Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EXECUTION
1.0. INTRODUCTION
Wal-Mart is the world’s largest company by revenue and the largest retailer in
the world (See Annex 1). The company is a retail market leader in the U.S.
and is a major competitor in all geographic markets in which it operates.
Forbes listed Wal-Mart as the 24th most valuable brand in the world in 2018,
worth US$24.1 billion. No other direct competitor, except Amazon, has made
it to the Forbes list of the top 50 most valuable brands.
1
six steps are: strategy implementing and lastly carrying out an evaluation of
the whole process.
Wal-Mart Inc.’s corporate mission is “to save people money so they can live
better.” This statement reflects the ideals of the company’s founder, Sam
Walton. Strategic decisions in the business are a direct manifestation of this
mission statement, which is synonymous to the company’s slogan, “Save
money. Live better.” Based on this statement, it is clear that Wal-Mart’s
business strategies involve using price as a selling point to attract target
consumers. The significance of such a selling point is exhibited in many of the
company’s strategies. For example, Wal-Mart Inc.’s marketing mix or 4P
involves low prices as a strategy. Other areas of the company are determined
by the need to minimize selling prices as a way to achieve competitiveness.
Wal-Mart fulfils the “save people money” component of the mission statement
through its low selling prices. For example, consumers save money by
spending less in buying goods from the company’s stores, compared to
buying the same or similar goods from midscale and high-end stores.
However, it is not yet clear if the company satisfies the “live better” component
of this corporate mission. There are criticisms regarding very low wages that
pose challenges for Wal-Mart’s employees when it comes to improving their
lives, in addition to various human resource management issues in the
organization. There are also criticisms about the long-term economic effects
of the company’s large-scale sales of cheap imported goods.
2
2.3. Business Model Canvas for the Wal-Mart
1) Key Partners
a) Direct Suppliers
b) Landlords
c) Investors
d) Manufactures
e) International Labor Organization
2) Key Activities
3) Key Resources
a) Vendor Relationships
b) Distribution systems
c) Highly Skilled Management
d) Purchasing and Procurement
4) Value Proposition
5) Customer Relationships
a) Mobile Apps
b) Advertisements
c) Mailing
6) Channels
a) Physical stores
b) Online stores
7) Customer Segments
3
a) Low Income
b) Frugal
c) Rural Customer Base
8) Cost Structure
9) Revenue Streams
a) Financial Services
b) Commissions
c) Retail Sales
d) Warranties & Insurance
a) Economic Crisis
b) Discovering new, less expensive outsourcing opportunities
c) Building strong relationships with 3-F printing industry
(Source: https://prezi.com/wfitrhvbsx0s/wal-mart-business-model-canvas/)
4
3.0 STRATEGIC ANALYSIS
Hypothesis
Core Assumptions
This hypothesis needs to be applied against the following tests: the value test,
the execution test, the scale test and the defensibility test. As technology
continues to shape the way we shop online, the market and customers
demands that Wal-Mart Infrastructure evolve with these advances so that it
continues to provide value to the Customers on shopping in stores, online or
with their phones which is more seamless than it used to be. Wal-Mart
possesses unique assets and capabilities to serve customers with their
stores, clubs, global supply chain, data and great associates and how they
integrate with each other. Wal-Mart want their customers to find what they
want, at a value, in a convenient, enjoyable way, regardless of how they shop.
Wal-Mart customer proposition is focused on four areas – price, access,
assortment and experience, thus passing the value test.
This hypothesis would pass the scale test because on the e-commerce front,
Wal-Mart provide those same things through an expanded assortment of
approximately 8 million items on walmart.com in the U.S. Interestingly, 75
percent of walmart.com sales come from non-store inventory, thus providing
incremental sales growth beyond our stores. And, this is a global effort. In
Brazil, for example, Wal-Mart online assortment, including from marketplace
partners, grew 10-fold last year.
5
All these core assumptions need to pass the defensibility test.
