Professional Documents
Culture Documents
-81((',7,21
JESSICA ALBA
THE HONEST COMPANY’S
$200 MILLION FOUNDER
(SHE ALSO MOONLIGHTS
IN HOLLYWOOD)
NORTHWESTERN
MUTUALVOICE:
THE POWER OF
EMPOWERMENT
AMERICA’S RICHEST
6(/)Ŝ0$'(:20(1
FROM BEYONCÉ AND SHERYL SANDBERG TO TORY BURCH AND JUDGE JUDY
THE DEFINITIVE RANKING OF THE TOP 50 CEILING CRASHERS
PLUS: OUR 12TH ANNUAL POWER LIST
YOU MAY BE OUTNUMBERED,
The completely redesigned 2015 Edge is here and ready for almost anything, with available features like a front
180-degree camera, enhanced active park assist and Lane-Keeping System. It’s comforting to know you have a
few surprises of your own. Go to ford.com to find out more.
BUT NEVER OUTSMARTED.
ON THE COVER
66 | NATURAL WOMAN
Actress Jessica Alba has quickly built a
personal $200 million fortune, and she’s done
it the hard way, in a field that has nothing to
do with the entertainment business.
BY CLARE O’CONNOR
84 | AMERICA’S RICHEST
SELF-MADE WOMEN
FORBES has compiled its first ever list of the
top 50 self-made women in the U.S.
BrandVoice
WITH NORTHWESTERN MUTUAL
The Power of Enpowerment 70
COVER PHOTOGRAPH
BY JAMEL TOPPIN FOR FORBES
Northwestern Mutual sees the bigger picture when it comes to helping clients. We start
by asking the right questions and listening to your personal story. Then we customize
our investment and insurance solutions for you, addressing risk and managing wealth
to help you make sure that the future you imagine is the future you achieve.
You and Northwestern Mutual—stronger together.
Northwestern Mutual is the marketing name for The Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company (NM), Milwaukee, WI (life and disability insurance, annuities) and its subsidiaries.
Northwestern Mutual Investment Services, LLC (securities and investment advisory programs), subsidiary of NM, broker-dealer, registered investment adviser, member FINRA
(www.finra.org) and SIPC (www.sipc.org).
June 15, 2015
LEADERBOARD
16 | THE WORLD’S 100 MOST POWERFUL WOMEN
They’re the new A-list: the 100 women at the forefront of business,
tech, entertainment, finance, philanthropy, global leadership and more.
18 | RICHEST BY STATE: DELAWARE
Gore-Tex might be plenty lightweight, but the fortune of its inventor
is anything but. Plus: the billionaire king of the supplements.
20 | SOCCER’S MOST VALUABLE TEAMS
The 20 richest “footy” franchises are now worth an average $1.16 billion.
22 | BUSINESS LIBRARY: POPCORN PAPERBACKS
Transforming bestselling novels into billion-dollar
Hollywood tent poles.
24 | SEAL THE DEAL
Not every business occasion calls for a tie—but when one does, these
bulletproof silk beauties are a natural around your neck.
26 | CONVERSATION
Readers debate China’s influence atop our list of the biggest public
companies. Plus: startup secrets from Scribd CEO Trip Adler.
THOUGHT LEADERS
30 | INNOVATION RULES // RICH KARLGAARD
Society’s lottery winners.
TECHNOLOGY
44 | MERCHANTS OF PARALLEL WORLDS
Improbable invented a new way to simulate almost any complex
system in software. Warriors, gamers and economists are
extremely interested.
BY PARMY OLSON
ENTREPRENEURS
48 | IT’S PONDEMONIUM!
Greg Wittstock pretty much invented the backyard-pond industry, but
with family conflicts, soaring and then falling sales and a collapsed
roof, his life sounds like reality TV.
BY KARSTEN STRAUSS
48
STEP IT UP.
Get ready to ask yourself, “How early is too early to get to the airport?”
Getting into Delta Sky Club® is standard with every Delta One™ ticket,
with complimentary drinks and snacks, Wi-Fi, and more.
All Delta Sky Club rules apply and are available at delta.com/skyclub
June 15, 2015
INVESTING
54 | MALL VULTURES
Retail’s physical struggles mean big business for two
creative real estate fixers.
BY STEVE SCHAEFER
58 | INVESTMENT STRATEGIES
// WILLIAM BALDWIN
Alpha, beta, gotcha.
60 | THE PATIENT INVESTOR // JOHN W. ROGERS JR.
Hurry up and wait investing.
62 | FIXED-INCOME WATCH // RICHARD LEHMANN
The DEFCON approach to investing.
FEATURES
94 | PAINTING SILICON VALLEY RED
China’s three tech giants—Baidu, Alibaba, Tencent—are quietly
plowing billions into America’s hottest startups. Their goal:
slit each other’s throats back home. The result: astounding
valuations for app developers.
BY LIYAN CHEN
LIFE
102 | THE GREAT AMERICAN SUPERCAR
With a rich racing history and classic design, the Ford GT
has been steadily increasing in value—and a new model
is on track for 2017.
94 BY ALLEN ST. JOHN
102
Stay connected with Verizon’s new international voice, text and data
bundles, now starting at only $15 monthly access when added to a
domestic plan. Plus get unlimited access to select Wi-Fi hotspots
while traveling outside the U.S.
Our Surcharges (incl. Fed. Univ. Svc. of 17.4% of interstate & int’l telecom charges (varies quarterly), 18¢ Regulatory & 95¢ Administrative/line/mo. & others by area) are in addition
to monthly access & not taxes (details: 1.888.684.1888); gov’t taxes & our surcharges could add 6% – 44% to your bill. Activation/upgrade fee/line: $40. IMPORTANT CONSUMER
INFORMATION: Subject to Cust. Agmt, Calling Plan & credit approval. Up to $350 early termination fee/line. Offers & coverage, varying by svc; see vzw.com. © 2015 Verizon Wireless. I6303
FORBES
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Steve Forbes
IN BRIEF
CHIEF PRODUCT OFFICER
Lewis D’Vorkin
FORBES MAGAZINE
Finding Success
EDITOR
Randall Lane
EXECUTIVE EDITOR
The Hard Way
Michael Noer BY LEWIS D’VORKIN
ART & DESIGN DIRECTOR
Robert Mansfield
I’m off to Paris soon for a round of sales calls (it’s a tough job,
FORBES DIGITAL
but someone has to do it), and I expect lots of questions about
VP, INVESTING EDITOR
Matt Schifrin
Facebook’s newest product, Instant Articles. Media pros
MANAGING EDITORS gnashed their teeth for months awaiting its arrival. Finally,
Dan Bigman – Business, Bruce Upbin – Technology
a few high-profile publishers signed on, agreeing to post a
SENIOR VP, PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT AND VIDEO
Andrea Spiegel limited number of stories on the social network rather than
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, DIGITAL PROGRAMMING STRATEGY rely solely on outbound links to their sites. In my best French
Coates Bateman
accent, I’ll respond to the quizzical this way: Plus ça change.
ASSISTANT MANAGING EDITORS
Kerry A. Dolan, Luisa Kroll – Wealth In other words, the more things change the more they stay
Frederick E. Allen – LEADERSHIP the same.
Loren Feldman – ENTREPRENEURS
Why would I say that? Firsthand experience:
Tim W. Ferguson FORBES ASIA
Janet Novack WASHINGTON AOL: I joined the portal in 2000 and watched as publish-
Michael K. Ozanian SPORTSMONEY ers battled—and frequently paid—to be “anchor tenants” in
Mark Decker, John Dobosz, Deborah Markson-Katz DEPARTMENT HEADS
Avik Roy OPINIONS hopes of attracting digital “eyeballs.” Interests were never
Jessica Bohrer EDITORIAL COUNSEL aligned, so traffic proved fleeting.
BUSINESS
Mark Howard CHIEF REVENUE OFFICER Paywalls: Failing to monetize those eyeballs with premium
Tom Davis CHIEF MARKETING OFFICER ad inventory, the same publishers fantasized about get-
Charles Yardley PUBLISHER & MANAGING DIRECTOR FORBES EUROPE
ting passersby to sign up for digital subscriptions. Very few
Nina La France SENIOR VP, CONSUMER MARKETING & BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT
Fred Poust SENIOR VP, CONFERENCES & BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT pulled it off.
Michael Dugan CHIEF TECHNOLOGY OFFICER
Elaine Fry SENIOR VP, M&D, CONTINUUM
iPad: In Rupert Murdoch’s Fifth Avenue apartment for the
launch of The Daily (now defunct), I could see publishers
FORBES MEDIA
Michael S. Perlis PRESIDENT & CEO
dreaming that the iPad would spur circulation. The result:
Michael Federle CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER lots of downloads, limited usage.
Tom Callahan CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER
Terrence O’Connor CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER Mobile apps: With handheld devices surging, the news
Will Adamopoulos CEO/ASIA FORBES MEDIA media saw a distribution play. Never mind that the only
PRESIDENT & PUBLISHER FORBES ASIA
news apps that work offer one-stop utility (think weather
Rich Karlgaard PUBLISHER
Moira Forbes PRESIDENT, FORBESWOMAN and traffic) or community.
MariaRosa Cartolano GENERAL COUNSEL
Margy Loftus SENIOR VP, HUMAN RESOURCES Faced with disruption, publisher after publisher practiced
Mia Carbonell SENIOR VP, CORPORATE COMMUNICATIONS reinvention without reinvention, hoping the genius of others
FOUNDED IN 1917
would bail them out. That strategy hasn’t worked out so well.
B.C. Forbes, Editor-in-Chief (1917-54) FORBES looked inward, then set out to chart its own
Malcolm S. Forbes, Editor-in-Chief (1954-90)
James W. Michaels, Editor (1961-99) course—with a long way still to go. Sure, we’d be happy to put
William Baldwin, Editor (1999-2010)
up Instant Articles on Facebook. Who’s going to turn their
JUNE 15, 2015 — VOLUME 195 NUMBER 8 back on a billion people? But we’ve spent the last five years
doing the things that truly matter. We changed our content,
FORBES (ISSN 0015 6914) is published semi-monthly, except monthly in January, February, April, July, August and October, by Forbes
Media LLC, 499 Washington Blvd., Jersey City, NJ 07310. Periodicals postage paid at Jersey City, NJ 07302 and at additional mailing
offices. Canadian Agreement No. 40036469. Return undeliverable Canadian addresses to APC Postal Logistics, LLC, 140 E. Union Ave., labor and advertising models, creating some disruption of our
East Rutherford, NJ 07073. Canada GST# 12576 9513 RT. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Forbes Subscriber Service, P.O. Box
5471, Harlan, IA 51593-0971. own. We listened to the audience. It wanted authentic, pas-
CONTACT INFORMATION
For Subscriptions: visit www.forbesmagazine.com; write Forbes Subscriber Service, P.O. Box 5471, Harlan, IA 51593-0971; sionate storytelling. We listened to marketers—what they’d
or call 1-515-284-0693. Prices: U.S.A., one year $59.95. Canada, one year C$89.95 (includes GST). We may make a portion of
our mailing list available to reputable firms. If you prefer that we not include your name, please write Forbes Subscriber Service.
For Back Issues: visit www.forbesmagazine.com; e-mail getbackissues@forbes.com; or call 1-212-367-4141. pay and what they’d pay for. It required efficient content cre-
For Article Reprints or Permission to use Forbes content including text, photos, illustrations, logos, and video:
visit www.forbesreprints.com; call PARS International at 1-212-221-9595; e-mail http://www.forbes.com/reprints; or e-mail
permissions@forbes.com. Permission to copy or republish articles can also be obtained through the Copyright Clearance Center at
ation and new ad formats.
www.copyright.com. Use of Forbes content without the express permission of Forbes or the copyright owner is expressly prohibited.
PROMESSE
STEEL, 30 MM, QUARTZ
30 DIAMONDS
www.baume-et-mercier.com
FACT & COMMENT — STEVE FORBES
“With all thy getting, get understanding”
FREE TRADE
MEANS MORE JOBS
BY STEVE FORBES, EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
A CRITICAL RAP against the proposed bill of 1996 came out of the pioneering
Trans-Pacific Partnership is that it will policies of Wisconsin, which demon-
destroy jobs, which is the argument strated that there could be a work re-
labor unions always use to oppose free- quirement for benefits, thereby providing
trade agreements like this one. Nonsense. a safety net while not destroying the hab-
What destroys jobs is innovation and its necessary for leading a productive life.
productivity. When allowed to do so, Welfare rolls were slashed everywhere.
people always look to find new and bet- A variety of tax “experiments” are cur-
ter ways of doing things—or to come up rently under way that bode well for radical
with new things altogether. Who had federal tax reform after the 2016 elections.
heard of an iPad or the process we call Governor Sam Brownback of Kansas
streaming just a few years ago? In the was pilloried for enacting major tax re-
constant turbulence of free markets some jobs are elimi- ductions that supposedly blew gaping holes in the state’s
nated, but the overall number and quality of jobs improve. budget because rapid economic growth didn’t instantly
People today wax nostalgic over manufacturing, just materialize. Put aside the fact that some of his other tax
as they did over farming before that. In reality, both, proposals weren’t enacted and that he didn’t get all the
until recent decades, involved backbreaking manual tightening on overall spending he wanted. Democrats
labor. Remember the criticism that factory work was thought they’d knock him out in 2014. Instead, Brownback
soulless and repetitive? Factory assembly lines are won, and his tax cuts, which took effect little more than
largely a thing of the past in this country. Job destruc- two years ago (he whacked income tax rates and elimi-
tion? The U.S. railroad industry has shed a million nated those levies altogether for small businesses), are
jobs since the end of WWII, yet our standard of living starting to yield a bumper crop in prosperity. Private-sector
today is significantly better than it was then. job growth in Kansas is now outpacing that in most other
It’s human nature to look for and lash out at targets states. The state’s unemployment rate is among the na-
when our lives are disrupted by economic change. But tion’s lowest. Just as impressive is Kansas’ employment-to-
when barriers to progress aren’t put in the way, most population ratio, which is well above the national average.
people quickly land on their feet. Ohio’s chief executive and possible presidential can-
The problem today isn’t nefarious bankers or didate, John Kasich, is also hacking away at his state’s
currency-manipulating foreigners; it’s our own govern- personal income tax, with an eye to eliminating it alto-
ment, which has hobbled us with a horrific tax code, a gether, relying instead on broad-based consumption
destructive monetary policy and a tsunami of opaque taxes. (He’s already done away with Ohio’s death tax.)
rules regarding health care and everything else and Even blue states are getting the tax message. Look
prevents us from focusing our energies on productive at Maine, which a GOP presidential candidate hasn’t
activities that would benefit us all. carried since 1988. Governor Paul LePage is pushing
to eliminate the state’s income tax by 2020. Maine has
long been in the economic dumps, and LePage, who
Tax Rate Cuts Work—Always was a successful businessman before going into politics
One of the genius features of our federal system of govern- full-time, knows that this is chiefly due to the state’s
ment is that it allows states to be laboratories for policies, to hostile tax environment. Liberals and legacy media
see what works and what doesn’t. The great welfare reform outlets can’t stand LePage’s unabashed free-market
principles and his willingness to there’s precedent for for young people.
let reporters know what he thinks outstanding athletes Back in 1959 he
of them and their employers. Their receiving the award, started a scholarship
consternation was palpable when he including Ernie Banks, at Columbia Univer-
won a stunning reelection victory. Stan Musial and wom- sity. His namesake
Other Republican governors have en’s basketball head museum focuses on
been stalwart pro-growth tax reform- coach Pat Summitt. education and char-
ers, and the results have been impres- By the calculations acter development.
sive. Political leaders in both parties of Bill James, whose Of course, Berra
should read An Inquiry into the Nature novel and enlightening is most noted for his
and Causes of the Wealth of States by ways of measuring the paradoxical quotes
Arthur Laffer, Stephen Moore, Rex performance of base- and witticisms—now
A. Sinquefield and Travis H. Brown ball players and teams called Yogi-isms—
(Wiley, 2014). It gives conclusive, has revolutionized the which are legion.
empirical proof that over time states way the game is played In 1973 Berra was
with no income taxes perform better and how managements Yogi celebrates his 90th birthday. managing the New
than those with the heaviest burdens: put their teams togeth- York Mets. By the dog
better in economic growth, popula- er, Berra is the greatest catcher in base- days of summer the team found itself
tion growth, job growth, personal ball history. There’s no more demanding in last place in its division. Fans were
income growth and—liberals, please a position in America’s favorite pastime, furious, and sportswriters demanded
note—government revenue growth. physically or mentally (the catcher to know, what now? Berra famously
What the states are demonstrating signals the type of pitch he wants the replied, “It ain’t over ’til it’s over.” In-
is that simplification and major income hurler to throw, which takes on-target deed, the Mets miraculously got their
tax rate reductions generate prosperity. knowledge of both the batter and the act together and ended up winning the
pitcher). Even on a team noted for such National League championship, best-
legendary sluggers as Mickey Mantle, ing the formidable and much favored
Home Run For Berra for seven years led the Yankees Cincinnati Reds in the playoffs.
in runs batted in. He was the catcher in As a player Berra was noted for
America 1956, when Don Larsen threw the only successfully hitting bad pitches.
