Professional Documents
Culture Documents
6 (2010), 1151-1158
Original Research
Experimental Study of the Lower Heating Value
of Medical Waste
Janusz Bujak*
Abstract
This paper presents an experimental study of the heating value of medical waste using an input-output
method. The study was carried out at the Oncological Hospital in Bydgoszcz, Poland, over a period of three
months. The installation for thermal treatment consisted of a loading unit, a combustion chamber, and a dis-
charge chamber (thermoreactor). The medical waste constituted the primary fuel, and high-methane natural
gas acted as the secondary fuel. With regard to the high heating value and low humidity of medical waste, the
thermal processing in the combustion chamber fulfilled the criterion of stable combustion (autothermal com-
bustion). The average temperature in the combustion chamber was 665.5ºC during the testing period. The
study showed that the heating value of the waste varied considerably. The amount of incinerated waste varied
between ṁmw=70 kg/h and 140 kg/h during the testing period. The calorific value of the medical waste fluc-
tuated between 8.5 MJ/kg and 41.2 MJ/kg, with a mean value of qmw=19.1 MJ/kg.
residues and a secondary chamber for complete gaseous demands and supplies, the shapes of buildings in the
product combustion. Furthermore, Feindler [7] developed demand area, and life-cycle analysis. The utilization of
the input-output method to determine the solid residue heat- waste heat in the industrial area has also been described by
ing value, thermal efficiency of the incineration system, and Meneghetti et al. [14]. That work illustrated a waste-to-
specific steaming rate of two-stage municipal solid residue energy plant to be used for the industrial waste of the dis-
combustors with multiple furnaces. Kuo et al. [8] estimated trict of Friuli Venezia Giulia. It described how the expense
the heating value of solid residue, steaming rate, and ener- for woodworking-waste disposal can become an advantage
gy recovery efficiency based on the energy balance analy- for the firms of the district owing to the incineration of this
sis for the boiler-furnace system. waste in a plant unique for the type of waste treated.
Solid residue heating value estimation can provide As mentioned above, medical waste is comprised of
insight into the quantity of fuel needed to burn and the heterogeneous components in various quantities. Therefore,
amount of energy that could be recovered [9-11]. The it is difficult to separate a representative sample to deter-
insight into the amount of recovered energy, in turn, enables mine its heating value in a calorimetric bomb or with chem-
one to apply suitable solutions and technologies needed for ical analysis. This paper presents an experimental study on
its management. Holmgren [12] analyzed a municipal dis- estimating the heating value of medical waste using the
trict-heating (DH) system that uses waste heat from indus- input-output method that considers the energy flux balance.
tries and waste incineration as base suppliers of heat and is The tests lasted for three months and were conducted in a
currently investing in a natural-gas-fired combined heat- hospital. The results can be useful at the design stage of the
and-power (CHP) plant. That study showed that there is incineration facilities for medical waste, e.g. when sizing a
room in the DH system for all three energy carriers: heat combustion chamber or a thermoreactor. Knowledge of the
from industries, waste incineration, and CHP plants. Mori waste heating value also permits the estimation of the quan-
et al. [13] presented a model for heat energy from river tity of secondary fuel or the determination of the energy
water and treated sewage water, and a system using waste- efficiency of an incinerator that incorporates a heat recov-
heat energy from municipal solid-waste incineration plants ery boiler.
was built and applied to the Tokyo urban area in Japan, con-
sidering the spatial and time-related distribution of
Energy Balance, Mass Balance,
and the Heating Value of Medical Waste
Technology Description
natural gas B
E ng flue gases E fg-pe
m ng t ng B
DISCHARGE
CHAMBER m fg t fg E fg-che
E es-dch
E es-cch
LOADING
B
E mw m mw COMBUSTION
CHAMBER
m amw t amw
E as-pe E as-che E amw
Fig. 2. Energy and mass flows of the incinerator.
...where the components of energy flux supplied to the sys- After introducing the subsequent equations:
tem are on the left side of the equation (1), and the compo-
nents of energy flux lost or carried away from the installa- m ng m ng cch m ng dch (7)
tion are on the right side.
