Professional Documents
Culture Documents
17159/2411-9717/2017/v117n4a3
329
Installation of resin-grouted rockbolts in hard rock mining
About 10% of the resin-grouted rockbolts that were installed different minerals in the Bushveld Complex crystallized at
in the last quarter of 2015 were installed incorrectly. The different temperatures, forming a layered structure. Due to
consequences of poor support design and installation are the tensile zone in the hangingwall, it is possible for the rock
rockfalls, increased support costs, and delays in production. strata to separate, resulting in falls of ground. Therefore, the
Poor design and incorrect installation of any form of support layering of rocks in the shallow areas of the Bushveld
in any underground mine introduces adverse risks in the Complex can be compared with the stratified sedimentary
mining environment (Henning and Ferreira, 2010). rocks found in coal mining environments. Resin-grouted
Based on the information from support audits and the rockbolts were first introduced in the coal mining industry,
mine records, it was clear that the mine had pronounced and the ability to create stable beams in underground coal
design and operational inefficiencies. To ensure that the mines using fully grouted rockbolts led to the adoption of this
support design and installation processes do not pose any support system in platinum mines.
adverse risk to the mine or personnel, a full investigation was
$% $%%$ #"!$%! %#"%%
carried out.
"$"%#"$ %
!##!#"%%!$%$ $% The fully-grouted rockbolt support system consists of a
The authors noted that the majority of the recorded faulty ribbed tendon that is anchored in geotechnically sound rock
rockbolt installations were visible to the observer during using a full-length column of resin that is obtained from
support audits (e.g. protruding rockbolts). A significant resin capsules (Barrett, 2006). During installation, the
number of faulty rockbolts, i.e. under-tensioned or over- rotation of the rockbolt mixes the components of the resin
tensioned bolts and bolts with insufficient resin, are not capsules. When the two components are mixed correctly, the
recorded as faulty since the entire installation process needs resin will set and hold the rockbolt in the support hole,
to be observed in order for these faults to become apparent. It resulting in an effective anchorage (Barrett, 2006). The fully-
was therefore necessary to go underground and obtain grouted rockbolt support system is a stiff form of support,
essential information to help the mine to address the design which is highly recommended for shallow mines such as the
and operational inefficiencies. The findings of this one studied. The stiffness of the support system depends on
investigation will potentially help the mine, and similar the load transfer mechanisms between the resin, the rock,
mines, to improve the efficiency, and reduce the costs, of and the bolt (Mark, 2000). Rockbolts were initially grouted
support installation, as well as improve safety and using a single type of resin, but the inherent inefficiencies of
productivity (Ferreira, 2012). this led to the establishment of the dual system, i.e. the
slow/fast resin combination (Varden and Villaescusa, 2006).
$!#$ This system, which is used at the mine, employs a fast-
The main objectives of the investigation include: setting resin at the toe of the support hole and a slow-setting
® Identifying and addressing the challenges that lead to resin towards the collar, thus combining the advantages of
poor installation of resin-grouted rockbolts at the mine both resins. Henning and Ferreira (2010) recommended
® Reviewing the support design used at the mine and resin-grouted rockbolts mainly for rocks without widely open
identifying its limitations discontinuities or voids that will cause resin loss, rocks
® Optimizing the support design parameters without continuous water runoff problems, and for long-term
® Making recommendations that can be used to improve support in thinly bedded roof strata.
the support design and the installation process.
$#"$$"!%$"# %%!
$%%!$% ! Rockbolts serve the purpose of binding together broken or
The data used in this investigation was collected in the stratified rock layers to forestall falls of ground (Esterhuizen,
development ends in block 9 and block 12 of the mine. The 2014). In order to achieve this objective, four basic
mine uses three different forms of bolt support, namely resin- roofbolting mechanisms were developed (Chen, 1994):
grouted rockbolts, split sets, and mechanical anchor bolts. ® Simple skin support
However, the study is limited to the use of resin-grouted ® Suspension mechanism
rockbolts since these are the main form of bolt support used ® Beam building mechanism
in the development ends. ® Keying of blocky and highly fractured ground.
The studied mine is characterized by insignificant horizontal
$$"!%"%#!$!$
clamping forces that are required to keep the rock mass intact
To effectively understand the research problem, the literature in order to generate a self-supporting beam (Gamboa and
related to the area under investigation was critically Atrens, 2003). The resin-grouted rockbolts are used at the
summarized. The literature surveys permitted the authors to mine for both suspension and beam-building mechanisms.
identify the strengths and weaknesses in previous research The rockbolts are also primarily used for keying of blocky
work. and highly fractured rock masses.