There’s an online petition to have perfect game in World Series history. When asked about that, he replied,
Yogi Berra receive America’s highest Several times Berra was the American “If I can hit it, it’s a good pitch.”
civilian award, the Presidential Medal League’s Most Valuable Player. It’s no Other sayings among his many:
of Freedom (petitions.whitehouse. surprise he’s a Hall of Fame member. “When you come to the fork in the
gov). It needs to garner 100,000 elec- Yogi Berra served his country in road, take it”; “Nobody eats there
tronic signatures by June 8 merely the Navy during WWII, participating anymore; it’s too crowded”; “It’s déjà
to get the attention of the White in the D-Day invasion. vu all over again”; “The future ain’t
House. A whole lot more than that Berra has long been an advocate what it used to be”; and “I didn’t re-
would be terrific. of diversity and tolerance in baseball ally say everything I said.”
Berra, who just turned 90, de- and elsewhere. He’s also a great sup- Yogi Berra was a big man in baseball
serves the medal for many reasons, and porter of educational opportunities and has been an even bigger one in life. F
Credit approval required. Offered by Capital One Bank (USA), N.A. ©2014 Capital One
LeaderBoard THE 100 MOST POWERFUL
June 15, 2015
WOMEN ON EARTH 16
MULTILEVEL MARKETING’S
MADE MAN 18
FROM BESTSELLER
TO BLOCKBUSTER 22
THE TOP-EARNING
SOCCER PLAYERS
CRISTIANO RONALDO $79 MIL
Real Madrid
LIONEL MESSI $70.5 MIL
Barcelona
ZLATAN IBRAHIMOVIC $41.8 MIL
Paris St.-Germain
GARETH BALE $34.9 MIL
Real Madrid
NEYMAR $31.7 MIL
Barcelona
RADAMEL FALCAO $31 MIL
Manchester United
WAYNE ROONEY $25.8 MIL
Manchester United
JAMES RODRIGUEZ $25.4 MIL
Real Madrid
SERGIO AGUERO $25.3 MIL
Manchester City
LUIS SUAREZ $19.9 MIL
Barcelona
AMOUNTS REPRESENT SALARY PLUS ENDORSEMENTS.
BILLIONAIRE 37 BUSINESS 15
Indra
Gina Nooyi
Rinehart CEO
Billionaire-activist PepsiCo
Australia U.S.
5 17 20
44 Mary
Laurene Barra Irene Marillyn
Powell Jobs CEO Rosenfeld Hewson
Billionaire- General Motors CEO CEO
philanthropist U.S. Mondelēz Lockheed Martin
U.S. U.S. U.S.
69 26 55 56 65 75
Zhang Ellen Beth Phebe Rosalind Diane von
Xin Kullman Comstock Novakovic Brewer Fürstenberg
Cofounder-CEO CEO CEO, Business CEO CEO Founder
SOHO China DuPont Innovations, GE General Dynamics Sam’s Club DVF
China U.S. U.S. U.S. U.S. U.S.
12 ENTERTAINMENT 70 76
Güler Carol
Oprah Sabanci Meyrowitz
Winfrey Chair CEO
Media mogul Sabanci Holding TJX Companies
U.S. Turkey U.S.
73 72 57 85 43
Tory Elizabeth Sofía Kiran Ho
Burch Holmes Vergara Mazumdar-Shaw Ching
Founder-CEO Founder-CEO Entertainer- Chair CEO
Tory Burch Theranos entrepreneur Biocon Temasek
U.S. U.S. U.S. India Singapore
79 88 21 94 53
Miuccia
87 Judy Beyoncé Beth Brooke- Mary
Folorunsho Knowles Callahan Erdoes
Prada Alakija Faulkner Marciniak
Musician- CEO, Asset
Co-CEO Business tycoon Founder-CEO Global vice chair
entrepreneur Management
Prada Nigeria Epic Systems EY
U.S. JPMorgan
Italy U.S. U.S. U.S.
91 64 97 67
Sara 100 50 Taylor
54 81 82 Raja Easa Lubna
Blakely Lee Boo-Jin Ellen Angelina Shakira Yao Al Gurg
Swift Jolie Olayan
Founder- President DeGeneres Mebarak Chen Managing director
Musician- Actor-advocate CEO
philanthropist Cheil Industries Host-advocate Musician-advocate Actor-advocate Easa Saleh Al
philanthropist U.S. Olayan Financing
Spanx South Korea U.S. Colombia China Gurg Group
U.S. Saudi Arabia
U.S. U.A.E.
7 10 16 58 61 28
Dilma Michelle 11 Cristina Donna Arianna Anna
Rousseff Park Geun-hye Fernández Langley Huffington Wintour
Obama Chair
President President de Kirchner Editor-in-Chief Artistic director
First Lady Universal Pictures
Brazil South Korea President Huffington Post Condé Nast
U.S. U.S.
Argentina U.S. U.S.
36 38 74 80 93 99 6
27 34 Federica Nancy Dana Katharine Shobhana Greta Van
Christine
Michelle Loretta Mogherini Pelosi Walden Lagarde
Viner Bhartia Susteren
Bachelet Lynch Foreign policy Minority leader CEO Managing director
Editor-in-Chief Chair Anchor
President Attorney general chief House of Fox Television International
The Guardian HT Media Fox News
Chile U.S. European Union Representatives Group Monetary Fund
U.K. India U.S.
Italy U.S. U.S. France
23 31 46 47 62
40 41 Helen Sri Mulyani Drew Ertharin Margaret
Ewa Queen Clark Gilpin Faust Cousin Chan
Indrawati
Kopacz Elizabeth II Administrator President Executive director Director-general
Managing director
Prime minister Monarch UN Development Harvard UN World Food World Health
World Bank
Poland U.K. Programme University Programme Organization
Indonesia
New Zealand U.S. U.S. China
49 42 PHILANTHROPY 86
48 Samantha 59 Sheikha Lubna Kaci
Ngozi Sheikh Al Qasimi Kullmann Five
Power
Okonjo-Iweala Hasina Wajed Minister of Intl Chair
Ambassador
Finance minister Prime minister Cooperation & Norwegian Nobel
United Nations
Nigeria Bangladesh Development Committee
U.S.
U.A.E. Norway
63 66 83 89
Nemat Patricia
Mary Jo “Minouche” 68 Fabiola Harris
White Peng Liyuan Gianotti
Shafik CEO
Chair First Lady Director-general
Deputy governor Bloomberg
SEC China CERN
Bank of England Philanthropies
U.S. Italy
U.K. U.S.
3
19 71 Melinda 92 9
Abigail Elvira 96 Gates Risa
Susan
Johnson Ellen Cochair Lavizzo-Mourey
Nabiullina Wojcicki
CEO Johnson-Sirleaf Bill & Melinda CEO
Governor CEO
Fidelity President Gates Foundation Robert Wood
Bank of Russia YouTube
Investments Liberia U.S. Johnson Fdtn
Russia U.S.
U.S. U.S.
30 35 39 13 14 22 24
Arundhati Chanda Adena TECHNOLOGY Ginni Rometty Meg Marissa Safra
Bhattacharya Kochhar Whitman Mayer Catz
Friedman CEO
Chair CEO Co-president IBM CEO CEO Co-CEO
State Bank ICICI Bank HP Yahoo Oracle
Nasdaq U.S.
of India India U.S. U.S. U.S.
U.S.
India
FINANCE 25 29 32
Angela Ursula Ruth
Ahrendts Burns Porat
Senior VP CEO CFO
Apple Xerox Google
U.S. U.S. U.S.
8 45 33 51
Renée Lucy Amy
Sheryl
James Peng Hood
Sandberg
President CEO, Small & CFO
COO
Intel Micro Finl Svcs Microsoft
Facebook
U.S. Group Alibaba U.S.
U.S. China
18 77 78 84 90 95 98
BY CAROLINE HOWARD
Ana Patricia
Botín Mary Solina Chau Padmasree Gwynne Weili Dai Jenny
Chair Meeker Hoi Shuen Warrior Shotwell Cofounder Lee
Banco Santander Partner Cofounder CTO COO Marvell Managing partner
Spain Kleiner Perkins Horizon Ventures Cisco Systems SpaceX Technology Group GGV Capital
Caufield & Byers Hong Kong U.S. U.S. U.S. Singapore
U.S.
CHRIS LYONS (LEFT); PAUL ZIMMERMAN / GETTY IMAGES FOR USANA (RIGHT); HAL MAYFORTH (BELOW); JAGADEESH NV / EPA/ NEWSCOM (TOP)
(1.57% GROWTH YEAR-ON-YEAR) the way down the depth chart? Well, maybe—but it sure helps to have founded the
GSP PER CAPITA: joint. Myron Wentz, founder and chairman of nutritional-supplement seller Usana
$68,631 Health Sciences, became a billionaire in May when his firm’s stock popped 20% in
a day after Usana beat earnings expectations. He joins Richard DeVos and the late
(RANKS NO. 1 NATIONWIDE)
Jay Van Andel of Amway, as well as Antônio Luiz da Cunha Seabra, a founder of
RICHEST: Brazil’s Natura Cosméticos, in forging a ten-figure fortune from a door-to-door sales
ROBERT GORE company.
$675 MILLION Wentz, 74, owns 51% of Salt Lake City-based Usana, which sells protein
snacks, nutrition shakes and vitamins. His stake jumped to $910 mil-
lion after it reported first-quarter earnings of $19.7 million,
SPORTSMONEY
Soccer
$1,835
Team Values
ALL FIGURES IN U.S. DOLLARS.
$1,181
VALUE 5 YEARS AGO ($MIL) $982
+58% +59% $990 $1,000
+53% $837
$775 $822
$700 $800
+33% +33% +33% $634
$572 $600 $656 $646 +27%
+19% +17% +17% +42%
$436 $439 +10%
$294 $349 $413 -2% -2% -1%
$309 $353 $384 $372 -5%
-15% $265
-10%
$261 $258
$175 $198 $172 $197
$125 -1%
-9%
Atletico de
Galatasaray
West Ham
United
Newcastle
United
Napoli
Madrid
Inter Milan
Schalke 04
Tottenham
Hotspur
Germain
Borussia
Juventus
Arsenal
Chelsea
Manchester
Bayern
Manchester
Dortmund
AC Milan
Liverpool
City
Munich
United
Real Madrid
Paris Saint-
Barcelona
30 UNDER 30
Power Players
Science and energy innovations from the FORBES 30 Under 30, in 30 words or less.
Anna Schneider
SOCCER BY MICHAEL K. OZANIAN; 30 UNDER 30 BY KATHRYN DILL
each step, charging a lithium-ion polymer battery pack. An hourlong walk times when appliances are likelier to run on
generates 30 to 60 minutes of iPhone talk time. wind or solar instead of coal. Next: electric
car chargers that refuel with clean energy.
Dave Smith
LIQUIGLIDE | 30
Gets your lotion in motion
by creating a permanently slippery surface, making it
easier to squeeze the last drop from creams, glues and
toothpaste. Scored $7 million funding in March.
LeaderBoard over the last year—but after he misses the annual meeting,
shares tumble 47% before trading is suspended.
BUSINESS LIBRARY
Popcorn Paperbacks
Want to make a fortune in Hollywood?
Hit the books first.
other YA staples: The Hunger Games, Twilight IRON MAN 3 1.22 BIL 2013
and C.S. Lewis’ The Chronicles of Narnia.) AVENGERS: AGE OF ULTRON 1.2 BIL 2015
THE DARK KNIGHT RISES 1.08 BIL 2012
And while literary purists might lament the
THE DARK KNIGHT 1 BIL 2008
CHINAFOTOPRESS / GETTY IMAGES (TOP)
PHOTOGRAPH BY DAVID ARKY FOR FORBES; STYLE DIRECTOR: JOSEPH DEACETIS; BLOOMBERG (TOP)
The ties here tell a differ- ($395). Bottom, from left: silk tie
by Hermès ($200); silk tie by Brioni
ent story. Though the labels ($230); silk tie by Charvet ($245);
are exceptional, they don’t silk tie by Giorgio Armani ($245). BY MICHAEL SOLOMON
CONVERSATION
CALL THEM THE new Gang of Four: Our May STARTUP
25 Global 2000 list of the world’s biggest pub-
lic companies drew tremendous attention to the
SECRETS
quartet at the top: four state-owned Chinese banks Trip Adler, CEO of digital-library
with a combined market cap of $880 billion. Ranjit subscription service Scribd, talked
Goswami, a professor at India’s Institute of Manage- to FORBES readers about the art
ment Technology, cast a wary eye on “the new era of entrepreneurship.
of social-capitalism,” while Gwynn Guilford of the
@NOELLYSAM What’s the
digital news outlet Quartz used our list as a spring- best way to attract investors
board for a thoughtful essay about China’s “bank or strategic partners to join
bloat.” Slate’s Lily Hay Newman, in a piece about your venture?
U.S. ports’ vulnerability to a cyberattack, noted a
study that found 74% of last year’s Global 2000 are
digital-security laggards. (We eagerly await this @FORBES Traction. If
year’s results.) “Doesn’t this sound kind of, um, you can demonstrate real
growth early on, investors
important?” she wrote. Well, sure. Good thing will probably come to you.
we have nothing to fear from Chinese hackers. And that’s true at the later
stages of a business too.
@FORBES There’s a
lot that matters over
How the HondaJet Took Flight: An Engineer’s 29-Year Obsession
the course of five years:
39,623
team, finding product
market fit, finding a
business model, finding
Visa Moves at the Speed of Money a scalable way to grow.
36,381
Being willing to change
while still being stubborn
about the initial idea.
Baby Buffett: Will Bill Ackman Resurrect the Ghost of Howard Hughes and Build a Corporate Empire?
36,146
@APOLACK Many entre-
preneurs say culture is as
Tired of Recruiting’s Broken Image, Airbnb Rewrites the Playbook
“Ackman has the simple as hiring the right
holding company and people and transparency
29,407
the legendary Howard thru tools like Slack. True/
Hughes name. To false? Why?
Meet the Darpa-Backed Hackers Building a Google for Every Web Weakness
build an enduring
“It’s part of a business, he needs
15,082 broader ‘mass- permanent capital.”
scanning’ movement @FORBES I’d give a simi-
MARTIN BUREAU / AFP / GETTY IMAGES
The Job of the Future Is Training Robots to Work With Humans that uses brute force lar answer. Hire the right
to peel away the people, create a transparent
13,069 facade of security environment, trust your
team. It’s also important
BY MEHRUNNISA WANI
The Human Genome Project, which first mapped our genetic blueprint, opened a world of possibilities. What if we
could treat cancer by going after the genes responsible for the disease? This spirit of innovation has put Dana-Farber
at the forefront of cancer genetics. In fact, we discovered that lung cancer patients with an EGFR mutation dramatically
respond to a drug that targets it, extending lives worldwide. Today, we are developing the next generation of targeted
therapies that are showing promise for many cancers, including lung, stomach, colorectal, melanoma and breast –
with the hope of new advances on the horizon.
Defining Moments
SHELLEY O’CONNOR
Morgan Stanley, Wealth Management
When Shelley O’Connor joined Morgan Stanley’s wealth
management office in San Francisco right out of college, she
planned to work for just one year before pursuing a graduate
degree in psychology. That was in 1984 when there were three
women Financial Advisors in the entire firm and no women
among the firm’s senior leadership. Now, 30 years later, she is
Head of Field Management for Morgan Stanley’s wealth
management business, a member of the firm’s Operating
Committee and a tireless advocate for women in the workplace.
