Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fig.1. Paraschistura nielseni, 55.7 mm SL, collected from Shapur River, in the Persis basin, southern Iran.
found in inland waters of Turkmenistan, east of and stained using alcian blue and alizarin red based
Baluchistan in Iran, and the Indus River in Pakistan on Taylor & Van Dyke (1985). The skeletal
and Afghanistan (Coad 2015; Freyhof et al. 2015). structures were dissected and photographed using a
Paraschistura nielseni (Nalbant & Bianco 1998) (Fig. scanner (Epson v600) equipped with a glycerol bath.
1) is endemic to Iranian inland waters commonly The skeletal structure of cleared and stained
called sagmahi-ye Nielseni (Coad 2015). In 1966, specimens were observed and studied by an
this species was described by Bărănescu and Nalbant MS5Leica stereomicroscope. The skeletal elements
as Nemacheilus bampurensis (Coad 2015; Freyhof et were drawn based on digital pictures using
al. 2015). Paraschistura nielseni is known from the CorelDrawX6 software. Nomenclature and
Helleh and Mond River drainages (Persis basin) abbreviation of the skeletal elements were based on
which drain to the northern Persian Gulf (Freyhof et Prokofiev (2009).
al. 2015). Due to difficulties in using external
morphology of the members of this genus for Results
studying their taxonomy and limited information on Neurocranium: The anterior part of the neurocranium
these species, the present study was conducted to is narrower and its posterior part is approximately
provide a detailed description of osteological oval-shaped. The maximum width of the skull is
characteristic of P. nielseni. Since, osteological formed at the level of the pterotic. The ethmoid
features are important in the taxonomy of the family region comprises of the paired lateral ethmoid and,
Nemacheilidae; the results of this study can be used unpaired prevomer and supraethmoid-ethmoid (Fig.
as a reference to more accurately compare and 2a). The supraethmoid-ethmoid is a stretched bone
distinguish different species of the genus. that is vertically fused to the prevomer and firmly
connected to the frontal by a zigzag gap posteriorly.
Materials and Methods In the anterior part of the neurocranium, the paired L-
Twelve specimens of P. nielseni (38-65 mm in shaped lateral ethmoids are present. The lateral
standard length) were collected by electrofishing ethmoid possesses a well-developed anterior process
from the Shapur River (Helleh drainage, Persis basin, and also possesses a rod-like processes posteriorly.
Fars Province, Iran) (51°33'06"E, 29°45'44"N). The The prevomer is almost square-shaped and connected
collected specimens were anesthetized in 1% clove to the orbitosphenoid and parasphenoid posteriorly
solution and then fixed in 5% buffered formalin. For (Fig. 2b).
osteological examination, specimens were cleared Several small and free bones are connected to the
156
Azimi et al.-Osteological characteristics of Paraschistura nielseni
of Cobitis avicennae
Fig.2. Neurocranium of Paraschistura nielseni (from the dorsal (a), lateral (b), and ventral (c) sides): pr-Bo: basioccipital
process; Bo: basioccipital; Epo: epiotic; Exo: exoccipital ; fon: fontanelle; Fr: frontal; fr-Exo: foramen exoccipital; Let:
lateral ethmoid; Orb: orbitosphenoid; Pa: parietal; Pe: prevomer; Pro: prootic; Ps: parasphenoid; Pto: pterotic; Pts:
pterosphenoid; Se: supraethmoid-ethmoid; Soc: supraoccipital; Spo: sphenotic.
ethmoid part of the neurocranium, including the connecting to the prepalatine laterally (Fig. 3a). Also,
unpaired kinethmoid, paired preethmoids-II and this bone is connected to the anterior edge of the
prepalatines (Fig. 3). The preethmoid-II is rod-like prevomer posteriorly and to the maxilla anteriorly.
157
Iranian Journal of Ichthyology (September 2015), 2(3): 155-164
158
Azimi et al.-Osteological characteristics of Paraschistura nielseni
of Cobitis avicennae
to the prevomer laterally. Also, this bone is
connected to the prepalatine, preethmoid-II and
endopterygoid anteriorly and posteriorly,
respectively. The endopterygoid is elongated and it is
connected to the metapterygoid and ectopterygoid
ventrally. This bone is connected to the autopalatine
by a condyle anteriorly. The metapterygoid is almost
rectangular in shape and positioned between the
hyomandibular and quadrate. The hyomandibular is
extended longitudinally and its dorsal part is wider.
