You are on page 1of 8

PART 1

Chapter 3
CONSTITUTION AND
CONSCIOUSNESS

OBJECTIVES 3.1 Prakr.ti: THE CONSTITUTION


● To understand the concept and applicability
- When the śukra (‘semen’) meets the an.d. ān.u (‘ovum’)
of the physical constitution in Ayurveda.
in the fallopian tube to form the embryo, they each
● To understand the concept and applicability
- carry with them a similar combination and dominance
of the mental constitution in Ayurveda.
of the dos. as present in the father and mother at the
● To understand the concept of mind and
- time of conception. The result of this union, as well as
consciousness from an Ayurvedic the time and season of conception, the food and habits
perspective. of the mother during gestation, and the karmic influ-
ences of the being to be born, forms the prakr. ti, or
constitutional nature of the embryo. Every person has
a prakr. ti, which can be of seven types:
● Vāta
● Pitta
● Kapha
● Vāta-kapha
● Vāta-pitta
● Pitta-kapha
● Vāta-pitta-kapha.
Because everyone is composed of all three dos. as these
constitutional types are only indicative of the predom-
inance of one, two or all three of the dos. as (called eka,
sam.sarga and sammiśra/sannipāta, respectively).
The activities of the dos. as in the prakr. ti represent the
normal activities of the body and are not necessarily
reflective of any kind of diseased state (i.e. vikr.ti).
Thus, prakr. ti does not relate to treatment inasmuch
as its knowledge assists with daily, preventative meas-
ures to optimise health. To some extent prakr. ti can
also assist in the formulation of a prognosis and in the
individualisation of a treatment regimen. In some
cases a patient will be seen to display a disease that is
identical with their prakr. ti, but not necessarily.
In a state of disease the prakr. ti can be very difficult
to identify correctly because, like an onion, the

27
-
28 PART 1: Theory and practice of Ayurveda

prakr.ti is hidden within layers of the disease sympto- that the sammiśra prakr.tis (i.e. all three dos. as in
mology. Most Āyurvedic physicians will admit that it perfect balance) is the best prakr.ti, followed by the
can be very difficult to determine one’s own or some- sam. sarga prakr.tis, and then the eka prakr.tis.
one else’s prakr.ti, and thus it is generally recom- Generally, kapha is considered to be the best prakr.ti
mended that treatment be provided on the basis that because the natural tendency towards disease is less,
the human body has only one prakr.ti, predominant and a greater resistance and strength are displayed.
in pr.thvı̄ and ap. Treatment is thus directed to the Pitta is next, with a moderate resistance to disease.
specific signs and symptoms of the vikr.ti (‘disease’), Vāta is considered to be the weakest eka prakr.ti
rather than the prakr.ti. Learned Āyurvedic physi- because it is the strongest dos. a, and thus a vāttika
cians suggest that it takes years of experience to accu- prakr.ti will display a greater tendency towards weak-
rately ascertain prakr.ti, although in certain cases, ness and disease. Sam. sarga prakr.tis indicate that
especially in eka prakr.tis, it is possible to identify it two dos. as are equally dominant, with kapha-pitta
correctly without too much effort. prakr.tis being the best in this category, followed by
Considering that dos. a means ‘blemish’, anyone who kapha-vāta and then by pitta-vāta. The final cate-
exhibits a particular dos. a or combination of the dos. as gory of prakr.ti represents an equal dominance of all
in their prakr.ti will have a tendency when in a relative three dos. as, and can be of two types. A sammiśra
state of normalcy to exhibit minor symptoms native to prakr.ti represents all three dos. as is a state of perfect
those dos. a(s). Although the prakr.ti is a kind of blue- equilibrium, whereas a sannipāta prakr.ti represents
print for our development, the influence of the dos. as a constitution in which all three dos. as are imbal-
changes as each of us ages, and as a result the prakr.ti anced. The former prakr.ti could thus be considered
may or may not be relevant to the maintenance of the best prakr.ti and the latter the worst. Very often it
health. Some practitioners feel that it is even possible to is the state of mind and spiritual development that
change or modify one’s prakr.ti, whereas others sug- determines how a tridos. aja prakr.ti will manifest: if
gest that this is impossible. The concept of prakr.ti res- pure of mind, focused and disciplined, the sammiśra
onates within jyotis. , an ancient form of Vedic sidereal prakr. ti will have few problems or obstacles to
astrology that links prakr.ti with the natal chart, or the health. If confused, distracted, and undisciplined then
position of the planets at birth. While this natal influ- the sannipāta prakr.ti will be miserable. Thus in a
ence plays a significant role upon one’s development, sannipāta prakr. ti the spiritual responsibility is
this chart is always in juxtaposition with the transit much greater, but the reward is equally great. It is a
chart, the current position of the planets relative to the calling, however, that only a few individuals will be
natal arrangement. Although insightful, the natal able to answer.
