Professional Documents
Culture Documents
KNOWLEDGE IN PRACTICE
I am really grateful for the contribution made by all our team members. The restriction of page numbers
limited inclusion of all the articles. The articles submitted would definitely be placed in our subsequent issues.
Once again thanks a lot to all the team members of MTC for their continued support and encouragement.
"I like a teacher who gives you something to take home to think about besides homework." -- Edith
Ann, [Lily Tomlin]
Innovative Strategies to Finance SMEs • Lack of data base with regard to their
By operation, performance, strength and
DR.S.N.Ghosal weaknesses and market volatility on
Director: NICCO FINA regular basis;
NCIAL Services Ltd., Kolkata • Heavy transaction costs due to
inability to access modern technology;
Small and medium enterprises (SMEs) are one • Very low margin as supply chain is not
of the largest employment opportunity provider only inadequate but also exploit the
next to basic industry i.e. agriculture. In India high degree of dependence of these
it generates more than 40% of value addition to enterprises on middlemen operating
the manufacturing industries and one third of the supply chain;
our exports. In developed countries it would be
• Most of them lack education and fund
interesting to note that its role is much higher
to upgrade technology and volatility of
and rewarding. For example in USA and
market.
Japan it provides 67% and 80% employment
opportunities and contributes 61% and 72% to Some Recent Innovations
the manufacturing output in those countries
respectively. It would therefore be interesting It has therefore become imperative to address
to make an in-depth analysis of funding these the above issues to make funding of SMEs
institutions as these institutions are generally attractive and user friendly. In recent years it
promoted by individual and or family is interesting to note that both governments as
entrepreneurs with limited financial resources well as financial institutions of both developed
but endowed with rewarding innovative ideas and developing countries have initiated some
and initiatives and therefore need external positive and progressive measures to hold
funding for survival and growth and hands of small and medium entrepreneurs’ to
unfortunately in developing countries they access funds at a reasonable and affordable
have very limited access to external funds and costs and without any usual hurdles. In fact
therefore most of these enterprises suffer and these initiatives aimed at both reduction of cost
even close down due to high cost, inadequacy of funds and risks associated with such
and abnormal delay they usually suffer in funding. These initiatives could be summed up
sourcing external funds. as follows:
It is not for nothing such neglect and hesitant • Venture capital funding intuitions have
behavior has been developed by the funding been floated, often called as P.E, funds
institutions for these enterprises. In fact these have been floated to induct fund at low
have happened due to: cost, share the risk and to provide
• Poor managerial and marketing skills management and technology up
usually associated with these gradation support to these enterprises;
enterprises;
• Unusual vulnerability to market risk
and consequent sudden mortality;
“No matter what your product is, you are ultimately in the education business. Your customers need to
be constantly educated about the many advantages of doing business with you, trained to use your
products more effectively, and taught how to make never-ending improvement in their lives. “--
Robert G
• Credit guarantee and credit rating • Funding institutions are not prepared to
agencies have been floated to support assume the role of partners of these
and empower lending institutions to enterprises to share their risks and
shoulder the inherent risks provide much needed management
unhesitatingly in funding these support at least in their fund
enterprises adequately and timely; management if not for other areas of
management ;
• Innovative products and instruments • Non availability of database to study
have been introduced by the financial the inherent risk patterns of these
institutions to enable these enterprises enterprises and inadequate market
to source fund at low cost and intelligence that deters these
collaterals; and institutions to take timely steps and
strategies to offset the impact of market
• Improved training modules and lending volatility;
options have been constantly • Non availability of appropriate market
researched and introduced to make for these enterprises to source equity
these enterprises more viable and and debt funds at competitive price.
attractive to make these enterprises
more and more attractive and viable It is therefore obvious that there is need to
enterprises to lending institutions. bring out some radical changes both in
policies, practices and procedures as well as in
However despite such recent efforts an in strategies, structures and stimulus to be
depth analysis would reveal that SMEs still imbedded in the financial institutions and
need some more holding hands to be groomed financial markets to enable these enterprises to
as enterprises that would lead the financing have access to fund, management and market
institutions to compete with each other to fund support to achieve robust growth. In this regard
these enterprises as funding these institutions following innovative changes need to be
would enable them to earn revenue safely and adopted by the funding agencies of SMEs.
steadily. In this regard it would be interesting
to comprehend some of the existing gaps that • SMEs need to develop a partnership
have deterred the funding agencies to become with funding agencies like micro
aggressive and competitive funding institutions financing institutions, and or banks to
of SMEs. These gaps are as follows: share risk and participate in
management and marketing.
