Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fostering Educational Opportunities for Students with Disabilities Through the Utilization of a
Angela Martin
IN HIGHER EDUCATION
SECTION 1
Introduction:
The setting of this project took place at Concordia University Ann Arbor, a four-year
institution. Concordia University Ann Arbor is a private liberal arts university in Ann Arbor,
Michigan, United States. Concordia University Ann Arbor is a Lutheran higher education
community committed to helping students develop in mind, body, and spirit for service to Christ
in the Church and the world. In the 2017-2018 academic school year, Concordia’s enrollment
was approximately 1,000 students. The researcher worked with Concordia’s Coordinator of
Disability Services, Emily Perry to develop and implement a program to better serve and
acclimate students with disabilities to the college environment. This program will help high
school students with disabilities transition to the world of higher education. Research shows that
students with disabilities are the most recent marginalized group to move toward equal
opportunity in education. Their campus wide involvement enhanced the overall post-secondary
Concordia University Ann Arbor. Upon completion, she was the Graduate Assistant for
Residence Life while completing her Master’s Degree in Student Personnel Administration in
Higher Education. In addition to her Graduate Assistantship, she worked at Just Us Club in Ann
Arbor. Just Us Club is a private charitable organization that provides high-quality, affordable,
family friendly programs for children and adults with disabilities. Just Us Club is a place where
individuals with special needs are able to get the quality care they deserve. The researcher also
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 2
served as the senior leader at a day camp each summer for children aged 4-11 with physical
disabilities and coached softball for adults with cognitive disabilities. The researchers current
role is a behavior therapist, providing for individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorder. This work
made a positive impact on the plans for this project and drove a force to implement such a
program.
Statement of Problem:
Research showed, one in six or 15% of children aged 3 through 17 years had one or more
developmental disabilities, which can potentially effect day-to-day functioning. With the
implementation of this program and buddy system created to help individuals with disabilities
transition to college life and transition to opportunities beyond k-12 education places a high
importance on understanding disabilities. In addition, it can create a campus wide awareness for
those who may not be fully educated or lack the experience of working alongside individuals
with disabilities. Research obtained shows the need for more higher education opportunities to be
made accessible for those students with disabilities. An individual should never be defined by
their disability but rather their ability, its important to show support and guidance towards
Transition options and extended community comfort was created for students with
disabilities to get acclimated to the change from high school to college, as well as it could create
SECTION II
LITERATURE REVIEW
“Students with disabilities are the most recent marginalized group to move toward equal
opportunity in education. Federal laws prohibit discrimination against students with disabilities.”
(Eckes & Ochoa, 2005, p. 12) In addition, federal laws seek to provide those individuals with
appropriate services and support. Providing educational opportunities for students with
disabilities begins with elementary and secondary education. However, more and more
opportunities for higher education have become available. Elementary and secondary education
is obligatory and no student with disabilities may be rejected. On the opposite end, higher
education is voluntary and often rejects students with disabilities who are hoping to further their
education. Unfortunately, it is not uncommon for higher education to dismiss students with
disabilities for substandard academic performance. Students with disabilities typically do not
receive the same level of academic preparation in K-12 education as their peers without
disabilities, contributing to them not going on to higher education in larger numbers. The
umbrella of student disabilities includes learning disabilities, attention deficit and hyperactivity
disorder, visual impairments, deaf and hard of hearing, health impairments, mental health issues,
physical disabilities, and autism or Asperger’s syndrome. “Students with learning disabilities
now constitute the largest portion of students identified with a disability in public school; of all
students with disabilities, 46.2% are classified as having a specific learning disability” (U.S
Now more than ever, students with disabilities have access to educational
education beyond high school and preparing for a career. But higher education is
more than just job training. It opens doors to new friendships, opportunities,
experiences and careers. It can broaden an individual’s abilities –both socially and
income. (p. 1)
Schools are becoming better skilled at supporting individuals with disabilities, but there is still
room to grow and improve. Therefore, like any student it becomes crucial for an individuals to
do research to find the school that is going to best meet their needs and goals. The better
prepared an individual is for higher education, the easier it will be to be successful. It is never too
“Many students with disabilities now spend more time in inclusive settings than ever
before and have the benefit of transition services. This and the fact that their right to an education
is now better protected than ever, continuing after high school is now a natural next step for
many students with disabilities” (Navigate Life Texas, 2017 p. 1). Some of the key components
to transitioning to higher education are making the adjustment, working with disability services
and other supports, self-advocacy and understanding the rights and responsibilities as a student
and knowing the law (Texas Council for Developmental Disabilities, 2017, pp. 11-13). The
Texas Council for Developmental Disabilities created a Higher Education Resource Guide for
Students with Disabilities to start thinking ahead. In this resource they also provided several
beneficial resources for students with disabilities looking to further their education. Research
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 5
proves the importance of preparation. It is important for students to know what they are looking
for from a school and nothing reveals more than a campus visit. When visiting a campus,
students and families can meet with advisors, speak with financial aid, make an appointment
with the school’s Office of Disability Services to discover the accommodation that can be made
living accommodations, etc. Assistive technology may also be provided, which includes
computer mouse alternatives, voice recognition software, eye tracking software and ability
switches. The types of accommodations will surely depend on each college and university.