chart is not as significant in the assessment of the cur- The following are descriptions of each prakr.ti. This
rent status as is the transit chart. Corresponding with can be a somewhat speculative process as these types
the transit chart is the concept is vikr.ti, or the ‘disease and especially the dual and tri-dos. a prakr.tis are not
tendency’, which may or may not be similar to the as well defined in the ancient texts as one might wish.
prakr.ti. For example, Āyurveda recognises that an The process to determine the characteristics of each
individual with a kapha prakr.ti could have a vāttika dos. a should largely be determined by assessing and
disorder, such as anxiety. It is thus important to distin- comparing the various gun.as of the dos. as, and relat-
guish prakr.ti from the disease state, or vikr.ti. Just by ing this to observed physiological characteristics that
using treatments to balance prakr.ti the treatment of a are native to the person and do not represent patholog-
disease may not be effective. ical changes. Thus for most people the qualities of the
Within Āyurvedic circles, especially in the context prakr. ti will be clearly evident during childhood and
of the theories of rebirth and karma, there is a ten- youth, when most people are healthy, but may become
dency to rate each prakr.ti in a hierarchical fashion. obscured with age and disease.
One opinion is that the eka prakr.tis are the most
favourable (i.e. kapha, pitta, vāta), followed next by
Kapha
sam. sarga prakr.tis (i.e. kapha-pitta, kapha-vāta,
and pitta-vāta), and then sannipāta prakr.tis (i.e. Guru (‘heavy’), snigdha (‘greasy’), śita (‘cold’), mr.du
vāta-pitta-kapha). Another perspective suggests (‘soft’), sthira (‘stable’) and picchila (‘slimy’). A gen-
Constitution and consciousness 29

eral tendency to gain weight, with a heavy, sthenic easily observed due to a deficiency in the overlying
build. The shoulders are broad and the torso, legs and muscular and fat layers. Vātaja prakr.tis will usu-
arms are thick and large; in women the hips are broad ally display a strong aversion to cold, with irregular
and breasts are full. The musculature is well-developed or poor peripheral circulation. A tendency to more or
but usually hidden by a layer of fat, hiding any angu- less constant movement, often confused or peripheral
larities of the skeleton. The feet are large and thick. to the situation at hand, including twitching, tap-
Facial features are broad and full, and generally well ping, bouncing, picking and shaking. The joints often
proportioned. The skin is soft and smooth, and the hair pop and crack, and the muscles have a tendency to go
is generally smooth, thick and greasy. The orifices (eyes, into spasm. Vāta is the most sensitive of the
nose, ears, mouth, rectum, uretha, vagina) are moist prakr. tis to sensory stimuli, with poor powers of
and well-lubricated. There is a tendency to lethargy or recuperation and endurance. Digestive powers are
inactivity, although once motivated the energy released typically weak or erratic, with a general tendency to
can be very powerful, with great endurance and constipation.