This bone has two developed processes in its anterior
Fig.5. Lateral view of suspensorium in Paraschistura and posterior margins and connected to the interhyal
nielseni. Apl: autopalatine; Ect: ectopterygoid; End:
endopterygoid; Hm: hyomandibular; Io: interopercle; and symplectic ventrally and to the metapterygoid
Mtp: metapterygoid; Op: opercle; Po: preopercle; Q: anteriorly. There are two hyomandibular condyles in
quadrate; So: subopercle; Sym: symplectic.
the dorsal margin of the hyomandibular for
pterosphenoid, sphenotic and prootic, and the articulation to the neurocranium.
posterior one by the sphenotic and pterotic. The The quadrate has a pointed and stretched ventral
parietal, frontal, and supraoccipital are contributed in process inclined posteriorly (Fig. 5). Also, this bone
the formation fontanel that is covered by a connective is connected to the endopterygoid dorsally and
tissue and extended longitudinally (Fig. 2a). metapterygoid posteriorly. The symplectic is almost
Jaws: The upper jaw comprises the maxilla and triangular in shape and situated under the
praemaxilla (Fig. 4a). The premaxilla is a narrow L- endopterygoid and posterior to the quadrate. The
shaped bone and composed of two parts, i.e. ectopterygoid bears a pointed process anteriorly and
ascending and alveolar premaxilla processes. The a downward process ventrally.
horizontal part is arc-shaped and vertical part is Opercular series: The opercular series consist of the
narrower and longer (Fig. 4a). The maxilla is a large opercle, preopercle, subopercle, and interopercle
laminar bone and slightly twisted along its (Fig. 5). The opercle is the largest element in this
longitudinal axis. The lower jaw is composed of the series and has a rod-shaped process antero-dorsally
dental, retroarticular, articular and coronomeckelian for connecting to the levator operculi muscle. The
(Fig. 4b). The dental is the largest of this set and ventral margin of the opercle is connected to the
includes two parts i.e. the narrow ramus dentalis and subopercle. The subopercle is a stretched bone and
wider coronoid process. This bone is connected to the connected to the interopercle anteriorly. The
articular postero-dorsally and to the retroarticular preopercle is narrow and arc-shaped, and situated on
dorsally. The articular is connected to the dental the interopercle. The interopercle is elongated and
anteriorly, retroarticular ventrally and quadrate wider at its middle part.
posteriorly. The coronomeckelian is a small and Branchial arches: The branchial arch consists of the
triangular bone which is positioned in the dorso- unpaired basibranchial and paired hypobranchial,
medial part of the dental (Fig. 4b). ceratobranchial, epibranchial, and pharyngobranch-
Suspensorium: The suspensorium comprises the ials (Fig. 6). There are four basibranchials in this
autopalatine, endopterygoid, ectopterygoid, series that the fourth one is very small. Five
metapterygoid, hyomandibular, quadrate and ceratobranchials are the largest elements of the
symplectic bones (Fig. 5). The autopalatine possesses branchial arch that fifth one is modified into the
a blade-like process in the middle and it is connected pharyngeal teeth. The numbers of the epibranchial
159
Iranian Journal of Ichthyology (September 2015), 2(3): 155-164
of Cobitis avicennae
Fig.8. Pectoral girdle of Paraschistura nielseni. Cl: cleithrum; Cor: coracoid; Mcor: mesocoracoid; pect-R: ray of the
pectoral fin; Rad: ossified pectoral radial; Sc: scapula.
Fig.9. Dorsal fin (a), anal fin (b) and pelvic girdle (c) of Paraschistura nielseni. Adp: anal distal pterygiophore; Dfr:
dorsal fin rays; Dfs: dorsal fin spin; Dr: distal radial; Mp: mesial pterygiophore; Mr: medial radial; Pp: pterygiophore;
Sty: stay.
a stay is located at the end of the tenth pterygiophore pterygiophore is positioned in the front of the
(Fig. 9a). The numbers of unbranched and branched nineteenth centrum. In addition, this fin bears three
rays are four and 8½, respectively. unbranched and 5½ branched rays (Fig. 9b).