While many colleges may offer special programs for students with disabilities, Landmark
College is one of the only accredited colleges in the United States designed exclusively for a
student who learns differently. Landmark College’s mission is to transform the way students
learn, educators teach, and the public thinks about education. At Landmark students learn how to
learn, which essentially helps them become not only more confident but also more independent.
At Landmark students with disabilities can get more personable and directed assistance they
often search for. To top it all off, the courses are tailored to meet the educational needs of the
education within eight years of leaving high school (National Center for Special Education
Research, 2011, p. 9) Roughly 19% of students who receive help for their disabilities in high
school acknowledge in college that they need the same assistance. Learning disabled students
are more likely than other students to drop out of four-year college. In fact, only 41% complete a
four-year degree within 8 years of finishing high school. (National Center for Learning
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 6
Disabilities, 2014, p.31) Students with learning disabilities are the biggest group of students with
students. Since a learning disability is an “invisible” disability students with them bear a burden
of proof to establish their special needs. (National Center for Special Education Research, 2011,
para. 5)
In K-12 education, students with disabilities benefit from individualized education plans
(IEP) and a team that is committed to help them learn (U.S Department of Education, 2000). In
higher education, the approach is a lot less hands on. Students are expected to identify their
disability, as well as speak up if they need help. This is where the transition from high school to
college becomes problematic, students do not identify with their disability until classes have
already begun. If an individual with disabilities wants to receive accommodations, they must
disclose their disabilities and take initiative in requesting the accommodations. Accommodations
often include but are not limited to extended time for timed examinations, special parking spaces,
and large print software. (Macomb Community College Special Services, 2017, para. 6) Students
with disabilities often run into financial difficulties. They generally have lower incomes than
their peers, making it difficult to meet the special needs associated with daily and academic life.
The longer time a student with disabilities needs to complete their studies increases their cost and
the financial barriers they face. This is a contributing factor to why it may take a student with
disabilities twice as long to complete a degree. Additionally, student aid programs, such as the
Pell Grant program, do not provide flexibility to offer a maximum full-time award to students
with disabilities who are not taking a full class load (12 credits).
With the implementation of a transition program and buddy system to help individuals
with disabilities transition to college life and transition to opportunities beyond k-12 education
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 7
places a high importance on understanding disabilities. The transition from high school to
college is challenging for many individuals and may be exceptionally difficult for those with
disabilities. After speaking with a counselor at Roseville High School I was pleased to learn
many things. They do work with Michigan Rehab Services (MRS) to create a plan for students.
In addition, there is a school in the Kalamazoo area called MI Career and Technical institute that
is for any student with special needs. Each student must also be provided with a transition plan
on their Individualized Education Plan. Roseville High School also takes students to transition
workshops at Macomb Community College. (L, Coppola, personal communication, March 27,
2017)
It is safe to say that regardless of being protected by the law, students with disabilities
have a lot to consider when choosing a college to attend. Certain colleges will have access to a
larger resource center, and have more experience accommodating students with disabilities.
