Professional Documents
Culture Documents
avalanche in the Tibetan Himalaya. Conrad barely survived the avalanche and soon
began to suffer from Survivor’s Guilt. In the months following the tragedy, Conrad and
Alex’s widow, Jennifer tried to comfort each other and unexpectedly found love.
Alex’s death was but one of many tragedies that unfold when families lose loved ones
in the mountains. The celebrated high altitude Sherpa families suffer this same fate
more than any other group as they work at extreme altitude for Western expeditions.
In honor of Alex’s legacy Jennifer and Conrad seek meaning beyond tragedy with a
mountaineering school for Sherpas and high altitude workers - The Khumbu Climbing
School.”1
Photo: CJ Carter
Interacting
Intera
Interacti
era cting
cting wit
with
h Extr
E
Extreme
xtreme
xtr eme En
Envir
Environs
virons
vir ons V2
There is always a medium—a common ground through which two dissimilar cultures
can connect. For this project, that medium is climbing. The Sherpa have been
assisting ascents of Mount Everest since the beginning of its legacy as an object of
conquest. Both natives of the Himalaya and foreigners aspire to achieve the goal that
it presents. But the mountain takes many lives. Irrespective of race or creed, peoples
of the east and west alike have perished on its slopes. However circumstances have
made the Sherpa an unsuspecting target for the mountain’s temper. Approximately
one-third of all of the lives claimed by Mount Everest have been Sherpa.3 And yet
these people are the greatest asset to every individual that comes to set their sights
on its peak.
3
Climbing is not simply a means of employment for the Sherpa, it is an opportunity to
have fun. And through the joy that this type of recreational climbing brings, a culture
is strengthened and its ties to other cultures are deepened.
The Khumbu Climbing School has taken place now for over five years, training the
Sherpa in how to climb safely and enjoyably. While an impact has been made, only so
much can be done on a dusty snowy field without facilities. As word of the school has
spread, more and more Sherpa have become interested in climbing and participating.
With greater numbers attending, there is a need for a building where the Sherpa can
come to learn and to climb. That is where this project begins.
Introduction
Introd
Introduct
roduction
uction Photo: CJ Carter
INTERACTING WITH EXTREME ENVIRONS VOLUME 2:
INTEGRATED DESIGN PROPOSALS FOR
THE KHUMBU CLIMBING SCHOOL
NEPAL
SCHOOL
OF
ARCHITECTURE
© 2008 Montana State University. All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America.
This book was submitted by Chris Hancock, Justina Hohmann, Dylan McQuinn, Jaron Mickolio, Sarah Mohland, Nick Molinaro, Dean Soderberg, and Emily Van Court as
educational credit for the “Interacting with Extreme Environs” design/build studio.
Project Supporters: MSU Division of Graduate Education, MSU College of Arts and Architecture, NCARB Grand Prize Award 2006, MSU School of Architecture, Chris
Bergum
Unless otherwise noted, all photographs in this book were taken by members of this studio.
7
1
Purpose: To present several performance-based design proposals for the Khumbu
Climbing School in Phortse, Nepal.
Performance Question: How can new technologies, which increase warmth and
structural safety from earthquakes, and new uses, such as climbing education,
reading, and medical training, not only be integrated with, but reinforce the existing
traditional forms, uses, and materials that define the Sherpa identity?
Concept: Pairing the usually conflicting attributes of old and new through the use of
design strategies, such as view manipulation, skill capacity equalization, and method
familiarization, can create solutions that simultaneously strengthen traditional identity
and enhance performance.
Project Brief 10
Introduction 11
People/Social Resource Map 12
9
PROJECT BRIEF
Alex.
Land Doners: Lhakpa Sherpa, Panuru
Sherpa “The Alex Lowe Charitable Foundation (ALCF) is dedicated to preserving his legacy by
providing direction and financial support to sustainable, community-based humanitarian
Use: climbing school, climbing training programs designed to help the people who live in remote regions of the world. This
and recreation, community events, library, foundation carries on Alex’s spirit of adventure.”2
potato seedling testing and dispersal
KHUMBU CLIMBING SCHOOL MISSION STATEMENT
Factors of Influence: tradition and
culture, safety, warmth “To increase the safety margin of Nepali climbers and high altitude workers by
encouraging responsible climbing practices in a supportive and community-based
program.”3 6
“The mission of the School of Architecture is to prepare students for the lifelong critical
engagement in the arts and science of architecture. We teach and practice a moral,
ethical and aesthetic responsibility to society and the natural world in the design of the
built environment.
The Sherpa have been sequestered in the Khumbu Valley of Nepal for over 400 The Alex Lowe Charitable Foundation has risen to the task of saving Sherpa lives and
years, quietly living near the “roof of the world”, Mount Everest. A devout group of reinforcing their cultural heritage. One of their initiatives, the Khumbu Climbing School
Buddhists, they fled religious persecution in Tibet and settled the sacred Khumbu (KCS), has made a direct impact on the climbing culture of the Himalaya. Now the
Valley of the Himalayas: the ultimate environment—exotic, extreme, intense, and Sherpa have the opportunity to be trained not just in the skills of climbing, but in the art
untouched…untouched until the early 1900’s when climbing for sport was popularized of climbing as well. Climbing is not simply a means of employment for the Sherpa, it is
by the English. an opportunity to have fun. And through the joy that this type of recreational climbing
brings, a culture is strengthened and its ties to other cultures are deepened.
Since the 1950s, over two million foreigners have visited the Khumbu Valley, the
main access route to Mount Everest and its neighboring peaks. This has introduced The successful response to the annual school session has created a need for a more
Western attitudes and commercialization, directly affecting the livelihood, beliefs, and formal space in which to teach the Sherpa. Because of this, the Alex Lowe Charitable
lifestyle of the Sherpa, and transforming the region from an agricultural economy Foundation has partnered with the School of Architecture at Montana State University
into a service economy. The agricultural economy naturally supported indigenous to design and build facilities for the school in Phortse, Nepal. Although small in scale,
development; by nature, the service economy, focuses on networking with outside the capacity for the building to influence the Sherpa and the Region is astronomical.
communities, and reinforces outside influences. Climbing, previously a necessary This strategy of teaching climbing skills and English, coupled with constructing a safer
method to get from one village to the next, is now a world sport. The Sherpa, with and more comfortable building that becomes an exemplary self-sustaining model, can
few technical climbing skills and broken English, have become low-paid porters. This redirect the forces of change to strengthen the Sherpa cultural heritage.
combination of conditions have put Sherpa cultural heritage, traditions, and lives at
risk. In fact, one-third of the deaths on Mount Everest have been Sherpa. Designing a climbing school for the small village community of Phortse may initially
appear to be a simple task. And yet the precarious position of the Khumbu Valley
Realizing the impact on the region, in 1978 the Nepalese Government commissioned and its inhabitants—straddling the gap between their cultural heritage and the 21st
two Italian architects, Valerio Sestini and Enzo Somigli, to research Sherpa architecture Century western world—infinitely complicates this project. By defining clear factors
in the Khumbu Valley. Their findings were documented for the United Nations of influence and establishing strong achievable goals, the process of designing
Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization as one of the first formal steps to performance architecture can be used as a guiding approach for the project.
preserving the Sherpa culture of the Khumbu. In their book, Sherpa Architecture, Performance architecture emphasizes superior building performance over design
they noted the changes occurring in the region and caution against influences that might moves that represent purely aesthetic ideals. It quickly navigates designers through
irrevocably altar the Sherpa culture. Trailoka Nath Upraity, Nepalese Ambassador to questions of how to balance culture and tradition with environmental needs, and filters 11
France, concludes his forward to the book with this statement: through uncertainty created through unsubstantiated design decisions.
“…Hence this study represents a very useful and unique record of a style of architecture This book documents the process and product of eight students and a professor
which may largely disappear in a few generations…. [This] document is an important charged with this task: design a building that can serve as a facility for the Khumbu
contribution to the studies of traditional architecture of a people accustomed to living Climbing School in Phortse, Nepal. Address issues of culture, environment,
in a very challenging environment.”8 technology, and ownership. Work with a vast array of collaborators. Design a building
for the Sherpa that they can and will take ownership of themselves.
It is clear, from this report and other sources, that If nothing is done to temper the
outside influences penetrating the Khumbu Region and rectify this imbalance, the
21st Century will use the Sherpa and destroy their culture for the sake of climbing.
