Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Numerous effective behavioral therapies have been developed that can bring the treatment to the
patient rather than bringing the patient to treatment. These behavioral therapy techniques, which
can provide effective treatment across the spectrum of severity of alcohol abuse disorders, include
facilitated selfchange, individual therapies, couples and family approaches, and contingency
management. New methods of delivery and successful adjuncts to existing behavioral treatments also
have been introduced, including computerized cognitive–behavioral treatments, Webbased guided
selfchange, and mindfulnessbased approaches. Although a wide variety of behavioral approaches
have been shown to have good efficacy, choosing the treatment most appropriate for a given patient
remains a challenge. KEY WORDS: Alcohol use disorders (AUDs); alcohol and other drug use (AODU) treatment
method; behavioral therapy; individual therapy; facilitated selfchange; family or couples therapy; contingency
management; cognitive–behavioral therapy; efficacy
S
ince the mid1980s and 1990s, couples and family treatments, facilitated techniques designed to facilitate healthy
behavioral treatment of alcohol selfchange approaches, and aversion behavior change. Coping skills training,
abuse and dependence (i.e., alcohol therapy. Many other alcohol treatments cognitive behavioral treatment, brief
use disorders [AUDs]) has advanced also incorporate behavioral principles. behavioral interventions, and relapse
steadily. This article introduces different For example, 12step groups (e.g., prevention also introduce concepts from
types of behavioral treatment, summa Alcoholics Anonymous) often rely on cognitive therapy and social learning
rizes the evidence for their efficacy, and positive reinforcement (e.g., by recog theory, primarily the identification
describes alternative methods of delivery nizing abstinence anniversaries) and of cognitions related to alcohol use
and adjuncts to existing treatments that behavioral modeling (e.g., by having and situations in which maintaining
might appeal to some patients. In addi a sponsor). Motivational interviewing abstinence might be challenged. For
tion, the article discusses the importance (see Miller and Rose 2009) also often example, the cognitive concept of
of moving beyond a focus on compar relies on behavioral principles (e.g., selfefficacy, or belief in one’s ability
ing the effectiveness of existing active reinforcement, modeling) within the to abstain from alcohol, plays a promi
behavioral treatments and toward a treatment session. This review high nent role in both cognitive–behavioral
research agenda that considers more lights those interventions that are treatments and relapse prevention.
thoughtfully how people change as well rooted in behavior therapy (see table). Likewise, an individual’s expectations
as the mechanisms of change during All of these treatments can be delivered regarding the effects of alcohol (i.e.,
the course of behavioral treatments. in individual sessions or group formats, expectancies) often are identified
and many of them have been adapted and challenged during the course of
to be delivered in a variety of treatment cognitive–behavioral interventions.
Behavioral Treatment settings, including residential, outpa Coping skills training and relapse
Approaches tient, computerized, medical, and prevention primarily focus on identifying
workplace settings.
Several distinct treatments exist under KATIE WITKIEWITZ, PH.D., is an
the general rubric of behavioral treat assistant professor in the Department of
ments for AUDs, including coping
Conceptual Overview
Psychology at Washington State University–
skills training, relapse prevention and All behavioral approaches to treatment Vancouver, Canada. G. ALAN MARLATT,
other cognitive–behavioral treatments, of AUDs combine an attention to general PH.D., is a professor in the Department
contingency management approaches, behavioral principles (e.g., reinforcement of Psychology at the University of
brief behavioral interventions, behavioral and punishment) with therapeutic Washington, Seattle, Washington.
Coping skills training Social learning theory and skills training to enhance Monti, P.M.; Kadden, R.M.; Rohsenow, D.J.; et al.
individual coping skills. Also includes cue exposure with Treating Alcohol Dependence: A Coping Skills Training
response prevention to extinguish association between Guide. Second Edition. New York: Guilford Press, 2002.
alcohol cues and alcohol seeking.
Kadden, R.M. CognitiveBehavior Therapy for
Substance Dependence: Coping Skills Training, 2002.
