Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
This paper examines seasonal affective disorder (SAD) through the lens of biological and
cultural anthropology, using several cultures to determine variation within the illness. Seasonal
affective disorder is a sub-category of depression in which the patient experiences oversleeping,
overeating, drastic mood changes, weight gain, carbohydrate cravings and more in response to a
change in climate, temperature, and/or amount of light. SAD has been part of the psychology
field since the 1980s, but it could have existed in human biology for much longer. Evolutionary
adaptations and genetics are taken into consideration when evaluating the origins of the illness.
Outside of biological and psychological perspectives, SAD is considered to be an evolutionary
response to cold weather, in which a person would hibernate (as other animals do) in order to
preserve energy, protect oneself from the elements and predators, and to improve chances of
reproduction and survival. Culture shapes SAD through the use of societal messages and social
expectations, and the way psychology projects its knowledge onto the public. It is also shaped by
the way each individual culture perceives mental illness. Cultural anthropology argues against
modern psychology, being in favor of evolutionary and sociocultural theories rather than
biomedical ones.
1
Samantha Osani
INTRODUCTION
affliction in the world of Western medicine, though it presents itself in a number of ways.
depression, in which the patient becomes depressed during colder, darker seasons. It can
also happen during the summer, though the frequency of those cases is significantly
environment, hours of sunlight during the day, and decreased levels of important
hormones. But our knowledge of SAD is influenced by “Western assumptions about the
mind and body” (Tsai 2002), and is therefore limited. Depression and other similar
Ethan Watters’ book Crazy Like Us details the infiltration of Western mental
illnesses across cultures, showing that the culture of countries such as Japan and China
did not have prior concepts of these illnesses (Watters 2010). Western medicine has
neglected to acknowledge the fact that each culture defines their perception of mental
illnesses, and that this influences the diseases themselves. This book largely influenced
mental illness is something this paper intends to question. Through the use of research, I
set out to determine whether or not SAD is influenced by culture, just as depression and
2
Samantha Osani
other mental illnesses are. Are sufferers of SAD responding in an evolutionary way, or
could they also be merely influenced by social messages and cultural ideals? Would SAD
different cultures interpret ideas in different ways. Based on this concept, a cross-cultural
comparison of SAD should reveal the answers. Across various locales, this paper presents
affective disorder affects millions of people globally, and while biological factors remain
annually at the same time each year” (Rosenthal 1984). The twenty-nine patients featured
carbohydrate craving” in response to changes related to climate and altitude. Nearly thirty
years later, this is still the general definition of SAD: symptoms of depression incurred by
lower temperatures and often, higher altitude. This study conducted by Rosenthal
concluded that artificial light was shown to improve the depression of approximately a
third of the patients; this research paved the way for further light testing on SAD patients.
The idea of winter depression has been around longer than the term itself.
Although Rosenthal conducted the light therapy study in 1984, an earlier study conducted
in 1981 followed the winter depression of eleven patients. All of who exhibited classic
3
Samantha Osani
relationship strains (Asher 1982). These studies and symptoms pose an interesting
hypothesis: if a person can succumb to these ailments simply due to colder weather and
fewer hours of exposure to sunlight per day, then has SAD existed for thousands of
years? It would make sense for one to assume that humans who have long thrived in cold,
dark climates could fall victim to winter depression, but the situation is much more than it
affective disorder. The condition first appeared in the DSM-III, released in the late
are four diagnostic criteria in the DSM for SAD: a relationship between mood changes at
a particular time of year (i.e. fall or winter), changes from hypomania in summer to
depression in winter, remissions of SAD in at least the past two years, and SAD episodes
Typical symptoms listed in the DSM include overeating, oversleeping, weight gain,
carbohydrate craving and irritable mood in response to the time of year. Light treatment
is referenced, but the DSM also states that the majority of SAD patients are women. This
fact encourages the theory that SAD, along with other depressive states, could potentially
be an evolutionary response.
There are many controversies surrounding not only depression but also the whole
caused by reduced intake of light by the hypothalamus, the part of the brain that regulates
4
Samantha Osani
mood, sleep, and appetite. When a person is suffering from SAD, they experience a
drastic change in all of these categories. A lack of light delivered to the eyes – and
disruption in circadian rhythm (Sohn 2005). For animals, melatonin is the “mediating
hormone between light and seasonal behavior” (Sohn 2005), and this causes scientists to
believe the same applies to humans. Much like animals, humans adapt to their
“Our brains evolved under ‘field conditions’ of long daily sunlight exposure,
subject to rhythmic lengthening and shortening by seasons. Now, however, most of our
days are unnaturally dark and our nights are unnaturally light. We have lost our strongest
connection with the daily rhythm of nature” (Norden 1995). This quote from Michael J.