Introduction
PEOPLE SOCIAL Jenni Lowe-Anker
KCS Administrator
Adam Knoff
The Khumbu Climbing School is made This diagram documents the collaborators KCS Instructor
possible by a multitude of efforts for this project, their affiliations, and their Panuru Sherpa
KCS Instructor
stemming from the mission of the Alex contribution capacities as it relates to the
Lowe Charitable Foundation (ALCF). design performance. Amy Bullard
KCS Instructor
The interactions with the foundation
and its affiliates have allowed the Many factors of influence had to be Kris Erickson
MSU architecture team to accumulate considered to ensure the success of this KCS Instructor
information vital to the building design. project. Some of them are internal to the Pete Athans
KCS Instructor
Khumbu Valley while others stem from
The people of the Khumbu Region external forces. This diagram documents Renan Ozturk
KCS Instructor
supplied critical cultural information the starting point for defining goals for
the project. It is against these goals that Ross Lynn
to the studio. Experiencing the place KCS Instructor
and participating in charrettes with the the design schemes will be compared
in order to determine if the architecture Pamela Hainsworth
villagers of Phortse became crucial KCS Administrator
to the design process and would not performs adequately to meet the needs
of the school and the people. CJ Carter
have happened without the support of
numerous people. Heather Archer
The most important factors of influence MSU SOA Student
Numerous people also contributed to include heritage views, cultural Chris Hancock
time, money, and information to the preservation, western influence, and MSU SOA Student
design process. The MSU architecture building comfort (or lack-thereof). Justina Hohmann
MSU SOA Student
team communicated with professional
architects, engineering students, Dylan McQuinn
MSU SOA Student
instructors of ALCF, and directors of
affiliated organizations. The information Jaron Mickolio
MSU SOA Student
obtained from these social resources was
Nick Molinaro
then utilized to create a fully integrated MSU SOA Student
design. Sarah Mohland
MSU SOA Student
Many people also assisted the design Dean Soderberg
team with supplementary information MSU SOA Student
Lila Bishop
Means+Methods English Program
Lhakpa Norbu
Lhakpa Dorji
Peter Janke
BuildingUse Architect
Chhongba Sherpa
Marie Wilson
Architect
Bob Mechels
Architect
Hadrian Predock
Environmental Architect
S y s t e m s Chris Bergum
Architect
Steffan Dorsling
Architect
Reed Kroloff
Director of Cranbrook Universtiy
Anders Larsson
BuildingForm
MSU COE Professor
John Cooney
MSU COE Student
Britney Giles
MSU COE Student
13
Tom Kujawa
MSU COE Student
Bill Grey
M a t e r i a l MSU Plants Sciences
S y s t e m s
Introduction
Interacting with Extreme Environs V2
Photo: CJ Carter
The success of this project depended upon collaboration with many individuals
and groups, including the Alex Lowe Charitable Foundation and its affiliates, other
departments within Montana State University, and guest critics. Specific architectural
processes and strategies were chosen and executed based on appropriateness,
resultant capacities, and student capabilities.
15
Cultural Identity
SHERPA
CULTURAL IDENTITY
Sherpa culture derived from ancestral Foreign influences have affected the The global influences on the Khumbu maintain a distinct, culturally sustainable
roots in the Khams region of Tibet. vulnerable Sherpa culture in ways both region have caused a radical adaptation identity.
Devotion to the sacred traditions of detrimental and beneficial. The western and integration process of the Sherpa
Himalayan Buddhism was a factor in incursions of the 1800’s introduced cultural assemblage. The Sherpa desire The intent of the Khumbu Climbing
their exodus across the highest terrain trade and occupational commerce. some of the elements of modernity. School reflects the desire to offer a
on the planet to settle in the remote The contemporary forces of the late They want to live more comfortable conscientious building that will provide
valleys of the Solu-Khumbu in the 1900s brought new forms of industry: lives and be economically sustainable. benefits toward the consolidation and
1500s. Their identity is dependant upon mountaineering and tourism. Each Globalization has had an effect on the stabilization of the Sherpa cultural identity
a fragile relationship with their extreme era brings new opportunities and Sherpa culture, but through effective as it continues to evolve with the modern
environment. challenges. design decisions and processes they can world.
Khumbu Timeline
- http://www.everyculture.com/South-Asia/Sherpa-History-and-Cultural-Relations.html
- Stevens, Stanley F. Claiming the high ground : Sherpas, subsistence, and environmental change in the highest Himalaya. 1993. University of California Press.
1900s CONTEMPORARY FORCES
KHUMBU
Chomolungma
(Mt. Everest)
Historical events have shaped the geo- To help offset these de-territorializing • 5000 Tibetan refugees enter Khumbu Tengboche
Monastery
spatial distribution of the Sherpas in forces and help stabilize the cultural after Chinese occupation (1959) Sagarmatha Nat’l Park
the Khumbu Valley. Each event helps identity of Phortse, the Khumbu Climbing •
to territorialize or de-territorialize their School will act as a community center • Hillary/Norgay summit Everest (1953)
•
cultural identity. and offer such services as showers and • Shaha Dynasty encourages western Lukla
a library. Ideally, the school will become tourism and mountaineering (1952)
For many years the village of Phortse a destination and help to invite more •
has been dissociated from the Everest tourism and economic value to Phortse, • Tengboche Monastery founded (1916) Western Tourism Sherpa emigration to Darjeeling
•
base camp trail and is experiencing while simultaneously preserving its • Sherpa emigration to Darjeeling
a de-territorializing force from the cultural heritage. The project will be a (1900)
contemporary factors of western tourism consolidating factor that will strengthen Chomolungma
(Mt. Everest)
(1886)
•
Chomolungma
1500s EARLY MIGRATIONS (Mt. Everest)
17
retreats Dingboche
•
Phortse
Record of visitors to the Sagarmatha National Park displayed at the park entrance
Cultural Identity
TRADITIONAL USE
11
11 11
19
Cultural Identity
VILLAGE PHORTSE
FOOTPRINT SIZE
ORGANIZATION ARCHETYPE
Phortse’s location in such an The Sherpa culture and the Khumbu
extreme environment coupled with Valley developed in isolation from the rest
the materials available in the region of the world from the 1500’s until 1951,
led to it’s development of a visual when Nepal was opened for climbing.
language common to its buildings. This As a result of its 400 years of isolation,
language encompasses both the spatial the Sherpa culture developed a unique
relationships between buildings as well cultural identity. However, outside
as the proportions and organization of influence penetrating the Khumbu Valley
facades. Each building is unique but to the high peaks has changed the unique
nonetheless has many attributes in character of this place and its people.
common with the rest of Phortse. All culturally relevant buildings in The vast majority of buildings in the
In 1978 the United Nations Educational, Phortse and the Khumbu are built from Khumbu are two stories, and are based
From a collection of photographs, we Scientific and Cultural Organization a prototypical block. The block has an on the various footprint configurations.
documented every culturally relevant (UNESCO) and two Italian architects elongated linear plan. This plan is the The base floor historically was used
building in Phortse to understand visited the Khumbu Region of Nepal in module that forms the basis for a series for agricultural functions and shelter
and distill the attributes common to an effort to document the Sherpa culture, of variations that accommodate different for livestock, while the upper floor
the village’s buildings. The attributes and more specifically its buildings. In needs for space. was appropriated for domestic uses.
include orientation, facade proportioning, their report titled Sherpa Architecture, Because agriculture was the vocation of
composition, roof forms and datum. they categorize the buildings according to The first of two addition variations in plan the region for over 400 years, there are
their most essential elements of design is another elongated linear plan formed very few single-story dwellings.
To explore some of these attributes, such as orientation, form, material, and by two inline modules. The second is an
studies were done based on two- relationship to the landscape. L-shaped plan formed by rotating one
dimensional views. Other attributes module with respect to another (shown
pertained more particularly to perspective From the UNESCO report we distilled below).
and thus required a three-dimensional the attributes common to buildings built
analysis. before the influx of foreign influence.
These attributes are common to most
It should be noted that while exhibiting buildings in the Khumbu Valley and are
some attributes common to Phortse, highlighted in the report in an existing
the contemporary lodges were omitted building in Phortse. This particular
from this analysis in order to maintain structure exemplifies the essence of
cultural integrity and consistency with typical Sherpa residential/non-religious
the conclusions drawn. buildings.
Note: These images were created using computer modeling software Rhino 4.0.
Dwellings are crowned with a low The culturally archetypal buildings in Because the landscape of Phortse
pitched ridge roof that ends in either a Phortse all are aligned parallel with the slopes, the buildings are dug into the
gable or hip. Gable roofs typically have topography. The town slopes down terrain, allowing for both thermal and
an “eyebrow,” or built-up continuation of to the South-West, giving the village material efficiency. Buildings are set into
the eaves along the facade beneath the east-west topography. The southern- the terrain at roughly half their depth and
gable. most facade is the primary fenestrated height, making it possible to connect the
face of the building, and therefore second story with the terrain at the rear
The L-shaped forms have a hip and establishes the axis by which the building of the building.
valley condition at the junction of the two is elongated. The resulting short north-
modules. south axis and elongated East-West axis
allows for maximum daylight penetration.
The doors are typically placed on the
south face, but are more flexible in their
placement than the windows.
21
Cultural Identity
TERRACING HERITAGE PLANE COMPOSITION
The Sherpa’s historical vocation was The built landscape is a reflection of the
agriculture which necessitated finding or Sherpa’s reconciliation with the extreme
making arable land. As a result the typical nature of their environment. Because
town sites were south-facing shelves at these shelves were chosen for their
the threshold between the mountain and access to sunlight for crops, Phortse’s
the river gorges. These shelves however buildings take advantage of the village’s
were not level enough to be viable fields orientation towards the sun for light and
for crops and needed to be built into heat. HERITAGE PLANE COMPOSITION
terraces to help facilitate the agricultural
process and soil maintenance.
MOUNTAIN PEAKS
PHORTSE PLATEAU
RIVER GORGE
TERRAFORMED LAND MANIPULATION We studied the relationship of openings There is a more or less independent
to mass proportions of the buildings of relationship of organization between the
Phortse and found that most any facade upper and lower level openings in the
proportion typically had 3-4 windows buildings of Phortse, Openings roughly
on the upper level that were of a typical ever “stack” structurally but vary widely in
small rectangular shape. There also were both number and alignment with regard
instances where an elongated window to the upper story.
was used in which cases typically only
2-3 windows were used.