Anal fin skeleton: The anal fin skeleton includes Pelvic girdle: The pelvic girdle consists of the paired
seven pterygiophores and one stay. The first pelvic bones and radials (Fig. 9c). These bones are
161
Iranian Journal of Ichthyology (September 2015), 2(3): 155-164
of Cobitis avicennae
shape and its ventral surface is not alveolar. Also, the the genus Oxynoemacheilus and Paracobitis
right and left lobes of the bony capsule are (Prokofiev 2010).
symmetrical and divided by the manubrium (Fig. The anterior facet of the hyomandibular in
11b). P. nielseni, is formed by the pterosphenoid and
sphenotic, and the posterior one by the pterotic and
Discussion sphenotic while in O. kiabii (Mafakheri et al. 2014)
In the present study, the skeletal system of P. nielseni and O. bergianus (Jalili & Eagderi 2015), the anterior
was described in detail. Based on the results, the facet is formed by the prootic, pterotic and sphenotic.
length of the occipital region in P. nielseni is less than Whereas, Prokofiev (2010) noted that the anterior
one-third of the neurocranium length similar to the facet is formed by the sphenotic and prootic, and the
majority of the loach species (Prokofiev 2010). In posterior one by the sphenotic, prootic and pterotic.
P. nielseni, the supraethmoid-ethmoid and prevomer The coronomeckelian of P. nielseni is situated on
are fused similar to other loaches, with the exception the dorso-medial part of the articular similar to that
of Lefua spp., Oreonectes platycephalus, Yunnanilus of O. kiabii (Mafakheri et al. 2014) and O. bergianus
pleurotaenia, Triplophysa microphthalma, T. tenuis (Jalili & Eagderi 2015), but Prokofiev (2010) noted
(Prokofiev 2010) and Schistura fasciolata (Sawada that the coronomeckelian is connected to the base and
1982). The connection of the lateral ethmoid to the dorsal edge of the coronoid process in loaches.
neurocranium in P. nielseni is at the level of the There are four basibranchials in P. nielseni
anterior margin of the orbitosphenoid, similar to similar to O. kiabii (Mafakheri et al. 2014) and
Oxynoemacheilus kiabii (Mafakheri et al. 2014) and O. bergianus (Jalili & Eagderi 2015), but Prokofiev
O. bergianus (Jalili & Eagderi 2015). However, (2010) reported three basibranchials in the genus
based on Prokofiev (2010), this bone in loaches is Paraschistura. The two extra urohyals were not find
connected to the supraethmoid-ethmoid. in P. nielseni; however, in O. kiabii (Mafakheri et al.
There is no preethmoids-I in P. nielseni, whereas 2014) and O. bergianus (Jalili & Eagderi 2015), they
in other genera such as Lefua, Oreonectes, exist. Also, these bones are not reported by Prokofiev
Yunnanilus, Eonemachilus, Micronoemacheilus, (2010) for thee members of this family. Paraschistura
Hedinichthys, Orthrias and Triplophysa, paired nielseni has five hypurals in its caudal skeleton, while
preethmoids-I present connecting to the lateral edge O. bergianus (Jalili & Eagderi 2015) has six hypurals.
of the anterolateral processes of the prevomer In P. nielseni, the base of the right pelvic bones is
(Prokofiev 2010). In P. nielseni, the sesamoids are separated from the main body which is not observed
not completely ossified, but in O. kiabii, the in O. kiabii (Mafakheri et al. 2014) and O. bergianus
sesamoids are clearly ossified (Mafakheri et al. (Jalili & Eagderi 2015). In P. nielseni, the bony swim
2014). Whereas, the presence of the sesamoid bladder capsule is rectangular-shaped and its ventral
ossifications in loaches was rejected (Sawada 1982); face is not alveolar similar to O. bergianus (Jalili &
the sesamoid ossifications were reported in Eagderi 2015), while the ventral face in O. kiabii
Paracobitis malapterura, P. longicauda, Dzihunia (Mafakheri et al. 2014) is alveolar.
amudarjensis and Oxynoemacheilus angorae In conclusion, the findings of this research
(Prokofiev 2004, 2009). The prevomer is square- showed that P. nielseni has a number of distinct and
shaped in P. nielseni similar to O. kiabii (Mafakheri important osteological characteristics including a
et al. 2014) whereas, this bone is elongated and square-shaped prevomer, four basibranchials, a semi-
rectangular in O. bergianus (Jalili & Eagderi 2015). ossified sesamoid, a non-alveolar bony swim bladder
The sphenotic and epiotic are contacted in P. nielseni, capsule and separated pelvic bone bases that can be
similar to Paraschistura cristata and the members of used to distinguish this species from other loach
163
Iranian Journal of Ichthyology (September 2015), 2(3): 155-164