You are on page 1of 8

A contemporary review of the factors involved in

complete dentures. Part II: Stability


T. E. Jacobson, D.D.S.,* and A. J. Krol, D.D.S.**
University of California, School of Dentistry, San Francisco, Calif., and Veterans Administration Medical Center,
San Frankco, Calif.

C omplete denture stability is the resistance to


horizontal or rotational forces. It differs from retention
tissues not only allows the establishment of border seal
and coverage of maximum supporting area but also
in that stability resists forces in the horizontal plane provides maximum contact of the denture base with
whereas retention is the resistance to vertical dislodging facial and lingual ridge slopes.
forces. As described in Part I, stability ensures the The nature of the overlying soft tissues determines
physiologic comfort of the patient while retention the potential of a given region in tolerating stress.
contributes to psychologic comfort. The lack of stability While the tissues of the maxillary palatal inclines are
often makes ineffective the factors involved in retention ideally designed to resist forces of the denture base, thi
and support. A denture that shifts easily in response to maxillary facial and mandibular lingual inclines may
laterally applied forces can cause a disruption in the be less effective due to the thin alveolar mucosal
border seal or prevent the denture base from correctly covering.
relating to the supporting tissues. The factors that Optimal denture stability requires that those tissues
contribute to stability include ridge height and confor- that provide resistance to horizontal forces be properly
mation, base adaptation, residual ridge relationships, recorded and related to the denture base. Boucher2
occlusal harmony, and neuromuscular control. These notes that stability is obtained by incorporating the
factors can be condensed into the following cate- surfaces of the maxillary and mandibular ridges, which
gories: are at right an.gle to the occlusal plane. He further
1. The relationship of the denture base to the states that stability requires “maximum use of all bony
underlying tissues foundations where the tissues are firmly and closely
2. The relationship of the external surface and attached to bone.“3 Positive and intimate contact of the
border to the surrounding orofacial musculature denture base with these inclines as limited by the
3. The relationship of the opposing occlusal sur- nature of the overlying soft tissues determines the
faces degree of stability attained.

RELATIONSHIP OF DENTURE BASE MANDIBULAR LINGUAL FLANGE


TO TISSUES The most desirable feature of the lingual slope of the
The relationship of the intaglio of the denture base mandible is that it approaches 90 degrees to the
to the underlying tissues is dependent on the impres- occlusal plane. This enables it to effectively resist
sion procedures of the clinician. The section on support horizontal forces. The posterior lingual flange is usual-
demonstrates the significance of this relationship as it ly able to be extended inferiorly more than the anterior
pertains to the tissues that provide resistance to vertical lingual flange. Although the posterior fibers of the
forces directed toward the residual ridge. This relation- mylohyoid muscle attach more superiorly on the man-
ship also contributes to denture stability. dible, they descend nearly vertically to attach to the
Friedman’ describes the contacting of the labial and hyoid bone. Even when contracted, the muscle fibers
buccal flanges with the labial and buccal ridge slopes as extend medioinferiorly, allowing the posterior flange to
critical factors contributing to stability. Adequate extend to or beyond the mylohyoid ridge. Anteriorly,
extension of the denture border as limited by movable the mylohyoid muscle fibers are directed more horizon-
tally to communicate with fibers of the opposite side
along a midline tendinous raphe. When cu>ntracted,the
*Assistant Clinical Professor, Removable Prosthodontics. anterior mylohyoid muscle tenses the floor or the
**Chief of Dental Services, Removable Prosthodontics. mouth and limits the extension of the more anterior

THE JOURNAL OF PROSTHETIC DENTISTRY 165


JACOBSON AND KROL

i @ Post. Ant.
/
Fig. 1. Waxed anatomic model, A, and diagram, B, illustrate attachments and fiber
direction of mylohyoid muscle. C, Cross-sectional diagram of a mandibular denture
indicates relationship of lingual flange to underlying mylohyoid muscle. Posteriorly, as
a result of the more vertical fiber direction, flange may be extended more inferiorly than
anteriorly. Dotted lines represent an activated mylohyoid muscle.

lingual flange (Fig. 1). The extent of contact of the


lingual flange with the lingual ridge slope is thereby
dictated by the functional mobility of the floor of the
mouth.
In addition to determining the inferior extension of
the flange, the musculature of the floor of the mouth
may also influence the degree of intimate contact
allowed. Any flange extension below the mylohyoid
ridge must incline medially away from the mandible to
allow for the mylohyoid muscle contraction (Fig. 2).
The degree of positive contact of firm ridge to flange
may also be compromised by the presence of a thin
mucosa overlying the bony ridge slopes that does not
tolerate stresses effectively and, therefore, may require
relief.