a steady pace. A kapha prakr.ti might suffer from
minor congestive conditions, such as respiratory and
Sam.sarga and sannipāta prakr.tis
gastrointestinal catarrh. They may display a mild aver-
sion to cold and prefer warmer climates, but if they are Prakr. tis that are either sam. sarga (two dos. as) or
physically active they can withstand even very cold sannipāta (three dos. as) will display some of the
weather quite easily. gun.as of the involved dos. as, although because some
of these qualities are opposite in nature they may be
poorly manifested. Generally speaking one dos. a will
Pitta
tend to dominate a sannipāta or sam.sarga prakr. ti,
Us.n.a (‘hot’), tiks.n.a (‘sharp’), snigdha (‘greasy’), but the influence of the sub-dominant dos. a(s) will
laghu (‘light’), drava (‘fluid’), sara (‘movement’). affect the overall manifestation.
Strong metabolism, strong digestion, and a general Pitta-kapha prakr.tis will generally display a
tendency to mild inflammatory states. Physically, the sthenic build and a layer of fat as in kapha prakr.ti,
body is of average build, lighter than that of kapha, but there will be a tendency to a ruddier complexion
with a well-developed musculature but generally less and more physical activity that a pure kapha.
fat. The features are more angular than those of Warm, humid weather also adversely affects this
kapha, and facial features are thinner, sharper and prakr. ti.
longer. The skin is often quite ruddy and there is a gen- Vāta-kapha prakr.tis will often display a lighter
eral tendency to excessive heat. Warm temperatures build and proportionally longer limbs, or are shorter
and hot climates are poorly tolerated. A tendency to and smaller, than a pure kapha. There is generally
excessive hepatic and gastrointestinal secretions, loose more sensitivity to coldness than in any of the other
bowel movements, and more frequent urination. dos. as, and a similar tendency to mucus congestion
Generally more sensitive to sensory stimuli than and digestive weakness as kapha. As there is less overt
kapha, especially with light, heat and sound. moisture in the body any congestive problems tend to
Physically active, movements are co-ordinated, quick worsen under the influence of dryness.
and efficient, sometimes aggressive, with determina- Vāta-pitta prakr.ti is in many respects similar to
tion and purpose. vāta, but generally with a stronger and more compact
build, with somewhat larger muscles. There is a great
deal of movement associated with this prakr.ti, com-
Vāta
bining a curious combination of determination and
Laghu (‘light’), śita (‘cold’), rūks. a (‘dry’), cala confusion. There is a general sensitivity to sensory
(‘movement’), viśada (‘friction’), khara (‘rough’), stimuli such as light, heat, sound and dryness.
sūks. ma (‘subtle’). A general tendency to being Digestive secretions tend to be concentrated and
underweight and asthenic, with dry rough skin, intense, but are often irregular.
small wiry muscles and irregular proportions. The The sannipāta prakr.ti is the most difficult to
bony prominences of the skeleton and the veins are ascertain due to the expression of contradictory
-
30 PART 1: Theory and practice of Ayurveda

qualities present in all three dos. as. A sannipāta wet weather. Dreams tend to be kinesthetic, joyful, and
prakr. ti may be reactive to any change in diet, peaceful, and are associated with objects such as
lifestyle or the environment, especially extreme water, snow, the moon and flowers.
changes. The result of this reactivity is minor condi-
tions that change or alternate in nature, which have
Pitta manas
a greater tendency to manifest as vikr.ti (‘disease’).