Shelley O’Connor
T
oday O’Connor oversees a nation- a supporter and member of the inaugural Officer for the branch organization. Two years
wide network of approximately class of MAKERS @ Morgan Stanley Wealth later, she moved on to become Chief Admin-
16,000 Financial Advisors in more Management, a digital and video storytell- istrative Officer for the Wealth Management
than 600 branch offices that provide ing platform that annually showcases 15 of business, and in 2010 she was named Chief
a wide range of financial products and ser- the firm’s accomplished women nominated Executive Officer of Morgan Stanley Private
vices to individuals, businesses and institutions. by their peers. Bank, National Association, which provides
While there are significantly greater numbers cash management and lending products and
of women in Financial Advisor and leadership services as part of Morgan Stanley’s compre-
roles at the firm today, O’Connor would like to Stretching Boundaries, hensive wealth management offering. Four
see even more. Creating Opportunities years later, in February 2014, she was named
Working closely with senior leaders across O’Connor doesn’t mind stepping out of her Head of Field Management.
the organization, O’Connor is helping the comfort zone to create and follow career
firm expand its hiring, training and devel- opportunities. She has found every one
opment programs targeted to women. To of those opportunities within the Morgan Changing the Face of
encourage women to enter the business, Stanley organization, which she considers a Wealth Management
the firm has a range of apprenticeships that true meritocracy. Hard work and focus have In the year since she has been in her Field
offer stretch assignments, mentoring and helped her succeed. Management role, O’Connor has focused on
coaching for women at all career levels— Two weeks into her first job as an assis- growing the business and helping Financial
recent college graduates, women looking tant in the branch and eager to learn more, Advisors leverage the resources of the full
for a mid-career change and women return- O’Connor started attending a weekly research firm to deliver the superior experience that
ing to the workforce meeting for Financial clients expect.
after a break. O’Connor “We need to resemble Advisors broadcast from As she continues to refine her organi-
also champions ongo- the New York office. She zation, O’Connor also is mindful of statis-
ing learning and sup- and reflect the clients quickly became hooked tics about the growing financial power of
port through multiple we serve.” on the business. Over the women. With women now in control of
women’s networking years she raised her hand investment decisions for almost 40% of U.S.
groups and event s —Shelley O’Connor, repeatedly for new roles investable assets, she believes that attract-
like the firm’s biennial and opportunities and ing, advancing and empowering women in
Morgan Stanley
Women’s Leadership rose through the ranks to wealth management careers is extremely
and Multicultural Lead- Wealth Management become the Southwest important and the right thing to do. “We
ership Summits, which Region Manager for the need to resemble and reflect the clients we
bring together top-performing women and Private Wealth Management business. serve,” she says. Q
multicultural Financial Advisors and Branch After 20 years in California, in 2004 she
Managers for peer-to-peer learning and joined the Wealth Management leadership
professional development. O’Connor is also team in New York as the Chief Operating Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC. Member SIPC.
Invest In
What Lasts
How do you pass down what you’ve spent your
life building up? A Morgan Stanley Financial
Advisor can help you create a legacy plan based
on the values you live by. So future generations
«¸¬¯¸¯Ǥ¾°¼¹·¸¹¾´¿½¾Ã¹¿¼·¹¸¯Ãʦ¬¿¾«¶½¹
ù¿¼¯Â«·º¶¯ʧ¯¾ʤ½²«À¯¾²«¾¹¸À¯¼½«¾³¹¸ʧ
morganstanley.com/legacy
© 2015 Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC. Member SIPC. CRC 1134840 04/15
THOUGHT LEADERS
RICH KARLGAARD // INNOVATION RULES
surely lucky to be endowed with the 99.99th percentile IQs they didn’t and U.S. militaries finally believed the Wright
choose. But they each devoted tens of thousands of hours in applying their Brothers had mastered controllable flight,
smarts to learning about software. Gates forfeited great opportunities by nine years of bad food, bug bites, crashes and
sneering press coverage had passed. President
RICH KARLGAARD IS THE PUBLISHER AT FORBES. HIS NEW BOOK, TEAM GENIUS: THE NEW SCIENCE OF HIGH-
PERFORMING ORGANIZATIONS, COMES OUT IN JULY. FOR HIS PAST COLUMNS AND BLOGS VISIT OUR WEBSITE Theodore Roosevelt had the good grace not to
AT WWW.FORBES.COM/KARLGAARD.
call the Wright Brothers “lottery winners.” F
30 | FORBES JUNE 15, 2015
Your IT solution
should be reducing your workload, not adding to it.
At CenturyLink, we believe you shouldn’t spend more time getting technology to work than you do benefitting
from it actually working. So we design our managed services solutions to work better together – from our
high performing broadband network to our IT infrastructure and services. Delivering reliable uptime and
dedicated support, all backed by multi-layered security, is what we do at CenturyLink. Because technology
should help you manage the complexity of your business, not add to it.
centurylink.com/link
THOUGHT LEADERS
PAUL JOHNSON // CURRENT EVENTS
The EU is the product of a deal between France and Germany, nei- with Europe. It remains to be seen what ef-
ther of which had much experience with democratic institutions and fect this will have on Europe. My guess is that
both of which are accustomed to a strong, centralized state and bu- other countries will follow suit. Then Europe
reaucratic uniformity. Britain’s Magna Carta means nothing to them, will learn the lesson that overambitious fed-
and the U.S. Bill of Rights isn’t part of their history. They are the eralism doesn’t pay. F
PAUL JOHNSON, EMINENT BRITISH HISTORIAN AND AUTHOR; DAVID MALPASS, GLOBAL ECONOMIST, PRESIDENT OF ENCIMA GLOBAL LLC; AND AMITY SHLAES, WHO SERVES AS PRESIDENTIAL
SCHOLAR AT KINGS COLLEGE AND CHAIRS THE COOLIDGE FOUNDATION BOARD, ROTATE IN WRITING THIS COLUMN. TO SEE PAST CURRENT EVENTS COLUMNS, VISIT OUR WEBSITE AT
WWW.FORBES.COM/CURRENTEVENTS,
1. Use our free online mapping tool to hand-select postal routes based FREE
online
on average household size, age range, and income.* mapping
tool
2. Determine the total postage cost per route using our calculator.
You could end up paying as low as 18.3¢ per piece!
*Data, including age range and average household income and size, is based on the prior report from the 2010 U.S. Census Bureau.
†Limit one kit per customer per address. Offer available while supplies last.
Privacy Notice: For information regarding our privacy policies, visit usps.com/privacypolicy.
©2015 United States Postal Service®. All Rights Reserved. The Eagle Logo is among the many trademarks of the U.S. Postal Service®. EDM-COMP-A-FORB
THIS IS WHY YOU NETJET.
Our fleet of 700 jets flew over 127 million miles last year – double that of our competitors,
combined. So whether you are departing Barcelona, Beijing, or Boston, there is a NetJets
aircraft and crew standing by for you. This is who we are.
INNOVATION IN
THE AGE OF EXPERIENCE
We live in an age where businesses need to look beyond the aesthetics of a product or the
practicalities of a service…where consumer engagement and loyalty count far more than features
Ŵ
ē
ŵ
ĥ
be sold to.
Products are no longer enough The key to making consumer It enables everyone within
The 3DEXPERIENCE Platform
for today’s consumers who value experience the true focus of a company to play an active
Explained
experience over all else. innovation is to capture insights role in experience development.
and expertise from across The 3DEXPERIENCE platform
With a single, easy-to-use, is a business experience platform.
THE AGE OF EXPERIENCE a business’s entire ecosystem.
compass-like interface, the It provides software solutions
HAS ARRIVED Shaping the right consumer 3DEXPERIENCE platform powers for every organization in your
experience requires not only INDUSTRY SOLUTION EXPERIENCES company – from engineering
Executives and academics the involvement of but also the – based on 3D design, analysis, to marketing to sales – that
everywhere accept that in the collaboration between all roles simulation and intelligence help you, in your value creation
modern economy, the key to process, to create differentiating
within a company – from software in a collaborative,
success is delivering consumer consumer experiences.
marketing and management interactive environment.
experiences that demonstrate to sales and engineering. With a single, easy-to-use interface,
true differentiation. The Age of Experience represents it powers INDUSTRY SOLUTION
Only by connecting all the dots Ŵ
EXPERIENCES, based on 3D design,
And yet, the task is a daunting one between people, ideas and data can businesses prepared to place analysis, simulation and intelligence
at best. What exactly is meant by a business drive consumer loyalty, a new focus on creating unique software in a collaborative interactive
experience? And, more importantly, engagement and value. and truly rewarding consumer environment. It is available on premise
ŵ
ď experiences. and in public or private cloud.
given the complex array of emotional,
IF WE WANT TO THRIVE It’s time to ask the right questions,
rational and physical responses
IN THE AGE OF EXPERIENCE, understand the present and navigate
that inevitably drive consumer
connection? WHERE CAN WE TURN? the future – now made possible
with the 3DEXPERIENCE platform.
The 3DEXPERIENCE® platform from
IF WE CHANGE THE WAY Discover the 3DEXPERIENCE
Dassault Systèmes is a business
WE INNOVATE, CAN WE experience platform: a new class
platform and our INDUSTRY SOLUTION
DEVELOP EXPERIENCES THAT EXPERIENCES at 3DS.COM.
of collaborative environment
CONSUMERS DEMAND?
Ŵ
It takes a special kind of
companies create differentiating compass to understand the
present and navigate the future.
consumer experiences.
About Dassault Systèmes Dassault Systèmes, the 3DEXPERIENCE Company, provides business and people with virtual universes to imagine sustainable innovations.
Its world-leading solutions transform the way products are designed, produced and supported. Dassault Systèmes’ collaborative solutions foster social innovation, expanding
possibilities for the virtual world to improve the real world. The group brings value to over 190,000 customers of all sizes, in all industries, in more than 140 countries.
3DEXPERIENCE is a registered trademark of Dassault Systèmes or its subsidiaries in the U.S. and/or other countries.
want power everywhere,
can we generate it anywhere?
Airborne, wireless wind turbines –
a dream our software could bring to life.
Innovative thinkers everywhere use
INDUSTRY SOLUTION EXPERIENCES
from Dassault Systèmes to explore
the true impact of their ideas. Insights
from the 3D virtual world allow energy
companies to rethink the way we
generate and distribute power – even
to the most remote locations. How long
before sustainable energy is a reality in
all four corners of the earth?
Fracking’s
Cowboy
Rides Again
America’s wildest wildcatter,
Aubrey McClendon, found new
life—and new billions—after his
spectacular plunge from the
top of the oil game. Trouble has
already come calling.
BY CHRISTOPHER HELMAN
I
n early 2013, during his last days as CEO
of Chesapeake Energy, Aubrey McClen-
don was one busy guy. Chesapeake’s
board gave him the boot following a
litany of accusations about his ram-
pant conflicts of interest, lavish perks, reckless
bets and failure to disclose that he had person-
ally borrowed around $1 billion, some from
Chesapeake’s own lenders. But before leaving
the building, McClendon allegedly gave himself
a parting gift. According to a lawsuit filed by
Chesapeake in February, he had his assistant
print out highly sensitive maps of oil and gas press release. “It is a sad day to see Chesapeake Still hungry: After
prospects in Ohio’s natural-gas-rich Utica shale stoop so low as to sue its cofounder for hav- rounding up more
than $10 billion from
formations, and he e-mailed more proprietary ing information that was earned, paid for and investors for oil and gas
and valuable information to his private account. provided through my contracts with Chesa- exploration, McClendon is
McClendon set up a new operation—Ameri- peake.” Through a spokesman, McClendon tells again raising funds.
can Energy Partners—in offices up the street FORBES he expects to be vindicated in arbitra-
from Chesapeake’s Oklahoma City campus. tion. Raymond declined to speak with FORBES.
He found a deep-pocketed partner in John Regardless of who’s right, one thing is clear:
Raymond, CEO of $15.5 billion Houston private McClendon’s life after Chesapeake has been
equity outfit Energy & Minerals Group (and son every bit as outrageous as you’d expect for the
of legendary Exxon CEO Lee Raymond). Mc- man FORBES dubbed “America’s Most Reckless
Clendon quickly got to work: By the time Ches- Billionaire” in 2011 after a 22-year run leasing
apeake filed its lawsuit alleging theft of secrets, up more than 13 million acres of land across ten
American Energy’s Utica affiliate had already states. He built Chesapeake from nothing in
SEAN GARDNER / REUTERS
bought up more than $1.5 billion of acreage. 1989 into the juggernaut of America’s fracking
As for those allegations of theft? “I am boom, with an enterprise value of $30 billion
entitled to possess and use the 20 terabytes and more natural gas production than any other
of information I own,” McClendon said in a American company save Exxon Mobil. He
clocked in then at No. 359 on The Forbes 400 to an April SEC filing FLASHBACK
list of the richest Americans, with a personal net by one of McClen-
worth of $1.2 billion. don’s companies, the
McClendon may have fallen far off the list Department of Justice
since then, but he’s done nothing to diminish his is investigating him.
reputation as the world’s wildest wildcatter. In DOJ won’t confirm.
just over two years McClendon, via American Then there’s Mc-
Energy Partners, has spent more than $10 bil- Clendon’s Texas fra-
lion of other people’s money (about $5.9 billion cas—a flurry of suits
in equity leveraged up with $4.5 billion in debt) between American
to acquire about 600,000 acres in Ohio, West Energy and Denver-
Virginia, Oklahoma and Texas for oil and gas based Enduring Re-
exploration. Raymond’s EMG has put up some sources over a $2.5 bil-
$3.5 billion. First Reserve, the energy-focused lion, 60,000-acre deal
private equity giant, chipped in most of the rest, (McClendon’s biggest
with McClendon contributing $200 million of so far) that’s already
his own, according to a spokesperson. (McClen- gone bad.
don declined interview requests from FORBES.) Another con-
But just as it did at Chesapeake, McClen- cern: McClendon’s
don’s fast-and-loose style could be catching up compensation under
with him. Thanks to the implosion of oil and gas the kind of heads-
prices, billions of dollars of top-of-the-market I-win-tails-I-don’t-
asset purchases are likely slipping underwater, lose arrangement he OCT. 24, 2011
and his burgeoning empire is at risk. He’s now pioneered at Chesa- Before his fall at Chesapeake, McClendon put on
looking to raise billions more from investors, peake. His manage- a Bordeaux-fueled charm offensive to win over a
betting a rise in prices will vindicate him and ment company gets skeptical FORBES reporter, including an uninvited
paid to oversee all the hotel room upgrade. “He is without a doubt the most
reap huge profits.
admired—and feared—man in the U.S. oil patch. But
The first sign of trouble came in early assets that Ameri- he’s also the most reckless, the alpha wildcatter
2015, when Raymond removed McClendon as can Energy’s affili- with an off-the-charts risk tolerance. … He may have
CEO of American Energy’s Appalachia affili- ates acquire. Beyond changed my room, but McClendon didn’t entirely
ate, replacing him with Jeff Fisher, a former that, according to an change my view of his company.”
top executive at Chesapeake. Raymond also American Energy debt
negotiated a settlement between that company circular, he gets “incentive units” that will pay
and Chesapeake over those theft allegations; out once the private equity guys realize a return.
in April American Energy agreed to hand over The incentive is for McClendon to do deals, lots
6,000 Ohio acres and pay Chesapeake as much of deals, in order to maximize his chances of big
as $25 million. McClendon’s spokesman says payouts down the road. But if oil prices stay low,
it would be a mischaracterization to say that his management company still gets paid.
Raymond’s settlement was done behind Mc- The debt circular for its Permian Basin unit
Clendon’s back, though he wasn’t party to it shows just how expensive the arrangement can
(McClendon is still in arbitration with Chesa- get. The company’s production costs average
peake over its personal claims against him). The $83 per barrel of oil (and natural gas equiva-
episode strained relations between Raymond lents), well above current oil prices. Actual
and McClendon, according to sources, though a drilling costs? Six bucks. Overhead? Three. But
spokesman for McClendon insists, “It’s my un- “management services” fees are $12 per barrel
derstanding that Aubrey and John remain great and “incentive unit expenses” paid to McClen-
friends and strong partners, and are in constant don and his team are $39. For the two months
communication.” ending September 2014, American Energy ac-
Meanwhile, in April Chesapeake agreed to crued $41 million in these costs.
pay $25 million to settle charges against the A spokesman says McClendon’s manage-
company brought by the Michigan attorney ment fees were high in 2014 because of startup
general that McClendon violated antitrust laws costs; they should be lower next year. Also, the
back in 2010 by conspiring with a rival to limit units won’t have any value to McClendon until
what they’d pay for natural gas leases. According the private equity firm has made back its money
© 2015 Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Preferred Guest, SPG, Element and their logos are the trademarks of Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, Inc., or its affiliates. For full
terms of this offer, please visit elementhotels.com
plus a decent return. operations and exists merely to use stock to buy BY THE NUMBERS
Still, thanks to these fees and incentives, the things. McClendon hopes to raise $230 million
company’s production costs are nearly double the in an Avondale IPO, which could come soon.
average North American oil company’s, accord- McClendon also aims to access $4 billion A LONG WAY,
ing to Bernstein Research. Remove them and the through two private investment funds. He BABY?
Permian Basin affiliate would have costs around formed the first, called American Energy Capital Five percent of the top 500
$32 per barrel—profitable in all but the worst mar- Partners-Energy Recovery Program, in partner- U.S. companies are now run
ket conditions. But backing them out would pre- ship with American Realty Capital. The other, by female CEOs. Though
sumably mean backing out Aubrey McClendon. Energy 11, is backed by the management of that’s hardly gender parity,
women’s ascent in corporate
Raymond is said to be seeking a buyer for Apple Hospitality REIT, which made money in America is accelerating.
some of the Texas assets. McClendon’s spokes- deals with Chesapeake years ago. Both ventures Who knows—maybe we’ll
man says although it “will always consider mon- describe themselves in SEC filings as being hit 15% by 2030.
etization opportunities” American Energy is still “blind pool” offerings, with no existing opera-
“looking for more assets to acquire.” tions other than the vim and vigor of McClen-
This seems unlikely if oil prices stay low. don, who will manage the cash as he sees fit.