• Funding modules are not developed • A specialized capital market need to be
wherein delivery and amount of funds developed to help SMEs to float equity
are not linked with time of needs and and debt instruments;
growth of these enterprises; • Evolve a digital smart card to enable
SMEs to access fund as and when they
need;
“This is the nature of genius, to be able to grasp the knowable even when no one else recognizes
that it is present.” -Deepak Chopra
• Build market intelligence kiosks at It is true that these innovative strategies could
convenient places to assist SMEs to be introduced gradually as it would need to
update their market intelligence and build appropriate financial, production and
accordingly regulate production, price marketing environment for enabling SMEs to
and product supply chain including up develop more sustainable model to grow and
gradation of technology to match the develop management and marketing expertise
changes perceived in design and and introduce upgraded technology to become
fashions etc.; more productive with improved quality and
• Creating institutions and products to enhanced competitive strength. In this regard it
enable securitization of SMEs debts would be needless to say that Indian
and enhancing their capabilities to government and financial institutions have to
have access to liquidity as and when traverse miles to reach the desired goal as has
needed; been enumerated above.
• Developing derivative markets to hedge In fact in this regard it would be helpful to
their price and currency risks. undertake a study of a very illustrative and
educative model developed by JAPAN. In fact
In recent years some initiatives have already much could be learnt from JAPAN as it has
been taken by government of India and been able to respond to the needs of SMEs
commercial banks to facilitate funding SMEs very successfully and therefore SMEs have
by creating credit rating facilities to classify grown over there over the years with vision
these enterprises on the basis of risk and and profit. The policy that has been adopted
thereby enabling banks to assess risk in such by JAPAN to give boost to SMEs could be
funding in advance and accordingly fix more summed up as follows:
flexible terms and conditions for lending these • It has helped financial institutions to
enterprises. Similarly VENTURE CAPITAL adopt a lending policy on partnership
funding institutions have also been floated to model with additional support of
assist SMEs to assume risk with their support. providing the facility of securitization
Further commercial banks have been to maintain their liquidity intact and to
encouraged to lend to SMEs on the basis of the transfer a part of their risk to other
feasibility and viability of projects rather than institution;
appraising them on the basis of collaterals • It has also developed database to assist
offered for such loans. These are obviously SMEs to assess both financial and
healthy move but much more needed to be market risks and do away with the
done particularly in re-engineering lending present practice of depending on
strategy. It would be necessary to asymmetrical data available from
• Introduce transaction lending diverse sources; and
technology;
• Develop relationship lending
methodology; and
• Adopt sharing and partnering policy
with borrowers.
“This is the nature of genius, to be able to grasp the knowable even when no one else recognizes
that it is present” - Deepak Chopra
• It has made arrangement to assess on • Further in JAPAN the credit guarantees
regular basis the impact of policy offered to SMEs have worked wonder
changes and also to comprehend to give boost to financing of SMEs.
problems faced by SMEs from time to These studies have also revealed that
time. These studies reveal some of the entrepreneurs need to be assisted in
hard facts that need to be addressed by developing viable business enterprises
policy makers to facilitate financing keeping in view their capability and
institutions to develop appropriate vision as well as passion. Most of the
strategies to counter such issues that are entrepreneurs have the capacity and
found hindering the growth of SMEs. vision to develop innovative business
For example one such studies revealed but in general they lack the capability
that SMEs in JAPAN with low return to translate and implement these as
on assets and poor equity ratios have feasible and viable projects. It would be
been paying high rate of interest and therefore imperative for financial
consequently defaulting and ultimately institutions to assume the role of a
languishing, these studies have also development bank and assist the
revealed that adaptation of change in entrepreneurs in developing feasible
policies as has been highlighted above and sustainable project.
have impacted well as these have This would necessarily need to develop
enabled them to source fund at partnership model that would create virtually a
competitive rates and sharing and partnership of entrepreneurs and banks. The
transferring risks with the financial partnership concept would take care of sharing
institutions as and when considered of risks in proportion to their respective
necessary to improve their liquidity and financial involvement. Further if it is extended
reduce their risks. In fact it has now a further it would help borrower to source fund
proven fact that lending based on at competitive rate if not concessional rate. In
collaterals and personal guarantees of fact such partnership would do away ultimately
entrepreneurs are more risky and the practice of charging interest on loan as
therefore need to be replaced by the there could be an arrangement of sharing of
newly developed strategy that takes revenue. In fact this is already in vogue in
into consideration the viability, Islamic banking.
feasibility, competence and market It is obvious therefore that there is dire need to
accessibility of the venture rather than create constant value addition in delivery
collaterals and personal guarantees as model of capital and equity to SMEs. The
per conventional method of lending. In innovations adopted by JAPAN are worth
fact policy emphasis now is to develop emulating by India and all other countries that
relationship banking instead of seeking heavily lean on SMEs for their export and
collaterals and guarantees. GDP growth. In fact banks have no other
alternative but to develop innovative models
for inclusive growth as recent global financial
crisis has mirrored the misery of globalization
without inclusive growth.
