Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/312023621
CITATIONS READS
0 173
5 authors, including:
Confidence Muzerengi
University of Venda
11 PUBLICATIONS 28 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Jabulani Gumbo on 07 June 2017.
158
Int'l Conf. on Advances in Science, Engineering, Technology & Natural Resources (ICASETNR-16) Nov. 24-25, 2016 Parys (South Africa)
there is still potential for gold in Giyani green stone belt where profile (20-25 cm) per procedure of [15]. For studies on vertical
the mine is located. The general objective was to assess the dispersion of mercury, at each sample site, a sample was
distribution of mercury in mine tailings and stream sediments in collected at a depth of 20-25 cm of the stream sediment. The
the study location of New Union Gold Mine. The specific collected tailings and stream sediment samples were sealed in
objectives were: to determine the levels of mercury at top and plastic sachets, labeled with date of sampling, GPS coordinates
bottom profiles at each sampling site (vertical migration) and and then transported in a cooler box (with ice) to the University
then horizontal migration of mercury from each sampling site of Venda laboratory for further processing.
towards the Mandzoro River. TABLE I
DESCRIPTION OF SAMPLING POINTS AT NEW UNION GOLD MINE AND STUDY
SITE
II. CHARACTERISTICS OF THE STUDY AREA
Sample Site name Description
The New Union Gold Mine is situated in Ka-Madonsi village A1 Mine Tailings dam A Mine Tailings dam A
close to Malamulele town, Limpopo province in South Africa A2 Mine Tailings dam A Mine Tailings dam A
(Fig. 1). The occurrence of gold mineralization is controlled Mine Tailings dam B Mine Tailings dam B
B1
spatially by the presence of folding, which caused gold to Mine Tailings dam B Mine Tailings dam B
B2
concentrate in fold hinges. Gold is texturally associated with a Stream 1 (green colour) The site is upstream and it drains the
sulphur-rich arsenopyrite in garnetiferous, biotite-rich bands S1 mine shaft and gold ore processing
[6]. The banded iron-formation (BIF) unit changed from plant
predominately silicate facies near surface, to sulphide facies S2 Stream 2 (blue colour) The site receives water inflows from the
mine tailings A and B
with depth. Geologically, the study area is formed of Archean
S3 Stream 3 (yellow The site receives water inflows from
granite, which invaded the older highly metamorphosed colour) stream 2 and continuation of stream 1
micaceous quartzite, banded ironstone and amphibolites [6]. S4 Stream 4 (yellow The site is midstream of stream 1
The study area is arid, with a dry season that stretches from colour) flowing towards Mandzoro River
April to October with high temperatures of 40 oC and minimum S5 Mandzoro river (river The site is part of upstream Mandzoro
colour) River before stream 4
or no rain [14]. The wet season is from November to March with
S6 Mandzoro river (river The site is part of downstream
temperature range of 25 to 30oC and the annual precipitation is colour) Mandzoro River
less than 450 mm [14]. The mine tailings samples were
collected from four sites on the tailings dams A and B (Figure 2.2 Sample preparation
1). For horizontal dispersion of mercury, six sampling sites were The mine tailings and sediment samples were air dried in at
selected on the stream (stream 1) that drains the tailings dams the laboratory. The dried samples were then milled by Retsch
and then joins the main stream (stream 2) that flows towards RS 200 grinding mill machine for 2 min to 80% fine or <75 µm
Mandzoro River, a tributary of Shingwedzi River. using ring mill. The milled samples were then weighed (Radwag
BP balance), 5 g of each was then transferred into a 200 ml glass
beaker for acid digestion with 20 ml of nitric acid AR. The
beakers were then placed on a hot plate for about one hour to
allow digestion to occur. The digested solutions were then
transferred to a 100 ml volumetric flasks and de-ionized water
was added to reach the mark. The samples were homogenized
by shaking the flask.
