Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: This paper describes the synthesis of sulfobelite clinkers incorporating mining rejects. The targeted Zn-
Received 13 October 2016 Pb tailing wastes generated in the diapiric zone (NW Tunisia) were tested in clinker/cement composi-
Received in revised form tions to ensure the inertization of existing hazardous heavy metals. Mineralogical composition of the two
8 September 2017
selected samples revealed calcite, dolomite, quartz, kaolinite, galena, pyrite and gypsum as crystalline
Accepted 8 November 2017
phases. Vertical distributions of dominant heavy metals (Pb, Zn and Cu) in soil profiles show enrichment
Available online 9 November 2017
in the surface layers and decrease towards the depth. In sintered clinkers powders, the presence of the
targeted crystalline phases (trialuminate sulphate (C4A3S), belite (C2S), and ferrite (C4AF)) are in the
Keywords:
Mining rejects
predicted desirable amounts.
Diapiric zone Heat flow generated during the hydration of different cement pastes showed a slower reaction for
Clinker clinkers with higher amounts of C4A3S or constituted by coarser particles. After 28 days curing, the best
Heavy metal mechanical resistance (24.34 MPa under compression) was obtained for the clinker calcined at 1350 C
Immobilisation and showing a suitable particle size distribution. Concerning heavy metals, immobilisation of 75e85% of
Pb, Zn and Cu was assessed in the mortars formulated with the produced clinker/cement, posing no
hazardous risks to the environment.
© 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction clinkers present low CO2 rate and sintering temperature (saving
energy) in comparison to commercial OPC products (Telesca et al.,
Concrete based on Ordinary Portland Cements (OPC) is the most 2016; Quillin, 2001; Senff et al., 2011). Therefore, up to 35% CO2
widely used material in buildings throughout the world. Indeed, its emission reduction (depending on the composition) can be
workability, mechanical behaviour and durability have contributed attained (Aranda et al., 2011).
to its extensive use (Li, 2011; Desmettre and Charron, 2013; Tang Moreover, in the quest of low cost raw materials, some the
et al., 2015). However, its synthesis demands large amount of en- recent investigation had been focused on the recycling of different
ergy and produces a lot of CO2, while consuming considerable wastes in the cement industry like Industrial By-Products (Telesca
amounts of non-renewable raw materials. OPC production is et al., 2016); red mud (Senff et al., 2011), rubber (Idrissi, 2012);
responsible for 6% of anthropogenic CO2 emissions which arose phosphogypsum (Huang et al., 2016), fly ash (Ma et al., 2013), are
from calcite decarbonation and fuel combustion (Aranda et al., some examples.
2011; Damtoft et al., 2008; Telesca et al., 2016; Reddy et al., 2014; This paper is aligned with that purpose, since describes the
Ke et al., 2012). synthesis of sulfobelite clinkers incorporating mining rejects.
Over the years, more interest in developing alternative clinkers Moreover, tested clinker and cements are being targeted also for
and cements have been reported, aiming to decrease CO2 emissions inertization or immobilisation of heavy metals containing wastes.
and using low-cost materials (Berger, 2009). Sulfobelite-based Currently, on the NW Tunisia (Siliana governorate), large
quantities of mine discharges containing high levels of Pb, Zn, Cd
occupy large dumping areas without any special precaution for
* Corresponding author. their harmful effects on humans and the environment (Boussen
E-mail address: w.hajjaji@ua.pt (W. Hajjaji).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jafrearsci.2017.11.004
1464-343X/© 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
166 J. Nouairi et al. / Journal of African Earth Sciences 139 (2018) 165e172
Fig. 2. Powder diffraction pattern of representative samples from the old tailings of
Lakhouat (T1) and Fej Lahdoum (T2): C ¼ Calcite, D ¼ Dolomite, Q ¼ Quartz,
Gy ¼ Gypsum, K ¼ Kaolinite, G ¼ Galena, Py ¼ Pyrite.
Sphalerite
Quartz
Galena
Calcite
Galena
Fig. 3. SEM micrographs of T1 (A) and T2 (D) samples. EDS mapping of dominant heavy metals are shown also shown: B and C for T1; E and F for T2.
from 1992 to 2008 (ONM, 2010) and the Lakhouat mine (T1) (in the
Table 2 Siliana district, located just 120 km south of Tunis), where the
Chemical composition of T1 and T2 (wt.%). mining of the lead and zinc lasted almost a century since its dis-
T1 T2 covery in 1892 until the exhaustion of the ore reserves in 1992
(Fig. 1). The Fej Lahdoum abandoned mining site is located in the
SiO2 15.5 23.4
Al2O3 6.56 10.1
upstream part of the Medjerda River (the biggest supplier of fresh
CaO 19.9 27.6 water in Tunisia). This region is characterized by a semi-arid
P2O5 0.05 0.09 climate (see Fig. 2).
