You are on page 1of 23

CHAPTER I

Introduction

Background of the study

Islamic economy is one of the fastest growing segments worldwide that estimated to be

worth S3 trillion in 2021. Halal food is the largest pillar, where Muslim spent $1.17 trillion in

2015. The figures encourage many market players to enter to this market. However, Halal goods

market is some extent is different from other industries due to the Islamic culture and traditions.

Islam as a religion that has influence on different aspects of its followers requires Muslims to

follow the specific law, which is known as Shariah. According to the Shariah, Muslims should

follow the specific procedure to prepare their daily meals in order to make it acceptable to eat or

consume in Islamic terms to make it Halal. Halal market is expanding rapidly in recent decades,

as the population of Muslims has reached around 1.8 billion.

Contrasting to values of Islamic market is the modern world which increasingly

concerned with the process of providing products and services to people who want to satisfy man

(Sharif, 1996). It is possible to meet all basic human needs completely. Basic human needs as

human beings are not increased. The exchange is the heart of conventional marketing.

Traditionally the exchange is regarded as the central concept of marketing (Bagozzi, 1975; Hunt,

1976). But in the process of this exchange, the customer is free to choose the type of goods and

services; even there are no restrictions for suppliers. In conventional marketing, alcohol, magic,

etc. also exchanged if it maximizes profits and utilities. No matter if the goods are harmful or

beneficial to the buyer. If something has economic utility can be exchanged in the market.

1
Pursuing the production and exchange of products and services are not guided by ethics (code of

conduct) in the form of a real, though, the concept of social marketing, a little attention to social

welfare has indicated.

This study aims to show and distinguish the role impact of Halal management on

business performance of Muslim owned establishments and its increasing market in the industry.

Islam Religion sees business activities as an important resource for someone to make a living

during this process in accordance with Islamic teachings related to the proper ways to do

business. Allah ordained Prophet Muhammad to be a successful businessman before his

prophetic life (Antonio, 2007). Because Islam is the way of life, a code of conduct marketing

should be guided by the Quran and Hadith, which are the two main sources of reference for

Muslims in order to succeed in life and hereafter. Islamic perspective guarantees the important

things in the field of global business for several reasons. First, Islam provides a framework that

forms the moral and ethical behavior of the growing number of Muslim consumers worldwide.

Second, an increasing number of Muslim population represent some of the most affluent

consumers in the world. Third, there has been an increase in the level of foreign investment in

Muslim countries in recent years. Fourth, there is a growing momentum towards the

establishment of Muslim trading zone (Saeed et al, 2001). Islam is a comprehensive way of life

that provides rules for everything including commercial activities (Arham, 2010). Halal

management plays a key role in an Islamic business’s sales, market and over-all performance.

Theoretical Framework

Purchasing is an imperative marketing discipline in defining the buyer-supplier

relationship, alsoknown as reverse marketing (Biemans & Brand, 1995; Leenders & Blenkhorn,
2
1988) or backward integration (Kraljic, 1983). There is prospective to build up an overall ethical

(food) brand by harnessing Islamic values and attributes like animal welfare, health,

sustainability, less waste, fair working conditions (El Garah et al., 2012).

Delener (1994) states that religious factor is one of the most important aspects of

culture that influences the behaviour of consumers. This is because religiousity is an important

value in the individual user's cognitive structure, and therefore has an impact on one's behaviour.

Studies have shown that purchase of halal products is not solely based on the product's

functionality, taste or price of the product, but the denominator of religious values of a customer

is a consideration for the purchase. There are also previous studies from various researchers

focusing on religious-related studies which show that religiosity influences the purchase pattern

and can influence consumer attitudes and behaviours in general (Delener, 1994; Pettinger et al.,

2004), and food purchasing decisions and eating habits in particular (Mennell, Murcott & Van

Otterloo, 1992; Steptoe & Pollard, 1995; Swanson, 1996; Shatenstein & Ghadirian, 1997; Asp,

1999; Mullen, Williams & Hunt, 2000; Blackwell, Miniard & Engel, 2001). Other studies have

also shown that in most societies, religion plays one of the most influential roles of forming food

choices among individuals (Musaiger, 1993; Dindyal, 2003).