American Energy-Permian Basin slashed Caveat emptor. A close read of the lengthy
planned 2015 capital spending from about $1 bil- “Conflicts of Interest” section of the American
lion to less than $500 million, according to Stan- Energy Capital prospectus finds that McClen-
dard & Poor’s. Even with reduced drilling plans don, as manager, owes no fiduciary duty to the
2015
the company could need to raise billions before partnership. He can even sell it oil and gas assets FEMALE CEOS:
it’s able to generate enough free cash flow to live he already owns. And after doing so, he will con- 25 (5%)
within its means. It’s the same story at American tinue to be paid management fees, “which may TOP:
Mary Barra,
Energy’s other affiliates—too much debt, lots of result in a profit” to his company. A McClendon General Motors
capital required to develop assets bought at the spokesman insists he has no intention of selling (No. 7 of 500)
top of the market and uncooperative oil and gas his own oil and gas assets to the partnership.
prices. In May Carin Dehne-Kiley, an S&P credit Neither Raymond nor the Energy & Minerals
analyst, downgraded the ratings of American Group has any piece of these offerings. Even now,
Energy and its sister companies on concerns of with oil back to $60 a barrel, shares in the best-per-
overleverage and dwindling liquidity. forming oil companies are down 20% from June
McClendon’s strategy might have worked 2014 highs; Chesapeake is off 50%. A generous es-
had oil prices stayed high. “He was paying top timate has EMG and First Reserve sitting on paper
dollar at a time when prices were peaking,” says losses of $2 billion in American Energy deals. A 2000
Christopher O’Sullivan, president of Paloma spokesman for McClendon disputes this figure.
STAN HONDA / AFP / GETTY IMAGES; TIMOTHY ARCHIBALD / BLOOMBERG; WALLY MCNAMEE / CORBIS
FEMALE CEOS:
Resources, which had agreed in early 2014 to “He got out over his skis on this last round,” 2 (0.4%)
TOP:
sell McClendon its acreage in Ohio. But the deal says O’Sullivan. In April he finally squared away
Carly Fiorina,
never got done. Two weeks before closing in a deal to sell his Ohio acreage to Gulfport Energy Hewlett-Packard
early 2015, O’Sullivan says, McClendon admit- Corp. for $300 million. Still, O’Sullivan wishes (No. 13)
ted “he didn’t have the money to close the deal.” McClendon luck. “He’s maybe recklessly aggres-
Why not? A McClendon spokesman says in an sive at times, but I admire his conviction and I
e-mail that the company “subsequently deter- always liked doing business with him. His style
mined not to complete the transaction for a appeals to me.”
variety of good reasons” but refused to elaborate. McClendon’s next big idea: According to a
Meanwhile, it’s been months since American source close to the matter, he’s eyeing 16 million
Energy announced a new acquisition, and Mc- acres in northern Australia’s McArthur Basin,
Clendon has been busy, looking for new money. where there might be 200 trillion feet of shale 1985
In early April McClendon filed with the SEC an gas waiting to be drilled, chilled and shipped to FEMALE CEOS:
IPO prospectus for a startup called Avondale Asia as liquefied natural gas. Just think: a whole 2 (0.4%)
TOP:
Acquisition Corp. Avondale is an SPAC—that new continent, ripe for the fracking. What could Katharine Graham,
pre-2009 creature that has no assets and no possibly go wrong? Washington Post Co.
(No. 323)
SOURCE: CATALYST ANALYSIS OF THE
FINAL THOUGHT 500 LARGEST COMPANIES BY REVENUE
(2000 AND 1985) AND S&P 500 (THROUGH
“Oil is a resource that anesthetizes thought, blurs vision, corrupts.” JANUARY 2015).
—RYSZARD KAPUSCINSKI
Merchants
Of Parallel
Worlds
Improbable invented a new way
to simulate almost any complex
E
very Friday just after lunch, the candidate for Improbable’s sim software. Tradi- Inventing the what-if
machine: Improbable’s
videogame developers at Bossa tional MMORPGs like World of Warcraft have to Herman Narula and Rob
Studios in London’s East End take a take serious shortcuts around reality to simplify Whitehead in the pool
break from all the coding to try out the computational load for the game. You can of Narula’s family home
in North London.
their own work. This spring they’ve slay a dragon, for example, but it will respawn
been putting the finishing touches on Worlds for thousands of other players to slay, too. But in
Adrift, a so-called massively multiplayer online Worlds Adrift, one player kills a dragon and it’s
role-playing game in which thousands of people really dead. One day in March, as Bossa’s coders
float across a virtual sky on ships, attacking one were play-testing their game, they picked up a
another. They’re hoping to build the next World flare gun meant only for signaling and threw it at
of Warcraft, an MMORPG that grossed more another player; sure enough it caused a red flash
than $1 billion last year. on the screen, indicating an injury. “They hadn’t
Bossa’s game could be even better, because it coded it as a weapon,” says Bossa Studios co-
will be more real. Bossa turned to Improbable, founder Henrique Olifiers, but because the simu-
another startup 2 miles to the west, which has lation was based on complex principles of phys-
invented a new way to simulate extremely com- ics and biology, any physical object hurled with
plex systems. A floating fantasy world is a perfect speed did damage. The result was a world almost
FINAL THOUGHT
“If our brains were simple enough for us to understand them, we’d be so
simple that we couldn’t.” —IAN STEWART
46 | FORBES JUNE 15, 2015
THERE’S A LAUGH, AND YOU REALIZE
YOU’RE SPEAKING THE SAME LANGUAGE.
ADP and the ADP logo are registered trademarks of ADP, LLC.
ADP – A more human resource. is a service mark of ADP, LLC.
Copyright © 2015 ADP, LLC. Talent Management | Benefits Administration | Workforce Optimization
estate market collapsed in 2008, the backyard-
ENTREPRENEURS pond business collapsed with it. And then liter-
ally, when 700 feet of steel-reinforced ceiling
INVENTING AN INDUSTRY collapsed under the weight of 2 feet of snowfall
turned to ice. Luckily, the roof came down on
a Sunday, when nobody was on-site, but by the
time construction crews swept up, Wittstock
had seen his revenue cut in half to $29.5 million
and he’d had to lay off almost 45% of his staff.
Today the roof has been fixed, and Wittstock
says Aquascape is growing again: “We had to
strip and rebuild the whole business from the
ground up.” A motivational poster depicting the
collapsed roof hangs on an office wall, showing
Wittstock and his managers in the foreground,
wearing hard hats and stern expressions, be-
neath the word “perseverance.”
Now 45, Wittstock first got his hands dirty
in the pond business when he was 12. After his
father, Gary, an engineer, uprooted the family
from New Jersey and moved them to Wheaton,
Ill., he promised his son he’d build a pond for
his pet turtles. “It leaked, turned green and my
prized turtles migrated away,” says Greg. But the
experience proved invaluable. “It became my
backyard classroom because every year I’d rip
it out and rebuild it,” he says. “My pumps were
clogging, so I put them in a garbage can—that
was my first skimmer. My ponds were turning
It’s Pondemonium! green, so I used a cattle trough—that was my
first biological filter.”
Greg Wittstock pretty much invented the Eventually others started admiring his cre-
backyard-pond industry, but with family ations. “I thought, there’s gotta be a business
here.” In 1991 Wittstock, then a junior at Ohio
conflicts, soaring and then falling sales and a State, built five ponds, netting him $11,000. The
collapsed roof, his life sounds like reality TV. following August interest spiked after a Chicago
BY KARSTEN STRAUSS Tribune article on his work, and he collected
$36,000 in deposit checks in one day.
When Wittstock’s father joined the venture,
I
Selling the lifestyle:
“Everybody wants a water
n 2005 Greg Wittstock built what he it was as an equal partner. A brief collaboration,
feature. They just don’t says was the largest sloping green roof however, led to a decadelong feud. “My dad be-
know it yet.” in North America to cover the parking lieved that the key to success was the engineer-
lot at the headquarters of Aquascape, ing of the products,” says Greg, “and I believed
a backyard-pond company he founded that the key to success was selling the lifestyle.”
outside Chicago in 1991. Topped with a layer Tired of the friction, Gary left Aquascape in
of earth and prairie vegetation, the roof was 1996 and started his own pond-accessory busi-
part of a complex Wittstock ordered when ness, PondSweep. “My goal was to build a better
Aquascape was enjoying explosive growth and filter I could sell to Greg,” Gary says, “but Greg
seemed on its way to surpassing his goal of $100 was so angry that he really didn’t want to buy fil-
million in annual revenue. The project featured ters from me.” Instead, they became competitors
JEFF SCIORTINO FOR FORBES
Koi ponds, babbling waterfalls, a mini soccer and stopped speaking. At its peak PondSweep
field, a batting cage, a basketball court, a gym hit almost $7 million in sales, then faltered.
and a spa. In 2006 Greg bought the company’s
But by February 2011 the roof had caved in remaining assets, and Gary now works for
on Aquascape, first figuratively: When the real Aquascape’s social media team. “We’ve never
TONDA 1950
Rose gold
Ultra-thin automatic movement
Hermès alligator strap
Made in Switzerland
www.parmigiani.ch
LES STUDIOS PARMIGIANI BEIJING, DUBAI, GSTAAD, KIEV, MACAU, MIAMI, MUNICH,
PORTO CERVO, SAO PAULO, SHANGHAI, SINGAPORE, TIANJIN
ENTREPRENEURS INVENTING AN INDUSTRY
had an issue since he’s come back into the says, “everything I did I had to filter through the TRENDING
business because I’m the sole owner,” says budget, where before I had no budget because I
Greg. Gary has a gentler view: “I think we had double-digit growth every year.” What the 70 million
appreciated each other more because we’d Three rounds of layoffs cut Aquascape staff Forbes.com users
been separated for a while.” from 195 to 110, some of whom exited bleating are talking about.
For a deeper dive go to
After his father left, Wittstock tried franchis- expletives and damnation. A professional turn-
FORBES.COM/ENTREPRENEURS
ing but couldn’t find contractors willing to pay around specialist—hired as president in 2007—
$50,000 for franchise rights. So he taught the alienated managers and left after 18 months, PERSON
contractors his pond-building system through replaced by CFO Colleen Heitzler, who still runs WILLIAM HSU
demonstrations and a certification program, the day-to-day. “I’m not a manager,” Wittstock While many accelerators
mandating that they use his equipment. “It’s a says. “I’m a visionary.” work with dozens of
companies a year for
The future he envisioned included selling a three months each,
rainwater-retention system that never lived up Hsu’s MuckerLab
to expectations and catering to hobby build- mentors just ten or
ers by developing entry-level pond kits and so, for the whole
components. Today do-it-yourselfers represent year. Pitching him?
Don’t say you have no
30% of Aquascape’s retail sales. To reach the competitors.
uninitiated, Wittstock attacked social media,
launching a Facebook page and a YouTube IDEA
BETTER HEAD-SHOP
channel that’s up to 9 million views. DESIGN
And slowly the pond industry is climbing If legal pot businesses
Pond envy: The typical customer who buys a pond, back. Last year Aquascape netted $2.8 million on are going to overcome
Wittstock says, will eventually upgrade twice. $35 million in revenue, and it projects double- their seedy past,
franchise system without a franchise fee,” he digit growth this year. One competitor, New they need nice
interiors: good
says. Jersey-based Savio Engineering, had $6 million lighting, placement
The average specialty contractor builds 30 in sales in 2014 and is seeing a 15% increase this of complementary
to 40 ponds, or “water features,” a year. Witt- year, says its president, Valerie Steele, who adds products … and odor
stock says customers who buy a pond generally that Wittstock’s promotion of the industry ben- mitigation.
upgrade twice, usually to an 11-by-16-foot kit for efits everyone. “I think one of his better skills is COMPANY
about $10,000: “Everybody wants a water fea- marketing,” she says. NEW BELGIUM
ture. They just don’t know it yet.” Wittstock now has his own reality show to BREWING
His annual pond-building events have grown sell the aquatic lifestyle. Premiering last Sep- The 100%-employee-
owned company is
to include hundreds of contractors and enthusi- tember on Nat Geo Wild, Pond Stars saw Witt- now the fourth-largest
asts. Every year at the largest of these shindigs, stock and pals tackling pond builds in various craft-beer producer in
dubbed Pondemonium, Wittstock throws the locations while enduring each other’s friendly the U.S. and is opening
spotlight on his “Top Frogs”—those contractors ribbing. Though the show attracted a cult fol- a new brewery in suds-
who buy the most merchandise from him (in his lowing, its ratings were lackluster and Nat Geo mad Asheville, N.C.
heyday he gifted them Escalades and Hummers declined to renew the series.
as prizes). Steve Shinholser of Premier Ponds So Wittstock took over, renaming the show
in Burtonsville, Md., who won last year’s top Aquascape Pond Squad, installing a production
honors for selling more than $1 million worth studio in his offices and shooting episodes at
of pond gear, says in 14 years he’s never built a $25,000 a pop to air on his YouTube channel.
KATHRYN SCOTT OSLER / THE DENVER POST VIA GETTY IMAGES (RIGHT)
pond without Aquascape equipment. “As long as consumers can find the content,” he
Sipping ice tea from a 70-ounce Bubba Keg says, “I’m happy.”
mug, Wittstock gazes out his office window at Wittstock still thinks he can turn Aquascape
his own pond—a 650,000-gallon, self-support- into a $100 million business eventually, in part
ing ecosystem with an underwater cave and a because his contractors know what they’re doing
grotto. It was completed in 2008, the year real now. “When it was the heyday,” he says, “they
estate values tanked and homeowners stopped were making money by osmosis. Today they’re
spending money on landscaping. Suddenly, he making money because they’re good.”
FINAL THOUGHT
*Wells Fargo rewarded Carolyn Miye $10,000 to help with her marketing plans.
© 2015 Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. All rights reserved. Member FDIC.
Swiss francs (about $700,000 ) in his bank ac-
ENTREPRENEURS count, he didn’t yet have enough money saved.
But the new contract forced his hand, so Büsser
LUXURY left. On July 25, 2005 he incorporated MB&F
—Maximilian Büsser & Friends—gambling his
I
n 1998 the venerable jewelry house based only on a hand-painted plastic mock-up,
Harry Winston hired a 31-year-old each advancing 35% of the $150,000 retail price.
Jaeger-LeCoultre product manager to (Retailers did so despite their belief that his radi-
head the company’s struggling watch cal watch—which looked like the love child of an
division. Within seven years Maximil- owl and a pair of binoculars—was “unsellable.”)
ian Büsser had boosted revenue from $8 million The cash advance pulled Büsser through, and by
to $80 million and garnered industry respect year three MB&F had $2 million in revenue.
by partnering with Switzerland’s top indepen- For its tenth anniversary the company created
dent watchmakers to produce the Opus series the HM6 Space Pirate, a biomorphic timepiece
of ultracomplicated timepieces. To reward the with four domed dials and a flying tourbillon in
SIDDHARTH SIVA FOR FORBES
young CEO, Winston offered Büsser a generous the center. Büsser says the $230,000 watch is the
new contract—and he responded by quitting. most outrageous of his career, but tame com-
The trouble was a noncompete clause in the pared with the concepts he has planned out to
offer, which conflicted with Büsser’s dream of 2022. “Our clients expect to be amazed,” he says.
launching his own brand. With just 900,000 “Our biggest risk now is not to shock.” F
Health care reform is no time for maintaining the status quo. Especially when it costs your
business time and money. Rather, this is the moment to seriously consider new ways to offer
a competitive health benefit program that also maintains the overall health of your company.
It’s time for a private health insurance exchange.
Of the private exchanges, only one offers the experience you want with the highly adaptable
solution you need: OneExchange. We have served over 1,100 employers and 800,000 customers,
representing a wide range of industries. Our solutions are simple, effective, and proven.Visit us
at chooseoneexchange.com and see what we can do for you.
Mall
Vultures
Retail’s physical struggles mean
big business for two creative
real estate fixers.
BY STEVE SCHAEFER
O
n a freezing, snow-covered Friday
in early March, Andy Graiser and
Emilio Amendola are standing
in the parking lot of a suburban
Long Island strip mall, ruminating
on the evidence of drastic changes to the retail
sector over the last 25 years.
One side of the strip houses a 10,000-square-
foot Ulta Beauty next to Tilly’s, DressBarn and
Modell’s. In 2012, when the pair started workout
firm A&G Realty Partners, based in Melville,
N.Y., that same space was almost entirely occu-
pied by a Barnes & Noble. Going back further, a
Tower Records and a Pergament paint store.
“From what it looked like before to what it
looks like now, you never would have expected ing $1 trillion in spending—are anything but mall For retailers, A&G
this,” Amendola says of the mix of stores and rats. So, many real-estate-centric retailers are Realty’s Andy Graiser
and Emilio Amendola
restaurants that now make up the strip mall. Left scrambling, and that makes for a booming busi-
are both undertakers
unsaid and largely unseen is the fact that he and ness for A&G Realty’s Amendola and Graiser. and obstetricians.
