You are on page 1of 6

Dissolution of Colemanite Process Waste in Oxalic

Acid Solutions
Salih U. Bayca,a Feray Kocan,b and Yuksel Abalib
a
Mining Division, Celal Bayar University, Soma Vocational School, Soma, 45500 Manisa, Turkey; salihbayca@gmail.com (for
correspondence)
b
Chemistry Department, Celal Bayar University, Science and Arts Faculty, 45030 Muradiye, Manisa, Turkey
Published online 12 November 2013 in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com). DOI 10.1002/ep.11889

The dissolution of colemanite waste in oxalic acid solu- Imamutdinova and Zdanovskii reported that when boron
tions was studied in a batch reactor, and the characteriza- minerals were dissolved in inorganic acid solutions, the reac-
tion of colemanite waste was determined by X-ray tion products formed a layer on the mineral surface, and this
diffraction analysis and X-ray Fluorescence analysis. The film resulted in a decreasing reaction rate [4, 5]. Recently, the
dissolution parameters in this study were acid concentration, dissolution kinetics of colemanite in acid solutions has been
stirring speed, and reaction temperature, and it was observed investigated. Alkan et al. studied the leaching kinetics of
that the dissolution rate increased with increasing reaction colemanite in water saturated with carbon dioxide and
temperature. The experimental data were examined by using observed that the leaching was controlled by a chemical
homogeneous and heterogeneous kinetic models, and the dis- reaction [6]. The dissolution of colemanite in aqueous acetic
solution kinetics of the waste was determined to be a pseudo- acid solutions was studied by Ozmetin et al. [7]. They
first-order homogeneous reaction control model. The activa- reported that the dissolution was controlled by a pseudo-
tion energy of colemanite waste in oxalic acid solution was first-order homogeneous reaction. Temur et al. investigated
calculated to be 27.80 kJ/mol. Thus, pure boric acid crystals the dissolution kinetics of colemanite in phosphoric acid sol-
can be produced using of colemanite waste, and this can utions and determined that the dissolution kinetics was con-
benefit the environment and the economy. V C 2013 American trolled by a surface chemical reaction [8]. Kucuk et al.
Institute of Chemical Engineers Environ Prog, 33: 1111–1116, reported that the dissolution of colemanite containing clay
2014 minerals in water saturated with sulfur dioxide was con-
Keywords: colemanite waste, dissolution, leaching, trolled by a chemical reaction model [9]. The dissolution of
kinetics, boric acid, boron oxide, reaction control model colemanite in oxalic acid solutions was investigated by Alkan
and Dogan [10]. They found that the reaction was controlled
INTRODUCTION by product layer diffusion. Cavus and Kuslu studied the dis-
Colemanite is a calcium borate mineral (theoretically, solution of colemanite in citric acid solutions and observed
50.8% B2O3) with a monoclinic crystal structure and a chemical that the reaction was controlled by diffusion through the
composition of Ca2B6O11.5H2O or 2CaO.3B2O3.5H2O. In Tur- product layer [11]. The dissolution of colemanite in
key, the boron minerals colemanite, ulexite, and tincal are pro- (NH4)2SO4 solutions was studied by Tunc et al. [12] who
duced commercially in large amounts, with colemanite ore reported that the dissolution reaction was controlled by a
(32% B2O3) produced in open mines in Bigadic, Balikesir semiempirical model. Gur et al. studied the dissolution of
province. The colemanite process is carried out in ore prepara- colemanite in sulfuric acid solutions at high solid/liquid
tion facilities near the ore mines of Bigadic. Colemanite is ratios and reported that the dissolution reaction was con-
enriched via processes such as crushing, wetting in water, trolled by product layer diffusion [13].
washing in a tumbler, sieving, triage, and classification, and it Boric acid is effective in reducing the flammability of cel-
is produced for sale as concentrated colemanite in different lulose insulation, in cotton batting used in mattresses, and in
grain sizes and chemical compositions. A major portion of the wood composites, and is thus used as a fire retardant in
concentrated colemanite produced here is exported [1]. The these products [14]. Commercially produced boric acid
boron oxide content of the two particle sizes of commercially (B(OH)3) is 56.25% B2O3, and 99.90% pure. Boric acid is
produced grounded colemanite is 40 6 0.5 % B2O3 with parti- produced with three different levels of sulfate content. These
cle size of 245 lm and 275 lm [2]. are high sulfate with a maximum of 500 ppm SO4, low sul-
Four fraction particle sizes are produced in the plant. The fate with a maximum of 130 ppm, and ultra-low sulfate, with
products of the concentrator plant are very coarse particle a maximum of 12 ppm [2].
size of 25–125 mm with 42 6 1% B2O3, coarse particle size The aim of this study was to investigate the dissolution
of 3–25 mm with 35 6 2% B2O3, medium particle size of 1–3 kinetics of colemanite waste. This study investigated the dis-
mm with 28 6 2% B2O3, and fine particle size of – 1 mm. solution of colemanite waste in oxalic acid solutions. Several
The fine particles, which include 17 6 5% B2O3, are pumped experimental parameters were determined for the dissolution
into three waste dams [3]. reaction kinetics. The effects of impurities on the reaction
rate were studied. To determine the kinetics and kinetic
model of the dissolution of colemanite waste in oxalic acid
C 2013 American Institute of Chemical Engineers
V solution, conformity to heterogeneous and homogeneous

