Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Specifying
Requirements for
Concrete Mixtures
By Colin L. Lobo, Ph.D., P.E.
12 STRUCTURE magazine
Figure 2. Increase in an indication of the permeability of concrete by ASTM C1202 Figure 3. Increase in the drying shrinkage of concrete by ASTM C157 with an
with an increase in cement content (mixtures with 40% slag cement by weight of increase in cement content (mixtures with 40% slag cement by weight of cementitious
cementitious materials at w/cm 0.40, 0.47, and 0.55). (Obla et al., 2017) materials at w/cm 0.40, 0.47, and 0.55). (Obla et al., 2017)
scaling in this type of exposure. In reinforced concrete, scaling will drying shrinkage is illustrated in Figure 2 and Figure 3,
reduce cover and exacerbate reinforcement corrosion. This exposure respectively. This tends to reduce the amount of SCMs that can be
condition is rare in buildings. This limit was stated in 85% of the used and increases the paste volume to impact performance adversely.
specifications reviewed in the evaluation. The specification of this limit There are no minimum cement content requirements in ACI standards
is either a misunderstanding of the intent or a directive to minimize for buildings. This requirement considerably constrains the ability of a
the use of SCMs in concrete. concrete producer to optimize a mixture for the best performance and
The use of SCMs for improved durability – reduced permeability limits competitive bids. This requirement, in addition to conservative
and resistance to deterioration due to alkali-silica reactions, sulfate requirements for w/cm, results in actual concrete strengths 30 to 40%
attack, and other chemicals – is well established. Reduced permeability higher than the specified strength, thereby causing an ineffective design
of concrete protects the corrosion of reinforcement. In mass con- that makes the concrete construction more expensive and less sustainable.
crete members, increasing the quantity of continued on next page
SCMs is the more economical means to
reduce the potential for thermal cracking.
The use of SCMs also improves the work-
ability of concrete by achieving higher
slump with less water and reducing the
potential for segregation. It also supports
We are recruiting
sustainability initiatives. Resulting slower
setting or rate of strength gain can be
offset by the judicious use of admixtures
and verified by maturity methods to esti- Robert Bird Group offers you the opportunity to join us
A P R I L 2 019 13
Other Issues • Prohibiting the adjustment of mixture proportions of
• Invoking more restrictive requirements for concrete-making approved mixtures – real-time minor adjustments (without
materials, like aggregates or fly ash, than what is in the ASTM requesting approval) are needed to maintain quality and
specifications – this causes available sources with local history consistency to accommodate variation in source materials
to be restricted from use or requires materials to be imported. and environmental conditions.
• Requiring the use of specific brands or sources of materials, like • Restriction on cement alkali content, primarily as an attempt
admixtures or cements – producers have established contracts to minimize the potential for deleterious cracking due to alkali-
and requiring the use of materials they are not familiar with aggregate reactions (AAR) – ASTM C1778 recognizes that
can cause problems. INFO SPECS
the use of a low alkali cement does not necessarily prevent the
File Name: 18-2650 Ad_Structure_Mar_CRS Corporate Page Size: 5w" x 7.5h"
• Specifying the combined grading PR#: no
of aggregates
Job#: 18-2605
to relatively problem and provides various options to mitigate AAR.
Number of Pages: 1
tight bands
114 4 E. Newpor t Center Dr.
with the intent to
Artist: control
Georgina workability
Morra Email: or shrinkage/
gmorra@mapei.com Bleed: •
Yes T
ight
Amount: controls
.125" on the slump or other fresh concrete properties
Dcurling
eerfield – B e this
a c h , typically
F L 3 3 4 4 2 cannot be enforced
Date: February 1, 2019 11:09andAMoften cannot be Colors: CMYK – can impact
Process, 4/0 constructability. ACI 301 permits the contractor
N Oachieved
T E : C O L O R S V with
I E W E D Olocal
N - S C R E Ematerials
N A R E I N T E N D Eor
D F during
OR VISUAL Rproduction.
E F E R E N C E O N L Y A N D M A Y N O T M A T C H T H E F I N Ato
L P Rselect
I N T E D P the
R O D U Cslump
T. and document that in a submittal. In today’s
The intended performance may not be achieved. concrete, slump is not a measure or control on water content.
• Including references to the Code or
non-mandatory guides or state-of-the-
art reports – these include committee
14 STRUCTURE
18-2650 Ad_Structure_Mar_CRS
magazine Corporate.indd 1 2/6/19 2:03 PM
References
Lemay, L., Lobo, C., and Obla, K., Performance-Based Specification for Concrete: A Focus on Innovation, Quality, and Customer Satisfaction,
STRUCTURE, April 2005, pp. 22-25.
Obla, K., and Lobo, C., “Prescriptive Specifications: A reality check,” Concrete International, American Concrete Institute,
August 2015, pp. 53-55.
ACI 318-14, Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete, American Concrete Institute, 2014, 520 pp.
ACI 301-16, Specifications for Structural Concrete, American Concrete Institute, 2016, 64 pp.
Obla, K., Hong, R., Lobo, C., and Kim, H., “Should Minimum Cementitious Contents for Concrete be Specified?,”
Transportation Research Record 2629, Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2017, pp. 1-8.
A P R I L 2 019 15