusing from moral obligation
particularly in large, established on government mandated CO2 culture encourages
to opportunity
ones. Culture needs to be seen as emissions levels to rethinking experimentation and
a complement to the more formal, the manufacturing process, • Emphasizes execution
well-articulated rules of doing supply chain, and even recycling as much as ideals the free flow of ideas.”
business. Yet many of the rules of vehicles themselves.
• Integrates the discussion – Larry Page, CEO , Google
and guidelines of historic corporate
into the strategy and
success—including hierarchy, Innovation Culture
operations of the company
processes, and the elimination • Embraces design
of risk—often stifle culture change thinking and human- • Eliminates competing priorities
and the innovation that can centered design inside the company
accompany it.
• Measures what’s • Sees sustainable materials
Embracing the tenants of the meaningful and processes as part
cultures of innovation and of brand differentiation
sustainability are necessary if the • Looks outward,
not just inward • Empowers teams that
auto industry is to successfully
morph as new processes
transform and succeed in a • Fosters learning more and ideas unfold.
competitive digital marketplace. than knowing
A company must look at its values,
how it sees customers, and its • Understands the value
internal culture to determine what and parameters of risk
it can change. and failure

• Values the unstructured

77 NTTI3.COM
REORIENT PROCESSES
“Learning to see waste
AND OPERATIONS
and systematically
eliminate it has allowed
lean companies such
Creating Organizations that Facilitate as Toyota to dominate
Customer Value and Engagement
entire industries. Lean
The need to reorient processes and In the digitally-driven company,
operations is a natural outcome of where that which adds value to
thinking defines value as
the exercise of rethinking value to the customer experience reigns ‘providing benefit to the
map to customers’ needs, and then supreme, it would seem that auto
customer’; anything else
building an appropriate culture of companies need to begin to rethink
innovation around that. Historically, they way that they are organized, is waste.”
the organizational structure of the at least to the level that they
auto industry has been driven by present themselves to customers. - Eric Ries, author of “The Lean Startup”

a need for internal efficiencies, In thinking about processes and


resulting in vertically oriented the structures that follow them,
functional structures. Customers, auto companies would be wise to
however, usually need to interact begin with the question: “What is
and have visibility with a company relevant to the customer and
across vertical functions, given their how do they want to access it?”
desire to be able to access various
groups simultaneously across
the company. Customers want and
need to engage horizontally.

78 NTTI3.COM
RE-ENGINEER IT

The companies of Auto 3.0 will quickly and efficiently by adapting


thrive or stumble in a new dynamic products, services, and operations
global marketplace with rules to address emerging opportunities
of operation that are constantly and challenges. Companies with
being rewritten by changes in business agility have technology
the surrounding social, cultural, in their DNA and the organizational
economic, political, and technical capability to use it as a source
landscapes. Digital technology of competitive advantage - to
and the information infrastructure experimenting with options, proto-
that supports it are driving the typing potential solutions, gaining
sea change in values, customer insights from internal and external
experiences, operations, and data, and quickly executing to drive
technology. Historic competitive meaningful business outcomes.
advantage, market valuations and
The successors in this new
reputations that took decades to
digital era of the automotive
create are susceptible to being
industry will be the companies
displaced at any moment of time
with both the technology and
– from forces inside or outside the
cultural DNA that can imagine
industry.
and implement the flexible IT
The key to success for businesses systems and teams the world of
in this exciting and sometimes business agility now demands.
chaotic marketplace is Business
Agility. Business Agility is the ability
to sense changes and respond