Environmental Progress & Sustainable Energy (Vol.33, No.4) DOI 10.1002/ep December 2014 1111
Figure 1. X-ray diffraction analysis of colemanite waste. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at
wileyonlinelibrary.com.]

Table 1. Chemical analysis of colemanite waste

Oxides Percent
CaO 29.98
B 2 O3 22.07
SiO2 14.12
MgO 4.87
Al2O3 0.36
Fe2O3 0.43
Na2O 0.02
SrO 0.90
LOI 27.25

mathematical modeling was analyzed by regression analysis.


The activation energy of the dissolution was calculated, and
the parameters, which most affected the speed of dissolution,
were found. This study offers an alternative solution to the
evaluation of the processing of mineral colemanite waste
stored in pools. No study was found in the literature relating
to the dissolution kinetics of colemanite waste. Furthermore,
this study is important in terms of environmental impact Figure 2. The leaching experiment test set-up.
assessment.

MATERIALS AND METHODS


The colemanite ore was processed at Eti Mine Bigadic a 500-mL three-neck glass reactor at atmospheric pressure. A
Boron Concentrator Plant. The sample (fine fraction) was mechanical stirrer with a digital display was used to agitate
taken from the tailing dam. Laboratory tests were performed the solution. A programmable refrigerated bath/circulator
on the sample at DEFAM (Experimental Natural Science was used to keep the reaction medium at a constant temper-
Research Center of Celal Bayar University). Chemical analysis ature. A spiral condenser was used to avoid solution loss by
showed that the sample contained 22.07% B2O3. The chemi- evaporation. The temperature of the solution in the reactor
cal analysis results from X-ray fluorescence (XRF) of the cole- was measured with a portable digital temperature controller
manite process waste (other than B2O3) are given in Table 1. with a probe and was found to range between 0 and 150 6
X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis of the waste was carried out 0.1 C. Waste was weighed to 0.1 mg using an analytical bal-
on a Rigaku DMAX 2200 Series with Cu Ka radiation. As ance. A digital chronometer was used to measure the reten-
seen in Figure 1, the waste was mainly composed of cole- tion time. The oxalic acid, D-mannitol, sodium hydroxide,
manite with small amounts of calcite, dolomite, and quartz methyl red, and phenolphthalein reagents were of analytical
minerals. grade.
The test setup was designed to leach the waste and is During the dissolution process, 100 mL of oxalic acid
shown in Figure 2. The dissolution tests were carried out in solution was placed in the reactor and stirred. After the

1112 December 2014 Environmental Progress & Sustainable Energy (Vol.33, No.4) DOI 10.1002/ep
Table 2. Test variables

Parameters Values
Reaction temperature ( C) 25 40 50 60 70
Acid concentration (g/L) 40 80 100
Stirring speed (rpm) 200 500 700
Reaction time (min) 5 10 20 30 60 120

Figure 3. Effect of oxalic acid concentration on leaching of


colemanite waste (solid to liquid ratio of 10 g/L, stirring
speed of 200 rpm, at 40 C). [Color figure can be viewed in
the online issue, which is available at wileyonline Figure 5. Effect of reaction temperature on leaching of cole-
library.com.] manite waste (acid concentration of 40 g/L, solid to liquid
ratio of 10 g/L, stirring speed of 200 rpm). [Color figure can
be viewed in the online issue, which is available at
wileyonlinelibrary.com.]

a volumetric method [15] and the experimental parameters


used in the dissolution processes are given in Table 2. Disso-
lution kinetics calculation method was given by Abali et al.
[16].