23
The datum is a pervasive logic in the The basic massing of the buildings in
Phortse archetype. This low linear roof Phortse fall in to four typical lengths
line as well as the alignment of windows some more common than others. The
from the eaves of the roof establishes proportions are primarily a result of the
a strong datum. On the gable end, the need for maximum southern exposure
datum is continued through an eyebrow. so tend to form elongated masses 2-3
A secondary logic present in most every times wide as they are tall.
building is a symmetry of the facade with
regards to openings and accentuated by
*4 the gable ends.
Cultural Identity
Interacting with Extreme Environs V2
The success of this project depended on collaboration with many individuals and
groups, including the Alex Lowe Charitable Foundation and its affiliates, other
departments within Montana State University, and guest critics. Specific architectural
processes and strategies were chosen and executed based on appropriateness,
resultant capacities, and student capabilities.
Project Timeline 27
Site Research: Visit 1 28
Design Charrette: Visit 2 30
Design Studio: Fall 2008 34
25
PROJECT TIMELINE MSU ACADEMIC TEAM
Mike and Bob
Environmental
Structure
Use
Environmental Systems
Materials
CONSTRUCTION
B Breaking ground
Jan 2008 Aug 2008 Jan 2009 Aug 2009 Jan 2010
Educational Journey
SITE RESEARCH:
VISIT 1
During the January 2008 session of the
Khumbu Climbing School, MSU student
Heather Archer and MSU graduate
Marie Wilson trekked to Phortse, Nepal
to research the site and see the school 1
in action. They also explored the culture
of the Sherpa and spent over a week
with them, learning about the people and
their lives. These images are merely a
glimpse into what they saw.
4 6
10
29
9 11
Educational Journey
DESIGN CHARRETTE:
VISIT 2
In August of 2008, MSU graduate
students Justina Hohmann, Dylan
McQuinn, Sarah Mohland, and Nick
Molinaro travelled with MSU Professor
Michael Everts to Phortse, Nepal to hold
a design charrette with the local Sherpa
community. The map to the right shows
the trekking route of the group. Along
the way they ammassed nearly 6000
photographs, some of which are shown
below.
khumbi yul
ul lha
m
5761m phortse
ama dabl
dablam
6856m
6856
4 day hike
lukl
lukla
30 minute flight from kathmandu
12 31
Educational Journey
The design charrette in Phortse consisted
of the architecture team from MSU, the
team’s guide, Chhongba Sherpa, and
several community members of Phortse.
Initially the team met with Chhongba and
a few community members to gather
initial ideas. Three long days were then
spent measuring and documenting the
site, creating design schemes, building
models, and producing drawings and
diagrams to express those ideas. The
team worked with materials that they had
either brought with them to Nepal or had
acquired along their journey, including
traditional Nepali paper and several
cardboard boxes that had to be portered
from Lukla to Phortse.
Educational Journey
DESIGN STUDIO:
FALL 2008
The majority of the research and design
work in this book was created and
compiled during the Fall 2008 semester
design studio at MSU. For this studio four
undergraduate students—Christopher
Hancock, Jaron Mickolio, Dean
Soderberg, and Emily Van Court—joined
the team that had travelled to Nepal in
August. The undergraduate students
were quickly briefed on the project and
design charrette, and then the studio
began working to create several design
schemes that will be presented at the
2009 Khumbu Climbing School session.
Educational Journey
Interacting with Extreme Environs V2 Photo: C.J. Carter
Performance architecture is “an emerging design paradigm in which building
performance, broadly understood, becomes a guiding design principle. This new
kind of architecture places performance on par with form-making; it utilizes digital
technologies of quantitative and qualitative performance simulation to offer a
comprehensive new approach to the design of the built environment.”1
The Khumbu Climbing School design proposals are required to meet several performance
criteria that address factors such as warmth, light, usability, constructability, and
traditional architectural forms. Focusing on performance provides a natural way of
measuring the potential success of each design proposal.
Project Goals 38
Site Parameters 38
Site Description 38
Phortse Site Plan 39
Building Site 39
Performance Component Map 40
37
As a performance-driven architectural design project, each design proposal must meet There are several key constraints that The site for the Khumbu Climbing School
the following goals: have been placed on this project. sites on a field to the southeast of the
village adjacent to two lodges and the
THE DESIGN PROPOSAL MUST BE HERITAGE-DEPENDANT. They must be MATERIAL SIZE nearby hillside. This field is where the
routed in the traditional Sherpa culture. First, material transportation to the Khumbu Climbing School currently meets
site severely limits the type and size of for training purposes during its sessions.
IT MUST INTEGRATE NEW FORMS, MATERIALS, AND CONSTRUCTION building materials. Every material used The land is owned by the owners of the
METHODS WITH THE EXISTING SHERPA IDENTITY. While the building is routed must be small enough to be able to be two lodges who have agreed to donate
in traditional Sherpa culture, it must also bridge the gap through the use of forms, carried on a porter’s back and weigh less equal portions of their land for the
materials, and construction methods, to the 21st Century. than about 100 lbs. construction of the climbing school.
THE BUILDING MUST BLEND IN VISUALLY WITH THE LOCAL ARCHITECTURE. MATERIAL LOCATION The site slopes to the southwest with
Its forms should be recognizable as part of the Phortse archetype when viewed from Second, the limited material resources about a 19-foot difference in height from
key vantage points throughout the village and the area. in the area must be used in lieu of back to front. A rock wall surrounds
flying in materials imported from other the fields and an additional wall runs
THE BUILDING MUST BE SAFE. Current construction practices do not produce locations such as the USA. Although directly through the site, dividing the field
structurally sound buildings. one shipping container may ultimately be between its two owners. To the edge of
used for a specialized item, the majority the site is a large juniper tree, one of the
IT MUST PERFORM BETTER ENVIRONMENTALLY THAN EXISTING SHERPA of the materials used in the construction only trees in Phortse. Since this village
ARCHITECTURE. In particular, the building must overcome the taxing environmental must be obtainable from either Nepal or exists approximately at the tree line of
conditions of the site. The building must be warm. It must make use of daylight. It China. For instance, wood is currently the mountains, it is important to keep this
must incorporate other environmental strategies to increase comfort. unavailable in the region. tree in the design if at all possible.
THE BUILDING MUST ACCOMMODATE THE KHUMBU CLIMBING SCHOOL LOCAL INVOLVEMENT
SESSION ACTIVITIES. The design must allow for climbing education, reading, Part of the intent of this project is to help
medical training and new forms of activities to take place. stimulate the economy of the Khumbu
Region. Therefore the construction
THE DESIGN SHOULD FOSTER COMMUNITY INTERACTIONS. It should be a process needs to be designed and
place where community events can occur as well as house a community library. implemented with an emphasis on
labor. This is opposite of how buildings
IT SHOULD GIVE BACK TO THE LAND. Since the building is occupying a precious are designed and constructed in the
growing field, it should compensate in some way for the growing area it displaces. USA, where time and efficiency are
prized. Local Sherpa will porter as
THE DESIGN MUST BE SUCH THAT THE COMMUNITY CAN TAKE OWNERSHIP many materials from Lukla to Phortse as
OF IT. If this does not happen, the community will not use the building. possible and will construct the building
themselves. 2
10 ft wide no-
build easement
building site
approx. 5250 sq ft
N
Ma
in E
panuru lodge
0 25’ 50’
ntr
yT
39
rail
LEGEND
PATH
0 100’ 200’
PHORTSE BOUNDARY
BUILDING
SITE
Performance Architecture
A. Means & C. Environmental
PERFORMANCE Methods
B. Building Use Systems
COMPONENTS
1. Environmental 1. Climbing 1. Climate
Performance-driven architectural design
requires that many design aspects must 2. Monetary a. Training Wall a. Sun
be examined thoroughly. These aspects,
or components, once explored, provide a
Fundraising b. Climbing Wall b. Wind c. Air Quality
series of options that can be strategically
combined to produce a performance-
driven design. This diagram shows the 3. Quality 2. Gathering c. Comfort i. Air Barrier
components explored for this project.
4. Availability a. Community 2. Systems ii. Air Circulation
The following pages document the
research and exploration undertaken for iii. Cross
a. Local 3. Living a. Warmth
many of these components. Ventilation
Since our project has several b. New 4. Learning i. Direct Solar Gain d. Power
performance-specific goals, a few of
these component choices will take c. Specialized 5. Service i. Hydro
ii. Sun Space
priority over the others in the design
schemes. These components have
d. Available a. Showers iii. Trombe Wall ii. Solar
been highlighted in color. Please note
that components highlighted in grey will
be examined in subsequent semesters. 5. Skill Capacity b. Library iv. Thermal iii. Wind
Insulation
Performance Architecture
One of the most important performance criteria for the design is to make sure that the
spaces created will fulfill the fuctions of the program laid out for the school. While the
school is not in session the building will need to perform well for community fuctions,
such as banquets, ceremonial gatherings and as a meeting space.
The photograph to the left was taken at the Sherpa Museum in Namche Bazaar.
