Monkey Cage

It’s actually older people who

have become more cynical
about U.S. democracy
By Erik Voeten December 14, 2016

Millennials have come in for a lot of blame lately. They have ruined democracy. They are culpable for Hillary Clinton’s loss.
Newsweek proclaimed that millennials have fallen out of love with democracy. An entire generation has lost faith in
democracy, says another dramatic headline.

Pinning societal problems on younger generations is an age-old pastime. But it seems particularly unfair this time around. The
election of Donald Trump and the Brexit vote in the United Kingdom are the events that triggered a lot of these discussions.
Only 37 percent of people under 30 voted for Trump. Younger people were also much more likely to vote against Brexit.

Moreover, when you look more closely, it’s actually older people who have become more cynical about U.S. democracy.

Much of the hype about millennials comes from a heavily publicized finding from the 2011 World Values Survey. Millennials
were less likely to attach a great deal of importance to living in a democracy and were somewhat more likely to embrace
alternatives, such as a strong leader. This finding is limited to the United States and much more modest than originally
portrayed.

So what if we look at more data? Very few surveys in the United States ask similar abstract questions about the value of
democracy. But we have a lot of high quality data going back a long time on confidence in actual democratic institutions.

The graph above examines patterns since the early 1970s in whether Americans have “a great deal of confidence, only some
confidence or hardly any confidence at all” in the United States Congress. The data come from the high quality General Social
Survey.

The percentage of Americans who have “hardly any” confidence in Congress has increased sharply since 2003. There were
barely any age differentials for most of the past four decades. Now there is almost a 20 percentage-point gap between the
youngest and the oldest generations. And it’s the older generations that have become more cynical.
The graph above looks at confidence in the Federal Executive. Again, it’s older, not younger Americans, who have less
confidence in the executive. This is a relatively recent phenomenon. There was no age gap before the 2000s.
 

I also looked at confidence in nondemocratic institutions, such as the military, and did not find a similar age gap. So it seems
that confidence differences are about the functioning of democratic institutions.

Monkey Cage newsletter

Sign up
Commentary on political science and political issues.

The final graph goes back even further in time. It plots averages for a 100-point trust in government scale developed by the
American National Election Studies. The scale combines assessments about whether people “trust the federal government to
do what is right,” “that the federal government is run by a few interests or for the benefit of all,” “how much the government
wastes tax money” and “how many government officials are crooked.”

The pattern is similar: In 2012 younger people are on average more trusting in the government than older people, although the
difference is not that large. By contrast, in earlier surveys there are no age differences of note.

So what does this mean?

Actual unhappiness about the functioning of the government is not the same thing as abstract preferences for democracy over
its alternatives. Perhaps young people just haven’t been paying attention. Maybe good democrats (with the lowercase “d”)
should be upset about the way the government is functioning. So, millennials’ relative lack of cynicism about U.S. political
institution could reflect their apathy.

Maybe. But confidence in actual institutions is much more concrete and easier to make sense of than public opinion over
imaginary alternatives. Older people are more upset about how U.S. institutions actually work. And they behave like it in the
voting booth. Perhaps we should start worrying about old people.

Erik Voeten is the Peter F. Krogh Associate Professor of Geopolitics and Justice in World Affairs at Georgetown
University's Edmund A. Walsh School of Foreign Service and the Department of Government.
 Follow @ErikVoeten

PAID PROMOTED STORIES Recommended by

 

This Startup Might Make You WunderBrow tested by CBS' “Shark Tank” Star’s Brilliant
Ditch Your Broker The Doctor Advice For Paying Off Your
Business Insider WunderBrow on Health & Style magazine Mortgage
Bills.com

4 Things One Guy Discovered This Article Will Change The The Highest Paying Cash Back
After Wearing MeUndies for a Way You Buy Glasses Forever Cards On The Market
Month GlassesUSA Credit Cards
AskMen.com