La lámpara de Diógenes,




 









 *

Juan Manuel Campos Benítez

1. Introducción

 



!
 "
  
! 
!


# !


 "!!#




!


# !
$


!#
" 

 

"!%
"

 "!!#


&'
 "!!#






("


("


# !
&

"! 
!

 "!!#
)
& 

&

!

# !

*



!

 "!!#

!



#
!
!
"







" 
+$#

&

,
)

&
!

# !

*
!

 "!!#
!


!#


 
-
 !

%
"
!#


!
"

!#

!!

!

!

 !

"
%&.
("

 !







 "
!
$
("


!#



!

!#
!

!#



("


("
!

("
 !

"


("'
 !










/
("
!!
!

!0

 "!!#


("



# !
!" 


("






" 



%
%!%
$
("

"


" 
 

"
"


1 
("
.
! 
!

# !
2




 "'



!#

# !

 "!!#
3
 "




!0
("'

 "!!#

("'

# !
2

&


 
"
4

"
("
&
("'

 "
!!#
("'

 "!
"

"

"

" 
!

 
$
("
("
%

""0

%& 

 

5&'


"
("


("
6
("



("

 "
!

# !

-

 


!"#




 
  




!
"

  



!

"
!
.



"!

 "!!#


# !
/
("
 
("





("6.

*
7
0


 

!8

"
7!#



# !

"
!

175
 2. La lógica y sus presentaciones
3
# !

%
 


 

 
"
 


-
 !
 
!
"
6
 "


.
!
 
&
 


 #!

" 

-"! 


9".

"!%


# !

!


.!

"
&



# !
("6.
" 
!
!

!


.!


# !

("
!


 
XIX
!
:
;
 







!"

&

<# !
.!=


7
!.

3
!
 #!


"
!"


! 
!







!
<'!=
("


%
 



 "
>!
3
# !
?
&'


 ?
 

#


"
 "*


! 
"("

!
&#!

6 



7
"
 



("
" 

!" 


<&.&=


%"
!
3



("

#

# !


 @ 
 
.

 






("
("

!"


 

3
!#
("

%!

 "*
"

"
'!!

!"("

!
"
&"
!! 
 @!
 

!!


-
&!


'!

&
 

"
!"


 
!"  
("

" 
 


86
A6
&

%&
&



*

%&

 
*
"
2
+!".


",
3

"#


"
&
&!
!!

 

("




!"
!#


*
$
!
A0
<
!#
#!


!
("
&
#

 



 
8
"



 


&=3
-

 !


# !
%
 


 

 

%




 
%
"

$ 
"
%
 
"
 


" 

%
!& 
 
!0
# !
#!
# !


# !


!!
# !
docens,

"

# !
.!!
# !

 
# !
!

# !
utens, 

5


# !0

la utens


docens
D"6.

*
!
("

# !


!

("
("
%
! 
)

!
" 

 
# !

("
!
("


!&
2

%!%
!
&


/#0


Analíticos 
# !
docens



Refutaciones sofísticas


Tópicos 
# !
utens,
!
2#
 !
&'
&

 !
"("

'

("
7
"
 


. 
"




 !


# !
utens

 
"
'



.!
!



.
!!


docens
-

 
!

"#
!.!



#!
&'


!
 

 "!#

 

 "
!!"
"("



/
("
" 

&
# !

!"
 0

176
 -




!!

%!

!
 

6#



# !



!!

%!
 

6#



!

'
2
! "

!!

!"

&


!


6#



("
 !
 

6#





("

" 
! 
!
 
!
! 


E

F
 
%
("
*
&
("
 

"
86

&
!
"("

"

&
("
%
! 
-
"




 
! 


&
" 
("
"("



&

# !
9*

"

&

&'
"

!



"0



  

Investigaciones
 

3" G
H 

3. ¿Qué lógica escoger?

2

 "



 "
!!

!

("



"


;&

 "

("'
("

# !


("


8
)
& 


! 
"





# !
utens 

# !
docens
 
!
"
 
!




 0



!!
.

!


# !
" 



" 
I!"


("


&*&

!


!


!#


!!
3
 "

!
" 
!



