Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract. Road bridges represent a large financial investment and provide an essential service to the community
and economy of a country. Being such important structures, they are regularly inspected, monitored and assessed.
Inspections are required to ensure that bridges serve efficiently and that maintenance costs are kept within the
estimated budget during the structure’s specified life. Concrete bridges in Albania have been constructed with
different standards, in different periods and exposed to traffic loads which have rapidly increased during the last
two decades. Additionally, the existing condition of these bridges has not been clearly defined yet. Therefore, an
attempt was made in this study to draw a general picture of the condition of Albanian bridges, based on the visual
inspection of 104 bridges with a total length of 7271.6 m, along 263 km road in different parts of the country. The
selected bridges pertain to the road network with the heaviest traffic volume within the country. This network also
contains bridges constructed in all the various construction time periods of Albania. The investigations
demonstrated that the general physical state of the bridges is poor; therefore, the service provided by the bridges
poses potential dangers.
1 Introduction
Bridges are the most delicate and critical sections of road networks. Maintaining the integrity of a bridge structure
is an increasing problem, particularly when any bridge ages. The collapse of the Silver Bridge in the US on
December 15, 1957, resulted in the death of 46 people. This tragic collapse led to the development of bridge
inspection standards in USA (Chen & Duan, 2003; Bridge Inspection Manual, 2010). Today, advanced bridge
management programs are widely used to ensure that the service provided by bridges remains efficient throughout
the specified service life of these structures (Waher, 1999). The management systems are specified on different
types of inspection to identify distress and its causes in periodic time frame BS 5400 (BS 5400-4, 1990). The
British Standard for design and construction of steel, concrete and composite bridges emphasizes that bridges
require regular inspection under competent direction.
Over the past decades, many new bridges and roads have been built in Albania. The construction of these bridges
and roads was done in different time periods, which were characterized from different types of construction codes.
The construction of bridges in modern history of Albania has initially started with engineering intuition and
knowledge; afterwards the Soviet Union standard and later the Albanian Standard and Code (KTP 23-78) were
implemented. In the past two decades, the United States Standards (AASHTO), the British Standard (BS), and the
European Norms (EN), have been used in bridge construction.
Albanian national ways have 562 bridges, running a total length of 19.295m over the entire country (Albanian
Bridges, 2010). Most of these bridges have been in use for traffic for more than 35 years. During this long-term
period there have been no regular inspections on these structures.
Nowadays different countries use different bridge management programs (REAM, 2003; Wan et al., 2010;
Thompson et al., 1998; Hawk & Small, 1998; Chassiakos et al., 2005; Gurevich & Vlahos, 1999; Jaafar et al.,
2003). The first bridge management system used in Albania was “Bridge Management Expert” (BMX) version
4.0 in 2010 (Albanian Bridges, 2010). This program includes an inventory system, an inspection system, and a
data management system to record inspections’ findings as well as maintenance recommendation. Three trained
engineers performed conditional inspections of the 562 Albanian bridges within a year, which was part of a
European Union funding project. Although it was the first inventory and inspection work in the country, the final
report did not provide details on the level and condition of deteriorations in these structures.
This study is an attempt to draw a general picture of the condition of Albanian bridges, based on the visual
inspection of 104 bridges with a total length of 7271.6 m; along 263 km road from different parts of the country.
The main material used in the construction of the bridges in Albania is reinforced concrete; therefore, this study is
mostly focused on reinforced concrete bridges. Bridges were selected from a road network which carries the
heaviest traffic volume within the country and represents different bridge construction time periods.
1
A GENERAL OVERVIEW ON THE PHYSICAL CONDITION OF ALBANIAN BRIDGES
2 Methodology
To carry out the objectives of the study, a suitable methodology is adopted. The framework outline of the adopted
methodology is shown in Figure 1.
