You are on page 1of 5

ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE

Volume 00, Number 00, 2019


ª Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.
DOI: 10.1089/env.2018.0019

Toxic Bios: Toxic Autobiographies—A Public


Environmental Humanities Project

Marco Armiero, Thanos Andritsos, Stefania Barca, Rita Brás, Sergio Ruiz Cauyela, Cxağdas x Dedeoğlu,
Marica Di Pierri, Lúcia de Oliveira Fernandes, Filippo Gravagno, Laura Greco, Lucie Greyl,
Ilenia Iengo, Julia Lindblom, Felipe Milanez, Sérgio Pedro, Giusy Pappalardo, Antonello Petrillo,
Maurizio Portaluri, Elisa Privitera, Aysxe Ceren Sarı, and Giorgos Velegrakis

ABSTRACT
Downloaded by 186.214.178.112 from www.liebertpub.com at 01/20/19. For personal use only.

In this article, we present Toxic Bios, a public environmental humanities (EH) project that aims to
coproduce, gather, and make visible stories of contamination and resistance. To explain the rationale of
the project and its potentialities, first we offer a brief reflection on the field of the EH and its (possible)
contribution to environmental justice research, then, we illustrate the guerrilla narrative strategy experi-
mented through the project.

Keywords: environmental humanities, toxic autobiographies, guerrilla narrative, narrative justice

ENVIRONMENTAL HUMANITIES
Marco Armiero is the Director of the Environmental Huma-
nities Laboratory at the Royal Institute of Technology, Stock- AND ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE
holm, Sweden, and Senior Researcher at the Istituto di Studi
sulle società del Mediterraneo, CNR, Napoli, Italy.
Thanos Andritsos is a PhD researcher in Economic Geo-
graphy and Regional Development at the Harokopio University
I n the past decade, we have seen the emergence of
a new field of studies: the environmental humanities
(EH). This field includes all the humanities disciplines that
and a member of Commonspace cooperative.
Stefania Barca is a senior researcher at the Center for Social engage with the environment, as, for instance, ecocriti-
Studies–University of Coimbra, Portugal. cism,1 environmental history, environmental philosophy,
Rita Bras coordinates the project ‘‘Pólen,’’ an audiovisual arts, film studies, and others. For Castree et al., the EH
channel about environmental conflicts in Portugal. ‘‘illuminate peoples’ complex and divergent understand-
Cxağdasx Dedeoğlu is a research associate at The Center for
Critical Research on Religion, Newton, MA. ings of life—human and nonhuman—on Earth,’’ including
Marica Di Pierri is a PhD student at the University of Pa- in the analysis ‘‘things as love, trust, fear, commitment,
lermo, Italy, and the president of the Documentation Center on devotion, and loyalty.’’2 Although some scholars may
Environmental Conflicts, Italy.
Lúcia Fernandesisa postdoctoral researcher at the Center for
Social StudiesUniversity of Coimbra, Portugal. Sergio Ruiz Cayuela is a PhD student at the University of
Filippo Gravagno is an associate professor of Urban and Coventry, UK, within the ITN Marie Sklodowska-Curie RE-
Regional Planning at the University of Catania, Italy. COMS Resourceful and Resilient Communities.
Laura Greco works for the Italian NGO A Sud. Aysxe Ceren Sari is a researcher at the C
xEKÜL Foundation for
Lucie Greyl works for the Italian NGO A Sud. the Protection and Promotion of the Environment and Cultural
Ilenia Iengo is a PhD student at the Humboldt University, Heritage. Turkey.
Germany, within the ITN Marie Sklodowska-Curie WEGO Giorgos Velegrakis is an affiliated researcher at the National
Feminist Political Ecology. and Kapodistrian University of Athens and a member of the
Julia Lindblom is a freelance journalist. Commonspace cooperative.
1
Felipe Milanez is a lecturer of Humanities at Federal Uni- The most widely quoted definition of ecocriticism is that of
versity of Bahia, Brazil. Cheryll Glotfelty. ‘‘Simply put, ecocriticism is the study of the
Giusy Pappalardo is a postdoctoral researcher at University of relationship between literature and the physical environment.’’
Catania, Italy. In: Cheryll Glotfelty and Harold Fromm (eds). The Ecocriticism
Sérgio Pedro is a jurist and activist of the FIAN (international Reader. (The University of Georgia Press, 1996), xviii.
2
NGO for the Right to Adequate Food) Portuguese branch. Noel Castree, William M. Adams, John Barry, Daniel
Antonello Petrillo is an associate professor of Sociology at the Brockington, Bram Büscher, Esteve Corbera, David Demeritt,
University Suor Orsola Benincasa, Italy. Rosaleen Duffy, Ulrike Felt, Katja Neves, Peter Newell, Luigi
Maurizio Portaluri is a medical doctor at the General Hospital Pellizzoni, Kate Rigby, Paul Robbins, Libby Robin, Deborah
Perrino in Brindisi, Italy. Bird Rose, Andrew Ross, David Schlosberg, Sverker Sörlin,
Elisa Privitera is a PhD student at the University of Catania, Paige West, Mark Whitehead, and Brian Wynne. ‘‘Changing the
Italy. Intellectual Climate,’’ Nature Climate Change 4 (2004): 765.