! 
"


# !
! 


("




3.1. Dentro de la lógica !

/


!
("
%

# !
("

 !

" 



*
!
("
%



("



# !


# !
docens
3
 
8
 !

!
&

 


# !
!
)&
!
("




# !




"
0
# !

!

# !

 ! 
!"

.

!! 

" 


 !
2" 
 6









&#!

!

# !
&#!

("
&'


# !
.!
"("
%
!



2" 



7.!








" 

!
"
!*"

 

("






' 0

7.!



 "!!#
"


!"

" 
%&

"
6

!
  


 
J

7
("

! 




-! 
!".



8
 



 



!
 



/("

%

"
!!#


' 





"
 




!

!
 

"&





&
!
' 
 
-
!

!!#

&!

# !


!
!
"
" 


!!


' 
!
&

  
.&
.!
' 
& 

177
 
&


 

 !
&!
&'

# !

 ! 


!
!
' 






   
!
"



 
K

"

# !

&

!"
" 
!"


 
<7=


# !
5 
!


&


# !

3
 
.



$" 


!"#
 "



!


# !

 


# !

!.!


# !
!

# !
"!


# !
!

# !

!" 

!!!




 !#

&'

# !
!.!
2


&'



# !
7


# !
!


 
# !
 
("
!"


'!
7.!



$
("
! 
"


# !
("
%
! 
" 


"
# !
 
/
 

"
# !
 
"!


!L
)
" 


!"#
!

! 
!

 

modus ponens



# !
&
!" 



 


 

4

1
M  




"
.&0
!" 
!%


 
 

 

  
 




7N
2" 

6

! 


!"
# !
  



"




# 

!"#

!"
" 
" 

!


!
.!!


# !
3
" 
# !
.


 



!"



 !
!

 
% 
("


!
!



3
# !
docens
"
"

"


!*
("

 !
! 
a priori
("'
# !
 


!
&

& 
!6
!%6 
 "




!

!!

 
("
("



!%6

3.2. Dentro de la lógica "

3
# !
utens
&'
"
"
 
!*
-
 !





("
! 


;
 "

!" 
("


("


 
XV

XVI
" &

"
"!#



! 
# !
("

8&


"  
 
$
"

!
!
%!
"
"
("


# !




"
("

!!


#!


 @!


! 
2

%&

"





# !
utens


!!

'
"
&0
+("'



!!,
2"

 !



.!


/ "

!!!
" 
 !0



!!

!


.
.


.
-

!!


'!


.
.



-

!!
&"!

 !
6

&'

 
-

!!
&"!
 "!



!!


 



&

"

 "
!!#
2"

 !
"
" 
" 

 

!!



.

!!



!!
"

!!
-


!
" 

"
%& 
!!
("

!




" 
!!





!! 
"("
%
&"

178
6
+O




!!,
-

!!
%



97
!



"

!!
("


"!!

 
("

8&
P%
2
%!

8
)
& 

.

 !


"!!
)


"
("
%
 

!!6



!!

%!

"
!#
!
("

&("
 

!

$ 
!#
"
" 

"

6

"

" 
!
%

("
!"
!

# !
docens

4. ¿De veras hay que escoger una lógica?

F

("


! 
"


!


# !
%
&

2


%!

"&

!

#
!


&


!"

!" 
"
 
2"

'!



! 
"



!


# !


#
!

# !
3
6
("
 

%&

 "!
"



# !



("

# !

!
6
!!

 
("

" 

*"
! 




 


("
!
("

# !
&





3

 

&'


&'

 
"
97#
&



("
 !
"
6


)
& 
%
"!
 
%
("
! 
"


# !


"
86

("

("
 8



("
("


!*
%


!
!



)



 "
!!#


!
!
!

!!
2"

# !
" 

&

8

!"("
.&
 "!


 

)
& 

" 
 !"

! 
"


"


("




 "!
!#

!!
7!


!!
%"
!
!'

# !

 .
 
("
 !
%

("

# !
 !
"

 





"

 
!
/
("
%
("
! 
"

# !
("
("

 !" 






" 



" 


!
 

%

8
Q




"

&
" 

"
0
+


8
# !

"

" ,
3
 "

 



 
" 
"

!" 


