Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
The Indian telecom sector like any other industrial sector in the country has gone
through many phases of growth and diversification. Starting from telegraphic services,
the field of telecommunication has now expanded to make use of technologies like Glo-
bal System of Mobile Communication (GSM), Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA)
and Wireless in Local Loop (WLL) to 3G in the mobile phones. The research focuses on
Customer Satisfaction of Mobile Phone Service Users Operating in the Malwa Region of
the Punjab. In this study the opinions of 75 respondents were taken. The tools used for
collecting the data were structured questionnaire and unstructured interview. For analy-
sis purposes, Cronbach’s Alpha, Weighted Average, Ranking, Chi Square and the Per-
centage method have been used. The results revealed that most of the respondents were
satisfied with their current service provider but still twenty percent respondent’s want to
shift their service provider show maximum willingness for shifting to Airtel. Call
Charges was the main reason of changing the service provider, with a weighed score of
3.53, followed by Poor Network and Poor Customer Care Service, having weighted
scores of 3.21 and 2.20 respectively.
Keywords: Customer Satisfaction, Value Added Services, General Packet Ra-
dio Service, Short Message Service and Customer Care.
º·¤Ñ´ÂèÍ
æ ¢Í§¡ÒÃàµÔºâµáÅФÇÒÁËÅÒ¡ËÅÒ â´ÂàÃÔèÁµé¹¨Ò¡¡ÒúÃÔ¡ÒÃâ·ÃàÅ¢áÅéÇ¢ÂÒÂÁÒà»ç¹¡ÒÃãªé
¤ÇÒÁ¾Ö§¾Í㨢ͧÅÙ¡¤éÒµèÍ¡ÒÃãËéºÃÔ¡ÒÃÁ×Ͷ×Íá¡è¼Ùéãªéã¹à¢µÁÑÅÇҢͧá¤Çé¹»Ñ-¨Òº §Ò
________________________________
*Mr. Vipan Bansal obtains M Phil (Management), MBA (Marketing), M Tech (Industrial
Engineering) and B Tech in Mechanical. He is an assistant professor in Mechanical at DAV
University, Jalandhar Punjab, India. His interests cover Production and Operation Management.
**Ms. Bindu Bansal obtains M Tech and B Tech in Computer Science Engineering. He is an
assistant professor in Computer Science Department at Guru Nanak Dev Engineering College,
Ludhiana Punjab, India. His interests cover Image Processing.
31
Vipan Bansal and Bindu Bansal
32
A Study on Customer Satisfaction of Mobile Phone Service Users Operating in the
Malwa Region of the Punjab
ducted at first stage to identify factors that Chaterjee and Chaudhuri (2010) iden-
contributed towards the customer satisfac- tified the most important and least impor-
tion of mobile phone users. It was tant factors affecting choice of service pro-
followed by a questionnaire to gather vider operating in Kolkata. The study was
quantitative data and further analysis was conducted with 337 respondents within an
done by us-ing conformity factor analysis. age group of 18-25 years by using the
The results confirmed a multidimensional Herfindahl Index (HHI), ANOVA and Rank
construct of customer satisfaction in the Score Analysis. The result revealed that the
Pakistani cel-lular phone communication factors like good network coverage and
sector. Cus-tomer satisfaction of cellular family or friends using the same network are
phone users in Pakistan consisted of four of utmost importance to the customers
factors includ-ing price, transmission whereas the offer of free connection with the
quality, usage ease and service support. handset being the least important one.
Qureshi and Sahu (2009) revealed that Sathish et al. (2011) examined the factors
Airtel is the market leader in the lifetime that influence the consumers in switching
plan segment in Bhopal followed by Idea. the service provider. The area covered un-
People like the lifetime plans provided by der this study was Chennai, with a sample
the companies. TATA Indicom has the least size of 112 respondents. The variables con-
customers in Bhopal, whereas Reliance and sidered for the study were consumer de-
BSNL have an almost equal percentage of mographics, consumer satisfaction with the
customers. But respondents were not aware existing service provider. Factors influenc-
about the bond of cellular compa-nies with ing the switching behavior and factors that
TRAI, that cellular companies can deliver affect the switching behavior of consum-ers
their services till their licenses have validity, were grouped into customer service, service
and they have to renew them for providing problems and usage cost. The re-sults from
further service. the study revealed that call rates played the
Chander (2010) assessed the usage most important role in switch-ing the service
pattern of functionalities of mobile phone provider followed by net-work coverage;
handsets and customer satisfaction level of value added service and customer care while
mobile phone users. Presales/sales, net- advertisement played the least important
work, VAS, cost of service, customer care role.