2.3 pH and electrical conductivity measurements of stream
sediments
From each stream sediment sample, 100 g was weighed and
Fig. 1 The location of New Union Gold Mine tailings are drained by then mixed with 100 ml of de-ionized water. After some
streams flowing towards Mandzoro River (www.Google. 2016). The vigorous shaking, the stream sediment samples were left for 30
mine tailings sampling points A1, A2, B1 and B2 and sediment min to settle. The pH and electrical conductivity measurements
sampling sites, S1 to S6 along the streams and Mandzoro the river. The
were carried out as per procedure of [16] on the same aqueous
stream flow is S1 to S4 and river flow is from S5 to S6.
sediment samples. The pH was then determined in triplicate
with a pH meter (HANNA Instrument, Germany) previously
III. MATERIALS AND METHODS
calibrated as per manufacturer’s procedure. The electrical
2.1 Sampling procedure conductivity was determined in triplicate with a conductivity
meter (Multi 340i/SET) which was calibrated using
The tailings and stream sediment samples were collected conductivity standards following the manufacturer’s protocol.
from ten sites along streams, Mandzoro River and New Union
Gold Mine tailings in September 2010. Table 1 below shows the 2.4 The analysis of total mercury
sampling points, a description and GPS coordinates. The mine The acid digested sediment samples were analyzed (in
tailings were collected at the surface, termed top soil profile duplicate) for total mercury (total Hg) at CSIR, Pretoria. The
(0-3 cm) as per procedure of [15]. The stream sediments were analytical method involved stannous chloride in acid solution
collected at the top soil profile (0-3 cm) and at the bottom soil and the procedure was based on NIOSH 6009 method (cold
159
Int'l Conf. on Advances in Science, Engineering, Technology & Natural Resources (ICASETNR-16) Nov. 24-25, 2016 Parys (South Africa)
vapour atomic absorption spectroscopy) [17]. The total Hg was Union Gold Mine sediments showed the presence of heavy
determined with a Perkin Elmer AAnalyst 700 and AS 91 auto metals, Ni, Cu, Mn, Zn, Co and Cd. The pH of the stream
sampler. sediment samples at New Union Gold Mine tailings was found
to be acidic and the range from (3.25 to 4.45) for sample points
2.5 Data analysis
1 to 4 (Fig. 2). Further from sample point S4, the pH has
The sediment and tailings raw data was expressed in mg/kg increased to >6.00 and the EC has decreased < 8 mS/cm for
(dry weight) respectfully. The statistical analysis was carried sample points S5 and S6 (Mandzoro River).
out with single factor ANOVA with the use of Microsoft Excel
18.00 7.00
to determine the significance difference between the top (0-3 EC_Top EC_bottom pH_Top pH_Bottom
6.00
IV. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
pH
12.00 5.00
The research findings indicate that mercury was present at the
four selected sites of the New Union Gold Mine tailings and the 10.00
4.50
levels of total Hg in mine tailings were above the South African 6.00 3.00
Sediment Quality Guidelines of 5 µg/g dry soil, Germany S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6
160
Int'l Conf. on Advances in Science, Engineering, Technology & Natural Resources (ICASETNR-16) Nov. 24-25, 2016 Parys (South Africa)
the two mine tailings dams. There was an erratic change in the the main stream 1 draining towards Mandzoro River. The picture was taken in
concentration of mercury in the sediments from sample point S1 September, 2010, a dry period.
to S4. The ANOVA test showed that the total Hg values Our study concurs with the study of [21] about the presence
between the upper top profiles (0-3 and 20-25 cm) were and high levels of total Hg in stream sediments close to source
significantly different (p < 0.00) for sample points S2 to S4 with of mercury contamination, but differs in the actual total Hg
the exception of sample point S1 (p > 0.30). This may be content. The study of [21] was on former Cato Ridge mercury
attributed to the vertical dispersion of mercury into the lower processing and recovery plant in Durban, South Africa. Though
layer (20-25 cm) as result of increased water inflows from the New Union Gold mine is now an inactive mine, the Hg
tailings dams. With regards to sample point S1, the high contamination is still occurring as indicated by the present
mercury concentration and evenly distribution (top and bottom study. In Ecuador, in Nambija gold mine district, inactive mines
layers) may be attributed to former gold ore processing plant are being reworked by small scale miners such that Hg levels in
that was located close to this sampling site. some of the streams and Nambija river range from 0.7 to 9.3
µg/g (mean value of 2.70 µg/g dry weight) [22]. The study of
[22] also reported even higher Hg levels, 21.33 µg/g dry weight,
in the stream sediments that were located close to gold ore
processing site.