$% # %%$#"%"%%#!$!$%#"%" !##!#"%% !%$ #"%$!$
#"$ !#!#"%!!%# % $%"%%!#"%#"$ Chen (1994) stated that any inadequacies in the design of a
Shallow underground mines are characterized by a significant support system may result in failure of underground
tensile zone in the hangingwall, which presents the risk of excavations. On the other hand, a conservative design will
hangingwall failure. Cawthorn (2007) stated that the increase costs. It is very important to optimize the support
L
330
331
Installation of resin-grouted rockbolts in hard rock mining
Table II
&&-$-1.$2/&20'12,0*.)*+)2!-.12,%##/+02)1,-".
losing a total of R12.61 per hole when installation is done Summary of the authors’ findings:
effectively. However, the loose and exposed rockbolts that ® Bolt length: 2 400 mm (threaded portion measured 130
were inspected were not fully grouted. mm)
® Bolt diameter: 24.2 mm on the bolt and 25 mm on the
#"%#"#" %%!$% !%$ #"% !
ribs
PTOs and inputs from field experts enabled the authors to ® Resin capsule size: 500 mm by 25 mm
gather information which was then compared with the ® Support hole diameter: 33.5mm (32 mm diameter drill
standard mine support design. The main differences between bits plus 5% hole reaming).
the study findings (actual design) and the standard mine
Table IV shows the efficiency of support based on the study
support design (planned design) are presented in Table III.
findings, assuming that the length of the support hole
The actual diameter of the support holes (33.5 mm) is
is 2.4 m.
greater than the design diameter (32 mm). This is because
The support system has significant problems. Each
the drill bits ream the holes. Tadolini (1998) has shown that
support hole requires an additional 8% resin to be fully
reaming of the holes increases the design diameter by a
encapsulated and to offer maximum anchorage of the bolt.
maximum of 5%.
This is why around 250 mm of the rockbolts was not
encapsulated with resin.
Table III
-&&1+1.$1,2 1011.20'12#(*..1)2*.)2*$0%*( !###"%!$% !%$ #"
,%##/+02)1,-". In practice, the support holes require 8% more resin per hole.
Possible solutions to this problem would be to increase the
(*..1) $0%*( size of the rockbolts, increase the sizes of the resin capsules,
Bolt diameter (mm) 25 24.2 or reduce the sizes of the support holes. Increasing the sizes
Support hole diameter (mm) 32 33.5
of the rockbolts and resin capsules will have serious cost
Threaded portion of bolt (mm) 100 130
implications. Therefore, the size of the support hole should
Table IV
'121&&-$-1.$2/&2,%##/+02 *,1)2/.20'12,0%)2&-.)-.",2
L
332
"$"% $!#"
The following observations were made during the PTOs.
Table V
'121&&-$-1.$2/&2,%##/+02 *,1)2/.20'12*%0'/+,2/#0-!*(2)1,-".2/&20'12,%##/+02,,01!2
L
333
Installation of resin-grouted rockbolts in hard rock mining
-"%+12&&1$0-12*.$'/+*"12(1."0'2$ %*."(12/&2-.,0*((*0-/.
-"%+122+/$ /(02-.,0*((1)2-.2*.2/1+)+-((1)2,%##/+02'/(1
at an angle of less than 70° does not effectively clamp the
1.5 m fallout height of the hangingwall properly. Figure 2
shows how the effective anchorage length decreases with shallow mining environments. In shallow mining
decreasing installation angle. It was observed that some of environments there is no stress fracturing or horizontal
the support holes were not drilled at the preferred angle of clamping force to keep the rock mass together to create a self-
90° to the hangingwall and the sidewalls. This results in a supporting hangingwall beam, as there is in deep mines
decrease in the bearing capacity of the rockbolt and reduces (Gamboa and Atrens, 2003). The rock mass in shallow
the efficiency of the bolt in creating a stable beam. Such environments is in a tensile state and associated with weak
behaviour was observed in four of the six drill rig operators joint planes or dilations in the hangingwall (Gamboa and
that were studied. Atrens, 2003). This is why it is important to effectively
tension the rockbolts in order to create the required clamping
force. The drilling of the support has an effect on the tension
The majority of the support holes were not drilled to the applied in the rockbolts.
design length of 2.4 m, but were either over-drilled or under-
$#$% !%$
drilled. The authors randomly selected and measured 12
support holes during installations in block 9, and 12 in block Over-drilling the support holes results in insufficient
12. The random selection of holes eliminates human bias tensioning of the rockbolts. When a support hole is over-
and allows statistical conclusions to be made and generalized drilled, there may be insufficient thread left outside the
to a larger population. Figure 3 shows the deviation of the support hole to fasten and tighten the nut (Barrett, 2006).