RESIDUAL RIDGE ANATOMY


The development of stability is limited by the
Fig. 2. Lingual flange of mandibular denture must anatomic variations of the patient that determine the
incline medially to allow for contraction of mylohyoid
muscle, which lies beneath mucosa covering lingual residual ridge height and conformation. Large, square,
slope of residual ridge. Dotted lines represent an acti- broad ridges offer a greater resistance to lateral forces
vated mylohyoid muscle. than do small, narrow, tapered ridges (Fig. 3). Small,

166 FEBRUARY 1983 VOLUME 49 NUMBER 2


COMPLETE DENTURE STABILITY

Fig. 3. Tapered, round, and square ridges diagrammatically in cross section. Potential
for denture stability increases as a residual ridge becomes more square shaped.

Fig. 5. Inclination and external contour of lingual


flange may be designed to harmonize with muscular
action of tongue.
Fig. 4. Diagrammatic representation of maxillary and
mandibular complete dentures that have been
designed to enhance seating of prosthesis during RELATIONSHIP OF THE EXTERNAL
function shown in frontal cross section. SURFACE AND PERIPHERY TO
SURROUNDING OROFACIAL
rounded irregularities of the residual ridge also con- MUSCULATURE
tribute favorably to stability. Therefore, alveoplasty at Some important yet easily overlooked determinants
the same time as extractions should be limited only to of both denture stability and retention involve the
removal of bone that would prevent fabrication of a relationship of the polished surface of the denture base
successful prosthesis (for example, sharp spicules, to the surrounding musculature of the orofacial cap-
severe undercuts, and insufficient interarch distance). sule. Actions of the musculature on the denture base
Removal of all irregularities to create a smooth, even generally result in lateral and vertical dislodging
ridge would diminish potential stability. forces.
Another factor to be considered in stability is the Certain fact’ors involving the musculature and the
arch form. Square or tapered arches tend to resist polished surface of the denture can facilitate stability in
rotation of the prosthesis better than ovoid arches. two ways. First, the action of certain muscle groups
The shape of the palatal vault contributes to stability must be permitted to occur without interference by the
as limited by the length and angulation of the palatal denture base so that they will not dislodge the prosthe-
ridge slopes. A steep palatal vault may enhance stabil- sis during function or compromise stability. Second, the
ity by providing greater surface area of contact and dentist must recognize that normal functioning of some
long inclines approaching a right angle to the direction muscle groups can be used to enhance stability. Alter-
of force. ations in external denture base contours can lead to a

THE JOURNAL OF PROSTHETIC DENTISTRY 167


JACOBSON AND KROL

Fig. 6. A and B, Concave contours of external surfaces of maxillary and mandibular


denture flanges permit musculature of lips, tongue, and cheeks to effect a seating of
denture during function.