Generally speaking, a sannipāta prakr.ti will tend Laghu (‘light’), us. n.a (‘hot’), snigdha (‘greasy’),
to display signs of a vāta-pitta or vāta-kapha tiks.n.a (‘sharp’), sara (‘moving’) and drava (‘fluid’).
prakr.ti. Thus, the approach taken to balance the Generally charismatic, ambitious, courageous and
dos. as will be directed to vāta first, and then pitta extroverted. Usually passionate, dynamic and some-
or kapha. times argumentative, a tendency to impatience and
irritability, and in some cases can be aggressive or vio-
lent. Enjoys spicy foods, loud debates and is strongly
3.2 Manas prakr.ti: THE interested in the opposite sex. Often insightful and per-
CONSTITUTIONAL INFLUENCE ceptive, with a fluid, subtle intelligence that can pro-
UPON MIND vide clarity. Good critical thinking skills but
a tendency to negative criticism and judgment. Self-
Apart from the symptoms that relate to physiology and disciplined and focused, sometimes obsessed, egotisti-
disease, each prakr.ti also influences mental and emo- cal or proud. Generally sceptical and rational-minded.
tional characteristics. In most cases the features of the Speaks from theoretical knowledge, technique, logic
manas prakr. ti are congruent with the physical or law. Dreams tend to be highly visual, vivid and
prakr.ti, but sometimes they are not. In some cases the emotional, sometimes with anger and violence, and
manas prakr.ti represents an evolutionary change in are associated with objects such as the sun, fire and
the psychosomatic consciousness of a person, such as blood.
a person who has a vātaja prakr.ti developing a more
kaphaja mind, or vice versa. Over time the body will
Vāta manas
progressively express these mental qualities in a physi-
cal way, although inherent characteristics of the Laghu (‘light’), śita (‘cold’), rūks.a (‘dry’), cala (‘mov-
prakr.ti may never be lost completely. To determine ing’), viśada (‘friction), khara (‘rough’) and sūks.ma
the nature of the various manas prakr.tis, each type (‘subtle’). Quick thinkers and quick learners, fond of the-
is identified according to the gun.as associated with ory and philosophy, sometimes with a poor memory or
each dos. a or combination of dos. as. concentration. Generally enthusiastic at the outset of an
enterprise, but have difficulty sustaining or following
through. Often jumps to conclusions too quickly, or has
Kapha manas
unrealistic expectations. Ungrounded and irrational,
Guru (‘heavy’), śita (‘cold’), snigdha (‘greasy’), sometimes paranoid and delusional. Pestering, obsessed,
sthira (‘stable’), mr.du (‘soft’) and picchila (‘slimy’). talkative, spiteful, angry and unreasonable. More affected
A general tendency to mental lethargy and difficulty by extra-sensory phenomena than the other dos.as, and
with abstract thinking. Minor difficulties in trying to has difficulty relating to a commonly held reality.
follow conversations, especially when people are talk- Generally more psychic and more creative than the other
ing quickly. Generally easy-going and happy, good prakr.tis. Often speaks from fantasy or from extrasensory
memory, they do not like to ‘stir things up’. Benevolent, experiences. May suffer from poor self-esteem, insecurity
generous, and mothering, but with a tendency to and loneliness and faithlessness. Generally fearful and
become attached to people, places and things. Some anxious, and often appears distracted and confused.
difficulty controlling cravings to foods or pleasurable Unconventional, controversial, sometimes distorted or
experiences, but not to the point of injury or harm. even perverted. Dreams tend to be highly auditory or
Kinesthetically orientated, speaks from physical, prac- visual, with feelings of despair and loneliness, and are
tical experiences. Grounded, earthy wisdom. A ten- associated with objects such as the wind and sky, and
dency to despondency, even depression, in cold, cloudy, activities such as flying or moving quickly.