Retail: Retain and Sustain Indian retail on the fast-track
• The Indian retail market is the fifth-
By largest retail destination globally. It is
Prof. Rupali Kumar estimated to grow US$ 637 billion by
2015.
Asst. Professor, Bharati Vidyapeeth institute
of Management and Research • Retail contributes to 10 per cent of
&
India’s Gross Domestic Product and
Mr. Manish Bestia and Ms. Ashima Kapoor
(Student- BVIMR) provides employment to 8 per cent of
India’s working population.
The paper on the Indian Retail Industry was
carried out with the objective to find out the • Higher disposable incomes, easy
relevance of the terms “Retain’’ and “Sustain’’ availability of credit and high exposure
for retailing and to formulate a model for the to media and brands has considerably
retailers to help them Retain their customers increased the average propensity to
and Sustain in the market. 20 retailers were consume over the years.
randomly selected for the survey and they were
put questions through direct interview and Importance of “Retaining Customers’’ in
questionnaire. Percentage analysis method was Retail Industry
used to analyse the data. The research paper • Customer’s loyalty leads to greater
suggested that in future: sales and revenue, better prediction of
Ø Focus on consumer by providing him
sales, requires minimal marketing
with value products at a convenient and
efforts, and creates customers who are
well designed retail store.
less sensitive to the marketing efforts of
Ø Mass customization is the way of the
competitors.
future.
• Gaining customer loyalty is also a key
Ø Focus on differentiating with other
corporate challenge today especially in
competitors by providing a complete
this increasingly competitive and
shopping experience.
crowded marketplace because of the
Ø Use innovative techniques and store
eventual profitability it will provide.
formats like pop-up retail, to target
consumers who lead hectic lives and Based upon the findings of research the
need an outlet for high-speed retail. following model was formulated:
“I am always ready to learn although I do not always like being taught” - Winston Churchill
• Geographic
• Demographic
• Psychographic
• Behavioralistic
(II) Buying their Interest:
• Existing Customers: - These are the customers that The last step of the cycle is to
efficiently utilize the existing
the retailer is already catering to.
loyal customers in generating
• Competitor’s Customers: - These are the customers more sales for the retailer and
of the competitors of the retailers. The retailers need bringing new leads (customers) to
to identify their competitor’s customers and should the retailer. This can be attained
target to convert them into its own customers. by good Customer Relationship
Management by the retailer.
(II) Organizing the Potential Customers: It was concluded that:
The next step is to divide the entire customer base “In the retail industry, the
identified in the first step into different segments. It can success mantra is to retain its
be segmented on the basis of the following customer’s customer for its survival in the
characteristics: market.”
“It is not the strongest of the species that survive, nor the most intelligent, but the one most
responsive to change”- Charles Darwin
FORMATION OF MANAGEMENT TEACHERS CONSORTIUM (MTC)
Management Teachers Consortium (MTC) is a voluntary non- profit group of individual as well as
organisation have been created as a Google Group. The stake holders are Management Teachers and B-
Schools. The group was formed on 29 Jun 2010. As of now 270 management educators/corporate
executives from across the world have voluntarily joined this group and share their thoughts and views on
various issues related to management education.
OBJECTIVES
The group is created with a view to provide a common platform to all management teachers across the
world to share/exchange/express their opinion and develop knowledge and social capital which ultimately
go down to classrooms. The ultimate benefits propel to management students, management institutions,
policy makers, corporate and other interested parties. This leads to an effective, efficient and productive
management education system. This is a consortium based on ethics and value system.
Management Education cannot be isolated/detached from corporate as corporate plays a major role and
the main stake-holder. Based on corporate requirements management education has been undergoing
continuous changes over the years. Globalisation has given a new twist and course like MBA
(International Business), MBA (IHRM) etc are in good demand.
Most of the B-Schools have Industry- Institute- Partnership-Cell, to work closely with Corporate and it
has really helped colleges to fine tune their courses, start different certification programme, personality
development programme and various other co-curricular activities, which finally helped colleges to place
their students in good companies.
Keeping this wide perspective in mind, MTC has opened up the forum, in the month of July’2010, for
corporate executive to share their views on management education, throughput and their expectations
from students/B-schools. Surely, this will further give momentum to this Consortium and will create
synergy leading to Win-Win situation.