Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Alan Walsh
Division of Chemical Physics
CSIRO
P.O. Box 160
Clayton, Vic, 3168, Australia
When Foil Miller invited me to I realize that anyone who reminis- tained in absorption and atomic spec-
participate in the Silver Anniversary ces is usually so decrepit that his tra in emission. The result of this
Symposium on Great Moments in memory is totally unreliable. I shall, musing was quite astonishing: there
Analytical Chemistry, he suggested therefore, try to avoid too many er- appeared to be no good reasons for
that I may care to indulge in some rors of fact by restricting my com- neglecting atomic absorption spectra;
personal reminiscences and com- ments largely to matters which are on the contrary, they appeared to
ments regarding the development and documented in reports of CSIRO, in offer many vital advantages over
present status of atomic absorption correspondence, or in publications. atomic emission spectra as far as
spectroscopy. I hope the ones I have My initial interest in atomic ab- spectrochemical analysis was con-
selected may illuminate, if not an- sorption spectroscopy was a result of cerned. There was the attraction that
swer, the problem posed by the title two interacting experiences: one of absorption is, at least for atomic va-
of my address. the spectrochemical analysis of met- pours produced thermally, virtually
als over the period 1939-46; the other independent of the temperature of
Presented at the Pittsburgh Conference on of molecular spectroscopy over the the atomic vapour and of excitation
Analytical Chemistry and Applied Spec- period from 1946-52. The interaction potential. In addition, atomic absorp-
troscopy, Cleveland, Ohio, March 6, 1974. occurred early in 1952, when I began tion methods offered the possibility of
Silver Anniversary Symposium on Great avoiding excitation interference,
Moments in Analytical Chemistry and to wonder why, as in my experience,
Applied Spectroscopy. molecular spectra were usually ob- which at that time was thought by
many to be responsible for some of
the interelement interference experi-
enced in emission spectroscopy when
using an electrical discharge as light
- 2 -
source. In addition, one could avoid
problems due to self-absorption and
self-reversal which often make it dif-
The purpose of this report .is to suggest a new technique for ficult to use the most sensitive lines
recording absorption spectra which offers many interesting possibilities. in emission spectroscopy.
The method is basically simple and is illustrated in the diagram below.
As far as possible experimental
problems were concerned, I was par-
ticularly fortunate in one respect. For
several years prior to these first
thoughts on atomic absorption, I had
been regularly using a commercial in-
frared spectrophotometer employing a
modulated light source and synchro-
nously tuned detection system. A fea-
ture of this arrangement is that any
radiation emitted by the sample pro-
duces no signal at the output of the
detection system. This experience
Assuming that the sample is vaporised by the usual methods, e . g. had no doubt prevented the forma-
flame, arc, or spark, then the emission spectrum is "removed" by means tion of any possible mental block as-
of the chopper principle . Thus, the absorption spectrum of the vapour sociated with absorption measure-
ments on luminous atomic vapours.
is measured by passing through it white light which is chopped. The
absorption spectrum and the emission spectrum are then scanned by a In an internal report for the period
February-March 1952,1 suggested
detector, the output from which is amplified by an amplifier tuned to that the same type of modulated sys-
the same frequency as the chopper. Thus the emission spectrum produces tem (Figure 1) should be considered
no output signal and only the absorption spectrum is recorded. for recording atomic absorption spec-
For analytical work it is proposed that the sample is dissolved, tra. The following extracts from that
report may be of interest:
and then vaporised in a Lundegardh flame . Such flames have a low
temperature (2000°K) compared to arcs or sparks (500CTKJ and have the
advantage that few atoms would be excited, the great majority being in
the ground state . Thus absorption will be restricted to a small number
Figure 1 . Extract from report for Feb-
ruary-March 1952
Stagnant or Pregnant?