Constitution and consciousness 31

Sam. sarga and sannipāta manas 3.3 Trigun.a manas: THE QUALITIES
prakr.tis OF THE MIND
A pitta-kapha manas prakr.ti will generally display
similar properties to a kapha manas prakr.ti, but is In Chapter 2 the basic components of the Sāṅkhya
more dynamic, passionate and ambitious. Although darśana were introduced, and specifically, the arising of
there is a tendency to be fairly conservative at the out- the trigun.as of sattva, rajas and tamas. To recall this
set, once properly motivated and enthused a pitta- teaching, sattva is the principle of harmony, purity and
kapha manas prakr.ti can be an instrument for light, rajas is the quality of conflict, movement and
significant social change. Quite often these are the colour, and tamas is the quality of cohesion, stasis and
most superficial and materially focused of the manas darkness. Collectively, the trigun.as are the qualities
prakr.tis, and as a result they are often quite success- that represent all phenomena.
ful but may lack any kind of spiritual perspective. The Although we can apply tridos. a to the mind and
highly sensual nature of pitta-kapha may cause this emotions, it is difficult to anticipate the wide variety of
type to be mildly addicted to various substances and potential behaviours within each manas prakr.ti
activities, and have difficulty seeing the point in giving from this alone. Āyurveda deepens this approach by
them up. ascertaining which of the trigun.as guide the con-
Vāta-kapha manas prakr.tis will generally dis- sciousness of a particular manas prakr.ti. Thus we
play a strong sensitivity to other people, and are gen- can use the trigun.a theory to describe more or less
erally humble, considerate, shy and compassionate. spiritually evolved forms of each prakr.ti.
They are often quite creative, highly imaginative and When we speak of the mind and emotions, how-
artistic, and are strongly inspired by the natural world. ever, it is important to make the distinction between
They tend to lack motivation and drive, however, and gun.a and dos. a. In fact there is only one gun.a of the
because they tend to have poor self-esteem, are nega- mind and it is sattva. Rajas and tamas exist as dos. as
tively affected by criticism. Vāta-kapha manas of the mind that become vitiated and cloud the equi-
prakr.tis tend to be something of a chameleon, and librium and clarity of our true sattvic nature. Thus
often have difficulty making a stand or confronting the pure mind that is directed to self-realisation is
somebody on an important issue. In many cases this sattvic in nature, and the thoughts and emotions that
type will end up feeling unfulfilled in life, despite their swirl through it and disrupt this quest are rajasic and
inherent creativity. tamasic. Spiritual evolution is the process by which
Vāta-pitta manas prakr.tis are a volatile mix of we develop our sattvic or buddha nature, moving
vāyu and tejas, and thus this prakr.ti often suffers closer to the purity and absolute brilliance of the One.
from mental volatility, sometimes expressing exces- Thus, when we assess the mental state of a patient, for
sive confidence, even arrogance, but when criticised example, we are also trying to understand these ele-
falls back into patterns of self-doubt and confusion. ments of spiritual evolution.
They are quite often highly reactive, explosive, and
argumentative and often require a great deal of
Sattva
patience on the part of others. There are quite often
brilliant thinkers, highly intelligent and very cre- Sattvic individuals respond well to spiritual, vibra-
ative, and if they can find a loving and maternal tional or subtle therapies in the treatment of physical
environment in which to work, can be highly effec- and psychological complaints. Techniques include self-
tive and very successful. inquiry, prayer, rituals, meditation, breathing exer-
The sannipāta prakr.ti is a combination of all cises, mantra, minerals and gems.
three dos. as, and thus the range of mental and emo-
tional behaviours can vary to a great degree.
Rajas
Generally they will tend to display signs of a vāta-
pitta or vāta-kapha prakr.ti. Thus, the approach Rajasic individuals respond well to natural, but more
taken to balance the dos. as will be directed to vāta overt healing therapies such as self-discipline, dietary
first, and then pitta and kapha. changes, nutritional supplementation, physical
-
32 PART 1: Theory and practice of Ayurveda

manipulation, music and colour therapies, and herbal angry, selfish, self-aggrandising, reflective only
and homeopathic treatment. after acting
2. Sarpa (‘snake-like’): harsh, rough, angry,
courageous, critical, capable, fickle, deceitful,
Tamas
causes dissension
Tamasic individuals display a poor compliance with 3. Śākuna (‘bird-like’): greedy, intolerant, restless,
holistic therapies, dietary or lifestyle recommendations, fearful
and have difficulty understanding the body other than 4. Rāks. asa (‘impish’): prejudiced, angry, fearsome,
how it functions as a kind of machine. More often than irritable, jealous, critical, paranoid, lazy
not, such individuals will turn to more invasive thera- 5. Pais.āca (‘fiendish’): glutinous, rude, undisciplined,
pies such as pharmaceuticals and surgery for treatment. obsessed with sex, unclean, adventurous
6. Preta (‘ghostly’): greedy, uncooperative, lazy,
In addition to the trigun. a model the Suśruta unhappy, unfulfilled, weak.