support holes from the designed length of 2.4 m both in Correct fastening and tightening of the nut results in effective
block 9 and block 12. tensioning of the bolt. Other impacts of over-drilling the
Only 12.5% of the support holes that were measured support hole include the possibility (based on the degree of
were drilled to the correct design length—37.5% of the holes over-drilling) that some of the resins capsules may not be
were over-drilled while 50% were under-drilled. Under-drilled penetrated (Barrett, 2006). Figure 4 shows a rockbolt that
holes were mainly as a result of poor drilling practice or poor was installed in an over-drilled hole.
scaling of the excavation. Over-drilled holes were also a
"$#$% !%$
result of operator inefficiencies.
When support holes are under-drilled, a significant portion of
the bolt protrudes outside the hole. In this case, fastening
It is important to tension rockbolts properly, especially in and tightening of the bolt may result in either over-
tensioning or under-tensioning. Figure 5 shows the
-"%+12'12)-&&1+1.$12 1011.2*.2/1+01.,-/.1)2*.)2%.)1+
-"%+121*,%+1)2(1."0',2/&2,%##/+02'/(1,2*"*-.,020'12)1,-". 01.,-/.1)2+/$ /(02*,2*2+1,%(02/&2%.)1+)+-((-."20'12,%##/+02'/(1,
(1."0',2
/+,01+2
L
334
335
Installation of resin-grouted rockbolts in hard rock mining
masses for the design of tunnel support. Journal of Rock Mechanics and
3/.$(%,-/.,
Geotechnical Engineering, vol. 6, no. 4. pp. 189–236.
The investigation indicated that the standard support design
used at the studied mine requires improvement. In practice CAWTHORN, R.G. 2007. The centenary of the discovery of platinum in the
the support holes are short of resin, leading to the rockbolts Bushveld Complex. Journal of the Southern African Institute of Mining
not being fully grouted. Drilling accuracy is a serious concern and Metallurgy, vol. 107, no. 1. pp. 1–4.
at the mine. Of the 24 holes that were measured, only 12.5%
were drilled to the correct length. The rockbolts installed in CHEN, D. 1994. Design of rock bolting systems for underground excavations
the under-drilled holes (representing 50% of the measured PhD thesis, University of Wollongong.
holes) are either over-tensioned or under-tensioned, while
those installed in over-drilled holes (37.5% of the measured ESTERHUIZEN, A. 2014. Unique fall-of-ground prevention strategy implemented
holes) are definitely under-tensioned. The mine is faced with at Two Rivers Platinum Mine. Journal of the Southern African Institute of
considerable challenges when it comes to conforming to the Mining and Metallurgy, vol. 114, no. 10. pp. 785–790.
® The standard mine support design should be optimized fully encapsulated rockbolts. Proceedings of the 10th Congress of the
International Society of Rock Mechanics: ‘Technology Roadmap for Rock
by reducing the diameter of the drill bit from 32 mm to
Mechanics’, Sandton, South Africa. International Society for Rock
28 mm and reducing the length of the support hole
Mechanics. pp. 113–118.
from 2.4 m to 2.35 m. These changes will enable the
mine to use different combinations of resin capsules to
HENNING, P. and FERREIRA, P. 2010. In-stope bolting for a safer working
reduce the cost of installation per support hole
environment. Journal of the Southern African Institute of Mining and
® The mine should provide intensive training to the
Metallurgy, vol. 110, no. 1. pp. 47–51.
support crews to address the concerns associated with
drilling accuracy and conformity to the rockbolt Hermanus, M.A. 2007. Occupational health and safety in mining-status, new
manufacturer’s recommendations developments, and concerns. Journal of the Southern African Institute of
® Informal and formal planned task observations should Mining and Metallurgy, vol. 107, no. 8. pp. 535–540.
be carried out more frequently by the rock engineering
department to ensure adherence to set standards MARK, C. 2000. Design of roof bolt systems. Publication no: 2000-151.
® The use of a T-spanner to re-tension all the installed National Institute for Occupational Health and Safety, Pittsburgh, PA.
rockbolts is recommended, since the results presented
indicate that all the rockbolts were under-held and TADOLINI, S.C. 1998. The effects of reduced annulus in roof bolting performance.
tensioned prematurely Proceedings of the 17th International Conference on Ground Control in
® It is important to test the quality of the resins by Mining. Department of Mining Engineering College of Engineering and
sacrificing one resin capsule from each box before Mineral Resources. West Virginia University, Morgantown, WV.
336