2
The Value of Structural Health Monitoring for the
reliable Bridge Management
The preliminary inspection is undertaken to identify bridge structures, either registered or not by authorities. In
the preliminary inspection all road structures with a span length of more than 8m were inspected. In order to
minimize the inspection time and maximize the number of inspected elements, the route shown in Figure 3 is
followed (Inspection Manual, 2007). A database for inspected bridges was created, and, in this way, all the bridge
elements were inspected. The equipment used for preliminary inspection was:
1. Personal (safety belts, hats and shoes, vests)
2. Data recording (Inspection checklist, pens and digital camera)
3. Measuring (Laser meter, 5m tape and 50cm ruler)
4. General (Hammer and vegetation clearing tool)
For all found defects a photo and a hand sketching was done.
2.5 Detailed Inspection
The detailed inspection is the final stage of the field work. After completing the preliminary inspection, the main
types of defects and distresses where detected. Afterwards, a detailed inspection was carried out. It should be
noted that it was based on some expectations of cause and effect relation, as all defects and distresses have a chain
effect. All these chain effects, which were difficult to notice at the beginning, were part of the detailed inspection.
For example, a blocked bearing will cause extra stresses on a load carry element; as a result, cracks will appear in
the structure. Detailed inspection specified all the types of defects and distresses found on an inspected bridge
structure.
3
A GENERAL OVERVIEW ON THE PHYSICAL CONDITION OF ALBANIAN BRIDGES
3.1 Scouring
Among the inspected bridges, 82 pass over water environment; 22 (26.8%) of these bridges have no scour risk; 52
of them (63.5%) have low or moderate scour risk. Yet, 8 bridges or 6.7% are in high or very high risk. Most of
Albanian rivers have an aggressive flow regime. Due to this aggressive regime, they carry a lot of river material
towards the seas.
The last two decades Albania witnessed a tremendously increased demand in the construction industry. The chief
material of this industry is concrete and concrete’s main materials are aggregates and sand. Aggregates and sand
is taken from riverbeds without any criteria; moreover, most of the times working companies were not licensed.
This problem has been on focus of national newspapers and television news, but still there is no evident effort
made for the solution of this problem (Top-Cannel, 2012; Gazeta Tema, 2012). From a different perspective, the
foundation depth is insufficient in many bridges. Having pile foundation bases, almost every inspected bridge has
serious scour problems. This is viable even for bridges built in the last ten years. Among the inspected bridges, in
none of them any pile cap is buried. In order to avoid similar problems in the future, scouring should be the focus
of bridge designers. The main causes of scour are: high river flow, human intervention, and insufficient foundation
depth. In order to minimize scour effect, some recommendations have been listed below (King & Razak, 2000).
a. The bridge structure should cross the river perpendicularly
b. Abutments should not be placed inside the waterway
c. The number of piers inside the river should be minimized
d. Piers should be of oval shape
e. Pile caps should be buried
The assessment of scour on the pile load carry capacity of Mat Bridge has been investigated as part of a case study.
Pile elements were analyzed analytically basing the study on geotechnical data. The effects of different scour
depths on pile load carry capacity were investigated. The depth of scour in Mat Bridge varies from 0.5m to 4.5m.
The highest scour depth in a 30 cm diameter pile is 4.5m: this score depth results into a loose in load carry capacity
of circa 17.64%. The highest scour depth in a 100 cm diameter pile is 3.0m: this score depth results into a loose in
load carry capacity of circa 32.11%. Although the safety factors in soil mechanics vary from 2.5 to 3, the reduction
in load carry capacity is considerable. The bearing capacity of pile has a direct effect on the safety of the entire
bridge structure. Such losses in the bearing capacity pose a serious risk for pier settlements or for overturning, due
to the increased water pressure. It is suggested that these effects must be subject of further studies, focusing on
deflection and bridge load carrying capacity (Periku & Yardim, 2012).
4
The Value of Structural Health Monitoring for the
reliable Bridge Management
steel bars. Especially in marine environment, sodium chloride causes serious problems. Albanian bridges in
general suffer from carbonation and sodium chloride attacks. In some foundations, sulphate attacks were also
recorded. The main causes of chemical attacks are: insufficient concrete cover, poor quality of concrete, lack of
design details, and poor maintenance.
