Professional Documents
Culture Documents
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
Sol1- Restructuring may include company reorganization, closure, insolvency, merger &
acquisition, downsizing, externalization and delocalization.
Restructuring is driven by several factors including a more open global economy, downturns
in economic growth, an ageing population, introduction of new technologies affecting ways
of working and the necessity to combat climate change and to reduce environmental impact.
Restructuring is the corporate management term for the act of reorganizing the legal,
ownership, operational, or other structures of a company for the purpose of making it more
profitable, or better organized for its present needs.
Objective Of Restrucrting
A- EXPANSION
1) Growth-
2) Technology
3) Product Advantage and product differentiation
4) Govt Policy
5) Exchange rates
6) Political economic stability
7) Diffrential labour costs
8) Diversification
9) Economies of scale
B-CORPORATE CONTROL
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
C-CONTRACTION
1) Improving Performance
2) Booming Independence
3) Effort of unlearn
4) Strategic Adjustment
5) Increasing Value
D-CHANGE IN OWNERSHIP
1) Manoeuvring Leverage
2) Alteration in the control structure
3) Providing fairness to minority shareholders
Market share
Resorce transfer
Market Power
Acquisitions can provide access to new products much more quickly and at a lower
cost than internal development of new products.
Many firms in the pharmaceutical industry use acquisitions to enter markets quickly,
to overcome the high costs of developing products internally, and to increase the
predictability of returns on their investments.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
Strategy Performance
- Poor strategy or - Poor or declining performance
implementation - Difference between desired and
- Overdiversification actual performance
- Leverage - Assets are undervalued
- Perceived threat of takeover
EXAMPLES
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
Bankruptcy filings in the United States can fall under one of several chapters of the
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
Chapter 11 gives the debtor a fresh start, subject to the debtor's fulfillment of its obligations
under its plan of reorganization.
A Chapter 11 reorganization is the most complex of all bankruptcy cases and generally the
most expensive. It should be considered only after careful analysis and exploration of all
other alternatives.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
merger occurred between Time Warner Incorporated, a major cable operation, and the
Turner Corporation, which produces CNN, TBS, and other programming. In this
merger, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) was alarmed by the fact that such a
merger would allow Time Warner to monopolize much of the programming on
television. Ultimately, the FTC voted to allow the merger but stipulated that the
merger could not act in the interests of anti-competitiveness to the point at which the
public good was harmed.
Market-extension merger - Two companies that sell the same products in different
markets.
EXAMPLES
1) Eagle Bancshares Inc by the RBC Centura-
which is one of the ten biggest banks in the metropolitan Atlanta region as far as
deposit market share is concerned. One of the major benefits of this acquisition is that
this acquisition enables the RBC to go ahead with its growth operations in the North
American market.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
These mergers involve firms engaged in unrelated type of business activities i.e. the
business of two companies are not related to each other horizontally ( in the sense of
producing the same or competing products), nor vertically( in the sense of standing
towards each other n the relationship of buyer and supplier or potential buyer and
supplier). In a pure conglomerate, there are no important common factors between the
companies in production, marketing, research and development and technology. In
practice, however, there is some degree of overlap in one or more of this common
factors.
Conglomerate mergers are unification of different kinds of businesses under one
flagship company. The purpose of merger remains utilization of financial resources
2) L&T and Voltas Ltd are examples of such mergers.
3) Mahindra and mahindra and indian aluminuim limited
Q6- How can one measure the success or failure of merger? Explain with the help of
example?
Sol6-Success can also be measured when the following objectives of the merged entity is
achived (page 81)
HP AND COMPAQ
Failure can also be measured when the following objectives of the merged entity is
achived (89)
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
Failure occurs on average, in every sense, acquiring firm stock prices likely to reduce when
mergers are announced; many acquired companies sold off; and profitability of the acquired
company is lower after the merger relative to comparable non-merged firms
1. Excessive premium
In a competitive bidding situation, a company may tend to pay more. Often highest bidder is
one who overestimates value out of ignorance.
2. Size Issues
A mismatch in the size between acquirer and target has been found to lead to poor acquisition
performance.
3. Lack of research
Acquisition requires gathering a lot of data and information and analyzing it. It requires
extensive research. A carelessly carried out research about the acquisition causes the
destruction of acquirer's wealth.