Available at: http://www.bhrm.org/guidelines/CBT
Kadden.pdf
Relapse prevention Identifying client’s highrisk situations for relapse and Daley, D.C., and Marlatt, G.A. 2006. Overcoming Your
and cognitive– using cognitive and behavioral techniques to help clients Alcohol or Drug Problem: Effective Recovery Strategies
behavioral therapy cope with risky situations. Workbook. New York: Oxford University Press, 2006.
Contingency Using reinforcing and punishing consequences to alter Higgins, S.T.; Silverman, K.; and Heil, S.H. (Eds.).
management substance use behavior. Requires identification of client Contingency Management in Substance Abuse
specific consequences and making receipt of consequences Treatment. New York: Guilford Press, 2008.
contigent on some desired behavior (e.g., abstinence).
Petry, N.M. A Clinician’s Guide for Implementing
Contingency Management Programs, 2001. Available at:
http://www.bhrm.org/guidelines/petry.pdf
Brief behavioral Assessment of alcohol use and personalized feedback. General: Saitz, R. and Galanter, M. (Eds.). Alcohol/Drug
intervention Focus on providing a menu of strategies for change, Screening and Brief Intervention: Advances in Evidence
goal setting, empathy, and enhancing selfefficacy. Based Practice. Binghamton, NY: Haworth Medical
Press, 2007.
Behavioral couples/ Evaluation and treatment of relationship factors that con McCrady, B.S., and Epstein, E.E. Overcoming Alcohol
family therapies tribute to alcohol use and a focus on increasing relation Problems: A Couples Focused Program. Therapist Guide.
ship factors conducive to abstinence. Incorporates posi New York: Oxford University Press, 2009.
tive activities, communication skills training, and identifi
cation of potential relapse triggers. O’Farrell, T.J., and FalsStewart, W. Behavioral Couples
Therapy for Alcoholism and Drug Abuse. New York:
Guilford Press, 2006.
Facilitated selfchange Assessment and feedback, motivation information and Hester, R.K., and Miller, W.R. Behavioral selfcontrol
selfhelp materials focused on goalsetting, problem training. In Hester, R.K., and Miller, W.R. Eds. Handbook
solving skills, and selfmonitoring. of Alcoholism Treatment Approaches. New York:
Pergamon Press, 1989.
Aversion therapy Pairing alcohol (sight, taste, or other cue) with an No empirically supported manuals available.
unpleasant experience (including nauseainducing drugs
and electric shock). Covert sensitization uses imagery of
aversive scenes paired with imagery of drinking alcohol.
highrisk situations for drinking and used as an adjunct to another treat ence these behaviors, including com
then building a repertoire of coping ment, share three central components: munication, conflicts, and problem
skills to help patients approach risky solving. Both behavioral couples
situations without using alcohol. Brief • Monitoring the individual carefully treatment (McCrady and Epstein
interventions, such as brief physician (e.g., using urinalysis or blood tests) 1995) and marital family therapy
advice (Fleming et al. 2000) and the so that alcohol use is identified; (O’Farrell et al. 1993) incorporate
Brief Alcohol Screening and Intervention several behavioral techniques designed
for College Students (BASICS) approach • Providing tangible positive rewards to reduce drinking and drinking
(Dimeff et al. 1999), also utilize many (such as vouchers that can be related problems as well as increase
cognitive–behavioral tools; however, exchanged for retail goods or cash) caring behaviors, enhance communi
in these cases, treatment occurs over a for a desired behavior (e.g., abstinence cation, and improve relationship
short period of time (often an hour or from alcohol); and functioning. Recent studies have
less). The effectiveness of these approaches found that both behavioral couples
has been demonstrated in numerous • Withholding rewards (e.g., vouchers) therapy and behavioral family therapy
studies. For example, Fleming and or implementing other negative are related to better outcomes following
colleagues (2000) found that brief consequences (e.g., providing negative treatment than behavioral individual
physician advice, delivered across two reports to interested other parties, therapies (see McCrady et al. 2009;
physician visits and two followup such as family members or parole O’Farrell et al. 2010). Skills training,
phone calls, resulted in a significant officers) when alcohol use is identified. contingency management, and behav
reduction in alcohol use and binge ioral contracting often are primary
drinking episodes for up to 4 years Cognitive therapy typically is not components of these treatments.