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Effects of Oxalic Acid Concentration on the Extraction


of the Waste
The experiments were performed in an acid concentration
range of 40–100 g/L acid with a solid/liquid ratio of 10 g/L
and stirring speed of 200 rpm at 40 C, and the results are
given in Figure 3. A great increase in the dissolution rate was
observed with an increase in the acid concentration.
Although the dissolution efficiency rose rapidly in the first 20
min of the experiment, this increase slowed between 30 and
Figure 4. Effect of stirring speed on leaching of colemanite 120 min.
waste (acid concentration of 40 g/L, solid to liquid ratio of
10 g/L, at 40 C). [Color figure can be viewed in the online Effects of Stirring Speed on the Extraction of the Waste
issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.] To determine the effect of stirring speed on the coleman-
ite acid dissolution process, dissolution experiments were
performed with a stirring speed of 200, 500, and 700 rpm at
a temperature of 40 C, a period of 5–120 min, 40 g/L acid
concentration, and a 10 g/L solid-liquid ratio. Results are
desired reaction temperature was reached, a certain amount given in Figure 4. At 30 min and 200 rpm, a dissolution effi-
of dried waste was added to the solution. After a certain ciency of 18.6% was obtained. At 30 min and 500 rpm, this
period of time, the stirring was stopped. The hot solution was 15.3% and at 30 min and 700 rpm it was 15.5%. Maxi-
was filtered through filter paper without any change in tem- mum dissolution efficiency was obtained at a stirring rate of
perature. The dissolution experiments were repeated at least 200 rpm. An increase in the stirring rate caused a decrease in
twice. The amount of B2O3 in the filtrate was determined by the dissolution efficiency.

Environmental Progress & Sustainable Energy (Vol.33, No.4) DOI 10.1002/ep December 2014 1113
Figure 7. The variation in 2ln(1 – X) with time at different
stirring speed. [Color figure can be viewed in the online
Figure 6. The variation in 2ln(1 – X) with time at different issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
acid concentration. [Color figure can be viewed in the online
issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.]