1
2 ARMIERO ET AL.

of narrative (in)justice as key to EJ research, arguing that


contaminated communities have also been exposed to a form
of narrative violence consisting in the silencing and/or in-
visibilization of their stories. The price these communities
have paid for progress and economic growth has been erased
from collective memory. The EH are well suited to uncover
this narrative injustice and, consequently, to counteract it by
FIG. 1. Logo of the Toxic Bios project (from ‘‘telling the right story,’’ that is, unearthing or coproducing
www.toxicbios.eu) more just narratives by exposing injustice while exploring
envision the EH as a new discipline, we align ourselves paths and visions that have often been ignored.8
with those who prefer to think of it as a multidisciplinary Sabotaging toxic narratives
field, wherein scholars from various disciplines converge,
often with a strong commitment toward the environmental Directly connected to the concept of narrative (in)justice
challenges of the present. In an introductory volume to the is that of toxic narrative. According to the collective of
field, Iovino and Oppermann have written that ‘‘[this new Italian radical writers Wu Ming, mainstream narratives are
field] brings the social sciences, the humanities, and the often toxic in the sense that they ‘‘contaminate’’ public
natural sciences together in diverse ways to address the discourses by imposing official truths while dismissing any
current ecological crises from closely knit ethical, cultural, alternative point of view.9 We assume that toxic narratives
philosophical, political, social, and biological perspectives.’’3 are another name for what Latinx critical race theorists
Downloaded by 186.214.178.112 from www.liebertpub.com at 01/20/19. For personal use only.