According to the Ahmad (2004) the halal (permissible) means that the food is free

from any part or substance extracted from animal that considered Haram, not containing

substance declared as filthy according to the Islamic Law, not processed using utensils or

machinery which is filthy and the process, preparation and storage of food should not exposed to

the non halal substance. The concept of halal not only applied to food production, but also in

other aspects. The processing of the foods should follow the good manufacturing practices

3
which keep the food from being contaminated with non halal elements. Halal also not only

matter about the food and drink, but also the daily life of a Muslim. They also claimed that the

missing of Muslim entrepreneurs in the halal industry makes consumers to be less appreciation

for halalness concept which theoretically must be produced by Muslim society for Muslim

consumers.

Statement of the Problem

Islamic Market is one of the fastest growing commodity on the global marketing

industry today. Many investors see the increasing value of Islamic goods on the stock market but

Shariah law plays vital role in this commerce since religion and culture is a big part of Islamic

Market, thus, Halal management is in use.

 Does the usage of Halal management creates marketability and income for the business?

 Is this type of management boost the demand of the business’s product?

 What are the impacts on the business with the use this management?

Conceptual Framework

The purpose of this study is to determine the impacts of Halal management on business

performance. Halal management is a concerted effort of various industry players in food,

pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, packaging and logistics as well as services from all over the world.

Figure 1 shows some approaches and improved aspects to recover negative impacts of halal

management on business performance such as Halal integrity, Halal policy and Halal mission.

To provide a Halal Management, the company/ business must have obtained Halal certification

and apply it to each service and product, ensure the conformance of Halal policy for the

4
production and marketing of every product, and provide training and information to staff

pertaining to concept and requirement of Halal.

Figure 1. A Schematic Diagram of the Conceptual Framework of the study

Halal Islamic
Policy Marketing

Halal Impact factors of


Halal
integrity Halal Management
Mission
on Business
Performance

Hypothesis

Halal management is necessary to a performance of an Islamic business in order to

successfully enter and compete in an Islamic market. There is a significant relationship between

the impacts of Halal Management on Business Performance.

Significance of the Study

The result of this study would be important to the business owners of the halal

management in determining the management’s impact on the business performance that will

ensure enhance the business owner’s management for better performances. The findings of the

study will hopefully benefit the following individuals in the society:


5
The Business Owners. The finding of this study would serve as additional information to the

business owners that would help them improve the performance of their business.

The Academicians and scholars. The result will be important to academicians or scholars as it

provides useful material for reference and future research since Halal Management is a

continuous phenomenon that still requires more studies.

The Future researchers. The findings of this study will provide a valuable and related study for

future researchers who will be conducting a similar study.

Scope and Limitation

This study is focused on the impacts of halal management on business performance.

The approach to this study is to exhibit the role of Halal management on the impact on business

performance. The respondents of the study are limited to Individual using Halal Management in

their business at Mindanao State University Main Campus Marawi City. The central objectives

of our research is to determine the impacts of halal managements and to find out and examine the

area of consumerism in the halal products and halal awareness in the management. The

researchers will provide a questionnaire about the impacts of halal management on business

performance to the College of Business Administration and Management students in Mindanao

State University, Marawi City and the results will be gathered and analyzed by the researchers.

Definition of terms

Halal Management. The act or skill of controlling and making decisions about a halal business,

department, and others. Is managing of all the functions and activities necessary to determine and

achieve halal products (Merriam Webster 2019).


6
Halal system is defined as the organizational structure, responsibilities, procedures, activities,

capabilities and resources that together aim to ensure that products, processes or services will

satisfy stated or implied aims, i.e., production of halal products. (A. A. Norman 2008).

