Professional Documents
Culture Documents
We mostly admit
the information that makes us feel great about ourselves,
while conveniently filtering whatever unsettles our fragile egos
and most vital beliefs. Ideology powerfully masks what, to
the uncaptivated mind, is obvious, dangerous, or absurd and
there’s much about how, and even where, we live that leaves
us in the dark. Fear of conflict, fear of change keeps us that
way. An unconscious (and much denied) impulse to obey and
conform shields us from confrontation and crowds provide
friendly alibis for our inertia. And money has the power to blind
us, even to our better selves. // MARGARET HEFFERNAN
T h e A rt i fac t P ro j e c t:
P ro c e s s Bo o k
ANDREA GOMEZ
CONTENTS
06
introduction
10
background
& history
18
social impact
30
design solution
36
bibliography
4
01 ART I FACT PROC ES S BOOK/ / I NTR ODUCTI ON
INTRODUCTION
According to the Merriam-Webster the golden throne. So why is it that the concept of
dictionary a toilet is a, “fixed receptacle into using the toilet is so taboo? Is it because it makes
which a person may urinate or defecate, typically us feel vulnerable and exposed? It’s funny to think
consisting of a large bowl connected to a system that using the toilet was something the Romans
for flushing away the waste into a sewer or once considered to be a part of socializing in the
septic tank,” (“Toilet”). These words, in the 21st public baths.
century, don’t happen to bring the prettiest or When I first began this project I was a bit
most glamorous notions to mind. Yet, at the same weary of the artifact I chose. I wondered if I had
time the usage of a toilet is something we are all made a mistake. At the time I did not think of the
but more than accustomed to. On average we toilet as a fascinating artifact with much current
spend roughly two years doing our business on profound relevance. I admit I felt influenced by
7
ART I FACT PROC ES S BOOK / / I NTR ODUCTI ON
THE VACUUM TOILET the now seeming childish stigma associated with PROJECT INTENT PROPOSAL
the object of my study. To me, going to the toilet
The vacuum toilet is something you and following all of the motions, from lifting the lid “My research topic is the toilet. I want
often see in airplanes and trains. It’s a and flushing, was such an automatic dull process. my research topic of toilets to be
type of toilet that has been affected by It was such a minute part of my day that I had
technology in recent years. Today, it’s one specifically focused on its fascinating
never given it much thought; it seemed far from
of the toilets that uses the least amount evolving history and its varied uses
fascinating. But, boy was I wrong.
of water (Toilets Around the World, worldwide. Through the conglomerate
2016). Beginning this project I had no idea what
the outcome would be. I began my preliminary use of illustrations, diagrams, and
research by observing all the different types of photography, I will demonstrate and
toilets I could find. The images on the left will
study the different toilets of the world
give you a small taste of the complex world of
toilets pertaining to cultures, regions, styles, and their impacts on society. I want
and sheer taste. I was amazed to have found all to take a taboo topic that nobody
of these interesting shapes and styles that have chooses to talk about, even though
SQUAT TOILET been unknown to me all this time. As I did a bit it’s an essential part of our everyday
more research I realized that the toilet stood
This toilet type can be both dry or use for something much bigger than what I initially
lives, and normalize it in a palpable and
water to flush. It’s primarily found in thought. The toilet in itself can be a broad object interesting manner. I want the viewer
Asian countries or in some parts of Africa. to tackle since billions of people around the world to understand and acknowledge the
The way it’s used requires for the person from all different countries, economic statuses, wicked ingenious simplicity of an item
to squat over the toilet that is positioned life situations, and religions, make use of it. How
on the floor. Sometimes this method of
we most take for granted when millions
can I look at it? How am I able to comprehend
toilet can become unsanitary (Toilets something that to me at first seems so simple and still don’t have access to it. Technology
Around the World, 2016). make it into something much bigger and long- has affected the toilet tremendously
lasting. How can I help others? This was my biggest through the years yet some people
challenge. After much deliberation I drafted my
worldwide still utilize relatively primal
project intent and began working.
