Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ireland was the centre of paralysis: Joyce accused Irish people to be weak, passive, unable or unwilling
to rebel against the British domination. Dubliners is a collection of fifteen short stories about people
living in Dublin: mainly, lower middle class Dubliners, who witnessed economic problems, moral
constraints caused by religion, and political, economic and cultural domination by the British.
Like Jonathan Swift had done 150 years before in his novel “Gulliver’s travels”, Joyce also accused Irish
people to be weak and passive (although Joyce deeply loved his motherland Ireland).
The dominant theme of the fifteen short stories is the failure to find a way out of this paralysis: the
main characters of each short story know that the life they are leading is unsatisfying and frustrating,
but they cannot (or maybe don’t want to) do something to change it. Their free will is paralyzed (like in
Italo Svevo’s “inetti”).
Each short story opens in medias res, when a turning point is going to occur in the life of the
protagonist. This critical moment is called “epiphany”: an epiphany is the sudden manifestation of a
hidden or removed truth (for example: a fear, or a secret wish). It is a spiritual revelation, a sudden
recognition of meaning, caused by an external object or an unexpected situation, a song, a scent, an
image. After the epiphany, the character changes his understating of himself and the reality around
him, for he realizes his or her miserable condition.
EVELINE (Dubl.)
“Eveline” is the story of a young woman abused by her alcoholic father. She has the chance to leave to
Buenos Aires with her boyfriend Frank, but she hears a song that reminds her of the melody she heard
on the day of her mother’s death. Eveline promised her mother to look after the house and keep the
family together. At the dock, where she and Frank are about to embark, Eveline decides not to leave:
Eveline is paralyzed in her horrible life. The name “Eveline” is symbolical/allegorical: Eveline means
“Little Eve”. So, unlike Eve in the Bible (who chose to eat the Forbidden Apple), she is unable to choose,
her will is paralyzed.
ULYSSES
In “Ulysses”, Joyce’s masterpiece, Stephen Dedalus returns to Dublin. He has failed as an artist, now he
is only a simple teacher. The story is set in Dublin on a single day: June [the] 16th, 1904. Stephen has
lost his father (Simon Dedalus has cut him out of his life). Another Dubliner, Leopold Bloom, a 38-year
advertising canvasser, son of a Hungarian Jew, suffers from two emotional crises: the loss of his father
and of his son, and the infidelity of his wife, Molly Bloom. Stephen, Leopold and Molly correspond to
Telemachus, Ulysses and his faithful wife Penelope. According to the mythical method, the twentieth
century versions of Homer’s characters reveal the clash between a mythical, meaningful, ordered past
and a meaningless, chaotic present. Joyce made a constant parallel between antiquity and present
time. Every character and every episode is linked to the Odissey: Joyce shared Eliot’s idea that using
myth is “the only way of giving shape and significance to the immense panorama of futility which is
contemporary history” (quotation from T. S. Eliot’s “Ulysses, order and myth”)
Joyce and the other modernist writers wanted their writing to be the mirror of their chaotic world:
modern society witnessed a disordered lack of meaning, which no omniscient and absolute point of
view could solve. That’s why there are many narrative point of views in modernists works.
Another technique used by Joyce is the mythical method, theorized by the modernist writer T. S. Eliot:
the writer makes a continuous comparison between an ordered and meaningful mythical past and
the chaotic and meaningless present, in order to “give shape and order to the immense panorama of
futility” which is modern time, and to show the breakdown of European culture. (example: Molly
Bloom-Penelope in the “Ulysses”)
3
DETTATO
Joyce is the pioneer of the modern novel, he broke the heritage with the tradition of realistic novel of
the previous century. Joyce wrote “Dubliners”, “A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man” and “Ulysses”.
“Dubliners” is a collection of 15 short stories; each story covers a crucial moment of the life of the main
character. The story opens in medias res, we are not given a complete report of the life of the
protagonist; the reader gets in immediate contact with the main character, who is first described in his
quotidian life in Dublin; the protagonist knows that the life he is leading is unsatisfactory but he
cannot (or maybe he does not want to) do something to change it. He is paralyzed and his free will is
ill, like Italo Svevo’s “inetti” (unfit).
None of the protagonists of the 15 short stories of “Dubliners” can say “no” to their frustrating life;
unlike Joyce, Eveline and Gabriel know that their life is unsatisfying, but they remain trapped,
paralyzed. Gabriel, the main character of “The Dead”, is a teacher and a literary critic. Gabriel cannot
make art, he is sterile, he is spiritually dead. His wife Gretta is touched when a song reminds her of her
first love, Michael, a singer, a young man who was able to make art, who was spiritually alive. Michael
died: he was seriously ill but he wanted to see his love Gretta before he died. When Gabriel asked
Gretta “Why did he die?”, she answered: “I think he died for me”. This is an epiphany to Gabriel: not
because he becomes aware that his wife still loves Michael, but because he realizes for the first time
that he has nobody and nothing to live or die for: his life seems to be empty to him, without sense,
without purpose.
An epiphany is an unexpected spiritual revelation of a removed truth; this revelation happens
because an external object, a song, a scent reminds the protagonist of some hidden or removed
secret of the past. After an epiphany, everything changes in the life of the protagonist: he starts to
see himself and the world around him with a new awareness.
Joyce deeply loved Dublin: in his masterpiece “Ulysses” the streets and the places of Dublin are
described to the smallest detail; despite his love for Dublin, for Ireland, Joyce was aware that Dublin
was the centre of paralysis: Dubliners were passive people, unable to say “no” to the economic,
political and cultural domination of England. Like Swift had done 150 years before, when in “Gulliver’s
travels” he mocked the superiority of English people and wanted to push Irish people to rebellion,
Joyce also accused Irish people to be weak.
Joyce chose a voluntary exile before in Paris, then in Trieste. Trieste was an influent cultural capital
during the first decades of the XX century. In Trieste Joyce made friends with Italo Svevo, he
encouraged him when his first novels seemed to be a failure.
Joyce knew Freud’s psychoanalysis: he was completely aware that the traditional novel was not
appropriate for the modern literature anymore. A new writing technique was necessary: the interior
monologue, a stream of memories [=of consciousness], ideas, fears, emotions which freely flow at a
pre-speech level, that is before they are translated into words to share with others. Joyce used the
stream of consciousness technique in his masterpiece “Ulysses”. The best example of interior
monologue can be found in the last chapter of “Ulysses”, titled “Penelope”. One of the main characters,
Molly Bloom, after she urinates, a stream of physical liquids, is about to fall asleep, when a stream of
memories, desires, sensations, begins to flow in her consciousness. She remembers her youth in
Gibraltar, her first loves, when she met her husband Leopold, in an accumulation which reaches the
climax when she thinks “And I said <<yes, I want it, yes…>”. Molly Bloom is the XX century version of
Homer’s Penelope: Joyce employed the mythical method, theorized by Eliot, to contrast the mythical
past to the squalid present.
4
FORM
Free indirect [indirect] speech and free association of ideas
Stream of consciousness technique and interior monologue
Discontinuous narrative and multiple narrative points of view
Quotation and wide use of classical allusions
THEMES
Life is viewed as incoherent, experience as fragmented, reality as a matter of perception.
Alienation and spiritual loneliness
Objection to traditional thoughts and moralities
Disillusionment and despair of the individual
EVELINE (VIDEO)
10
11
12
13