Lastly, these core assumptions need to pass the defensibility test. While it is
possible for other competitors or potential competitors to imitate Wal-Mart
information and technology infrastructure but they have a long way to go to
keep up with Wal-Mart since in all markets, Wal-Mart is committed to
providing customers convenient access to Wal-Mart. They are innovating
through e-commerce, mobile and various pickup sites to provide customers
more shopping options than ever before. They are especially focused on
grocery home shopping, with expanded operations in the U.K., Mexico and
Japan. Asda doubled its Click & Collect sites, and in Japan, Wal-Mart
automated the order picking process to fulfill Seiyu.com grocery orders more
efficiently and sustainably. E-commerce sales growth has been strong. Brazil
e-commerce sales in fiscal 2015 grew faster than the market despite strong
competitive pressures, and in China, Yihaodian saw traffic increase more than
60 percent. No matter the shopper preference, we’ll continue to strive to be
the destination of choice.
In summary, the core assumptions pass all four tests. Since the assumptions
passed all four tests, we can put them up against a series of thought
experiments to identify the following: what we know, what we don’t know,
what we don’t know but can and what we don’t know but can’t.
We know that Price leadership is core to who Wal-Mart are. Everyday low
cost ("EDLC") is our commitment to control expenses so those cost savings
can be passed along to our customers. Wal-Mart Omni-channel presence
provides customers access to our broad assortment anytime and anywhere.
We strive to give our customers and members a great digital and physical
shopping experience.
6
We know that during fiscal 2018, we generated total revenues of $500.3
billion, which was primarily comprised of net sales of $495.8 billion.” (Figure
1).
What does ‘being the largest retailer in the world’ mean to Wal-Mart?
Economies of scale. The company can share its fixed costs over many
products, which makes Wal-Mart one of the cheapest places to shop.
Huge gains from implementing best practice. The company can identify
better ways of performing tasks; managing stores and hiring new
employees and can achieve huge gains by implementing these best
practices in its vast network of stores.
Market power over suppliers and competitors. Due to its size, Wal-Mart
can exercise its market power over suppliers by requiring lower prices
from them. The company can also affect the competition by selling
selected items at a loss, thus driving competition out of the market.
What we do not know is that what will happen after 5 years from now taking
into consideration that information technology is changing fast and that way
can Wal-Mart maintain its retailer superiority in the world?
7
4.0 STRATEGIC IMPLEMENTATION
First, we will look at alignment while applying the 4A Model (Annex 2) to Wal-
Mart. Let us go straight to alignment to determine if Walmat is aligned both
externally and internally. Wal-Mart Constant improvements of assortment,
price and access are basis of Wal-Mart business strategy. In simple terms,
Wal-Mart strives to offer the widest choice of products for the cheapest price,
along with giving customers the opportunity of choosing the most convenient
channel to facilitate the purchase.
Wall Mart competitive advantage relies on cost leadership. Moreover, the
strategic level management consistently aims to associate Wall Mart
competitive advantage with price, access, assortment and experience. Since
his appointment as CEO in February 2014, Doug McMillion introduced
important changes in Wal-Mart business strategy in the following three
directions:
1) Increasing focus on customer services. In February 2015, the company
announced a USD1 billion investment in U.S. hourly associates to
provide higher wages, more training and increased opportunities to
build a career with Wal-Mart.
2) Improving groceries. Due to increasing level of health-consciousness of
consumers, Wal-Mart is attempting to increase its range of organic
options and fresh produce. This change is more evident in the US
market and it is being actively integrated into marketing communication
message of the brand.
3) Enhancing the flexibility of the shopping experience. It has been noted
“Wal-Mart is working to integrate its physical stores with the digital
business”. For example, thanks to the latest changes, customers are
able to collect their online orders from stores and they can also get text
reminders from the pharmacy.
The next segment of the 4A Model we will look at is ability to implement its
strategy focusing on talent.
8
According to Bryon, the global business landscape is rapidly evolving. No
longer can talent acquisition professionals wait for job candidates to reach out
to organizations. Instead, organizations must take a proactive approach to
talent acquisition, or they risk missing out on opportunities to attract, hire and
retain qualified professionals.
At Wal-Mart, the business was forced to revamp its talent acquisition strategy
to keep up with the pace of change in the retail market, Bryon said. Wal-Mart
evaluated its talent acquisition strategy, and ultimately, found that it needed to
develop new strategies to find talent in time.