Graiser have played a role in driving that transfor- Over the last two decades the pair have re-
mation by helping retailers extricate themselves negotiated and mitigated more than $6 billion
from underperforming stores, negotiate rent re- in leases and worked on nearly 30,000 prop-
ductions and optimize their real estate assets. erties, mostly for onetime retailing greats like
In today’s ultracompetitive climate, retailers CompUSA, Blockbuster and Borders. A&G typi-
are finding themselves with limited options for cally charges from 3% to 10% of gross proceeds
expansion. Industrywide, net new-store growth on leases or properties sales. The recent sale of a
is virtually nonexistent. Consider that U.S. shop- distribution center for bankrupt retailer Delia’s
ping center space grew by an annual average of for $4 million, for example, netted A&G an esti-
169 million square feet from 2000 through 2008. mated commission of $120,000. Its work with
For the last five years the pace has slowed to less Borders brought in more than $1 million.
than 50 million square feet per year. Long Island native Graiser is the idea man,
Retailing is facing an existential crisis cen- opining on the industry’s future and how lack of
tered on its so-called footprint. Many blame the new development and concern for liquidity has
MATT FURMAN FOR FORBES
economic fallout from the financial crisis and prompted retailers to make acquiring leases an
recession, but the real culprits are digital and effective growth strategy. Amendola, a Bronx-
mobile alternatives from the likes of Amazon, raised son of a barber, is the numbers man.
Wayfair and Tire Rack. The new 80-million- RadioShack is a client. When its efforts to
strong wave of Millennial shoppers—represent- avoid Chapter 11 failed, A&G sold dozens of
leases, many to GameStop, before the filing. deal uncovered Toys “R” Us’ hidden real estate
Amendola and Graiser started working to- value. Then in 2005 KKR, Bain and Vornado Re- TRENDING
gether in the early 1990s, managing the real estate alty Trust bought the retailer for $6.6 billion.
portfolio of New York’s Dabah family, which Despite successes like Toys “R” Us, Amendo- What the 70 million
controlled jeansmaker Gitano Group and retail la and Graiser thought working under liquidator Forbes.com users
chain the Children’s Place. In 1992 the 170-store Gordon Brothers was less than ideal, because are talking about.
For a deeper dive go to
Children’s Place was lurching toward bankruptcy the stigma made healthy clients shy away. The
FORBES.COM/INVESTING
after losing as much as $69 million in one year, two quit and launched A&G Realty in 2012.
but the team was able to settle with landlords for Today, Graiser says, A&G is doing just as
35 cents on the dollar, avoiding a Chapter 11 filing. much with healthy retailers as distressed ones.
Amendola, Graiser and a third partner then It has been helping furniture chain La-Z-Boy
struck out on their own under a new banner at expand, Yum Brands exit KFC locations and
DJM Realty, specializing in distressed situations. CVS renegotiate leases. The 11-person firm has
A key assignment came in 1995 when Fashion 21 current projects involving 1,800 locations.
Bug, a subsidiary of Charming Shoppes, hired Back in the parking lot in Huntington, N.Y.
DJM to close 290 stores and try to renegotiate Graiser points to the nearby Walt Whitman
rents on the rest of its 1,400-store chain. The Shops, a traditional mall turned “inside out” by
mandate was seen as a no-win proposition. owner Simon Property Group, with restaurants
“They already had bankruptcy counsel ready and entertainment luring customers. Impor-
to go,” Graiser recalls. Because of its puny size tantly, store entrances like those to Pottery Barn
and short track record, DJM partnered with the and Gap open directly to the parking lot. It’s a
larger Boston-based liquidator, Gordon Brothers. potentially mall-saving trend. COMPANY
SHAKE SHACK
“They had all kinds of systems and staff, and One by-product of digital growth is a shrink- Extraordinary valuation
we were there with our pencils and legal pads,” ing of retailer footprints. Big boxes and vast, and minuscule store
Amendola recalls. DJM ran circles around its time-sucking indoor malls are out, while lower- count can’t stop the
larger teammate. “Fashion Bug was the deal that cost strip malls that offer everything from urgent trendy burger chain’s
care to organic grocers are in. galloping stock price.
put us on the map,” Graiser says.
It also opened the eyes of Gordon Brothers, Graiser also notes that digital disruptors like PERSON
which acquired DJM in 1998. A deal with Toys Amazon and eyeglass merchant Warby Parker SETH KLARMAN
“R” Us showcased DJM’s workout creativity. may move toward strategic physical outposts. Billionaire investor
takes the other side
In 2003 the chain was closing Kids “R” Us and “Millennial customers shop very differently, and
of David Einhorn’s big
trying to get out of other locations. Major REITs retailers have to learn from it,” says analyst Dana shale oil short; bets
wanted to buy their leases for pennies. Telsey. She points to Macy’s, which plans to hire on Pioneer Natural
“They were always the first tenant in a 150 employees for a new San Francisco-based Resources.
shopping center, so they had cheap rents and digital unit. Williams-Sonoma spent
IDEA
long-term deals that lasted forever,” Amendola $42 million last year on its e-commerce effort, NEW LIFE IN LEFT-
explains. “They had every right a tenant could which produced more than half its revenue. FOR-DEAD EQUITIES
want; the landlords would have loved to get those Kroger is expanding in organic food, but it also Verizon’s $4.4 billion
AOL pickup shows
leases back.” When he and Graiser saw the land- just bought analytics firm dunnhumbyUSA.
there’s still some
lords’ paltry offer—about $60 million for the 127 Telsey argues that technology rivals real value in maligned
stores—they phoned Toys “R” Us management. estate as firms try to stay ahead of Millennial no-growth names.
RICKY CARIOTI / THE WASHINGTON POST VIA GETTY IMAGES
“They gave us 120 days,” Graiser recalls. So trends. “It has to be a regular part of how retail-
for three days the duo took a hotel suite during a ers use capital,” says Telsey, citing the latest
shopping-center convention in New York. twentysomething-inspired shift. “There’s a
“We had a different retailer coming in every reason restaurants, gyms and hair salons are
half hour,” Amendola says, “and we made sure growing,” she says. Whether it’s a GameStop or a
that when Staples came in Office Depot was Drybar or a Starbucks moving in or out, upheav-
right behind them, so they’d see each other.” als in retailing cause Amendola’s and Graiser’s
Office Depot wound up offering $200 million smartphones to start buzzing. And that’s music
for all 127 leases in one neat transaction. The to their ears.
FINAL THOUGHT
ALPHA, BETA,
GOTCHA
IN 1999 IT WAS dot-com new issues. potential downturns.”
In 1957 uranium mining stocks were Wouldn’t it be great to outsmart beta? To
hot. In 1637 investors were overweight have some system for getting 100% of the
tulip bulbs. gain but suffering only 80% of the loss?
An ever present hazard on Wall The grand idea started when academ-
Street is the risk of falling prey to an ics discovered an “anomaly” in stock prices:
investing fad. I see one building right Low-beta stocks like Kroger and Visa have
now. I can see it by looking at the press done better than you would have expected,
releases that float in over the transom. given their lower risk. In theory you could
The frenzy of the moment is “smart have mechanically harvested a pile of low-
beta.” beta stocks, leveraged up the portfolio to
A beta coefficient, by itself, is a le- where it was just as risky as the overall mar-
gitimate measure of the risk in a portfolio. If it’s 1.5, then the portfolio ket and then beaten the market by a mile.
is expected to lurch up 15% when the market goes up 10%, or down Alas, moneymaking anomalies don’t per-
15% if the market goes down 10%. A fundamental law of investing sist. Once they are discovered, they are priced
says that risk cuts both ways. away. Given the popularity of ETFs chasing
Smart beta is a little less fundamental. It’s the notion that you can after low volatility, it’s a good bet that low-
beat the market by fiddling with the buttons on your stock screen. beta stocks are collectively overpriced now.
You could, for example, change the way you weight the positions in In 2011 this column gave a favorable men-
a portfolio. Instead of holding stakes proportional to each company’s tion to Arnott’s weighting scheme, suggest-
market capitalization, as stock indexes traditionally do, you could ing that it was a way to bet against market
weight them equally or weight them according to book value, divi- fads and lighten up on overbought sectors. It
dends or earnings. might be able to deliver an extra half a point
Like all fads, this one worked at the beginning. Robert Arnott, an a year of performance, I guessed. Nowadays,
innovator in alternative portfolio weights, has done very well with with all the copycats on Arnott’s tail, I’d
temper that prediction. Maybe you’ll land
an extra quarter of a point. Consider the
GAINS WITHOUT THE PAINS? POWERSHARES FTSE RAFI U.S. 1000 ETF (PRF, 94), but
DON’T KID YOURSELF don’t expect wondrous performance.
As for the many imitators who are turn-
a business built on Rafi (Research Affiliates Fundamental Index) ing Arnott’s idea into a hype factory, be
stock-weighting formulas. You can get Rafi-flavored mutual funds and wary. I went looking for a poster child of
exchange-traded funds. the smart-beta phenom and found some-
And as with all fads, the innovators were followed by imitators and thing called First Trust Multi Cap Growth
the imitators are now being followed by idiots. Scores of smart-beta Alphadex ETF. It’s an equally weighted
funds are drawing in late-coming customers. They have hoovered up collection of 495 stocks scientifically selected
$400 billion or so of investor money. to generate “alpha,” which is a fancy way of
A variation on the theme, reaching fever pitch in product saying that you beat the market.
announcements, is “low-volatility” investing. (Low-volatility stocks Do you? Over the past five years the Al-
THOMAS KUHLENBECK FOR FORBES
are not synonymous with low-beta stocks, but there is a lot of phadex product, which costs 0.7% a year, has
overlap.) Here in my in-box is a press release trumpeting a whole earned a compound annual 15.6%. You could
suite of low-vol funds. The declared aim is “taking advantage of the have done 16.2% with a plain old S&P 500
equity market’s potential upside while providing protection from index fund costing a tenth as much.
Best of all is the ticker for the Alphadex
GO TO FORBES.COM/SITES/BALDWIN FOR MORE ON TAX-WISE INVESTING STRATEGIES. fund. It’s FAD. F
you have high conviction, and be very patient. Here’s how the paper con- that goes up and down with copper prices. I
cluded: “Our results thus suggest that Warren Buffett’s investment skill see it as a company that increasingly adds value
seems generally shared by mutual fund managers in the top Active Share through logistics and makes itself necessary to
customers’ supply chains. It sells below 13 times
JOHN W. ROGERS JR. IS FOUNDER AND CHIEF INVESTMENT OFFICER OF CHICAGO-BASED ARIEL
INVESTMENTS. FOR MORE INFORMATION VISIT WWW.ARIELINVESTMENTS.COM. earnings, a substantial discount to the market. F
In the lead role: John Travolta, movie legend and aviation aficionado.
Guest star: the legendary North American X-15 that has smashed all
speed and altitude records and opened the gateway to space. Production:
Breitling, the privileged partner of aviation thanks to its reliable, accurate
and innovative instruments – such as the famous Chronomat, the ultimate
chronograph. Welcome to a world of legends, feats and performance. CHRONOMAT 44
B RE I T L I N G . C O M
INVESTING
RICHARD LEHMANN // FIXED-INCOME WATCH
RICHARD LEHMANN IS EDITOR OF THE FORBES/LEHMANN INCOME SECURITIES INVESTOR NEWSLETTER AND PRESIDENT OF LEHMANN LIVIAN FRIDSON ADVISORS.
FOR MORE INFORMATION FOLLOW HIM AT FORBES.COM/LEHMANN.
Northwestern Mutual realizes that money matters, but what matters more is you. Your goals.
Your interests. And the things you want to accomplish most in life. We’ll be right there with
you every step of the way, helping you discover what’s possible and guiding you with
a financial plan that turns your biggest goals into your biggest achievements.
You and Northwestern Mutual—stronger together.
Northwestern Mutual is the marketing name for The Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company (NM), Milwaukee, WI, and its subsidiaries.
Features June 15, 2015
FROM MOVIE STAR TO MOGUL 66
BrandVoice
WITH NORTHWESTERN MUTUAL
THE POWER OF EMPOWERMENT 70
In 1995 Web-design
instructor Lynda
Weinman bought
the URL Lynda.com
as a resource for her
students. It grew into
an educational empire.
In May she sold it
to LinkedIn for
$1.5 billion. Class
dismissed.
PAGE 84
BY CLARE O’CONNOR
W
Natural Woman
PHOTOGRAPH BY JAMEL TOPPIN FOR FORBES
MAKEUP BY LAUREN ANDERSEN FOR AVON AT THE WALL GROUP; HAIR BY RENATO CAMPORA USING ORIBE HAIRCARE FOR THE WALL GROUP;
WARDROBE STYLING BY EMILY CURRENT AND MERITT ELLIOTT FOR THE WALL GROUP; DRESS BY ROKSANDA LLINCIC; BONE HEELS BY JIMMY CHOO. US.JIMMYCHOO.COM.
Actress Jessica Alba has quickly built a personal
$200 million fortune, and she’s done it the hard way, in a
field that has nothing to do with showbiz.
I
t’s Kombucha Thursday ing products, it hit $10 million in a baby shower thrown by family and
at the Santa Monica head- revenue. By last year it was $150 friends, she remembers her moth-
quarters of The Honest million, and industry insiders are er advising her to use baby detergent
Company, which means predicting over $250 million this to prewash the piles of onesies she’d
that groups of young, year. The company is focused on received as gifts. She used a main-
stylish workers gather growth over profits, boasting a cur- stream brand and immediately broke
at communal tables in rent valuation to match: $1 billion. out into ugly red welts, harkening
a converted toy factory to slurp That figure means Alba, who owns back to a childhood spent in and out
fashionable fermented tea. Jessica between 15% and 20% of
Alba, Hollywood star and company the company, according
cofounder, sits in the adjacent room. to a source with knowl-
She’ll join her troops shortly, but for edge of her investment,
now she’s transfixed by a box of tam- is sitting on a fortune of
pons that looks more like it holds $200 million. She’s on Women
an expensive candle than Kotex.
“Dope!” she declares, approvingly.
her way to earning a spot
on FORBES’ new rank-
To Watch
“We’re using all-organic cot- ing of America’s Richest WHO WILL NEXT BREAK
ton and plant-based polymer and Self-Made Women, just INTO THE TOP 50 RANKS
OF THE MOST SUCCESSFUL
a bio-plastic applicator,” says the $50 million shy of Beyon- SELF-MADE WOMEN?
34-year-old actress earnestly, con- cé and Judge Judy, who OUR MONEY IS ON ALBA
trasting that with the plastic content are tied at number 49. AND THESE SEVEN
of drugstore tampons and their effect The only other two celeb- RISING STARS. THEY
HAIL FROM DIFFERENT
on hormones. Honest’s new feminine rities to make the inaugu- INDUSTRIES, INCLUDING
care line launches in July. ral list are Oprah and Ma- ENTERTAINMENT, TECH
Alba can go similarly deep on donna. The difference is AND RETAIL, BUT THEY
almost all of The Honest Compa- that foursome made their ARE ALL MAKING THEIR
MARK. —Katia Savchuk BULLOCK
ny’s 120 products, whether the in- money in their core field,
gredients in a new organic beeswax media and music. Alba, at
sunscreen or the clever insulation a young age, has done it Cindy Monroe Films, has made 8 movies
since 1998 and scored earlier
pocket hidden inside a chic $170 veg- in a completely unrelat- $200 MILLION
AGE: 40. RESIDENCE: with a lucrative syndication
an-leather diaper bag. Yes, she has a ed industry. But ask Alba NEW ALBANY, OHIO deal with its George Lopez
pretty face—it seems as if every men’s and she’ll tell you she When she was 28 and a young sitcom. She is set to voice a
magazine has named her the most and Honest are just get- working mother, Monroe villain in Minions, this sum-
had an idea to help women mer’s Despicable Me spinoff.
beautiful woman in the world at ting started. “If we really Her performance in Gravity
some point—but it’s the details from want to make a difference earn extra money by hosting
parties selling gifts and ac- in 2013 earned her a second
which great fortunes stem. in the world and people’s cessories. She held the first in Oscar nod—and a $60 million
Details and hard work. Alba health, it’s billions and 2003. Since then over 300,000 payout. Bullock also owns
consultants have held more two restaurants in Texas.
laughs about how she once worked billions of dollars, not just
than 4.5 million parties for her
an 86-hour week as the star of James one,” she says, surveying
company, Thirty-One Gifts.
