Professional Documents
Culture Documents
6.50 kN/m
319
RL 101.143 500
2500
face angle q= 90.000 0
ka1 = 0.274
5143
a
8643
d= 22.500 0
2643
q= 95.249 0
92.950 ka2= 0.311
RL 96.00
Heel side Toe side
2800
f
q
d= 22.50 0 d 150 500 500 150
g
3500
300
q= 90.00 0
B C A
ka3 =
700
0.274
400
RL 92.500
3200 1300 1000
5500
1
Design of Retainning Wall
2
Design of Retainning Wall
Dist. of Resultant Force from the toe = LADL = MDL / WDL = 3.19 m
Eccentricity w.r.t center of base slab = eDL = B/2 - LADL
= 2.75 - 3.19 = -0.4421 m
Dist. of Resultant Force from the toe = LADL = MDL / WDL = 2.99 m
Eccentricity w.r.t center of base slab = eDL = B/2 - LADL
= 2.75 - 2.99 = -0.2412 m
b. Active earth pressure
Height of earthfill upto FDL H = 6.64 m
Active earth pressure intensity pa = ka3 g H = 36.37 kN/m2
3
Design of Retainning Wall
Total force due to earth pr.& LL surcharge = 120.80 + 43.64 = 164.44 KNm
moment due to earth pr.& LL surcharge = 337.03 + 144.96 = 481.99 KNm
d. Fluid pressure
The stress due to fluid pressure is calculated as per the provisions under Cl. 217.1 of IRC:6-2000.
Summary of Forces and Moments with soil over the TOE. ( Serviceability limit )
Sl.no Describtion Force kN L A from Moment Knm
Vertical Horizontal toe m Resisting Overturning
1 Dead load of retaining wall 881.70 3.19 2814.47
2 Active Earth pressure 120.80 2.79 337.03
3 Live load surcharge 43.64 3.32 144.96
4 Fluid pressure 105.91
Horizontal load
Total 881.70 164.44 2814.47 481.99
Summary of Forces and Moments with no soil over the TOE. ( Serviceability limit )
Sl.no Describtion Force kN L A from Moment Knm
Vertical Horizontal toe m Resisting Overturning
1 Dead load of retaining wall 814.30 2.99 2435.74
2 Active Earth pressure 120.80 2.79 337.03
3 Live load surcharge 43.64 3.32 144.96
4 Fluid pressure 105.91
4
Design of Retainning Wall
Horizontal load
Total 814.30 164.44 2435.74 481.99
g. Check for over turning with soil over toe ( Serviceability limit )
Total over turning moment MO = 481.99 kNm
Total resisting moment MR = 2814.47 kNm
Factor of safety aginst over turni = MR / M O
= 2814.47 / 481.99 = 5.84 > 2 safe
Stress at toe or he = SV 1 + 6e
B B
5
Design of Retainning Wall
5.50 ^2 x 1
Stress at Toe side = 95.60 kN/m2
Stress at Heel side = -95.60 kN/m2
Total Stresses due to self weight and Lateral force ( Serviceability limit )
Stress at Heel side = 106.89 kN/m2
Stress at Toe side = 213.73 kN/m2
3200 1300 1000
169.05 194.30
106.89 kN/m2 kN/m2
kN/m2 213.73
kN/m2
Max. pressure developed at the bottom of foundation is well within the SBC of the soil at the
founding level and no tension at the foundation. Hence the section adopted is safe.
Note:- Since the foundation is kept less than 3.500 m below the ground level,
passive relief is considered in the design.