After introducing the subsequent equations: m amw m amw cch m amw dch (8)
E amw E amw cch E amw dch (3) ...equation (6) has the following form:
E ang E ang cch E ang dch (4) m mw m ng cch m ng dch m amw cch
m amw dch m ang cch m ang dch m as m fg
...equation (1) has the following form:
(10)
Emw Eng cch Eng dch Eamwcch Eamwdch Heating Value of Medical Waste
Eangcch Eangdch Eas pe Easche Eescch The heating value of medical waste was determined
based on the energy and mass balances (5) according to the
E E
es dch E
fg pe fg che
(5)
following formula:
(11)
Mass Balance of the System Eas pe Easche Eescch Eesdch E fg pe E fg che
...where:
m mw m ng m amw m ang m as m fg (6)
E mw m mw q mw (12)
...where the components representing mass supplied to the
m mw m as m fg m ng cch m ng dch
system are on the left side of the equation (6), and the com-
(13)
ponents carried away from the installation are on the right m amw cch m amw dch m ang cch m ang dch
side.
1154 Bujak J.
RECORDER
ti
COMPUTER
EMISSION
P T
B
NATURAL GAS B
GM DISCHARGE FLUE GASES
GM1 CHAMBER
LOADING OF B
COMBUSTION
MEDICAL WASTE CHAMBER
ASH
AM2
T
AM1
Fig. 3. Measurement system of energy fluxes supplied to the Fig. 4. Gas sampling system (measurements of flue gas fluxes
investigated installation. and dustiness).
Experimental Study of the Lower Heating Value... 1155
Table 1. Flue gas composition after the recovery boiler. The air used for natural gas combustion was taken directly
Type of measured parameter Min Max from the surroundings (incineration room). The tempera-
ture of the air fluctuated between ti=tang=25.2ºC and 29.5ºC.
CO2 [kg/h] 211.0 317.5
The enthalpy flux in this air did not exceed Ėang=3.2 kW.
O2 [kg/h] 385.6 572.5
H2O [kg/h] 134.6 351.1 Energy Flux Lost or Carried Away
from the System
Other compounds [kg/h]
(CO, NOx, SO2, HCl, HF, 1.7 9.9 The physical and chemical enthalpy fluxes of the flue
volatile dust) gases were removed from the incineration system after the
discharge chamber. The temperature of the flue gases oscil-
lated between tfg=1,102.7ºC and 1,167.5ºC. As seen in Fig.
6, the energy flux of flue gases removed from the incinera-
Table 2. Chemical composition of natural gas.
tor varied considerably and fluctuated between 202.3 kW
Methane [%] 97.51 and 1,530.1 kW. The average value of the energy flux
Ethane [%] 1.06 obtained in the testing period was Ėfg=1,012.9 kW. Because
there was only a trace amount of carbon monoxide in the
Propane [%] 0.37
flue gases (0.1-1.1 kg/h), the energy flux carried away as
CO2 [%] 0.05 chemical enthalpy was negligible.
Heat flux is lost from the incinerator to the environment
Nitrogen [%] 0.81
through the external surfaces of the combustion and dis-
Others [%] 0.20 charge chambers, as well as from the physical and chemi-
cal enthalpy fluxes of the exiting slag and ash. Fig. 7 shows
that the energy flux lost through the external surfaces of the
incinerator had an approximately constant value. The mean
The natural gas used for incinerating the medical waste value of the heat flux lost due to heat transfer through the
was comprised of 97.5% methane, and its calorific value combustion chamber was Ėes-cch=26.4 kW, and that through
was 36.2 MJ/N·m3. A detailed description of the natural gas
composition is shown in Table 2.