Halal Integrity. Is the quality of being honest and having strong moral principles, or moral

uprightness. It is a personal choice to hold one's self to consistent standards. In ethics, integrity is

regarded as the honesty and truthfulness or accuracy of one's actions. (Merriam Webster 2019)

This research although academic is meant to have a real value in improving the integrity of the

halal food supply chain, providing value to the food industry, to countries that are concerned

about this supply chain and to Muslim consumers. Halal integrity is crucial to the success of the

emerging halal market. (Siti Zamanira)

Halal mission. Food that's halal is allowed under the religious laws of Islam. It's especially

important for observant Muslims to eat only halal meat that's been prepared in a certain way. The

adjective halal can describe non-food items, and also allowable or proper behavior. (M.Z., Azila,

J).

Business performance. Entails reviewing the overall business performance and determining

how the business can better reach its goals. This requires the alignment of strategic and

operational objectives and the business' set of activities in order to manage performance. Because

BPM seeks to aggregate available information, managers are more informed about the company's

position and are able to make better decisions. Also called corporate performance management.

(Sin and Tse 2000).

7
Innovative performance. Is a key driver of business performance. Institutionalizing strategy-

driven Enterprise Innovation Management allows you to maximize the impact of your innovation

investment portfolio and aligns your investment decisions with performance goals. Intrinsically

linked to your organization’s business strategy are the best-practice metrics for measuring

performance. (Gunday et al., 2011).

Islamic Marketing. Can be defined as the wisdom of satisfying the need of customers through

conduct of delivering Halal- wholesome, pure and lawful products and services.

The Halal certificate. Is a document that guarantees that products and services aimed at the

Muslim population meet the requirements of Islamic law and therefore are suitable for

consumption in both Muslim-majority countries and in Western countries where there are

significant population group who practice Islam (France, Germany, United Kingdom, Spain).

Halal certification is a process which ensures the features and quality of the products according

to the rules established by the Islamic Council that allow the use of the mark Halal. (Zakiah

Samori).

8
Chapter II

Review of Related Literature and Studies

Related Literature

Sulayman (1998) reviewed the theory of economics of Islam, remarked product as a

fundamental element in Islamic thoughts. Generally, from the Islamic perspective, any related

process and function should be done within ethical boundaries set by Sharia. In this case, product

can be considered as Halal (permissible or lawful, opposite of Haram) if it can provide core

benefits and values to consumers. Additionally, market players expected to operate in morally

acceptable manner. Thus, producers and marketers use Halal certificate to reassure customers to

convince consumer about integrity of production process. Halal certificate grants assurance to all

consumers since it fulfills the Shariah law. Preparing and consuming Halal products is a must for

Muslims that is forecasted to be 29% of the world population by 2030 (Grim and Karim, 2011).

Growing demands over Halal market on the one hand, have made the market more attractive for

most of producers, suppliers and traders and on the other provoked Halal certificate as one of the

fastest growing product certification. In other words, Halal market has targeted by many

manufacturers and brands.

Halal matters throughout the entire supply chain, from farm to fork. This is documented

by (Lodhi,2009) who explained the process of Halal food chain from the source to the

consumer .The slightest presence of non-Halal elements will void the Halal status.( Zulfakar et

al.,2013) suggested complete segregation, Halal certification, and the presence of Halal-trained

employees are critical to the success of a Halal supply chain. Demand for a skilled workforce

9
and experts in Halal logistics can be met by developing formal degrees in Halal supply chain and

logistics at postgraduate, graduate and undergraduate level (La Londe and Ginter, 2003) as Halal

studies in universities is a way forward to manage Halal businesses (Ahmad et al., 2011). Several

studies managed to underline the need for well-knowledge and trained employees to be present

during Halal product preparation and Halal logistics activities such as pre-slaughter, slaughtering,

processing and preparation, procurement, packaging, storage, transportation, and tracking and

tracing. According to (Riaz and Chaudry,2004), the presence of Muslim employees acts as a

supervisory role and it is important as to ensure that no livestock is tortured (stunned) and only

proper tools and techniques, such as sharp knives, is practiced. Hence, the knowledge about

Halal and Halal logistics procedures, and presence of Muslim employees during Halal product

processes is very critical for a total Halal supply chain, and protecting consumers from

unintentionally consuming non-Halal products and services.