4. Diversification
Very few firms have the ability to successfully manage the diversified businesses. Unrelated
diversification has been associated with lower financial performance
While previous acquisition experience is not necessarily a requirement for future acquisition
success, many unsuccessful acquirers usually have little previous acquisition experience.
successful acquisitions.
Conglomerate mergers proliferated in 1960s and 1970. Many conglomerates proved unwieldy
and inefficient and were wound up in 1980s and 1990s. The unmanageable conglomerates
contributed to the rise of various types of divestitures in the 1980s and 1990s.
At times acquirers do not carry out the detailed diligence of the target company. They make a
wrong assessment of the benefits from the acquisition and land up paying a higher price.
Integration of the companies requires a high quality management. Integration is very often
poorly managed with little planning and design. As a result implementation fails. The key
variable for success is managing the company better after the acquisition than it was managed
before. Even good deals fail if they are poorly managed after the merger.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
Control of the new unit should be taken immediately after signing of the agreement. ITC did
so when they took over the BILT unit even though the consideration was to be paid in 5
yearly installments.
The important task in the merger is to integrate the target with acquiring company in every
respect. All function such as marketing, commercial; finance, production, design and
personnel should be put in place. In addition to the prominent persons of acquiring company
the key persons from the acquired company should be retained and given sufficient
prominence opportunities in the combined organization.
Lack of due diligence is lack of detailed analysis of all important features like finance,
management, capability, physical assets as well as intangible assets results in failure. ISPAT
Steel is a corporate acquirer that conducts M&A activities after elaborate due diligence.
Merger between two equals may not work. The Dunlop Pirelli merger in 1964, which created
the world's second largest tier company, ended in an expensive divorce. Manufacturing plants
can be integrated easily, human beings cannot. Merger of equals may also create ego clash.
Cash acquisitions results in the acquirer assuming too much debt. Future interest cost
consumes too great a portion of the acquired company's earnings (Business India 2005).
If merging companies have entirely different products, markets systems and cultures, the
merger is doomed to failure. Added to that as core competencies are weakened and the focus
gets blurred the fallout on bourses can be dangerous. Purely financially motivated mergers
such as tax driven mergers on the advice of accountant can be hit by adverse business
consequences. The Tatas for example, sold their soaps business to Hindustan Lever.
It would be serious mistake if the takeovers were concluded without a proper audit of
financial affairs of the target company.
Risk of failure will be minimized if there is a detailed evaluation of the target company's
business conditions carried out by the professionals in the line of business.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
After signing the M&A agreement the top management should not sit back and let things
happen. First 100 days after the takeover determine the speed with which the process of
tackling the problems can be achieved. Top management follow-up is essential to go with a
clear road map of actions to be taken and set the pace for implementing once the control is
assumed.
Merger between two weak companies does not succeed either. The example is the Stud
backer- Packard merger of 1955 when two ailing carmakers joined hands. By 1964 both
companies were closed down.
Lack of proper communication after the announcement of M&As will create lot of
uncertainties.
Some of the role leadership should take seriously are modeling, quantifying strategic benefits
and building a case for M&A activity and articulating and establishing high standard for
value creation. Walking the talk also becomes very important during M&As.
Not giving sufficient attention to people issues during due diligence process may prove costly
later on.
Another feature of 1990s is the growth in strategic alliances as a cheaper, less risky route to a
strategic goal than takeovers.
Merger should not result in loss of identity, which is a major strength for the acquiring
company. Jaguar's car image dropped drastically after its merger with British Leyland.
In some cases it reduces buyer's efficiency by diverting it from its core activity and too much
time is spent on new activity neglecting the core activity.
Immediate results can never be expected except those recorded in red ink. Whirlpool ran up a
loss $100 million in its Philips white goods purchase. R.P.Goenk's takeovers of Gramaphone
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
Company and Manu Chhabria's takeover of Gordon Woodroffe and Dunlops fall under this
category.
Sol7-Although merger and acquisition are often used as synonymous terms, there is a subtle
difference between the two concepts.
1.In the case of a merger, two firms together form a new company. After the merger, the
separately owned companies become jointly owned and obtain a new single identity. When
two firms merge, stocks of both are surrendered and new stocks in the name of new company
are issued. Generally, mergers take place between two companies of more or less same size.