d.Summary of Forces and Moments with no soil over the TOE (construction stage)
Sl.no Describtion Force kN Moment Knm
Vertical Horizontal Resisting Overturning
1 Dead load of retaining wall 814.30 2599.32
2 Active Earth pressure 120.80 337.03
3 Live load surcharge 0
4 Fluid pressure 105.91
6
Design of Retainning Wall
Total Stresses due to self weight and Lateral force ( Serviceability limit )
Stress at Heel side = 123.86 kN/m2
Stress at Toe side = 172.25 kN/m2
Summary of Forces and Moments with soil over the TOE ( Equilibruim )
Sl.n Resisting Overturning Vertical Horizontal Moment kNm
Describtion
o Effect Effect Load Load Resisting Overturning
1 Dead load of retain 0.95 1.05 837.62 0.00 2673.744 0.00
2 Active Earth pressu 0.00 1.50 0.00 181.20 0.000 505.55
3 Live load surcharge 0.00 1.20 0.00 52.37 0.000 173.95
4 Fluid pressure 0.00 1.00 0.00 105.91 0.000 0.00
Horizontal load
Total 837.62 233.57 2673.74 679.50
Dist. of Resultant Force from the toe = LADL = MDL / WDL = 3.19 m
= eDL
Eccentricity w.r.t center of base slab = B/2 - LADL
= 2.75 - 3.19 = -0.4421 m
Summary of Forces and Moments with no soil over the TOE. ( Equilibruim )
Sl.n Resisting Overturning Vertical Horizontal Moment kNm
Describtion
o Effect Effect Load Load Resisting Overturning
1 Dead load of retain 0.95 1.05 773.59 0.00 2313.957 0.00
2 Active Earth pressu 0.00 1.50 0.00 181.20 0.000 505.55
3 Live load surcharge 0.00 1.20 0.00 52.37 0.000 173.95
4 Fluid pressure 0.00 1.00 0.00 105.91 0.000 0.00
Horizontal load
Total 773.59 233.57 2313.96 679.50
Dist. of Resultant Force from the toe = LADL = MDL / WDL = 2.99 m
Eccentricity w.r.t center of base slab = eDL = B/2 - LADL
= 2.75 - 2.99 = -0.2412 m
e. Check for sliding with soil over toe ( Equilibrium limit )
Total horizontal forces causing sliding Hs = 233.57 kN
Total horizontal forces aginst sliding HR = 0.6 x vertical loads
= 0.6 x 837.62 = 502.57 kN
7
Design of Retainning Wall
Stress at toe or he = SV 1 + 6e
B B
Total Stresses due to self weight and Lateral force ( Equilibrium limit )
Stress at Heel side = 57.59 kN/m2
Stress at Toe side = 247.00 kN/m2
3200 1300 1000
8
Design of Retainning Wall
167.79 212.56
57.59 kN/m2 kN/m2
kN/m2 247.00
kN/m2
Summary of Forces and Moments with no soil over the TOE. ( Equilibruim )
Sl.n Resisting Overturning Vertical Horizontal Moment kNm
Describtion
o Effect Effect Load Load Resisting Overturning
1 Dead load of retain 0.95 1.05 773.59 0.00 2469.355 0.00
2 Active Earth pressu 0.00 1.50 0.00 181.20 0.000 505.55
3 Live load surcharge 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.00
4 Fluid pressure 0.00 1.00 0.00 105.91 0.000 0.00
Horizontal load
Total 773.59 181.20 2469.35 505.55
Check for sliding ( Equilibruim limit )
Horizontal force against sliding = 0.5 x 773.59 = 386.79 kN
Factor of safety against sliding = 386.79 / 181.20 = 2.13
> 1.50 Hence Safe
Check for overturning ( Equilibruim limit )
Factor of safety against overturning = 2469.4 / 505.55 = 4.88
> 2.00 Hence Safe
Check for the Safe bearing capacity at the foundation level
Centre of gravity of the force = 2469.4 / 773.59 = 3.19
= 2.75 - 3.19 = -0.4421 m
1. Stresses due to self weight
Stress at toe = 773.59 1 + 6 x -0.4421
5.50 5.50 = 72.82 kN/m2
9
Design of Retainning Wall
151.61 183.25
kN/m2 kN/m2 207.60
73.71 kN/m2
kN/m2
Dist. of Resultant Force from the toe = LADL = MDL / WDL = 2.99 m
Eccentricity w.r.t center of base slab = eDL = B/2 - LADL