It was difficult to determine the elementary composition
f l u x ofo chemical
flux f c h e m ienthalpy
c a l e n tash amedical
l p y a swaste
medical waste
of the medical waste because of its heterogeneity. Hospital e n t h a l pflux
enthalpy y f l as
u x air
a sused
a i r for
u s medical
e d f o r waste
m e d icombustion
c a l w a s t eflux
c o of
m bchemical
ustion
1200 enthalpy
f l u x o f asc hnatural
e m i c agas
documentation revealed that plastics were the main compo- l enthalpy as natural gas
1000
f l u x[kW]
400
Energy Flux Supplied to the Incinerator
200
2008-11-10
2008-11-12
2008-11-19
2008-11-23
2008-11-27
2008-11-24
2008-11-26
2008-12-01
2008-12-05
2008-12-13
2008-12-17
2008-12-22
2008-12-24
2008-12-28
ical waste, natural gas, and air used for their combustion. As
seen in Fig. 5, the greatest energy flux represents the waste.
Period
P e r i o of
d otime
f time
The values of the flux varied from 80.9 kW to 1,119.8 kW.
Fig. 5. Energy flux supplied to the incinerator.
The mean value of the chemical enthalpy flux as medical
waste was Ėmw=600.2 kW. The energy flux as natural gas
(secondary fuel), in turn, fluctuated from 126.5 kW to 811.0
kW, reaching an average value of Ėng=415.7 kW during the
Enthalpy flux of flue gases [kW]
Enthalpy flux of flue gases [kW]
1600
800
combustion (autothermal combustion). The average tem-
600
perature in the combustion chamber was 665.5ºC during the
400
testing period. At the standard conditions of the incinerator
200
operation there was no gas consumption in the combustion
0
chamber. The gas burners supporting the chamber activated
2008-11-08
2008-11-10
2008-11-12
2008-11-19
2008-11-23
2008-11-27
2008-11-24
2008-11-26
2008-12-01
2008-12-05
2008-12-13
2008-12-17
2008-12-22
2008-12-24
2008-12-28
bustion oscillated between tamw=93.7ºC and 127.5ºC, and the Fig. 6. Physical and chemical enthalpy flux of flue gases exit-
enthalpy flux in air was between Ėamw=5.2 kW and 95.2 kW. ing the discharge chamber.
1156 Bujak J.
H e a flux
Heat t f l uloss
x l –o combustion
s s - c o m bchamber
usti on cha mb e r
medical waste determined for a mean heating value.
90
80
Probable measured deviation of the lower heating
19.1±0.89
s [k W ]
70
value (MJ/kg)
l o s [kW]
50 value (MJ/kg)
40
a t f lflux
30
H e Heat
20
10
flux of the flue gases obtained via measurements was com-
0
pared with the value determined by the balance calcula-
2008-11-08
2008-11-10
2008-11-12
2008-11-19
2008-11-23
2008-11-27
2008-11-24
2008-11-26
2008-12-01
2008-12-05
2008-12-13
2008-12-17
2008-12-22
2008-12-24
2008-12-28
tions.
The amounts of waste, secondary fuel, air used for com-
P ePeriod
r i o d oof
f ttime
ime bustion, slag, and ash were measured during the investiga-
Fig. 7. Heat flux lost to the atmosphere through the external tion. The mean calculated flux of the flue gases, which was
surfaces of the combustion and discharge chambers. equal to the total amount of medical waste, secondary fuel,
and air for combustion (without slag and ash), was com-
pared with the results obtained by the flue gas continuous
the discharge chamber was Ėes-dch=31.5 kW. The energy flux control panel. The maximal difference between the mean
losses due to deslagging and deashing were not significant. flux and the measured flux was 4.6%.
Neither the physical enthalpy flux nor the chemical
enthalpy flux exceeded 3 kW in each case.
Conclusions
Heating Value of Medical Waste
This work describes experimental studies on the heating
The tests showed (Fig. 6) that the heating value of med- value of medical waste using the input-output method. The
ical waste is highly variable. It should be noted that the incineration system consisted of a loading unit, a combus-
amount of burned waste fluctuated in the range from ṁ mw=70 tion chamber, and a thermoreactor. The tests were carried
kg/h to 140 kg/h over the entire investigation period. The out in the Oncological Hospital in Bydgoszcz. Medical
heating value of medical waste during the tests ranged from wastes were supplied as primary fuel, and high-methane
8.5 MJ/kg to 41.2 MJ/kg, with a mean value of qmw=19.1 natural gas fed the system as secondary fuel. The investiga-
MJ/kg. The calorific value of the medical waste was deter- tion lasted for three months.
mined by Eq. 11. The measurements were carried out at a The study showed that the medical waste was character-
steady state, excluding start-ups and damping periods. ized by a high calorific value and low humidity; hence, the
thermal treatment process was steady (autothermal). The
Accuracy of the Measurement Analysis mean temperature in the combustion chamber was 665.5ºC.