and billing were identified as six broad pa- Mariappan (2011) conducted a study on
rameters that contribute to overall satis- the sensitive issue of banning of mobile
faction of mobile phone users with their phones within the collegiate premises. A
mobile service provider. It has also been sample of size 1200 respondents was taken
found that none of the mobile service pro- by mixing college students and their par-ents
viders in Jammu City were able to meet and teachers. For analysis chi-square,
the benchmarks set up by TRAI, on any of measures of central tendency and coeffi-
six broad parameters namely cient of variation were used. It was found
presales/sales, network, VAS, cost of that popular brands among the student re-
service, customer care and billing. spondents were Nokia followed by Sonny
33
Vipan Bansal and Bindu Bansal
34
A Study on Customer Satisfaction of Mobile Phone Service Users Operating in the
Malwa Region of the Punjab
35
Vipan Bansal and Bindu Bansal
36
A Study on Customer Satisfaction of Mobile Phone Service Users Operating in the
Malwa Region of the Punjab
dents have been using pre-paid plans while tomer care department followed by roam-ing
29% have been using post-paid plans and and the SMS plan. As discussed above these
16% of respondents use both pre-paid and Value Added Services were mostly used by
post-paid connections. The reasons for a the respondents but the lack of clar-ity in
higher percentage of respondents using charges and activation and deactiva-tion of
prepaid connection may be because of these VAS make the respondents
higher transparency in this category. Yet it uncomfortable and they need to frequently
has been observed that different respon- talk to the customer care department for
dents prefer different plans according to their queries. So, if the companies bring the
their requirement and there is also a cat- more clarity into their billing and plans i.e.
egory which enjoys the benefits offered by the SMS plan it will reduce the burden on
both the plans. the customer care department and brings
From the Table 6, it has been found that more customer satisfaction.
SMS is ranked first place by the respon- It has been found that 45% of respon-
dents as usage of VAS followed by GPRS. dents are satisfied after contacting the cus-
A major driver of SMS may have been the tomer care department. 11% of respon-dents
TV reality and game shows etc. Even the are not satisfied with the customer care
start and close of VAS is also done with the department. 44% are neither satisfied nor
help of SMS. Caller tones and GPRS occupy dissatisfied with the customer care de-
third and fourth place respectively in terms partment. 46% of respondents feel that dif-
of usage of VAS. Voice Mail is the VAS ficulty in connecting with the customer care
which is least preferred by the re-spondents, department was the main reason of dissat-
having a weighted score of 1.51. isfaction. Most of the time the call was not
From the Table 7, it has found that bill- connected to the customer care depart-ment.
ing is the main reason to contact the cus- If the call was connected, the respon-
Table 6: Usage Pattern of Value Added Services
Use of VAS Very Often Sometimes Rarely Never Total Weighted Ranking
Often Average
SMS 27 19 13 1 15 75 3.56 1
MMS 1 8 5 6 55 75 1.59 4
Voice Mail 1 7 3 7 57 75 1.51 5
Caller Tone 5 14 11 10 35 75 2.25 2
GPRS 6 10 15 8 36 75 2.23 3
37
Vipan Bansal and Bindu Bansal
dents had to go through a number of op- The Analysis depicts that Airtel seems
tions to talk to the customer care depart- to be the best service provider in the
ment, which irritates the respondents and Malwa region because of two reasons.
brings dissatisfaction to the minds of the First it has the maximum share (%age).
respondents. 27% of respondents feel that Second maxi-mum respondents shifted
the time taken by the centre for a complaint towards Airtel after their dissatisfaction
was too long. 15% think that customer care with other service providers.
executives were not equipped with ad- It has been depicted in Table 9 that Call
equate information. 6% said customer care Charges is the main reason for shifting the
executives were not polite and 6% have the service provider followed by Poor Network
opinion that customer care executives were and Poor Customer Care Service.
not able to understand the problem. Very
few think that customer care execu-tives
activated unwanted services which created a CONCLUSIONS
feeling of dissatisfaction.
Table 8 shows the Net Gain and Loss 1. It has been found that the
of Service Providers after shifting. It has majority of respondents use the mobile
been found that Airtel gains 27% respon- phone to make calls (weighted score of
dents which shows the faith of the 4.35) fol-lowed by alarm clock
respon-dents in Airtel whereas Idea loses (weighted score of 3.92).
20% re-spondents. Aircel and BSNL 2. It has been found that SMS is the
lose their re-spondents by 7% each. most widely used Value Added Service fol-
38
A Study on Customer Satisfaction of Mobile Phone Service Users Operating in the
Malwa Region of the Punjab
39
Vipan Bansal and Bindu Bansal
40