Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FOIA REQUEST
Fee waiver requested
Expedited processing requested
Pursuant to the federal Freedom of Information Act, 5 U.S.C. § 552, Legalprise, Inc.
requests access to and copies of all communications and documents regarding the
regulation of law firms that file and prosecute foreclosure lawsuits.
This request is being sent to the FTC, FHA/HUD, and SEC. Legalprise, Inc.’s purpose in
seeking this information stems from the following actions on behalf of each agency
individually and collectively:
Federal Trade Commission. The FTC has initiated and moved forward with regulation
aimed, in part, at licensed attorneys working on behalf of foreclosure defendants. The
FTC’s stated motivation for regulation is an allegation that the foreclosure defense bar
1
consistently engages in consumer fraud. While it is true that particular foreclosure
defense attorneys acted in contravention of the ethical regulations of their state’s bar,
those attorneys represent a nominal fraction of foreclosure defense attorneys, were
promptly disciplined by their state’s bar, and have otherwise been managed by the legal
community. Because the actions of a few attorneys hardly represents a systemic issue
within the foreclosure defense bar, and because only approximately 3% of homeowners
retain counsel, regulations that further restrict the availability of licensed legal
representation only exacerbate the housing crisis. Further, conspicuously absent from the
regulation’s purview are restrictions on foreclosure prosecution attorneys. The documents
attached to this request as “Appendix A” and “Appendix B” demonstrate the need for
such regulation because they regard unethical conduct by Florida’s largest “foreclosure
mill,” The Law Offices of David J. Stern, P.A. despite previous bar sanction.
Securities & Exchange Commission. Mr. Stern recently took public the “back-office”
processing component of his law firm, trading under ticker “DJSP.” The prospectus of
DJSP indentifies that the company’s core product, foreclosure processing, may constitute
the unlicensed practice of law but fails to disclose that its former iteration was disciplined
by the Florida Bar for exactly that same infraction, nor that the discipline included a
guilty plea for filing false affidavits2. Please explain why the SEC is allowing DJSP
stock to continue trading given that the company failed to disclose it’s prior dealings with
the Florida Bar and continues to operate in direct violation of the findings and mandates
of the Florida Bar by processing 6,000 foreclosures per month under the names of only
approximately 15 attorneys. Additionally, please also disclose any enhanced due
diligence steps the SEC took to protect the public from Mr. Stern, the CEO of DJSP, who
has a history of filing materially false and misleading documents in official proceedings.
1 http://www.tewlaw.com/attorneys/cardenas‐alberto/
2 http://google.brand.edgar‐online.com/displayfilinginfo.aspx?FilingID=7333260‐50390‐
100834&type=sect&TabIndex=2&companyid=784122&ppu=%252fdefault.aspx%253fsym%253dDJSP, page 11
2
All Agencies. Please disclose the names of all decision makers responsible for
monitoring ethical compliance and the specific policies and procedures of such
monitoring, including all documents related to the ethical or financial ramifications
involved with high-volume foreclosure filers.
Where possible, Legalprise, Inc. would like to receive all information produced as a
result of this request in electronic format.
If Legalprise, Inc.’s request is denied in whole or part, it asks that you justify all deletions
by reference to specific exemptions of the act. It also expects you to release all segregable
portions of otherwise exempt material. Legalprise, Inc. also reserves the right to appeal
your decision to withhold any information or to deny a waiver of fees.
Please waive any applicable fees. Release of the information requested is in the public’s
interest because it will contribute significantly to the public’s understanding of
government operations and activities. The information sought is in the public's interest
because the current housing crisis is, in part, a result of the reckless and fraudulent
prosecution of foreclosure suits by “foreclosure mill” law firms. Legalprise, Inc. intends
to immediately aggregate and publicly disseminate any information obtained as a result
of this request in order to spotlight the inadequate attention given to “foreclosure mill”
practices. It is Legalprise’s hope that raising awareness of the issue will lead to legislative
or administrative action in the near future.
Legalprise, Inc. requests expedited processing of this request because it concerns a matter
of urgency. As a research company that works closely with journalists, homeowner
advocates, and licensed attorneys, Legalprise, Inc. is primarily engaged in disseminating
information for public benefit. The public has an urgent need for information about
discussions related to potential regulations of foreclosure prosecution practices because
informed members of the public might contribute through lobbying or other contacts with
public officials, and, in these instances, delay would deny the public of its ability to make
known its views in a timely manner. We, on behalf of Legalprise, Inc., certify that its
statements concerning the need for expedited processing are true and correct to the best
of our knowledge and belief.
Legalprise, Inc., its owners, and the undersigned foreclosure advocates look forward to
your reply within 20 business days, as the statute requires.
3
Sincerely,
Cosigners:
4
/s/ Ashley G. Abano /s/ Richard A. Hall
Ashley G. Abano, Esq. Richard A. Hall, Esq.
President, Founder President, Founder
Law Offices of Ashley G. Abano, APLC BottomLine Lawyers
San Diego, CA Auburn, CA
5