Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Received: 23 August 2016 / Accepted: 20 April 2017 / Published online: 8 May 2017
The Institution of Engineers (India) 2017
123
202 J. Inst. Eng. India Ser. A (June 2017) 98(1-2):201–210
occurs at mid-span and, therefore, the moments due to dead longitudinal direction for all spans ranging from 10 to
loads (at mid-span) and due to live loads (under a wheel) 50 m. Tables 1 and 2 show active axles for IRC Class-70R
cannot be simply added to find design moment. Moreover, in wheeled and Class-A loading respectively over the length
case of Class70-R/Class-A wheeled load, which consists of for bridge span ranging from 10 to 50 m.
several axels, the number of axels to be considered over the
bridge of given span and their location is tedious to find out IRC Class-70R Wheeled Vehicle Loading
and needs several trials to determine the exact number of
wheels that should be considered. Shipman examined the The types of bending moment by considering various load
effect of lane load on the position of AASHTO HL-93 applied to the bridge have been calculated and shown in
loading to develop maximum bending moment in the simply Tables 1 and 2. Figure 1 shows the load arrangements
supported bridges and developed a simple expression to based on vehicle movement at a particular direction.
calculate the position of critical load resulting in maximum
moment; however, he did not incorporate the effect of dead IRC Class-A Wheeled Vehicle Loading
load in locating the critical axle [5]. The aim of the present
study is to find the number of wheels and their location to Figure 2 shows the load arrangement based on vehicle
produce absolute maximum moment in the bridge consid- movement for Class-A wheeled vehicles.
ering the effect of dead load and dynamic impact factor used
by IRC [3] for live loads. Finally, in order to enable the
designers, the design moments due to Class-70R wheeled Determination of Design Moment using
and Class-A loading, critical load position from rolling load Conventional Approach
concept and present approach and shift distance of critical
load have been presented in tabular form for simply sup- In the conventional approach, design moments are obtained
ported spans ranging from 10 to 50 m. by superposing the moments due to dead loads at mid-span
and maximum moment due to vehicular loads using the
rolling load concept.
Identification of Wheel Loads Producing For the IRC Class-70R wheeled and Class-A loading,
Maximum Moment the wheel contact area is considered small and, therefore,
wheel loads are considered as concentrated point loads
For larger spans, generally all the vehicular axels together acting at the center of gravity of actual wheels as shown in
produce maximum moment in the bridge, however, for the Figs. 1 and 2. Since the live loads plying over the bridge
small span bridges, especially for spans less than the dis- deck may occupy any location on the lane, for the safe
tance between extreme axels, all the axels may not lay on design of bridge there is a need to determine maximum
the bridge, and even for spans longer than the distance bending moment due to vehicular live loads. The longitu-
between the extreme axels, sometimes do not develop dinal position of vehicle resulting maximum longitudinal
maximum moment. For instance, in case of IRC Class-70R bending moment in the bridge may be determined as
wheeled vehicle, the distance between first axle and last follows.
axle is (excluding bumper and front clearances) measures Let the loading system consisting loads P1…Pi…Pn cross
13.4 m, but even for 17.5 m long bridge span, maximum the bridge from left to right. Considering the reference point
moment is developed when last six wheels are over the for the live load at the last load of the loading system over the
span and first wheel is on approach slab. In general, the bridge i.e. Pn, and assuming that the ith load and the resultant
axel(s) to be considered beyond the bridge either may be on of the loading system R are located at distance of xi and x
front side or on rear side and it depends on span of bridge respectively from the reference point. From the rolling load
and the magnitude of load on front and rear axles. In order concept, maximum bending moment in a simply supported
to facilitate the designers for manual design, a study has beam should occur under one of the concentrated load,
been made to identity the loads to be considered over the referred as critical load here onwards. Let the load Pi be the
span producing maximum bending moment in the simply critical load (Pc) under which maximum moment will occur
supported bridges of span ranging from 10 to 50 m. The and it is located at distance xc(=xi) from reference point and
loads to be considered over the span which develop max- at distance ‘s0’ from the mid-span of bridge as shown in
imum moment in simply supported bridge are referred as Fig. 3.