SO3 21.9 9.12
K2O 0.33 0.55
MgO 3.99 5.12 2.2. Characterization tests
TiO2 0.2 0.35
Fe2O3 5.91 4.1
Pb 1.54 0.46 The studied mining tailings, and products were analysed using
Zn 4.27 2.31 XRD by Rigaku Geiger flex diffractometer with a Cu Ka radiation
Sr 2.37 1.17 source in 10e800 2Ө, the scan rate of 0.02, 4s per step. The GSAS-
Ba 2.43 0.86 EXPGUI software was used for the phases' quantification of the
LOI 15.1 14.7
various phases following a Reference Intensity Ratio (RIR) and the
168 J. Nouairi et al. / Journal of African Earth Sciences 139 (2018) 165e172
Fig. 4. Studied soils P1 (N36 160 30.7300 E 09 140 48.2000 ) and P2 (N36 220 55.2400 E 09 060 26.7000 ) and metals distribution.
CT1A CT2A
CT1B CT2B
matrix has been developed. Nevertheless, the existence of C2S and enrichment at the surface and a decrease in depth of Pb, Zn, Cu and
hexagonal C4A3S is still evident. Cr with values exceeding the normal\allowed heavy metal
According to Fig. 9, the first peak is attributed to the dehydration concentrations.
of gypsum (CSH 2) into anhydrite (CS) and is similar for all the tested In clinker calcined at 1400 C and 1350 C, the targeted crys-
materials. This study shows that once mixed with water, ions such talline phases (C4A3S, C2S and C4AF were formed with relative
þ
Ca2þ, SO2-4 , Na … are released as a result of a strong chemical re- amounts close to predicted compositions with a5 wt.% deviation.
action (Chenchen et al., 2016; Reddy et al., 2014). The heat flow When tested as cements, the workability and the compressive
generated upon hydration of different cement pastes showed a strength of …. showed different behaviour related to particle size
rapid reaction after initial mixing (3 h for CT1B, 4 h for CT2B, 5 h for and content of the C4A3S phase. The mortars cured for 1, 14, 21 and
CT2A and 6 for CT1A). A better workability is observed in cements 28 days displayed good mechanical properties with strength values
based in clinkers calcined at 1450 C (CT1A and CT2A). This reaching ~25 Mpa.
behaviour could be related to the higher amount in C4A3S and Finally, the concentrations of metal contaminants in the final
coarser clinker particles (Fig. 7). products were very low. Therefore they present no environmental
As illustrated in Fig. 10, differences in the compressive strength danger or threat to human health, especially that they are incor-
results were also observed. After 28 days curing, CT1B samples with porated into the cement matrix, and thus there is not risk of
clinker calcined at lower temperature 1350 C showed maximal leaching or transportation. Moreover, concentrations of leached
mechanical strength (24.34 MPa). In fact, cements made from sul- contaminants decreased in clinkers and mortars by 75e85%. This
fobelitic clinkers show higher mechanical strengths at early ages shows that this application can help in the immobilisation of Zn, Pb
(Cai and Zhao, 2016). In this case, this could be due to the good and Cu from similar mine tailings.
particle size distribution in the sample CT1B (Fig. 7). In the case of
CT2 based cements, clinker with a higher amount of C4A3S gave
better compression resistance due to higher reactivity of this
compound. However, the compressive strength of CT2A with
clinker calcined at 1400 C decreases after 14 days due to the excess
of sulphur oxide.
Quillin (2001) reported that the hardening rate of sulfoalumi-
nate cements is intermediate between those of Portland and
aluminate cements, however being much faster than a Portland
cement. During the early hydration stages, the formation of
ettringite is responsible for hardening of sulfobelitic cement, while
strength gain in OPC is due to CeSeH formation. At later ages, the
strength development of sulfobelitic cements depends primarily on
CeSeH gel formation (Ma et al., 2013).
However, the variation in mechanical behaviour (Mechanical
strength CT1A < CT2A and CT2A > CT2B) observed between sam-
ples calcined at 1400 C (A) and 1350 C (B) should be the result of
the difference in the initial raw tailing compositions.
In order to track the leaching of heavy metals from the pro-
cessed cements and mortars, acid attack (with aqua regia) was
performed. For comparison, levels extracted from the tailings are
also given in Fig. 11. The dilution effect affecting the final leaching
data was neutralized by normalising the used T wastes amount in
all tested cements/mortars. Concentrations of leached contami-
nants decreased considerably in clinkers and mortars. Indeed, 75%
of Pb was immobilised in the mortars CT2B. Also, the concentra-
tions of Zn and Cu in CT2A sample decreases by approximately 85%
and 80%, respectively. The leached heavy metals values are in
accordance to Council Decision of 19 December 2002 establishing
criteria and procedures for the acceptance of waste at landfills
pursuant to Article 16 and Annex II to Directive 1999/31/EC (2003/
33/EC). Several recent investigations are focused on retention of
inorganic pollutants in soils through immobilisation in the cement
matrix at different pH range (Moon et al., 2013). Ettringite is sug-
gested to be a good candidate for fixing various divalent cations
such as Cu 2þ, Pb2þ and Zn2þ in substitution of existing Ca2þ(Moon
et al., 2013).
4. Conclusions