In these cases, the process is called Merger of Equals. merger happens when two
companies agree to operate together under the same ownership. Ideally, both companies
are of similar size. Both companies in this case surrender their shares and new shares
are issued.
2.However, with acquisition, one firm takes over another and establishes its power as the
single owner.Generally, the firm which takes over is the bigger and stronger one. The
relatively less powerful, smaller firm loses its existence, and the firm taking over, runs the
whole business with its own identity. Unlike the merger, stocks of the acquired firm are not
surrendered, but bought by the public prior to the acquisition, and continue to be traded in the
stock market. An acquisition happens when a company takes over a company and
establishes ownership over that company. Typically, the company which is acquired or
the target company ceases to exist as a separate entity. An example can be Corus which
ceased to exist when it was taken over by Tata Steel. Today the company operates as a
100% subsidiary of Tata Steel
3.Another difference is, when a deal is made between two companies in friendly terms, it is
typically proclaimed as a merger, regardless of whether it is a buy out. In an unfriendly deal,
where the stronger firm swallows the target firm, even when the target company is not willing
to be purchased, then the process is labeled as acquisition.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
dissolved and a new entity is created. Here, the acquired company transfers its assets,
liabilities and shares to the acquiring company for cash or exchange of shares. For example,
merger of Hindustan Computers Ltd, Hindustan Instruments Ltd, Indian Software Company
Ltd and Reprographics Ltd into an entirely new company called HCL Ltd.
Notice that the spinoff shares are distributed to the parent company
shareholders. There are two reasons why this creates value:
1. Parent company shareholders rarely want anything to do with the new spinoff. After all, it's
an goes public. underperforming division that was cut off to improve the bottom line. As
a result, many new shareholders sell immediately after the new company
2.Large institutions are often forbidden to hold shares in spinoffs due to the smaller market
capitalization, increased risk, or poor financials of the new company. Therefore, many large
institutions automatically sell their shares immediately after the new company goes public.
Simple supply and demand logic tells us that such large number of shares on the market will
naturally decrease the price, even if it is not fundamentally justified. It is this temporary
mispricing that gives the enterprising investor an opportunity for profit.
There is no money transaction in spin-off. The transaction is treated as stock dividend & tax
free exchange.
For examples-Kotak Mahindra capital finance ltd formed a subsidiary known as kotak
Mahindra capital corporation
SELL OFF–
Selling a part or all of the firm by any one of means: sale, liquidation, spin-off & so on. or
General term for divestiture of part/all of a firm by any one of a no. of means: sale,
liquidation, spin-off and so on.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
PARTIAL SELL-OFF
A partial sell-off/slump sale, involves the sale of a business unit or
plant of one firm to another.
It is the mirror image of a purchase of a business unit or plant.
From the seller‘s perspective, it is a form of contraction; from the
buyer‘s point of view it is a form of expansion.
For example: When Coromandal Fertilizers Limited sold its cement division to India Cement
Limited, the size of Coromandal Fertilizers contracted whereas the size of India Cements
Limited expanded
Q9 What are the various options available to shake off a hostile takeover?Quote a case
of successful shakeoff?
The two terms - ‗mergers‘ and ‗acquisition‘ represent the ways by strategies used by
companies to buy, sell and recombine businesses. In the present day when there exists cut
throat competition in every sphere, not all mergers and acquisitions are consensual and
peaceful.
The concept of takeovers without consent have, therefore been ideally termed ―hostile
takeovers‖. no consented The history of hostile takeovers can be traced to 1980‘s, with the
US Supreme Court for the first time sat in judgment over the anti-takeover provisions of the
Illinois Business Take-Over Act and pronounced them as invalid in their landmark ruling in
There was a time some 2 decades back when hostile acquirers struck terror in the hearts of
corporate boards.. If wealthy dealmakers wanted to take over a company in a hostile
acquisition, bite it into pieces, and then spin those pieces off for a profit, there wasn‘t much
that the board of a company could do to stop the massacre. It was at that time that ‗poison
pills‘ and other anti takeover strategies were conceptualized. The anti=take over strategies
developed during that era quickly transformed the takeover law and fortified the pre-emptive
defenses of companies.