dynamic seating and stabilizing action directed toward (Fig. 4). The maxillary buccal flange should incline
the prosthesis. laterally and superiorly. The mandibular buccal flange
The denture border must be extended to contact the should incline laterally and inferiorly, and its lingual
movable tissues. Optimal extension also enhances sta- flange should incline medially and inferiorly. Such
bility and support. The actions of the levator anguli inclinations will provide a favorable vertical component
oris (caninus), incisivus, depressor anguli oris (triangu- to any horizontally directed forces.
laris), mentalis, mylohyoid, and genioglossus muscles To direct a seating action on the mandibular den-
can lead to dislodging forces if the denture base does not ture, the tongue should rest against a lingual flange
provide freedom for these muscles to function. Proper inclined medially away from the mandible and some-
border or muscle molding prior to the final impression what concave (Fig. 5). The degree of inclination
ensures optimal border extension. depends on the balance of the muscular forces of the
The external surface should be developed to harmo- tongue as opposed to the mylohyoid and superior
nize with the associated functioning musculature of the constrictor muscles.5 Some authors recommend posteri-
tongue, lips, and cheeks. Fish4 believed that the con- or extension of the lingual flange to fill the retromylo-
tours of the polished surface provided the principal hyoid space to permit the base of the tongue to
factor governing complete denture stability. In 1933 he contribute to the neuromuscular control of the prosthe-
wrote that “it is not so widely understood that the sis.“’ Inclination of the lingual flange must be designed
actual shape of the whole of the buccal, labial, and to guide the tongue to rest over the flange and permit
lingual surfaces can wreck the stability of a den- any horizontal forces generated against the denture
ture just as completely as a bad impression or wrong base to be transmitted as seating forces.
bite.” In order to appreciate this principle, it is Generally, the buccal and labial flanges of the
necessary to understand the anatomy and function maxillary and mandibular dentures should be concave
of the muscles that comprise the tongue, lips, and to permit positive seating by the cheeks and lips (Fig.
cheeks. 6). The primary muscles of the lips and cheeks are the
orbicularis oris and buccinator muscles, respectively.
INFLUENCE OF OROFACIAL These muscles are active during speech, mastication,
MUSCULATURE and deglutition. The proper contour of the denture
The basic geometric design of denture bases should flanges permits the horizontally directed forces that
be triangular. In a frontal cross section, the maxillary occur during contraction of these muscles to be
and mandibular dentures should appear as two trian- transmitted as vertical forces tending to seat the
gles whose apexes correspond to the occlusal surface prosthesis.

168 FEBRUARY 19.93 VOLUME 49 NUMBER 2


COMPLi?TE DENTURE STABILITY

IMPORTANCE OF THE MODIOLUS AND


ASSOCIATED MUSCULATURE
Fish4 describes the muscles of the musculi cruculi
modioli or modiolus and their actions in detail. The
modiolus or tendinous node is an anatomic landmark
near the corner of the mouth that is formed by the
intersection of several muscles of the cheeks and lips.
These include the orbicularis oris, buccinator, caninus,
triangularis, and zygomaticus muscles (Fig. 7).
Because none of these muscles contains fibers that
have more than one bony attachment, they depend on
fixation of the modiolus to allow isometric contraction.
By studying the diagram of these fan-shaped muscles,
one can understand the various interactions that are
possible. Contraction of the triangularis, caninus, and
zygomaticus muscles fixes the modiolus, allowing the Fig. 7. Intersection of muscles of facial expression
that comprise modiolus.
buccinator muscle to contract isometrically. This causes
the buccinator muscle to tense, allowing it to control the
food bolus on the occlusal table. Isotonic buccinator VARIETY OF TECHNIQUES
muscle contraction in the absence of modiolus fixation The idea of establishing harmony between the
would pull the corner of the mouth posteriorly. A polished surface of the denture and the associated
similar situation can be described for the orbicularis musculature has provided the basis for a number of
oris muscle and the remaining musculature of the techniques for complete denture construction. This
modiolus. It can be fixed more anteriorly as when the “neutral zone” (concepthas been described with various
word “hoe” is pronounced or posteriorly as with modifications by a number of authors.“‘-!’ The theory
“he.” used to develop the denture base contours is based on
The denture base must be contoured to permit the the belief that the muscles should functionally mold not
modiolus to function freely. In the premolar region the only the border but the entire polished surface. Even
mandibular denture should exhibit both a shortened the teeth are placed within the “neutral zone,” where
and narrowed flange to permit the action that draws facial and lingual forces generated by the musculature
the vestibule superiorly and the modiolus medially of the lips, tongue, and cheeks are balanced. This
against the dentures. This action is easily demonstrated functional rather than anatomic placement of the
by drawing the corners of the mouth inward. artificial teeth is believed to further enhance the
The buccinator muscle may be divided into superior, stability of the dentures by minimizing active forces.
middle, and inferior divisions. According to Fish,4 the The authors do not necessarily recommend such
superior fibers act to seat the maxillary denture, the techniques in all cases, but recognjtion of the
middle fibers control the bolus of food, and the inferior need for a harmonious relationship between den-
fibers contribute to mandibular denture stability. ture base and surrounding musculature is cer-
While the middle fibers contract, controlling the bolus, tainly important.
the inferior fibers relax to form a pouch capable of
storing food until needed to form another bolus. RELATIONSHIP OF OPPOSING
Extension of a concave denture base into this pouch OCCLUSAL SURFACES
allows the cheek to lie over the flange. Harmony developed between the opposing occlusal
A clinical study involving electromyographic analy- surfaces also contributes to stability. Regardless of the
sis of the function of the buccinator muscle by Lund- type of posterior tooth form or occlusal scheme used,
quist’ supports this basic theory by Fish. The study the dentures must be free of interferences within the
further showed that the nature of buccinator muscle functional range of movement of the patient” The
contraction was not able to adapt to changes in the functional range of movement refers to the positions
contours of the denture base. Because learning and through which the lower jaw moves horizontally dur-
adaptation appear to be limited, the denture contours ing normal speech, swallowing, and mastication. Dur-
should be designed to harmonize with existing buccina- ing both functional and parafunctional movements, the
tor muscle function. occlusal surfaces should not strike prematurely in