Norden’s book Beyond Prozac perfectly encapsulates the majority of theories relating
evolution to seasonal affective disorder. Our sedentary, workaholic lifestyle has only
been part of human history for roughly a century, not nearly enough time for our bodies
In terms of basic human biology, dreading cold weather and long, dark nights
from the elements and predators. As previously stated, the DSM estimates 60-90% of
SAD patients to be women. Only in the last century, approximately, have we as a species
attempted to label every commotion our bodies project outwards, mental illness and
physical ailment alike. Perhaps depression is the result of millions of years of evolution.
Many researchers studying SAD seem to think so. The symptoms of SAD include
5
Samantha Osani
Professionals have compared these symptoms to ancient seasonal lifestyle patterns and
concluded that the symptoms align with characteristics of those lifestyles. Caroline Davis
conserve energy in colder seasons when resources are scarce, and also to enhance
survival through the winter, that species is going to consume high amounts of
carbohydrates, reduce their physical activity, and retreat to a place they can sleep for long
periods of time. Seasonal affective disorder may indeed be a leftover trait given to us by
our ancestors to protect us from the elements and ensure the continuation of our species.
The issue with this gift, however, is that it does not align with our current modern
lifestyles, and we have not been enveloped by those modern lifestyles long enough to
Another problem is that of society. While our ancestors and other species
hibernate without trouble, the human race has evolved to the point of individualism. That
is to say, a human will find a problem within themselves and label it unique and worthy
of attention and treatment, instead of acknowledging the problem as part of the human
condition. Seasonal affective disorder is an excellent example; a person may find him or
herself suffering from winter blues, and seek the help of doctors and medication. This is
due to the rise of psychology in the Western world. Psychology conveys messages to the
6
Samantha Osani
public based on their professional opinion, and that opinion is interpreted by society as
fact. Commercials will tell people that, if they are suffering from symptoms A-Z, they
certainly need this medication, whereas anthropological research will tell that person
those symptoms are normal to the human species and they simply need to incorporate a
light box and more physical activity into their daily routines. We are a society of instant
gratification, and if we can pop a pill to cure our problems, we will surely do so before
In addition to evolution, location may also have a key role concerning SAD.
Much of the research seems to agree that regions of higher latitudes such as Scandinavia,
Alaska and Iceland have higher frequencies of SAD patients (Jackson-Triche 2002).
Lower altitudes also have higher rates of seasonal depression. Knowing that SAD could
cold weather, it is understandable that regions of higher latitude with cold, dark periods
are where many SAD patients are identified as living. The following section will compare
people of various locations and their cultures to show variation within the illness.
As with many other mental disorders, SAD was first defined by American
psychologists three decades ago. SAD, along with those other disorders, slowly made
their way as an export to other countries and cultures. In Crazy Like Us, Ethan Watters
describes how depression made its way over to Japan in the last few decades; Japan did
not have a concept of depression prior to Western psychiatry introducing itself to the
culture. Having depression is seen as a sign of weakness in the Japanese culture, so many
people are reluctant to say they are depressed. While the Japanese version of depression
7
Samantha Osani
opportunity to profit off of the millions of people inhabiting Japan. They sent
their anti-depressants.
The majority of Japanese people surely did not need anti-depressants, nor did they
worked their black magic to make a spot for themselves in the Japanese market through
the use of their integrated spies and target-specific advertisement. The idea that Western
concepts of mental illness can drastically alter many aspects of a culture posed a serious
question for this research; apart from biological factors, could culture have something to
do with SAD?
