Class Debate: Manufacturing Debate

Teacher Name: Mr. Hagans

Student Name: ________________________________________

CATEGORY 4 3 2 1
Information All information presented in Most information presented Most information presented Information ha
the debate was clear, in the debate was clear, in the debate was clear and inaccuracies O
accurate and thorough. accurate and thorough. accurate, but was not usually not cle
usually thorough.

Respect for Other All statements, body
Team language, and responses
were respectful and were in
appropriate language.
Statements and responses Most statements and Statements, re
were respectful and used responses were respectful and/or body la
appropriate language, but and in appropriate consistently no
once or twice body language, but there was one
language was not. sarcastic remark.

Use of Facts/Statistics Every major point was well
supported with several
relevant facts, statistics
and/or examples.
Every major point was Every major point was Every point wa
adequately supported with supported with facts, supported.
relevant facts, statistics statistics and/or examples,
and/or examples. but the relevance of some
was questionable.

Organization All arguments were clearly
tied to an idea (premise)
and organized in a tight,
logical fashion.
Most arguments were All arguments were clearly Arguments we
clearly tied to an idea tied to an idea (premise) but tied to an idea
(premise) and organized in the organization was
a tight, logical fashion. sometimes not clear or
logical.

Rebuttal All counter-arguments were Most counter-arguments Most counter-arguments Counter-argum

accurate, relevant and were accurate, relevant, were accurate and relevant, not accurate a
strong. and strong. but several were weak.
Understanding of The team clearly The team clearly undestood The team seemed to The team did n
Topic understood the topic in- the topic in-depth and understand the main points adequate unde
depth and presented their presented their information of the topic and presented the topic.
information forcefully and with ease. those with ease.
convincingly.

Date Created: Mar 13, 2019 03:37 pm (CDT)