Professional Documents
Culture Documents
As you read your novel, take notes on it using the questions and format presented below. The
general idea is that you are locating and responding to passages (or drawings) in the novel that
seem to deal with Arnold’s sense of identity, his sense of who he is and how he fits into his
community and the larger world, and how he maintains hope in the face of adversity (or
problems). You should copy down passages from your novel and then write about how these
passages demonstrate how Arnold sees himself and his sense of identity, and how he maintains
hope or a positive attitude in the face of challenges and set-backs.
1. Reading Schedule: Due Friday, Oct. 22: Chapters 1-15 (to the end of page 113)
(“Hunger” Pains” is the name of chapter 15)
Due:Friday, Oct. 29: Chapters 16-29 (page 114-end of book)
Requirements:
“A” Level: You read and write on The Catcher in the Rye (see separate instructions)
--At least 10 passages and responses
--Responses are at least 150 words in length
--Word Count is included
--Neatly written or TYPED
--Your journals are handed in ON TIME
--Page numbers are provided for all passages quoted
Use a “Dialogue Journal” format to collect passages and your responses to them (see
DO NOT write your dialogue journal in your
below.)
composition notebook. Write it on loose-leaf
paper (or type it) that can be handed in to me.
Passages My thoughts and comments
Can you imagine what would have This happens when Arnold’s dad is driving him to
happened to me if I’d turned around and gone Reardan High School for his first day. Rowdy
back to the rez school? punched Arnold when Arnold told him that he was
going to leave the rez to go to school in town with
I would have been pummeled. Mutilated.
the white kids. Arnold knows that he can’t go back
Crucified. now because he is seen as somehow betraying his
You can’t just betray your tribe and then people by going off the rez.
change your mind ten minutes later. I was on a
one-way bridge. There was no way to turn I think it is sad that he feels like the only way he
around, even if I wanted to. will be able to achieve his dreams and overcome the
“Just remember this,” my father said. poverty and loser mentality on the rez is to go
“Those white people aren’t better than you.” against his own people. You would think that
But he was wrong. And he knew he was people would support each other when they try to
wrong. He was the loser father of a loser better their lives. But I guess if one person does
Indian son living in a world built for winners. better than those around him, that makes those
people have to take a look at themselves and see
how poor their lives are and that they COULD
change if they wanted to. I think sometimes people
Page 55 get trapped into thinking that there aren’t options
and then they get used to being victims. Arnold is
trying to change that for himself, and unfortunately
that means that he is seen as someone who is
betraying his community.