This book will outline all of the process I and unsanitary variations of the toilet.
underwent to get from point A to point B. Point How can we change this? What will
A being something as simple as an object of our this situation look like in 100 years?
choice and point B being the big picture in need I hope that through this project I
COMBINATION TOILET of a design solution. I will make some big leaps
and draw connections you probably didn’t see
can open up the conversation about
For those that are torn between choosing coming but it was a pleasurable experience that an obscure topic we choose not to
a squatting toilet or a western toilet, this humbled me and made me appreciate the tools I talk about and ignore even when we
would be the choice for them. It provides can provide to affect others in this world.
the option for the person to stand or to
interact with it on a daily visit.“
squat depending on their wishes. These
types of toilets can be seen mostly in
Indian homes (Toilets Around the World,
2016).
8 9
02
BACKGROUND & HISTORY
The use of the toilet, as you can imagine, was The toilet has come a long way from its humble yet
sparked by nature’s calling! The need for a place to extremely unsanitary beginnings. Through a few
tend to one’s personal business was created by a centuries it evolved into the toilet we know and
natural physiological need. Of course, 10,000 years love today. The basic concept of the modern toilet
ago there were no ceramic bowls with flushing has not changed in itself since it was invented a
mechanics to do the deed. Instead, most people couple of hundred years ago. It’s something to
probably had a favorite bush. Today, we don’t have think about with today’s modern technology, how
recordings telling us exactly how all of this worked. come it hasn’t transformed?
11
ART I FACT PROC ES S BOOK / / H I STORY
S-Trap | London
First Flush | Minoans, Crete Alexander Cumming came close to
inventing the toilet we know and love
In a castle in the island of
today by developing the S-Trap. This new
Knossos in Crete you can find
invention allowed for water to block smells
the first toilet that we know
and other gases from the sewer.
was flushed with water. By
flushing I mean waste was
washed away with buckets of
water (Wald, The First History).
12 13
ART I FACT PROC ES S BOOK / / H I STORY
14 15
ART I FACT PROC ES S BOOK / / H I STORY
16 17
03 ART I FACT PROC ES S BOOK / / S OC I AL I M PACT
SOCIAL IMPACTS
As I’ve mentioned before, some sort a toilet might be seen as the ultimate luxury.
of toilet situation has existed for as long as we Sometimes all it takes is a little bit of perspective.
humans have been around. This means it has been This part of the research gave me room
with us through the good, the bad, and the ugly of to do plenty of self-reflection and a bit of self-
human society through the ages. When I touched loathing. It made me realize that I give myself
on the history of this artifact in the previous the freedom of taking a lot of things in my life
pages I mentioned the technological advances for granted. There are millions of people that
that have taken place but excluded cultural and don’t have access to something, that for me, has
social relevance. For instance, in America there are become a fact of life such as a toilet. Additionally,
corporations that allow for the toilet to become a through time it has also been the center of racism,
simple commodity whereas in rural India having power, and privilege.
19
ART I FACT PROC ES S BOOK / / S OC I AL I M PACT
2.4
RUSSIA
39,468,700
PAKISTAN
68,666,800
CHINA
BILLION
329,851,200
NIGERIA
130,387,500 INDIA
774,222,300
ETHIOPIA
71,217,200
CONGO INDONESIA
50,833,300 100,168,400
20 21
ART I FACT PROC ES S BOOK / / S OC I AL I M PACT
HEALTH RISKS
22 23
ART I FACT PROC ES S BOOK / / S OC I AL I M PACT
The problem is that it varies depending on begin utilizing the facing hardships. India is not the only place system is really expensive for the city and the
the people of each country, their resources latrines as storage sheds and animal keeps having these issues. The same can be said people.
and government planning. India is one (Royte, Nearly A Billion). for many other countries such as Bangladesh, Having a sewer system doesn’t
the countries struggling with it the most. Personally, I believe it is all about China, and Haiti. necessarily mean the end to the problem.