THE IOURNAL OF PROSTHETIC DENTISTRY 169


JACOBSON AND KROL

An anatomic fully balanced occlusion would, therefore,


not be indicated for a skeletal Class II mandibular
retrognathic patient displaying a functional range of
lateral and protrusive excursions of 4 to 6 mm or
greater.
Some authors recommend occlusal schemes that
direct forces to minimize the unseating of the denture
during unilateral excursive tooth contacts. According to
certain monoplane occlusal schemes, positioning O-
degree teeth slightly lingual to the mandibular ridge
crest may enhance denture stability. Zero-degree teeth
may reduce horizontal forces by eliminating the
inclined planes introduced by the cusp angles of
Fig. 8. Tendency to lingualize forces transmitted to anatomic teeth.
mandibular denture to minimize dislodging leverages The theories of lingualized occlusion provide both a
during working-side contact in absence of a fully
balanced occlusion. limited range of excursive balance and a directing of
forces to the lingual side of the lower ridge during
localized areas. Such contacts cause uneven stresses to working-side contacts (Fig. 8). Such concepts may
be transmitted to the dentures during function. This minimize horizontal stress and enhance denture stabil-
results in lateral and torquing forces that adversely ity by controlling the leverages induced by eccentric
affect stability. Bilateral, simultaneous, posterior tooth tooth contacts.‘4-‘6
contact in centric relation is essential. For many Other philosophies depend on the learned neuro-
patients the normal range of horizontal movement of muscular skills of the patient. Some patients are
the mandible is limited to centric relation. This is instructed to chew in such a manner that tooth contacts
particularly true for skeletal Class III or mandibular are limited to centric relation. Horizontal forces can be
prognathic patients. Excursive balance may not be minimized when the patient learns to place food
necessary in such situations. Patients who exhibit a bilaterally to ensure simultaneous posterior contact
wider functional range of movement, often seen in without a balanced occlusion.
skeletal Class II or mandibular retrognathic patients, Woelfel et al.” showed that most functional closures
require consideration of premature occlusal contacts, of the complete denture patients occurred in close
which may occur when the mandible does not close in proximity to centric relation. A study by Frechettels
centric relation. demonstrated even force distribution regardless of tooth
position in patients who chewed bilaterally. In another
THEORIES OF OCCLUSION study he further concluded that bilateral chewing
Various philosophies have been proposed either to contributed more to denture stability than balanced
provide for a fully balanced occlusion throughout occlusion.18 However, the learning of new neuromuscu-
lateral and protrusive excursive movements or to con- lar patterns is often limited, and not all complete
trol the direction of forces experienced during localized denture patients appear to be capable of masticating
occlusal contact. Setting of anatomic or semianatomic bilaterally in centric relation.
artificial teeth to provide excursive balance is thought The selection of anatomic, semianatomic, or nonana-
to minimize localized stress concentration and lateral tomic artificial teeth depends partially on the chosen
dislodging forces by ensuring multiple points of contact occlusal scheme. Still another factor to be considered in
to distribute functional occlusal forces. On closure selection of cusp form and occlusal scheme involves the
through a bolus of food, bilateral posterior tooth quality of the residual ridge in terms of height and
contacts within the range of balance ensure a seating of conformation. Unfavorable ridges exhibiting severe
the prosthesis. To minimize dislodging forces the resorption patterns may contribute to compromised
occlusion must be balanced throughout the functional stability due to a poor denture base-residual ridge
range of movement of the patient. A balanced occlusion relationship. Use of anatomic artificial teeth in such
is limited by the buccolingual and mesiodistal width of situations may not provide the advantages normally
the anatomic cuspal inclines. Patients who exhibit a expected. If balanced occlusion is desired throughout a
functional range of movement beyond the limits of limited functional range of movement for patients with
balance would benefit less from such an arrangement. deficient residual ridges, the use of nonanatomic O-