3.4 Cracks
Cracks are the ‘language’ of reinforced concrete structure. It is very important to understand and analyze them to
understand the behavior of any structure. There are structural and non-structural cracks. It is obligatory to monitor
structural cracks. From exposed steel bars, it is seen that Albanian bridges are over-reinforced. It is not common
to meet flexural cracks. The types of cracks mostly seen in these bridges are shear cracks, longitudinal cracks,
and plastic shrinkage cracks, as shown in Figure 7. Shear cracks are the most delicate structural cracks found on
the inspected bridges, as shown in Figure 7 (a). From the exposed steel bars (Figure 8.), it is seen that steel bars
designed to resist moment are very dense. However, the same attention has not been paid to stirrups; they have
been placed far from each other, sometimes more than 50cm. Additionally, they are small in diameter.
Longitudinal cracks are mostly seen in abutments and sometimes in piers, as shown in Figure 7 (b). These types
of cracks usually happen due to differentiated settlement of foundation. Plastic shrinkage cracking occurs in the
surface of fresh concrete, soon after it is placed, and while it is still plastic. It is widely seen especially in deck
elements, where the concrete surface is greater, as seen in Figure 7 (c). The bridge implementer should be careful
about the concrete itself, the weather and the temperature as well as the concrete placement, in order to avoid
these types of cracks. Among the 104 inspected bridges, 28 of them, or 26.9%, have no crack risk; 67 of them, or
64.4%, have low or moderate crack risk; and 9 bridges, (or 8.7%) are in high or very high risk. The main causes
5
A GENERAL OVERVIEW ON THE PHYSICAL CONDITION OF ALBANIAN BRIDGES
of cracks are: overload, poor workmanship, and lack of design details. In spite of the presence of structural and
non-structural cracks, the problematic phenomenon noticed in almost every bridge is concrete spalls, discussed
below.
(a) Shear crack (b) Longitudinal Crack (c) Plastic shrinkage cracks
Fig. 7. Cracks
6
The Value of Structural Health Monitoring for the
reliable Bridge Management
7
A GENERAL OVERVIEW ON THE PHYSICAL CONDITION OF ALBANIAN BRIDGES
8
The Value of Structural Health Monitoring for the
reliable Bridge Management
4 Conclusions
This study was carried out to identify the current status of bridges in Albania and to review the deficiencies
occurring on these structures. It is recorded that the existing bridges are in poor or very poor physical conditions
and have many defects and deficiencies. The main causes of these defects according to visual inspection are traffic
load, environmental conditions, aging, poor workmanship, lack of detailed design, and lack of maintenance.
Problems like the collapsing of the entire bridge structure are rare. Nonetheless, scouring is the main cause of most
collapses. Other problems like missing or under-strength parapets, broken or nonfunctional drainage pipes, blocked
and extremely rusted bearings, as well as nonfunctional expansion joints may sometimes lead to major safety
problems, and bridge owners have, thus, to take precautions.
The samples used in this study represent 18.51% of the number and 37.69% of the length of the total national
bridge stock of Albania. Excessive attention was paid so that the used section was the most encompassing
representative of Albanian bridges.
It is observed that required attention is not paid while selecting and designing some bridge elements like bearings,
expansion joints, and/or foundation depth. These defects can be found even in quite new bridges, as pointed out
by problems such as horizontal deformation in elastomeric bearings, broken or nonfunctional expansion joints, and
scouring problems. The drainage system and the expansion joints are two other vital elements which should be
constructed with care. Most of the defects found in the drainage systems and expansion joints were the result of
poor workmanship. Both bridge designers and implementers in Albania should take into consideration the common
bridge defects listed above. Relevant departments should pay attention to the preparation of a functional
maintenance program. Finally, these issues should be carried to a public level to increase awareness about the
bridge conditions and potential risks. This awareness will increase relevant departments’ responsibility, and this
will have a significant impact on the improvement of the current status of Albanian bridges.
