Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Due to the development of the automotive fuel cell systems, the study on water-injection twin screw
Received 19 June 2008 compressor has been aroused again. Twin screw compressors with water injection can be used to supply
Accepted 27 May 2009 the clean compressed air for the Proton Exchange Membrane (PEM) fuel cell systems. In this research, a
Available online 23 June 2009
thermodynamic model of the working process of water-injection twin screw compressor was established
based on the equations of conservation of mass and energy. The effects of internal leakage and air–water
Keywords: heat transfer were taken into account simultaneously in the present mathematical model. The experi-
Twin screw compressor
ments of the performance of a prototype compressor operating under various conditions were conducted
Water injection
Performance
to verify the model. The results show that the predictions of the model are in reasonable agreement with
the experimental data.
Crown Copyright Ó 2009 Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1359-4311/$ - see front matter Crown Copyright Ó 2009 Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2009.05.018
3402 J. Li et al. / Applied Thermal Engineering 29 (2009) 3401–3408
Nomenclature
cell applications and considered that the compressor efficiency 2.2. Governing equations of control volume
was a crucial element for the fuel cell overall performance [12].
Moreover, this research team spent many years to be involved in On the basis of the conservation equations of energy and mass
research on the screw compressor and expander technology continuity, the simultaneous differential equations describing the
[13–16]. The twin screw compressor is an ideal machine for the internal energy and mass of air in the control volume in terms of
pressured air system in the PEM fuel cell systems in automobiles. the rotation angle of the male rotor can be written as [17,18]:
Because of oil contamination, the oil-injection twin screw com-
dðUÞ X dmi X dmo dW dQ
pressor may be unsuitable for PEM fuel cell systems while the ¼ hi ho þ ð1Þ
dh dh dh dh dh
water-injection twin screw compressor has no contamination. So
dW dV
it is necessary to study the performance of twin screw compressor ¼ p ð2Þ
with water injected used in PEM fuel cell systems thoroughly.
dh dh
Because of the water injected into the twin screw compressor where W and Q are work and heat, respectively, and the heat should
which is the cooling and sealing medium, the air leakage in the be included the heat transfer between the air and the water or the
compressor decreases and a lower discharge temperature is compressor body.
achieved. This reduces power consumption of the compressor The air mass change in the control volume is given by:
and improves the efficiency of the PEM fuel cell systems. In our re- dm ¼ dmi dmo ð3Þ
search, a water-injection twin screw compressor that used in the
PEM fuel cell systems has been developed. Moreover, a mathemat- Eqs. (1)–(3) are the governing equations of the mathematical model
ical model of working process in a water-injection twin screw which can be used to calculate pressure, temperature and other
compressor considering internal leakage and heat transfer has thermodynamic properties.
been established. In addition, the performance of a prototype twin
screw compressor has been tested by the experiment.
2.3. Leakage
where A is the area of the leakage paths, p1 is the pressure of air in Q 4 ¼ naV 2=3 ðT T b Þ ð10Þ
the high pressure chamber and p2 is pressure of air in the low pres-
sure chamber, a is the hollow bubble ratio, C is the flow coefficient where n is the correction factor, a is the coefficient of heat transfer,
considered to be a single constant, x is the ratio between the total V2/3 denotes the area of heat transfer, V is the volume of the working
mass of air and the total mass of air–water mixture in the working chamber, T is the temperature of the working fluid, and Tb is the
chamber. temperature of the compressor body.
Thus the Q in Eq. (1) can be found from the following equation:
2.4. Heat transfer Q ¼ Q3 þ Q4 ð11Þ
P T
2
m
3 4 5
1
1. Twin screw compressor
P T
2. Air filter
9 3. Power and speed meter
P
T 8 4. Motor
7 5. Frequency-converter
6. Water-air separator
6 7. Air tank
8 m Flow meter 8. Controlling valve
9. Measurement system for air
W Power and speed meter flow rate
11
10 P Pressure sensor 10. Water tank
12 11. Water cooler
T Temperature sensor
12. Water filter
Table 2
Operating conditions of the compressor.
pressor, and thus the heat exchange between the water and the air
is weakened and the pressure will increase slightly. Moreover, the
volumetric efficiency will be greater due to the rise of the rotation
speed (see Fig. 5), leading to the increase of the pressure in the
compression process.
Fig. 3. The diagrams of compressor with variable water flow rates.
