Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: This paper describes the production of fully consolidated wires from aluminum alloy AA2050 and alu-
Received 1 February 2010 minum alloy AA2195 machining chips via the friction extrusion process. In this work, the extrusion rate
Received in revised form 16 June 2010 was linearly related to the power input/die rotational speed. Hot crack and cold crack defects appeared
Accepted 16 August 2010
on wires produced using either too high or too low a power input/die rotational speed. The extruded
wire microstructure consisted of fully equiaxed, recrystallized grains. Average grain size in the wires
generally increases with the increase of die rotational speed/extrusion power. Micro-hardness was homo-
JEL classification:
geneous across the wire transverse cross-sections. Positive response to post-extrusion heat treatment
81.20.Hy
was observed with increasing extrusion power indicating increasing temperature and in process solu-
Keywords: tion heat treatment of the wire with sufficient extrusion power. The ductility of defect free wire was
Friction extrusion demonstrated by the absence of cracking in 5T bend tests.
Recycling © 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Wire
1. Introduction cussed. The effect of cold press pressure prior to melting process in
aluminum chips recycling was studied by Mashhadi et al. (2009).
There are two primary methods of recycling aluminum chips Aluminum chips were granulated, cold compacted and extruded at
to produce a useful product: the so-called ‘conventional’ method the temperature range of 500–550 ◦ C by Gronostajski and Matuszak
and the direct conversion method (Tekkaya et al., 2009). The con- (1999), and additional sintering process was added before the final
ventional method requires melting of the material to be recycled, extrusion of aluminum chips recycling by Samuel (2003). 6061 alu-
casting of a billet, and then hot extrusion of the billet to form a minum blocks were directly hot extruded from compacted chips
consolidated product in wire or rod form. The direct conversion by Tekkaya et al. (2009). Al powder was added as a soft matrix in
method utilizes conventional hot extrusion which may or may the 7075 aluminum chips direct conversion process, and the influ-
not be preceded by a static pressing stage. Compared with con- ence of Al powder content and extrusion temperature in products
ventional recycling, the direct conversion of aluminum scrap into mechanical properties were discussed by Sherafat et al. (2009).
compact metal may result in 40% material, 26–31% energy and Friction stir processing (FSP) and friction stir welding (FSW) are
16–60% labor savings (Gronostajski and Matuszak, 1999). In the solid state processes for microstructure modification and joining,
past decade, research works of aluminum chips recycling were car- respectively. Both rely on plastic dissipation for heat genera-
ried out with both ‘conventional’ and direct conversion methods. tion and may be considered severe plastic deformation processes.
Various aluminum turning scraps were melted at 800 ◦ C to recover FSW was patented by The Welding Institute in 1991 (Thomas et
aluminum metal with the protective salt flux under nitrogen atmo- al., 1991). In both technologies, welding and processing, a rotat-
sphere by Xiao and Reuter (2002). In that paper, it also showed that ing, non-consumable tool, is used to produce a plasticized layer
the difficulty of recycling the selected aluminum scrap depends on which undergoes severe plastic deformation and heating. Gener-
scrap type, scrap size distribution, contaminant, and the ratio of ally speaking, application of FSP to metals results fine grains in
surface area to body volume. The recyclability of aluminum chips the processed zone due to substantial deformation at hot work-
was experimentally studied by Puga et al. (2009) by using differ- ing temperatures. In addition, FSP has been used to close porosity
ent melting techniques and the influence of chips preparation in in castings as shown by Fuller et al. (2007) in an application to
the aluminum alloy recovery rate and dross production was dis- Ni–Al bronze. In 1993 another friction based process, friction extru-
sion, was patented by The Welding Institute (Thomas et al., 1993).
This patent was allowed to lapse in the early part of this decade.
However, there are some attractive aspects of the friction extrusion
∗ Corresponding author. Tel.: +1 803 777 1279; fax: +1 803 777 0106.
process and it may yet prove to be an industrially useful technique
E-mail addresses: tang@cec.sc.edu (W. Tang), reynolds@cec.sc.edu
(A.P. Reynolds). for the achievement of several purposes, e.g. recycling of machin-
1 1
Tel.: +1 803 777 9548; fax: +1 803 777 0106. ing waste, consolidation of powder product and, potentially, as a
0924-0136/$ – see front matter © 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2010.08.010
2232 W. Tang, A.P. Reynolds / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 210 (2010) 2231–2237
Fig. 4. Macro-views of wires produced by friction extrusion. (a) Alloy/rpm from top
to bottom: 2050/400 rpm, 2195/200 rpm, 2195/100 rpm. (b) 2050 wire (250 rpm)
after 5T bend.