India has roughly 569 million people still education. But it’s an endless grim cycle. In cities like Delhi, only 56% of the waste is
defecating outdoors. This means in the People first need to be taught about the A HIGH PRICE managed in a proper and safe manner. In
bushes or sometimes even into a direct water dangers and diseases related to open urban cities the problem of open defecation
In countries like the US, the sewers are
source, contaminating the water (Royte, defecation. At the same time, in these small is rising because so is the population and
directly connected to a water treatment
Nearly A Billion). rural areas the poverty levels are extremely there are no more extra toilets in sight.
plan. These plants are costly not only to build
India’s prime minister campaign in 2014 high. This means that if someone has the Communal toilets aren’t people’s favorites
but to keep running and up to standards.
even had the slogan, “toilet before temples.” option of using a latrine as a livestock shelter either. They are dirty, foul, and overcrowded
In lower income countries, the alternative is
With his ideas and positive attitude he to make money to feed their families instead with long lines. The toilets at night can also
collecting the sludge from septic tanks and
planned to put and end to open defecation of a restroom facility, which would they be violent for women since they become
latrines which sometimes isn’t done correctly.
in India by 2019. In order to achieve these choose? Their priorities need to shifted. targets. This leaves citizens opting to
Additionally, households are responsible for
goals, 40 billion dollars were put in place What they need to understand is that better defecate outdoors (Royte, Nearly A Billion).
getting rid of their own waste. Otherwise,
to create latrines and behavior changing sanitation will positively affect every aspect
connecting all the toilets to a main sewer
“blitzes” called the Clean India Mission. of their lives. By having better sanitation
Would all of this work to make a lasting efforts and toilet facilities, people won’t
impact? Hopefully yes, but realistically no. fall sick as often and water sources will
India has deep rooted customs that are hard have a smaller chance of being polluted.
to change. In the past, other governments This in return allows for greater clean water
and leaders have tried implementing these measures to be taken because the results
new latrines in rural areas and nothing would be evident and not truncated by the
changes. What ends up happening is people ignorant but desperate actions of humans.
It’s a domino effect. In the end, children
are the ones who suffer the most when it
comes to contracting diseases related to
feces-contaminated water. The bacteria
found in the water can cause cholera and
even hepatitis A. In a well developed
country these diseases might not have a
high fatality rate but in places like rural India
they do. Diarrheal related illnesses affect
the already malnourished children and can
stunt growth. When a child falls ill they have
to miss school, when they miss school they
are being deprived of the very knowledge
that could potentially save them. Girls also
have a particularly difficult time when they
menstruate because the bathrooms at school
are not adequate and clean. This also forces
the girls to stay at home, missing more days
of school.
This is a problem that needs to be
looked at from all different angles and needs
to be understood from the perspective of
the impoverished individuals that are
24 25
you own the
toilets, you
sir own the
world, always
26 27
ART I FACT PROC ES S BOOK / / S OC I AL I M PACT
A TOTALLY DIFFERENT KIND OF usually take the little ones into the stalls with
SOCIAL IMPACT them. So she mentions that restrooms are
technically equal in space but not when taking
When I said it’s more than just a toilet, I into consideration bodies, experiences, and
meant it. When it comes to sexism, racism, needs (Chemaly, The Everyday).
and power the toilet has found itself at the So it’s not all about sexism but
center of it all. unfortunately racism as well. For a long time
Let’s go back to the Victorian era restrooms were segregated by skin color. Jim
where the toilets were made for men and Crow laws were harsh and inhumane meaning
the creation of gender segregated restrooms black men and women across the nation were
began to be a step in the right direction, demanded by law to actually use different
somewhat. Before the social construct of toilets, if they were even available. This
extreme privacy and intimacy of the toilet would translate to the ultimate act of white
came to be, people had no qualms about supremacy and ignorance. Jim Crow laws led
using the toilet together (remember the to accommodations and facilities that were
Roman baths?) and not separated by sex. inferior than those for whites (Hansan, 2011).