Meaning
When an acquirer takes the control of a company by purchasing its shares without the
knowledge of the management it is termed as a hostile takeover. Thus, when an acquirer
silently and unilaterally, makes efforts to gain control of a company against the wishes of the
existing management, such act amounts to hostile takeover. Hostile takeover is an attempt by
outsider to wrest control away from an incumbent management.
The classic „poison pill strategy‟ (the shareholders‟ rights plan) is the most popular
and effective defense to combat the hostile takeovers. Under this method the target
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
company gives existing shareholders the right to buy stock at a price lower than the
prevailing market price if a hostile acquirer purchases more than a predetermined amount
of the target company‘s stock.
The purpose of this move is to devalue the stock worth of the target company and dilute the
percentage of the target company equity owned by the hostile acquirer to an extent that
makes any further acquisition prohibitively expensive for him. „White Knight‟ is another
type of defense mechanism. In this case, a third company makes a friendly takeover
offer to the company facing a hostile takeover.(RIL BUYS 14.98% IN EIH HOTEL
GROUP TO HELP IT HOSTILE OPEN OFFER FROM ITC WHICH ALSO HOLD
SIMILAR PERCENTAGE OF SHARES IN EIH ) This is a common tactics in which the
target company finds another company to enter the scene and purchase them out and away
from the company making the hostile bid. The several reasons why the companies prefer to
be bought out by the third company could be -- better purchase terms, a better relationship or
better prospects for long-term success. At times these ‗white knight‘ companies only help the
target company improve the deal terms with the hostile bidder. A very good example is of
Severstal which acted as a ‗white knight‘ in the Arcelor-Mittal deal, and causing a 52.5 %
increase in the Mittal offer.
Some other types of defenses which are available to the targeted company are:
Pac-Man Defense – wherein a target company thwarts a takeover bid by buying
stocks in the acquiring company, then taking the bidder company over.
Staggered Board:-It is used generally in combination with ‗Shareholder‘s Rights‘
plan and is considered most effective. This method drags out the takeover process by
preventing the entire board from being replaced at the same time. The directors are
grouped into classes, each group stands for the election at each annual general
meeting. It prevents entire board from being replaced at one go.
Golden Parachute is a tactics which works in the manner that it makes the
acquisition more expensive and less attractive. It is provision in a CEO's contract,
which is worded such that the CEO gets a large bonus in cash or stock if the company
is acquired.
The term ‗Target company‘ refers to is a listed company, whose shares or voting rights are
acquired/being acquired or whose control is taken over/being taken over by an acquirer either
directly or by acquiring control of its holding company or a company which is controlling it,
which is not a listed company.
As per regulation 2(1)(b), the term ―acquirer‖ means any person who, directly or indirectly,
acquires or agrees to acquire control over the target company, , either by himself or with any
person acting in concert with the acquirer. The term acquirer has been given a wide meaning
as the definition takes into account not only substantial acquisition of shares by a person, but
also takeover of control of the company.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
An explanation was inserted in the definition of the term ―control‖ vide SEBI (Takeovers)
Second Amendment, Regulations, 2002. The explanation provides that transfer from joint
control to sole control over a company is not to be considered as change in control if it has
been effected in accordance with regulation 2(1)(e), i.e., through inter se transfer of shares
among promoters.
The Takeover Code makes it difficult for the hostile acquirer to just sneak up on the target
company. It forewarns the company about the advances of an acquirer by mandating that the
acquirer make a public disclosure of his shareholding or voting rights to the company if he
acquires shares or voting rights beyond a certain specified limit. However, the Takeover
Code does not present any insurmountable barrier to a determined hostile acquirer.
The Takeover Code, vide Regulation 23, also imposes a prohibition on the certain actions of
a target company during the offer period, such as transferring of assets or entering into
material contracts and even prohibits the issue of any authorized but unissued securities
during the offer period. However, these actions may be taken with approval from the general
body of shareholders.
However, the regulation provides for certain exceptions such as the right of the company to
issue shares carrying voting rights upon conversion of debentures already issued or upon
exercise of option against warrants, according to pre-determined terms of conversion or
exercise of option. It also allows the target company to issue shares pursuant to public or
rights issue in respect of which the offer document has already been filed with the Registrar
of Companies or stock exchanges, as the case may be.