Fig. 3. Milled aluminum chips for direct conversion to wire via friction extrusion.
Each unit on the scale represents 1 mm.
Fig. 5 shows higher magnification views of representative
defective wires. The wires extruded at 300 and 400 rpm exhib-
in normal industrial practice the aging step is typically preceded ited closely spaced, circumferential, surface, cracks as shown in
by a solution heat treatment, water quenching, and stretching to Fig. 5(a). The cracks were not observed over the entire wire
several percent plastic deformation. surface. In the 2050 wires extruded at 300 and 400 rpm, the
cracks appeared after 125 mm and 75 mm of extrusion, respec-
2.3. Metallography and mechanical testing tively. The 2195 wire produced at 300 rpm exhibited cracking after
90 mm of wire was extruded. Fig. 5(b) shows the surface of a
Wires were initially inspected visually. Subsequently, trans- 2195 wire extruded at 100 rpm. In this wire, the surface defect
verse and longitudinal cross-sections of the extruded wires were appears to be a result of cold tearing and individual tears do not
ground, polished and etched with Keller’s Reagent (190 ml water, extend around the entire circumference; however, the tearing is
2 ml HF, 3 ml HCl, and 5 ml HNO3 ). Microstructures were examined present along the entire length of the wire. Also evident on the
by optical microscopy. The grain size of each wire was measured 100 rpm wire is the low pitch twist mentioned in the previous
using the mean linear intercept method (ASTM, 2004). paragraph.
Vickers micro-hardness tests were performed on the wire
transverse cross-section. On each wire a hardness traverse was 3.2. Extrusion rate and power
made along an entire diameter with an indentation spacing of
0.254 mm (10 or 11 indents), a load of 200 g, and a loading time Typical curves of die movement, Z-axis load, and die rotational
of 10 s (HV200). Hardness was measured in as extruded and post- speed during extrusion are shown in Fig. 6. The die rotation rate is
extrusion heat treated conditions. Bend tests were carried out on quite steady and in accord with the commanded value during the
selected, as extruded, wire (i.e. prior to PEHT). Wires were bent extrusion process. The Z-axis force was fairly stable although some
around a mandrel with a radius of 12.5 mm (approximately five spikes can be observed. Also, there is a substantial spike in load dur-
times the wire thickness). ing the highly transient, initial portion of the process (near 10 s).
3. Results
Defect free wires were produced from both 2050 and 2195
chips at intermediate die rotation rates (150, 200, and 250 rpm).
At all other die rotation rates, surface flaws were observed visu-
ally. Fig. 4(a) shows representative good quality and poor quality
wires. The top wire in the figure is a 2050 wire produced with a die
rotation rate of 400 rpm. Cracks may be observed over about 50%
of the wire surface. The middle wire is 2195 produced at 200 rpm:
the entire surface is quite smooth but a slight twist can be seen
especially on the left. The wire at the bottom of the figure is 2195
produced at 100 rpm. The low rpm wire exhibits cold tearing along
the entire length of the wire and a more pronounced twist. In gen-
eral, the twist is not obvious on any of the wires made at die rotation
rates greater than or equal to 250 rpm but becomes more apparent
with decreasing rpm below 250. All the defect free wires exhibit
Fig. 5. Extruded wire surface defects caused by excessively high or low die rotation
good ductility in the as-extruded condition as evidenced by their rates (wire diameter of 2.5 mm sets scale). (a) 2050 wire extruded with 400 rpm die
performance in bend tests (Fig. 4(b) for example). rotation rate and (b) 2195 wire extruded with 100 rpm die rotation rate.
2234 W. Tang, A.P. Reynolds / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 210 (2010) 2231–2237
Fig. 12 shows the average hardness for all wires before and after
post-extrusion heat treatment. The results are based on 10 or 11
evenly spaced Vickers micro-hardness indentations made across
the transverse cross-section of each wire both before and after post-
extrusion heat treatment (e.g. Fig. 9(a)). In the figure, the error bars
are representative of one standard deviation. With one exception
the standard deviations are very small: less than 3% of the mean.