sam. hitā describes another model that breaks down
the trigun.as into 16 archetypes. The first seven arche-
Tamasic archetypes
types relate to sattva, the second six are rajasic, and
the last three relate to tamas. Each archetype within a 1. Paśu (‘beast-like’): rude, boorish, weak intellect,
sattvic, rajasic or tamasic group is also arranged in a secretive, obsessed with sex, uncooperative
hierarchical fashion, the first being the most sattvic 2. Mātsya (‘fish-like’): fearful, restless, foolish,
and the last being the most tamasic. obsessed with food, quarrelsome, idiotic
3. Vanaspati (‘plant-like’): sedentary, oblivious,
unconscious, removed from the pursuit of
Sattvic archetypes
dharma, artha and kama.
1. Brahmā (‘supreme deity’): pious, honest, com-
passionate, wise, charitable, hospitable, free of
desire, hatred and ignorance, speaks from the 3.4 Manas: THE MIND
heart, excellent memory
2. Māhendra (‘king of the gods’): courageous, ready There was a great deal of speculation in the philosoph-
for action, charismatic, beneficent, protector of ical teachings of ancient India as to the nature of the
dharma, artha and kama, servant of the Earth mind. There was a profound understanding that the
3. Varun. a (‘god of the waters’): courageous, mind and all that it embodies has an ethereal quality.
capable, desires/achieves cleanliness, love of We are apparently born with a mind and develop an
water, easily pleased but easily angered identity with it, and carry it with us until it is lost upon
4. Kaubera (‘god of wealth’): charitable, tolerant, death. But what is mind? How is it defined? Can you
prosperous, enjoys comfort, surrounded by family point to it? How can you define, by any means, what the
and friends, intense anger and joy mind is, when the mind itself is involved in the expla-
5. Gāndharva (‘celestial being’): artistic, musical, nation? ‘I think, therefore I am’, wrote Descartes, but
studious, enjoyment of fragrances and costume, the Vedic sages might have asked: ‘you think, but what
pleasure-seeking is thought?’ Inquiring into the nature of mind and its
6. Yāmya (‘god of death’): determined, efficient, origination has been the preoccupation of Indian phi-
impartial, fearless, free of passion, firm losophy for millennia.
7. R.s. i (‘sage’): free of desire, meditative, disciplined, Where is your mind? Is it contained within the brain
celibate, philosophical, habitually engaging in as modern science tells us? You watch a child playing in
penance and fasting. the playground, you see a bird sitting in a tree. Where is
your mind? Is it in your head? Is it in your eyes? Or is your
mind with the child, with the bird?
Rajasic archetypes
To understand your mind requires that you study it.
1. Asura (‘demonic’): misguided, courageous, At this moment please focus on your mind, finding that
wealthy, unrestrained, jealous, charismatic, part of you that is thinking and chase it down. Take
Constitution and consciousness 33

hold of it and look it squarely in the eye. Where is it? It Measurement is an act of division, of separating the
disappeared! Where did it go? But like a flash it is back, whole into a system of units. As Zeno illustrated in his
thinking about how you couldn’t find it. paradox, there are an infinite number of points, both in
To understand the mind requires that we witness it. time and space, that need to be crossed during the race.