Among the newly created EH centers, the Environ- have called majoritarian stories10 and we argue that, from
mental Humanities Laboratory (EHL), based at KTH an EJ point of view, those stories hinder the possibility to
Royal Institute of Technology in Stockholm, is well known even see the injustice. A toxic narrative blames the exposed
for its societal engagement, its commitment to socio- communities for their lifestyle or naturalizes a capitalist-
environmental justice, and its undisciplined approach. made disaster as a tragic accident. Working with narratives
Following Bergthaller et al., the EHL envisions environ- and meaning-making through the methodologies and the-
mental justice (EJ) as one of the crosscutting themes ories of the (critical) humanities, the EH have the tools to
around which the plurality of EH disciplinary approaches disarticulate and sabotage those toxic narratives.
can find a common ground: ‘‘As a concept, environmental Imagining alternatives
justice certainly identifies overlapping territory where so-
cial, cultural and environmental challenges must be con- Science fiction writer Ursula Le Guin has often argued that
fronted all at once.’’4 According to Rob Nixon, one of the capitalism and its apparently inescapable power need new
most influential EH scholars, the engagement with EJ has imaginaries.11 Political ecologists have echoed Le Guin’s ar-
contributed to expunge ‘‘some earlier more naı̈ve and gument, lamenting that nowadays ‘‘it is easier to imagine the
more provincial versions of environmental humanities’’ end of the world than the end of capitalism.’’12 This is an in-
while keeping it open to a nonacademic audience.5 tellectual defeat rather than a political one. EH can challenge
In this article, we explore further Rob Nixon’s insights hegemonic concepts such as growth, modernization, and com-
on the connections between EJ and EH, proposing four petition while excavating the variety of ideas and experiences
main areas of intervention. produced on the ground. As examples, we might list here re-
search in degrowth and feminist political economy, dismantling
Looking for narrative justice the imaginary of economic growth vis-à-vis uncovering alter-
native visions and social practices, or research on the com-
Coming from different disciplinary fields, both Donna
mons and commoning practices as alternatives to capitalism.13
Houston6 and Stefania Barca7 have proposed the concept
8
Barca. ‘‘Telling the Right Story.’’
3 9
Serenella Iovino and Serpil Oppermann. ‘‘Introduction.’’ In: Wu Ming. How to Tell a Revolution from Everything Else.
Serpil Oppermann and Serenella Iovino (eds). Environmental (UNC Global Education Center, 2011). <www.wumingfoundation
Humanities: Voices from the Anthropocene. (Rowmann & Lit- .com/WM2_UNC_talk_on_revolution.pdf> (Last accessed Au-
tlefield, 2016), 1. gust 31, 2016).
4 10
Hannes Bergthaller, Rob Emmett, Adeline Johns-Putra, Agnes Daniel G. Solórzano and Tara J. Yosso. ‘‘Critical Race
Kneitz, Susanna Lidström, Shane McCorristine, Isabel Pérez Ramos, Methodology: Counter-Storytelling as an Analytical Framework
Dana Phillips, Kate Rigby, Libby Robin. ‘‘Mapping Common for Education Research,’’ Qualitative Inquiry 8 (2002): 23–44.
11
Ground: Ecocriticism, Environmental History, and the Environ- Here we are referring to her speech at the National Book
mental Humanities,’’ Environmental Humanities 5 (2014): 271. Awards in November 2014. <www.sfcenter.ku.edu/LeGuin-
5
Miyase Christensen. ‘‘Slow Violence in the Anthropocene: An NBA-Medalist-Speech.htm>.
12
Interview with Rob Nixon on Communication, Media, and the According to Mark Fisher, this line can be attributed to both
Environmental Humanities,’’ Environmental Communication 12 Fredric Jameson and Slavoj Žižek. In: Marcı̀k Fisher (ed). Capi-
(2018): 7–11. talist Realism: Is There No Alternative? (Zero Books, 2009), 2.
6 13
Donna Houston. ‘‘Environmental Justice Storytelling: An- See, for instance: Giacomo D’Alisa, Federico Demaria, and
gels and Isotopes at Yucca Mountain, Nevada,’’ Antipode 45 Giorgos Kallis. Degrowth: A Vocabulary for a New Era.
(2013): 417–435. (Routledge, 2015); J.K. Gibson-Graham. The End of Capitalism
7
Stefania Barca. ‘‘Telling the Right Story: Environmental (As We Knew It). (Blackwell Publishers, 1996); Silvia Federici.
Violence and Liberation Narratives,’’ Environment and History Revolution at Point Zero. (PM Press, 2012); and Massimo De
20 (2014): 535–546. Angelis. Omnia Sunt Communia. (Zed Books, 2017).
A PUBLIC ENVIRONMENTAL HUMANITIES PROJECT 3
Downloaded by 186.214.178.112 from www.liebertpub.com at 01/20/19. For personal use only.

FIG. 2. Toxic Bios interface for the online search (from www.toxicbios.eu)