= 2.75 - 2.99 = -0.2412 m
e. Check for sliding with soil over toe ( Foundation design )
Total horizontal forces causing sliding Hs = 233.57 kN
10
Design of Retainning Wall
g. Check for over turning with soil over toe (Foundation design )
Total over turning moment MO = 679.50 kNm
Total resisting moment MR = 3799.53 kNm
Factor of safety aginst over turni = MR / M O
= 3799.53 / 679.50 = 5.59 > 2 safe
Stress at toe or he = SV 1 + 6e
B B
Total Stresses due to self weight and Lateral force ( Foundation Design)
Stress at Heel side = 138.59 kN/m2
Stress at Toe side = 294.25 kN/m2
3200 1300 1000
11
Design of Retainning Wall
229.15 265.95
138.59 kN/m2 kN/m2
kN/m2 294.25
kN/m2
Summary of Forces and Moments with no soil over the TOE. ( Foundation )
Sl.n Vertical Horizontal Moment kNm
Describtion Comb-2
o Load Load Resisting Overturning
1 Dead load of retaining wall 1.35 1099.31 0.00 3509.083 0.00
2 Active Earth pressure 1.50 0.00 181.20 0.000 505.55
3 Live load surcharge 1.20 0.00 0.00 0.000 0.00
4 Fluid pressure 0.15 0.00 15.89 0.000 0.00
Horizontal load
Total 1099.31 181.20 3509.08 505.55
Check for sliding ( foundation )
Horizontal force against sliding = 0.5 x 1099.31 = 549.65 kN
Factor of safety against sliding = 549.65 / 181.20 = 3.03
> 1.50 Hence Safe
Check for overturning ( Foundation )
Factor of safety against overturning = 3509.1 / 505.55 = 6.94
> 2.00 Hence Safe
Check for the Safe bearing capacity at the foundation level
Centre of gravity of the force = 3509.1 / 1099.31 = 3.19
= 2.75 - 3.19 = -0.4421 m
1. Stresses due to self weight
Stress at toe = 1099.31 1 + 6 x -0.4421
5.50 5.50 = 103.48 kN/m2
206.16 224.30
kN/m 2
kN/m2 238.26
12
Design of Retainning Wall
161.49 kN/m2
kN/m2
13
Design of Retainning Wall
Adopting a clear cover of 500 mm and Providing 12 mm dia. As the main rebar
Effective Depth available d = 500-40-6
= 454
Design M = 53 kN.m
Design oVEd = 51 kN
Design oH = 45 kN.m
Design of Main reinforcement
Determination of x/d
X/d = =1.2 - ((1.44 - (6.68Mu / fck b d2 ))1/2
= 1.2-(1.44-(6.68*53x10^6 )/ (25x 1000x454^2))1/2
= 0.029
14
Design of Retainning Wall
15
Design of Retainning Wall
16
Design of Retainning Wall
Pa1 13.687
15.548 PL2 7.463
H2 = 4.14
b d
17
Design of Retainning Wall
Distance of Resultant Force from the toe = LADL = MDL / WDL = 0.469 m
Eccentricity w.r.t center of base slab = eDL = B/2 - LADL
= 0.500 - 0.47 = 0.031 m
Moment due to self weight = 192.02 x 0.03 = 5.904 kNm
Moment due to Fluid pressure
Height of section = 7.94 m
Intensity of fluid pressure = 4.80 kN/m2
Height of earthfill upto foundatioH
Force due to fluid pressure = 4.80 x 7.94 2 / 2 = 151.42 kN
< 134.90 kN
Moment due to this force = 151 x 7.94 / 3 = 400.91 kN
< 315.16 kN
Earth pressure governs the design
18
Design of Retainning Wall
Adopting a clear cover of 1000 mm and Providing 16 mm dia. As the main rebar
Effective Depth available d = 1000-40-8
= 952
19
Design of Retainning Wall
= 40000 mm2
Main Steel Required = 2003 mm2 pt = 0.2103992
Required 16 mm and Providing 100 mm c/c
Provide 16 mm and Providing 150 mm c/c 1341.00 mm2 a1
Provide 16 mm and Providing 150 mm c/c 1341.00 mm2 OK a2
2682.00
Compression side Reinforcement @ Stem :
Minimum Steel of Tensionreinforcement= 2003 mm2
Minimum steel = 25% of Astmin
= 0.25x 2003
= 501 mm2 < 501 mm2
Required 12 mm and Providing 226 mm c/c
Provide 12 mm and Providing 150 mm c/c 754.00 mm2 OK b1