The United States exemplifies Western medicine, therefore it would make sense
that up to ten percent of the population suffers from seasonal affective disorder. This
means that millions of people in the United States suffer from SAD every year, in
addition to the people suffering from major depressive disorder. Compared to the vastly
lower percent of populations suffering from SAD in other Western cultures including the
U.K., Canada, and Australia, the United States seems to be more susceptible to SAD than
others (Holistic 2013). What is causing this discrepancy? The answer lies in Ethan
Watters’ book Crazy Like Us. His theory that we are exporting mental illness rings true
on both sides. We formulated all types of mental illnesses before exporting them to other
cultures, thus we are exposed to them first. This gives our population a longer time to be
8
Samantha Osani
are a forward-thinking culture, we assume we can find a logical solution for everything
we experience; thus the invention of modern psychiatry. As a culture, we absorb the fact
that a pill can probably ease any type of pain. We receive these messages in the media
every day, through television commercials, radio and newspaper advertisements, movies,
and so many more. Because of these messages, people tend to say “I’m depressed” more
than “I feel sad”, and to many doctors, that is deserving of a diagnosis and medication
(Theiss 2012). It is possible that many diagnoses of depression stem from people
absorbing messages conveyed to them, subconsciously, through the media. For cultures
lacking the concept of depression, they express their feelings through visible sadness and
somatization (Kleinman 1991). Now that Western ideas have begun to infiltrate other
regions, those messages may be a driving force behind SAD in other cultures as well as
our own.
regarding every aspect of depression in Japan. Although this book does not explicitly
mention seasonal affective disorder, comparisons and inferences can be made due to the
relatively unheard of until the last two decades. There exists a form of depression in
Japan that is more common than clinical depression: karoshi. Karoshi is overwork
depression, which often leads to suicide. With the introduction of modern psychiatry,
depression went from a “rare” disease to something tangible and treatable (Kitanaka
2012). Kitanaka also argues that depression in Japan is “reshaping cultural debates about
9
Samantha Osani
how society should deal with individual subjects of social distress”: this relates to Ethan
Depression from a psychiatric standpoint is fairly new to Japan; therefore the lack of data
on SAD across the population is a reflection of that. The most recent research conducted
regarding SAD in Japan dates to 2003, and compares factors including climate, latitude,
and socio-cultural elements as influencing SAD among adults and high school students in
Japan. Of roughly ten thousand Japanese people tested, two percent met the criteria for
SAD. The study concluded that SAD was more common in high school students than in
adults, stating that socio-cultural factors were more of a driving force for them than in
adults, who seemed to respond more to latitude and climate (Imai 2003). These results
reveal something very important: Western concepts of mental illness are clearly seeping
into the minds of the younger generations and being validated, while adults report typical
cultural versus biological elements when studying seasonal affective disorder and the
In other colder climates such as Canada, the research varies. An indigenous Inuit
community in the Canadian Arctic was studied for SAD and it was determined that, while
twenty-five percent of them were depressed, very few of them matched the diagnostic
criteria for SAD (Haggarty). For descendants of Icelandic emigrants to Canada, the
frequency of SAD was extremely low compared to other parts of the population
adaptation against SAD. The prevalence of SAD in Canada is roughly two to three
percent of the total population: comparing this to the ten percent of the United States, and
10
Samantha Osani
the fact that Canada is closer to the north pole (latitude hypothesis), we can assume that
Australia lies within a temperate zone that is usually void of SAD patients, it is curious
that roughly two percent of the population suffers from it. Of all the modernized, Western
countries, Australia has the lowest rate of SAD (Murray 2004). The low percentage of
Australians suffering from SAD could be a reflection of the latitude and climate
hypothesis: if generations of Australians or indigenous folk have lived in the climate long
enough, they would not need SAD to combat the elements of winter. However, many
Australians are emigrants from Europe, unlike their aboriginal neighbors. A few hundred
years of generations could not eradicate the genetic necessity for SAD altogether, though
it may have made it easier to evolve under temperate conditions. The small percentage of
SAD patients in Australia potentially reveals how many of those European emigrant
TREATMENT
The majority of SAD patients around the world do not realize that SAD is a
normal feature to the human existence, and will subsequently seek treatment. Because the
exact cause of seasonal affective disorder remains a mystery, there are various forms of
treatment available to patients. These range from the biomedical to the psychoanalytic,
and are generally specific to a theorized cause. For example, many doctors will
cold, dark climates. Three treatments for seasonal affective disorder include light therapy,
11
Samantha Osani
One theory on the causes of SAD states that the illness presents itself when
normal levels of daylight are unavailable. This causes the hypothalamus to malfunction,
and symptoms such as overeating or oversleeping appear. The treatment provided based
on this theory is light treatment. The benefits of light have been known since the ancient
Greeks, with solariums being popular in the early twentieth century for medical problems
ranging from psychiatric to general medical issues. By the time modern medication
became readily available in the later part of the twentieth century, however, the benefits
of light treatment were considered obsolete (Norden 1995). Now, light treatment is
that seasonal depression arises when “the number of daylight hours decreases… the
pattern of release of brain chemicals has been altered” (Jackson-Triche 2002). The book
further states that light therapy consists of a patient sitting near a light box, which has
treatment has been known to show significant improvement in patients. Whether or not it
functions as a placebo is unknown, but the results are drastic with no known side effects.