Let go of your mind, see it as a river flowing in front of Although the crowd sees the runner finish the race,
you. See how it moves, how the rapids and eddies they do not perceive the infinite nature of time and
swirl, how the river carries all kinds of debris in its space that has been crossed. Thus the observation of
waters, flowing past you endlessly. This is called sāks.i the runner finishing the race is not the complete experi-
bhavana in the Vedic tradition, ‘bearing witness’ to ence, but a mental construct based upon incomplete
the mind, and is a form of meditation. data. This illustrates how our experience, or that which
According to science, a thought is said to result we interpret as being reality, is in fact only a small part
from a pattern of stimulation generated by many of what is actually happening.
parts of the nervous system, determined and coloured
by the limbic system, thalamus and reticular activat-
ing system as being pleasurable or painful, and given 3.5 Citta: CONSCIOUSNESS
discrete characteristics by the cerebral cortex.
A thought is a singular event in nervous function, The underlying aspect of consciousness in Āyurvedic
a combined activity of the various aspects of the brain, thought is called the citta, the total potential field of
integrating and analysing sensory information from conditioned consciousness. It is the repository of all
all parts of the body into one definable ‘eureka’ of aspects of conditioned existence, and records these
nervous function. Consciousness is one thought con- influences upon itself. It includes the presence of sub-
nected to another to form a continuous stream of liminal activators called sam.skāras, the psychic
thoughts. As David Frawley describes in his book imprints that underlie our mental and emotional
Ayurveda and the Mind: The Healing of Consciousness, traits, derived from our experience over many life-
however, when brought under the lens of meditation, times. These psychic imprints propel consciousness
consciousness is like a pointillist painting, each into action, regardless of whether the imprint is
thought working together to form an impression of unconscious or conscious, internal or external, desir-
experience, but not reality itself. Consciousness is like able or undesirable.
a movie, a series of snapshots flashed rapidly onto a At the heart of this concept is the idea that it is these
screen, giving us the impression of continuity, but not sam . skāras that bind us to the wheel of sam . sāra. The
the entire experience. We miss out on a great deal of chain of cause and effect that defines the existence of
information, and thus consciousness is a distortion, sam.sāra is called pratityasamutpāda ( pratitya
an incomplete knowing of the infinite nature of ‘dependent,’ samutpāda, ‘origination’), first enunci-
experience. ated by Gotama Buddha soon after he had attained
This view of consciousness is also illustrated by the nirvān.a. The Buddha indicated that these sam . skāras
writings of the Greek philosopher Zeno of Elea (c. 490 exist and are created because of avidyā, or ‘ignorance’,
BCE). In his paradox entitled The Dichotomy, Zeno that what we hold to be reality is in fact a misconception
describes a runner in a race who must travel a given dis- that ultimately leads to dukha (‘unhappiness’).
tance (d) in a given amount of time. Zeno suggests in According to the yogic tradition there are two
this paradox that before the runner can finish the race, forms of sam.skāras; namely, those that promote the
he must travel half the distance (d/2). And in order to direction of consciousness externally and generate
travel half the distance, the runner must travel one- further sam.skāras, called vyutthana (‘waking con-
quarter the distance (d/4), and so on, over an infinite sciousness’), and those that stem the flow of con-
number of points ordered in the sequence d/2, d/4, d/8, sciousness and thereby prevent the generation of
etc. Because this sequence goes on forever, it therefore further sam.skāras, called nirodha (‘conscious
appears that the runner will never finish the race. Zeno’s restriction’). Nirodha is said to be synonymous with
theory, however, is in direct contrast to the experience of the attainment of samādhi (‘perfect concentration’),
the wildly cheering crowds who perceive the runner fin- the highest limb of as. t.āñga yoga, an absorptive state
ishing the race. So who is right? in which subject and object become one.