Making communities out of stories the patterns of authorship and production of knowledge,
Storytelling is not only a methodology to collect he edited a book collection in which 10 women wrote
stories of contamination. It has always been a founda- their stories of activism and contamination.15 It was from
tional tool in community building. Bonds are created by that experience that we started thinking of an open
sharing stories. Storytelling creates a narrative agora platform to expand the collection of toxic stories. Our
where nonmainstream forms of evidence and under- familiarity with the EJ Atlas (https://ejatlas.org) and the
standing are transformed into collective knowledge. With work of Joan Martinez-Alier’s team16 was also crucial in
their focus on first person or collective narratives and the future development of the Toxic Bios platform.
storying, the EH can help to understand the making of While for Martinez-Alier the EJ Atlas offers the empir-
a resisting community. Indeed, we do not think of ical data for a statistical approach to EJ, the Toxic Bios
such communities as ‘‘natural’’ entities, produced by the platform can provide the materials for a narrative ap-
simple fact of living in the same neighborhood, but rather proach to it.
as being produced through struggles and stories. In this Despite an extremely limited budget, the project has
sense, we envision the EH as both an investigative and created to date ( June 2018) nine Toxic Bios Hubs,
performative practice, which both excavate and copro- mostly formed by hybrid groups of scholars and activists.
duce these foundational stories. The hubs are distributed in seven countries (Brazil,
Greece, Italy, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, and Turkey), but
new hubs can continuously join the project. The aim of
TOXIC BIOS AND GUERRILLA NARRATIVE the project is to coproduce and/or uncover stories of
contamination and resistance. All these stories, almost 70
Toxic Bios was born as a spin-off of a writing project by June 2018, will be available on the Toxic Bios plat-
developed by Marco Armiero while researching the form (www.toxicbios.eu), on a geo-referenced map
waste struggles in Naples, Italy.14 Aiming to challenge through which they can be searched by places, themes, or
names. An abstract in English accompanies each story.
14 We have called the approach used in this project
The so-called Campania waste emergency comprises both
the mismanagement of urban waste by the local government and
guerrilla narrative (GN), meaning the sabotage of toxic
the illegal dumping of toxic waste by the mafia. It is impossible narratives, which silence injustice, through the coproduction
to mention all the publications produced on the waste emer-
gency. For an EH perspective on the waste crisis, see Serenella
15
Iovino. Ecocriticism and Italy. (Bloomsbury, 2016), 13–43. A Marco Armiero. Teresa e le altre. ( Jaca Book, 2014).
16
well-informed and concise excursus on the Campania waste The EJ Atlas is an open access database of environmental
emergency is available in Wikipedia. conflicts.
4 ARMIERO ET AL.

of a counter-hegemonic storytelling.17 Methodologically, Transcorporeality in action


GN is a close relative to oral history, with which it shares Toxic Bios is deeply influenced by what feminist
the ambition to recenter historical narratives around the scholar Stacy Alaimo has defined ‘‘trans-corporeality.’’
voices of those who have been ignored or silenced. According to Alaimo, ‘‘Trans- corporeality means that all
Compared with oral history, GN has a more explicit creatures, as embodied beings, are intermeshed with the
political agenda, it includes a larger variety of formats dynamic, material world, which crosses through them,
(video, audio, autobiography, interview, songs, pictures, transforms them, and is transformed by them.’’22 Con-
writings, etc.), and has a more explicit collective char- firming the transcorporeality paradigm, the Toxic Bios
acter in the sense that it presupposes the sharing of stories are often more-than-human stories. Antonio
stories as an empowering strategy. In GN, the storyteller Costa, from Portugal, offers a clear example of this more-
is telling her story not only to a researcher who will use than-human narrative when in his story he connects the
it as a source, but also to the public at large. A GN dead fish in the river, the factory in the background, and
approach has been recently employed in epidemiological the health problems of the people living there. Some-
research in Manfredonia, Italy, where it has allowed as- times the transcorporeality has a more positive charac-
sessing the long-term effects of an industrial disaster ter, envisioning a more-than-human community. Angela
occurred in 1976 by crisscrossing the collective mem- Rosa, a Portuguese farmer fighting against genetically
ory and public perception of toxicity with the available modified organisms, pesticides, and oil extraction, speaks
public health data.18 of her intimate connection with the land, the trees, and
Together with oral history, (eco)feminist theories and the (agri)cultural landscape.
Downloaded by 186.214.178.112 from www.liebertpub.com at 01/20/19. For personal use only.