The presence of Hg in both the top and bottom profile in the
stream sediments is a major cause of concern. A study by [21] of
an abandoned Hg processing plant in Cato Ridge, South Africa,
showed the potential migration of Hg towards groundwater
sources and possible contamination of surface water sources.
According to [10], groundwater water sources are extensively
used by rural communities for drinking water and or irrigating
their agricultural fields. The study of [23] in China,
Fig. 3 The total Hg distribution in the, top 0-3 cm and bottom 20-25 cm profile, demonstrated that the majority of total Hg was sedimented in the
of the stream sediments Xiaxi river sediments, 2.1 µg/g of total Hg, which concurs with
our study especially for sample site 6.
The Mandzoro River is approximately 2 km from the New
Mercury is a persistent toxic chemical that has a long
Union Gold Mine tailings and the stream sediments were
retention period in the stream sediments and thus, may be able
collected during the dry period when there was no water in the
to contaminate the aquatic ecosystem [24-25]. In the aquatic
river. The results indicate that there was mercury in the stream
environment, mercury may bioaccumulate in fish as methyl-Hg
sediments of Mandzoro River (Fig. 3). The ANOVA test
and become biomagnified in the food chain [26]. Thus, humans
showed that the total Hg values between the upper top profiles
are exposed to mercury contamination via a number of routes
(0-3 and 20-25 cm) were not significantly different (p > 0.15)
such as consumption of contaminated fish, drinking
for sample point S5. With regard to sample point S5, the high
contaminated water and mine tailings dust inhalation [10][27].
mercury concentration appears to be evenly distributed between
Mercury is toxic to humans as it attacks the central nervous
the top and bottom profiles. The presence and the origin of the
system and eventually leads to an incurable condition known as
mercury is difficult to ascertain at this stage except to speculate
the Minamata disease [28].
that it may be due to atmospheric Hg deposition and or seepage
(during wet summer) from the nearby New Union Gold Mine V. CONCLUSION
tailings (Fig. 4). The ANOVA test showed that the total Hg The study showed the presence of high levels of Hg in the
values between the upper top profiles (0-3 and 20-25 cm) were mine tailings ranging from 161.8 to 1999.1 µg/g. The low pH
significantly different (p < 0.00) for sample point S6. This may and high EC as a result of acid mine drainage further enhances
be attributed to the vertical dispersion of mercury into the lower the solubility and transportation total Hg from the mine tailings
layer (20-25 cm) as result of increased water inflows from the towards the river. The dispersion (horizontal and vertical) of
tailings dams via streams 1 and 2. total Hg in the stream sediments showed an erratic behaviour,
though with gradual decrease from mine tailings, 2.60 µg/g dry
weight, to the streams (0.94 µg/g dry weight) and an increase in
the stream sediments (2.40 µg/g dry weight). Hence the
presence of mercury in the environment may impact negatively
on human health and other aquatic organism since mercury is
the most toxic and bioaccumulating pollutant. Thus, mitigatory
measures such as planting indigenous grass on the exposed mine
tailings should be carried to minimize the Hg erosion of the
mine tailings.
Fig. 4 The capillary action from below ground (during wet summer time) may
cause seepage to evaporate during the dry period forming efflorescent white
crust of metal sulphate (Nsimba, 2009)[8]. This is the sample point 3 located on
161
Int'l Conf. on Advances in Science, Engineering, Technology & Natural Resources (ICASETNR-16) Nov. 24-25, 2016 Parys (South Africa)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Thailand", Water, Air and Soil Pollution: Focus, vol. 6, pp. 191-206,
2006.
The Chief of Madonsi village, community and Triangle cc for [18] NIOSH, "NIOSH Manual of Analytical Methods (NMAM), Fourth
giving us permission to have access to the New Union Gold Edition", 15 August 1994.
