Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Answer: ...there is a legal difference between the husband and wife’s right
to sex: the husband can demand sex, and the wife is obliged to agree unless
there is a genuine physical or Shariah preventative. Even if she disagrees,
he has the legal right to insist that she comply.3
Modernity/Modernities, Modernism
Sufism as Anti-modern
In the modern period and particularly in the 20th Century, Sufism has
often received a negative evaluation in the Muslim world. This anti-Sufi
critique often mounts accusations that Sufism was authoritarian and feudal,
and that it encouraged withdrawal from practical life thereby inculcating
passivity. This world-denying tendency of Sufis, in turn, is criticized as
having left Muslim societies susceptible to conquest by colonial powers. In
addition, there is a more specific Islamic purist critique of Sufism, stretching
5
Having dealt with some of the modern critics of Sufism, I will now
characterize some of the more influential intellectual responses to Sufism by
Muslim intellectuals over the past century. This brief overview will establish
broad categories of how the conjunction of Sufism and modernity is variously
framed by the following types of thinkers or movements.
1) Islamic Modernism
2) Post-Tariqa Sufi Movements
3) Traditionalism/Perennialism
4) Progressive Muslims--“engaged Sufism”
5) New Age/eclectic Sufi movements
1) Islamic Modernism
the Second Millennium (Mujaddid Alf-i Thani) also inspired a number of 20th
century modernists.
The Modernist movement pioneered the reform and adaptation of
Islamic law in new nation states as well as the formation of modern
educational institutions and revised curricula on Western models. It agitated
for political liberalization or decolonization, and was central in establishing
mass circulation print media throughout the Islamic world. The Modernist
Islamic movement went into eclipse during the 1930s-1970s, being largely
supplanted, on the one hand, by purely secular projects (primarily
nationalism and socialism) and on the other hand, by revivalist and Islamist
religious projects.
In fact there are several types of Islamic Modernism with distinct links
or approaches to Sufi thought. Among them I will mention intellectual
rationalism and romantic idealist modernism.
a) Intellectual rationalism
by imitation of the Prophet.12 This attitude then initiated among Sufi scholars
a concomitant focus on study of the prophetic sayings (hadith) and reformist
attitudes to Sufi popular practices, at least among modernizing urban elites.
We may find here a hint of the “decline of Sufism” thesis, together with an
explanation of some roots of Sufi reform movements of the pre-modern
period. In response to the “neo-Sufism” hypothesis, numerous scholars have
disputed whether these elements of Sufi theory are in fact “new.” 13 Still,
parallels to modernization theory suggest that Sufism, through such
developments, was preparing to adjust to a new modern self-consciousness.
While eschewing folk and popular practices of Sufi, intellectual Muslim
modernists/liberals have tended to appreciate mystical poetry and other
aspects of Sufi influence on traditional Muslim cultures, acknowledging the
role of the Sufi tradition in that heritage.
In the verses above we find Iqbal expressing the following modern values
through Sufi associations:
2) Post-tariqa Sufism
10
3) Traditionalism
b) Fiqh-sation
Internet sites such as “Sunni path” offer commentary and advice in this
vein. Other sites feature op-ed type articles on Islamic and current events
topics authored by public intellectual convert Sufis such as Tim (Abd al-
Hakim) Winter and Nuh Ha Mim Keller, in addition to a younger cohort
including the Canadian, Faraz Rabbani, whom I cited as the outset of this
article.19 In this expression of Sufism there is an impulse to recover a
comprehensive paradigm of traditional Islamic scholarship and comportment
that I term, the “imagined madrasa”. This is the form of Sufism that most
resonates with the diaspora youth who populate Muslim student associations
and attend periodic seminars known as “Deen (religion) intensives”.
Since the legitimacy of legal discourse (fiqh) is unassailable, this
version of “modern” Sufism is able to cross over into venues such as Muslim
Student Associations and in the United States, the Islamic Society of North
America (ISNA). Previously such organizations had been dominated by
Islamist tendencies and generally were not welcoming to Sufism. However,
this strand of Sufism can present itself under rubrics drawn from the Qur’an
itself such as “tazkiyya al-nafs” (purification of the soul) and “ihsan”
(righteousness).20
Both perennialist traditionalism and “fiqh”sation movements find their
roots in Islamic Sufism, while rejecting secular modernity and the
desacralization of the world. At the same time each embraces modern
technologies, and even the discourse and realms of Western academia.