It shows a diagram of the Sherpa lifestyle throughout the year. It represents basic
Sherpa living and working activities as well as spiritual events.
Building Use 44
Seasonal Use Diagram 44
Climbing Wall 46
43
BUILDING USE SEASONAL USE
ANALYSIS Natural Resource Management
Potato Planting
The program for the Khumbu Climbing Gathering Space 1000-1200 sq ft The diagram to the right examines the Potato Weeding
School incorporates many traditional and potential uses of the building and the Potato Harvesting
new uses. The building will be a place Kitchen and 300 sq ft times of the year when these activities Dairy Production
where safe climbing practices can be Storage could take place. Firewood Collection
taught, along with English, and medical Equipment Room 300 sq ft Spinning and Weaving
training. It is intended to also serve as a and Storage Foilage Collection
center for community events. It will also
hold a small library, as well as a potato Office 100 sq ft Cattle Breeding
seedling room to test and disperse potato Living Space 200 sq ft Calving
tubers. Additionally the building will Barley and Buckwheat Sowing
contain living quarters for a caretaker. Meeting Room 200 sq ft
(12 people)
Religious
The chart to the right is a list of the Rest rooms 100 sq ft Pilgrimages (Kathmandu and India)
programmatic elements that are included
Shower 100 sq ft Losar (Gyalu Lhosar)
in the design proposals.
TOTAL 2300-2500 sq ft Mani Rimdu (Thame Monastery)
Mani Rimdu (Tengboche)
Yanchang
Social
Sherpa Weddings
Funerals
Trading with Tibet (Salt)
Trading with Solu (Grain)
45
Building Use
CLIMBING AND
PARAMETRIC CLIMBING WALL
TRAINING WALLS
Climbing is a new building use for the Through parametric modeling, the formal
Khumbu Region and integral to this extents of the climbing wall can be
project. While climbing walls are present extensively explored. The result is an
in Kathmandu, the Khumbu Region has understanding of the limits, function, and
yet to see one. The Khumbu Climbing mechanics of the wall. This allows for
School currently uses local trees and Spire Climbing Center, Bozeman greater design sensitivity to the wall and
ice formations around Phortse to train its surrounding space.
the Sherpa in safe climbing practices.
Incorporating a climbing wall into the
building design will increase the capacity
of the school to teach the Sherpa and
provide them with the means of training
during other times of the year, as well
as have fun.
X<Y
X>Y
47
This image depicts the programming
used to create the parametric climbing
The height of a wall is typically walls shown here. Grasshopper, a
determined both by the space it can plug-in for the 3D Nurbs modeling
occupy and the type of climbing it is program Rhino, allows the user to create
meant to support. For bouldering (low, The angles between two adjacent panels parametric models using simple graphical
no-rope) applications a wall may be The safety mat must extend a distance must be small enough to prevent a sharp coding functions and constants. Sliders
no taller than 12 feet and typically no from the wall of either 2.5 times the point from being created. If the angle can be added and given specific ranges
shorter than 8 feet. If the wall is meant overhang distance or 10 feet, whichever causes a point condition, an intermediate to show how increasing or decreasing
to accommodate roped climbers, then is greatest. This distance also increase panel must be added to transition one portion of the wall affects other parts
40 feet is a typical maximum height. as a function of the height of the wall. between the two wall sections. of the wall.
Building Use
Interacting with Extreme Environs V2
1
As a remote location on the planet, Phortse presents a unique set of challenges in
accurately predicting weather data and analyzing climate. Since there are currently no
weather stations in Phortse, a combination of data collected throughout the Khumbu
Region has been used to estimate and analyze Phortse’s climate. In particular, the
weather data sets for Pheriche (4258 m / 13970’) and Namche Bazaar (3560 m)
/ 11680’) have been averaged to estimate such data as average temperature and
relative humidity, because Phortse’s elevation (3840 m / 12598’) is almost halfway
between these two locations. These averages will provide numbers that are slightly
more conservative than what actually exists in the village.
Phortse Climate 50
-Sun 50
-Wind 52
-Comfort 54
Environmental Systems 56
-Warmth 56
-Light 57
-Air Quality 59
-Power 60
-Water and Sanitation 61
49
Heat Strategies 62
PHORTSE CLIMATE
SUN BUBBLE SUN PATH CHARTS
SUN
Phortse’s Climate at a Glance* This solar bubble shows how the sun will move across the site throughout the year. These images show the path of the sun
Because of the low latitude, the sun remains rather high in the sky during the year. across the site. The red shades describe
location: 27° 51’ North, 86° 45” East This means that the most important building surface in regards to both light penetration the solar irradiation hitting the site; deep
elevation: 12598 ft (3840 m) and solar heat is the roof. The section diagrams on this and the following pages show red depicts maximum solar irradiation.
avg. temperature: 36.4° F the solar altitude angles at various times during the day.
avg. relative humidity: 82%
avg. radiation: 19.4 Watts / sf
avg. annual precipitation: 25.8 in
avg. wind speed: 6.11 mi / h
avg. atmospheric pressure: 9.22 psi
summer zenith angle: 86°
Jun 21
winter zenith angle: 39° May 21
2
Apr 20
LINE
Mar 20
0 W E
OW
Feb 20
0
AD
Jan 21
2
SH
Dec 21
2
GE
RID
SW SE
S
AFT
ER
NO
3 pm ON NING
Dec 21 19 OPTIMAL D MOR
.4 AILY SUN A
NGLE
19.4 10 am
19.4
1:30 6.2 13.4 Dec 21
Dec 21 90
˚
12:20 11:15
Dec 21 Dec 21
67˚
To the east of the site is a short ridge that contains a row of trees, estimated at about The solar irradiance describes how much sun energy is penetrating a horizontal
208 feet. This means that the site will be in shade for large portions of the morning surface. The clearness index refers to the percentage of clear days throughout the
throughout the year. year. Together this information can be used to determine how much sun energy will
heat the building or be collected by a solar collector.
100
80
MAX
.5
60
21
C
DE
MEAN
40
AM
28
10
AR 21
JA
20
MIN
AM
0
10 AM
J F M A M J J A S O N D
51
90˚ 90˚
90˚ 90˚
1:30 pm, Dec. 21 12:20 pm, Dec. 21 11:30 am, Dec. 21 10:00 am, Dec. 21
Environmental Analysis
WIND
WIND ROSE KHUMBU WIND PATTERNS
The wind rose displays wind speed and This map of the Khumbu Valley shows
direction for the site throughout the PHORTSE - YEARLY AVERAGES the weather stations that have been
course of the year. The mountainous N collecting data since 2002 and the
region of the Himalayas creates infinite microclimate wind patterns that they
microclimates each with their own subtly NN
W NN
E have recorded.
complex wind patterns.
NW
NE
The Phortse wind rose data was derived MT.EVEREST(29035FT)
EN
BASE CAMP(17600FT)
WN
E
the Namche and Pheriche weather
PYRAMID(16,500FT)
stations, two villages that have their N
W E
NW
NE
intiuitive assumptions have been made
EN
WN
E
10 20 30%
N W
PHERICHE(13,975FT)
E
ES
NN
WS
W E
E
NN
W
neighboring wind stations.
NW
NE
E
SW
SE
WS
SE
W
SSE
EN
SSW
WN
E
PHORTSE(12500FT)
10 20 30%
W E S
N
W
The Khumbu valley topography dictates
ES
WS
E
W NN
NN E
SW
SE
SW
NE
SE
much of the resulting wind directions.
SSE
SSW
EN
E
10 20 S
30%
E
ES
E
formulated by the directions of the valley
SE
SSE
SSW
diagram.
S
LUKLA(8730 FT)
W NN W NN NN NN
NN E NN E W E W E
NN NN
NW
NE
NW
NE
NW
NE
NW
NE
W
W
EN
EN
W
WN
EN
EN
WN
WN
E
WN
E
E
10 20 30% 10 20 30%
W E W E 10 20 30% 10 20 30%
W E W E
WSW
WSW
ES
ES
WSW
WSW
E
ES
ES
E
E
SW
SE
SW
SE
SW
SE
SW
SE
SSE SSE
SSW SSW
SSE SSE
SSW SSW
S S
S S
In general, the daily wind flows are southerly in direction and are initiated by the
heating of the atmosphere over the mountain slopes of the Khumbu valley. Horizontal
EVENING CURRENTS (KABATIC) thermal gradients are established and the prevailing valley winds flow upslope in an
anabatic process. The nighttime winds can be considered as kabatic flows in which
radiative cooling of the upper mountainsides flow downslope as the daytime solar
heating diminishes. These nocturnal mountain winds tend to fall downslope and into
the drainage systems of the valleys. The diurnal variations of the monthly surface wind
vectors have been collected at the Periche and Lukla weather stations and are shown
53
Environmental Analysis
COMFORT ACTIVITY / CLOTHING
BIOCLIMATIC CHART
METRICS
loads. 4.4
10 Rock Climbing / 3.0- 55-74
Comfort levels can also be modulated by
Exercise 4.0
wind and shade if too hot (not shown)
and by direct solar radiation if too cold. 0
Typical Clothing Insulation Values
Typical clear day radiation at Phortse will
provide 260 Btu/hr ft2. This condition
-10 Description (CLO)
becomes a critical passive design
Walking shorts, short sleeve shirt (0.36)
strategy, because it can drastically
RELATIVE HUMIDITY (%) Trousers, long-sleeve shirt, sweater
modify the comfort level as shown. -20 (1.01)
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% plus long underwear bottoms (1.3)
Insulated coveralls, long sleeve thermal
underwear, long underwear
bottoms (1.37)
40 6
MAX
5
.5
30 MEAN
4
20 3
MIN
2
10
1
DAILY .1
MAX
0 0
J F M A M J J A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D
40
MIN
20
500
winter pre-monsoon monsoon post-monsoon
0
J F M A M J J A S O N D Montana Nepal Montana Nepal Montana Nepal
Environmental Analysis
ENVIRONMENTAL WARMTH
DIRECT SOLAR GAIN SUN SPACE
SYSTEMS
Due to the extreme environment in Phortse’s climate is such that heating
which this project located, the design is required throughout the entire year.