Cameron’s sci-fi TV series, Dark the open-plan company Revenues hit $643 million in Taylor Swift
Angel—the series that launched her floor from a conference 2014, down from $763 million $200 MILLION
the previous year. Monroe cut AGE: 25. RESIDENCE:
career. Now, she says, she spends room above its wooden NEW YORK CITY
costs to keep up profits and is
those 86 hours at a vintage teal blue rafters. now testing new products like The singer has transitioned
desk, overseeing marketing and monogrammed pillows, wall seamlessly from country
brand development for a compa- LIKE MOST GREAT art and fragrances. starlet to pop superstar, tak-
ny that feeds a growing demand for ideas, The Honest Com- ing home 8 Billboard music
awards in 2015—more than
safe, nontoxic products, particularly pany was inspired by a
among young helicopter parents who need that wasn’t being
Sandra Bullock Sam Smith, Hozier and One
Direction combined. Swift
$200 MILLION
treat children—and what goes near filled. In 2008 Alba was AGE: 50. RESIDENCE: has already earned roughly
AUSTIN, TEX. $300 million during her ca-
or inside them—like porcelain. newly engaged to Inter-
reer and plowed much of it
Safety sells. The Honest Compa- net entrepreneur Cash One of Hollywood’s highest-
into real estate, reportedly
ny has experienced an absurd level Warren and pregnant earning actresses. Her
buying homes in Nashville,
production company, Fortis
of growth. In 2012, its first year sell- with their first child. At Beverly Hills, New York City
The Power
of Empowerment
Forbes Insights and Northwestern Mutual asked women about what they
want to achieve, how confident they are in attaining those goals and what
makes them feel empowered. Here’s what they said:
ATTAINABLE GOALS
Percentage of respondents who say they are very likely to achieve these goals
Tonia Jenny
Book Editor
Achieving Being able to leave wealth
money/wealth for future generations
Least Attainable
27% 26%
ILLUSTRATIONS BY ANTHONY MUCIA
Source: Based on a Forbes Insights and Northwestern Mutual survey of 807 women in the United States. Forbes Insights conducts primary research designed
to support both strategic and tactical decisions for business executives.
Northwestern Mutual is the marketing name for The Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company (NM), Milwaukee, WI, and its subsidiaries.
Level of
Knowledge
brella brand positioning itself as the “It felt massive, so I was a little re- bringing that classic, all-American
go-to for all things eco-friendly, safe served at first. She jumped into it lunch the PB&J sandwich to nursery
and nontoxic. headfirst.” school. Too many kids had severe nut
A lightbulb went off for both of She went back to Brian Lee in allergies. “Autism, Tourette’s, chronic
them. Pretty soon Alba and Gavigan 2011 armed with data on the rise of allergies and asthmas and celiac dis-
were polishing off wine on nights childhood diseases and a much more ease—all of this stuff is on the rise,”
and weekends, cooking up a busi- concise ten-page pitch deck. Lee’s Lee says. “I almost had this moment
ness plan and buying up Web do- mind had changed—not coincidental- of awakening. Why aren’t we doing
main names with the word “hon- ly, he had recently become horrified something about this?”
est” in them. Through her husband, when his young son was banned from Lee got on board with Alba and
she met Web entrepreneur Brian Gavigan that year, bringing with
Lee, a trained attorney who had hit it him a fourth cofounder in Sean
big with LegalZoom.com, an online
legal-documentation service he co-
Movie Star Kane, who’d spent a decade sell-
ing discount products at Price-
founded with Robert Shapiro of O.J. Turns Mogul grabber.com. Lee and Alba seed-
Simpson infamy. THE HONEST COMPANY’S $1 BILLION ed their new startup to the tune
“I made some introductions VALUATION BEATS OUT THE LIFETIME of about $6 million, with anoth-
DOMESTIC BOX OFFICE OF ALL HER
for her and said good luck,” says MOVIES, COMBINED. er investor, according to a source
Lee, who looked at Alba’s 50-page close to the deal. (The compa-
PowerPoint in 2009 but didn’t bite. CAMP NOWHERE – 1994 ny would not comment on initial
$10 mil
He says now he was simply tied up investments or its founders’ cur-
NEVER BEEN KISSED – 1999
launching subscription shoe site $55 mil rent personal stakes.) The group
ShoeDazzle.com with then partner IDLE HANDS – 1999 called their new firm The Hon-
Kim Kardashian. $4 mil est Company, as a nod to its val-
HONEY – 2003
Meanwhile, Alba was busy with $30 mil ues and transparent ingredients.
her Hollywood career, starring in the SIN CITY – 2005
likes of Valentine’s Day, Little Fockers $74 mil ONE WALL OF THE HONEST
and Machete, all of which premiered FANTASTIC FOUR – 2005 Company’s L.A. office show-
$155 mil
in 2010. INTO THE BLUE – 2005
room best represents its roots.
Alba kept Gavigan on her pay- $19 mil On it you’ll find rows and rows
roll as a consultant. By 2011 she had FANTASTIC FOUR: RISE OF of diapers, mounted, matted and
THE SILVER SURFER – 2007
turned herself into an expert on con- $132 mil framed. Each has a whimsical
sumer products and traveled to Wash- GOOD LUCK CHUCK – 2007 design on the butt. There’s one
ington, D.C. to lobby for updated leg- $35 mil with a purple-and-green leopard
AWAKE – 2007
islation. She was—and is—particularly $14 mil print; there are juicy pink straw-
focused on reforming the 1976 Toxic THE EYE – 2008 berries and a stars-and-stripes
Substances Control Act, which has al- $31 mil print perfect for baby’s first
lowed more than 80,000 chemicals THE LOVE GURU – 2008 Fourth of July.
$32 mil
to remain in household products un- LITTLE FOCKERS – 2010
These are the diapers that
tested. Only 5 are regulated by the En- $148 mil gave The Honest Company its
vironmental Protection Agency; only VALENTINE’S DAY – 2010 start and indeed still account
$110 mil
11 are banned from consumer goods. for a large proportion of sales:
MACHETE – 2010
(In Europe that figure is more than $27 mil About 75% of revenues still
1,300.) “Enough people have to get SPY KIDS: ALL THE TIME IN comes from online commerce,
THE WORLD 4D – 2011
sick or die from a certain ingredient $39 mil and the majority of that is from
or chemical before it’s pulled from the ESCAPE FROM PLANET the company’s $79.95 monthly
EARTH – 2013
marketplace,” says Alba. $57 mil
bundles of diapers and wipes.
For Alba’s husband, Cash Warren, MACHETE KILLS – 2013
During Alba’s days scour-
it was a lesson in climbing a steep $8 mil ing supermarkets for safe baby
learning curve. “I didn’t know much SIN CITY: A DAME TO KILL detergent, she often wondered
FOR – 2014
about all the chemicals that were in $14 mil why no one in the retail or fash-
our consumer products, so she edu- TOTAL: ion world had yet come up with
$993 mil
cated me on this epidemic,” he says. seasonal designs for diapers. “I
SOURCE: BOX OFFICE MOJO.
Northwestern Mutual knows what it takes to succeed both on your balance sheet and
in your life. It takes the right financial partner who cares as much about your future as
you do, encouraging you to do the little things that add up over time, protect what
you’ve earned and truly achieve financial security.
You and Northwestern Mutual—stronger together.
Northwestern Mutual is the marketing name for The Northwestern Mutual Life Insurance Company (NM), Milwaukee, WI, and its subsidiaries.
P O W E R W O M E N
kind of want them to be cute,” she Series A that raised $27 million. Two things stand out on their
says. “And the natural diapers: Why That turned out to be just the start. short-term agenda. First, internation-
do they have to look like your baby’s As the diaper business proved its ef- al expansion. Honest products will
wearing a brown bag?” ficacy, Alba and her team—Lee serves debut in South Korea later this year
After having her first daugh- as the CEO—reverted to the origi- and in China possibly in 2016. And
ter, Honor, in the summer of 2008 nal concept: a single brand that car- then, most likely next year, a public
(in 2012 she had another daughter, ried its credibility across all products offering, according to people famil-
Haven), Alba also found herself rou- in the nontoxic universe. Raising a iar with the company. Such a move
tinely running out of diapers in the total of $127 million through August provides a war chest, though that
middle of the night. She was toy- 2014, The Honest Company has been doesn’t seem to be an issue at pres-
ing with the idea of a subscription able to create more products in dif- ent. “The company’s outperforming,”
service for nontoxic household es- ferent categories—dish soap, kitchen says General Catalyst’s Neil Sequeira.
sentials—cleaning products, maybe cleaner, detergent, nipple balm, multi- “They have pretty much unlimit-
diapers, too. But this was long before vitamins and even nursery furniture. ed access to capital and a very strong
monthly cosmetics-sampling startup balance sheet.” Liquidity, then, would
Birchbox launched, and that business LEE, ALBA AND THEIR TEAM in- seem to be the key driver.
model didn’t really exist. tended for The Honest Company to With a big payday in the offing,
Creating safe, chemical-free, non- remain online, where its revenues Alba remains an active presence,
toxic consumer goods from scratch grew steadily thanks in part to the much to the delight of her venture
without the infrastructure of, say, a capital backers, who had built-
Procter & Gamble or a Kimberly-Clark in celebrity endorsement from a
was a prospect that would cost way “Enough people cofounder. “I think they realized
more than even the $6 million seed have to get sick or they got a lot of bang for their buck,”
fund. So they went looking to get ven- die from a certain Lee says. Alba still makes the oc-
ture capital into the diaper business. ingredient or casional film, but she makes quick
“That’s the only thing we pitched,” says work of it. She shot her scenes for
Lee. “It was very strategic as we knew
chemical before the upcoming movie adaptation of
that was the way into your home.” it’s pulled from the hit series Entourage in three hours.
Lee was a known quantity among marketplace.” In 2016 she’ll appear in a sequel to
the venture capital firms of Palo Alto. crime-caper mainstay Jason Sta-
Even so, The Honest Company took tham’s The Mechanic. “It took ten
a gamble approaching backers with- actress “trying to yell from the roof- days in November and ten days in
out having made even a dollar of rev- tops,” as she describes her marketing January, and I got to be in a fun ac-
enue. “They hadn’t shipped yet when efforts. (She has over 5 million Insta- tion movie,” she smiles.
we invested, so it was a leap of faith gram followers on her own account.) Such efficiency is important
we don’t normally take in e-com- But almost as soon as they when you have 130 customer service
merce businesses,” says Neil Sequei- launched, high-end mommy-and-baby representatives to train in all things
ra, a managing director at General boutiques with cutesy names (The Honest. All told, there are now 350
Catalyst Partners. Pump Station in west L.A. and The employees at two offices.
He was a big believer in online- Upper Breast Side in Manhattan) While Alba doesn’t have the time
only models, having backed pioneer- cottoned on to The Honest Company, to travel the country educating re-
ing eyeglasses e-tailer Warby Parker. asking whether Lee and Alba had tailers, she now has the next best
He also liked the subscription aspect considered selling the brand in brick- person on her staff: her mother. A
of the business: It took much of the and-mortar stores. Stock in these year ago Cathy Alba came on board
pain—and expense—out of acquiring mom-and-pop shops sold out so at The Honest Company, spend-
new customers. “Assuming they like quickly that when Costco came calling ing two weeks a month telling store
it, the big Super Bowl ads and stuff in 2013 wanting to sell baby shampoo managers at Whole Foods and Buy
become less important,” he says. Early in family-size packs, the Honest team Buy Baby outposts across the coun-
on Honest relied on Facebook for effi- relented. Since then Whole Foods, try about her daughter’s struggles
cient advertising instead of tradition- Nordstrom, Buy Buy Baby, Destina- with childhood illnesses. Cathy came
al campaigns. General Catalyst joined tion Maternity and even discount out of retirement to take the gig. “I’m
Lightspeed Venture Partners and In- behemoth Target have started selling very much like Jessica,” she says. “All
stitutional Venture Partners in a 2012 The Honest Company’s wares. or nothing.” F
The
Modest
Tycoon
SHI International is the largest woman-owned
business in America, and it’s made Thai Lee a
billionaire. She’d rather you not call her that.
BY DAVID M. EWALT
T
hai Lee drives herself to work
and parks in the middle of the
lot, even when there are spaces
open up front. Her small office
sits right off a cubicle farm
filled with junior employees.
There’s no executive assistant
at the door keeping interrup-
tions away; she doesn’t have
JONATHAN KOZOWYK FOR FORBES
ones. And it’s made her a billionaire. handed me a printout of her 19 direct because of her accent and less-than-
You probably haven’t heard of reports. On it she had jotted down perfect fluency in English. “I was de-
her or her company, but under Lee’s each person’s start date and writ- termined to avoid any and all courses
management SHI International has ten “18 yrs avg tenure” at the bottom. that required writing and speaking in
grown from a failing software resell- Company marketing materials like to class,” she laughs, “because I was de-
er with five employees and about as boast about SHI’s sky-high 99% cus- termined to get the best grade possi-
many customers into one of the big- tomer retention rate. Because SHI is ble. I knew then that the best chance
gest and best-regarded IT providers private, it’s impossible to verify, butof success for me was to start my own
in the world, with $6 billion in sales the point is clear: Lee is obsessed business, because after I x-ed out all
and 3,000 employees worldwide. with keeping her customers and em- the professions I could not be suc-
Selling everything from third-party ployees happy. cessful in, that’s what I was left with.”
hardware and software to custom “It’s culture at this point,” she Lee chased her American dream
applications and consulting servic- says. “We have no executive parking. with serious intent. After college
es, SHI has amassed 17,500 custom- … We don’t have a special executive she returned to Korea and worked at
ers, including the likes of Boeing, compensation plan. We try to make auto parts maker Daesung Industrial
Johnson & Johnson and AT&T. It has sure that everybody feels valued.” In Co. in Seoul in order to raise enough
posted positive sales growth every this social compact they, in turn, cre-money to get an M.B.A. A few years
year of its existence and exceeded ate value. later she was back in Massachusetts
15% growth in 2014. While the pri- and in 1985 graduated from Harvard
vate company won’t reveal prof- THAI LEE’S FIRST FAMILY—the one Business School.
its, Lee, who is CEO, suggests its net she was born into, that Afterward she
margins are approximately 3%. is—moved around a lot chose jobs to help pre-
FORBES’ most conservative es- when she was little. She “I allotted pare her for inevita-
timates place the value of SHI just was born in Bangkok, myself ble entrepreneurship:
above $1.8 billion, and that makes Thailand. Her father, a some two years at Proc-
56-year-old Lee—who owns 60% prominent Korean econ- time: My ter & Gamble working
of the company—one of just 18 self- omist, traveled the world entire on such brands as Al-
made female billionaires in the U.S. promoting his country’s ways and Crest, then
Not that she’d ever brag. On the con- postwar development
20s, I was two years at American
trary, when FORBES first contact- plan. Lee, the second going to Express. “I knew that
ed her about appearing on our list of three daughters and learn all I wanted to prepare
of wealthiest self-made women, she one son, spent most of about myself, so I allotted
told her communications team to do her childhood in Korea. business.” myself some time: My
whatever it could to get her name re- From an early age she de- entire 20s, I was going
moved. When she found out FORBES veloped a reputation as to learn all about busi-
would proceed without her blessing, thoughtful, studious and ness,” Lee says. By age
she grudgingly agreed to this inter- prepared for any eventuality. 30, the long-term plan went, she’d
view. Later Lee argued unconvinc- “If you’re in Korea, you have to be running her own company. By 40
ingly that our estimate was too high. think about what would happen if she’d have a husband and kids.
And then she deflected any praise. North Korea invades,” says Celeste As it happened, the husband
“A dollar amount could never ac- Lee, her younger sister, who works came first. In 1989 Lee married Leo
curately convey the respect and ad- at SHI, “and whenever we played to- Koguan, a Columbia-educated lawyer
miration I have for the employees of gether, she was always planning our who shared her dream of entrepre-
SHI,” she says. survival. She’s the most focused per- neurship—and later that year spotted
Very hokey but also very central son I’ve ever met.” an opportunity to make it come true.
to how Lee has built her fortune. She In her teens Thai and her older Lautek, a struggling software com-
works in an industry where customers sister, Margaret, moved to America, pany in New Jersey, had a tiny divi-
frequently dump vendors as soon as where they lived with a family friend, sion called Software House that sold
someone else offers a lower price. Cod- attended high school in Amherst, business licenses to run programs
dling her employees, who in turn cater Mass. and then enrolled at Amherst like Lotus 1-2-3. It was down to only
to customers, is the key to her success. College. Lee eventually earned a dou- a few customers, but some of them
When I visited Lee’s office in Som- ble major B.A. in biology and eco- were big (like AT&T), and the cou-
erset, N.J. on a recent Friday, she nomics—subjects she chose, in part, ple perceived lots of potential value
in its relationships with vendors (like over-the-top customer service. puter stuff in a box—won their loy-
IBM). Koguan and Lee paid less than “We had no inventory, very little alty and their money. “Tech ven-
$1 million for that business, funding money, no market presence, no mar- dors and resellers have a propensi-
the purchase with savings and a few keting, no promotion,” says Melis- ty for being flipped quite frequently,”
small loans. Soon after, they rechris- sa Graham, SHI’s vice president of says Anthony Andreou, a leader at
tened the company with a name that new business development, a former Dun & Bradstreet, which has been an
reflected Lee’s global ambitions: Soft- Lautek staffer who became SHI’s SHI customer for over 15 years. “But
ware House International. first hire. “What we did have was when you have a good vendor that
The marriage didn’t survive, someone who wanted to make this provides great service, there’s stabili-
but the partnership still exists. thing work. Thai always had her eye ty and less of a reason to switch.”