These trends in “modern” Sufism tend to be favored by cultural and
economic elites while they remain conservative on social issues such as
gender relations. At the same time these Sufi movements are fairly liberal in
accommodating to living in the pluralistic West and definitely take a stand
against violence and terrorism on legal and moral grounds.
In the 20th century, some Sufi teachers traveled to the West and
Islamic mystical practices spread in various forms to Europe and America.
Alongside more recent attempts merge Sufism with strict compliance to
ritual law and exclusive Islamic identity, earlier trends in Western Sufism
seemed rather to favor eclectic and New Age forms that incorporated inter-
religious practice. Prominent examples of such groups are the Sufi Order of
the West inaugurated by the Indian Sufi, Inayat Khan (d. 1927) and carried
on by his descendants, and the Society for Sufi Studies, promoted by the
literary figure, Idries Shah (d. 1997). These movements are arguably small
although they have a wider outreach to non-Muslim audiences due to
publications and cultural activities.22
Since such eclectic Sufi movements, in which conversion to Islam is not
essential, generally address a Western audience, the emphasis is on
15
Conclusions
In history, Islam showed itself to be culturally friendly and in that regard, has been
likened to a crystal clear river. Its waters (Islam) are pure, sweet and life-giving but –
having no color of their own – reflect the bedrock (indigenous culture) over which
they flow. In China, Islam looked Chinese; in Mali, it looked African. 27
By extension in America, Islam will look American. Note that the image
for Islam in this case is that of a pure, life-giving stream of water that is
flowing and flexible. Dr. Abd-Allah goes on to use Qur’anic citations to back
up this vision. For example he cites the verse: “Accept (from people) what
comes naturally (for them). Command what is customarily (good).” (Qur’an
7:199).
Drawing on classical Islamic jurists, Abd-Allah also cite legal maxims
such as, “cultural usage shall have the weight of law” propounded by
scholars such as the Maliki scholar, al-Qarifi (d. 1285). The gist of this
argument is that Islamic legal judgments and, by extension, Muslim
behavioral norms, must take into account the diverse cultural realities
wherever Muslims live.
This model bears an interesting contrast with an alternative metaphor
for Islam in relation to culture that I discovered in what I would term a
conservative or Islamist position paper that also claimed to address the
theme of a “cultural imperative”. This article was authored by scholars
associated with the International Institute of Islamic Thought in Virginia.
Their analysis, in contrast to Abd Allah’s, calls for “a critical and objective
reassessment of the Muslim cultural and intellectual heritage of the past to
sift out the wheat from the chaff.”28 This version of a cultural imperative
offers what I call the “sieve metaphor” of the role of Islam. Among certain
Islamist inspired thinkers we observe hostility to culture and an attempt to
“correct” or “sift” it.
The objective of this second cultural imperative is stated as being the
development of “a valid methodology that will enable the reconstruction of
the modern Muslim mind along lines that will ensure the recovery of its
18
Marcia Hermansen
Loyola University Chicago
United States
1
Rabbani, Faraz, http://qa.sunnipath.com/issue_view.asp?HD=11&ID=1830&CATE=117. Reply originally published May
25, 2003.
2
www.muslimwakeup.com Muslim Wake Up is no longer an active site but is at present (2008) archived.
3
http://qa.sunnipath.com/issue_view.asp?HD=11&ID=1830&CATE=117. Published July 3, 2005. Accessed 11/10/07. The
source for the idea that she must comply at all times with her husband’s desire for sex comes not from the Qur’an but from a
number of hadith such as “If a man calls his wife to bed and she refuses, and then he sleeps angry, the angels shall curse her
until he awakens.” Rabbani cites this example in his original ruling.
4
http://www.muslimwakeup.com/main/archives/2006/02/consent-what-co.php Accessed Sept. 8. 2008.
5
This reply on the personal blog can no longer be viewed.