must respond to climate. The following Current building construction methods
systems demonstrate positive responses do not provide adequate protection from
to the climate analysis. They have the cold. A major focus of this project
been classified based on the type of is incorporating strategies that will
environmental comfort they provide: maximize the warmth of the building.
warmth, light, air quality, power, water,
and clean sanitation. These symbols Building heat loss depends on two
describe each system in terms of related things: resistance factors of building
technology, materials, and additional materials and infiltration rates.1
considerations:
It is necessary to increase the resistance
PASSIVE SYSTEM does
factors of building materials used in the
not require additional energy
(electricity)
construction of a basic Sherpa house: L A
ACTIVE SYSTEM requires R-Values of Construction Materials Direct solar gain systems comprise of By creating an indoor-outdoor space,
additional energy (electricity) sunlight penetrating through a window heat can be gathered in a sun space and
and warming a space containing a large transferred inside the building through a
EXISTING MATERIALS are thermal mass. Existing construction thermal mass.5 By adding interior stone
available Metal Roof .001 methods lack adequate interior thermal walls to the exterior stone construction,
Single Pane Glass 1.12 mass to absorb solar heat gain efficienty. glass windows windows can be used to
Stone Masonry .25 Modifying current stone construction and facilitate this type of heat gain. New
DIFFERENT MATERIALS need Wood Door 1.08
adding materials with higher insulating insulative materials will help the interior
to be introduced to the region
(R-value) 2 .25 .5 .75 1.0
properties will increase the capacity of of the building retain the heat that it
the space to store heat.4 gains.
SPECIALIZED SYSTEM
The majority (99%) of the heat lost
requires technical construction or
through building materials is lost through
maintenance
the roof. According to the sun path and
RELATES TO and affects another solar irradiance values at the site, the
system: roof contains the greatest potential for
passive solar heat gain throughout the
W L A P W day and year.3
Corridor 10
General Space 10 - 20
Plant Room *L1 15
Sports / Assembly 30
Office / Kitchen 50
General Inspection 100
8 10 *13 *L3
Environmental Analysis
SIDELIGHTING TOPLIGHTING REFLECTED LIGHT ELECTRIC LIGHTING
H H
2.5H 2.5H
W A W W A P
Window properties are rooted in Skylights in the Khumbu are made out By reflecting daylight into the space, Retrofit compact fluorescent light
Tibetan Buddhist traditions, but daylight of corrugated polycarbonate and have more even lighting can be created than fixtures (CFLs) are used throughout the
quality can be improved by adjusting no insulative properties. Insulative what currently exists. Daylight should be Khumbu. They use less electricity than
these factors.*L4 Window height is materials will improve performance and thought of as having one bounce before incandescent bulbs, however they can
proportional to light penetration into the minimize roof heat loss. Based on the it is distributed throughout the space.*L9 provide harsh light for certain activities.
space. Good daylight penetrates about solar path and irradiance, the optimal The material that light is bouncing off Specialized fixtures should be considered
15 feet, and reasonable daylight up to building surface for both light and heat of should be of a high reflectance to for some parts of the project in order to
30 feet. Beyond this electric lighting is gain is the roof.*L7 Skylights should be maximize the amount of daylight that provide the best lighting for visually-
needed.*L5 Window glazing with higher oriented accordingly, and adjusted to penetrates the space. Reflected light is challenging tasks. It is important to
insulative properties should be used. minimize heat loss and glare. commonly created with light shelves. minimize glare and maximize efficiency.
*A4
Environmental Analysis
POWER
HYDRO SOLAR WIND
It is estimated that:
water used: 1.5 gallons/person/day
people per climbing school session: 65
days needed: 60
P total gallons needed: 5850
annual precipitation: 25.8 in
P W
Since it is anticipated that an excess of Since the Khumbu Valley receives much Standing water in cisterns will need to
power could be generated from solar and The annual precipitation provides more water during its monsoon season, barrels be filtered for many factors, including
wind systems, this will need to be stored than enough water for the climbing and cisterns are already being used to contamination and taste. Some systems
in batteries. Batteries should be sized in school facilities.*W2 capture and store water. When sized require energy, while others rely on
order to be able to provide power during appropriately for water retention from gravity. Portered components will require
the cloudy days of the monsoon season. the monsoon and storage throughout specialized installation and maintenance.
Deep cycle batteries are designed for the year, the additional factors that must A biosand filter can process up to
such storage and operate from 32˚F to be considered are filtration (of standing 15.85 gals. of water/hour, requires little
104˚F. Weight is a factor since they will water), preventing freezing in winter, and maintenance, and has been tested for
need to be portered to Phortse.*P8 potential roof loads from roof cisterns. multiple climates.*W5 61
*W1.1
Environmental Analysis
HEAT STRATEGIES
SOLAR HOT WATER COMPOSTING TOILET SOLAR ORIENTATION
Jun 21
W P L A May 21
Apr 20
2
LINE
be used to heat water for showers or be incorporate composting. Composting
Mar 20
0 W E
OW
incorporated into other systems, such as toilets convert solid waste into reusable Feb 20
AD
heat exchangers that provide warmth. fertilzer.*W9 This natural decomposition Jan 21
2
SH
Dec 21
2
Roof systems are common in the region, can be incorporated into existing toilets, GE
but ground-level systems could also be however this requires specialized RID
used. Cistern and PV panel size and adaptations high altitudes.*W10 The SW SE
orientation should be considered in the system will need heating, ventilation, and
design. New technologies could help regular maintenance.*W11 S
increase the efficiency of the system. AFT
ER
NO
3 pm ON NING
Dec 21 19 OPTIMAL
MOR
.4 DAILY SUN
ANGLE
19.4 10 am
19.4
1:30 6.2 13.4 Dec 21
Dec 21
12:20 11:15
Dec 21 Dec 21
*W8 *W12
• Roof surfaces are optimal for heat gain • This breathing solar wall preheats fresh • Acts as a modified trombe wall. • Earth berming increases resistance to
for high solar angles. outdoor air. • Exterior glazing traps solar radiation heat loss through floors and walls.
• Rooftop collectors heat air between • South facing dark perforated metal that is absorbed by vented thermal mass • Temperature difference between
corrugated metal absorber plate and an absorbs solar radiation. wall. outside and inside is reduced.
insulating layer. • Convected heat is collected in air space • Nighttime or translucent insulation can • R-values increase at depths greater
• Mechanical ducts move heated air into behind. be installed in the air space to inhibit than 2ft.
the wall cavity of external walls. • Duct work directs air into habitable conductive heat losses. • Insulative values depends on soil type,
• Murocaust refers to the wall cavity space. • The translucent material has high density, and moisture content.
between the thermal mass wall and an • Air is heated 10 to 40 degrees sunlight transmission, low emittance, • Stepped topography of site provides
external insulating layer. fahrenheit. and a U-value of less than 0.18BTU/ good opportunity for earth envelope and
• Heat is released into the habitable space • Floor plenum distributes heat to thermal hr ºF ft2. contouring on three sides of building,
through extended radiant transmission. mass floors for heat storage or directly • Deliberate use of apertures in while opening towards the southern
into living space. the thermal wall alow for controlled exposure.
• The solar wall and cavity also reduce daylighting within the building.
conductive heat loss.
• A small mechanical system can
DOUBLE GLAZING
BLACK CORRUGAT- augment air flow.
ED METAL PLATE
FLOOR PLENUM
NORTHERN EXPOSURE
RETURN DUCT PERFORATED BLACK METAL EXTERIOR GLAZING GROUND CONTACT
Environmental Analysis
Interacting with Extreme Environs V2
The requisite factor in determining the building form was integrating the design into
the contextual fabric of the existing buildings in the village. The performance criteria
was created by establishing the specific views to the site and maintaining a traditional
composition in the designs from these specified heritage planes. Many studies were
developed to confirm and reconfirm the continuity of the design within the site with
respect to the traditional architecture of Phortse.
View Shed
Building Form Studies
Visual Presence
Volume Descriptions
Spatial Diagrams
65
Building Form
VIEW SHED PARALLAX SITE A
[X, Y, Z] [0’, 0’, 0’] [-4477’, -2030’, -197’]
E
B
A 1
2 4
67
Building Form
BUILDING FORM
STUDIES
This studio has explored several
determining factors of building form
throughout the semester including siting,
visual, volumetric, and spatial factors.
Many study models were built to help
examine each factor and determine what
specific choices could be made for this
design.