In London, as urbanization and presumed More recently, the issues of gender
morality soared, a more solid concept of segregated restrooms have come to light
privacy and this vulnerability associated with due to the topic of gender itself and what it
the toilet came to be. The horrible thing is entails for trans-gender people. For instance,
that the public restrooms primarily catered to a controversial law was passed in North
men at the time. Some places even refused Carolina that instructed people to use the
to hire women because they could not bathroom that corresponded to the gender
accommodate them to their facilities. Women listed on their birth certificate.
could go out of the house as far as their
bladders could take them. Women even had
to resort to utilizing a sort of device
that they could place underneath
their dresses, called a urinette, so they
could relieve themselves sometimes
even on the side of the street (Moss,
The Dirty Secret).
Even in today’s day and age we see
some problems between restrooms for men
and women. Soraya Chemaly wrote an article
for TIME magazine that highlighted the sexist
nature of today’s queues to use the restroom.
Personally I would not call it sexist but just a
complete lack of understanding and reality.
When you go to a football game and during
halftime everyone rushes to the restroom,
you will see longer desperate lines for the
females and not the males. Why is that? Well
Chemaly brings up excellent points. Initially,
the women have to sit whereas men can use
an urinal, cutting the space in half allowing
for more urinals. Women also menstruate and
28 29
04 ART I FACT PROC ES S BOOK / / DES I GN S OLUTI ON
31
PROJECT PROPOSAL encountered was what if I would like to learn
more about other unspoken of issues that
Out of the three design solutions I had
exist, where would I go? What if I wanted
finalized, the phone application won my heart
to help this problem or hear interviews?
and is the one I have decided to pitch as
I’d probably have to conduct an extensive
my ultimate design solution. The inspiration
Google search hoping the sources were
for this app came about after realizing my
correct.
extreme lack of knowledge of issues that
All of this gave me even more energy
affect other countries or other people in this
and encouragement to create Omitted.
world, sometimes here in the United States.
Omitted will provide users with simple and
It’s not just about the lack of knowledge but
quick different type of “news.” It’ll give us
also about my interest of wanting to know
the awareness of other people’s problems
more; how many other problems are out
that are not just our own. I titled it Omitted
there that affect millions of people each
because usually things like the toilet are
day yet I don’t know about them? There are
topics we choose to not think about because
bound to be others around the globe that
they make us feel uncomfortable, dirty, or
want to become more in tune with the world
ashamed. They are the issues that constantly
just like me.
get left out of the narrative, and ultimately,
In the beginning, I was particularly
out of our lives.
driven and interested by the lack of coverage
I also didn’t want this to be the next
by mainstream news sites and by news sites
trendy thing, Instead it can become a place
I’m not particularly referring to the videos
where people can share comments and
your aunt shares on FaceBook about sick
stories. Making it more of an encouraging
puppies. Even though this could become
and positive community working together for
a more serious outlet since it’s constant
a common goal: to become more aware of
content people are exposed to each day
the problems that exist in this world.
regularly, but how can we make it more
than just a thumbs up? The other issue I
32 33
FUTURE VISION & PLANS book is quickly coming to an end let me add
that I have thoroughly enjoyed all of the parts
Above you can see what the app could
and pieces that have made this book what
potentially look like. The branding and colors
it is. It was something that I was originally
from the design actually heavily influenced
afraid of doing, I mean a toilet? Yuck. But
the look and feel of this book. I want it to
I can say with all of my heart that my heart
be captivating and engaging. Since some of
and mind are changed. It was a pleasure.
the topics covered could potentially be really
Thankfully, this process is not done just yet!
sensitive or just difficult to discuss I want
Here are some of the things I plan on doing
to create a system with vibrant yet serious
as part of my next steps:
tones.