The couple, who have two teenage on what would make SHI relevant.” Andreou credits Lee’s manage-
children, divorced in 2002, but From the start Lee told her staff ment as a key reason that Dun &
Koguan remains nonexecutive they could make their own decisions Bradstreet stays with SHI. “Thai is a
chairman and owns the remain- about how to manage their custom- remarkable leader,” he says. “She is
ing 40% stake in SHI. (FORBES re- very smart, very focused and humble.
ers. “She took aside the outside sales
quested to speak to Koguan, but SHI force, the ones going out and win- She really empowers her employ-
declined. Other attempts to reach ning new business, and told them, ees and allows them the scope and
him were unsuccessful.) ‘You are the president of your com- the breadth to serve their custom-
pany,’” says Graham. “If you are re-ers well.”
LEE NEVER HAD A specific interest sponsible for a customer, you own Even in the early days of the com-
in technology. When she was in col- that. Being empowered that way, it’s pany, Lee knew that customers would
lege and deciding to start a business, very important.” notice if SHI went out of its way to
she “wasn’t thinking of technology at Treating customers like partners— solve their problems—and that’s how
all.” At that time personal computers instead of just consumers of com- the company would expand.
weren’t common, so her ex- Graham remembers a Fri-
posure to them was limited. day afternoon when one of
She’s never been the early- Foreign Born SHI’s largest software cus-
adopter type. NEARLY A THIRD OF AMERICA’S 50 RICHEST SELF- tomers called and said it
“Actually, I proba- MADE WOMEN WERE BORN ABROAD. LIKE THAI was spending millions a year
bly would be the last per- LEE, THESE EXECUTIVES AND ENTREPRENEURS buying computer hardware
son,” she says. “Gadgets BUILT THEIR FORTUNES AFTER MOVING TO THE U.S. from someone else—but the
have to provide real utility. company liked SHI better, so
NAME NET WORTH PLACE OF BIRTH
I have to extract more out it wanted to switch vendors
of it than I would put into Jin Sook Chang $3.05 BIL SOUTH KOREA and buy computers from
learning about it.” It might Peggy Cherng $1.5 BIL BURMA SHI, too. Starting Monday.
be, she says, that she ap- “I don’t know that we’d
Neerja Sethi $1.1 BIL INDIA
proaches technology in a ever sold a computer before,
way that’s more common Thai Lee $1.1 BIL THAILAND but they had a very good re-
among women—she’s prac- Eren Ozmen $900 MIL TURKEY lationship with us,” says Gra-
tical and wants to see the ham. “So some of us went to
Christel DeHaan $900 MIL GERMANY
technology prove its util- Thai and said, ‘Here’s our
ity before she buys in. (It’s Weili Dai $720 MIL CHINA opportunity.’ ”
one of only a few times in Safra Catz $525 MIL ISRAEL Lee told the team to go
our conversations that she for it. “A bunch of people
Jane Hsiao $510 MIL TAIWAN
acknowledges her gender worked all weekend to figure
might distinguish her from Jayshree Ullal $470 MIL U.K. out how we were going to do
other CEOs.) Diane von Fürstenberg $450 MIL BELGIUM that,” says Graham. Fifteen
It’s a mind-set that has years later that company is
Sonia Gardner $380 MIL MOROCCO
worked in her company’s now one of SHI’s top three
favor, especially in the early Kit Crawford $360 MIL CANADA customers.
days, when SHI’s biggest Sachiko Kuno $330 MIL JAPAN “Doing things we never
differentiator wasn’t cut- did before, that was excit-
Adi Tatarko $300 MIL ISRAEL
ting-edge technology but ing,” she says. “We were
$872_ORFDORIĆFH
Some discounts, coverages, payment plans and features are not available in all states or all GEICO companies. GEICO is a registered serv
ice mark of Government Employees Insurance Company, Washington, D.C. 20076; a Berkshire Hathaway Inc. subsidiary. © 2015 GEICO
America’s Richest
Self-Made Women
FORBES has compiled its first ever list of the nation’s top 50 most successful
women as measured by their net worths. The exclusive freshman class
includes entrepreneurs, CEOs, entertainers, designers and even an author.
PORTRAITS, CLOCKWISE FROM TOP LEFT: MICHAEL CHO, ENRIQUE MOREIRO, KEVIN WHIPPLE, PATRICK WELSH
cheaper and less painful than other tests, it is now Chief merchandising officer with director Tyler Per-
available in 41 Theranos labs at Walgreens. Theranos of $4.4 billion (sales) For- ry. Her movie imprint,
raised $400 million from venture investors. Company ever 21, fast fashion chain Harpo Films, copro-
was valued at $9 billion last year, which made her the that she owns with her hus- duced MLK Jr. biopic
youngest self-made female billionaire in the world. band, Don. South Korean Selma. Still makes
immigrants, they opened their first 900-square-foot money from spinoffs
shop in 1984. They now operate over 680. like Dr. Oz.
2. Diane Hendricks
$3.7 BILLION
AGE: 68. RESIDENCE: AFTON, WIS. 6. Judy Faulkner
Owner and chairman of $4.8 $2.6 BILLION AGE: 71. RESIDENCE: MADISON, WIS.
billion (sales) ABC Supply, a Computer programmer is founder and CEO of $1.8 billion
wholesale distributor of roof- (sales) Epic Systems, which sells software used to store
ing, window and siding ma- medical information on more than half the U.S. population.
terials. She cofounded ABC Clients include Mayo Clinic and Johns Hopkins. Epic has
with her husband, Kenneth partnership with Apple to help patients share with their
(d. 2007). doctors biometrics stored in health care apps.
To compile net worths, we valued individuals’ assets, including the value of stakes in public companies, on May 15, when we locked in stock prices. We valued private
companies by speaking with an array of outside experts and conservatively comparing them with public competitors. To be eligible for this list, women had to have
substantially made their own fortunes and be U.S. citizens or permanent residents. In cases where they started businesses with, and still share with, their husbands, we’ve
assigned them half of that combined wealth. We attempted to vet these numbers with all list entrants. Some cooperated; others didn’t.
POWER
to change the financial landscape,
and it’s time we worked together
to make it happen. How can we
do it? Education that empowers.
Connections that inspire. Steps you
TO
take command of your financial
future. Because you’ve worked hard
for your money. It’s about time it
YOU.
Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC, Member NYSE, SIPC, 900 Salem Street, Smithfield, RI 02917. © 2015 FMR LLC. All rights reserved. 704111.2.0
49. Judy Sheindlin
$250 MILLION
AGE: 72. RESIDENCE: NAPLES, FLA.
Better known to fans as Judge Judy.
Her eponymous show, on air for 19 sea-
sons, is seen by 10 million viewers a day.
Only woman in her first-year law school
class of 126 in 1963, she became a fam-
ily court judge in 1982. She retired as
a supervising judge in 1996, when her
show debuted. Makes an estimated $47
million a year and recently signed new
5-year deal with CBS.
Buenos Aires-based photographer Federico Winer creates perspective-altering compositions from Google
Earth satellite images. This view of Silicon Valley indicates Zip code areas of Chinese investment in red.
startup like Peel that’s outside of its core business, not chief financial officer, Jennifer Li, right-hand woman to
to mention its core country? its billionaire CEO, Robin Li, helped lead Baidu’s rough-
In a word: smartphones. The three BAT companies ly $200 million investment in Uber at a reported $41 bil-
each monopolize a sphere of China’s desktop-style lion valuation. A search engine buying into a car-hailing
online behavior, but they risk falling behind in mobile. app doesn’t make a ton of sense on paper. No matter,
The Honorable Jessica Alba Rosalind Brewer Ina Garten GAYLE KING Chelsea Handler
Nancy Pelosi The Honest Company Sam’s Club Barefoot Contessa CBS This Morning;
O, the Oprah Magazine
Comedian, TV
Personality & Author
U.S. House of
Representatives
/VZ[LKI`4VPYH-VYILZ[OPZT\S[PNLULYH[PVUHSNH[OLYPUNVMPUÅ\LUJLYZ^PSSJVTL[VNL[OLY[VHKKYLZZ[VKH`»ZTVZ[WYLZZPUNPZZ\LZ
ECONOMIC INNOVATION
LEADERSHIP
EDUCATION
HEALTh
7RKDYHPHDQLQJIXOLPSDFWOHDGHUVPXVWVHL]HRSSRUWXQLWLHVWRHਬHFWLYHO\HQJDJHZLWKDGLYHUVHDUUD\RI
VWDNHKROGHUVWREXLOGFRPPXQLW\DURXQGDVKDUHGYLVLRQ+RZDUHWRGD\ۑVPRVWVXFFHVVIXOOHDGHUVUHGHਭQLQJ
SDWKZD\VWRSRZHU DQGKRZFDQHDFKRIXVEHिHUOHYHUDJHRXULQਮXHQFHWRLJQLWHODVWLQJFKDQJH"
Uber
1,000 $42,800
Deal Size ($mil)
FEEDING
UNICORNS Epic Games $682
Tango $1,033
Investments from the BAT ShopRunner
Snapchat
$15,000
trio increase in tandem with $667
Lyft
ever larger private funding $971
Jet $600
rounds ($4.5 billion in total) Fanatics
$3,288 Fab
for the likes of Uber, Lyft $1,173
Glu
and Snapchat. Kabam Taboola Mobile
$869
$1,032 $1,004
100
Cyanogen
$640
Post-Money Quixey Pocket Gems
Valuation ($mil) Peel $400
Snapchat $181 $300
O Baidu $860
Quixey $600
zulily $1,500
O Alibaba TrustGo Mobile Weebly
O Tencent $30 $490 Scanadu $105
Cyanogen
XValuation unavailable. $120 Whisper $229
Peel Plain
X Vanilla
Games $91 Kamcord $105
1stdibs
WhoSay $40 $439
V-Key X
10 IndoorAtlas X OUYA $72
Ark
X
Scaled Inference $49
Couple $26 X AltSpaceVR
X Tile
PandaWhale
Origami Plain Vanilla
X
Labs Games
$13 $10
Sonalight
X
Kamcord
X X
Watsi
Loom
Contacts+ $4
XKamcord Heirloom Technology SOURCES: PITCHBOOK; FORBES.
1 X X
6/2011 12/2011 6/2012 12/2012 6/2013 12/2013 6/2014 12/2014 6/2015
says Li: “Mobile development in China is exploding. Francisco-based mobile-gaming startup Kabam hit the
Baidu’s vision today is to connect people with services. road in China for his latest funding round last spring,
Uber is an example of that.” hopeful for access to that market. “Entering China is a
Plus, she needed to respond to her two rivals. As pretty complicated affair,” he says. “It operates in a very
Uber set foot in China, Tencent and Alibaba were al- different fashion than any other market in the world
ready backing two Uber clones, Didi Dache and Kuaidi because of such a strong presence of the major Chinese
Dache, respectively. Now the Chinese can hail Uber on Internet players.” For the next few months the 35-year-
their phones through Baidu Maps. The search engine old Chinese-American, who cofounded his company in
is also hoping to leverage Uber in Baidu Wallet’s uphill downtown Mountain View above a dim sum restaurant,
battle against Alibaba’s Alipay and Tencent’s WeChat sought out the BAT trio, among others, and ended up
Payment. Not to be outflanked, Tencent and Alibaba with five term sheets. “It’s a lot of dinners, a lot of bai-
merged their ride-share shops, creating a near monopo- jiu,” grins Chou, referring to a potent Chinese liquor.
ly worth $8.75 billion. And the battle rages on. By July Kabam had its number—a valuation that shot
Kevin Chou could do that math. The CEO of San it past the $1 billion “unicorn” threshold—from Alibaba,
Whether it’s an executive breakfast, a festive holiday party, or a full-scale corporate retreat, Carnegie Hall
offers new event-space options with views of Central Park and access to the Weill Terrace.
Carnegie Hall is proud to partner with Stephen STARR Events to offer artistic, specially curated dining
experiences for its clients, with bold, flavorful fare prepared from locally sourced and seasonal ingredients.
carnegiehall.org/starr | 212-903-9647
Photos: Carnegie Hall by Jeff Goldberg / Esto; May Room by PIXELLAB; Weill Terrace Room by Sofia Negron; Weill Music Room by Jennifer Taylor.
CHINA IN THE VALLEY
which plunked down $120 million for just over a 10% the first partners of Alipay’s ePass program, which en-
stake, as well as instant credibility and relationships in ables U.S. retailers to sell directly to Chinese consumers.
China. “If you don’t know who you’re working with, you “It came up afterwards, after we started to understand
can really get yourself into trouble,” says Chou. more about each other,” CEO Scott Thompson says.
Alibaba, for its part, paid the premium with a clear eye “Now it’s obvious that there’s something else we can do
on Tencent, the world’s largest gaming company, which together, and it’s likely to be a really interesting big busi-
has $7.2 billion in revenue from online gaming alone last ness at some point.”
year. The deal came with an initial commitment by Kabam Such synergies (and enormous valuations) make the
to launch ten games during the next three years through BAT troika today’s investors of choice. Silicon Valley used
Alibaba, including ones related to Hollywood blockbuster to look askance at money coming from a place where the
movies like Lord of the Rings, Hunger Games and Fast and central government blocks everything from Facebook to
Furious. Expect Alibaba to leverage its investment by using Gmail. “When Alibaba first invested, we took it with a
its PayPal clone, Alipay, for mobile micropayments and by huge grain of salt,” says Peel’s Krishnan. Now companies
promoting Kabam through the Alibaba-backed like Snapchat look eagerly to
video site Youku Tudou. “WHILE THEY China—the disappearing-mes-
“While they care about the financial re-
turns, the amount of money they put into
CARE ABOUT sage app is reportedly raising
$200 million from Alibaba,
Kabam is a rounding error,” says Chou. “They THE FINANCIAL which again seems to be target-
don’t stress out anytime when there’s a small RETURNS, THE ing Tencent, specifically its
problem.” Alibaba even organizes an annual AMOUNT OF MONEY WeChat service. No matter that
“Ali-family” party for its portfolio compa- THEY PUT IN IS A Snapchat is banned in China
nies with the hope of fostering synergies. ROUNDING ERROR.” (or that Tencent also invested
San Mateo-based ShopRunner, which raised in a 2013 round).
$206 million from Alibaba in 2013, was one of “They’re playing a global
game of domination on the
Internet,” says Patrick Riley,
founder and CEO of search
engine Ark, for which Tencent
participated in a $4.2 million
seed round. “It goes entirely
against the reputation, what
the United States thinks of Chi-
nese companies, which is just
copy-paste.” With BAT leading
the trend, other tech compa-
nies, from mobile giant Xiaomi
to Baidu rival Qihoo, are fol-
lowing in their footsteps with
smaller deals. With the right
bets in Silicon Valley, Chinese
companies can redeploy the
U.S. startups’ technology and
talent for their immediate next
steps: expansion into other
emerging economies such as
India and Brazil. Eventually
they’ll grab a piece in the satu-
TIMOTHY ARCHIBALD FOR FORBES
B
ill Nelson wasn’t looking for an more than double their original sticker price. In
investment, just a thrill. So nine fact, the GT is the only American production car
years ago the then 64-year-old built this millennium that’s an appreciating clas-
retired engineer from Asbury, N.J. sic rather than a fast, expensive used car.
went to his local Ford dealer and It’s not just 200mph top speeds but also esca-
put down $160,000 to buy the fastest and most lating prices that separate true supercars—such
expensive production car the company had as the Ferrari F40, the Porsche Carrera GT and
ever built, the Ford GT. the McLaren F1—from run-of-the-mill exotics,
“I’m a lifelong Ford guy,” he explains. “When and the Ford GT has earned its membership in
I saw that car, I absolutely had to have one.” this exclusive club.
Owning America’s first supercar has given “Ford checked off all the right boxes,” says
Nelson more than his share of adrenalized Wayne Carini, owner of Connecticut’s F40
drives on New Jersey’s back roads. And one day Motorsports and the host of Velocity’s Chasing
it will potentially deliver an impressive return Classic Cars. “It’s an iconic car.”
on his money. Buyers like Nelson aren’t so much purchasing
Earlier this year another Ford GT—one bear- 3,400 pounds of superplastic aluminum as they Coming soon: The 2017
ing an early VIN of 003—brought an astonishing are the story behind it. The GT is the successor Ford GT will deliver 600-
plus hp and is expected
$605,000 at Barrett-Jackson’s Scottsdale Auc- to one of the greatest racing cars of all time, the to have a base price near
tion. And lesser GTs routinely change hands for Le Mans-winning GT40s of the late 1960s. The $400,000.