dissolution rates of waste at different temperatures are given


in Figure 6. These results were analyzed using the equations
Table 3. Variation of dissolution rate with temperatures. of heterogeneous and homogeneous reaction-control mod-
els. The values of these models were plotted against time to
Temperatures (K) k R2 determine their slopes, and the k and regression coefficient
298 0.0149 0.9919 (R2) values of these models for each temperature were calcu-
313 0.0387 0.9884 lated using the slopes of the lines. The leaching kinetics of
323 0.0403 0.9916 waste in oxalic acid solutions did not fit heterogeneous
333 0.0626 0.9964 kinetic models because they did not produce linear relation-
343 0.0662 0.9916 ships. Moreover, the pseudo-second-order homogeneous
reaction-control model did not produce a linear relationship.
However, a high regression coefficient was obtained for the
Effects of the Reaction Temperature on the Extraction pseudo-first-order homogeneous reaction-control model. The
of the Waste kinetics of a pseudo-first-order-reaction-control model is
given by the following equation [17]:
To determine the effect of temperature on the acid disso-
lution of colemanite, dissolution experiments were per-
formed at temperatures of 25, 40, 50, 60, and 70 C, a 2ln ð12XÞ 5 kt (3)
dissolution period of 5–120 min, a stirring speed of 200 rpm,
a solid-liquid ratio of 10 g/L, and an acid concentration of 40 The first order reaction control models can be fitted due
g/L. Results are given in Figure 5. At 20 min and 25, 40, 50, to linear regression. The regression coefficients and k values
60, and 70 C, dissolution efficiencies were 10.34, 16.67, are given in Table 3 for the first order reaction control
19.58, 19.58, and 18.62%, respectively. For a dissolution time model. The results show that the k values increased with the
of 20 min, dissolution efficiency rose rapidly between tem- dissolution temperature.
peratures of 25 and 50 C. For a dissolution time of 20 min, When the dissolution temperature was increased from 25
the increase in dissolution efficiency rate slowed between 60 to 70 C, the k values increased nearly 4 times. A plot of the
and 70 C. With increasing temperature, the solubility of cole- pseudo-first-order homogeneous reaction-control model, –
manite in oxalic acid solution increased. In this way, the dis- ln(1–X), versus time results in a linear relationship at differ-
solution rate of boron oxide at high temperature reached ent acid concentrations as shown in Figure 6, at different stir-
99.98%. ring speeds as shown in Figure 7, and at different
temperatures as shown in Figure 8.
Okur et al. found that the leaching kinetics of colemanite
Kinetic Analysis of Dissolution in sulfuric acid solutions followed a modified Avrami-type A
The rate of reaction between a solid and a liquid can be model [18]. Sinirkaya et al. obtained a similar result for tincal
described by heterogeneous or homogeneous-control mod- waste in CO2-saturated water [19].
els. Fluid-solid heterogeneous reaction systems have impor-
tant applications in chemical and metallurgical processes. A Activation Energies
successful reactor design for this process depends mainly on To calculate the activation energy for the dissolution reac-
kinetic data. Reactions occurring between fluid and spherical tion, an Arrhenius graph was drawn using the data in Figure
solid particles can be expressed as follows [17]: 5. A graph of lnk versus 1/T was drawn using the graph of
the effect of temperature in the acid dissolution of coleman-
Aðf Þ 1 bBðsÞ ! products
ite waste, and Figure 9 was obtained. Table 3 shows the vari-
Pseudo-first-order reaction-control models were used as ation in speed of dissolution of colemanite waste in oxalic
the homogeneous models in this study. The results of the acid solution.

1114 December 2014 Environmental Progress & Sustainable Energy (Vol.33, No.4) DOI 10.1002/ep
reaction controlled by surface chemical reactions is above 40
kJ/mol [20]. The activation energy of colemanite in acidic sol-
utions was reported in the literature to be between 28 and
89 kJ/mol. The activation energy for colemanite dissolution
was studied in phosphoric acid solutions [8]. It was found
that the activation energy of this process was 53.91 kJ/mol.
Kucuk et al. found that the activation energy was 39.53 kJ/
mol for colemanite containing clay minerals in water satu-
rated with sulfur dioxide [9]. Cavus and Kuslu reported that
the activation energy was 28.65 kJ/mol for colemanite in cit-
ric acid solutions [11]. The activation energy was found to be
30 kJ/mol in sulfuric acid solutions [18]. Kum et al. calculated
the activation energy for a solution of calcined colemanite as
89 kJ/mol. Karagolge et al. calculated the activation energy
as 50.6 kJ/mol [21, 22].
In this study, the activation energy of the dissolution of
colemanite waste in oxalic acid solutions was found to be
27.80 kJ/mol. However, the activation energy of the dissolu-
Figure 8. The variation in 2ln(1 – X) with time at different tion of pure colemanite in oxalic acid solutions was found to
temperature. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, be 39.77 kJ/mol [10]. The activation energy of colemanite
which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.] waste was lower than the activation energy of pure coleman-
ite. A similar result was also reported by Kucuk et al. [9].

Dissolution Products
The dissolution process of colemanite waste in oxalic acid
solution takes place via the following set of reactions. The
dissolution of oxalic acid is obtained in an aqueous medium
as follows:

C2 H2 O4 :2H2 OðaqÞ ! 2C2 H2 O4ðaqÞ 1 2H2 O (1)

C2 H2 O4ðaqÞ 1 2H2 OðlÞ ! 2C2 O22 1


4 ðaqÞ 1 2H3 O ðaqÞ (2)

The overall reaction is as follows:

2CaO:3B2 O3 :5H2 OðsÞ 1 4H3 O1


ðaqÞ ! 6BðOH Þ3ðaqÞ 1 2Ca
21

1 2H2 OðlÞ
(3)