Halal industry represents a very large and rapidly expanding market segment. It is a new

force of market organization and identification. Halal food is becoming an increasing part of

consumers’ diet and has become a multi-billion dollar global industry involving multinational

companies that have aggressively expanded their halal-certified product lines. From a market

perspective, the traditional major target markets of halal food are the Asia-Pacific and the Middle

East. To date, the Muslim market is composed of approximately 25 percent or 2 billion of the

entire world population. Muslims represent a majority in more than 50 countries in Asia, Africa,

and Europe and their religion, Islam, is considered the fastest growing among all religions on

earth both through birth and conversion. Those 2 billion Muslims live in economically feasible

numbers in most countries in the world. In US Dollar, the global Muslim consumer market is

10
forecasted to reach a staggering USD30 trillion by 2050 (Alserhan, 2010; Mordor Intelligence

Report, 2018).

Several factors have driven halal market forces as highlighted by Sungkar (2008). Firstly,

Muslim populations are now increasing and many Muslim nations are reaching a stage of

development whereby they can begin to influence world markets, both as producers and

consumers. Sungkar (2008) stressed that, as the world and Muslims get richer, the appetite for

trade increases. And when the consumer incomes of Muslims rise, they become fussier about the

products that they want to buy. As a general rule, the rise in income typically correlates to an

increase in the demand for more value-added and differentiated products. When Muslims have

higher purchasing power, they are able to be more selective about what halal foods they want to

buy. Secondly, products such as halal meat are increasingly popular among non-Muslims too and

this has significantly enhanced the halal industry sector. Halal certified products are attracting

non-Muslims consumers aware of the wholesome hygienic and contamination free principles

underlying halal food production. Lastly, requirements for food exporters to comply with halal

requirements and to provide halal certificate also lead to the growth of halal food industry (Al-

Harran and Low, 2008).

As the Halal market is a lucrative business, and with billions of customers, governments

are pouring-in supports to help and promote the Halal industry, such as setting up Halal

certification authority, providing incentives for Halal businesses, funding research on Halal

related studies through universities and research institutes as well as organizing Halal training for

industry practitioners. (Golan et al.,2004) stated that the government should protect consumers

from unsafe food by legislating guidelines or laws. In the context of Halal supply chain

11
management, (Samsi et al.,011) describe the government roles are significant which involves

planning, developing, implementing, regulating, promoting and educating Halal industrial

players and Halal consumers.

Furthermore, efforts from various governments such as Department of Islamic

Development Malaysia (JAKIM) (Malaysia), Majlis Ugama Islam Singapura (MUIS) (Singapore)

and Brunei Halal (Brunei Darussalam) (Adams, 2011), are some examples that Halal is a good

business to venture. Malaysia government’s efforts in promoting Halal industry are admirable,

such as pumping millions into the national budget (Ramli, 2006), and that large sum of the

budget was allocated for halal product development, better halal certification standards and halal

promotional activities (Mohd Adly, 2005).

In Islam, every aspect of human life must be in accordance with the will of God. In Islam,

the marketing is not limited to the sale or imaging to benefit from the goods and services in all

businesses. In Islam all activities and transactions considered as worship (QS2: 30). Islam is a

way of life that is governed by rules that limit, which is explained and practiced by Prophet

Muhammad SAW. Even nature and human behavior should not be against the Islamic faith,

sharia, and Akhlaq. In addition to this, Islam set some rules of food meant to improve human

welfare, also from Allah (QS5: 48). Halal management complies with Islamic ethics, these

Islamic ethics must be observed by the business and employees in order to deem or certify a

product is Halal and is favorable to be consumed by Muslims and does not violate the rules of

Shariah Law.