References
AASHTO, Bridge Design Specifications. USA 2007.
Bridge Inspection Manual, Washington Department of Transportation, 2010.
BS 5400-4. Steel, concrete and composite bridges. Code of practice for design of concrete bridges, ISBN 0 580
184420. Published by British standard Institute, 1990.
Chassiakos A. P., Vagiotas P., Theodorakopoulos D.D., “A knowledge- based system for maintenance planning
of highway concrete bridges”, Advances in Engineering Software, Volume 36 Issue 11-12. 2005.
Chen W.F., Duan L., “Bridge Engineering: Construction and Maintenance”, CRC Press LLC, Boca Raton, Florida,
2003.
Delegation of the European Commission to Albania, “Albanian Bridge Asset Management System Manual
Introduction & Overview”, Ref: EuropeAid/127796/C/SER/AL. 2010.
Gazeta Koha Jone, “Tragjedia e Himares, homazh dhe dhimbje per 13 viktimat”, May 23, 2012, Viti XXII, Nr.
130 (6346). 2012.
Gazeta Panorama, “Peshkopi, dy te vdekur ne aksident”, www.panorama.com.al/aktualitet/. Access on 22
February 2011.
Gazeta Shekulli, “Studentet qe perloten shqiperine”, May 23, 2012, Viti XVI, Nr. 3680. 2012.
Gazeta Shqiptare, “Kronike e nje vdekje te paralajmeruar”, May 23, 2012, Viti XIX, Nr. 5648. 2012.
9
A GENERAL OVERVIEW ON THE PHYSICAL CONDITION OF ALBANIAN BRIDGES
Gazeta Tema, “Fiksi denoncon skandalin: Për 3 mijë euro drejtori i partisë së çamëve të lejon të shkatërrosh çdo
lumë”, http://www.gazetatema.net, Access on 14 May 2012.
Gurevich D., Vlahos N.J., Network-level bridge management systems for national road administrations Eighth
TRB international bridge management conference, Denver, Colorado, USA p. F-2/1. 1999.
Hawk H., Small E.P., “The BRIDGIT bridge management system”, Struct. Eng Intern, No 8(4), pp.309–314. 1998.
Inspection Manual for Highway Structures, Volume 1-2, TSO. London 2007.
Jaafar M.S., Yardim Y., Thanoon W.A., Noorzaei J., “Development of a Knowledge-Based System for Bridge
Condition Assessment”. Indian Concrete Journal, December 2003, Pages 7-13. 2003.
King N. S., Razak R.A, “Bridge Hydraulic Problems in Malaysia”. Paper published in proceedings of the 4th
International Seminar on Bridges and Aqueducts Mumbai, India. 2000.
Periku E., Yardim Y., “Deficiencies of Some Important Bridges in Albania”, Proceedings of the Balkans
Conference on Challenges of Civil Engineering, Tirana, Albania. 2011.
Periku E., Yardim Y., “Effect of Scour on Load Carry Capacity of Piles on Mat Bridge”, Proceedings of
International Student Conference of Civil Engineering, Tirana, Albania. 2012.
REAM “A Guide to Bridge Inspection, Road Engineering Association of Malaysia”, Kuala Lumpur, 2003.
Thompson P.D., Small E.P., Johnson M., Marshall A.R., “The PONTIS bridge management system”. Struct Eng
Intern, No.8 (4), pp.303–308. 1998.
Top-Cannel, “Fikse Fare, 01 May 2012”, http://www.top- channel.tv/video.php?id=11501&ll=12, Access on 14
May 2012
Waher G.A., FHWA, Federal Highway Administration - US department of Transportation. Developing NDE
Technologies for Infrastructure Assessment, 1999.
Wan B., Foley C., Komp J., “New bridge decks and overlays”, SPR # 0092-09-06, Transportation Research Center,
Marquette University, 2010.
10