2CaO:3B2 O3 :5H2 OðsÞ 1 2ðC2 H2 O4 :2H2 OÞðaqÞ ! 6BðOH Þ3ðaqÞ


Figure 9. Arrhenius plot for the leaching of colemanite 1 2CaC2 O4ðsÞ 1 2H2 OðlÞ
waste. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which
is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.] (4)

The reaction between colemanite and oxalic acid results


in boric acid solution and calcium oxalate solids. Colemanite
The reaction-control model of colemanite process waste waste dissolved in a hot oxalic acid solution and a pregnant
in oxalic acid solution was determined to follow a pseudo- leach solution was formed. Liquid and solid phase were
first-order homogeneous reaction-control model. The activa- obtained with filtering the pregnant leach solution. As the
tion energy of the dissolution was calculated from the Arrhe- liquid phase cooled, white boric acid crystals were
nius Eq. 4 as follows. precipitated.
The output of colemanite mineral processing at a cole-
k 5 ko exp ð2E=RT Þ (4) manite mine is colemanite concentrate and colemanite waste.
Colemanite waste is stored in ponds as a suspension. This
Ln(k) versus 1/T gives a straight line of slope 2E/R. From waste is not sold, and constantly requires more storage
the slope of this line, the ko values and the activation energy, space, causing great problems for the environment. In this
E, of the dissolution rate of waste in oxalic acid were deter- study, colemanite waste was turned into a new product,
mined as follows: boric acid, by dissolution in oxalic acid. The sale price of
boric acid is much higher than that of colemanite concen-
2ln ð12XÞ 5 ko exp ð3343:7=T Þ t trate, and in addition, this study will provide great benefits
to the environment by the reduction in stored wastes.
E 5 27:80 kJ =mol
CONCLUSIONS
Activation energy of 27.80 kJ/mol was calculated from the The mineral content of colemanite waste was calculated
slope of the Arrhenius graph of the dissolution of colemanite to be 43% colemanite, while impurities constituted the
waste in oxalic acid solution. remaining 57% of the waste. When the dissolution kinetics of
Alkan and Dogan found the activation energy of the dis- colemanite waste in oxalic acid solutions was studied in a
solution of colemanite in oxalic acid solution to be 39.77 kJ/ batch reactor, the dissolution results showed that the dissolu-
mol [10]. It has been found that the activation energy of the tion rate increased with increasing reaction temperature. The