"The pace of change in retail is really fast. And if you're not keeping up with it
and don't have the right skills to create strategies, you're going to find yourself
in a position where you're not viable in the marketplace for very long," Bryon
stated.
With the ability to find talent in time, an organization can employ the right
professionals, at the right time, every time, Bryon indicated. This capability
can make a world of difference for any organization, as it enables an
organization to consistently connect with top talent when necessary.
9
Wal-Mart operates on a line of business (or divisional) organizational
structure, which has helped them to move to the top and stay at the top of the
retail division.
The chain of command is going from the top, or CEO, down to the lower level
managers in each department in each store. The accountability is going down
from the lower end managers at each store to the top executive or CEO. The
functional structure would not work for Wal-Mart because it is an organization
structure that is designed for smaller businesses with little to no chain of
command and communication within its company. The Matrix structure “is a
hybrid of divisional and functional structure (Writing, 2014). This particular
structure can create power struggles because there are different managers
working in area with the same level of Authority.
The customer base within the Wal-Mart Corporation is a very versatile part of
the corporation. Due to them having stores worldwide, they have many
different cultures and nationalities shopping at their locations for a variety of
things. With this, they have to base their product on their location so that they
can provide for the local consumers and keep them coming back.
Out of all the organizational structures, Wal-Mart would not have gotten where
it is today if they used a functional structure or a matrix structure. Using the
line of business (or divisional) structure has very profitable for the Wal-Mart
Corporation. It has allowed them to divert power among the different store
managers and district managers and to build and maintain a customer based
that is devoted to them.
10
With regards to agility segment of the 4A Model, which evaluates an
organization’s ability to be responsive and nimble with their strategy to drive
performance, as part of an effort to make the world’s largest retailer more
agile, Wal-Mart Labs has been working behind the scenes to define a micro
services architecture that leverages a two-year effort to change the
organization’s approach to DevOps. Now Wal-Mart Labs is looking to share
the fruits of those investments by contributing the core code it uses to
manage DevOps to the open-source community.
Kimmet says that Wal-Mart Labs has decided to make OneOps an open-
source project to give back to the open-source community it has been relying
on for core technology since 2011. Specifically, the retailer is making use of
open-source technologies such as Node.js and Cassandra databases to
make it possible to construct various applications using thousands of micro
services that can be dynamically invoked using well-defined application
programming interfaces (APIs).
“We have a motto that says 'if you built it, you own it,'” he says. “OneOps
gave us a solid foundation to accomplish that goal.”
11
Hose new applications, which span everything from mobile devices to the
Internet of things (IoT), are crucial weapons in a global e-commerce contest
that pits Wal-Mart against the likes of Amazon and Alibaba, as well as a
host of other rivals that are emerging as the cost of entry into the online
retail sector continues to decline in the age of the API economy.
In fact, Wal-Mart just predicted that its sales growth for this year would only
be in the range of 2 to 3 percent, rather than the 5 percent it previously
forecast. Since then, the company’s stock has been taking a pounding on
Wall Street, wiping out millions of dollars in valuation.
In the last few years, Hurwitz says, the company has made a lot of progress
in terms of providing an improved customer experience that spans both their
online and retail outlets. But overall, she adds, Wal-Mart continues to play
catch-up.
Much like many IT organizations these days, a core part of the Wal-Mart IT
strategy is to hire lots of engineering talent to build new applications using
open-source software. But Scott Crawford, an industry analyst with 451
Research, notes that open-source software cuts both ways in terms of
benefits and costs.
“With open-source software, you can lower your costs and gain more
visibility into the code,” says Crawford. “But support can be a challenge in
the sense of finding a fix to a particular issue because there isn't one vendor
throat to choke.”
Regardless of how the company goes about becoming more agile from a
technology perspective, IT organizations across the board would be well-
advised to pay close attention to how the retailer’s IT strategy is evolving.
As a company that generates billions of dollars in annual sales, Wal-Mart
has an impact on almost every part of the economy in one form or another.
12
So, when Wal-Mart changes the way its applications interact with its
backend systems, it’s only a matter of time before every organization that
does business with the retailer will be required to follow suit.