‘active axels’. The CSiBridge beam-line modelling method From the Fig. 3 the distance of resultant R from mid-
has been used to determine active axels in IRC Class-70R span ‘z’ may be determined as ðxi x s0 Þ and the
wheeled and Class-A loading, these vehicles were gradu- reaction at support B, RB may be calculated by considering
ally moved over the span at the interval of 0.1 m in the equilibrium of moment at support A as,
123
J. Inst. Eng. India Ser. A (June 2017) 98(1-2):201–210 203
Table 1 IRC Class-70R wheeled vehicle axle arrangement for span 10–50 m
Span Case Wheel loads to be considered over Loading to be considered for IRC Class 70-R wheeled vehicle
range no. span for Max. BM (active axels)
(L), m
X
L 1 ½ðxc xÞ s0 L
MA ¼ 0 ¼ R z RB L ¼ 0; Mi ¼ R s P1
2 2 L 2
ðx1 xi Þ P2 ðx2 xi Þ Pi1 ðxi1 xi Þ
Substituting the value of z as z ¼ ðxi x s0 Þ in
above expression, RL R½ðxc xÞ s0 Rs0 Rs0 ½ðxc xÞ s0
Mi ¼ þ
1 z 1 ½ðxc xÞ s0 4 2 2 L
RB ¼ R ¼ R P1 ðx1 xi Þ P2 ðx2 xi Þ Pi1
2 L 2 L
ðxi1 xi Þ
1 ½ðxc xÞ s0
RB ¼ R For maximum moment under critical load, (dMi/
2 L
ds0) = 0
Bending moment at the location of critical load (Pc) may
dMi ½ 0 1 R R½ðxc xÞ 2s0
be calculated as, ¼0R þ0 þ 0
ds0 2 2 L
L 0
M i ¼ RB s 0 P1 ð x 1 x i Þ P 2
2
dMi
ðx2 xi Þ Pi1 ðxi1 xi Þ or, ds0 ¼ ½Rðxc xÞ=L 2Rs0 =L
2
d Mi
Substituting value of RA ¼ 0 2R=L ¼ 2R=L
ds2
123
204 J. Inst. Eng. India Ser. A (June 2017) 98(1-2):201–210
Table 2 IRC Class-A wheeled vehicle axle arrangement for span 10–50 m
Span Case Wheel loads to be Wheel load arrangement for maximum moment
range no. considered over span for
(L), m Max. BM (active axels)
123
J. Inst. Eng. India Ser. A (June 2017) 98(1-2):201–210 205
Table 2 continued
Span Case Wheel loads to be Wheel load arrangement for maximum moment
range no. considered over span for
(L), m Max. BM (active axels)
123
206 J. Inst. Eng. India Ser. A (June 2017) 98(1-2):201–210
or, dMi
dsm ¼ ½RðxLc xÞ 2Rs
L wsm
m
The bridge with loading system shown in Fig. 4 (with dead Since R, L and w are always positive, thus d2M/ds2m will
load of w kN m-1) is considered in proposed approach. If the be always negative, hence maximum moment is obtained,
resultant of the loading system is located at distance ‘z’ from dMi ½Rðxc xÞ 2Rsm
the mid-span, the reaction at support B, RB may be calculated ¼ wsm ¼ 0
dsm L L
by considering the equilibrium h i
P of moment at support A as, ½Rðxc
xÞ=L Rðxc
xÞ ðxc
xÞ R
MA ¼ 0 ¼ R L2 z þ wL L2 RB L ¼ 0; Or, sm ¼ 2R=Lþw ¼ 2RþwL ¼ 2 RþwL=2 :
Let for this combined loading system, the critical load Pc The above expression for s may be re-written after
is located at distance ‘sm’ from the mid-span of bridge. The including the impact factor ‘I’ as,
distance of resultant R from mid-span ‘z’ may be deter-
ðxc xÞ ð1 þ I ÞR ðxc xÞ
mined as ðxi x sm Þ. sm ¼ ¼ m
Substituting the value of z in above expression, 2 ð 1 þ I ÞR þ wL=2
2
ð1 þ I ÞR
1 z wL 1 ½ðxc xÞ sm wL where; m ¼
RB ¼ R þ ¼R þ ð1 þ I ÞR þ wL=2
2 L 2 2 L 2
Here, ‘sm’ is the distance of the critical load Pc from
1 ½ðxc xÞ sm wL mid-span to obtain maximum moment and ‘m’ is the
RB ¼ R þ
2 L 2 modification factor to incorporate the dead load effect and
Bending moment at the location of critical load (Pc) may impact factor in determining the position of critical load
be calculated as, producing absolute maximum longitudinal bending
2 moment in the deck.
