Professional Documents
Culture Documents
What criteria are implied in the standards and understandings regardless of the task specifics?
What qualities must student work demonstrate to signify the standards were met?
Use mathematical and/or computational Students must be able to interpret graphs, use them
representations to support explanations of factors to explain limiting factors, understand carrying
that affect carrying capacity of ecosystems at capacity and limiting factors, understand the
different scales. concepts at different scales of populations.
Through what authentic performance task will students demonstrate understanding?
Task Overview: Using their knowledge gained from the African Lions: Modeling Population activity, students will
work in groups to model the reintroduction of wolves into Yellowstone National Park to explain the density-
dependent and density-independent limiting factors that affected the wolves’ population growth and carrying
capacity. Students will use data collected by the National Park Service and will research the types of limiting
factors present in Yellowstone. Then, students will construct a model that includes a graph of wolf population
growth, and an explanation of the various factors that limit this growth, using labeled drawings and arrows to
show these ecological relationships. Students will then peer review each other’s models, and then revise as
needed. This model can then be further refined later in the unit when students learn about ecological disturbances
and human impacts on ecosystems.
What student products and performances will provide evidence of desired understandings?
Model includes a labeled graph of the Yellowstone wolf
The product will be the initial model and revised
model after peer reviewing. Later in the unit, population growth over time, as well as labeled pictures
students will further refine the model and this will with arrows to show relationships between biotic and
be used as evidence of understanding as well. abiotic factors that represent limiting factors.
By what criteria will student products and performances be evaluated?
Student groups’ models will be graded on a holistic Students will need to include the components of
modeling rubric as well as on a collaboration rubric the model, a caption for their graph, precisely
since students worked in groups. Students will be show the relationships between the
given an analytic rubric to use for self-assessment components, describing cause and effect, and
throughout the completion of the assessment, and
connect to scientific theory of population
will be used to monitor progress and provide
feedback.
dynamics.
Yellowstone Wolves Model Components
❏ Labeled graph with caption
❏ At least three (3) density-dependent limiting factors
❏ At least two (2) density-independent limiting factors
❏ Carrying capacity of the Yellowstone wolves
Student Names: Period:
YELLOWSTONE WOLVES MODELING RUBRIC
Advanced (3) Developing (2) Needs Improvement (1) Score
Model • Clearly labels and defines ALL • Labels and defines MOST of the • Components of the model are missing
components components of the model components of the model or improperly labeled
(see list above) • Graph is clearly and accurately l abeled • Graph is MOSTLY labeled clearly and • Graph is largely missing or improperly
• Graph type is appropriate for purpose accurately labeled
• Graph type not appropriate for purpose
Relationships • Clearly illustrates relationships • Adequately illustrates relationships • Inadequately illustrates relationships
between between components of the model between components of the model between components of the model or
components of • Accurately explains the cause and • Reasonably explains the cause and missing relationships
the model effect between limiting factors and wolf effect between limiting factors and wolf • Incoherently explains the cause and
population growth and carrying capacity population growth and carrying capacity effect between limiting factors and wolf
population growth and carrying capacity
Connections to • Accurately connects the model to • Adequately connects the model to • Inaccurately connects the model to
scientific theory scientific principles of population scientific principles of population scientific principles
and limitations dynamics and ecological relationships dynamics and ecological relationships • Model is unable to be transferable to
• Model is transferable to make • Model has potential to be transferable make predictions in other scenarios
predictions in other scenarios to make predictions in other scenarios • Inadequately describes the limitations
• Clearly outlines the limitations of the • Adequately describes the limitations of of the model or missing
model the model
Notes: Total:
Student Name: Period:
YELLOWSTONE WOLVES: HOLISTIC RUBRIC
1 2 3 4
❏ The product does not show ❏ The product shows a ❏ The product shows a ❏ The product shows a clear
an understanding of the developing or partial reasonable understanding and accurate
cause and effect understanding of the cause of the cause and effect understanding of the cause
relationship between and effect relationship relationship between and effect relationship
limiting factors and the between limiting factors limiting factors and the between limiting factors
wolf population growth and the wolf population wolf population growth and the wolf population
and carrying capacity. growth and carrying and carrying capacity. growth and carrying
capacity. capacity.
❏ The product contains FEW ❏ The product contains
essential components to ❏ The product contains MOST essential ❏ The product contains ALL
be considered a strong and SOME essential components to be essential components to
useful model. components to be considered a strong and be considered an
considered a strong and useful model. exceptional and useful
❏ The student rarely useful model. model.
demonstrated ❏ The student demonstrated
collaboration skills, ❏ The student attempted to strong collaboration skills, ❏ The student demonstrated
organization skills, and demonstrate collaboration organization skills, and exceptional collaboration
self-regulation skills during skills, organization skills, self-regulation skills during skills, organization skills,
the assessment process. and self-regulation skills MOST of the assessment and self-regulation skills
during the assessment process. THROUGHOUT the
process. assessment process.
Notes:
Overall Score: