Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HEALING HANDS
Vol. 4, No. 5 ■ October 2000
1
HEALING HANDS
A PUBLIC ATION OF THE HCH CLINICIANS’ NETWORK
symptoms and retard further cognitive better.” Unfortunately, this is more the easily adhere to treatment, which brings
impairment. But patients with SPMI often exception than the rule, according to HCH relief from symptoms that interfere with
refuse medication. providers, whose clients may resist treatment social and cognitive functioning. Thus resi-
for years. dential stability is an important element of
C O - M O R B I D I T I E S At least one-half of any therapeutic strategy for the homeless
severely mentally ill homeless people are FEW WILLING AND ABLE mentally ill.
estimated to have a co-occurring substance P ROV I D E R S HCH clinicians struggle to
abuse disorder, according to Gary Morse, establish reliable referral networks that meet R E C OV E RY M O D E L O F C A R E
PhD, Community Alternatives, St. Louis, the human as well as medical needs of their Effective care for SPMI homeless clients
Missouri. But concurrent, integrated treat- mentally ill homeless clients. Projects that should follow a recovery model similar to
ment approaches thought to be most effective are affiliated with academic medical centers that used in the treatment of addiction disor-
for dually diagnosed individu- ders [See box], says Dr. Yuodelis
als are scarce in actual prac- Mental Health Outreach to Homeless Individuals: WHAT WORKS 5 Flores, who advocates a harm
tice.5 “Substance abuse exacer- • Intensive, personalized case management over a period of time reduction approach. “Treatment
bates cognitive impairment must be individualized and pro-
• Flexible ser vice planning and deliver y, addressing clients’ basic needs
over the long term, making ceed in steps. First, make
response to traditional addic- and priorities first clients feel safe in your pres-
tions treatment very difficult,” • Overlapping, individualized phases of treatment: ence. Use tact and diplomacy
says Dr. Yuodelis Flores. It also 1. Case finding/client identification to establish rapport; don’t ask
wreaks havoc with personal for all information at once.
2. Engagement/assessment and planning
finances and significantly Help clients connect with
3. Active resource and ser vice assistance (housing, entitlements, cloth-
increases other health risks — other providers to address co-
exposure to infectious diseases ing, transpor tation); direct psychotherapeutic inter ventions occurring illnesses. Use a team
and violence, social isolation, 4. Transition and relapse prevention — psychiatric medication manage- approach to case management,
and other hardships associated ment; concurrent, personalized case management and group therapy including
with extreme poverty. “Co- persons who have had positive
Gary Morse, PhD,
occurring mental illness and experiences with medication to
substance abuse makes it more Community Alternatives: Innovations in Behavioral Care, St. Louis, Missouri assist other clients in accepting
likely that people will be treatment. Consumer-driven
chronically homeless,” she says. Multiple are more likely to have established relation- care is important. Begin with extremely low
diagnoses vastly complicate the care of these ships with mental health professionals and doses of medication to minimize side effects.
clients, report HCH clinicians. other specialists. Unfortunately, many clini- Most important, be patient; building trust
cians outside targeted homeless programs and fostering treatment adherence may take
F E A R A N D M I S T RU S T O F C A R E - lack the experience, skills, and often the a long time.”
G I V E R S Paranoia may compound clients’ desire to engage and successfully treat the
rational fears of medication side effects or serious and complex health problems that I N T E G R AT E D S E RV I C E S Homeless
health systems that have failed to serve them distinguish severely mentally ill persons who service providers agree that fundamental
well, increasing their resistance to treatment. are homeless from those who are housed. changes in mainstream health care delivery
“Paranoid schizophrenics are adept at con- systems must be made to meet the needs of
cealing their mental illness to remain Effective Responses: persons with thought, mood and behavior
unmedicated,” notes Yuodelis Flores. “They H O U S I N G A S H E A LT H C A R E disorders that undermine their capacity to
become fearful whenever increased interest is Experienced mental health practitioners advocate for themselves or even seek the
expressed in them, and frequently travel from understand that permanently re-housing care they need. “Homeless mentally ill peo-
shelter to shelter, city to city.” Consequences homeless mentally ill persons is not a simple ple have multiple needs and require multiple
of lack of treatment include worsening of matter easily solved by inexpensive, quick services which must be provided over the
symptoms, homelessness, incarceration, vic- fixes. But they also know that treatment of long term,” explains Dr. Osher. “For those
timization and suicide. “The longer mental serious mental illness is difficult or impossible with severe mental disabilities, outreach,
illness goes untreated, the more difficult it is without some measure of residential stability.2 integrated case management, safe havens,
to treat,” she warns. “Optimally, treatment “Patients with severe mental illnesses who treatment, income support and benefits,
should begin during the first psychotic break. are housed have fewer complications, and are vocational training, supported employment,
People who receive treatment early in the much less likely to have co-occurring disor- and safe and affordable housing must all be
course of their illness often develop insight ders that exacerbate their illness,” explains woven together to end the cycle of homeless-
into their symptoms and adhere to treatment Dr. Yuodelis Flores. As a result, they more ness.”3 ■
2
HEALING HANDS
A PUBLIC ATION OF THE HCH CLINICIANS’ NETWORK
“You can’t be pushy, and you can’t set the “Newer anti-psychotics are among the safest drugs available. You can’t overdose on them and
agenda, warns psychiatric nurse Carol they don’t have many serious side effects or require blood monitoring. They are also easy to
Moriarty, BSN, RN, of Anchorage. “The client use in treatment — a single dose at bedtime or during the day (which may be preferable for
has to set the agenda, and you have to follow
street dwellers afraid of taking medications that induce deep sleep at night, when they are
it.” Every HCH project should have a close,
collaborative relationship with a psychiatrist more likely to be victimized).”
who is knowledgeable about the homeless Christine Yuodelis Flores, MD, Seattle, Washington
population, declares Christine Yuodelis Flores,
MD, of Seattle. Case managers and psychia- Although the mental health professionals pursuit by witches in the US government.
trists must work hand-in-hand to document interviewed for this article reported no diffi- He listed the psychiatrist’s name on his pass-
functional disabilities appropriately, she says. culty obtaining atypical psychotropic med- port as next-of-kin. Admitted involuntarily
ications free or at reduced prices from drug to an inpatient psychiatric unit for over a
The case manager helps gather medical his- companies, others say cost is a serious barrier month, he got the best care he had ever
tory information from other places. Some to obtaining these drugs for uninsured per- received, she reports, because Switzerland’s
Masters-level social workers document sons. The cost of a one-month supply of laws controlling involuntary treatment are
clients’ disabilities extremely well, she says. olanzepine is $504.17 for the most common far more lenient than King County,
A psychiatrist has only to review and dose (20 mg), reports Moriarty. “Don’t be Washington’s, and because he wasn’t dis-
approve their reports. “I review all data from fooled into thinking there are no adverse charged prematurely for financial reasons, as
the case manager and the medical history, effects from the newer psychotropic drugs,” in the United States.
together with information obtained from my she warns. “Tremendous weight gain (25–120
interview with the patient before arriving at lbs) can occur in patients taking olanzepine, Although psychotropic drugs may be neces-
a diagnosis,” she explains. “It may take more and risperidone can cause stiffness and lacta- sary to control disruptive symptoms, they are
than one interview. Some patients are reluc- tion in both women and men.” not sufficient to enable patients to cope with
tant to reveal any information — but that the life-long challenges presented by severe
tells you something too.” Resistance or lack of adherence to treatment mental illnesses. Individual and group therapy,
is a serious concern, as already mentioned. life skills training, and ongoing support groups
CONSIDERING THERAPEUTIC Patients frequently relapse during the course are also recommended to enable these persons
A LT E R N AT I V E S Clinicians must weigh of treatment and must be re-engaged. Laws to maintain stable housing, regain control
the pros and cons of prescribing older versus varying from state to state prohibit involun- of their lives, and re-enter the community,
newer (atypical) anti-psychotic drugs. tary treatment except under specific circum- PATH Exemplary Program practitioners
“Although older medications (fluphenazine, stances. In Alaska, for example, a court order remind us.
5
HEALING HANDS
A PUBLIC ATION OF THE HCH CLINICIANS’ NETWORK
3
HEALING HANDS
A PUBLIC ATION OF THE HCH CLINICIANS’ NETWORK
W H O W E R E YO U B E F O R E YO U G OT S I C K ? Just listening to staff meeting to tell us about their work with Mental Health
Carol Moriarty, BSN, RN, is enough to lower one’s blood pressure Homeless Services, a subsidiary of the mental health adult residential
a few notches. This psychiatric nurse, case manager and clinical asso- services unit of the county mental health services agency. They
ciate for the Crossover House Project in Anchorage, Alaska, exudes explained that their outreach is based on four basic principles:
compassion and gentle humor. Her project has also been recognized • Maintaining a consistent presence in places where homeless
as an exemplary PATH program for its aggressive community out- people congregate;
reach and skillful engagement of homeless persons with psychotic • Focusing on long-term goals including access to housing and
disorders. social services, and establishing a relationship with a mental
health counselor;
“Our number one engagement tool is hanging out,” says Moriarty. • Flexibility in service provision, proceeding at the individual
“We go into shelters and soup kitchens, get to know people who client’s pace; and
appear to be mentally ill, and give them an opportunity to know us. • Ongoing education of clients and other providers to assure that
An introduction from someone they know is helpful. Most don’t homeless people with mental disorders are never inappropriately
want anything to do with us and run.” Outreach may take as long as discharged from care.
15 years, she says. “Sometimes it’s hard to tell whether hallucinations
are secondary to a substance abuse disorder or a pre-existing mental “We base our outreach on a one-stop-shopping model, meeting
illness. Substance abusers may act like schizophrenics. Over time, homeless clients where they are with a package of services,” explains
we’ll see that they aren’t.” mental health manager Whitney Henry, MS (clinical psychology).
“Needs are addressed as they arise, with no appointments necessary,”
Moriarty and her colleagues try to lure people into their center with adds Cliftemma Allen, MA (counseling), mental health supervisor
lunch, coffee, clothing and bus tokens (so they don’t have to accept a for the Northwest region’s homeless services. “We receive referrals
ride in someone’s car). The facility is extremely attractive, with free from hospitals, county agencies, the police, community-based organi-
showers, free laundry and fairly loose rules. Clients can lie down on zations, citizens and shelters — where clients are also referred for ser-
the couch and take a nap. “They don’t sleep well outside when it’s vices. It’s a two-way street.”
below zero,” she explains. Clients can read the newspaper or maga-
zines there. “It’s a safe, comforting place to hang out.” “We practice ‘car therapy’ and ‘fast food therapy’ — developing rela-
tionships with our clients while driving to pick up food stamps or
“There are tremendous losses that must be grieved. Ask clients to talking at McDonald’s over lunch — whatever it takes,” says Nella
tell the stor y of their loss without labeling it as loss — ‘Tell me Leppo, BS (physiological psychology) mental health therapist for the
Mt. Vernon region. Outreach and shelter-based workers follow
what things were like before you got sick.’ ”
clients through the referral system within and beyond Fairfax
Carol Moriarty, BSN, RN, Anchorage, Alaska County. “We respond to the transience of our homeless clients by
remaining in close contact with providers in neighboring jurisdic-
“Don’t insist that clients acknowledge their mental illness,” she tions — in effect, by being transient ourselves,” remarks Dale
advises. “It doesn’t really matter. Try to get them to take medication Davidson, MA (neuropsychology), mental health supervisor for the
to make them feel better. Don’t label the illness ‘mental.’ Accept the Woodburn region. “We don’t allow clients to burn their bridges. It
client’s explanation for not feeling well.” Most people are aware that may take years and various engagement efforts, but we never give up
they are sick; they may or may not notice stigmatization by others, on them.” ■
which often occurs. Moriarty deals with stigma by addressing it from
a perspective of grief and loss. She offers an eight-week session on Reminders for Clinicians who Care for the
grieving, loosely adapting Elizabeth Kubler-Ross’ principles. “The
Homeless Mentally Ill
breakthrough is the identity part — when clients reveal who they
were before they got sick. Then we grieve together for the person • Relationship is the most impor tant element of healing.
who was.” • Don’t give up on anyone — provide services and be their advocate.
• Be open and receptive to second chances.
N O BU R N E D B R I D G E S For the past decade, Fairfax-Falls
• Allow time; expect this to be a long-term relationship.
Church Community Services Board (CSB), Fairfax County, Virginia,
has placed full-time outreach therapists in two county shelters and a • Set attainable, client-centered goals.
community mental health center, as the centerpiece of their exemplary • Build up formal and informal community resources.
PATH program. Drop-in groups of social workers and licensed thera- • Maintain a consistent presence.
pists provide direct service at each of these three sites, functioning • Remember — you can’t equate success with the number of
primarily as evaluation and referral clearinghouses for street-dwelling
people ser ved or the number of ser vices provided.
homeless people.