79 NTTI3.COM
Historic Barriers to IT
Evolution in the Auto Industry

Some of their most innovative As established auto companies IT environment where Agile IT • Perceived requirement
and formidable future competitors begin to evolve into the successful coexists with the well-established that all information
of the leading auto OEMs “were digital organizations of the information systems of record. services be on premise
born digital” – Tesla and Google future, they need to begin with IT can no longer be limited to a
• Lack of acceptance
for example. Unsaddled by legacy the realization that the road to ‘come and fix it’ utility within a
and trust in
systems and practices, they have becoming a digital business goes business. Auto companies must
cloud environments
a significant structural advantage through their IT functions. The shift their focus from IT as an
that allows them to rapidly enter challenge that many of them face isolated department-centric utility • Focus on technology
markets and scale by leveraging is that they are saddled with IT to IT as a strategic capability for internal purposes
new information technology infra- that has organizational structures, deployed across the company. and not in collaboration
structure and processes. These management models, operational Creating this kind of environment with suppliers, strategic
structural advantages give them processes, workforces, and systems will, by definition, require a partners, and customers
incredible business agility that that were built to solve the “turn of flexible, extensible and reliable
they can effectively use to out- the century” problems of the past. bridge between systems of Agile
maneuver significantly larger and and traditional IT.
The new auto company IT
more established competitors.
environment must be a hybrid

The new equation for IT success in the evolving digital auto company:

AGILE IT + PLATFORM THINKING

80 NTTI3.COM
The old industrial IT model focused Agile IT focuses on how to
ruthlessly on standardization, implement new technology and
implementing command and control processes in a faster and less
based management structures, and capital-intensive manner. It
centralized teams designed to drive provides the ability to achieve The digital auto company that demands business
economies of scale and optimize minimum efficient scale in any agility requires an approach to IT that fosters
unit costs. While providing success process without requiring the experimentation and innovation at a rapid pace.
in addressing long-term projects volume, size, and scale that used Today’s IT organizations can adopt the new Agile IT
or repeatable, recurring problems, to be required to drive efficiency model in an incremental and iterative way.
this approach to IT has been in the old industrialized IT model.
accompanied by increased time to
market, reduced flexibility and stifled
innovation.
5 1. Adaptive enterprise
architecture
2. Digital portfolio
management

2
Agile IT is about building a new 1. Innovative 3. Innovation and
sustainable model for managing business customer centricity
system
the “Business of IT.” It is purpose- 4. Platform thinking
2. Sustainable
built to be adaptive and extensible workforce 5. Horizontal IT teams
to meet the evolving IT needs of
digital businesses. Using systems
Components Capabilities
1 3 8
1. Agile IT 1. Understand the
thinking, it addresses the skills, business 1. Real lean
process, technology, systems, and 2. Manage IT as
2. Design thinking
a business
organizational dynamics that are Goal 3. Be the change agent 3. Discovery-driven planning
the underpinning of today’s digital
businesses. Leadership 4. Visual management
5. Servant leadership
Behaviors 6. 10-20-70 Learning model
7. Component design and APIs
8. Crowdsourcing

81 NTTI3.COM
Plays
Platform Thinking

In order to build the Agile IT


systems required by the emerging
digital generation automobile
company, robust and well-designed Around the approach to SAAS
technological and strategic Platform Thinking, the
platforms must be put into place, most important concerns for
SERVICE
often in parts of the company IT leaders will be to: PROVIDERS
outside of the traditional IT
• Create scalable, secure, and
domain. Platform Thinking focuses
extensible systems
on creating more throughput
and output for IT without resorting • Construct a highly cohesive
to traditional approaches to set of services
achieving scale.
• Build with an ecosystem of MULTI-SIDED
partners PLATFORMS

• Loosely couple internal IT


systems with partner systems

• Consume IT as a service

• Take advantage of open APIs

• Provide value to all participants


PARTNER
a cross the company
ECOSYSTEM

ENTERPRISE
CUSTOMERS

82 NTTI3.COM
APPENDIX
ABOUT NTT INNOVATION
INSTITUTE, INC.

ABOUT THE AUTHORS

COLLABORATOR AND
CONTRIBUTOR BIOS

OTHER BOOKS FROM


NTT INNOVATION
INSTITUTE, INC.