However this may be of little respite as the debentures or warrants, contemplated earlier must
be issued prior to the offer period. Further the law does not permit the Board of Director, of
the target company to make such issues without the shareholders approval either prior to the
offer period or during the offer period as it is specifically prohibited under Regulation 23.
During a takeover bid, it may be critical for the Board to quickly adopt a defensive strategy to
help ward of the hostile acquirer or bring him to a negotiated position. In such a situation, it
may be time consuming and difficult to obtain the shareholders‘ approvals especially where
the management and the ownership of the company are independent of each other.
The Takeover Code is required to be read with the SEBI (Disclosure & Investor Protection)
Guidelines 2000 (―DIP Guidelines‖), which are the nodal regulations for the methods and
terms of issue of shares/warrants by a listed Indian company. They impose several
restrictions on the preferential allotment of shares and/or the issuance of share warrants by a
listed company. Under the DIP guidelines, issuing shares at a discount and warrants which
convert to shares at a discount is not possible as the minimum issue price is determined with
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
reference to the market price of the shares on the date of issue or upon the date of exercise of
the option against the warrants. This creates an impediment in the effectiveness of the
shareholders‘ rights plan which involves the preferential issue of shares at a discount to
existing shareholders.
The DIP guidelines also provide that the right to buy warrants needs to be exercised within a
period of eighteen months, after which they would automatically lapse. Thus, the target
company would then have to revert to the shareholders after the period of eighteen months to
renew the shareholders‘ rights plan.
Without the ability to allow its shareholders to purchase discounted shares/ options against
warrants, an Indian company would not be able to dilute the stake of the hostile acquirer,
thereby rendering the shareholders‘ rights plan futile as a takeover deterrent.
Also, the FDI policy and the FEMA Regulations have provisions which restrict non-
residents from acquiring listed shares of a company directly from the open market in
any sector, including sectors falling under automatic route. There also exist certain
restrictions with respect to private acquisition of shares by non-residents, under automatic
route, is permitted only if Press Note 1 of 2005 read with Press Note 18 of 1998 is not
applicable to the non-resident acquirer. This has practically sealed any hostile takeover of any
Indian company by any non-resident.
However, for the poison pill strategy to work best in the Indian corporate scenario certain
amendments and changes to the prevalent legal and regulatory framework are required.
Importantly, a mechanism must be permitted under the Takeover Code and the DIP
Guidelines which permit the issue of shares/warrants at a discount to the prevailing market
price. These amendments would need to balance the interests of the shareholders while
allowing the target companies to fend off hostile acquirers.
Possibilities in India
The DIP Guidelines do not stipulate any pricing restrictions on the issue of non-convertible
preference shares, non-convertible debentures, notes, bonds and certificates of deposit. Thus,
companies may consider structuring a poison pill in place whereby backend rights which
permit the shareholders to exchange the rights/shares held for senior securities with a
backend value as fixed by the Board, are issued to existing shareholders when the hostile
acquirer‘s shareholding crosses a predetermined threshold.
As most takeovers are carried out through borrowed funds, the use of backend rights reduces
the profitability of the takeover because of the mounting interest rates on borrowings; thus
deterring the hostile acquirer and more importantly sets the minimum takeover price, which is
the price at which the shares have been exchanged for senior securities.
Another method is where a company puts a provision in its Articles of Associations to the
effect that a hostile acquirer who succeeds in taking control of that company and/or its
subsidiaries is prohibited from using the company‘s established brand name. A live example
is of the Tata companies who have put in place a an arrangement with the Tata Sons
holding entity, whereby any hostile (or otherwise) acquirer of any of those entities is not
permitted to make use of the established “Tata” brand name.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
As a consequence, the bidder might be able to take over the target Tata company but will be
shortchanged as it will not be entitled to a significant bite of its valuation — the valued brand
name!!
Hostility is usually perceived when an offer is made public that is aggressively rejected by
the target firm. Consequently, perceptions of hostility are closely linked with takeover
negotiations that are far from completion. Often firms engage in confidential negotiations
before there is a public announcement of a bid or an intention to bid. In some cases, the first
public announcement is of a successfully completed negotiation, which would be perceived
to be friendly, even if the early stage private negotiations would have seemed hostile if they
had been revealed to the public. In other cases, private negotiations break down and one of
the parties decides that public information about the potential bid would enhance its
bargaining position.