Mental Health Homeless Services, Fairfax County, Virginia
Four of these mental health practitioners graciously devoted part of a
4
HEALING HANDS
A PUBLIC ATION OF THE HCH CLINICIANS’ NETWORK
M A N AG I N G M U LT I P L E D I AG N O S E S fragmented discharge planning. The client that clients with multiple diagnoses show up
One HCH clinician reports a case illustrat- smells bad, is extremely abusive to clinicians, for clinic appointments and get proper med-
ing the quandary many clinicians face in and chronically misses appointments, some- ical care,” says outreach therapist Dale
deciding how to handle severely mentally ill times returning years later. When HCH Davidson, MA, Fairfax County, Virginia.
patients with multiple diagnoses. A client providers objected to his misuse of medica- “Educating clients and other providers is an
with schizophrenia and a self-reported gender tions and suggested that a representative essential part of this work. We accompany
identity disorder repeatedly obtains Premarin payee assume responsibility for his finances, clients to pick up supplies, advocate for them
(estrogen) from area physicians not associat- he left again. The good news is, he is report- when they are inappropriately discharged,
ed with the HCH project. The hormone ed to have engaged with another case man- and do everything we can to keep them in
therapy exacerbates his asthma and a serious agement program to which they referred him. housing. For clients who are resistant to care,
cardiac condition. He has been homeless for it’s important just to be there, with very fre-
17 years, intermittently hospitalized, with “An increasing part of our job is making sure quent contacts.” ■
SOURCES AND RESOURCES: 6. National Resource Center on Homelessness and Mental Illness: Toll Free Number:
1. William R. Breakey, MD — as cited in Meyer and Schwartz editorial, Social Illness as (800) 444-7415; www.prainc.com/nrc/index.html.
Public Health: Promise and Peril, J Am Pub Health Assn, August 2000: 7. Crisis Prevention Institute, Inc. (CPI), 3315–K North 124th St., Brookfield, WI 53005:
www.apha.org/journal/editorials. (800) 558-8976; www.crisisprevention.com.
2. Gary Morse, PhD. A Review of Case Management for People Who Are Homeless: 8. National Coalition for the Homeless. Mental Health and Homelessness, NCH
Implications for Practice, Policy, and Research; McMurray-Avila M, Gelberg L & Factsheet #5, April 1999: http://nch.ari.net/mental.html.
Breakey WR. Balancing Act: Clinical Practices that Respond to the Needs of Homeless
9. US Dept. of Health and Human Services. Mental Health: A Report of the Surgeon
People — presented at the DHHS/HUD Homelessness Research Symposium, October
General. Rockville, MD: NDHHS/SAMHSA/CMHS/NIH/NIMH, 1999:
1998: http://aspe.hhs.gov/progsys/homeless/symposium.
www.surgeongeneral.gov/library/mentalhealth/home.html.
3. Fred Osher, MD. Homelessness Complicates Treatment for Mental Illness, HealthLine: a
10. Lipton FR, et al. Tenure in Supportive Housing for Homeless Persons with Severe
publication of Health Care for the Homeless, Inc., Baltimore, Maryland, June 2000.
Mental Illness, Psychiatr Serv, April 2000; 51(4): 479–86.
4. Federal Task Force on Homelessness and Severe Mental Illness. Outcasts on Main Street.
11. Fisk D, et al. Integrating Consumer Staff Members into a Homeless Outreach Project:
Washington, DC: Interagency Council on the Homeless, 1992: (800) 444-7415 (FREE
Critical Issues and Strategies, Psych Rehab J, March 2000;23(3):244–52.
report, 91 pages).
12. Rosenheck R, Frisman L & Kasprow W. Improving Access to Disability Benefits among
5. Gary Morse, PhD. Reaching Out to Homeless People with Serious Mental Illness under
Homeless Persons with Mental Illness: an Agency-specific Approach to Services
Managed Care. Center for Mental Health Services/SAMHSA/DHHS, June 1999.
Integration, Am J Pub Health, April 1999; 89(4): 524–28: www.apha.org/journal
Communications Committee
Adele O’Sullivan, MD (Chair); Jan Caughlan, LCSW-C; Lisa Cunningham Roberts, MA, NCC; Liz DelaTorres, BSW; James Dixon, BSW;
Karen Holman, MD, MPH; Scott Orman; Linda Ruble, PA-C, ARNP; Pat Post, MPA (Editor)
Healing Hands is a publication of Health Care for the Homeless Clinicians’ Network, National Health Care for the Homeless Council.
P.O. Box 60427, Nashville, Tennessee 37206-0427 ~ For membership information, call (615) 226-2292 or visit www.nhchc.org.