83 NTTI3.COM
ABOUT NTT INNOVATION
INSTITUTE, INC.

NTT Innovation Institute, Inc. is NTT i3’s Core Platforms NTT i3 offers three platforms to
the Silicon Valley-based, open for Agile IT help IT departments tackle these
innovation/applied research and In order to build the agile and challenges:
development center of NTT Group. hybrid IT systems required by  
Cloud Services Orchestration
NTT i3 builds platforms that are the emerging digital generation
Platform
transforming today’s enterprises of automobile companies, robust
that allows IT departments to
into the digital businesses of the and well-designed technological
understand their application
future. Our platforms help clients and strategic platforms must
portfolios, migrate the most suited
engage with customers and markets be put into place, often inareas
applications to the cloud and
in exciting new ways by pushing outside of the traditional IT domain.
provide a seamless way to manage
the boundaries of cloud computing, Legacy systems must be modified
this new hybrid environment.
information security, machine and integrated in a way that
learning, and the Social Network acknowledges complex privacy, Global Threat Intelligence Platform
of Things. NTT i3 builds on the vast speed, and reliability needs that that brings real-time data-driven
intellectual capital base of NTT were inconceivable at the time insights into the identification and
Group, which invests more than of their original design. And all understanding of cyber-security
$2.2 billion a year in R&D, with an of these IT systems need to be threats and needs.
extensive network of technology integrated and orchestrated in a
An Elastic Services Edge Platform
partners, engineers, and scientists. way that makes the management
that leverages network function
of a dynamic hybrid information
virtualization (NFV) to push virtual
environment possible.
network functions (VNF) to the edge
of the enterprise’s network, bringing
agility, security, and flexibility into
the infrastructure.

84 NTTI3.COM
About the Authors

Srini Koushik
Srini Koushik served as the President and CEO of
NTT Innovation Institute Inc., the Silicon Valley-based Srini has a passion for lifelong learning and holds a bachelor’s
degree in physics from the University of Madras, a master’s degree
R&D arm of the NTT Group, a global leader in computer science from the University of Bombay, a master’s
in information and communications technology. degree in business administration from Ohio State University,
and executive education on Systems Thinking, Design Thinking,
With thirty years of experience as a programmer, architect, CTO, Clean Energy and Innovation from the MIT Sloan School of
CDO, and CIO for Fortune 100 Companies including IBM, HP, and Management and Duke University.
Nationwide, Srini has a track record of unpacking complex problems,
and hacking the technology and culture of global enterprises to
deliver extraordinary results.

He is an Open Group Distinguished Certified Architect and has


published several articles, including co-authoring a best-selling book,
Patterns for eBusiness in 2001.

Srini was elected to the IBM Academy of Technology, and was named
an IBM Distinguished Engineer in 1996. He was named an Elite8 CIO
by Insurance and Technology, a Top 25 CTO by Infoworld, a Top 10
All-Star in the financial services industry by TechDecisions, and a 2014
Computerworld Premier 100 Technology Leader.

85 NTTI3.COM
About the Authors

Dr. Rainer Mehl


Rainer is Head of Global Automotive Business
and EMEA Head of Manufacturing Consulting
for NTT DATA. He is responsible for market
positioning, strategic direction setting, sales, and
on/offshore delivery.
Rainer has over twenty years of experience in the consulting and IT
services industry. He started his career 1995 with Price Waterhouse and
then PwC, where he became a partner in 2000. After IBM acquired PwC
in 2002, he continued as Partner Vice President. Rainer leads consulting
projects as well as large IT programs for automotive clients, focusing on
customer experience processes and system integration. Since 2010, Rainer
leads the Manufacturing and Automotive Industry group at NTT DATA.

Rainer studied Economics and Political Science at the University of


Hamburg. He has a Ph.D. from the Universities of Hamburg and Torino. His
thesis focused on organizational development in the automotive industry.

86 NTTI3.COM
COLLABORATOR AND
CONTRIBUTOR BIOS

Jens Krueger

Competence Unit Manager, Innovation and Product Lifecycle Management,


NTT DATA

Jens is an executive consultant at NTT DATA Germany. After studying


computer science and business administration, he worked for 8 years in
the engineering IT department of an international Tier 1 automotive supplier,
playing a major role as the project manager for the global PLM project.
Since 1998, he has worked for NTT DATA in Munich in the competence
center of Innovation & Product Lifecycle Management. He manages the
PLM Platforms, Strategy & Architecture” Team and works with clients from
the automotive and aerospace industries.