In the case with the greatest variability (2050 wire produced at
150 rpm and post-extrusion heat treated) the coefficient of varia-
tion is still less than 10%. Though average hardness values changed
with die rotational speed and heat treatment, hardness values in
a single wire cross-section remained relatively constant from the
center to the edge. Several observations can be made based on the
data in the figure. The as-extruded hardness values for the 2050
wires and the 2195 wires are very similar for a given die rotation
rate: there is more separation for the post-extrusion heat treated
Fig. 7. 2195 wire length vs. extrusion time for different wire rotation rates. results. The as-extruded hardness values of the wires produced at
W. Tang, A.P. Reynolds / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 210 (2010) 2231–2237 2235
Fig. 9. Transverse cross-sections of wire extruded with different die rotation rates. (a) 2195 wire extruded with 100 rpm rotational speed, (b) 2195 wire extruded with
250 rpm rotational speed, (c) 2050 wire extruded with 400 rpm rotational speed.
100 rpm are the lowest: for higher die rotation rates there is very lit- The observed die rotation rate limits are almost certainly functions
tle difference in hardness. At all rotation rates greater than 100 rpm, of the parameters which have not been varied during this study,
post-extrusion heat treatment results in an increase of the average e.g. die geometry, extrusion force, and alloy composition. How-
hardness while at 100 rpm, post-extrusion heat treatment causes a ever, it is likely that the underlying, critical factor is the extrusion
slight decrease in hardness. The post-extrusion heat treated hard- temperature. As for FSW, it is very difficult to access the actual
ness values increase rapidly with increasing die rotation rate up temperature in the process zone. For friction extrusion, the heat
to 300 rpm for the 2050 and 250 rpm for the 2195. Above these source is contained in the deforming volume and it is not possi-
rotation rates, the hardness values reach a plateau. ble to introduce a thermocouple into this region. However, relative
The hardness and grain size data indicate a high level of homo- values of extrusion temperature can be deduced from the extruded
geneity across the wire cross-sections. This is likely due to the wire grain size when the material is the same. As in FSW, the higher
fact that after sufficient deformation to ensure consolidation is the processing temperature the bigger the grain size. (A measure
achieved, the microstructure and properties are then determined of the average welding temperature in friction stir welding is rel-
primarily by the temperature at which the final extrusion takes atively easy to obtain from thermocouples embedded in the tool
place. As in FSW, this final deformation temperature dictates the pin.) Therefore, by comparing grain size and grain size change with
grain size and (for precipitation hardening alloys) the level of solute rotational rate trends of the extruded wires we can obtain a basic
super saturation. idea of how the temperature varies with friction wire extrusion
processing parameters.
4. Discussion The relationship between wire grain size and die rotation rate
(Fig. 11) is very similar to that typically observed between friction
It is apparent that the process window for production of good stir weld (FSW) nugget grain size and friction stir weld tool rotation
quality wires by the friction extrusion process (as practiced in this rate. In Fig. 11, both wire grain sizes increased with the increase
study) is bounded by upper and lower values of die rotation rate. of die rotational speeds, and the increase of 2050 wire grain size
2236 W. Tang, A.P. Reynolds / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 210 (2010) 2231–2237
Fig. 12. Average Vickers hardness of 2050 and 2195 wires as functions of die rotation
rate. Error bars indicate one standard deviation.
(1) Defect free 2050 and 2195 aluminum wire can be directly pro-
duced from machining chips by the friction extrusion process.
Limits on the process appear to be related to the extrusion tem-
perature which, if too low, results in cold tearing and, if too high,
causes what appears to be a form of hot cracking.
(2) The wire extrusion rate is directly related to the extrusion
Fig. 11. Wire grain size as a function of die rotation rate. power for the range of parameters examined in this paper.
W. Tang, A.P. Reynolds / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 210 (2010) 2231–2237 2237
(3) The microstructure of the friction extruded wire is character- Hassan, K.A.A., Prangnell, P.B., Norman, A.F., Price, D.A., Williams, S.W., 2003. Effect
ized by equiaxed, recrystallized, grains: the average grain size of welding parameters on nugget zone microstructure and properties in high
strength aluminum alloy friction stir welds. Science and Technology of Welding
increases with increasing power up to some limiting value. and Joining 8, 257–268.
(4) The hardness of the wires is relatively homogeneous: a suffi- Jata, K.V., Semiatin, S.L., 2000. Continuous dynamic recrystallization during friction
ciently high extrusion temperature is required to promote good stir welding of high strength aluminum alloys. Scripta Materialia 43, 743–749.
Long, T., Reynolds, A.P., 2006. Parametric studies of friction stir welding by commer-
response to post-extrusion heat treatment by artificial aging. cial fluid dynamics simulation. Science and Technology of Welding and Joining
(5) Good bend ductility was exhibited by the as-extruded wires 11, 200–208.
which were produced using an intermediate die rotation Long, T., Tang, W., Reynolds, A.P., 2007. Process response parameter relationships
in aluminum alloy friction stir welds. Science and Technology of Welding and
rate. Joining 12, 311–317.
Mashhadi, H., Amini, Moloodi, A., Golestanipour, M., Karimi, E.Z.V., 2009. Recycling
While good quality wire has been produced using the friction of aluminium alloy turning scrap via cold pressing and melting with salt flux.
Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 3138–3142.
extrusion process, in order to improve the utility of the process, it
Puga, H., Barbosa, J., Soares, D., Silva, F., Ribeiro, S., 2009. Recycling of aluminium
will be necessary to increase the attainable extrusion rates with- swarf by direct incorporation in aluminium melts. Journal of Materials Process-
out entering the die rotation rate regime which causes overheating. ing Technology 209, 5195–5203.
This will necessitate research into effects of die geometry and extru- Reynolds, A.P., Tang, W., Khandkar, Z., Khan, J.A., Lindner, K., 2005. Relationships
among weld parameters, hardness distributions, and temperature histories in
sion force on extrusion rate and quality. alloy 7050 friction stir welds. Science and Technology of Welding and Joining
10, 190–199.
Samuel, M., 2003. A new technique for recycling aluminium scrap. Journal of Mate-
References rials Processing Technology 135, 117–124.
Sato, Y.S., Urata, M., Kokawa, H., 2002. Parameters controlling microstructure and
ASTM Standard #E112, 2004. Standard test methods for determining average grain hardness during friction-stir welding of precipitation-hardenable aluminum
size. alloy 6063. Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A 33, 625–635.
Fonda, R.W., Bingert, J.F., Colligan, K.J., 2004. Development of grain structure during Sherafat, Z., Paydar, M.H., Ebrahimi, R., 2009. Fabrication of Al7075/Al, two phase
friction stir welding. Scripta Materialia 51, 243–248. material, by recycling Al7075 alloy chips using powder metallurgy route. Journal
Fuller, M.D., Swaminathan, S., Zhilyaev, A.P., McNelley, T.R., 2007. Microstructural of Alloys and Compounds 487, 395–399.
transformations and mechanical properties of cast NiAl bronze: effects of fusion Tekkaya, A.E, Schikorra, M., Becker, D., Biermann, D., Hammer, N., Pantke, K., 2009.
welding and friction stir processing. Materials Science and Engineering A 463, Hot profile extrusion of AA-6060 aluminum chips. Journal of Materials Process-
128–137. ing Technology 209, 3343–3350.
Gerlich, A., Yamamoto, M., North, T.H., 2008. Local melting and tool slippage dur- Thomas, W.M., Nicholas, E.D., Needham, J.C., Church, M.G. Templesmith, P., Dawes,
ing friction stir spot welding of Al-alloys. Journal of Materials Science 43, C.J., 1991. International Patent Application No. PCT/GB92/02203 and GB Patent
2–11. Application No. 9125978.9.
Gronostajski, J., Matuszak, A., 1999. The recycling of metals by plastic deformation: Thomas, W.M., Nicholas, E.D., Jones, S.B., 1993. US Patent # 5,262,123.
an example of recycling of aluminum and its alloy chips. Journal of Materials Xiao, Y., Reuter, M.A., 2002. Recycling of distributed aluminum turning scrap. Min-
Processing Technology 92–93, 35–41. erals Engineering 15, 963–970.