L w L Thus it may be observed that the position of critical load
M i ¼ RB sm sm P1 ðx1 xi Þ
2 2 2 significantly depends on magnitude of total dead loads and
P2 ðx2 xi Þ Pi1 ðxi1 xi Þ live loads including dynamic impact effect in addition to
distance between critical load and resultant of loads. The
Substituting value of RA shift in the position of critical load with respect to con-
2 ventionally calculated critical load position, denoted as ‘d’,
1 ½ðxc xÞ sm wL L w L
Mi ¼ R þ sm sm
2 L 2 2 2 2 may be calculated as
P1 ðx1 xi Þ P2 ðx2 xi Þ Pi1 ðxi1 xi Þ ðxi xÞ ðxi xÞ ðxi xÞ
d ¼ m ¼ ½1 m
2 2 2
RL ½ðxc xÞ sm wL2 Rsm
Mi ¼ R þ
4 2 4 2 Substituting the value of ‘m’ in above expression
Rsm ½ðxc xÞ sm wLsm w L2 ðxi xÞ ð1 þ I ÞR
þ þ s2m Lsm
L 2 2 4 d ¼ 1
2 ð1 þ I ÞR þ wL=2
P1 ðx1 xi Þ P2 ðx2 xi Þ Pi1 ðxi1 xi Þ ðxi xÞ wL=2
¼
2 ð1 þ I ÞR þ wL=2
For maximum moment under critical load, (dMi/ds) = 0
As a special case, if self-weight of bridge (wL) is small
dMi ½ 0 1 R R½ðxc xÞ 2sm
¼0R þ0 þ compared to sum of moving loads (R) on the bridge span
dsm 2 2 L
i.e.wL \\ R, d tends to zero, consequently, the exact
wL w
ð0 þ 2sm LÞ 0 0 ¼ 0 position of critical load almost coincides with position of
2 2
critical load calculated using the conventional approach.
123
J. Inst. Eng. India Ser. A (June 2017) 98(1-2):201–210 207
123
208 J. Inst. Eng. India Ser. A (June 2017) 98(1-2):201–210
Table 3 Critical load position and bending moments for Class-70R wheeled loading
Span, Case Distance of critical load from Modification Distance of critical load from Shift in position Moment at critical load
m no. mid-span using conventional factor, m mid-span using proposed of critical load location including DL effect
method (s0) method (sm) (s0 - sm) due to kNm
Live Dead Total load
load load (MDL ? LL)
(MLL) (MDL)
self-weight) is considered uniform for all the spans and it is of load P8 is considered as reference point, then the dis-
assumed as 200 kN m-1 and impact factor for live loads is tance of resultant R i.e. CG of loading system from the
taken as per IRC6 [3]. The maximum bending moments for reference point may be determined as,
concrete bridges of spans ranging between 10 and 50 m P
P i xi
x ¼ P
due to assumed dead loads of 200 kN m-1 and in con- P1
junction with IRC Class-70R and Class-A wheeled vehicle 27 ð18:8 þ 17:7Þ þ 114 ð14:5 þ 13:3Þ þ 68 ð9 þ 6 þ 3ÞÞ
¼
have been presented in Tables 3 and 4 respectively. 27 2 þ 114 2 þ 68 4
¼ 9:7089 m
Numerical Example
The critical load may be identified by comparing the
For a 25 m span simply supported two-lane bridge, deter- sum of the loads on both side of resultant.
mine the design bending moment due to IRC Class-A Sum of Loads towards the left of C.G of loads =
loading. Take superimposed dead load including its self P5 + P6 + P7 + P8 ¼ 68 þ 68 þ 68 þ 68 ¼ 272 kN
weight as 200 kN m-1. Sum of Loads towards the right of C.G of loads =
It may be observed from Table 1 that for the span 25 m P4 + P3 + P2 + P1 ¼ 114 þ 114 þ 27 þ 27 ¼ 282 kN
the critical load case will be A-6, consequently, all the Since, the sum of the loads towards right of C.G of the
eight axles are to be placed on the bridge for finding out loading system is greater than sum of loads towards the left
maximum longitudinal bending moment in the bridge. of C.G of loads, the first load towards right i.e. P4 will be
Thus the resultant of the loading system (R) will be the critical load.