20
Design of Retainning Wall
1000 x 918
= 0.332 N/mm2 > 0.282 N/mm2 OK
DESIGN OF TOE SLAB
Moment calculation
Pressure distribution for no soil at Toe
5.5
0.619 0.531
0 3.35 1 1.15
161.5 kN/m2
208.2 kN/m2
230.8 kN/m2
238.3 kN/m2
Critical section for bending moment is at the face of stem. 222.2 kN/m
a) Bending moment due to soil pressure at the face of stem
= 154.010 kNm
Bending moment due to self weight of concrete
= 1.2 x 0.40 x 25 x 1.15 / 2 = 6.613 kNm
= 0.2 x 0.30 x 25 x 0.15 / 2 = 0.084 kNm
= 1.0 x 0.30 x 0.5 x 25 x ( 1.00 / 3 + 0.15 ) = 1.813 kNm
= 8.51 kNm
233.40 kN/m2
261.70 kN/m2
279.22 kN/m2
294.25 kN/m2
21
Design of Retainning Wall
22
Design of Retainning Wall
23
Design of Retainning Wall
= 1132 x 0.2
= 226 mm2
Required 10 mm and Providing 347 mm c/c (e)
Provide 10 mm and Providing 200 mm c/c 393.00 mm2 OK
Check for Cracking
steel area greater = 0.12%x 1000 x 700
= 840 mm2
Spacing Less than 3d = 3 x = 1857 mm ( Required )
566 mm ( Provided)
OK Spacing of bar
Diameter of rod < d/8
Daimeter of Rod = 12 mm
d/8 /8 = 77.38 mm
OK Diameter of bar
294.25 - 138.59
= 138.59 + x 4.969 = 279.22 kN/m2
5.500
24
Design of Retainning Wall
25
Design of Retainning Wall
= 993.624 kNm
= 954.984 kNm
Bending moment due to self weight of concrete
= 3.4 x 0.40 x 25 x 3.35 / 2 = 56.113 kNm
= 0.15 x 0.30 x 25 x 0.15 / 2 = 0.084 kNm
= 3.20 x 0.30 x 0.5 x 25 x ( 3.20 / 3 + 0.15 ) = 14.600 kNm
= 70.80 kNm
26
Design of Retainning Wall
= 984.12 kNm
27
Design of Retainning Wall
Distribution Reinforcement
Secondary transverse @ toeshould
reinforcement Slab: beAs per Cl.16.6.1.1.3
provided in one wayof slab.
IRC: 112
This-2011
should be at least
20% of the main reinforcement
= 1132 x 0.2
= 226 mm2
Required 10 mm and Providing 347 mm c/c
Provide 10 mm and Providing 200 mm c/c 393.00 mm2 OK ( e )
28
Design of Retainning Wall
OK Spacing of bar
Diameter of rod < d/8
Daimeter of Rod = 16 mm
d/8 /8 = 77.13 mm
OK Diameter of bar
Calculation of intensity of pressure at the critical section for shear
The critical section for shear is taken at the face of stem
Shear force due to soil pressure
= 161.49 + 208.25 x 3.350 = 619.31449 kNm
2
= 138.59 + 233.40 x 3.350 = 623.07635 kNm
2
Self weight of toe porti = 3.350 x 0.400 x 25 = 33.500 kNm
0.150 x 0.300 x 25 = 1.125 kNm
= 3.200 /2x 0.300 x 25 = 12.000 kNm
overburden earth = 3.350 x 7.943 x 20 = 532.181 kNm
= 3.200 /2x 0.300 x 20 = 9.600 kNm
Total = 588.406 kNm
Net shear force = 588.406 - 619.314 = -30.908 kNm
= 588.406 - 623.076 = -34.670 kNm
Induced shear stress in the section
= -34.670 x 1000 = -0.056 Mpa
1000 x 617
% of main steel provided = 0.159 %
Permissible shear stress in concrete for the above % of steel = 0.296 N/mm2
> -0.056 N/mm2 OK
Hence the section do not require shear reinforcement
29
Design of Retainning Wall
SOIL PARAMETERS:-
Angle of Repose, f = 30 0 or 0.5236 rad
Angle of wall friction , d = 00 or 0.0000 rad
Angle of Surcharge, b = 0 0
or 0.0000 rad
Angle of Internal wall slope, q = 90 0
or 1.5708 rad
Angle of Inclination of earthfill with the horizontal I = 00 or 0.0000 rad
Unit weight of soil g = 18 kN/cum
Safe Bearing Capacity of Founding Strata = 300 kN/sqm
MATERIAL DATA:-
Exposure = Moderate
Grade of concrete for RCC = M 25
Permissible Flexural Compressive stress M25 = 15 Mpa
PermissibleTensile stress in RCC M25 = 300 Mpa
LC-403
The design is based on the provisions of the following IRC codes.