When the incinerator worked at standard conditions, there
was no gas consumption in the combustion chamber. The
The measurement uncertainties of the lower heating
gas burners in the primary chamber switched on only during
value were determined by the total differential method. The
the system start-up. The tests revealed that the heating value
maximum and probable measurement uncertainties for the
of the burned wastes was highly variable. The amount of
calorific value of medical waste were determined using for-
incinerated wastes varied between ṁmw=70 kg/h and 140
mulas (14) and (15):
kg/h during the testing period. The heating value of medical
u ( q mw ) max ª n u ( xi ) º
r «¦ » (14) 45
q mw ¬ i 1 xi ¼
lue [MJ/kg]
40
35
2
u ( q mw ) prob § u ( xi )
n g v a[MJ/kg]
n
· 30
q mw
¦ ¨¨ ¸¸ (15) 25
i 1 © xi ¹ 20
r h e a t ivalue
15
8
L o w e heating
10
The results of formulas (14) and (15) are shown in
5
Table 3.
0
Lower
2008-11-08
2008-11-10
2008-11-12
2008-11-19
2008-11-23
2008-11-27
2008-11-24
2008-11-26
2008-12-01
2008-12-05
2008-12-13
2008-12-17
2008-12-22
2008-12-24
2008-12-28
wastes fluctuated between 8.5 MJ/kg and 41.2 MJ/kg, reach- ṁang-dch – flux of air mass used for natural gas combustion
ing the average rate of qmw=19.1 MJ/kg. The measurements in the discharge chamber (kg/h)
were carried out at steady state, disregarding the start-up ṁfg – flux of flue gas mass (kg/h)
periods and damping periods of the furnace. ṁmw – flux of medical waste mass (kg/h)
The obtained results can be helpful at the design stage ṁng – flux of natural gas mass (kg/h)
of incinerators, for example, to calculate specifications for ṁng-cch – flux of natural gas mass supplied to the combustion
combustion chambers or discharge chambers (thermoreac- chamber (kg/h)
tors). The knowledge of waste heating values permits the ṁng-dch – flux of natural gas mass supplied to the discharge
calculation of the amount of secondary fuel or the determi-
chamber (kg/h)
nation of the energy efficiency of the incinerator together
tang – air temperature used for natural gas combustion
with the heat recovery boiler.
(ºC)
tamw – air temperature used for medical waste incineration
Nomenclature (ºC)
tfg – temperature of flue gases (ºC)
Ėang – enthalpy flux with air used for natural gas ti – indoor air temperature (ºC)
combustion (kW) tng – temperature of natural gas (ºC)
Ėang-cch – enthalpy flux with air used for natural gas qmw – low heating value of medical waste (MJ/kg)
combustion in the combustion chamber (kW)
Ėang-dch – enthalpy flux with air used for natural gas
combustion in the discharge chamber (kW) Subscripts
Ėamw – enthalpy flux with air used for medical waste
incineration (kW) AM1 – air meter (air used for medical waste incineration
Ėamw-cch – enthalpy flux with air used for waste incineration – combustion chamber)
AM2 – air meter (air used for after-burning gases –
in the combustion chamber (kW)
discharge chamber)
Ėamw-dch – enthalpy flux with air used for after-burning gases
B – natural gas-fired burner
in the discharge chamber (kW)
GM – total gas meter
Ėas-che – chemical enthalpy flux of hot ash in the combustion
GM1 – gas meter – combustion chamber
chamber (kW)
Ėas-pe – physical enthalpy flux of hot ash in the combustion
chamber (kW) References
Ėes-cch – heat flux lost to the environment through the
external surface of the combustion chamber (kW) 1. KUO J.T. System simulation and control of batch-fed solid
Ėes-dch – heat flux lost to the environment through the waste incinerators. Transactions of ASME, Journal of
external surface of the discharge chamber (kW) Dynamic Systems, Measurement and Control. 118, 620,
1996.