These visual presence strategies Visual Shadow shows how certain Parallax refers to a principle where Rhythm reflects the inherent repetition
demonstrate different ways that the building elements can be hidden, or disjointed shapes appear to be a of windows, doors, roof elements, and
building can be designed to fit within the “shadowed” from view. completely connected object when other architectural features throughout
Phortse archetype and still express new viewed at certain angles. (See appendix Phortse.
building forms. page__.
69
Building Form
VOLUME
OFFSET GEODE EMBED
DESCRIPTIONS
These volumetric exercises show possible Offset refers to removing a portion of the Geode expresses the ability to Embed suggests pushing the building
architectural design moves that can be building, such as the training wall, away design something that looks like its into the landscape.
made with the overall building form. from the rest of the building in order to surroundings on the outside and yet
isolate an activity.
Passage reflects carving a path through Inhabit explores the possibility of making Climb reflects the ability of the building Pry suggests that a portion of the building
the building that connects different the climbing or training walls “living walls” to move with the slope of the landscape, can be embedded under a part of the
spaces. that contain other programmed space or the ability of the circulation within the landscape that has been pulled up.
within their structure.
71
Building Form
SPATIAL DIAGRAMS
POCHE TERRACE PERSPECTIVE
Space studies explore strategies for Poche is an architectural term that Terrace responds to the land terracing Perspective creates a space that is not
designing the programmatic areas of the describes filling an area in a drawing, that exists throughout the Khumbu shaped as it appears to be. This creates
building, such as the gathering space. model, or design in order to focus Valley. Programmed space can either be opportunities to hide interior forms from
The ability to express dualistic qualities in attention on another space. In this case, nestled within the terraces or they can be the exterior vernacular architecture, or
each strategy was emphasized. this strategy embeds space in what used as a stair and/or seating element. other parts of the building.
appears to be a filled-in space.
Gap looks at pulling apart portions of Light well specifically explores Direction refers to creating circulation Material suggests that spaces can be
the roof or wall to let in daylight and/or introducing daylight from above into patterns in the building that reflect either differentiated through the use of different
create additional space in the building. spaces. This can be linked directly with the Sherpa way of moving around and materials instead of using different
Such a gap could be used to create important programmatic elements as a through space, or the transition from forms.
indoor-outdoor space. means of marking them in the building. outside to inside.
73
Building Form
Interacting with Extreme Environs V2
As a remote location on the planet, Phortse presents a unique set of challenges in
accurately predicting weather data and analyzing climate. Since there are currently no
weather stations in Phortse, a combination of data collected throughout the Khumbu
Region has been used to estimate and analyze Phortse’s climate. In particular, the
weather data sets for Pheriche (4258 m / 13970’) and Namche Bazaar (3560 m)
/ 11680’) have been averaged to estimate such data as average temperature and
relative humidity, because Phortse’s elevation (3840 m / 12598’) is almost halfway
between these two locations. These averages will provide numbers that are slightly
more conservative than what actually exists in the village.
Materials
-Wood
-Wind
-Comfort
Environmental Systems
-Warmth
-Light
-Air Quality
-Power
-Water and Sanitation
75
MATERIALS WOOD
ROUGH CUT TIMBER DIMENSIONAL LUMBER
MAN-MADE
3 5
Plywood is available in the area in 1/8” A mountain variety of bamboo already Thatching consists of reeds from the Straw bale is a highly insulating material
and 1/4” thicknesses. Currently it is grows in the Himalaya; these temperate surrounding region woven to form a with compressive load bearing capacities.
used as interior sheathing for walls and clumpers can survive freezing winters. low-cost and marginally watertight Its thermal rating can range from R-30 to
ceilings. Plywood’s relatively ductile Bamboo’s fast growth rate and packable membrane. Although the technique is R-45. A post-and-beam framing system
nature allows it to be twisted into curving nature make it a viable and sustainable time-consuming, it could be considered can be placed inside the straw structure,
forms that have structural and aesthetic replacement for dimensional lumber. for use as a low-tech vapor barrier. but it must have a watertight veneer.
applications. It has structural capacities as well as As straw is such a valuable commodity in
durable qualities for use as an interior the area as feed it is not viable to use in
finish. a building capacity.
77
2 4 6
7 8
Sheet Metal is mostly used as a wind-or Corrugated metal is currently the primary Rebar is most commonly used to hold
low-tech vapor barrier. Its capacities for roofing material used in the valley. It is together stone and masonry units, and is
both of these tasks are low, making a packable and sheds water. However occasionally paired with mortar. Although
different application is necessary. It can without insulation, it is a poor roofing rare, if concrete is used, rebar serves as
be bent or rolled to increase its structural material due to extreme roof heat loss. reinforcing.
capacities or used as a way to reflect the Corrugated, like sheet metal, can be
sun and increase solar heat gain. bent to increase its structural capacities
so it is not only used as roofing.
9 10
Tension bridges in the area make good Aluminum is a lightweight and watertight While, the Sherpa are very skilled in this
use of steel cable. The success and alternative to traditional wood-framed construction technique, the quality of dry-
usefulness of the tension bridges lends windows. stack varies with each construction crew
well to its use in other applications, such because all of the stone is hand quarried
as tension building systems. and chiseled. This construction method
can be manipulated with purposeful
cracks and challenges for an exterior
climbing wall.
79
11
12 13 14
Stone with mortar is also a common Slate can be used as a roof, wall, or Mud veneer uses simple building Rammed earth requires a relatively
construction method in the valley. This floor material. It is currently quarried in techniques to achieve a tighter air and simple construction technique, offers
system, as opposed to dry-stack, is the region, although not commonly used. water seal than dry-stacked stone a high level of insulation, and does not
quickly assembled and requires lower Its versatility makes it a viable material alone. need an additional exterior or interior wall
quality chisel techniques. choice. covering in order to be sealed from water
infiltration. Typically additives are used,
but the composition of the mixture must
be determined by testing local soil.
15
16 18 19
A wide range of foam products, including Typically used as an exterior decking Tyvek, an almost exclusively-used brand-
rigid-board and spray foam, offers a material, UPM ProFi can be used as a name vapor barrier in the USA, is applied
variety of insulating options. Foam is structural material and an exterior wall between the sheathing and the exterior
lightweight, easy to apply, has a high surface. skin. This material prevents moisture
R-value (which could be lost over time), infiltration. It would be a helpful to the
and can be reusable. Unfortunately, most building during the humid months of the
foam products are petroleum-based and monsoon season.
toxic when burned. The environmental
cost of foam is very high.
81
17 20
21 23
Foil insulation is a reflective vapor barrier Fiberglass is currently used in as a low- Glass is a valuable commodity in the
with insulating capacities. Like the other tech skylight material. Alternatively, more Khumbu valley, due to the level of effort
synthetic products, it is lightweight and insulating materials may be available and care required for transport. Its use
easily applied. (such as brand-name Kalwall) for similar is limited to exterior windows.
skylight applications.
22
24 26 28
Nylon, a high-technology fabric, can Alternatives to natural down fill are Old newspaper is a valuable fuel, as
both act as a waterproof barrier but allow available through synthetic fibers. Clima opposed to the commonly used yak
breathability. A possible partnership with Shield, a North Face product, resists dung, but burns quickly and is not readily
North Face could make larger quantities moisture retention, promotes wicking, available in the area. It may also be
of this material available and practical in and contains heat better than traditional used as a form of insulation, but is highly
a building construction application. down fill. Down is rated on a warmth to flammable.
weight ratio (900 fill down = 1 oz. that
expands to fill 900 cubic inches; 900 fill
is exclusive to North Face.)
83
25 27 29
30 32 34
Discarded oxygen bottles can be found Fly ash is a by-product of burning coal. It is Climbing rope loses its level of safety for
throughout the region from climbers. most commonly used to replace Portland climbing purposes after a short period of
The bottles can be filled with water or Cement in concrete, but can be used as use. It is in abundance in the area.
air and used as a thermal mass to collect structural fill, embankment material, and
and dissipate solar radiation. However, as a soil stabilization agent.
this process downcycles the technology.