Mine. The University of Venda gave financial support for the http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2003-154/pdfs/6009.pdf (date accessed
21/08/12).
study project (I431) and travel costs (IP60) to attend and present [19] C.E. Steyn, H.V.H. Van Der Watt, A.S. Claassens, "On the permissible
at the 12th WaterNet/Warfsa/GWP-SA Symposium in Maputo, nickel concentration for South African soils", South African Journal of
Mozambique in 2011 and WISA Biennial conference in Cape Science, vol. 92, pp. 359-363, 1996.
Town, South Africa in 2012. [20] C. Mitileni, J.R. Gumbo, C. Muzerengi, F.A. Dacosta, "The Distribution
of Toxic Metals in Sediments: Case study of New Union Gold Mine
Tailings, Limpopo, South Africa". International Mine Water Conference,
REFERENCES
pp. 609-614, 2011.
[1] T. Viraraghavan, and M. Ionescu, "Land application of phosphorus-laden [21] E. Hagelberg, "The matrix dependent solubility and speciation of
sludge: a feasibility analysis," Journal of environmental management, mercury", 2006. http://oru.divaportal.
vol. 64, pp.171-177, Feb 2002. org/smash/record.jsf?pid=diva2:137047 (Date accessed 03/10/2011)
[2] N. Rembuluwani, F.A. Dacosta, and J.R. Gumbo, "Environmental Risk [22] ] C.R.Williams, J.J. Leaner, V.S. Somerset, J.M. Nel, "Mercury
Assessment and Risk Management Strategies for Abandoned New Union concentrations at a historically mercury-contaminated site in
Gold Mine in Malamulele, Limpopo, South Africa." Page 367-373. KwaZulu-Natal (South Africa) ". Environmental Science Pollution
International Mine Water Association conference proceedings, 2014. Research. DOI 10.1007/S11356-011-0458-8, 2011
[3] DEAT "Screening. Integrated Environmental Management Information [23] M.E. Ramìrez-Requelme, J.F.F. Ramos, R.S. Angélica E.S. Brabo,
series 1". (2002). Department of Environmental Affairs and Tourism, "Assessment of Hg contamination in soils and streams in the mineral
Pretoria. RSA. district of Nambija, Ecuadorian Amazon (example of an impacted area
[4] C.M. Flynn, & S.L. McGill, "Cyanide Chemistry- Precious Metals affected by artisanal gold mining) ", Applied Geochemistry, vol.18, pp.
Processing and Waste Treatment". USA Bureau of Mines. NTIS 371-381, 2003.
Publication PB96-117841, 1995. [24] Y. Lin, T. Larssen, R.D. Vogt, X. Feng, H. Zhang, "Transport and fate of
[5] D. Banks, "Hydrogeochemistry of coal mine drainage and other mercury under different hydrologic regimes in polluted stream in mining
ferruginous waters in north Derbyshire and South Yorkshire, UK". area", Journal of Environmental Sciences, vol. 23, pp. 757-764, 2011.
Quarterly Journal of Engineering Geology, vol.30, pp. 257-280, 1997. [25] WHO "Methylmercury, Environmental Health Criteria 101". World
[6] W. Pulles, S. Banister, M. Van Biljon, M, "The development of Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland, 1990.
appropriate procedures towards and after closure of underground gold [26] V. Papu-Zamxaka, T. Harpham, A. Mathee, "Environmental legislation
mines from a water management perspective". WRC Report No. and contamination: The gap between theory and reality in South Africa",
1215/1/05. Water Research Commission, Pretoria, 2005. Journal of Environmental Management, vol. 91, pp. 2275-2280, 2010.
[7] G.A. Potgieter & J.P.R De Villiers, "Controls of mineralization at [27] O.S. Fatoki, R. Awofolu, "Levels of Cd, Hg and Zn in some surface
Sutherland Greenstone Belt". South African Journal of Geology, vol. 1, waters from Eastern Cape Province, South Africa", Water SA, vol. 29, pp.
pp. 197- 203, 1986. 375-380, 2003.
[8] United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), "Current [28] H.M. Conesa, A.B. Moradi, B.H. Robinson, G. Kűhne, E. Lehmann, R.
