RECEIVED
Roy S. Moore DEC 18 2017
One Dexter Avenue
Montgomery, AL 36104 one Ro
December 14, 2017
Carol Mott
Investigator/Paralegal
Alabama State Bar
Disciplinary Commission
P.O. Box 671
Montgomery, AL 36101
RE: CSP 2017-1338 (Complaint of Mr. J. Whitfield Larrabee)
Dear Ms. Mott:
In regard to your letter of December 5 and the enclosed complaint, I respond as
follows:
1. The allegations of sexual misconduct, which Mr. Larrabee slanderously presents
as fact, refer to purported events that occurred decades ago. However, “formal
proceedings before the Disciplinary Board must be instituted by the filing of
formal charges within six (6) years from the accrual of the offense ....” Rule 31,
Ala. R. Disc. Proc. The allegations are simply too old for the Disciplinary
Commission to consider.
2. Any individual, including a lawyer, has a right to file a suit for the tort of
defamation, A statement by me of such an intention does not violate the rules of,
professional conduct.
3. The proceedings before the Court of the Judiciary (“COJ").and a subsequent
appeal to the Alabama Supreme Court corcluded earlier this year. 1 was
punished by a suspension for the remainder of my term without salary, the
longest suspension ever issued by the COJ. Although I was not removed from
office, after many months without a salary, I retired,
‘The Disciplinary Commission has no jurisdiction over an incumbent judge for
judicial acts during his term of office. Rule 1(a)(2),, Ala. R. Disc. Proc.
Jurisdiction over the same judge after his term of office concludes for acts that
Securred: while he was a judge is limited to conduct “that would have been
grounds for lawyer discipline.” Rule 1(a)(3), Ala. R. Disc. Proc. The factual
underpinning of the COJ case was an act taken in my administrative capacity asAlabama State Bar
December 14, 2017
Page Two
Chief Justice, an order directed to the probate judges of Alabama. Such an order
cannot be “grounds for lawyer discipline” because a lawyer has no power to
issue an administrative order to probate judges.
Sincerel
Roy 8. Moore