-
34 PART 1: Theory and practice of Ayurveda

Schematically, the yogic tradition indicates that the its focus to the nature of perceiving, to the nature of
citta consists of the aham.kāra, the manas and the becoming. As the yogic text the Goraks. a-paddhati
buddhi. The aham.kāra is for the most part consid- states:
ered synonymous with the Western concept of the ego,
‘Knowing that whatever he hears, be it pleasant
or that part of consciousness that retains a sense of
or unpleasant, it is Self, and the yogi
individuality, that responds to perceptions, feelings and
withdraws.’
thoughts and thereby initiates a variety of activities.
‘Knowing that whatever scent he smells with his
According to the Āyurvedic perspective the
nose, it is Self, and the yogi withdraws.’
aham.kāra is the process of self-identification, an
‘Knowing that whatever he sees with the eyes, be
inner ‘becoming’ that associates and builds up a con-
it pure or impure, it is Self, and the yogi
sciousness of itself from external relationships. This
withdraws.’
aham.kāra is said to arise because of a failure of our
‘Knowing that whatever he senses with his skin,
innate intelligence (buddhi), whose correct orienta-
tangible or intangible, it is Self, and the yogi
tion directs us to our true Self, that we are Brahman.
withdraws.’
When the buddhi fails to perceive this it will mistake
‘Knowing that whatever he tastes with the
the body for the Self, and the limits of human sensory
tongue, be it salty or not, it is Self, and the
perception (and scientific instrumentation) for the
yogi withdraws.’
whole of reality. The buddhi then becomes a tool of
(Feurstein 1997)
the aham.kāra, which uses this intelligence to ratio-
nalise its existence, creating a mental illusion of real-
The purification of the manas, however, can also
ity. This tool is the manas, or ‘lower’ mind, which
involve other methods, perhaps less radical than com-
concerns itself with the organisation of information
plete pratyāhāra. Among these are the practice
received from the five senses. For this reason manas is
yama (‘morality’) and niyama (‘self discipline’), and
often referred to as the ‘sixth’ sense, and with the five
the three components of the traditional Indian ideal of
senses ( jñāna indriyās) forms the sixfold base
the caturvarga: dharma (‘duty’), artha (‘wealth’),
(āyatana) described in the Buddhist concept called
kama (‘pleasure’).9 Although these practices do not
pratityasamutpāda (‘dependent origination’).
uproot the influence of the manas they create an
According to the schemata of pratityasamutpāda,
inner equilibrium within the mind that allows for con-
the sixfold base undergoes ‘contact’ (sparśa) with cor-
centration and mental clarity.
poreal phenomena (i.e. the tanmatras and pancabu--
Unlike manas, the buddhi is pure awareness, or
thas). This, in turn, gives rise to ‘sensory impressions’
that which directly perceives. When directed by the
(vedanā), ‘desire’ (tr. s.n.ā), ‘attachment’ (upādāna),
aham.kāra the buddhi is really involved only in sen-
and then finally, ‘becoming’ (bhava). According to the
sory perception, which results in manas. When the
Buddha this process of becoming (i.e. the aham.kāra)
buddhi has been purified from these limits, however, it
provides the impetus for birth, which ultimately results
is able to perceive directly the true nature of reality and
in ageing, disease and death ( jarāmarana), and thus
becomes freed from the cloud of avidyā, or ignorance,
dukha (‘unhappiness’).
generated by the aham.kāra. Hence, those who have
If anything, the manas can be said to be driven by
attained this degree of perception are called buddha,
the senses, and can experience an endless number of
an ‘awakened one’.
mental formations as a result, all of which ultimately
lead back to the same cycle of desire, attachment and
becoming. In the yogic tradition the most direct
ENDNOTE
method to uproot the activities of the manas is called
pratyāhāra, the fifth limb of as.t.āñga yoga. 9 The fourth component of the caturvarga is moks. a (‘liberation’).
Pratyāhāra involves the withdrawal of the senses and
the redirection of consciousness internally. The mind
withdraws from the sensuous experience and redirects

You might also like