6
That is, contemporary Perennialist and Traditionalist Sufis feel that Islamic modernists, as well as fundamentalists, are the
most negative influences within the Muslim community. See for example, Seyyed Hossein Nasr, The Garden of the Truth,
New York: Harper, 2007), 154-6.
7
As argued in numerous cases studies in Martin van Bruinessen and Julia Day Howell (eds.) , Sufism and the ‘Modern’ in
Islam (London: I. B. Taurus, 2007).
8
Charles Taylor, “Two Theories of Modernity” in Alternative Modernities ed. Dilip Parameshwar Gaonkar (Durham, NC:
Duke, 2001), 172 ff.
9
Fritz Meier, Zwei Abhandlungen iiber die Naqshbandiyya (Istanbul: Franz Steiner, 1994),
10
A. J. Arberry, Sufism (London: Allen and Unwin, 1950), 122.
11
On the Murabitun see Marcia Hermansen, “The ‘other’ Shadhilis of the West” in The Shadhiliyya, ed. Eric Geoffroy, (Paris:
Maisonneuve et Larose, 2005), 481-499.
12
Fazlur Rahman, Islam, (New York: Anchor Books, 1966), 193-6. 205-6.
13
R. S. O’Fahey and Bernd Radtke, “Neo-Sufism Reconsidered” in Der Islam 70, 1 (1993): 52-87.
14
This refers to an incident in which Shaykh Ahmad Sirhindi refused to follow the court custom of doing a prostration
before the emperor, Jehangir. For this he was imprisoned but later pardoned.
15
Kulliyat Iqbal (Pakistan: Ghulam Muhammad, 1973), 304. This poem is translated into English in Poems from Iqbal by
V. G. Kiernan (Bombay: Kutub, 1947), 52.
16
Hakan Yavuz and John L. Esposito, Turkish Islam and the Secular State: The Gulen Movement (Syracuse, NY: Syracuse
University Press, 2003).
17
This is also observed by Yoginder Sikand, “The Tablighi Jama’at in Mewat, India” in Martin van Bruinessen and Julia
Day Howell (eds.) Sufism and the ‘Modern’ in Islam (I. B. Taurus: London, 2007), 147. I compare Said Nursi and Maulana
Ilyas, founder of the Tablighi Jama’at in “Said Nursi and Maulana Ilyas: Examples of Pietistic Spirituality among 20 th
Century Islamic Movements” Islam and Christian Muslim Relations, 19 (1, 2008): 73-88.
18
Mark Sedgwick, Against the Modern World: Traditionalism and the Secret Intellectual History of the Twentieth Century
(Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004).
19
Websites featuring this sort of thought are http://www.masud.co.uk/, http://www.deen-intensive.com/,
http://www.thetraditionalpath.com/.
20
In fact, the hadith of Jibra’il, where the Prophet describes the succession of “Islam, Iman, and Ihsan” is often cited by
traditionalists as the basis of Sufism.
21
Engaged Sufism Special Issue of the Journal for Islamic Studies (South Africa) 26, 2006.
22
For a more detailed discussion of these movement see my article "Hybrid Identity Formations in Muslim America: The
Case of American Sufi Movements" Muslim World Spring 2000 (90 #1&2): 158-197.
23
Adonis, Sufism and Surrealism (London: Saqi, 2005) or Ian Almond, Sufism and Deconstruction : A Comparative Study
of Derrida and Ibn 'Arabi (London: Routledge, 2004).
24
Cheryl Bernard, "Civil Democratic Islam: Partners, Resources, Strategies," Rand Corporation, 2004.
http://www.rand.org/pubs/monograph_reports/MR1716/MR1716.pdf
25
Mahmood Mamdani, Good Muslim Bad Muslim: America, the Cold War, and the Roots of Terror (NewYork: Pantheon,
2004).
26
Another farming of this idea discusses the intersection of global and local factors. For a review of some of the theorists
see John Voll, “Contemporary Sufism and Social Theory” in van Bruinessen and Howell (eds.) Sufism and the ‘Modern’,
293.
27
Umar Faruq Abd-Allah, “The Cultural Imperative” www.nawawi.org/downloads/artical3.pdf
28
Mona Abu al-Fadl http://www.muslimwomenstudies.com/cultural_imperative.htm Viewed March 12, 2006
29
Ibid.