170 FEBRUARY 1983 VOLUME 49 NUMBER 2


COMPLETE DENTURE STABILITY

Fig. 9. A, Mounted casts depict a severe skeletal Class III edentulous patient. B, To
minimize anterosuperior shunting of maxillary denture during function, posterior
occlusion must be developed beyond anteroposterior midline of denture-supporting
area to include line drawn across land area of cast. C, Completed wax-up demonstrates
necessary occlusal contacts.

degree teeth set on a curve may provide the desired First, lateral tilting forces directed against the teeth are
occlusal contacts while eliminating the interlocking of magnified as the plane is raised. Second, the mandibu-
opposing anatomic teeth. lar denture need:sto be controlled by the musculature of
The subject of occlusion is filled with widely diver- the tongue, lips, and cheeks. An elevated occlusal plane
gent opinions. As concluded by the International prevents the tongue from reaching over the food table
Prosthodontic Workshop of 1972: “More long-term into the buccal vestibule. This compromises stability
statistical investigations are necessary to compare the and makes control of the food bolus and denture more
various occlusal designs so that more definable guide- difficult. A raised mandibular occlusal plane is usually
lines may evolve.“” Until then, dentists must rely on present when the vertical dimension of occlusion is
clinical experience in selection of posterior tooth form increased excessively. Various anatomic landmarks,
and appropriate occlusal schemes. such as Stensen’s duct and retromolar pad, should be
used to determine an acceptable level of the occlusal
TOOTH POSITION AND OCCLUSAL PLANE plane. Bisecting the interridge distance improves the
Other considerations relating to the occlusal surface mechanical advantage of the mandibular denture; but,
include the position of the teeth and the level of the if excessive mandibular ridge resorption has occurred,
occlusal plane. Anterior and posterior teeth should be the occlusal plane would be too low since less resorp-
arranged as close as possible to the position once tion usually occurs on the maxillae.
occupied by the natural teeth, with only slight modifi-
RIDGE RELATIONSHIPS
cations made to improve leverages and esthetics.
The superior-inferior position of the occlusal plane A problem of stability is the offset ridge relations
is also a factor to be recognized. A mandibular occlusal seen in prognathic and retrognathic patients. Normal
plane that is too high can result in reduced stability. dental relationships of the artificial teeth set on ridges