"Assuming that the sample is va- was interposed between the sodium ysis. "Look," I said, "that's atomic
porised by the usual methods, e.g., lamp and the entrance slit of the absorption." "So what?" was his
flame, arc, or spark, then the emis- spectroscope. When a solution of so- reply, which was the precursor of
sion spectrum is 'removed' by means dium chloride was atomised into the many similar disinterested reactions
of the chopper principle. Thus the air supply of the flame the signal at to our atomic absorption project over
emission spectrum produces no out- the oscillograph was reduced to zero. the next few years.
put signal and only the absorption The principle of the method is there- My report for June-July 1952 dis-
spectrum is recorded." fore established." cusses the problems of recording
"For analytical work it is proposed In retrospect, such optimistic naiv- atomic absorption spectra of flames
that the sample is dissolved and then ety is quite incredible. with a continuum source and con-
vaporised in a Lundegardh flame. This simple experiment gave me a cludes that a resolution of about 0.02
Such flames have a low temperature great thrill, and I excitedly called in À would be required; this was well
(2000°K) compared to arcs and John Willis, who at that time was beyond the best spectrometer avail-
sparks (5000°K) and have the advan- working on infrared spectroscopy and able in our laboratory at that time.
tage that few atoms would be excited, was later to make important contri- The report concluded as follows:
the great majority being in the butions to the development of atomic "One of the main difficulties is due
ground state. Thus absorption will be absorption methods of chemical anal- to the fact that the relations between
restricted to a small number of tran-
sitions and a simple spectrum would
result. In addition, the method is ex-
pected to be sensitive since transi-
tions will be mainly confined to those CHEMICAL PHYSICS SECTION
from the ground level to the first ex-
cited state."
At this stage I was thinking of elec- 42nd Bimontly Report. April-May, 1952.
trical discharges, as well as flames, as
a means of atomization. It will also
be apparent that initially I had not C.P. 1/14. Atomic Absorption Spectra
appreciated the difficulties which
In the previous report the application of atomic absorption spectra
would be involved in recording atomic
absorption spectra when using a con- to spectrochemical analysis was suggested. The possibilities of this
tinuum source. approach have been explored and the results obtained to date are most
The next Bimonthly Report, for the encouraging. In the preliminary work the apparatus shown below was used.
period April-May 1952, includes the
diagram shown in Figure 2 and de-
scribes our first experiment as follows:
"The sodium lamp was operated
from 50 cycles/sec. and thus had an
alternating output so that it was not
necessary to use a chopper. The D
lines from this lamp were isolated—
but not resolved from each other—by The sodium lamp was operated from 50 cycles/sec. and thus had
means of a direct vision spectroscope an alternating output so that it was not necessary to use a chopper.
and their intensities were measured
by means of a photomultiplier tube, The D lines from this lamp were isolated-but not resolved from each
the output from which was recorded other-by means of a direct vision spectroscope and their intensities
on a cathode ray oscillograph. Ampli- were measured by means of a photo-multiplier tube , the output from which
fication of the signal was achieved by was recorded on a cathode ray oscillograph. Amplification of the signal
the A.C. amplifiers in the oscillo-
was achieved by the A. C . amplifiers in the oscillograph . With the slit-
graph. With the slit-width used the
signal gave full-scale deflection on the width used the signal gave full-scale deflection on the oscillograph screen.
oscillograph screen. A Meker flame A Meker flame was interposed between the sodium lamp and the entrance slit
of the spectroscope. When a solution of sodium chloride was atomised into
the air supply of the flame the signal at the oscillograph was reduced to
zero. The principle of the method is therefore established. No attempt
Figure 2. Extract from report for A p r i l -
May 1952
Perkin-Elmer's new Models 241 and 241 MC Polarim- Four integration times: 1,5,20 and 50 sec. Plus a recorder
eters could be just what you need if you're faced with readout unit with four cyclic ranges: ±0.05°, ±0.5°,
one or more of the following measurement problems with ±5.0° and ±50.0°.
optically active substances: Operation? Extremely simple and versatile. Just push
• Quantitative determinations a button. You get an automatic gain and balance control,
• Characterization of pure substances test deflection in + and - directions, automatic lamp
• Study of kinetic reactions ignition.
• End point determination of titrations Like to know more about the Models 241 and 241 MC?
• Detection for liquid chromatography Write to the Instrument Division, Perkin-Elmer Corpora-
• ORD measurements tion, Main Avenue, Norwalk, Conn. 06856.
These instruments work on the highly-valued principle
of the optical null balance. You'll find them faster, surer
and more accurate than other instruments. They give
you the rotation on a five place digital display with sign. PERKIN-ELMER
CIRCLE 185 ON READER SERVICE CARD
706 A • ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY, VOL. 46, NO. 8, JULY 1974
ties have now been overcome, a n d it
seems t h a t t h e sputtering technique
will be applicable t o t h e analysis of a
wide range of m e t a l s a n d alloys. It re
m a i n s t o compare t h e performance
a n d range of these m e t h o d s with
those of other analytical techniques.