No. Element Islamic Ethics

12
1 Product o Compliance with Sharia
o Do not use God's name in
the brands and labels
o Halal (Holy and lawful)
o Accurate Labeling
o here are no weak packaging
o Do no harm to customer
o No thought is dull
o No products obsolete
o Value Resistance
o The environmental impact
2 Price o Fear of Allah (Allah is a
price setter)
o Fair and There should be no
cheating
o Approach public welfare
o Maximizing profits simply
not a priority.
o No price is justified
o There is no price
manipulation
o No predatory prices
o There are no feed prices
3 Place o Do not harm others streets
o No delay unnecessary
o There is no compulsion
o The distribution channel is
not encumbering customers
o Closure during Friday
prayers
o Avoid suspicious location
4 Promotion o Complying Sharia
o Women should not be used
to attract or lure customers
o No use suggestive language
and behavior
o There is no concealment of
facts and information
(Disclosure errors and defects)
oNo promotion of
manipulative behavior
o No sexual appeal
o There is no oath in the name
of God
o Attribute not excessive
13
o No ad was misleading
o There is no fraud
o No obscene ads
5 People o Complying with Islamic law
(Shari'a)

6 Process o Compliance Sharia


o The hospitality of Islam
o No bribes, no sexual
offenses
o Honesty, justice, respect for
the customer
o Do not sell liquor, not
detrimental,
o There is no compulsion
o Information correct
marketing
o There are no pressing
technical sales
o There is no oath in the name
of God
o There is no exploitation of
monopoly power
o There are no fraudulent
transactions
o Efficiency of interaction
Staff
o The use of customer waiting
time is right
o Respect a time

Related Studies

A few studies in the literature on the halal certification and business performance

relationship present an affirmative assessment of halal certification innovation leading to

improved business performance (Al-Harran and Low, 2008; Chan, 2011; Marzuki, Hall, and

Ballantine, 2011; and Rajagopal, et al., 2011). For instance, Chan (2011) argued that halal

certification has a significant effect on business performance by providing an enhanced quality


14
product that conveys competitive benefit and better performance. In his study, he revealed that

Currumbin Wildlife Sanctuary in Australia, Hilton Glasgow, and the Intercontinental Hotel in

Prague have reported significant improvement in their innovative business performance since

they started to offer new halal food products such as meat and beverages. According to him,

these places have become attractive destinations especially for Muslim travellers. Similarly,

Rajagopal et al. (2011) also revealed that food companies in the United Arab Emirates have

improved innovative performance after acquiring halal certification. Among these big companies

and retailers are Nestle, French supermarket chain Casino, Tesco, and Sainsbury. Rajagopal et al.

(2011) argued that products of these companies are quite unique in terms of quality because of

their halal certification logo where religious values and beliefs are upheld during the entire

product chain process. Marzuki et al. (2011) revealed that innovative companies with quality

halal products significantly improved their financial performance. This is in line with the Gulf

Marketing Review (2009) statement that Nestle has increased its profit since it moved its

halalrange into mainstream retail channels in Swiss supermarkets. Nestle has been offering halal

versions of many brands since 2004 in countries such as France, the UK and Germany. Halal

products are sold in 1,000 stores in five European countries. The product range includes Nido,

Smarties, Maggi soups, Kit Kat, Milo and Nescafe accounting for annual sales of around USD5.2

billion. Out of 456 factories, 85 are halal certified. These factories are mainly in Indonesia, South

Africa and the Middle East (Rajagopal, 2011). This indicates that halal certification improves

product quality, hygiene and safety which encourages more customers, thus increasing the firm’s

profitability.