practices have also been extremely influential for the


development of the Toxic Bios project. While method- Ways of knowing and regimes of legitimation
ologically rooted in Sandra Harding’s strong objectiv-
ity,19 Toxic Bios has evidently built upon a rich feminist A toxic story is intrinsically a story about the con-
scholarship, which has recentered research and theories struction and legitimation of knowledge. It tells a
around the materiality of the body and the environment.20 personal or collective truth that is almost always ques-
We have followed here what Iovino and Oppermann tionable. As Iengo and Armiero have argued, the body is
have argued about material ecocriticism: ‘‘Bodies, both a battleground where different narratives clash.23 Rosa
human and nonhuman, provide an eloquent example of Maria, a member of the Portuguese grassroots association
the way matter can be read as a text. Being the ‘middle ADACE, explains the difficulties to prove that a com-
place’ where matter enmeshes in the discursive forces munity has been contaminated, no matter how much the
of politics, society, technology, biology, bodies are environmental and public health problems may seem
compounds of flesh, elemental properties, and symbolic evident to local inhabitants. She talks about the impor-
imaginaries.’’21 tance of smell, taste, and traditional knowledge of wind
patterns as tools in the hands of citizens.24 However, this
CROSSCUTTING THEMES kind of knowledge, she believes, is not considered strong
IN THE TOXIC BIOS REPOSITORY enough to claim expertise in the face of corporate and
governmental power. Father Yannis, a priest of a small
Through coding and constant comparison, we have parish on the Asopos River in Greece, was accused to be
identified several themes traversing most, if not all, of the antiscience as he claimed to be able to perceive the in-
stories collected in the Toxic Bios project. dustrial contamination of the river through his senses,
that is, only by tasting or smelling the water. Similarly,
Giorgios, from the ‘‘SOS HALKIDIKI’’ antigold ex-
17
Ilenia Iengo and Marco Armiero. ‘‘The Politicization of Ill traction movement, argues that one can perceive the as-
Bodies in Campania, Italy,’’ Journal of Political Ecology 24 bestos contamination merely by looking at the stratum of
(2017): 44–58.
18
Bruna De Marchi, Annibale Biggeri, Marco Cervino, Cris- dust covering the olive trees in the area.
tina Mangia, Giulia Malavasi, Emilio Antonio Luca Gianicolo,
and Maria Angela Vigotti. ‘‘Case Study—A Participatory Pro- Politicization
ject in Environmental Epidemiology: Lessons from the Manfre-
donia Case Study (Italy 2015–2016),’’ Public Health Panorama 3 Many storytellers talk about their previous political
(2017): 321–327.
19
experiences. Some reveal that they have a history of
‘‘‘Strong Objectivity’: A Response to the New Objectivity social or political engagement, others insist that the
Question,’’ Synthese 104 (1995): 331–349. For a discussion of
how this approach can be applied to EJ research, see Barbara
22
Allen. Uneasy Alchemy: Citizens and Experts in Louisiana’s Stacy Alaimo. ‘‘Trans-Corporeality.’’ In: Rosi Braidotti and
Chemical Corridor Disputes. (MIT, 2003); and Stefania Barca. Maria Hlavajova (eds). Posthuman Glossary. (Bloomsbury,
‘‘Bread and Poison. The Story of Labor Environmentalism in 2018), 435.
23
Italy.’’ In: Christopher C. Sellers and Joseph Melling (eds). Iengo and Armiero. ‘‘The Politicization of Ill Bodies.’’
24
Dangerous Trade: Histories of Industrial Hazard Across a Marco Armiero and Salvatore Paolo De Rosa. ‘‘Political
Globalizing World. (Temple UP, 2012), 126–139. Effluvia. Smells, Revelations, and the Politicization of Daily
20
See, for example, Stacy Alaimo and Susan J. Heckman Experience in Naples, Italy.’’ In: Jocelyn Thorpe, Stephanie
(eds). Material Feminism. (Indiana University Press, 2008). Rutherford, and L. Anders Sandberg (eds). Methodological
21
Serenella Iovino and Serpil Oppermann. Material Ecocri- Challenges in Nature-Culture and Environmental History Re-
ticism. (Indiana University Press, 2014), 6. search. (Routledge, 2016), 173–186.
A PUBLIC ENVIRONMENTAL HUMANITIES PROJECT 5