THE JOURNAL OF PROSTHETIC DENTISTRY 171


JACOBSON AND KROL

that are in severe posterior crossbite can adversely 4. Fish, W. E.: Using the muscles to stabilize the full lower
affect stability. In complete dentures the normal tooth- denture. J Am Dent Assoc Zlh2163, 1933.
5. Roberts, A. L.: Principles of full denture impression making
to-tooth position may have to be altered to provide a and their application in practice. J PROSTHET DENT 1:213,
relationship that can enhance the stability. Weinberg2’ 1951.
recognizes the need to set teeth in crossbite when the 6. Roberts, A. L.: Effects of outline and form upon dental
ridges are in a severe crossbite relation. stability. Dent Clin North Am, July 1960, pp 293-303.
7. Edwards, L. F., and Boucher, C. 0.: Anatomy of the mouth in
The Class III patient frequently displays a lower
relation to complete dentures. J Am Dent Assoc 29331,
arch anterior to the upper arch in centric relation. 1942.
Sufficient mandibular posterior occlusion must be 8. Shanahan, T. E. J.: Stabilizing lower dentures on unfavorable
developed so that contact against the maxillary denture ridges. J PROSTHET DENT 12~420, 1962.
extends posteriorly more than half the distance from 9. Lundquist, D. 0.: An electromyographic analysis of the
function of the buccinator muscle as an aid to denture retention
the incisive papilla to the hamular notch (Fig. 9).
and stabilization. J PROSTHET DENT 9:44, 1959.
Without this contact the maxillary denture would tip 10. Fry, K.: The retention of complete dentures. Br Dent J 4497,
anterosuperiorly, traumatizing the maxillary anterior 1923.
ridge and loosening the maxillary denture. 11. Schiesser, Jr., F. J.: The neutral zone and polished surfaces in
The severe retrognathic or prognathous ridge rela- complete dentures. J PROSTHET DENT 14:854, 1964.
tionship can be remedied only to a limited extent 12. Beresin, V. E., and Schiesser, F. J.: The Neutral Zone in
Complete and Partial Dentures, ed 2. St. Louis, 1978, The
through prosthetic treatment. While some compromises C. V. Mosby Co.
in the ideal tooth-to-ridge and tooth-to-tooth relation- 13. Lott, F., and Levin, B.: Flange technique: An anatomic and
ships may be made, the range of correction of such physiologic approach to increased retention, function, comfort,
skeletal cosmetic deficiencies without surgical interven- and appearance of dentures. J PROSTHET DENT 16~394,
tions is limited. 1966.
14. Payne, S. H.: A posterior setup to meet individual require-
CONCLUSION ments. Dent Digest 4220, 1941.
15. Pound, E.: Utilizing speech to simplify a personalized denture
Both complete denture stability and retention are service. J PROSTHET DENT 24:586, 1970.
essential in providing successful prosthetic treatment. 16. Becker, C. M., Swoope, C. C., and Guckes, A. D.: Lingualized
The factors that contribute to these properties are occlusion for removable prosthodontics. J PROSTHET DENT
38:601, 1977.
highly interrelated, and the constant interaction 17. Woelfel, J. B., Hickey, J. C., and Allison, M. L.: Effect of
between stability and retention often makes them posterior tooth form on jaw and denture movement. J PROS-
indistinguishable. The factor of stability involve the THET DENT 12~922, 1962.
tissue, occlusal, and polished surfaces of the denture. 18. Frechette, A. R.: Complete denture stability related to tooth
Care must be taken in the development of all three of position. J PROSTHET DENT 11:1032, 1961.
19. Lang, B. R., and Kelsey, C. C., editors: International Prostho-
these surfaces to ensure optimal stability of the final
dontic Workshop on Complete Denture Occlusion. Ann Arbor,
prosthesis. Mich., 1972, The University of Michigan, p 132.
20. Weinberg, L. A.: Tooth position in relation to the denture base
REFERENCES foundation. J PROSTHET DENT 8~398, 1958.

1. Friedman, S.: Edentulous impression procedures for maximum


retention and stability. J PR~~THET DENT 214, 1957. Reprint requeststo:
2. Boucher, C.: Complete denture impressions based on anatomy DR. THEODORE E. JACOBSON
of the mouth. J Am Dent Assoc 31:124, 1944. UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA
3. Boucher, C. 0.: A critical analysis of mid-century impression SCHOOL OF DENTISTRY
techniques for full dentures. J PROSTHET DENT 1:472, 1951. SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94143

172 FEBRUARY 1983 VOLUME 49 NUMBER 2

You might also like