FINAL THOUGHT
“Any customer can have a car painted any color that he wants, so long as
it is black.” —HENRY FORD
Lifetime warranty
Laser Measured
Designed in USA -
FloorLiner™ Hand crafted in Germany
Acura · Audi · BMW · Buick · Cadillac · Chevrolet · Chrysler · Dodge · Ferrari · Ford · GMC · Honda · Hummer · Hyundai · Infiniti
Accessories Available for Isuzu · Jeep · Kia · Land Rover · Lexus · Lincoln · Maserati · Mazda · Mercedes-Benz · Mercury · Mini · Mitsubishi · Nissan
Oldsmobile · Plymouth · Pontiac · Porsche · Saab · Saturn · Scion · Subaru · Suzuki · Toyota · Volkswagen · Volvo · and more!
CIGARS
10 +HUMIDOR Only 29.99 $
95
RATED
93
RATED
91 94 96 92 90
RATED RATED RATED RATED RATED (10”x8.5”x4.25”) 40 Capacity
Discover
5 Troy Ounces U.S. Mint Silver
shown at actual size!
800-385-3303
www.montgomerychandler.com
guarantee on all orders. Call for complete
offer guidelines. Montgomery Chandler
765 N. 5th Street, Silsbee, TX 77656
Chandler
ON BOATING
“You are moving at racing speed, parting the
buttery sea as with a scalpel, and waters roar by,
themselves exuberantly subdued by your powers.”
—WILLIAM F. BUCKLEY JR.
OTHER THOUGHTS FROM THAT ISSUE: “How do men act on a “The cure for
KAPUT! “The Germans have a wonderful word for it: Erneuerungs- sinking ship? Do they hold anything is
energie, the energy of economic renewal. France has Erneuerungsen- each other? Do they pass saltwater: sweat,
ergie. So do Italy, Spain, Britain—and, of course, the U.S. and Japan. around the whisky? Do they tears or the sea.”
Who doesn’t have it? West Germany. The one-time workshop miracle
has become one of Western Europe’s most sluggish economies.” cry?” —SEBASTIAN JUNGER —ISAK DINESEN
AND
TH E
CUSTOMER
REVOLUTION
IS HERE
INSIDE
Capitalizing on the Dissatisfaction Economy
C RPSDQLHVPD\UHIHUWRORVLQJFXVWRPHUVDVȊFKXUQUDWHȋ
EXWIRUFXVWRPHUVLWȇVVLPSO\WKHHQGRIWKHUHODWLRQVKLS
7KH\ VZLWFK ZLWK D IHZ FOLFNV DQG RIWHQ IRU UHDVRQV WKDW
WKH FRPSDQ\ FRXOG KDYH DYRLGHG E\ HYROYLQJ WKHLU FXVWRPHU
VHUYLFHDURXQGWKHQHHGVRIWRGD\ȇVDOZD\VFRQQHFWHGFRQVXPHUV
Both enterprises and
customers see the same
7KLVFDQKDYHVLJQLFDQWLPSOLFDWLRQVRQWKHERWWRPOLQH problem. What has to
ȏ $FFHQWXUH HVWLPDWHV WKDW WKLV Ȋ6ZLWFKLQJ (FRQRP\ȋ
SXWVXSWRWULOOLRQRIJOREDOUHYHQXHXSIRUJUDEV change is corporate
WULOOLRQLQWKH86DORQH
• Harvard Business ReviewUHSRUWVWKDWDFTXLULQJDQHZ
culture and systems.”
FXVWRPHU LV IURP YH WR WLPHV PRUH H[SHQVLYH
WKDQUHWDLQLQJDQH[LVWLQJFXVWRPHU
— Robert Tas
ȏ 5
HVHDUFK IURP %DLQ &RPSDQ\ LQGLFDWHV WKDW
693&KLHI0DUNHWLQJ2ɝFHU3HJD
LQFUHDVLQJ FXVWRPHU UHWHQWLRQ UDWHV E\ MXVW
FDQLQFUHDVHSURILWVIURPWR &RUSRUDWLRQV DUH WDNLQJ QRWLFH 7KH\ȇUH DPSOLI\LQJ WKHLU
DWWHQWLRQWRFXVWRPHUVDWLVIDFWLRQDQGVKLIWLQJSRVLWLYHFXVWRPHU
Rising Customer Frustration H[SHULHQFHVWRWKHWRSRIWKHLUSULRULW\OLVW*DUWQHUUHSRUWVWKDW
'LVFRQQHFWHG RUJDQL]DWLRQDO JRDOV DQG VLORV DUH WKH URRW RI WKH RIEXVLQHVVOHDGHUVEHOLHYHFXVWRPHUH[SHULHQFHZLOOEHWKHLU
SUREOHP)RUUHVWHUUHSRUWVWKDWWKHFXVWRPHUH[SHULHQFHJDSLV SULPDU\EDVLVIRUFRPSHWLWLRQ
DȊUHVXOWRI\HDUVRIPLVPDWFKHGPRWLYDWLRQVEHWZHHQFXVWRPHU
WHDPVDQGWHFKQRORJ\WHDPVȋ Why Can’t You Be More Like Uber?
7KH FULWLFDO PRPHQW LV WKH UVW WLPH D FXVWRPHU UDLVHV DQ ȊΖQERWKFRUSRUDWHERDUGURRPVDQGLQWDONLQJWRFRQVXPHUVZH
LVVXH$FFRUGLQJWR$FFHQWXUHRIFXVWRPHUVVDLGWKH\ZRXOG KHDUDFRPPRQTXHVWLRQȆ:K\FDQȇWRXUFRPSDQ\EHPRUHOLNH
QRWKDYHVZLWFKHGSURYLGHUVLIWKHLULVVXHKDGEHHQUHVROYHGRQ $PD]RQ =DSSRV RU 8EHU"ȇȋ VDLG 5REHUW 7DV 693 DQG &KLHI
UVW FRQWDFW 'HVSLWH WKHLU GLVVDWLVIDFWLRQ VRPH FXVWRPHUV GR 0DUNHWLQJ 2ɝFHU DW 3HJD ZKR DOVR VHUYHV RQ WKH ERDUGV RI
VWD\%XWDVLVVXHVJRXQUHVROYHGȃRUSRRUO\UHVROYHGZLWKTXLFN WKH $VVRFLDWLRQ RI 1DWLRQDO $GYHUWLVHUV WKH $G &RXQFLO DQG WKH
[HVDQGPXOWLSOHZRUNDURXQGVȃWKHLUIUXVWUDWLRQEXLOGV 0RELOH0DUNHWLQJ$VVRFLDWLRQ
ADVERTISEMENT
atisfaction Economy
Ȋ:HDUHDWDQLQHFWLRQSRLQW%RWKHQWHUSULVHV 'RQ 6FKXHUPDQ &72 DQG 93 3URGXFW 0DUNHWLQJ DW 3HJD
DQG FXVWRPHUV VHH WKH VDPH SUREOHP DQG VDPH REVHUYHGWKDWKLVFRPSDQ\ȇVJOREDOFOLHQWVDUHWDNLQJVLPLODUVWHSV
RSSRUWXQLW\ :KDW KDV WR FKDQJH LV FRUSRUDWH UHFRJQL]LQJWKDWWKHEXVLQHVVREMHFWLYHVDQGV\VWHPVGULYLQJPRVW
FXOWXUHDQGV\VWHPVȋVDLG7DV JOREDOFRPSDQLHVZHUHFUHDWHGWRVHUYHRXWGDWHGSXUSRVHV
'HVSLWH DQ DEXQGDQFH RI GDWD FRPSDQLHV DUH Ȋ7KHUH LV DQ LQKHUHQW LQWHUQDO FRQLFWȋ KH H[SODLQHG
EOLQG WR ZKDW WKHLU FXVWRPHUV UHDOO\ ZDQW HYHQ DV Ȋ0DUNHWHUV NHHS SXVKLQJ EDWFKDQGEODVW RHUV WR PHHW VKRUW
WKH\ SULRULWL]H FXVWRPHU H[SHULHQFH RYHU RWKHU WHUPJRDOV&DOOFHQWHUVDUHZRUNLQJWRJHWSHRSOHRWKHSKRQH
HQWHUSULVHLQLWLDWLYHV7KHUHLVDJUHDWFKDVPEHWZHHQ IDVWHUWRPHHWDYHUDJHKDQGOLQJWLPHJRDOV7KHFXVWRPHUȇVQHHGV
FXVWRPHUH[SHFWDWLRQVDQGFRUSRUDWHJRDOV DUHLJQRUHGȋ
-LP %XVK (93 :RUOG 6HUYLFH DW $PHULFDQ $OLJQLQJWKHFXOWXUHSURFHVVDQGWHFKQRORJ\WRZDUGDEHWWHU
([SUHVV PDGH DQ HPSKDWLF SRLQW WKDW WRGD\ȇV FXVWRPHU H[SHULHQFH UHVXOWV LQ D PHDVXUDEOH LPSDFW WR EUDQG
FXVWRPHUV EHQFKPDUN WKHLU H[SHULHQFHV DFURVV GLHUHQWLDWLRQ DQG PDUNHW VKDUH ΖWȇV ZKDW KDSSHQV ZKHQ \RX
PXOWLSOHLQGXVWULHVΖWȇVQRORQJHUJRRGHQRXJKWR WUHDWHYHU\FXVWRPHUDVLIVKHZDV\RXUȊUVWFXVWRPHUȋ
EHWKHOHDGHULQMXVW\RXUFDWHJRU\
Customer Expectations
vs. Legacy Realities It’s no longer good
'HVSLWH DQ DOUHDG\ VWHUOLQJ UHSXWDWLRQ $PHULFDQ
([SUHVV ZDQWHG WR GR HYHQ PRUH WR LPSURYH
enough to be the best
FXVWRPHU H[SHULHQFH 7KURXJK WKHLU VWUDWHJLF in a particular industry,
LQLWLDWLYH Ȋ5HODWLRQVKLS &DUHȋ $PHULFDQ ([SUHVV
ORRNHG DW HYHU\WKLQJ WKURXJK WKH H\HV RI WKHLU
you need to be the best
FXVWRPHUV DGMXVWLQJ SHUIRUPDQFH .3ΖV DQG
WHFKQRORJ\WRVXSSRUWWKHLUQHZPLVVLRQ&XVWRPHUVDWLVIDFWLRQ
in the world.”
VFRUHVKDYHWULSOHGGHPRQVWUDWLQJWKHLPSDFWRIDOLJQLQJQRWMXVW
—Jim Bush
SURFHVVEXWFRUSRUDWHFXOWXUHDURXQGWKHLUFXVWRPHUV
(93:RUOG6HUYLFH$PHULFDQ([SUHVV
OCBC Bank in Singapore, ranked as one of the world’s strongest banks by Bloomberg, has
SXWUVWFXVWRPHUWKLQNLQJLQWRDFWLRQ7KHLUSURFHVVIRUDFXVWRPHUWRRSHQDQHZDFFRXQW
KDGEDOORRQHGWRWDVNVZLWKDKHDY\UHOLDQFHRQSDSHUIRUPV&XVWRPHUDEDQGRQPHQWDQG
FRVWVZHUHKLJK6DWLVIDFWLRQVFRUHVZHUHORZ
ΖQVWHDGRIDTXLFN[E\DGGLQJQHZGLJLWDOWRROVWRWKHROGSURFHVV2&%&WRRNDVWHSEDFN
DQGUHDUFKLWHFWHGWKHH[SHULHQFHDURXQGWKHFXVWRPHU)URPEDQNGHVLJQWRVRIWZDUHWRKRZ
FXVWRPHUVDQGEDQNHUVZRUNWRJHWKHUHYHU\WKLQJZDVYLHZHGWKURXJKWKHFXVWRPHUOHQV
7RGD\WDVNVKDYHEHHQFROODSVHG$VKDUHGVFUHHQH[SHULHQFHHQDEOHVWKHFXVWRPHU
DQGEDQNHUWRZRUNVLGHE\VLGHIURPWKHVWDUW7KHH[SHULHQFHLVJXLGHGVRHYHU\SURJUHVVLYH
VWHSLVSHUVRQDOL]HGWRWKHFXVWRPHUȇVQHHGV
$FFRXQWDFWLYDWLRQVDQGWKHLU1HW3URPRWHU6FRUHKDYHULVHQVLJQLFDQWO\7KHDSSURDFKLV
QRZDPDMRUVHOOLQJSRLQWDQGGLHUHQWLDWRUIRU2&%&
ADVERTISEMENT
Not only are we retaining ((ȇV XVH RI SUHGLFWLYH DQDO\WLFV DQG QH[WEHVWDFWLRQ
RHUV KDYH HQDEOHG WKH FRPSDQ\ WR TXDGUXSOH WKH QXPEHU
the right customers, we’re RI DFFHSWHG VDOHV RHUV WULSOH UHWDLQHG FXVWRPHU YDOXH DQG
VXEVWDQWLDOO\UHGXFHVXEVFULEHUUHWHQWLRQFRVWV
retaining more of them and 7HFKQRORJ\ WKDW OHYHUDJHV GDWD IURP WUDQVDFWLRQV
growing their value while LQWHUDFWLRQV SURGXFWV FDOO FHQWHU LQTXLULHV ORFDWLRQ DQG RWKHU
LQSXWV WR OHDUQ UHQH DQG SHUVRQDOL]H UHVSRQVHV IRU HDFK
we do it.” FXVWRPHU GULYHV HQKDQFHG H[SHULHQFHV )RUUHVWHUȇV 'RW\
GHVFULEHV WKH DSSURDFK DV D Ȋ&RQWH[WXDO 0DUNHWLQJ (QJLQHȋ
—Suzanne Woolley WKDW LSV WUDGLWLRQDO &50 XSVLGH GRZQ (QWHUSULVHV DQWLFLSDWH
Head of Customer Base Management, EE FXVWRPHUVȇ QHHGV UDWKHU WKDQ UHDFW HQDEOLQJ WKHP WR GHOLYHU
YDOXHLQWKHPRPHQW
ADVERTISEMENT
Safelite AutoGlassLVWKHOHDGLQJSURYLGHURIYHKLFOHJODVVUHSDLUDQGUHSODFHPHQWVHUYLFHVWR
PRUHWKDQRI86GULYHUVLQDOOVWDWHVΖWVFRQWDFWFHQWHUVKDQGOHPRUHWKDQFDOOV
HDFKGD\
7RVHUYHLWVFXVWRPHUVEHWWHU6DIHOLWHGHYHORSHGDPRELOHDSSOLFDWLRQWRȊWUHDWHYHU\
FXVWRPHUDVLIWKH\ZHUHWKHRQO\FXVWRPHUWKH\ZLOOVHUYHWKDWGD\ȋ7KHDSSOLFDWLRQVWUHDPOLQHV
FRRUGLQDWLRQEHWZHHQFXVWRPHUVFXVWRPHUVHUYLFHUHSVDQGWHFKQLFLDQVZKRSURYLGHVHUYLFHLQ
WKHHOG%RWKWHFKQLFLDQVDQGFXVWRPHUVKDGDUROHLQLWVGHVLJQ
7KHDSSJLYHVWHFKQLFLDQVLQIRUPDWLRQQHHGHGWRPDNHUHSDLUVLQFOXGLQJPDSVWRWKH
FXVWRPHUȇVORFDWLRQ&XVWRPHUVJHWWUDQVSDUHQF\LQWRWKHVWDWXVRIWKHLUUHTXHVW7KH\FRQUP
WKHZRUNRUGHURQOLQHJHWDPHVVDJHRQWKHWHFKQLFLDQȇVH[SHFWHGDUULYDOWLPHDQGVLJQWR
FRPSOHWHWKHSURFHVVRQWKHWHFKQLFLDQȇVPRELOHGHYLFH
7KHDSSKDVFUHDWHGFRVWVDYLQJVE\HOLPLQDWLQJSDSHUIRUPVDQGKDVJLYHQ6DIHOLWHJUHDWHU
H[LELOLW\LQDGMXVWLQJZRUNUHSDLURUGHUVRQWKH\ΖWDOVRJLYHVFXVWRPHUVDPRUHFRQVLVWHQW
H[SHULHQFHWKDWKDVUDLVHG6DIHOLWHȇV1HW3URPRWHU6FRUHIURPWR
YOU NEED TO
ANTICIPATE WHAT’S
RIGHT FOR CUSTOMERS.
CAN SALESFORCE?
PEGA CAN.
3HJD DSSOLFDWLRQV DUH GHVLJQHG WR KDQGOH WKH PRVW GHPDQGLQJ HQWHUSULVHOHYHO &50
®
UHTXLUHPHQWV6WUHDPOLQH\RXUEXVLQHVVFRQQHFWFXVWRPHUVHRUWOHVVO\DFURVVFKDQQHOV
DQGDGDSWWRFKDQJLQJUHTXLUHPHQWVDWWKHVSHHGRIEXVLQHVV6HHZK\3HJDLVUDWHGDVD
OHDGHUIRU&50VXLWHVIRUODUJHRUJDQL]DWLRQVLQWKHODWHVW)RUUHVWHU:DYH UHSRUW
TM