mobilization against contamination is their first experi- erasing its collective memories.27 Thereby, taking control
ence. The recurrence of this theme does not solve the of our stories is per se an act of rebellion. The power
definition of what is the political. As Armiero and D’Alisa of storytelling, of narrating injustice, is so strong that
have shown, Teresa, a Neapolitan activist fighting against state and corporate powers try to silence it, producing
the Campania waste emergency, did not consider her ex- toxic narratives or delegitimizing/killing those who can
perience with the Sem Terra Movement in Brazil as a tell different stories. After all, many of the environmental
political activity, for she went there through her local activists who have been killed in the past few years were
parish.25 The memory passed onto generations is another not ‘‘experts’’ in control of some unquestionable data, but
terrain of politicization, as in the story of the Vajont dam storytellers mobilizing their own experience in speaking
disaster in Northeast Italy.26 To this day, in the Vajont truth to power and to the public.28
valleys some kinds of mourning and memories are socially It is difficult to assess the policy impact of Toxic Bios
acceptable while others are silenced. Carolina is still and much work must still be done to imagine and ex-
among those who fight to politicize the suffering and periment all the possible paths that project may open.
transform it into collective actions, despite all the attempts The cases collected in this project show that scientific
to defuse the rage and narcotize the mourning. investigations and legal battles have often been generated
through the practice of producing and sharing counter-
Making kin through toxic lives narratives of contamination, as in the cases of Kirklareli
in the Thrace Region and of the Land of Fires in Italy.29
Toxic Bios opens a path of exploration in one of the
As another example of the policy outcomes of the pro-
Downloaded by 186.214.178.112 from www.liebertpub.com at 01/20/19. For personal use only.

most vexed issues in the study of EJ struggles: the


ject, we can mention that one researcher and one story-
community. Often, scholars working on EJ conflicts have
teller from Toxic Bios have been recently invited to the
been criticized for a certain romanticization of ‘‘the local
European Parliament to contribute to the elaboration of
community.’’ However, even more problematic is the
an EJ platform.
idea that the community is a pre-existing ontological,
Stories are powerful instruments: they can be used to
almost natural, fact. Instead, Toxic Bios reveals that a
change the world or to accept it as it is. Perhaps radical
resisting community is created in the very experience of
social change implies taking control of not only the
contamination; one might say that this bond is a collat-
means of production but also of those of narration.
eral and unwanted effect of the blend of toxins and
stories. The coral biography of Vincenzo, narrated by an
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
ensemble of activists from the Campania region (Italy), is
the self-evident representation of how the embodied ex-
The Toxic Bios project was funded by The Seed Box:
perience of toxicity creates new kin.
a Mistra–Formas Environmental Humanities Collaboratory.
Lucia Fernandes’ research is supported by Fundação para a
CONCLUSION
Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT, Portugal): grant SFRH/BPD/
79933/2011 (POCH funds from ESF and MCTES).
In this article, we have presented an ongoing EH
project that aims to foster EJ through enhancing narrative
AUTHOR DISCLOSURE STATEMENT
justice, contrasting toxic narratives, and uncovering un-
heard stories. We have placed this project within the
No competing financial interests exist.
larger field of the EH, suggesting a series of areas in
which it can contribute to the EJ field. More broadly, we
suggest that the Toxic Bios platform not only provides Address correspondence to:
empirical materials for scholars working on EJ but it also Marco Armiero
offers the GN practice as a tool to EJ scholars interested Department of Philosophy and History
in EH-oriented coresearch. The aim is to prove that EH Environmental Humanities Laboratory
scholars can contribute to EJ research and struggles. Royal Institute of Technology
Lois Gibbs, the leader of the Love Canal mobilization, Teknikringen 74D, Level 5
once said that one’s own story is the most precious Stockholm 100 44
weapon when fighting against environmental injustice. Sweden
Similarly, Naomi Klein has argued that the ‘‘shock
doctrine’’ can only be imposed on a community by E-mail: armiero@kth.se

25
Marco Armiero and Giacomo D’Alisa. ‘‘Rights of Re-
27
sistance: The Garbage Struggles for Environmental Justice in Naomi Klein. The Shock Doctrine. (Alfred A. Knopf, 2007).
28
Campania, Italy,’’ Capitalism, Nature, Socialism 23 (2012): The Global Witness’ reports on the assassination of envi-
52–68. ronmentalists have been crucial to raise awareness on this
26
In 1963 a massive landslide ruined in the Vajont reservoir, phenomenon <www.globalwitness.org/en>. Another important
causing a tsunami wave that killed 2000 people. For an EJ in- resource is also here <http://environmentalhistory.org/people/
terpretation of this story, see Marco Armiero. A Rugged Nation. environmental-murder>.
29
Mountains and the Making of Modern Italy. (White Horse Press, The Land of Fires is an area comprised between the cities of
2011), 173–194. Naples and Caserta heavily affected by toxic contamination.

You might also like