15
Islamic approach to the business is regulated by two sources, namely the Qur'an and the

Hadith of the Prophet shaped guide how Islam entire life. The practice of Islam is based on the

divinity and faith, and does not recognize the separation between the earthly dimension and

hereafter; it is different with western contemporary marketing practices based on profit

maximization. According to the Islamic perspective, activities are based on the goal of satisfying

the material alone will inhibit rational thinking people and will make them into slaves of a

marketing company. Islam respects freedom and offers free mankind from all shackles of slavery,

including from international market

Halal is an Arabic word which means permitted or lawful under the Islamic law (Jump, 2002)

(including the al-Quran, al-Hadith, Ijma’ (consensus) and Qiyas (deduction of analogy according

to the Syafie or any one of the Hanafi, Maliki or Hambali School of Thought or Fatwa approved

by the relevant Islamic Authority) (Bonne and Verbeke, 2008). The term

explains goods or actions that are permissible and wholesome according Shariah laws and

Islamic principles (Omar et al., 2013).Generally, marketing from Islamic perspective can be

defined as the promotion of products that would be in line with Islamic values. According to

Quran verse “One who believe! Eat not up your property among yourselves unjustly expect it to

be a trade amongst you, by mutual consent. And do not kill yourselves (nor kill one another).

Surely, Allah is most merciful to you” (Quran 4:29).

16
Chapter III

Methodology

Research Design

Quantitative research method is used in this research. The result and analyzing of the data

will be in numerical form. Non-experimental survey research is most applicable to this study. It

will produce the necessary results needed for the study. This offer relatively quick ways of

collecting information for conducting the study.

Research Locale

The study will be conducted at the Commercial Center of Mindanao States University,

Marawi City because most of the stores and shops are located in this area of the university.

Research Subject

The sample frame is 50, quota sampling followed by purposive sampling will be used in

this research. The sample list of the study is comprised of individual business owners who are

managing their business with the use of Halal Management in the university. The participants of

the study must have their own stores or shops within Mindanao States University.

17
Research instrument

The study is conducted via survey in which the participants are going to complete or

answer a controlled set of questions in a survey questionnaire. These are given to them for the

purpose of visual and clear understanding of the questions. The researchers must obtain

permission from the participants of the study by explaining to them the nature and the scope of

the study and ensuring them their participation in the study is strictly confidential. They are

given the freedom to keep their identity anonymous by leaving the name in the questionnaire

blank.

Data Analysis Method

In order to acquire the desired result through data gathering, the researchers used the survey

questionnaire. Questionnaire method has been used for primary data collection to identify the

impacts of Halal Management on the business performance. Respondents were individuals who

used halal management on their business. Primary data was first-hand information collected

through various methods such as observation, interview and survey. This data was directly

collected by the researcher from their original sources and analyzed following the research’s

objectives. Secondary data are sources containing data which have been collected and compiled

for another purpose. Secondary data doesn’t need to be collected by the researcher from the

respondents because it already exists. They’re already been collected by someone else and which

have already passed through the statistical process. Data was checked for accuracy and

conclusions were drawn relating to research aims.

Secondary data was collected from:

18
 Various articles which are published in journals, magazines, and research papers

published in research journals.

 Publications of renowned institutions who work on Halal Management.

 Web sites were also picked up as a major source to provide valuable and important data

for research and literature review.

The analysis started with the computation of frequencies and percentages to analyze

respondent’s profile in terms of name, gender and religion. The overall data was analyzed using

descriptive analysis to describe the relationship between variables in a sample or population.

This provides a summary of data in the form of mean, median, mode and standard deviation.

Statistical Method

The data from the questionnaire will be analyzed using the statistical tools such as

Frequency and Percentage Distribution, Mean. Pearson’s Correlation Coefficient, and Single

Regression. The result of this analysis will indicate the impacts of Halal Management on the

business performance of the respondents and it will clarify if Halal marketing could help in

business marketability.