The most famous recent proxy fight was Hewlett-Packard‘s takeover of Compaq. The
deal was valued at $25 billion, but Hewlett-Packard reportedly spent huge sums on
advertising to sway shareholders. HP wasn‘t fighting Compaq — they were fighting a
group of investors that included founding members of the company who opposed the
merge. About 51 percent of shareholders voted in favor of the merger. Despite attempts to
halt the deal on legal grounds, it went as planned.
YAHOO MICROSOFT TAKEOVER
Conclusion
Indian companies need to shift from desperate defensive play to getting ready on the
offensive. The reason for utilizing the poison pill defense is to protect shareholder value and
interest while stalling entities such as asset strippers that do not have the best interest of the
company in mind or add any value to it. However, companies need to ensure that this defense
is not misused by errant management. The need today, obviously, seems not to do away with
poison pills, but a change in the attitude and approach of the management towards the poison
pills. Not all hostile takeovers are bad; so long as the shareholders reserve the power to
exercise the poison pills and take an informed decision, the pills and hostile takeovers can do
more good than harm.
Intellectual Capital
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
Relational capital: All relations a company entertains with external subjects, such as
suppliers, partners, clients (brands, ...), research centres, etc.;
Human capital: The sum total of the useful knowledge of your employees and your
customers with more emphasis on knowledge and competences residing with the
company's employees;
Organizational capital: Collective know-how, beyond the capabilities of individual
employees. E.g.: information systems; policies; intellectual property.
Intellectual
Capital
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
Sol1- Brand equity refers to the marketing effects or outcomes that accrue to a
product with its brand name compared with those that would accrue if the same
product did not have the brand name. And, at the root of these marketing effects is
consumers' knowledge. In other words, consumers' knowledge about a brand makes
manufacturers/advertisers respond differently or adopt appropriately adept measures
for the marketing of the brand. The study of brand equity is increasingly popular as
some marketing researchers have concluded that brands are one of the most valuable
assets that a company has.
Good examples of companies with strong brand equity are corporations such as Nike and
Coca-Cola, whose corporate logos are recognized worldwide.
2. The difference between the market value and the book value of the company‘s
shares (market value added). Other firms quantify the brand‘s value as the difference
between the shares‘ market value and their adjusted book value or adjusted net worth
(this difference is called goodwill).
3. The difference between the market value and the book value of the company‘s
Company 2002 Brand 2001
brand contribution to Brand
value($ market Value
bn) capitalization of ($bn)
parent company
(%)
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
GE 41.3 14 42.4
4.2. Estimation of the advertising investment required to achieve the present level of
brand recognition.
5. The difference between the value of the branded company and that of another
similar company that sells unbranded products (generic products or private
labels). To quantify this difference, several authors and consulting firms propose
different methods:
5.1. Present value of the price premium (with respect to a private label) paid by
customers for that brand
5.2. Present value of the extra volume (with respect to a private label) due to the brand
5.4. The above sum less all differential, brand-specific expenses and investments.
This is the most correct method, from a conceptual viewpoint. However, it is very
difficult to reliably define the differential parameters between the branded and
unbranded product, that is, the
differential price, volume, product costs, overhead expenses, investments, sales and
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
5.5. The difference between the [price/sales] ratios of the branded company and the
unbranded company multiplied by the company‘s sales. This method is used by
Damodaran to value the Kellogg‘s and Coca-Cola brands.
5.6. Differential earnings (between the branded company and the unbranded
company) multiplied by a multiple. As we shall see further on, this is the method used
by the consulting firm Interbrand.
6. The present value of the company‘s free cash flow minus the assets employed
multiplied by the required return. This is the method used by the firm Houlihan
Valuation Advisors.
7. The options of selling at a higher price and/or higher volume and the options of
growing through new distribution channels, new countries, new products, new
formats … due to the brand‘s existence
These approaches fail because there is no direct correlation between the financial investment
made and the value added by a brand. Financial investment is an important component in
building brand value, provided it is effectively targeted. If it isn‘t, it may not make a bean of
difference. The investment needs to go beyond the obvious advertising and promotion and
include R&D, employee training, packaging and product design, retail design, and so on.
Comparables. Another approach is to arrive at a value for a brand on the basis of something
comparable.