R = 2792 ? 11492 ? 6894 = 554 kN. If the location ! xc ¼ x7 þ x6 þ x5 þ x4 ¼ 3 þ 3 þ 3 þ 4:3 ¼ 13:3 m
123
J. Inst. Eng. India Ser. A (June 2017) 98(1-2):201–210 209
Table 4 Critical load position and bending moments for Class-A loading
Span, Case Distance of critical load from Modification Distance of critical load from Shift in position Moment at critical load
m no. mid-span using conventional factor, m mid-span using proposed of critical load location including DL effect
method (s0) method (sm) (s0 - sm) due to kNm
Live Dead Total load
load load (MDL ? LL)
(MLL) (MDL)
As per the IRC6:2014, impact factor (I) for 25 m ðxc xÞ ð13:3 9:709Þ
Concrete bridge subjected to Class-A loading is, I = 4.5/ s0 ¼ ¼ ¼ 1:796 m
2 2
[6 ? 25] = 0.1451.
Now, the distance of the critical load P4 from right
support will be 12.5 - 1.796 = 10.704 m
Conventional Approach
Taking summation of bending moments at left support A
to find RB
Neglecting the effect of dead load, the distance of the X
critical load (i.e. P4) from the mid-span ‘s0’ may be cal- MRA ¼ RB 25 R ð25 10:704 ð9:091 5:5ÞÞ ¼ 0
culated as RB ¼ ½554 10:704=25 ¼ 237:211 kN
123
210 J. Inst. Eng. India Ser. A (June 2017) 98(1-2):201–210
Now the moment due to vehicular load may be MLLþDL ¼ 4785:61 þ 15611:83 ¼ 20397:44 kN m
calculated as
Thus it may be observed that keeping the critical load at
MLL ¼ ½2 ð1 þ IÞ conventionally calculated distance of 1.796 m from mid-
½RB 10:704 P3 1:2 P2 4:4 P1 5:5 span it overestimates the moments by 115 kN compared to
proposed modified methodology, where the critical load is
MLL ¼ ½2 ð1 þ IÞ
to be kept at 0.363 m from the mid-span. Also upon
½237:211 10:704 114 1:2 27 4:4 27 5:5 checking the case where wheel load was placed directly
above the centerline of the bridge to incorporate maximum
MLL ¼ ½2 ð1 þ IÞ 2135:125 ¼ 4270:25 1:145 dead load effect, it was found that this case gives bending
¼ 4889:43 kN m
moments lower than those calculated by placing the load at
Moments due to Gravity and super imposed load at mid critical location i.e. at 0.363 m from mid-span.
span: MDL = WL2/8 = [200 9 252]/2.2 = 15625 kN m
MLL ¼ 4889:43 þ 15625 ¼ 20514:43 kN m
Conclusions
Proposed Approach
Present study helps in eradicating the need of rigorous trial
The modification factor ‘m’ may be calculated as, and error to determine the number of wheels to be placed
on a particular span bridge to produce maximum bending
Rð1 þ IÞ
m ¼ moment, which can save valuable engineering decision
Rð1 þ IÞ þ wL=2
making time. Moreover, to facilitate the designers a simple
554 ð1 þ 0:1451Þ
¼ ¼ 0:202 and accurate method for determining the critical position of
554 ð1 þ 0:1451Þ þ 200 25=2
axels and maximum bending moment in the simply sup-
Hence, the distance of the critical load from the mid- ported bridges due to IRC Class-A and Class-70R wheeled
span of the bridge including the effect of uniformly vehicles, has been developed and the results have been
distributed dead load may be evaluated as, provided for bridges having span between 10 to 50 m for
sm ¼ s0 m ¼ 1:796 0:202 ¼ 0:3628 m the ready reference to the designers. Based on detailed
study, it has been observed that as the span length
Since, sm is positive, the critical load P4 should be increases, critical load approaches to mid-span. Via a
placed towards right with respect to mid-span, typical numerical example for 25 m span bridge subjected
Taking summation of bending moments at left support A to Class-A loading, it has been demonstrated that the
to find RB conventional approach is quite conservative and overesti-
X mates the maximum values of moments that are occurring
MRA ¼ RB L R ðL=2 þ sm ðxc xÞÞ ¼ 0
in the bridge. The proposed approach is recommended to
RB ¼ 554 ½25=2 þ 0:3628 ð13:30 9:709Þ=25 identify the critical load position and moment calculations
¼ 205:463 kN which is exact in nature. Proposed approach is quite easily
programmable for quicker use with any design software.
The bending moment at critical load position due to
dead load and live load may be calculated as,
MLL ¼ ½2 ð1 þ IÞ
½RB ðL=2 sm Þ P3 1:2 P2 4:4 P1 5:5 References
123