4.2. Effects on the efficiencies
process of the compressor will approach the isothermal working The comparison of the theoretical and experimental volumetric
process further with the increase of the water flow rate, as shown efficiencies of the twin screw compressor at different rotation
in Fig. 3. It also can be seen from the figure that the air pressure in speed and the water flow rate of 120 L/h is shown in Fig. 5. It
the adiabatic compression process is the highest because there is can be observed that the volumetric efficiency of the twin screw
no heat exchange during the process, and air pressure in the iso- compressor increases with the rotation speed, but the increment
thermal compression process is the lowest owing to the existence rate falls down. The change trend of volumetric efficiency obtained
of full heat exchange (the air temperature is constant). from the theoretical calculation is in reasonable agreement with
Fig. 4 shows the p–V indicator diagrams of the compressor at the data measured. Fig. 6 shows that the volumetric efficiency will
different rotation speed and a volumetric water flow rate of increase with the increase of rotation speed and water flow rate.
120 L/h. As seen from Fig. 4, the p–V indicator diagrams of working The calculated results of isothermal indicated efficiencies of the
process with water will deviate from the isothermal working pro- compressor are shown in Figs. 7 and 8. As seen from the two fig-
cess and be close to the adiabatic working process, with the in- ures, the isothermal indicated efficiencies of the compressor at
crease of the rotation speed. It is likely that the water injected the same rotation speed will increase with the increase of the
into each working chamber decreases owing to the rise of the rota- water flow rate. It can be explained by the fact that the increase
tion speed and the fixed total mass of water injected into the com- of the water flow rate leads to more significant heat exchange be-
3406 J. Li et al. / Applied Thermal Engineering 29 (2009) 3401–3408
Fig. 6. The volumetric efficiency changes with water flow rate and speed.
tween the water and the air (also see Fig. 3). However, as the rota-
tion speed increases, the isothermal indicated efficiency with the
same water flow rate increases first and then decreases gradually. Fig. 9. The power consumption of the compressor.
J. Li et al. / Applied Thermal Engineering 29 (2009) 3401–3408 3407
Table 3 5. Conclusions
Additional power for water injection.
Rotation speed (rpm) 2000 3000 5000 A twin screw air compressor with water injection used for PEM
Indicated power for air (W) 7835 12,028 20,578 fuel cell systems has been developed. A mathematical model sim-
Additional power for water and vapor (W) 213.2 267.8 453.7
ulating the working process of the water injection compressor has
Ratio of additional power to indicated power (%) 2.71 2.22 2.2
been established based on the conservation equations of energy
and mass continuity. The internal leakage through five paths,
air–water heat exchange and heat transfer between the working
4.4. Effects on the discharge temperature fluid and compressor body have been considered in the model.
The performance of the prototype compressor calculated by the
The change of the measured discharge temperature of the com- model shows a reasonable agreement with that measured by the
pressor with the water flow rate and rotation speed is shown in experiment.
Fig. 10. The discharge temperature decreases with the increase of The results of p–V indicator diagrams calculated by the model
the water flow rate at the same rotation speed and increases with show that the water injection can facilitate the compression pro-
the rise of the rotation speed at the same water flow rate. At the cess close to the isothermal compression process. As the water
same rotation speed, the heat exchange between the air and the flow rate increases, the isothermal indicated efficiency and volu-
water improves as the water flow rate rises, leading to the decrease metric efficiency will improve and the discharge temperature will
of temperature. At the same water flow rate, the water used to cool decrease. With the increase of the rotation speed, the volumetric
the air in the control volume decreases when the rotation speed is efficiency and discharge temperature will be greater, and the iso-
up, which results in the increase of the discharge temperature. thermal indicated efficiency will increase first and then decrease.
Fig. 11 shows the comparison of the discharge temperature ob- The power consumption of the compressor has an approximate lin-
tained by the model and experiment, respectively, at 3000 rpm. ear relationship with the rotation speed. The additional power con-
It can be seen that the maximum deviation of the discharge tem- sumption for water injection exists but it is only a small portion in
perature by the theoretical calculation and experimental measure- the power consumption of the compressor.
ment is about 3.8 K.
Acknowledgement
References
[1] S.E. Wright, Comparison of the theoretical performance potential of fuel cells
and heat engines, Renewable Energy 29 (2004) 179–195.
[2] Pasquale Corbo, Fortunato Migliardini, Ottorino Veneri, Experimental analysis
and management issues of a hydrogen fuel cell system for stationary and
mobile application, Energy Conversion and Management 48 (8) (2007) 2365–
2374.
[3] Mihai Radulescu, Olivier Lottin, Michel Feidt, Christophe Lombard, David Le
Noc, Stephane Le Doze, Experimental results with a natural gas cogeneration
system using a polymer exchange membrane fuel cell, Journal of Power
Sources 159 (2) (2006) 1142–1146.