Furthermore, the value creation of brands in the same category can be very different, even if
most other aspects of the underlying business such as target groups, advertising spend, price
promotions and distribution channel are similar or identical.
Comparables can provide an interesting cross-check, however, even though they should never
be relied on solely for valuing brands.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
Premium price. In the premium price method, the value is calculated as the net present value
of future price premiums that a branded product would command over an unbranded or
generic equivalent.
However, the primary purpose of many brands is not necessarily to obtain a price premium
but rather to secure the highest level of future demand.
The value generation of these brands lies in securing future volumes rather than securing a
premium price. This is true for many durable and non-durable consumer goods categories.
This method is flawed because there are rarely generic equivalents to which the premium
price of a branded product can be compared. Today, almost everything is branded, and in
some cases store brands can be as strong as producer brands charging the same or similar
prices. The price difference between a brand and competing products can be an indicator of
its strength, but it does not represent the only and most important value contribution a brand
makes to the underlying business.
Economic use. Approaches that are driven exclusively by brand equity measures or financial
measures lack either the financial or the marketing component to provide a complete and
robust assessment of the economic value of brands. The economic use approach, which was
developed in 1988, combines brand equity and financial measures, and has become the most
widely recognized and accepted methodology for brand valuation. It has been used in more
than 3,500 brand valuations worldwide. The economic use approach is based on fundamental
marketing and financial principles:
The marketing principle relates to the commercial function that brands perform within
businesses. First, brands help to generate customer demand. Customers can be individual
consumers as well as corporate consumers depending on the nature of the business and the
purchase situation. Customer demand translates into revenues through purchase volume, price
and frequency. Second, brands secure customer demand for the long term through repurchase
and loyalty.
The financial principle relates to the net present value of future expected earnings, a
concept widely used in business. The brand‘s future earnings are identified and then
discounted to a net present value using a discount rate that reflects the risk of those earnings
being realized.
To capture the complex value creation of a brand, take the following five steps:
1. Market segmentation. Brands influence customer choice, but the influence varies
depending on the market in which the brand operates.
Split the brand‘s markets into non-overlapping and homogeneous groups of consumers
according to applicable criteria such as product or service, distribution channels, consumption
patterns, purchase sophistication, geography, existing and new customers, and so on. The
brand is valued in each segment and the sum of the segment valuations constitutes the total
value of the brand.
2. Financial analysis. Identify and forecast revenues and earnings from intangibles generated
by the brand for each of the distinct segments determined in Step 1. Intangible earnings are
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
defined as brand revenue less operating costs, applicable taxes and a charge for the capital
employed. The concept is similar to the notion of economic profit.
3. Demand analysis. Assess the role that the brand plays in driving demand for products and
services in the markets in which it operates, and determine what proportion of intangible
earnings is attributable to the brand measured by an indicator referred to as the ―role of
branding index.‖ This is done by first identifying the various drivers of demand for the
branded business, then determining the degree to which each driver is directly influenced by
the brand. The role of branding index represents the percentage of intangible earnings that are
generated by the brand. Brand earnings are calculated by multiplying the role of branding
index by intangible earnings.
5. Brand value calculation. Brand value is the net present value (NPV) of the forecast brand
earnings, discounted by the brand discount rate. The NPV calculation comprises both the
forecast period and the period beyond, reflecting the ability of brands to continue generating
future earnings
Q14-Explain the importance of due diligence with examples and illustration checklist
for PATENT , TRADEMARK AND COPYWRIGHT?
When is it necessary?
New ventures
Mergers
Acquisitions
Licenses
IPO
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
2. Least priority is given to IP. DD Starts with Property and Fixed Assets
a. Software Company
b. Bio technology
c. Manufacturer
1. The term, Due Diligence, is usually associated with contracts or investment decisions
and, in general, means that proper efforts will be made in investigations or
examinations of information provided in a given transaction. Specifically, the Due
Diligence report is a thorough examination of the enterprise in all its aspects.
2. The Financial Due Diligence can be compared to an Audit of the particular enterprise
to determine its financial situation including a very detailed listing of all its assets and
of liabilities by category such as operating expenses, loan debts and so on.
3. The Legal Due Diligence encompasses a review of the legislation establishing the
enterprise and the provisions for its governance, and any other laws affecting the
enterprise. It also includes a review of current contractual obligations both short-term
and long-term. Also included are pending cases involving the enterprise.