The Frequency and Percentage Distribution was used to determine the answers of the

respondents according to their profile information. To get the percentage of the collected answers

from the respondents, get the quotient of the frequency of response and the total number of

respondents and then multiplied the answer by 100 as constant.

19
Formula:

𝒇
P = 𝒏 × 100

Where P is the percentage, F is the frequency/ number of response

n is the total number of respondents

Arithmetic Average (Mean) is the number of response divided by the total number of

respondents. Mean was used to determine the impacts of halal Management on the business

performance.

∑𝒙
X= 𝒏

Where x = total number of response and n = total number of respondents.

The goal here is to compute the correlations between the halal management and its impacts on

the business performance. A correlation coefficient depicts the strength of the link between two

quantitative variables, whether positive or negative. Our data consist of continuous variables so

we will use Pearson Correlation Coefficient. The Pearson correlation coefficient, r, can take a

range of values from +1 to -1. A value of 0 indicates that there is no association between the two

variables. A value greater than 0 indicates a positive association; that is, as the value if one

variable increases, so does the value of the other variable. A value less than 0 indicates a

negative association; that is, as the value of one variable increases, the value of the other variable

decreases. The t-test is used to establish if the correlation coefficient is significantly different

20
from zero, and, hence that there is evidence of an association between the two variables. There is

then the underlying assumption that the data is from a normal distribution sampled purposively.

Simple Regression tests how change in the predictor variable predicts the level of change in the

outcome variable. The factor that is being predicted is called the dependent variable which is

business performance. The factors that are used to predict the value of the dependent variable is

the independent variable which is the Halal Management. It allows us to summarize and study

relationships between two continuous variables.

21
References

Abusulayman, A.A. (1998). The theory of the economics of Islam. Journal of Islamic Economics,

Abul Hassan Chachi, A. & Abdul Latiff, S. (2008). Islamic Marketing Ethics and its Impact on
Customer Satisfaction in The Islamic Banking Industry. JKAU: Islamic Econom.

Abuznaid, S. (2012). Islamic marketing: addressing the Muslim market. An-Najah University
Journal for Research–Humanities.

Abdul Baqi, Muhamad Fuad. (2012). Terjemahan Al-Lu’lu’uwalmarjan (kumpulan hadits shahih
bukhari muslim). Semarang: PT. Pustaka Riski Putra.

Adnan, Ahmad Azrin. (2013). Theoretical Framework for Islamic Marketing: Do We Need a
New Paradigm? International Journal of Business and Social Scienc.

Al-Faruqi, I. R. (1992). Al Tawhid: Its Implications for Thought and Life. Herndon, VA:
International Institute of Islamic Thought.

Alom, Md. Mahabub & Haque, Md. Shariful. (2011). Marketing: An Islamic Perspective. World
Journal of Social Science.

Alhabshi, S. O. (1987). The role of ethics in economics and business. Journal of Islamic
Economic.

Al-Faruki, Ismail Raji. (1992). Al Tawhid: its implication for thought and life (IIIT. Kuala
Lumpur).

Al-Misri, Ahmad Ibn Naqub. (1991). The Reminiscences of the Traveler: A Classical Manual of
Islamic Sacred Law. Trans.by NoahHa Mim Keller (Modern Printing Press. Abu Dhabi).

American Marketing Association. (1960). Marketing Definitions: A glossary of marketing terms,


AMA, Chicago.

American Marketing Association. (2016). Marketing Definitions: https

Antonio, M. S. (2007). Muhammad SAW: The Super Leader Super Manager, Prophetic
Leadership and Management Centre, Jakarta

Arham, M. (2010). Islamic Perspectives on Marketing. Journal of Islamic Marketing.

Badawi, Jamal A. (2002). Islamic Worldview: Prime Motive for Development. Humanomics.

22
23

You might also like