Professional Documents
Culture Documents
[JANUARY 2013]
DIVINE AND HUMAN RESPONSIBILITY IN EURIPIDES’
HIPPOLITUS
CONTENTS
1. Biography
2. Sophists
3. Hippolytus
Euripides was born in the island of Salamis, in 480 B.C.E. His father is
said to have been a tradesman or tavern-keeper, his mother a seller of
herbs. His parents, however, must have had some means, judging by the
fact that they gave him a gymnastic education to prepare him for the
athletic contests. This was because they had misinterpreted an oracle given
to them before his birth which had promised the child crowns of victory. It
is said that Euripides actually won these sorts of contests in his boyhood,
but in fact he was destined to win victories in a very different arena.
HIPPOLYTUS
Euripides’ initial failure at the City Dionysia may have motivated him
to revisit the Hippolytus myth. The extant dramatization, titled Hippolytos
Stephanophoros (Hippolytus Crowned) or simply Hippolytus, is generally
believed to have corrected the characterizations that made the first version
so unpopular. This belief originated with Aristophanes of Byzantium, and
many modern scholars continue to hold this view. In this reading, both
Phaedra and Hippolytus remain chaste and share some of the responsibility
for their tragic fates. Instead of a brazen Phaedra propositioning
Hippolytus, the nurse betrays her mistress, which results in the downfall of
these two characters. Ultimately, all characters seem to be absolved of
their moral responsibilities. Rather, Aphrodite receives blame for the
deaths of Hippolytus and Phaedra, and the conclusion of the play
establishes ongoing strife between the goddess of love and the goddess of
chastity. Athenian audiences responded more positively to this reworked
version of the Hippolytus myth. Hippolytus was first performed for the City
Dionysia in 428 B.C.E. and won first prize. Euripides’ tragedy forms the basis
of a number of later adaptations of the Hippolytus myth, most notably
Racine’s seventeenth-century drama Phèdre (composed in French).
HIPPOLYTUS-THE PLOT
In the next scene, Theseus returns only to find his wife dead with a
letter on her body explaining that she had committed suicide because
Hippolytus raped her. The chorus, being bound by their pact with Phaedra,
cannot tell him the truth. Hippolytus appears, and though he seems quite
innocent in his demeanor Theseus immediately questions him about the
alleged crime. Hippolytus, being true to his word, holds his tongue and does
not tell Theseus what he knows; only that he is innocent. Theseus, believing
the letter to be the truth, curses Hippolytus using one of the three curses
which his father Poseidon (the god of water, ocean, and sea) has promised
him and then exiles him.
Suddenly, Artemis appears Theseus and tells him the truth of the
situation. She lays partial blame on Theseus for cursing his son, but
understands that the main faults lays with Aphrodite. She promises justice
by saying she will kill one of Aphrodites’ favorite humans. Hippolytus is then
carried in to a remorseful Theseus, and though Hippolytus was obviously
wronged he forgives Theseus and does not lay the blame of his death upon
him. Thus, the play of Hippolytus ends.
CHARACTERS & MOTIVS
The characters do worry about how the gods react to them at times.
Hippolytus does not seem to concern himself much with how Aphrodite
reacts to his behavior. At the beginning of the play, the old man questions
Hippolytus' decision not to worship Aphrodite, but Hippolytus really does
not worry that he may be making Aphrodite angry. He does care how
Artemis reacts, however, because he is hoping to keep her happy so that
she may help him out if he should need it. Theseus certainly concerns
himself with how the gods react, since he needs Poseidon to send a bull to
go kill his son. At the end of the play he does care what Artemis has to say
about him killing his son. He believes that he should be the one to die,
though Artemis is able to convince him that he was fooled by the gods.
Phaedra, on the other hand, really is in no position to care much about how
the gods react to what she does. This is because she is under the control of
Aphrodite. Aphrodite makes her love Hippolytus, it certainly is not of her
own free will.
Why the gods would treat the humans this way is a somewhat
complicated question. An easy answer would be that they have the power
to do to the humans what the please. But there are other reasons as well.
For instance, the theme of revenge plays a major role in the plot. The
actions of Aphrodite against Hippolytus are motivated by revenge. The
gods, at least in Hippolytus, are not malicious and wanting humans to suffer
for no good reason. Therefore, the most important reason for gods treating
humans the way they do is that they are reacting to the actions of humans;
this is especially true of Aphrodite's reaction to Hippolytus's failure to
worship her. The gods must derive something from the suffering of the
humans; otherwise there is no point in making them suffer. In this case, the
gods derive both sorrow and joy from the suffering of the characters.
Aphrodite certainly is happy that Hippolytus suffered and died through her
own actions, and that she causes Theseus to suffer as well by taking his son
away. On the other hand, she probably does not care much that she also
caused the death of Phaedra. Phaedra only serves as a pawn to get revenge
on Hippolytus. Aphrodite only cares to punish Hippolytus, and she would
have used Phaedra in whatever capacity necessary to get that revenge.
Artemis, however, is saddened by the loss of Hippolytus: "You and I are the
chief sufferers Theseus." (1337) Because of this, she vows to avenge
Hippolytus' death, and also tells him that he will not be forgotten by future
generations of Greeks, that his name will live on in glory. Interestingly,
Hippolytus was able to forgive his father even though his father caused his
death. That should not be surprising, because he realizes that his father was
fooled by the gods, and being an irrational human, could not really be
expected to know he was being tricked. Also, Artemis does not blame
Theseus for the death of his son: "It is natural for men to err when they are
blinded by gods." (1433-1434) The most important thing that the ending
shows is that sometimes the gods do care what happens to the humans. It
also shows how easily the power of the gods, particularly that of Poseidon,
could be misused because Theseus gets what he prays for, the death of his
son, but it is not really what he wanted.
One final form of revenge comes at the end of the play, when
Artemis vows to avenge the death of Hippolytus by interfering with a
human loved by Aphrodite. It is all a vicious cycle of revenge. This same
story could very easily happen again if Artemis does avenge his death. Also,
forgiveness is an important theme. Even though his father is responsible for
his death, Hippolytus is nevertheless able to forgive him. This comes from
the realization that his father had been deceived by the gods. In the end,
this proves once again that the Greeks were at the mercy of their gods and
that they had to try to live their life the best they could in spite of that fact.
Not only are the gods similar to humans, Euripides creates a world in which
humans expect the gods to interfere in their affairs. Beyond the obvious
examples of Aphrodite and Artemis, who are intimately involved in the
action of the play, the chorus refers to other deities who could have caused
Phaedra’s mania, including Pan and Hecate. Pan is a nature god, usually
depicted as a faun, who rules over wilderness, and Hecate, whom antiquity
portrayed as a virgin, is associated with crossroads, liminal spaces, and
magic. All of the divine figures mentioned by the chorus are somehow
“other,” which is appropriate based on Phaedra’s wild behavior. Beyond
the scope of the play, the chorus’ speculation indicates the greater
perception in Greek society that the gods involved themselves in the
everyday lives of humans.*
Bates, Alfred, ed. The Drama: Its History, Literature and Influence on
Civilization. Vol. 1. London: Historical Publishing Company, 1906.
Euripides. Hippolytus. Trans. David Grene. Euripides I. Eds. David Grene and
Richmond Lattimore. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1955.
Roisman, Hanna M. "The Veiled Hippolytus and Phaedra." Hermes Vol. 127,
No. 4 (4th Qtr., 1999)