Aside from Landmark College some other top universities for individuals with special needs are
University of Iowa, West Virginia Wesleyan College, Daemen College, Bellevue Community
College, Gallaudet University and many more. The University of Iowa offers students with
intellectual, cognitive, and learning disabilities access to the REACH program. REACH stands
for realizing educational and career hopes. Through this program students receive help with
several things from coursework to life on campus. Programs like REACH allow students the
opportunity to perform better academically, build career skills, and learn to live as independent
Some schools have more experience accommodating students with disabilities so have a
better understanding of what takes to help the students be successful. At Macomb Community
College their Special Services department falls under their academic advising and counseling
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 8
departments, which are run by Michelle Koss. Their primary goal is to help remove barriers to a
assistive technology, career awareness and exploration, alternative testing arrangements, etc.
Through Macomb Community College a student may become eligible if they are referred by
faculty or outside agencies, have any documented disability that would contribute to obstacles in
the college classroom, or have below-average grade point average. A student must also provide
acceptance documents, for example an individualized education plan, 504 plans, verification
forms, etc. The student is also responsible for requesting a classroom assistance letter (CAL)
each semester. In addition, students are responsible for giving their CAL to campus instructors.
Regarding Macomb Community College’s campus accessibility their buildings are equipped
with special runways, elevators, handrails, and specially constructed facilities in hopes of making
student movement and use easier. Elevators keys and special parking are also available.
Overall there are a lot of challenges to be faced and there are a lot of things to consider
make sure the school of their choosing is the right fit for them as an individual, while also
meeting their educational needs. It is beneficial to have a positive impact on the students
transitioning process to set them up to succeed and transition smoothly. Helping to prepare them
to be comfortable to speak up for themselves once they leave secondary education. With the
implementation of a transition program and buddy system for students with special needs
transition to higher education will help set them up to thrive and succeed. With the right
SECTION III
With the implementation of a transition program and buddy system to help individuals
with disabilities transition smoothly to college life places a high importance on the understanding
of disabilities by faculty and staff. Such a transition program will create a campus-wide
awareness for those who may not be fully educated or lack the experience of working alongside
individuals with disabilities. Research obtained shows the need for more higher education
opportunities to be made accessible for those students with disabilities. An individual should
never be defined by their disability but rather their ability. It is important to show support and
guidance towards helping them flourish. The overall goal of this program was to help students
with disabilities become accustomed to new environments and conditions, and provide them with
a buddy to help smooth their transition. This in turn could create campus-wide awareness of
different types of disabilities. When students with disabilities are provided opportunities for
continued support and guidance beyond K-12 education it prepares them to succeed beyond high
school.
Procedures
As stated above, the overall purpose of this program was to smooth the transition to
higher education for students with disabilities by helping them become accustomed to new
environments and conditions. This is made possible by providing students with a buddy to help
smooth their transition. This is done by the creation of a transition program for them to take part
in before they graduate from high school so they can have an idea of what to expect from
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 10
college. Student leaders from Concordia will be provided the opportunity to become a buddy.
The student leaders will be selected based on academic standing, leadership roles on campus,
willingness to serve and potential majors. The leaders will be approved through the completion
University. Once selected for the buddy role, each student will attend a mandatory training
during the weeks leading up to the beginning of the fall semester. Each Concordia student will
then be paired with their buddy based on the answers to the online questionnaire and
may include Coordinator of Disability Service, Director of the Academic Resource Center, a
My research began with interviews from two high school counselors from Michigan to
discuss what transition options they are providing for their current students with disabilities and
some of the challenges they face. This gave a better idea of what is already being done to help
students transition to higher education. When asked what current educators can do to help bridge
the gap between high school and higher education for students with disabilities, one counselor
stated “I think that everyone needs to be on the same page. As a high school counselor, it is hard
to know what every college offers for their students with disabilities. Maybe some streamlining,
for all colleges, would help.” When asked what advice they had for colleges and universities to
help make the transition to high school education as smooth as possible for student with
disabilities, one counselor stated “They need to have a program for these students that helps them
with socializing and getting them involved with a mentor who will take them out and help them
fit in.