87 NTTI3.COM
Monika Sadowska

Management Consultant at NTT DATA

Monika is a Management Consultant at NTT DATA Germany. She


specializes in consulting services such as strategy development, change
management, business process improvement, training, and coaching as
well as international rollout management for automotive and manufacturing
industry. She is part of the global automotive initiative at NTT DATA,
supporting operationalization of global strategy, sales and marketing
activities as well as process adaptations. Her focus is on developing
collaborative processes, and fostering knowledge sharing, dialogue,
and innovation. Monika has a master’s degree in Business Administration
with major in European Business Consulting from Munich University of
Applied Sciences.

88 NTTI3.COM
Adam Stephenson

Senior Director, Customer Experience Center

Adam leads customer experience and business development programs for


NTT Group at the Customer Experience Center in Silicon Valley. He works
to strengthen executive relationships with key business and corporate
decision makers by connecting client business objectives with current and
emerging technologies and services. He has over 20 years of experience
in technology and business development, and is an expert in software and
services. He is a frequent speaker, evangelist, and ambassador for the NTT
Group and NTT Innovation Institute brands within the United States, with
corporate groups as well as technology innovation and social responsibility
forums. Adam has bachelor degrees in Technical Writing and Computer
Science from Oregon State University.

89 NTTI3.COM
ADDITIONAL CONTRIBUTORS - NTT DATA GERMANY

Siegfried Adam
Senior Managing Consultant Connected Business Solutions

Christoph Aretz
Senior Managing Consultant Marketing and Sales

Lutz Kauertz
Vice President Discrete Manufacturing, Head of Metals, Mining and Engineering

Markus Klamet
Senior Managing Consultant, After Sales Services

Christof Kleinhenz
Managing Consultant Connected Car

Sebastian Tschödrich
Managing Consultant Digitization

Claudia Wegerer
Managing Consultant After Sales Services

Michael Wegenaer-Schuchardt
Managing Consultant Analytics and Big Data

90 NTTI3.COM
OTHER BOOKS FROM
NTT INNOVATION
INSTITUTE INC.

The following books can be found at:


www.NTTI3.com/publications

Digital Business Transformation

The Social Network of Things

Agile IT: Today’s IT for Tomorrow’s Solutions

91 NTTI3.COM
PHOTO CREDITS

Page 6 IgorGolovniov / Shutterstock.com Page 40 Taina Sohlman / Shutterstock.com

Page 7 Stanislaw Tokarski / Shutterstock.com Page 41 Taina Sohlman / Shutterstock.com

Page 8 http://www.bmw.com Page 44 www.wired.com

Page 9 http://www.google.com/selfdrivingcar Page 50 Filip Krstic / Shutterstock.com

Page 10 http://www.bmw.com (press kit) Page 56 Hattanas Kumchai / Shutterstock.com

Page 14 StockStudio / Shutterstock.com Page 57 Taina Sohlman / Shutterstock.com

Page 16 barbsimages / Shutterstock.com Page 59 lumen-digital / Shutterstock.com

Page 18 Hadrian / Shutterstock.com Page 61 http://www.google.com/selfdrivingcar

Page 21 Neirfy / Shutterstock.com Page 63 http://www.google.com/selfdrivingcar

Page 22 Chromatic Studio / Shutterstock.com Page 64 http://www.google.com/selfdrivingcar

Page 24 pio3 / Shutterstock.com Page 66 http://www.bmw.com

Page 25 Lyft_PressKit_01.JPG Page 67 http://www.bmw.com

Page 29 Anna Hoychuk / Shutterstock.com Page 75 http://www.toyota.com

Page 34 Bibiphoto /Shutterstock.com

92 NTTI3.COM

You might also like