2. IRC:6-2000
3. IRC:78-2000
30
Design of Retainning Wall
ka = 1+- a v cos 2 ( f - q - l )
cos 2 q cos ( q + d + l ) cos ( l ) ( 1 + k ) 2
Where
q = Angle that the face of wall makes with the horizontal line in clockwise direction
94
Vertical face of retaining wall = 0.00 or 0.0000 rad
0
1st Inclined face of retaining wall tan-1( 0.5 / 5.4 ) = 5.2 0 or 0.0916 rad
Vertical face of base slab = 0.00 0 or 0.0000 rad
1/2
k = sin ( f + d ) sin ( f - I - l ) 300
Parameters q f d I l k ka
Ver.face of retaining wall 0.0000 0.5236 0.0000 0 0.0957 0.457 0.3938
1st Inclined face 0.0916 0.5236 0.0000 0 0.0957 0.460 0.4288
Vertical face of baseslab 0.0000 0.5236 0.0000 0 0.0957 0.457 0.3938
Dynamic
Dynamic Shear pa = 0.5 g h2 kaH1 = 22.151 kN
31
Design of Retainning Wall
Dynamic
Dynamic Shear P = 1.2x 18 x 2.50 x 0.3938 = 21.265 kN
Dynamic increament = 21.265 - 14.782 = 0.000 kN
Moment Ma = 0.66 x 2.50 x 0.00 = 0.000 kNm
Total Moment = 18.477 + 0.000 = 18.477 kNm
Design moment = 18.477 x 0.500 = 9.239 kNm
Self weight
Considering 1m length of retaining wall and ignoring soil over toe slab
Sl. b d g Weight Cg @ toe Moment
Description
no m m kN/m 3
kN m kNm
1 Crash barrier and bracket 6.50 2.950 19.18
2 Stem
rectangular portion 0.50 2.50 24 30.00 1.25 37.50
Total WDL= 36.50 Total MDL= 56.68
Seismic Self weight = 36.500 x 0.096 = 3.504 kN
Eccentricity = 56.675 / 36.500 = 1.553 m
Moment = 3.504 x 1.553 = 5.441 kNm
AT TOP OF FOUNDATION
Earth pressure
Static
Force Pa2 = 15.398 kN
Moment M = 15.398 x 0.42 x 2.50 + 5.44 = 99.977 kNm
Fluid pressure
Dynamic
Force Pa2 = 0.3938 x 18 x 2.50 = 17.721 kN/sqm
= 0.500 x 17.72 x 2.50 = 22.151 kN
32
Design of Retainning Wall
33
Design of Retainning Wall
AT BOTTOM OF FOUNDATION
Static
Active earth pressure
Pa = 0.273736 x 18 x 8.643 = 42.586 kN/sqm
H. component of active earth pr. Pa = 0.5 pa H = 184.04 KN
This force acts at 0.42H from FDL LAa = 0.42 x 8.643 = 3.63 m
Moment due to this force = 184.04 x 3.63 = 668.06 KNm
Liveload surcharge
Equavalent height of LL surcharge hLL = 1.2 m of soil
Intensity of pr. due to LL surcharge pLL = g hLL = 21.60 kN/m2
H. component of LL surcharge PLL = ka3 pLL H = 51.10 kN
This force acts at 0.5 H from FDL LALL = 0.5 x 8.643 = 4.32 m
Moment due to this force = 51.10 x 4.32 = 220.84 KNm
Dynamic
Active earth pressure
Pa = 0.3938 x 18 x 8.643 = 61.264 kN/sqm
Force = 61.26 x 0.5 x 8.643 = 264.754 kN
Moment = 264.75 x 0.5 x 8.643 = 1144.133 kNm
34
Design of Retainning Wall
Self weight
Considering 1m length of retaining wall and ignoring soil over toe slab
Sl. Cg about
b d g Weight Moment
Description Bot of
no m m kN/m3 kN Footing kNm
1 Crash barrier and bracket 6.50 9.093 59.10
2 Stem
rectangular portion 0.50 5.14 24 61.72 6.07 374.71
triangle portion 0.50 0.24 2.64 24 7.70 4.38 33.73
3 Soil over Heel rec 1 0.24 2.500 18 10.93 7.39 80.77
Soil triangle 2 0.50 0.24 2.643 18 5.78 5.26 30.39
Soil Rectangle 3 3.61 5.143 18 333.93 6.07 2027.48
Total WDL= 426.55 Total MDL= 2606.19
Summary of stress
Sl.n Stresses due to Stress on Toe side Stress on Heel side
o kN/sq.m kN/sq.m