following the intervention. More recently, part of a contingency management
a study found that brief interventions treatment; however, contingency Facilitated SelfChange. The majority
were equally effective for alcohol management can lead to increased of people with AUDs do not seek
dependent and nondependent participants selfefficacy for abstinence (Litt et al. treatment, and most of them are able
(Guth et al. 2008). 2009), potentially by providing indi to quit drinking or maintain moderate
viduals with the experience of being drinking without receiving formal
Contingency Management Approaches. abstinent from alcohol (Witkiewitz treatment. Thus, most people quit
Contingency management approaches and Marlatt 2008). drinking on their own. In light of
rely more exclusively on the principles these findings, several treatments have
of operant conditioning—that is, Behavioral Couples, Marital, and been developed that aim to facilitate
they use reinforcing and punishing Family Therapy. These approaches selfchange. For example, behavioral
consequences to maintain positive incorporate a thorough assessment selfcontrol training (Miller and
behavior change. Contingency man of drinking behaviors and an analysis Munoz 1982) and guided selfchange
agement approaches, which often are of relationship factors that may influ (Sobell and Sobell 1993; also see
departments or trauma centers (Gentilello which best can be characterized as a which instigate and maintain prob
et al. 1995; Monti et al. 2007) indi cognitive–behavioral approach focusing lematic drinking patterns.
cates that these alternative treatment on coping skills training and identifi Those in the alcohol research field
settings might be essential for helping cation of highrisk situations for relapse, have learned over the years that many
people who otherwise would have not has been expanded to incorporate 8 people change between making the
sought treatment. Accordingly, those weeks of group training in mindfulness decision to enter treatment or an initial
treatment approaches that can be meditation (Bowen et al., in press). evaluation and actually starting the
adapted to different treatment settings The results suggest significant reduc first treatment session. Consistent
are particularly useful. Most of the tions in substance use, including with this observation, the provision
behavioral approaches described above alcohol use and polysubstance use, of specific treatments targeted to
can be adapted for multiple settings and craving for substances in the first address certain individual characteristics
(e.g., inpatient or outpatient treatment, four months following the interven determined at pretreatment evaluation
community centers, schools, primary tion (Bowen et al. 2009). has not led to substantial improve
care clinics, or emergency rooms) and ments in treatment outcomes (Project
delivery methods (e.g., phone, Internet, MATCH Research Group 1998). For
computerbased, postal mail), and a Understanding How example, recent analyses of data from
growing body of research evidence People Change the COMBINE Study (COMBINE
supports the adaptability of behavioral Study Research Group 2006)3 indi
interventions. The adaptation of these The majority of metaanalyses and cated that craving scores decreased
approaches to different delivery methods, controlled treatment trials have con significantly between the baseline
in particular, has great promise to change cluded that most active treatments are assessment and the first treatment
the face of treatment for AUDs. As equally effective; therefore, it might be session (Witkiewitz 2009). Likewise,
discussed in more detail in the article more important to focus on defining people with lower levels of craving at
by Gustafson and colleagues (pp. 327– exactly what treatment components are baseline did not especially benefit
337 in this issue), computer and Web responsible for this effectiveness. For from receiving a specialized treatment
based approaches are likely to greatly example, Moos (2007) described four session designed to impact craving.
expand the availability of evidence related theories that help explain the Thus, identifying a specific treatment
based behavioral treatment strategies. active ingredients that are common for a certain person (e.g., motivation
For example, an approach called to most effective treatments, drawing enhancement therapy for a person
ComputerBased Training in CBT upon social control theory, behavioral with low motivation) may be less use
(CBT4CBT) can predict greater treat economics and behavioral choice theory, ful than identifying those treatment
ment engagement and decreased drug social learning theory, and stress and elements and settings that are most
use compared with usual treatment coping theory to explain common appropriate for a given patient. For
(Carroll et al. 2008). Similarly, the components of effective treatment. example, a patient with no social
Drinker’s Checkup, a computerbased According to this analysis, important support system potentially might
brief intervention, can reduce the components included the following: receive greater benefit from a behav
quantity and frequency of drinking by ioral treatment that provided social
50 percent, with reductions sustained • Social support; support or skills for increasing social
through 12 months following the inter support for abstinence. Conversely,
vention (Hester et al. 2005). Finally, the • Structure and goal direction; a person who does not have much
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and time to attend treatment sessions
Alcoholism (NIAAA) recently launched • Provision of rewards and rewarding might benefit more from a Web
a selfchange Web site and booklet of activities; based intervention. And people who
called Rethinking Drinking (http:// are concerned about the implications
rethinkingdrinking.niaaa.nih.gov/) that • Normative models for successful of receiving formal treatment might
provides interactive feedback and tools abstinence; be best suited by selfchange methods.