31 33 35
to this site. These include ease of transportation, availability, life span, cost, etc. Ease of transportation + +
Structural Integrity + + + + + -
These site-specific criteria essentially ruled out conventional methods of foundation Mostly on-site material1 + + - +
construction involving reinforced concrete footings with stem or retaining walls. The In-country availability + - - + +
systems we found to be viable options are summarized below. Ease of construction - +
Insulation + NA - + -
Life Span + + + -
“Please note, following these summaries are two tables: First, we have outlined the Cost + - + +
feasibility of the various systems for different element in the foundation. Second, we
graded the different systems based on a preliminary set of evaluation criteria important
to the project. We have not made a final recommendation at this time as our teams will ( +) = Excellent performance in this category compared to the alternatives
jointly need to address the relative importance of each evaluation criterion.”1 ( ) = Average performance in this category compared to the alternatives
“Rammed earth within corrugated steel sheets utilizes highly-compacted soil walls as “Helical anchors are pre-engineered, galvanized steel shafts designed to be driven
the main load bearing elements. These walls could be constructed using only native in to the earth in much the same way a screw is driven into wood. They typically
soils from the building site, or small amounts of typical Portland cement could be mixed consist of a 1 1/2” or 1 3/4” square shaft with multiple helical plates (3/16” thick
in to provide increased strength and durability. The corrugated steel sheets would and 6” to 14” in diameter) welded to the lead section (see Appendix B for available
be placed on either side and initially act as the formwork during construction. After combinations)…. The sections will typically arrive at the site in prefabricated pieces
construction, the steel sheets would remain in place and provide protection from the 3’ to 10’ in length and several extension pieces will be added together to achieve the
elements as well as act as the wall’s reinforcement in much the same way rebar acts necessary embedment. For porter evaluation purposes, a 3-foot long section of the
in a concrete wall. Wall thicknesses vary depending on loading and construction, but smallest pier weights thirty pounds….
typically will be 1/8 to 1/10 of the wall height.…
“Advantages to this system:
“Advantages to this system: • Predicable results
• Majority of materials already on site • Installation equipment can reach limited access areas
• Other materials are easily sourced in-country and are fairly transportable • No excavation necessary
• Good geometric stability • Provides extremely high uplift capacities
• Long history of use in the region”4 • System is effective in cohesive and non-cohesive soils”9
5 6 10 87
7 8 11 12
“Gabions are large wire cages filled with cobbles and large gravel. They are typically 3’W “Geogrid and other types of geosynthetic frabrics are semi-rigid plastic meshes used
x 3’H x 6’L, (though other sizes are available). The cages are most often assembled to strengthen fill materials in earthwork projects. They are commonly used as the
on site and filled with native used as elements of retaining walls or to prevent erosion, reinforcing elements in mechanically stabilized earth (MSE) walls. This type of wall
but could also be successfully used as footings or foundation walls…. utilizes its own weight and friction to retain soil and is also capable of carrying significant
axial loads and absorbing large differential settlements without distress….
“Advantages to this system:
• Light weight transportation “Advantages to this system:
• Compliments current construction methods • Ability to easily retain
• Variety of uses (footings, foundation walls, retaining walls) • High ductility (seismic
• Wire cage provides backing for wall finish materials”13 • Lightweight reinforcing
• Use of native soils
• Easy to construct”16
14 17
15 18 19
1
Interacting with Extreme Environs V2
GRAVITY LOAD
STACKED STONE BUILT-UP WOOD SECTIONS
SYSTEMS
The next structural consideration deals Stacked stone walls with timber beams
with gravity loads and ensuring that are the existing gravity load systems
the building enclosure will stand. The in the Khumbu Region. It is likely that
amount of weight that the roof and floors stacked stone walls will be incorporated
need to hold is considered. Limitations into at least part of the design.
of available materials, material
transportation, and skill capacities of the
Sherpa builders have also been taken
into account.
GENERAL ASSUMPTIONS20
Loading:
Roof Dead Load = 15 psf
Roof Live Load = 20 psf
Roof Snow Load = 60 psf
Roof Wind Load = 15 psf
Floor Dead Load = 15 psf
Floor Live Load = 50 psf 89
22 23
91
24 25
26 27
31
93
29 32 33
35
36 38
34 37 39
42 43
40
44 45
95
41 46
*Note: These photo titles are from “Technical Memorandum III.”48 *5 “Preliminary Formwork for Main Frame”54
*1 “Example of Wood formwork with Bamboo Strips Applied”49 *6 “Main Frame Bamboo Poles”55
*2 “Completed Bamboo Panel”50 *7 “Bamboo Slats with Infill”56
*3 “Assembling Panels to Form Exterior Walls”51 *8 “Finished Product”57
*4 “Completed House with Plaster Finish”52
INTERIOR BAMBOO BEARING WALLS INTERIOR BAMBOO BEARING WALLS
“The International Network of Bamboo and Ratan (INBAR) have currently been “Bamboo poles are used for main wall frame of the bearing wall. Then bamboo slats
working on an eco-housing project in the western Tarai region of Nepal. The housing (laths) are nailed on either side of the bamboo poles leaving a hollow inside. The hollow
project consists of constructing prefabricated panels which are assembled together to space is then filled with cement mortar or packed mud or even rammed earth.”53
become the exterior walls of the homes. The panels consist of wood formwork with
pressure treated bamboo strips which are woven and nailed to the formwork. After the
house is assembled the panels are covered with cement mortar to provide continuity
between panels and a sealed finish. Using this construction concept could be very
valuable for an interior bearing wall application for the Khumbu Climbing School.”47
*1 *3 *5 *7
*2 *4 *6 *8
99
SCHEME A:
SOD
This scheme optimizes thermal The open organization of the building
performance through its orientation and allows for the reconfiguration of
the idea of using the earth as insulation. certain programmatic elements and
It reflects the Phortse Archetype through demonstrates parametric design and LIVING
SHOWER
MAGIC YETI LIBRARY
ROOM
REST-
similar construction and materials, as well efficiency of space.
as with an elongated shape and roof line. DN FIREPLACE
The modified L configuration creates
BOULDERING
an exterior gathering space along the
climbing wall. GATHERING
LIVIN
GW
DN
ALL
embedded into the earth to decrease LEVEL 2 ALL
GW
ININ
heat loss, while the south facade is TRA
oriented to expose maximum surface
area to the sun. A sod roof traps warmth
in the primary gathering space and
allows the building to look traditional
from viewpoints above the village.
ROOM
ROOM
REST-
REST-
STORAGE KITCHEN
UP FIREPLACE
BOULDERING
GATHERING
GATHERING
LIVIN
GW
ALL
L
WAL
G
ININ
LEVEL 1
UP TRA
3/64” = 1’-0”
B C
A
C
VIEW A VIEW B
H E R I TA G E P L A N E A HERITAGE PLANE B
H E R I TA G E P L A N E C
LIVING WALL
GATHERING
LIVING
KITCHEN
RESTROOMS
KITCHEN
RESTROOMS/SHOWERS
COMPOSTING SYSTEM
SOLAR APERTURES
ROOF CATCHMENT AREA: 1460
REFLECTED SOLAR RADIATION
(2) 250 GALLON CISTERN
ROOFTOP AIR COLLECTOR DRAINAGE
FILTER
MUROCAUST WALL ASSEMBLY
GRAY WATER
TRANSPIRED COLLECTOR
POTABLE WATER
COMPRESSED TROMBE WALL/ TRANSPARENT INSULATION ASSUMPTIONS:
GALLONS PER CAPITA PER DAY: 4.3
BLACK WATER
DIRECT GAIN THERMAL MASS POPULATION OF BUILDING: 65
USAGE: 1570 GAL
EARTH BERM INSULATION COMPOSTING SYSTEM NET H20: 434 GAL 105
FIREP
afternoon sun angles of the region. The RE
S
RO T-
structure rests in the site utilizing the OM
L
ACE
earth’s insulating properties on its north SH
OW
ER LIVING
side. The warmer southern side is ideal DN
DN
Program organization is based around
TR
the climbing walls which sculpt the AIN
ING
DN
UP LL
G WA KITCHEN
DERIN
FIREP
BOUL
RE
S
L
RO T-
ACE
OM
N GATHERING
RE
S
RO T-
OM EQUIPMENT ROOM/
STORAGE
UP
UP
TR
AIN
ING
WA
LL
LEVEL 1
3/64” = 1’-0”
B C
B
C
A
D
VIEW A VIEW B
GATHERING
LIVING
KITCHEN
RESTROOMS/SHOWERS
RESTROOMS
KITCHEN
COMPOSTING SYSTEM
SOLAR APERTURES
ROOF CATCHMENT AREA: 1530 SQ FT DRAINAGE
FIREP
and open to the south. CLASSROOM
L
ACE
The design takes into account and MAGIC YETI LIBRARY ALL LIVING
ING W
emphasizes the existing window rhythms TRAIN
of Phortse. A winding central stair
organizes the spaces surrounding it into
LEVEL 2
separate terraces and the training wall
pronounces the entry.
KITCHEN
FIREP
UP
DN
L
L
WAL
ACE
N GATHERING
MEETING ROOM
ING
ALL DN
ING W
TRAIN
R
LDE
BOU
UP
LEVEL 1
3/64” = 1’-0”
B C
B C
A
D
VIEW A VIEW B
CLIMBING WALL
ALL / FIREPLACE
GATHERING
LIVING
KITCHEN
ESTROOM
SHOWER & RESTROOM
RESTROOMS/SHOWER
KITCHEN
COMPOSTING SYSTEM
DRAINAGE
SOLAR APERTURES
ROOF CATCHMENT AREA: 1530 SQ FT
REFLECTED SOLAR RADIATION
(2) 250 GALLON CISTERN
ROOFTOP AIR COLLECTOR
FILTER
MUROCAUST WALL ASSEMBLY
GRAY WATER
TRANSPIRED COLLECTOR
POTABLE WATER
COMPRESSED TROMBE WALL/ TRANSPARENT INSULATION
BLACK WATER ASSUMPTIONS:
DIRECT GAIN THERMAL MASS GALLONS PER CAPITA PER DAY: 4.3
POPULATION OF BUILDING: 65
COMPOSTING SYSTEM USAGE: 1570 GAL
EARTH BERM INSULATION NET H20: 434 GAL
117
FIR
relationship between movement through
E
PL
AC
a building and movement on a mountain.
E
Switchbacks in the form of short stair sets
UP
bring the user from space to space which
are arranged as a series of terraces.