1 Active or Fluid pressure = 94.427 kN/sq.m -94.427 kN/sq.m
2 Live load surcharge = 39.377 kN/sq.m -39.377 kN/sq.m
3 Self weight static = 118.127 kN/sq.m 202.492 kN/sq.m
4 Self weight seismic = 49.625 kN/sq.m -49.625 kN/sq.m
Total Stresses = 301.557 kN/sq.m 19.062 kN/sq.m
Maximum stress developed = 301.557 kN/sq.m < 250 kN/sqm
Minimum stress developed = 19.062 kN/sq.m >
35
Design of Retainning Wall
191.19 kN/m2
242.57 kN/m2
301.56 kN/m2
274.27 kN/m
36
Design of Retainning Wall
f. Check for sliding with no soil over toe ( ETotal hogging moment = 889.956 kNm
191.19 kN/m2
242.57 kN/m2
301.56 kN/m2
274.27 kN/m
37
Design of Retainning Wall
301.56 - 19.06
= 19.06 + x 3.35 + 1.00
5.498
= 242.57 kN/m2
Bending mo 10 200
301.56 + 242.57 2x 301.56 + 242.57 1.148
M1 = x 1.148 x
2 301.56 + 242.57 3
= 185.76 kNm
38
Partial Safety factor for verification of Equilibrium ( Basic Combination )
Summary of Forces and Moments with soil over the TOE. ( Serviceability limit )
Unfactored Load & Moment Overtur Factored Load & Moment
Resistin
Sl.no Describtion Horzl Resistin Overtur g Effect ning Horzl Resistin Overtur
Vertl KN L A toe Effect Vertl KN
KN g ning KN g ning
1 Dead load of retaining wall 881.70 0.00 3.19 2814.5 0 0.95 1.05 837.62 0 2673.7 0
2 Active Earth pressure 0.00 120.80 2.79 0.0 337.034 0.00 1.50 0.00 181.20 0.0 506
3 Live load surcharge 0.00 43.64 3.32 0.0 144.958 0.00 1.20 0.00 52.3706 0.0 209
4 Fluid pressure 0.00 105.91 0.00 0.0 0 0.00 1.00 0.00 105.911 0.0 0
Total 882.00 164.44 2814.0 482.0 838.00 233.57 2673.7 715
Summary of Forces and Moments with no soil over the TOE. ( Serviceability limit )
Unfactored Load & Moment Overtur Factored Load & Moment
Resistin
Sl.no Describtion Horzl Resistin Overtur g Effect ning Horzl Resistin Overtur
Vertl KN L A toe Effect Vertl KN
KN g ning KN g ning
1 Dead load of retaining wall 814.30 0.00 2.99 2435.7 0 0.95 1.05 773.59 0 2314.0 0
2 Active Earth pressure 0.00 120.80 2.79 0.0 337.034 0.00 1.50 0.00 181.20 0.0 759
3 Live load surcharge 0.00 43.64 3.32 0.0 144.958 0.00 1.20 0.00 52.3706 0.0 209
4 Fluid pressure 0.00 105.91 0.00 0.0 0 0.00 1.00 0.00 105.911 0.0 0
815.00 164.44 2436.0 482.0 774.00 233.57 2314.0 968
d.Summary of Forces and Moments with no soil over the TOE (construction stage)
Unfactored Load & Moment Overtur Factored Load & Moment
Resistin
Sl.no Describtion Horzl Resistin Overtur g Effect ning Horzl Resistin Overtur
Vertl KN Effect Vertl KN
KN g ning KN g ning
1 Dead load of retaining wall 814.3 0.00 2599.3 0.00 0.95 1.05 773.59 0 2469.4 0
2 Active Earth pressure 0.0 120.80 0.0 337.03 0.00 1.50 0.00 181.20 0.0 272
3 Live load surcharge 0.0 0.00 0.0 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0 0.0 0
4 Fluid pressure 0.0 105.91 0.0 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 105.911 0.0 106
815.00 120.80 2599.0 337.0 774.00 181.20 2469.4 378
conrete rate = 3500
steel rate = 38000
optimization chart
25000
20000
15000
10000
5000
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
trial no
CROSS SECTIONAL DETAILS OF CRASH BARRIER AND BRACKET
50 175 50 175 50
500
900
250
150
50 500 toe
200 250 500
100