5. International and local consultants on behalf of the Privatisation Unit normally carry
out the Due Diligence study. In the case of Telecom Lesotho, Due Diligence studies
were carried out by PriceWaterhouseCoopers (Financial and HR), Clifford Chance
(Regulatory and Competition) and Edward Nathan & Friedland (Legal). These studies
were then incorporated into the Information Memorandum for potential investors.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
1. Obtain a complete list of the company‘s Indian, U.S., international, foreign patents
and patent applications.
3. Determine whether the procedures are followed and are appropriate and effective.
4. Obtain confirmation that the company has recorded assignments (where applicable)
for all U.S. and foreign patents and patent applications.
8. Actual or threatened litigation/claims against the company, such as cease and desist
letters. Current status of litigation. Study copies of settlements.
9. Search for patents and patent applications in the names of key personnel, consultants,
and principal clinical trial investigators
Sol15- The procedure for the amalgamation of two companies has to be viewed from the
Transferor and Transferee Company. Therefore, the procedure has been divided into two
parts i.e. procedure to followed by the transferor company and the transferee company
respectively.
2. Board Meeting
A Board Meeting shall be convened to consider and pass the following requisite resolutions:
- approve the draft scheme of amalgamation;
- to authorise filing of application to the court for directions to convene a general meeting;
- to file a petition for confirmation of scheme by the High Court.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
" Form No. 23 of Companies General Rules & Forms + copy of Special Resolution
" Resolution approving the scheme of amalgamation
" Special resolution passed for the issue of shares to persons other than existing
shareholders
13. Petition
For approval of the scheme of amalgamation, a petition shall be made to the H.C. within 7
days of the filing of report by the chairman.
Note:
" If the Regd. Offices of the companies are in same state - then both the companies may
move jointly to the High Court.
" If the Regd. Offices of the companies are in different states - then each company shall
move the petition in respective High Court for directions
14. Sanction Of The Scheme
The Court shall sanction the scheme on being satisfied that:
" The whole scheme is annexed to the notice for convening meeting. This provision is
mandatory in nature
" The scheme should have been approved by the company by means of ¾th majority of
the members present.
" The scheme should be genuine and bona fide and should not be against the interests of
the creditors, the company and the public interest.
After satisfying itself, the court shall pass orders in the requisite form
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
Sol17- Notes
Public-private transaction: involves offer for entire share capital of listed firm,
subsequent re-registration as a private company
1. Management buyout (MBO): when incumbent management team takes over firm
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
2. Management buying (MBI): when outside management team acquires firm and takes
it private
3. Institutional buyout (IBO): new owners of delisted firm are solely institutional
investors or private equity firms
3. Reverse LBO: secondary initial public offering (SIPO) for a previous LBO
Motives
Tax benefits
Control hypothesis
o Dividend payments
Q19-What is leveraged buyout?On what theorem it is based and what are its
advantages & weakness?
Sol19- A LBO is a company acquisition method by which a business can seek to takeover
another company or at least gain a controlling interest in that company. Special about
leveraged buy-outs is that the corporation that is buying the other business borrows a
significant amount of money to pay for (the majority of) the purchase price (usually over
70% or more of the total purchase price).
The debt which has been incurred is secured against the assets of the business being
purchased.
Interest payments on the loan will be paid from the future cash-flow of the acquired
company.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
Advantages of LBO
5. Leveraging: as the debt ratio increases, the equity portion of the acquisition financing
shrinks to a level at which a private equity firm can acquire a company by putting up
anywhere from 20-40% of the total purchase price.
Weakness of LBO
3. Risk of management and shareholder confrontation will impair the success of the
LBO.
4. Risk is effectively transferred to the Financer who has only interest compensation for
the risk; making the equation unfair.
5. Most of the LBOs were for asset stripping which is frowned upon by mature
corporate.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
The total return of an asset to its owners, all else being equal and within strict restrictive
assumptions, is unaffected by the structure of its financing. As the debt in an LBO has a
relatively fixed, albeit high, cost of capital, any returns in excess of this cost of capital flow
through to the equity.
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com
ANKUSH SINGH – 9702313357 (BOMBAY)
toankushsingh@rocketmail.com , toankushsingh@gmail.com