It is thought that light therapy delivers small amounts of Vitamin D to the body and
encourages both serotonin and melatonin production, both of which are limited in
availability for the human body during colder, darker periods (Norden 1995).
While light therapy is the recommended form of treatment for SAD patients, the
success rate is roughly fifty percent and tends to be combined with antidepressants. SAD
12
Samantha Osani
serotonin uptake inhibitor (SSRI). Escitalopram, fluoxetine, and citalopram all have been
proven clinically to reduce the symptoms of SAD in combination with light therapy. All
medications were shown to have a higher success rate by at least twenty percent over
disorder. But, as with all mental disorders, psychoanalytic treatment can further assist the
use of biomedical treatment. SAD has the potential to be cognitively and behaviorally
based, and researchers have discovered the positive influence that cognitive behavioral
therapy can have on patients. CBT is a very effective method for treating many forms of
diet and active lifestyle, having a strict bedtime routine to offset hypersomnia, and most
importantly, CBT aims to alter the thought process of the patient. According to the very
first CBT-SAD research study ever published, CBT was proven to help long-term
symptoms among patients (Rohan 2004). Additionally, CBT poses no negative side
CONCLUSIONS
Seasonal affective disorder may be thousands of years older than we think. Before
the content of this paper was researched and compiled, biological theories held their place
at the top of the causes. It is evident now that SAD is the result of so many more
elements. Biology states that SAD is caused by a reduced intake of light to the
13
Samantha Osani
rhythm, appetite, mood, and hormone production. Evolutionary theories describe SAD as
a vestigial trait, programmed into our DNA to help us ensure reproduction and survival
through winter against predators and the elements. The latitude hypothesis describes the
correlation between the high frequency of SAD patients and high latitudes, i.e. locations
closer to the poles where there are shorter, darker days, and colder climates.
Culture also plays a role influencing SAD, with each culture having various
perceptions of mental illness and depression, and each culture conveying those
perceptions in the media. The United States views mental illness as a chemical imbalance
in the brain, while the Japanese view it as a sickness of the soul or heart. These cultural
differences explain why the United States has the highest frequency of SAD patients
anywhere in the world. We have been exposed to mental illness and medication for such
a long time that our society has nearly become desensitized to it; it has become normal
for us to be diagnosed and medicated. Because of this, it is more important now than ever
for research related to evolution and culture to reach the minds of the public. Seasonal
affective disorder is so much more than a chemical imbalance in the brain: it is the
14
Samantha Osani
Sources
Imai, Makoto. Kayukawa, Yuhei. Ohta, Tatsuro. Li, Lan. Nakagawa, Takeo. Cross-
regional survey of seasonal affective disorders in adults and high-school students
in Japan. 2003. Journal of Affective Disorders.
Kitanaka, Junko. Depression in Japan: Psychiatric Cures for a Society in Distress. 2012.
Princeton University Press. Princeton, New Jersey.
15
Samantha Osani
JqLiyAGVrYCACA&ved=0CC0Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q&f=false>
Mersch, Peter Paul A. Seasonal affective disorder and latitude: a review of the literature.
Journal of Affective Disorders. 1999. 53(35-48).
<http://cbn.eldoc.ub.rug.nl/FILES/root/1999/JAffectDisordMersch/1999JAffectDi
sordMersch.pdf>
Norden, Michael J. Beyond Prozac: Brain-Toxic Lifestyles, Natural Antidotes & New
Generation Antidepressants. 1995. Harper Collins Publishing NY, NY
Patel, Vikram. Cultural Factors and International Epidemiology. British Medical Bulletin.
2001. Issue 57: 33-45.
<http://bmb.oxfordjournals.org/content/57/1/33.full.pdf+html>
16
Samantha Osani
Watters, Ethan. Crazy Like Us. 2010. Free Press. New York, New York.
17