Drinking Water Standards. Ground Water and Drinking Water", 13 p., Schulin, "Response of native grasses and Cicer arietinum to soil polluted
2000 with mining wastes: Implications for the management of land adjacent to
[9] E.B. Nsimba, "Cyanide and cyanide complexes in the Gold Mine Polluted mine sites". Environmental and Experimental Botany, vol. 65,pp.
Land in the East and Central Rand Goldfields, South Africa". Master’s 198-204, 2009.
thesis. University of Witwatersrand, South Africa, [29] S. Bose-O’Reilly, B. Lettmeier, R.M. Gothe, C. Beinhoff, U. Siebert, G.
2009http://wiredspace.wits.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10539/7052/MSc-dis Drasch,"Mercury as a serious health hazard for children in gold mining
sertation-elysee.pdf?sequence=2 (date accessed 23/08/2012). areas", Environmental Research, vol. 107, pp. 89-97, 2008
[10] S. Appiah-opoku, "Environmental impact assessment in developing
countries: the case of Ghana". Environmental Impact Assessment Review, Professor Jabulani Ray Gumbo graduated with a PhD in
vol. 21, pp. 59-71, 2001. Water Resources Management from University of Pretoria in
[11] K. Naicker, E. Cukrowska, T.S. McCarthy, "Acid mine drainage arising 2007. He was awarded the second best student poster price at
from gold mining activity in Johannesburg, South Africa and environs". the 12th International Conference on Harmful Algae in 2006
Environmental pollution, vol. 122, pp. 29-40, 2003. and the study was then published in the prestigious conference
[12] G. Mulugisi, J.R. Gumbo, F.A. Dacosta, C. Muzerengi, "The Use of proceedings after a rigorous peer review process. This author
Indigenous Grass species as part of Rehabilitation of Mine Tailings: A became a Member (M) of International Society for the Study of Harmful
Case study of New Union Gold Mine". International Mine Water Algae; International Mine Water Association; Water Institute of Southern
Conference. Page 609-614, 2009. Africa; Microscopy Society of Southern Africa and South African Council
[13] F. Winde, P. Wade, I.J.Van der Walt, "Gold tailings as a source of for Natural Scientific Professions. In 2008, he was appointed as a senior
waterborne uranium contamination of streams the Koekmoerspruit lecturer at University of Venda and in 2016 he was appointed as Associate
(Klerksdorp goldfield, South Africa) as a case study. Part I of III: Uranium Professor. He is the first or second author of more than 40 peer reviewed
migration along the aqueous pathway", Water S,.vol. 30, pp. 219-239, papers and co-authored a chapter in a book. He acts as a reviewer for NRF in
2004. the fields of cyanobacteria and has been invited to be a reviewer for Ohio Sea
[14] W.D. Bullen, (1995). "The Metallogeny of the Petersburg and Tzaneen Grant Proposal (USA); Journal of Applied Phycology (Australia);
areas. Geological Survey of South Africa", South Africa, pp 3-6, 1995. Bioresource Technology Journal (BITE) (USA); Journal of Freshwater
[15] T.R. Nkuna, "The Monitoring of Groundwater Level and Groundwater Ecology (Britain); South African Journal of Science (SAJS) (South Africa)
Quality Fluctuation in Madonsi Boltman B village, Limpopo Province, and African Journal of Biotechnology (AJB) (Nigeria). He lectures students
South Africa". Honours thesis (unpublished). University of Venda, at undergraduate and postgraduate levels in the fields of water treatment;
Thohoyandou, 2007. water quality management; water law and institutions; rural water supply
[16] P. Van Straaten, "Mercury contamination associated with small-scale and sanitation; data information systems and water quality principles and he
gold mining in Tanzania and Zimbabwe", The Science of the Total supervises several Honours, Masters and PhD students in the fields of water
Environment, vol. 259, pp. 105-113, 2000. quality management; aquatic ecotoxicology and limnology and water
[17] P. Sampanpanish, W. Pongsapich, S. Khaodhiar, E. Khan, "Chromium treatment.
removal from soil by phytoremediation with weed plant species in
162