MAGIC YETI LIBRARY
DN
106’
The building splits open to allow the
landscape inside and creates a gathering
space to celebrate the climbing wall. TR
RO ST-
AIN
OM
GI
RE
NG
RO ST-
OM
WA
R
RE
E
LL
OW
KITCHEN
SH
100’
DN
FIR
E
PL
GATHERING
AC
E
100’
UP
LEVEL 2
DN
EQUIPMENT ROOM/
STORAGE
TR 95’
AIN
IN
G
WA
BOUL
LL
DERIN
GATHERING
G WA
95’
LEVEL 1
LL
3/64” = 1’-0”
B C
VIEW A VIEW B
GATHERING
LIVING
KITCHEN
KTICHEN
RESTROOMS/SHOWERS
COMPOSTING SYSTEM
SOLAR APERTURES
ROOF CATCHMENT AREA: 1200 SQ FT
Conclusion
Reflections
The Next Step
125
This phase of the design/build studio for the Khumbu Climbing School has
accomplished the following:
127
If someone had told me a year ago that during 2008 I would have the opportunity
not only to travel to Nepal and trek through the Himalays, but also help design a
building for the people of the Khumbu Region, I would have thought they were joking.
Realistically how often is it that a student, even a graduate student, gets to help design
real architecture, let alone architecture for another culture and country?
But here I am at the end of a semester and the end of another phase of the design/
build studio for the Khumbu Climbing School. Some have commented to me on how
great it must be to be a part of such an undertaking. Others have asked what I have
learn working on such a project. Many just want to know what it’s like to be involved
in something so big and so far away.
To the first group I must confess that this project is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity
for any architect. For a student, the possibility of such an opportunity is entirely out
of reach. To be a part of such a rare project is overwhelming at best. To be so young
(24) and so inexperienced (1st-year graduate student) and still be allowed to work
on such an important project (that will help save Sherpa lives and strengthen Sherpa
culture) is an honor and a privilege.
To the second group I have to say that it would take another book to explain all that
I have learned as a member of this studio. Aside from the obvious of experiencing
a vastly different culture and learning how to design a building in a remote region of
the planet, there have been many things that I have learned about the design process
that I will carry with me through my professional career. Yet I think the most important
thing I have learned is how to work with a team of people for a common cause. Not
that I couldn’t do this before, but that the breadth of this experience has added depth 129
to my understanding that the design and construction of architecture is a community
process. Just as no man is an island, no design is created in a vacuum, and a strong
designer ultimately becomes the pen and the paper that the building occupants use to
create the spaces that they will inhabit.
So what is it like to be involved with something so big and so far away? AWESOME! It
truly is one of those things that you don’t quite understand or appreciate until you have
been involved yourself. And it is an experience that has empowered me to not only
continue to pursue architecture as a profession, but it has convinced me that it is only
ourselves that stands in the way of participating in meaningful projects in life.
The photograph to the left shows lodge owners Lhakpa Sherpa and Panuru Sherpa
with the local Lama and others at a breaking ground ceremony on the site of the new
Khumbu Climbing School facilities. Although the design has not yet been agreed upon
by the villagers and the Alex Lowe Charitable Foundation, this even had to happen
during the 2008 calendar year in order to initiate a successful construction process.
As devout Buddhists, the Sherpa follow a calendar that connects their six elements—
fire, air, water, earth, wood, and metal—with the passage of time. Every two calendar
years is represented by a different element. The year of this writing, 2008, is an earth
year, an auspicious year to begin construction, according to Buddhist tradition. Next
year (2009) will inaugurate the first of two fire years, a poor time to begin building.
Now that construction has begun with the blessing of the Lama, it may continue
through the fire years.
All of these steps will take place in subsequent semesters with some original
students and collaborators continuing on with the project, joined by new students
and collaborators. During the Spring 2009 semester, students will modify the design 131
based on the responses of the Sherpas, and explore wall and roof assemblies, material
performance, and overall building performance. Once this is done, construction
documents can be created and material purchase and transportation can be finalized.
Ultimately several students will travel once again to Phortse to assist in overseeing and
helping with the construction process.
1
These pages are intended to supplement the information presented in the main portion
of this document. Also included are model photos, a bibliography, and an endnotes
section.
Photosynth
Studio Models
Site Model
Notes
Bibliography
133
1
PHOTOSYNTH
3D REPRESENTATION VIEW STUDIES
135
Appendix
KHUMBU VALLEY
MODEL
Appendix
NOTES 9
10
Heather Archer, Site and Context, maps and photos of Phortse, Interacting
with Extreme Environs, (Bozeman: MSU, 2008) page 4.
Heather Archer, Site and Context, maps and photos of Phortse, Interacting
with Extreme Environs, (Bozeman: MSU, 2008) page 4.
11 C. J. Carter, 121 Nash Creek LN, Bozeman, MT 59715, 406.600.3807,
1 The Endless Knot DVD, Alex Lowe Charitable Foundation, 15 Dec. 2008, Phortse, Nepal, 2008.
http://www.alexlowe.org/store_kcs_endless.shtml. 12 Nepal, map, Google Earth 4.3.7284.3916 (beta), 8 Jul. 2008.
2 “MSU’s Mission -- Bozeman Campus,” Mar 2002, Montana State University,
16 Dec 2008, http://www.montana.edu/opa/policy/MissionBozeman.html.
3 T. R. Ried, “The Sherpas,” National Geographic May 2003: 42-71. CULTURAL IDENTITY
Bertolani, L. Tartari, G. Toyotsu, K. Ueno, K. Stepwise Onset of Monsoon Weather Huge-NC-Stacked. TJ Imports. 15 Dec. 2008. www.tjimports.com.au/images/
Observed in the Nepal Himalaya. Monthly Weather Review. Vol. 136. 2008. huge-nc-stacked.jpg.
Brower, Barbara. Sherpa of Khumbu: People, Livestock, and Landscape. (USA: “Khumbu Climbing School Mission Statement.” Alex Lowe Charitable Foundation. 30
Oxford University Press,1993). Nov. 2008. www.alexlowe.org/kcs.shtml.
Brown, G.Z. Sun, Wind, and Light: Architectural Design Strategies. (Hoboken, New Kolarevic, Branko. Malkawi, Ali. Performative Architecture: Beyond Instrumentality.
Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, 1985). (New York: Spon Press, 2005).
Cabini, E. Tartari, G. Verza, G.P. Vuillermoz, E. Summary Report 1994-2006. Lowe-Anker, Jennifer. Forget Me Not: A Memoir. (Seattle: Mountaineers Books,
(Khumbu Valley, Nepal: Pyramid Meteorological Network, 2008). 2008).
“Climbing Wall Holds – Intermediate.” Robbins Sports. 16 Dec. 2008. www. MacDonald, John W. Hay Bales. 22 Jul. 2007. Flickr. 14 Dec. 2008. http://flickr.
robbinssports.com/sporting-goods-store/climbing-wall-holds-intermediate-pi- com/photos/johnwmacdonald/871339358/.
2852.html.
Marcello Villegas. New Bamboo Architecture and Design. Bogata, Colombia. Villegas
Coburn, Broughton. Nepali Aama. (New York: Anchor Books, 1995). Asociados. 2003.
Cooney. Giles. Kujawa. Larrson. “Technical Memorandum I, II, & III.” (Bozeman: “MSU’s Mission -- Bozeman Campus.” Mar 2002. Montana State University. 16 Dec
MSU, 2008). 2008. www.montana.edu/opa/policy/MissionBozeman.
Costin, Bryan. Rebar. 9 Sept 2007. Flickr. 14 Dec. 2008. www.flickr.com/photos/ Nepal. Map. Google Earth 4.3.7284.3916 (beta). 8 Jul. 2008.
bcostin/1353072365/.
“Program Overview.” 13 Sep. 2007. MSU School of Architecture. 16 Dec. 2008.
Delanda, Manuel. A New Philosophy of Society: Assemblage Theory and Social www.arch.montana.edu/programoverview.
Complexity. (London & New York: Continuum, 2006).
Rita Sherpa, Ang. Subba, Sara. Sacred Sites of the Khumbu Region. (Katmandu:
The Mountain Institute, 2005).
Rutherford, Christine Louise. How They Clean Their Paintbrushes at the End of Each
Day P1070080. 2 Jul. 2007. Flickr. 13 Dec. 2008. http://www.flickr.com/
photos/christinelouise/page7/.
Sinclair, Cameron. Stohr, Kate. Design Like You Give a Damn. (Los Angeles:
Metropolis Books, 2006).
Straw Bale House. 2006. Solar Haven. 14 Dec. 2008. http://ww w.solarhaven.
org/NewStrawbale.htm.
The Endless Knot DVD. Alex Lowe Charitable Foundation. 15 Dec. 2008. www.
alexlowe.org/store_kcs_endless.shtml.
Tönges, Christoph. Interior View. Construction with Bamboo. 14 Dec. 2008. www- 143
users.rwth-aachen.de/Christoph.Toenges/pagesEN/bauwerke.
Woodhouse, Paul. 304 Stainless Steel Sheet Metal. 19 Feb. 2007. The Tin Basher.
15 Dec. 2008. www.butlersheetmetal.com/tinbasherblog/wp-content/
uploads/2007/02/304_stainless_steel_sheet1.jpg.