("

!


!#


" 


&!%



!
!"

 

2

%!%

("
6!





" 
%!
 
("


!





"  
("


!&R



$6
 " 
!#

&
!

 "!!#

!%6





# !
-


! !

 
-
 !

 



 "!!#

!%6
"





# !


sea la utens 

docens
-


" 0

!
 &

"!%

 "!!#
 6 
!

# !
utens
 6 
!



#!

"!%
!!


 "
!.!
2



 

XIX

!6

XX


# 
 *
"("

!

179
 
 

# !
docens
%! 
!


7 !
#!






! 

&


%
!

 !



# !
.!

"
" 
-


# 

# !
!&#
"
!

" 

!
&

#

("
"

 
&

"!#


"
# !
-
"
"

!#

 
!


 
!

!

!" 


# !
docens

%"&
# !
7!
("




 !

#
!
&
!

$%
) 

2!

I

:!%S

!

*
F
!"
"
7


# !



 E
/
("

&
!"



# !

"

!

#
!
"
!
%
"  






 



5&'

"

!#


("
("
!%6&

# !

docens
!&
".!
"



# !
utens
3
!




!
D" 
"!%

" 



# !
("

"


("

("


"
# !







7
"

# !
$
("
%&
"
 


7#


"

"



#
!
-
 
!

!%6



# !
!" 
!"




7!
!


# !
docens

 "

"

D"6.
%

!



# !
utens 

!

"
&"
 !#
 



!
&



5. La lógica y otras disciplinas

D" 
 
 

!
!


# !



 "!!#
3
# 
!
%
!% 
!


.!

%
 
!" 
&'



.!

("



78
"
!


!"

!"
 

.!
)
& 
"
!
%



6 



&&
"
!#
!"

&
"
7#


!

!
!"!#
!#!


$
("




# !
do-
cens

# !
!
!!
"
!
!!
"
!
.
*"
! 





!" 

%!%
.
*"
! 

!"("
!" 


!"
!
("
8




 "
!!
3

# !
" 

&'



!" 

 @!


!%L

"
" 
%
" 

"

!"






# !
utens
"




 .!
M
"
 
#!0


!#


 


""

"
 "*N
 
"



!!#

!


# !
docens

/
("



 "0
+
("'

# !


6 



!" 


 



&!%,
)

6 



 


"
<!!#
!=
!
!
("
%



!



# !



 
!
6 
&'



 !
 
("



<6#
'!=

" 

 

("
("
!" 


# !
&#!
-

&!%

""




3# !

1 



;

F&  
("

180
" 

 

!# 
   






.
"" 


" 

2
!*
M!



# !



 




 
!*N
Q
&
("





# !
docens



 

 "


 
3
!#


# !



# 
%
 
& "0
"


"


  !

!
!%6



-
"
!

%&
!" 


"
'! 
("
"!

# !
utens
" 

*
!

O



!

8

"
*





"#

!
"
!

!%
86
3" 



86


!!


!" 



 
"
%

*


!0


 '




"
*" 

!!'

("


&
 




!6


%&.
8 

!!





!

&  

 
+D"'

"

# 
!


,
2&&
("


.
&  

!"
"
!



*

!"#
.

" 
!
"
"
%

("


!"

 
!
"


"  

"

&  




F&.

" 
("
("
"
!!"#0

# !









!

*
 6
2"

 !
 
%&

 



%"&
8 



" 

 "
2"
&

*

!"#
%&.
  

("


.
" 

"


!! 




!"("

("





I 


!"#



'
("



%
!" 





("




 @ 
 


.
 
#!

"
&"
"



 

&"

("

 
2#




.
!! 
-
 
!

. 
%
 

"


*


!&

!
&
 
!" 

"

 


$" 




!

 

 !




!"!
"
!

 

 "

"
  



!

 "

!


"


"!%

.0
<
-
!
!=
<T

" 
=
 

! "6!
("

"
-
!

("

!

# !
utens
!

#!

.


"
 


&
T
8


!


# !

docens
"


7
"

# !
"("
%

"! 



!"

. 
3
# !
utens " 
! 
!

!

 
&!

!
 
"

 


"
!"

!
("
" 
8

!"

-

 


# !
utens " 



docens
" 
!

"
6


!!

%!%

%
!" 
!
 "



#!


*
!

.!
!"

%
 
&






%
3
 


!"#
 

! 
!

!"

"!%


Tópicos '!
&! 
<" =
("
" 


181
 
 "!#
)



!*
!




medieval de las obligationes
"
!
!!


!"#

. 



"
 



!"

!
/
!
!
"

*" 

7!#
!

 
# !
M
!
<
%&

!%=
("

&


!




 
("

!
("

"
&

 "
!"("
!
 
("
!


 
 

0
<

%&

!&

%&
!%=


!
<$'

"
%&=

<$'
"
=
 
("

!
<$'
"

!=

!"

&N
F
("

("


 


consequentiae



"
!
# !
&

 !


!

"



!
("

!"


Tópicos, 
!

"




# !
utens. 2
*0
"
<#!=
" 
0
<
("

!

 


!
&'


=
K

"
 
("
" 
"



"

&"!
 "

!!

 

("
 
"


<
 

!

&!
!
&'



&!=
#!

!
<
("

"
&" 

 

&"
&'



=

<
("

 

 

 
&'


=
1 

"
! !
!

*
"
<
 

!

&!=

"

!#
! #!
< 

!

&!=
&

! #!

<



!

&!=
5

"
 
modus ponens


modus tollens

!

.7
 
M
("

 

 


 
&'


N




!!"!




# !
!


!"

/




!
"
&
&

'
<# !=


< '!!=
 " 

)
 !!0

-

 
!

&
< '!!=
 

!#
 


!0

3
!!

' 
("
!
!


!!
!
!

%
("


 

!

" 




("
 "

!"


6#

!

# !


&'

!

/#

!!
.!!


!"#

"



" 
!
("


!!#
"


!
"

 
 
2


d U'!!V
#

8


"!#
# !
!!!






! 



6#

"

!"
UWV

" 
&!

 "

!
!!


!!#

d0

I"

 "
!#
 !
M'
sophismaN

;!"






("

6


%#


 
&





 
 &
R
' 
# !


!#

#
E

' 

! !#
 
 "!
 !
M'

182
 demonstratioN0

2!



*


!



7!




 
 !
!


# !

T
 

"
("

'
< '!!=
"
 



!
$
Mca
ERN
" 
<;

'!!=

!"
!


"
De nuptiis Philologiae et Mercurii M!! 

!
!
De septem
disciplinisN
&'
"
 


:!
("
#
<;
'!
!=

!"
!

"
De artibus ac disciplinis liberalium litterarum20
)






&

"


(" "
 


"
!" 


>.!

A#!


;'!!

scientia
sermocinales
!!

!"


 "*

-!
"


! 

#!
!
!



/!"
MREN

"
*

!#
"

# 
" 
 "!





!
 
("

("
4
0
"

# 

 "





P 
("

"
!
"
*

("

("



+!".
 

"

("



!,
/("
 

"*
Q


"
*



("

+!".
 



!



",
/("


"*
Q
%


# 
"

 "0




!
"
"
*

+!".
 ,
3
"*

*

-

# 
%

!
P 0

"
!
"
"
*

!&
+!".
 W,
$
("
P 
!
 




 "0
+

"
!
"
"

*
("

"W,
3
*


!0

("


*



*



("



"!
"("


$ 
!
("
"

# 


"
"
!
("
 0
Iste philosophus non fuit Evangelicus
.
 
 !

*


 "!
 !0
)
 "




("
 "



%&
" 




%&
-

%&

<%&=


&
" 
"


&
-
< "!=

.
7! 

"


!
("
" 
.



!
!




suppositio

"


.!!
.!

 .!R
-
'! 

" 

"
 



!



# 


# !
"("


"
7
&
#!

!

!" 


# !
utens
2
 
"
!

!
"

 

XII
("



!



 


# !

-




: 

$%
MYca.RN0

!


 

%&

 
nos esse quasi nanos gigantum umeris
insidentes 3
# !
 
!"



# !

 .!! 


7
!% 

# !
'!

3
6#


"

"

"
!"
%"
("
%
("


-

/& 
MEN

"
#$
 %
judío y un cristiano

!0
<





# 


&"!


 
 

6

 "

 

!"
UWV

"



6#=

>"

$!%
MEN
!0
<
("


183
 


%!%

("
;
%
  
%!


("

7



("
7!
!=
-7

!
!

!!


# 


'!
!

# !
("

"

!

!
!
.
" 
4!
1



 
XIVL
-

&



6#
" 
!
&'



!


("


 
!
-

 



/& 

>"
2 
;.
MYN

"
!!!#


6#

<&
.
!=
!
!
$'
A80

)
!


&
*
"
!

"
&
De

!&M3

! 

 &


!!
("
 N

!!


$"
4III
"
 
Quod ad Deum accedentes humanis disciplinis non indigent M
("

&"!

;

!

&
%"N

!0
<2

!"
UWV


&"("

& "
%"
("

" 
%!
!! 
!


'&


-
 !
+("'
! 
"
.




" 


,=
M'!!%"!()
-

"


!"
4

"
&
De divina omnipotentia in
reparatione corruptae, et factis infecti reddendis MLa omnipotencia
divina en relación con el restablecimiento de la virginidad perdida, y
de la conversión de lo hecho en no hechoN
!&
<)
& 


&
%"







!
  

" 

!
 



" 

 

!

"
!
MancillaN


"
8
!
&"

!" 


("

%
7

!

("
=

-
!
 .

"
 
"("

 


!"
 


"

!"

"
&
) " 

K
>
 



 
 


 "!#


 '!!
("

!
2 
;.



"


# !


!

3

 .!!
&!
"
!#

!

"!

&
!

*0
"
8


& 

 




"
! !#
"

"
8


 



&
("

 
)
& 
&!
("

& 


"

("

 

! !
7

8
3
& 
"




8
 

! !



! 
!
!"

 !
 

"
"6
-

8&


# 



&'

  



 @  
2
2 
;.
 "
!
0
!" 

# !

!
("


 

("

 

!"
%&.
("
! 

("
'

"
66
("
 

!"
)
 "
("
"


! 


"
%&.
("
! 



/#
("

"



&.!"

%&

("



 

("
!


!"

3
-!"
$" 
 "
("
;

" 
!&


184
 
%
("
!
("
!



!





""

!"

!

!
R
O
!"
&

!%6


7

!
!!#


!

Z%

)
-
MN
A!%6



'!!
"
%
 


*

!
&"
-
 !


("*


!' 
("0

5


%& 

%&


"
 
("
"

 

("


$!#
.
!" 
"("
"




&"
   
("
<%&
("
*
"6
"


"

 

;

  


&





-
!&

!  


!
" 
%!
! 


!"("
  
 
"
& 

&

.

("


&
!

;



! 
R

3
!"

"


"


!




!


 
-
 
("





("!

&



&


 
"
&
("
&

! 
 







 
2
!
!!#
!

"
&

De suis tentationibus


"
. 

;
Z%



;

 "0
<+!


!
"
("8
&
!


!"
 "
("

%
 
!!  


!!


,=
!


%&
!%
< 
&'
("


"
6 
"
" 




("
"
&" 
&

F
%
%
 
 
%

&
("
"
"
 
("
8

 



!"
 .
!!

 
=R
O



!"


&

"
!
!-
cit et prodest, <3
&
6 




 



!%




=
-
'!

'!!

 '!!

("
("
!


'!!
!"


 

("
("
!"


"
!"

"
*
! 
!


 
!
("



! 

*


 @ 
 

("
("

("

"
! 



!&
!


!
!" 

&'


# !
-
!9!


&0

!9!




6#

!9!

 #

!!
!
 





!
3
'!
"


"


.


A!

!
"
5"

"
2 
;

"
 

"
2 
/& 


/ "



>

&
 !
!
< 

"=

< 
 "=
!33

*+"

F
%& 


*

"
"
!"
%!

# !

%


&
"! 


!"

" 

!
 "

185
 



#


3

# 

# 
("



&!
"
!!"
!

"

%!
"
 "6

racional

&!
"
"


-

 

 

 
!

"


# !


"


6#
"

 '!!

!


# !

'!!
!


&




"

("
"!

"


6#
$
("

!7


!"#


. 




"



# !
utens
"
 "


 "


"
("
.
  

"
!!#


# !

docens


 
! 


!&

-
!%6


# !

"


"
&
("
%&.
("

& 
 




"
&
("


!


&0
<
!=

 !

<
6&=
!
("
%



!

&
# !





&
!



"!""
 

# !
!.!
" 


!!#
)


& 

# !
!.!

""

<
# !=RE
$

("

!%6


9!0
 

# !

("
 

"
<=
# !
%
("


"

7
"


#
!

)
& 
!
("


 

"
" 

"
!9!



!


("
%
%& 0
"
!9!


# !
utens


# !
docens

("6.
"
"
#

!9!
%
!"
6 



"

 "
-
!

 




 "!!#
%&.


"("

.
%

# !

 "


"
!

186
Notas

[

$ !
"! 

#


I4
$ 
T!

1 



O 


)
/ '
/  6!


!

1 



O)/



4!!

I !#

2  


:O/2
"




!#


 !#

Cfr
\T-/3-


H
MN
El desarrollo de la lógica
M 

P
" "6N

  
5!
!

2
&'

 "!#
 !


]#

-


!"
"
!  

/#

 


'!
!
-
 "!#
" 



# !
 "
!
"
'!!

!
!
M "!!#

&" N

&'
" 
! 
"



 "!#
!&

. 


&



<Q





 
X4
4
%&
%!%
"
.
!

"!

 "
'
!
" 


!.!
!
quiditas


ens
$
4


"
"
&
!
quiditas

"
& 

 # !




!#

" 
! 


'
ens


" 

 "
*"
!!#
!=
Cfr
2-A$I4/3
H
\
<$% 


%
!%

 " =

\A-5]/TT
T
/
\

P
2& 
MN


/ 4!
 5   6" 7//
$& 
$& 

O
2

L
3

AZI33Q
P!("

MN

7
M 


2
>N
:!
)7
:

R
E
Cfr
:-O$FZ5

MEN
Introducción a la lógica
'7!
OT/




36
28

("*

("




" 

# !
!.!
!

"

!



 !#
M<
 !#=

N

 

("
%



 


# !
("

&

!"


# !
!.!


 .




Cfr
2-^/

36
MRN
Introducción a las lógicas no clásicas
'7!
OT/


L
Cfr
2AI-)5
>%
MN
Introduction to Non-Classical Logic
$& 
$
& 
O
2
-
!
" 

"
 

!#
" 
!&


 


# !
!

*



.&


# !
!.!0

 

!
!"("
/

:

 
"







)



 
!! 
!
< 
"=

modus tol-
lendo ponens
  
"




2


!!
"

"!#

exclusiva M("
 

 

#
"

N

 
 
("

0

 

!
!"("
" 


"!#
7!"



"

 


 

ponendo tollens

 
"

 



"


"!#
7!"

" 

&
  

Cfr.
2AI-)5
>
Una brevísima introducción a la lógica
 



 
Z!'
'7!0
- 
Z!'

'7!
L
!







Cfr
>/A;I-)
P3"
MN
Lógica del tiempo
 

P
Z 86

  
2 

!

!"
L
 
E
<3
# !
!!

 
F 
M3
)
A GSN=

Cfr
P/TI\
/
)
5"

A
AS
MN
An Introduction to Reasoning
TG

187
 QS
!

2"&%
$
3
"
%!
7!
("

"





# !


6
.!


.!!




 
! 

Cfr
MRN
Filosofía de la enseñanza
M 

1 !
2.N
'7!
1$-


E
 
!0
<-8

"
8


!!
 
!
UWV


'

("



!!



 
8

("

 ("
!



 

 

("

 "


8=


Cfr
)I->-3
F
MN
Educating Reason. Rationality, Critical Thinking and
Education
TG
QS
A" 
!

!"





-7
"
"


&
<# !=
("
" 

7

! 
!

#
!
%
!
"
-
 !



# !
docens

" 
" 

!


"

# !
"
!" 

  !

! &  

&'
("
" 
&

#
!

Cfr
F//$\
)"
MN
Philosophy of Logics
$& 
$& 
O

2
!

T
!" 
("
("


 


# !
!"

!

("
("

utens 
docens
R

)
"
 "!#
ad hominem
!


"  
 "!

6


"#

 



 

!"




 

-

"  



!!
!



6
 
"
!%6
"("
'
!
 
 


"
"

#
!
E
Cfr
21/T;-A
/
MRN
Lógica
M 

P
2'6
:!N
:"
/
-
$


Cfr
A-;ZT;
H
MN
<-7!#

 "!#=

La lámpara de
Diógenes
8


R
*"
:'
O 
/"#

2"&
L
Cfr
$ZT)5/T5ITZ
1&.

"
/"
A
3#
MN
Elementos de

89:9# ;5!/-
tación normativa
'7!
1O 

)
3
"
"6

%
# !
M&

  
# !

!
 
#!N


 @!

"
.

!#



*" !


O
&"
 "!!#


& !

!"

)2/;-
2"
4!

<Z& =

\A-5]/TT
T
2&
P

\
/
M N
MN
The Cam-

 5   6" 7//
$& 0
$& 
O

2

R




Cfr
)5O2
-
<5!0
%


&

!("!
<

\A-5]/TT
T
2&
P

\
/
ibid

R


3




"

("
!!
&
!


# !

Cfr
/>T/4/$$/
)
MN
<=<9!"
:"
/

O:/8

;.
- 

L

Ibidem

Cfr
</&
/!"


A%!
; "=

MN
Antiqui rethores la-
tini
2
-7

!
2
/"
F "
2

R
F
 "!!#0

Alcuino. Diálogo sobre arte retórica M
/!"

$ 
/(" .
8

EN
57
 



  
 "!!#


 "!

188
!#

P
/

) 



O 
/"#


]!!
'7!



Cfr
</&
/!"


A%!
; "=
op. cit

RR
/!"
!

("
"
#!
R
Cfr
<O

 

 "*=

:-A5-33ZTI
1

>:" 
M N

MN
9!"

E


-!! 
I&!

1
 
  
5$)I$

E

$ 

Metalogicon

P"

)&"
McaN

;/1ZT5-
$

A8
MN
<$
/"
-86

' 


) 
XII=
Revista Española
de Filosofía Española

E
O 

] 6

R

Cfr
A/^/
ibidem
L
Cfr
1-AA-A4!
MN

  
M 

4!
1! N

4!
2!
;!

/ #




A/^/
op. cit

R


>I3)ZT
-
MN
9!
M 

/
2!

)
 
$&N
  
> 
!
I4

Cfr
/5-)
:
MN
Lógica de los estoicos
M 

 "
>!
:#N

  
5!


R

>I3)ZT
-
op. cit




O
. 

! 

Z%

)

-
MN
!
>
("
<
!!



("
$

2#
/#

$!#


!!

"=
O
("*
! 

!


!



-0
<
"

!"

("
!

$
!
]#

!
/#

!



!

P
$
!

!


=
Cfr
AZ55-A;/

-

MLN
Ensayos escogidos
!!#

F"&
6
'7!

)-2
!
$

" 

R
R

$ 

4Z3/T5-
)"
:

"
<1

'!!
O
&.!


Z%

)
-=

Revista Española de Filosofía Medieval

E


O 

] 6


F" 

)
4!
MLEN
! .

("
<!
!

!%
"
& 


" 

"
 !

=
! 

I
I!%
En el viñedo del texto. Etología de la lectura: un

!?#@5
B+9
M 

%
>6.6N

'7!
1$-

L
R
Cfr
4Z3/T5-
)"
:
ibidem
33
Cfr
>I3)ZT
-
MRN
Reason and Revelation in the Middle Ages
T"

QS
$%
)!&_
)
-
&


!"
"
 ! 

! 




!




6#

!#
RE
Cfr

*
2!


) 
4
)SS
<O

!#


!


! !!#0

!


/6 
T"
2!=



!!#
!#!
`%0JJGGG&" "JG!J2J3 J3 %b

!" 



&


3
"

"6
"
#



# !
#!





&

A!!#0
&


;!
& 0
&



189