5.0. CONCLUSION
13
6.0. ADDENDUM OF EXHIBITS AND CITATIONS
Countries served 28 35 11 9 14
14
Figure 2: Source: http://www.larrykeiter.com/site/wp-
content/uploads/2015/12/WalMart_Alignment_Mission.jpg.
Figure 3
15
One step down the hierarchy form the above, Wal-Mart executive team
comprises 29 senior managers for the following roles:
1. Executive Vice President and Treasurer
2. Executive Vice President, Softlines and General Merchandise, Wal-Mart
U.S.
3. Executive Vice President, Corporate Affairs
4. Chief Operating Officer, Global ecommerce
5. Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
6. Chief Merchandising Officer, Wal-Mart U.S.
7. Executive Vice President, Global People Division
8. Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Wal-Mart U.S.
9. Executive Vice President, Chief Administrative Officer
10. Executive Vice President, Operations, Sam’s Club
11. Executive Vice President-Merchandising, Sam’s Club
12. Executive Vice President, Global Governance and Corporate Secretary
13. Executive Vice President, Consumables and Health and Wellness and
U.S. Manufacturing Lead
14. Executive Vice President, Merchandising Operations, Wal-Mart U.S.
15. President and CEO, Samsclub.com
16. Executive Vice President, Global Chief Ethics and Compliance Officer
17. President and CEO, Walmart.com
18. Chief Operating Officer, Wal-Mart U.S.
19. Executive Vice President, Supercenters – Wal-Mart U.S.
20. Executive Vice President, Neighborhood Markets – Wal-Mart U.S.
21. Chief Administrative Officer – Wal-Mart International; President and
CEO, Wal-Mart Asia
22. Executive Vice President, Food, Wal-Mart U.S.
23. Executive Vice President and General Counsel, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.
24. Senior Vice President and Chief Marketing Officer of Wal-Mart U.S.
25. Executive Vice President, International People Division
26. Executive Vice President, Logistics, Wal-Mart U.S.
27. Executive Vice President, Chief Information Officer
28. Senior Vice President and Controller
29. Executive Vice President, Global Sourcing
16
Figure 4. Wal-Mart organizational structure at operational level (source: https://research-
methodology.net/walmart-leadership-and-walmart-organizational-structure/)
17
Annex 1: Company Background
Key Facts
Name Wal-Mart Inc.
Founded July 2, 1962
Logo
Annex 2: 4A Module
18
Alignment Agility
Talent Architecture
6.2. CITATIONS
1.0. https://www.slideshare.net/giantepedino/strategy-implementation-wal-mart-
case?from_action=save. Internet Accessed on 27/12/2018.
2.0. http://panmore.com/walmart-swot-analysis-recommendations-case-study.
Internet Accessed on 27/12/2018.
3.0. https://www.strategicmanagementinsight.com/swot-analyses/walmart-swot-
analysis.html. Internet Accessed on 27/12/2018.
4.0. https://research-methodology.net/walmart-business-strategy/. Internet
Accessed on 27/12/2018.
5.0. Strategic Management An in depth analysis of Wal-Mart and its global strategic
management and electronic distribution Analysis for Business Policy: Strategic
Management. Instructor: Dr. M. Reitzel, DeVry University, February 2007, Austin, TX.
6.0. https://research-methodology.net/walmart-stores-inc-report-2/. Internet
Accessed on 27/12/2018.
7.0. https://www.businessinsider.com/wal-marts-new-strategy-2015-2? Internet
Accessed on 27/12/2018.
8.0. http://www.argylejournal.com/chief-human-resources-officer/walmart-talent-
acquisition/. Internet Accessed on 27/12/2018.
9.0. https://research-methodology.net/walmart-leadership-and-walmart-
organizational-structure/. Internet Accessed on 30/12/2018.
10.0. https://lawaspect.com/organizational-structure-walmart/. Internet Accessed on
30/12/2018.
11.0. http://www.baselinemag.com/enterprise-apps/walmart-embraces-
microservices-to-get-more-agile.html. Internet Accessed on 30/12/2018.
19