Ideally, the next steps of this • Personas
project would be to fully go into design • User Flow Charts
and prototyping mode! I want to create
• Prototypes
something that does all of my research and
people I’ve read about justice. I am looking • Scenario Maps/User Stories
forward to reading about other topics that • User Tests
aren’t talked about enough and it would be • Animation Tests
my honor to shed some light on them. As this
34 35
BIBLIOGRAPHY Unknown - Provided by the Associated Press in New Delhi. “Billions Have No Access to Toilets, Says World Health
Organisation
Axford, Martin. “Hume, Robert: Thomas Crapper: Lavatory Legend.” School Librarian, Summer 2010, p. 122+. Report.” The Guardian, 1 July 2015, www.theguardian.com/society/2015/jul/01/billions-have-no-access-to-
Literature Resource Center, http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A243042681/Li- toilets-says
tRC?u=gain40375&sid=LitRC&xid=83707923. Accessed 14 Apr. 2018. world-health-organisation-report.
Bottomley, Frank. The Castle Explorer’s Guide. London: Kaye & Ward Ltd. 1979. p. 70 Unknown. “Sanitation: Fact Sheet.” World Health Organization, World Health Organization, 19 July 2017, www.
who.int/en
Chemaly, Soraya. “The Everyday Sexism of Women Waiting in Public Toilet Lines.” Time Magazine, 5 Jan. 2015, news-room/fact-sheets/detail/sanitation.
time.
com/3653871/womens-bathroom-lines-sexist-potty-parity/. Unknown. “The Men That Made the Water Closet.” Plumbing & Mechanical Magazine, 1 July 1994, theplumber.
com/the
Collinson, Alwyn. “Women’s Right to Sit Comfortably.” Museum of London, 6 Sept. 2017, www.museumoflondon. men-that-made-the-water-closet/.
org.uk
discover/womens-right-work-toilet-bathroom-victorian-london-wwi-factory-protest. Wald, Chelsea. “ The Secret History of Ancient Toilets.” Nature: International Weekly Journal of Science, vol. 533,
no. 7604, 26
Hansan, J.E. (2011). Jim Crow laws and racial segregation. Social Welfare History Project. Retrieved [date ac- May 2016, p. 533.
cessed] from
http://socialwelfare.library.vcu.edu/eras/civil-war-reconstruction/jim-crow-laws-andracial-segregation/
Kleiner, Diana E.E. “The Archaeology of Sanitation in Roman Italy: Toilets, Sewers, and Water Systems.” The Histo-
rian, no. 3,
2017, p. 635.
Koloski-Ostrow, Ann Olga. “Talking Heads: What Toilets and Sewers Tell Us about Ancient Roman Sanitation.” The
Conve
sation, 30 Apr. 2018, theconversation.com/talking-heads-what-toilets-and-sewers-tell-us-about-ancient-ro-
man-sanit
tion-50045.
Moss, Candida. “The Dirty Secret About Ancient Bathrooms.” Sordid Business, The Daily Beast, 20 Nov. 2016,
www.thedail
beast.com/the-dirty-secret-about-ancient-bathrooms?ref=scroll.
Royte, Elizabeth. “Nearly a Billion People Defecate Outdoors. Here’s Why.” National Geographic, Aug. 2017.
Suddath, Claire. “A Brief History of Toilets.” Time Magazine, 19 Nov. 2009, content.time.com/time/health/arti
cle/0,8599,1940525,00.html.
Thomas, George. “We Take It for Granted, but This Woman Has Walked 190,000 Miles for This Daily Need.” CBN
News, 12 July
2017, www1.cbn.com/cbnnews/world/2017/july/this-woman-has-walked-190-000-miles-for-water.
“Toilets around the World - Different Types of Toilets | Ben Franklin.” Benjamin Franklin Plumbing, Inc., 21 Oct.
2016, www.bfplumbingbayarea.com/blog/toilets-around-the-world/.
Unknown. “The History of Thomas Crapper.” The History of Thomas Crapper & Co, www.thomas-crapper.com/
The-Hist
ry-of-Thomas-Crapper.html.
36 37
thank you
38