In t h e m e a n t i m e , I would not ex
pect t h e scientific i n s t r u m e n t m a n u
facturers to be greatly interested in
the simple sputtering cell shown in
Figure 8.1 would, however, like t o
think t h a t some of t h e m are musing
on possible ways of embellishment t o
ensure t h a t any commercial version
will have a n impressive price tag.
We are now exploring t h e extension
of our work t o t h e v a c u u m ultraviolet
for t h e d e t e r m i n a t i o n of carbon,
phosphorus, a n d sulfur. W e also pro
pose t o extend our experiments t o t h e
analysis of powders a n d solutions. W e
are increasingly conscious of t h e i m
p o r t a n t advantages of cathodic sput Figure 8. Photograph of atomic absorption spectrophotometer incorporating
tering over t h e r m a l m e t h o d s of a t o m - sputtering chamber for atomization of solid samples
ization in isotopic analysis. Finally, I
believe our recent work on cathodic
sputtering takes u s one step nearer
t h e goal I discussed in m y first paper
on atomic absorption spectroscopy,
the development of absolute methods
of spectrochemical analysis.
It would appear, therefore, t h a t t h e Alan Walsh is assistant chief of the ble, and inexpensive hollow-cathode
subject h a s not really been stagnant, Division of Chemical Physics, Com discharge lamps. He has published
b u t merely pregnant, a n d h a s now monwealth Scientific and Industrial over 60 papers in atomic, infrared,
given birth t o new offspring on which Research Organization (CSIRO), and Raman spectroscopy. Dr. Walsh
I t r u s t Bunsen a n d Kirchhoff will Melbourne, Australia. He received is currently interested in what he
look with approval a n d regard as wor his DSc from Manchester Univer considers the ultimate goal of spec-
thy descendants of their original sity in England. He is considered trochemical analysis, the develop
brainchild. the "father" of atomic absorption ment of absolute methods. This inter
spectroscopy and exhibited a com est has resulted in the development of
References plete apparatus for the technique in methods of atomization by using ca-
March 1954. His now classic paper thodic sputtering; and these, in turn,
(1) G. Dieke and H. M. Crosswhite, J. appeared in Spectrochimica Acta in have led to the development of reso
Opt. Soc. Amer., 42, 433 (1952).
(2) Australian Patent Application 1955. He holds basic patents in Aus nance detection and selective modu
23,041/53 (Nov. 17, 1953). tralia, the U.S., and other countries lation techniques. More recently, he
(3) Australian Patent Specification on atomic absorption spectroscopy, and his colleagues have adapted these
163,586 (Oct. 21, 1954). multiple monochromators, and im techniques to the development of
(4) A. Walsh, Spectrochim. Acta, 7, 108
(1955); Erratum, ibid., ρ 252. provements in grating monochroma atomic absorption and atomic fluo
(5) C. T. J. Alkemade and J. M. W. Mi- tors. One of his major contributions rescence methods for the direct anal
latz, Appl. Sci. Res., B4, 289 (1955). was the development of intense, sta- ysis of solid samples.
(6) J. P. Shelton and A. Walsh, Proc.
XVth Congress IUPAC, 2, TV-50, Lis
bon, 1956.
(7) B. J. Russell, J. P. Shelton, and A.
Walsh, Spectrochim. Acta, 8, 317 (1957).
(8) J. E. Allan, Analyst, 83, 433 (1958).
(9) D.J.David, ibid., ρ 536.
(10) J. E. Allan, Spectrochim. Acta, 18,
605 (1962).
(11) A. Walsh, Proc. Xth Colloquium
Spectroscopicum Internationale, ρ 127,
Spartan Books, Washington, 1962.
(12) B. V. L'vov, Spectrochim. Acta, 17,
761(1961).
(13) D. A. Segar and J. G. Gonzalez,
paper presented at Fourth International
Conference on Atomic Spectroscopy, To
ronto, Canada, 1973.
(14) C. T. J. Alkemade, Proc. Xth Collo
quium Spectroscopicum Internationale,
ρ 143, Spartan Books, Washington,
1962.
(15) J. D. Winefordner and T. J. Vickers,
Anal. Chem., 36, 161 (1964).
(16) Β. Μ. Gatehouse and A. Walsh,
Spectrochim. Acta, 16, 602 (I960).
(17) D. S. Gough, P. Hannaford, and A.
Walsh, ibid., B28, 197 (1973).