Ėfg – enthalpy flux of flue gases (kW)
2. GOOD J., NUSSBAUMER T. Efficiency improvement and
Ėfg-che – chemical enthalpy flux of flue gases (kW) emission reduction by advanced combustion control tech-
Ėfg-pe – physical enthalpy flux of flue gases (kW) nique (ACCT) with CO/lambda control and set point opti-
Ėmw – flux of chemical enthalpy supplied as medical mization. In: Biomass for energy industry, 10th European
waste (kW) conference and technology exhibition, Wurzburg, Germany.
pp. 1362-1365, 1998.
Ėng – flux of chemical enthalpy as natural gas supplied
3. CHEN K.S., TSAI Y.J., LOU J.C. Three-dimensional com-
to the incinerator (kW) bustion modeling in municipal solid-waste incinerator.
Ėng-cch – flux of chemical enthalpy as natural gas supplied Journal of Environment Engineering 125, (2), 166, 1999.
to the combustion chamber (kW) 4. YANG Y.B., GOH Y.R., ZAKARIA R., NASSERZADEH
Ėng-dch – flux of chemical enthalpy as natural gas supplied V., SWITHENBANK J. Mathematical modeling of MSW
to the discharge chamber (kW) incineration on a travelling bed. Waste Management. 22,
ṁas – flux of ash mass (kg/h) 369, 2002.
5. RYU C., YANG Y.B., NASSERZADEH V., SWITHEN-
ṁamw – flux of air mass used for medical waste combustion BANK J. Thermal reaction modeling of a large municipal
(kg/h) solid waste incinerator. Combustion Science and
ṁamw-cch – flux of air mass used for medical waste combustion Technology; 176, 1891, 2004.
in the combustion chamber (kg/h) 6. KODRES C.A. Theoretical thermal evaluation of energy
ṁamw-dch – flux of air mass used for medical waste combustion recovery incinerators, part I: modeling. ASME Journal of
Energy Resources Technology. 109, 79, 1987.
in the discharge chamber (kg/h)
7. FEINDLER K.S. Adaptation of the boiler as calorimeter
ṁang – flux of air mass used for natural gas combustion method to two-stage municipal waste combustors. In:
(kg/h) Proceedings of the 1996 ASME 17th biennial waste pro-
ṁang-cch – flux of air mass used for natural gas combustion cessing conference. Atlantic City, NJ: ASME. pp. 459-82,
in the combustion chamber (kg/h) 1996.
1158 Bujak J.
8. KUO J.T., CHAN C.Y., CHEN C.N. Heat and mass balance 11. VAN KESSEL L.B.M., ARENDSEN A.R.J., BREM G. On-
analysis of Mu-Cha MSW-to-energy incineration plant. In: line determination of the calorific value of solid fuels. Fuel,
Proceedings of the second international conference on solid 83, 59, 2004.
waste management. Taipei, Taiwan: EPA and Taipei City 12. HOLMGREN K. Role of a district-heating network as a user
Government, ROC. pp. 265-74, 2000. of waste-heat supply from various sources – the case of
9. KATHIRAVALE S., YUNUS MNM., SOPIAN K., SAM- Göteborg, Appl Energy, 83, 1351, 2006.
SUDDIN A.H., RAHMAN R.A. Modeling the heating 13. MORI Y., KIKEGAWA Y., UCHIDA H. A model for detailed
value of municipal solid waste. Fuel. 82, 1119, 2003. evaluation of fossil-energy saving by utilizing unused but possi-
10. MERAZ L., DOMINGUEZ A., KORNHAUSER I., ROJAS ble energy-sources on a city scale, Appl Energy, 84, 921, 2007.
F. A thermo-chemical concept-based equation to estimate 14. MENEGHETTI A., NARDIN G., SIMEONI P. Waste-to-
waste combustion enthalpy from elemental composition. energy application in an industrial district, Apply Energy, 72,
Fuel. 82, 1499, 2003. 443, 2002.