Environmental Progress & Sustainable Energy (Vol.33, No.4) DOI 10.1002/ep December 2014 1115
most important parameters in the dissolution rate were found 8. Temur, H., Yartasi, A., Copur, M., & Kocakerim, M. M.
to be the reaction temperature and reaction time, while the (2000). The Kinetics of Dissolution of Colemanite in
least important were the acid concentration and stirring H3PO4 Solutions, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry
speed. The maximum boron oxide recovery obtained during Research, 39, 4114–4119.
dissolution was 99.3% for colemanite waste after 60 min at 9. Kucuk, O., Kocakerim, M. M., Yartasi, A., & Copur, M.
70 C. The reaction-control model of colemanite process (2002). Dissolution of Kestelek’s colemanite containing
waste in oxalic acid solution was determined to follow a clay minerals in water saturated with sulfur dioxide,
pseudo-first-order homogeneous reaction-control model. Dis- Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, 41, 2853–
solution at high temperature was found to be faster than dis- 2857.
solution at low temperature. The activation energy of 10. Alkan, M. & Dogan, M. (2004). Dissolution kinetics of
colemanite waste in oxalic acid solution was calculated to be colemanite in oxalic acid solutions, Chemical Engineering
27.80 kJ/mol. The activation energy of colemanite waste was and Processing, 43, 867–872.
lower than the activation energy of activation energy of pure 11. Cavus, F. & Kuslu, S., (2005). Dissolution Kinetics of
colemanite. Pure boric acid crystals were obtained by the Colemanite in Citric Acid Solutions Assisted by Mechani-
reaction of colemanite waste in oxalic acid. Thus, pure boric cal Agitation and Microwaves, Industrial & Engineering
acid crystals can be produced using colemanite waste. This Chemistry Research, 44, 8164–8170.
can contribute to the environment and the economy. 12. Tunc, M. Kocakerim, M. M., K€ uç€
uk, O., & Aluz, M.
(2007). Dissolution of colemanite in (NH4)2SO4 solutions,
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Korean J. Chem. Eng., 24, 55-59.
The author would like to thank Eti Mine Works General 13. Gur, A., Ceylan, H., Selçuk, A., & Yildiz, A. (2007). Disso-
Management Turkiye for the XRD, XRF and particle size lution kinetics of colemanite in sulphuric acid solution
analysis. for high solid to liqud rations, Oriental Journal of Chem-
istry, 23, 801–808.
NOMENCLATURE
14. Lyday, P.A. (2005). Boron, U.S. Geological Survey Miner-
k Reaction rate constant (min21)
als Yearbook, Bureau of Mines, Washington: Mineral
X Dissolution rate or fractional conversion
Commodity Summaries, United States Department of the
t Reaction time (min)
Interior.
T Temperature (K)
15. Koklu, M., Ozyetis, O., Maraslioglu, D., Yavuklu, E.,
E Activation energy (kJ/mol)
Celen, B., Tufan, T., & Gunduz, M. (2003). Developments
R Universal gas constant (j/mol K)
in analyzes of calcium borate (in Turkish), 18 Interna-
ko Frequency or pre-exponential factor (min21)
tional Mining Congress and Exhibition of Turkey (pp.
141–146), 10–13 June, Antalya.
LITERATURE CITED 16. Abali Y., Bayca S.U., & Mistincik, E. (2006). Kinetics of
1. Bayca & Salih Ugur. (2009). Effects of the addition of oxalic acid leaching of tincal, Chemical Engineering Jour-
ulexite to the sintering behavior of a ceramic body, Jour- nal, 123, 25–30.
nal of Ceramic Processing Research, 10, 162–166. 17. Levenspiel, O. (1999). Chemical Reaction Engineering (3
2. Etimaden. (2013). Available at: http://www.etimaden. Edition), New York: Wiley.
gov.tr 18. Okur, H., Tekin, T., Ozer, A. K., & Bayramoglu, M.
3. Bayca, S. U. Extraction of boric acid from colemanite pro- (2002). Effect of ultrasound on the dissolution of cole-
cess waste by attrition scrubbing and leaching, (manu- manite in H2SO4, Hydrometallurgy, 67, 79–86.
script in preparation) 19. Sinirkaya, M., Kocakerim, M. M., Boncukcuoglu, R.,
4. Imamutdinova, V.M. (1967). Kinetics of dissolution of Kucuk, O., & Oncel, S. (2005). Recovery of Boron from
borates in mineral acid solutions, Zhurnal Prikladnoi Khi- Tincal Wastes, Industrial & Engineering Chemistry
mii, 40, 2593-2596. Research, 44, 427–433.
5. Zdanovskii, A.B. (1981). Kinetics of borate dissolution in 20. Jackson, E. (1986). Hydrometallurgical extraction and rec-
acids, Issled Sint. Boratov, 97, 132-140. lamation (pp. 400), Chichester: Ellis Horwood Ltd.
6. Alkan, M. Kocakerim M. M., & Colak, S. (1985). Kinetics 21. Kum, C., Alkan, M., & Kocakerim, M.M. (1994). Dissolu-
of colemanite in water saturated by carbon dioxide, tion Kinetics of Calcined Colemanite in Ammonium Chlo-
Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, 35, ride Solution, Hydrometallurgy (Netherlands), 36, 259–
382-386. 268.
7. Ozmetin, C., Kocakerim, M. M., Yapici, S., & Yartasi, A. 22. Karagolge, Z., Alkan, M., & Kocakerim, M.M. (1992).
(1996). A semiempirical kinetic model for dissolution of Leaching kinetics of colemanite by aqueous EDTA solu-
colemanite in aqueous acetic acid solutions, Industrial & tions, Metallurgical and Materials Transactions B, 23, 409–
Engineering Chemistry Research, 35, 2355–2359. 413.

1116 December 2014 Environmental Progress & Sustainable Energy (Vol.33, No.4) DOI 10.1002/ep

You might also like