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 11
Next, I interviewed four Coordinators of Disability Services from other colleges and
universities to determine what kind of transition options they are currently providing for their
students, if any. Question two regarding current transition options provided for students with
disabilities to higher education, two of the four coordinators stated their institution had some
form of transition programs for students with disabilities currently in place. One coordinator
stated “We participate in transition fairs at the intermediate school districts, participate in
transition showcases, and travel to high schools in order to share information about transition at
exit IEP meetings (upon invitation). We work with our recruitment and outreach teams, sharing
None of the four coordinators rated their institution above a three when asked to rate on a
scale of one to five, one being very ineffective, 3 being neutral and 5 being very effective on how
their institution provided students with disabilities transition options to higher education.
When asked to identify challenges that hinder them from preparing students with
disabilities for higher education, one coordinator stated, “It is a struggle to educate students
about the differences between K-12 and college accommodations in a way which is meaningful
to them and which they understand. The law changes from a "success" to an "access" model, so
many K-12 accommodations (i.e. modified assignments, personal curriculum, etc.) do not apply
in college. Parents also struggle with both these changes as well as the changes to their access to
information and decision-making abilities. It's difficult to explain to parents why you can't share
grade information or why the students' teachers may choose not to speak to them about their
adult child, or why teachers don't share progress report information with the parents if their
student is experiencing difficulty. Students with disabilities sometimes struggle with creating
realistic career goals; it may not be realistic, for example, for a student with a cognitive
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 12
impairment to become a neurosurgeon, or for a student who is Deaf to graduate from the
interpreter training program.” The questions used for the interview can be found in (APPENDIX
A).
willingness to become a buddy, thoughts on their transition and benefits from the program.
Approximately 17 Concordia students were asked to take part in the online survey. In addition,
they were provided with a consent form allowing me to use the data collected for my project.
This was done using an online survey format to receive feedback from the students on the best
way to implement this program. When asked on a scale of one to five, one being strongly
disagree, 3 being somewhat agree and 5 being strongly agree on how much would you agree that
the implementation of a buddy system would benefit both current students and incoming students
with disabilities 29.4% answered with a 4 and 52.9% answered with a 5, equaling 82.3% total.
Individuals surveyed were asked to list one way Concordia could have made the
transition from high school to college smoother for incoming students, two students commented
on more opportunities to meet other students besides during orientation. One said “Orientation
was great, but it would’ve been nice to continue building those relationships throughout the year.
When asked if they would have benefited from having a campus buddy to help with their
transition from high school to college, of the 15 that responded 11 responded yes. One student
added “I think it would have helped me to feel more established on campus because I ended up
moving back home after my freshman year and commuting instead because I hadn't made strong
Additionally, students were asked for suggestions to create campus wide awareness about
different disabilities. One student said “Education and action- not only do students need
education (such as a seminar) about different disabilities because there is a negative stigma about
this word, but they also need to actually interact with people who have special needs in order to
break the stigma.” Another student said “I think your buddy system itself would really help with
this because people will learn by experiencing time with students who have disabilities while that
are with their buddies - building relationships.” The survey consisted of questions that can be
Once the information was gathered and analyzed I developed the details of the buddy
system program. The proposed program will then be presented to the director of the Academic
Resource Center at Concordia University Ann Arbor and will hopefully be implemented during
the summer of 2018 to assist incoming students with disabilities to have a smoother and more
successful transition to higher education. All data collected remained anonymous and
confidential and discussed only between members of the chosen board. The proposed program
included transition options for students on campus, in the classroom and in the surrounding
Timeline
September:
October:
November-December:
Finalize online questionnaire and get approval from content advisor for her to send out
January-March:
Make phone calls, set up interviews, & start collecting buddy questionnaires.
Interview other high schools and universities for best practices in regards to students with
disabilities.
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 15
April:
May:
June:
Provide the ARC final project for potential implementation at CUAA. (June 29th, 2018)
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 16
REFERENCES
Corlett, S. (2001). Special Educational Needs and Disability Act. Skill: National Bureau for
https://proxy01.cuaa.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/195188004?acco
untid=10245
Essex, T. A. (2012). Special education students with learning disabilities transitioning from high
school into community colleges (Order No. 3499682). Available from ProQuest Central.
https://proxy01.cuaa.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/945731213?acco
untid=10245
Heiman, T., & Precel, K. (2003). Students with learning disabilities in higher education:
from https://proxy01.cuaa.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/1942222
10?accountid=10245
Hitchings, W. E., Retish, P., & Horvath, M. (2005). Academic preparation of adolescents with
https://proxy01.cuaa.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/223127218?acco
untid=10245
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 17
Landmark College - The College of Choice for Students Who Learn Differently. (2017).