for helping people cut back on their Thus, it is important for treatment
drinking. Rethinking Drinking is freely • Enhancement of selfefficacy; and professionals, concerned family
available and has the ability to reach members, and patients who want to
millions of people who might be think • Teaching of coping skills. change their drinking behavior to
ing about changing their drinking consider “what will work best for
behavior on their own. A focus on such empirically me?” rather than “what treatment
In another adaptation of existing supported treatment processes, rather works best?” For researchers it is
treatments, recent research indicates the than on different treatment modalities,
3
potential value of adding mindfulness might provide an opportunity for a The COMBINE Study was a multisite randomized clinical trial
designed to test the effectiveness of pharmacotherapy with or
training to existing behavioral treat more general treatment of AUDs that without combined behavioral intervention in the treatment of
ments for AUDs. Relapse prevention, is linked explicitly to the core processes alcohol dependence.
Financial Disclosure LITT, M.D.; KADDEN, R.M.; KABELACORMIER, E.; RIMMELE, C.T.; HOWARD, M.O.; AND HILFRINK,
AND PETRY, N.M. Changing network support for M.L. Aversion therapies. In: Hester, R.K., and
drinking: Network Support Project twoyear follow Miller, W.R., Eds. Handbook of Alcoholism
The authors declare that they have no up. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology Treatment Approaches (2nd Ed.). New York:
competing financial interests. 77(2):229–242, 2009. PMID: 19309183 Pergamon Press, 1995.
SOBELL, L.C.; ELLINGSTAD, T.P.; AND SOBELL, problem drinkers. Addictive Behaviors 29(2):433– WITKIEWITZ, K. “Mechanisms of Change During
M.B. Natural recovery from alcohol and drug 439, 2004. PMID: 14732433 and Following Cognitive Behavioral Intervention
problems: Methodological review of the research for Alcohol Dependence: An Analysis of the
WALTERS, S.T.; BENNETT, M.E.; AND NOTO, J.V.
with suggestions for future directions. Addiction Drinking on campus. What do we know about COMBINE Data.” Research Society on Alcoholism
95(5):749–764, 2000. PMID: 10885050 reducing alcohol use among college students? 5th Annual PreConference Satellite Meeting on
Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment 19(3):223– Mechanisms of Behavior Change, San Diego, CA:
SOBELL, M.B., AND SOBELL, L.C. Problem Drinkers
228, 2000. PMID: 11027891 June 20, 2009.
Guided SelfChange Treatment. New York: Guilford
Press, 1993. WEISS, R.D.; O’MALLEY, S.S.; HOSKING, J.D.; ET
WITKIEWITZ, K., AND MARLATT, G.A. Why and
AL. Do patients with alcohol dependence respond
TUCKER, J.A.; VUCHINICH, R.E.; AND RIPPENS, to placebo? Results from the COMBINE Study. how do substance abuse treatments work?
P.D. Different variables are associated with help Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs 69(6):878– Investigating mediated change. Addiction
seeking patterns and longterm outcomes among 884, 2008. PMID: 18925346 103(4):649–650, 2008. PMID: 18339109
RETHINKING DRINKING
Alcohol and Your Health
Announcing NIAAA’s new
fully interactive Web site
and supporting booklet,
Rethinking Drinking.
Visit
RethinkingDrinking.niaaa.nih.gov
Download a pdf or order online (www.RethinkingDrinking.niaaa.nih.gov) or write to:
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, Publications Distribution Center,
P.O. Box 10686, Rockville, MD 20849–0686 Fax: (703) 3125230.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
National Institutes of Health • National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism