Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THE STATES
An Annual Report by Truth in Accounting
September 2018
Financial State of the States
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 2
Table of Contents
Executive Summary 4
Summary of Findings 8
Recommendations 25
Methodology 26
Appendices 128-133
www.statedatalab.org
page 3
Executive Summary
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 4
Introduction and Background
www.statedatalab.org
page 5
50 State Ranking (in order)
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 6
50 State Ranking (alphabetical)
www.statedatalab.org
page 7
Summary of Findings
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 8
Sunshine and Sinkhole States
TIA ranks each state by its Taxpayer Burden or Taxpayer Surplus. A Taxpayer
Burden is the amount of money each taxpayer would have to contribute if the
state were to pay all of its debt. Conversely, a Taxpayer Surplus is the amount
of money left over after all of a state’s bills are paid, divided by the estimated
number of taxpayers in the state. We split the states into two groups. States
that lack the necessary funds to pay their bills are called Sinkhole States, while
those that do have enough money are referred to as Sunshine States.
Alaska $56,500
North Dakota $24,900
Wyoming $19,600
Utah $4,400
Massachusetts -$33,500
Kentucky -$39,200
Illinois -$50,800
Connecticut -$53,400
www.statedatalab.org
page 9
Top 5 Sunshine States
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 10
Top 5 Sunshine States
www.statedatalab.org
page 11
Top 5 Sinkhole States
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 12
Top 5 Sinkhole States
www.statedatalab.org
page 13
50 State Ranking Chart
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 14
50 State Ranking Chart
www.statedatalab.org
page 15
Grading the States
Truth in Accounting’s grading system for the 50 states gives greater meaning to each
state’s Taxpayer Burden or Taxpayer Surplus. A state government receives a “C,” or
passing grade, if it comes close to meeting its balanced budget requirement, which
is reflected by a small Taxpayer Burden. An “A” or “B” grade is given to governments
that have met their balanced budget requirements and have a Taxpayer Surplus. “D”
and “F” grades apply to governments that have not balanced their budgets and have
significant Taxpayer Burdens. Based on our grading system, here are the numbers of
states for each grade:
A (6%)
B (14%)
D (36%)
F (20%)
C (24%)
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 16
Does Your State Balance Its Budget?
www.statedatalab.org
page 17
Does Your State Balance Its Budget?
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 18
How Timely is Your State Financial Report?
www.statedatalab.org
page 19
Timely State Reports
States that issued their financial reports within the GFOA’s 180-day deadline are
considered timely. This table gives the number of days it took a state to publish
its annual report after the end of the fiscal year. Here are the states that reported
their financials on time.
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 20
Tardy State Reports
Here are the states that did not publish their financial reports within the 180-day
deadline.
* Alabama’s comptroller had not made the annual report public as of Aug. 1, 2018.
** The New Mexico Department of Finance & Administration did not make the CAFR publicly available on its website until Aug. 3, 2018.
www.statedatalab.org
page 21
OPEB Reporting Rule Takes Effect in FY 2018
A new financial reporting rule taking effect for the 2018 fiscal year will
require states to report all unfunded other post-employment benefits
(OPEB), particularly retiree health care liabilities, on their balance sheet.
In FY 2017, total unfunded OPEB liabilities among the 50 states was $663.1
billion, though two-thirds of that, or $439.5 billion, was not reported on the
balance sheet. We refer to this as “hidden debt.”
The following chart shows states with the largest difference in reported vs.
total unfunded retiree health care promises, or hidden debt.
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 22
Why Truthful, Transparent and Timely
Financial Information is Important
www.statedatalab.org
page 23
Why Truthful, Transparent and Timely
Financial Information is Important
more accurate and realistic budget for concept that a balance sheet should
the following year. However, because be a snapshot of an entity’s financial
financial reports are not timely, they condition at a specific point in time.
cannot be used to assist the budgeting
process. Furthermore, these budgets The other issue caused by GASB 68
do not include all costs—they exclude is the expanded use of confusing and
large portions of compensation costs misleading accounts called “deferred
because money is not set aside to cover outflows” and “deferred inflows.”
retirement benefits as they are earned. These accounts distort states’ net
positions and expenses. For example,
While the implementation of the instead of recognizing the full loss in
Governmental Accounting Standards the value of its pension plan assets as
Board (GASB) Statement No. 68 an expense during the year in which
required state governments to report the loss occurred, a state increases its
their pension liabilities on their deferred outflows, which is on the asset
balance sheets, the amount being side of the balance sheet. TIA found
reported is still inaccurate because that the use of deferred outflows and
GASB gave states the option to report inflows inflated states’ net positions by
the liability using the prior year’s $193 billion.
numbers. For example, if the state’s
fiscal year end is June 30, 2017, the Most states continue not to report the
state could report the pension liability full cost of retiree health care debt
amount calculated on June 30, 2016. in their budgets and balance sheets.
Next year with the implementation of
GASB allows states to report their GASB Statement No. 75, state and local
pension liability using a different governments will be required to report
measurement date, but this practice these liabilities.
goes against the basic accounting
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 24
Recommendations
www.statedatalab.org
page 25
Methodology
TIA researchers use a thorough and taxpayer would have to pay to leave
holistic approach to determine the the state free of excessive debt. We
condition of government finances. calculate this number by subtracting
This approach compares bills— “total bills” from “assets available
including those related to retirement to pay bills,” and then take the
systems, and excluding debt related to resulting number, or “money needed
capital assets such as land, buildings, to pay bills,” and divide it by the
and infrastructure—to government estimated number of taxpayers with
assets available to pay these bills. We a positive federal income tax liability.
exclude capital assets because these Conversely, a Taxpayer Surplus is each
should not be sold to pay bills. taxpayer’s share of the state’s available
assets after all bills have been paid.
Historically, state and local
governments were not required to We also use a grading system
record the present value of their to provide a summary measure
obligations for public employee supplementing the bottom-line dollar
retirement benefits, including amount reported in our Taxpayer
pensions and retiree healthcare, as Burden calculation. Our letter grades
liabilities on their balance sheet. TIA also provide a valuable alternative
digs into the underlying reports for to the widely reported letter grades
hundreds of pension and related plans issued by credit rating agencies. We
to find these liabilities, and then puts believe government officials and the
that information on our own version media have become too reliant on
of what constitutes a valid balance credit ratings. These ratings focus on
sheet. the needs of bondholders and reflect a
government’s ability to pay bonds with
TIA ranks each state by its Taxpayer little consideration of other sources of
Burden or Taxpayer Surplus. The government debt, such as unfunded
Taxpayer Burden is the amount each pension liabilities.
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 26
State Reports
www.statedatalab.org
page 27
Page 28
Page 29
Page 30
Page 31
Page 32
Page 33
Page 34
Page 35
Page 36
Page 37
Page 38
Page 39
Page 40
Page 41
Page 42
Page 43
Page 44
Page 45
Page 46
Page 47
Page 48
Page 49
Page 50
Page 51
Page 52
Page 53
Page 54
Page 55
Page 56
Page 57
Page 58
Page 59
Page 60
Page 61
Page 62
Page 63
Page 64
Page 65
Page 66
Page 67
Page 68
Page 69
Page 70
Page 71
Page 72
Page 73
Page 74
Page 75
Page 76
Page 77
Page 78
Page 79
Page 80
Page 81
Page 82
Page 83
Page 84
Page 85
Page 86
Page 87
Page 88
Page 89
Page 90
Page 91
Page 92
Page 93
Page 94
Page 95
Page 96
Page 97
Page 98
Page 99
Page 100
Page 101
Page 102
Page 103
Page 104
Page 105
Page 106
Page 107
Page 108
Page 109
Page 110
Page 111
Page 112
Page 113
Page 114
Page 115
Page 116
Page 117
Page 118
Page 119
Page 120
Page 121
Page 122
Page 123
Page 124
Page 125
Page 126
Page 127
Appendix I: Financial State of the States Schedule
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 128
Appendix I: Financial State of the States Schedule
www.statedatalab.org
page 129
Appendix II: Schedule of Accumulated Bills
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 130
Appendix II: Schedule of Accumulated Bills
www.statedatalab.org
page 131
Appendix III: Retirement Liabilities
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 132
Appendix III: Retirement Liabilities
www.statedatalab.org
page 133
Notes
www.truthinaccounting.org
page 134
Notes
www.statedatalab.org
page 135
Page 136