[4] Rajesh K. Ahluwalia, Xiaohua Wang, Fuel cell systems for transportation:
status and trends, Journal of Power Sources 177 (1) (2008) 67–176.
[5] R. Cownden, M. Nahon, M.A. Rosen, Modelling and analysis of a solid polymer
fuel cell system for transportation applications, International Journal of
Hydrogen Energy 26 (6) (2001) 615–623.
Fig. 10. The discharge temperature of the compressor.
[6] Cheng Bao, Minggao Ouyang, Baolian Yi, Modeling and optimization of the air
system in polymer exchange membrane fuel cell systems, Journal of Power
Sources 156 (2) (2006) 232–243.
[7] W.K. Galen, A comparison of two air compressors for PEM fuel cell systems,
Master Degree Thesis of Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University,
USA, 2001.
[8] M.K. Gee, Cost and performance enhancements for a PEM fuel cell system
turbo-compressor, FY 2005 Annual Progress Report, DOE Hydrogen Program,
2005, pp. 985–988.
[9] Yuanyang Zhao, Liansheng Li, Huagen Wu, Pengcheng Shu, Theoretical and
experimental studies of water injection scroll compressor in automotive fuel
cell systems, Energy Conversion and Management 46 (9–10) (2005) 1379–
1392.
[10] K. Kauder, J. Temming, Steady operating behaviour of a screw type
supercharger–expander module for an automotive fuel cell system.
Scharubenmaschinen 2002, VDI Berichte 1715, Dortmund, September 2002.
[11] G. Hinsenkamp, M. Romba, Requirement for air management system in
automotive fuel cells, Scharubenmaschinen 2002, VDI Berichte 1715,
Dortmund, September 2002.
[12] Nikola Stosic, Ian K. Smith, Ahmed Kovacevic, Combined compressor–
expander in fuel cell application, in: 17th International Congress of
Mechanical Engineers, Sao Paulo, 2003.
[13] Ahmed Kovacevic, Nikola Stosic, Ian K. Smith, Numerical simulation of
combined screw compressor–expander machines for use in high pressure
refrigeration systems, Simulation Modelling Practice and Theory 14 (8) (2006)
1143–1154.
[14] Nikola Stosic, Ian K. Smith, Ahmed Kovacevic. A twin screw combined
Fig. 11. Comparison of the discharge temperature. compressor and expander for CO2 refrigeration systems, in: Sixteenth
3408 J. Li et al. / Applied Thermal Engineering 29 (2009) 3401–3408
International Compressor Engineering Conference at Purdue, July 2002, pp. Mechanical Engineers, Part E, Journal of Process Mechanical Engineers 209 (E2)
C21–C22. (1995) 125–136.
[15] N. Stosic, I.K. Smith, A. Kovacevic, Optimisation of screw compressors, Applied [20] J.S. Fleming, Y. Tang, G. Cook, The twin helical screw compressor Part 1:
Thermal Engineering 23 (10) (2003) 1177–1195. development, applications and competitive position, in: Proceeding of the
[16] N. Stosic, Lj. Milutinovic, K. Hanjalic, A. Kovacevic, Investigation of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part C, 212, Journal of Mechanical
influence of oil injection upon the screw compressor working process, Engineering Science 212 (5) (1998) 369–380.
International Journal of Refrigeration 15 (4) (1992) 206–219. [21] M. Fujiwara, Y. Osada, Performance analysis of an oil-injected screw compressor
[17] Z. Xing, Screw Compressor—Theory, Design and Application, China Machine and its application, International Journal of Refrigeration 18 (4) (1995) 220–227.
Press, 2000 (in Chinese). [22] L.J. Guo, Flow Mechanic of Two-phase and Multi-phase, Xi’an Jiaotong
[18] Huagen Wu, Ziwen Xing, Pengcheng Shu, Theoretical and experimental study University Press, 2002 (in Chinese).
on indicator diagram of twin screw refrigeration compressor, International [23] Ziwen Xing, Xueyuan Peng, Pengcheng Shu, Development and application of a
Journal of Refrigeration 27 (4) (2004) 331–338. software package for the design of twin screw compressors, in: Proceedings of
[19] J.S. Fleming, Y. Tang, The analysis of leakage in a twin screw compressor and its the International Compressor Engineering Conference at Purdue, USA, 2000 pp.
application to performance improvement, in: Proceeding of the Institution of 1011–1018.