Macomb Community College, Special Services. (2017). Retrieved October 20, 2017
from https://www.macomb.edu/future-students/student-resources/counse
ling-academic-advising/special-services/index.html
National Center for Learning Disabilities, The State of Learning Disabilities (2014.).
National Center for Special Education Research, NCSER Publications: The Post-High School
Outcomes of Young Adults With Disabilities up to 8 Years After High School: Key
Findings From the National Longitudinal Transition Study-2 (NLTS2). (2011). Retrieved
Navigate Life Texas, College and Alternatives for Students with Disabilities. (2017). Retrieved
adulthood/college-and-alternatives-for-students-with-disabilities
?accountid=10245
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 18
Texas Council for Developmental Disabilities, Higher Education Resource Guide Released.
education-resource-guide-released
University of Iowa REACH (Realizing Educational and Career Hopes). (2017). Retrieved
U.S Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics: Post secondary students
APPENDIX A
DISABILITY COORDINATORS
1.) What are some of the current transition options provided for students with disabilities to
2.) On a scale of 1-5 (1 meaning very ineffective and 5 meaning very effective), how
effective do you think your school/ institution is at providing students with disabilities
3.) What are some of the challenges you face when preparing students for higher education?
4.) What advice do you have for colleges and universities to help make the transition to high
5.) What kind of educational plans do you have in place for students to develop the skills
6.) What can current educators do to help bridge the gap between high school and higher
education?
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 20
APPENDIX B
Concordia University
Informed Consent Form
Authorization for an Adult to Serve as a Research Participant
As a part of the requirements for my Master’s degree from Concordia University—Ann Arbor, I,
Angela Martin will be conducting a project to Foster Educational Opportunities for Students with
Disabilities Through the Utilization of a Student-Peer Buddy System to Help with the Transition
to Higher Education I am requesting your permission to use your data from an interview, survey,
My Contact information:
Angela Martin
P: (586)822-0968
Email: angela.martin@cuaa.edu
******************************************************************************
************
I agree to participate in one or more forms of data collection about Fostering Educational
Opportunities for Students with Disabilities Through the Utilization of a Student-Peer Buddy
System to Help with the Transition to Higher Education to be conducted by Angela Martin
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 21
I understand that my participation is completely voluntary and that I may withdraw from the
research at any time I choose to do so, without penalty. I further understand that confidentiality
will be enforced at all times and that my information (data) will be protected from release to
anyone other than the researcher. Furthermore, I may request copies of the data and I may
Moreover, I further understand that prior to completion of the final research project report, all
identifying characteristics will be removed. I further understand that should I have questions or
Participant:__________________________________________________Date_________
Researcher:__________________________________________________Date________
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 22
APPENDIX C
1.) On a scale of 1-5 (1 meaning very dissatisfied and 5 meaning very satisfied), how
satisfied are you with your transition from high school to Concordia?
2.) List one way Concordia could’ve made the transition from high school to higher
3.) Would you have benefited from having a campus-buddy to help with your transition from
4.) What suggestions do you have for us to create campus wide awareness about different
disabilities?
5.) What is one tool or resources that has aided in your success at Concordia?
6.) On a scale of 1-5 (1 meaning strongly disagree and 5 meaning strongly agree) how much
would you agree that the implementation of a buddy system would benefit both current
This Survey will be sent to students email with a online survey link sent out to their emails.
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 23
APPENDIX D
Concordia University
Your feedback is essential in order to help students with disabilities transition to higher
education. Please consider participating in this survey by clicking on the on-line survey link
below
My Contact information:
Angela Martin
P: (586)822-0968
Email: angela.martin@cuaa.edu
If you choose to participate, I ask that you complete the on-line survey on or before May 16th,
2018
******************************************************************************
************
Before you begin the survey, please read the following information so that you fully understand
the potential risks, benefits, and confidentiality components of this study.
1. Participation in this study does not present any form of risk to you.
2. Completing this survey will require about five to ten minutes of your time.
3. Participation in this survey is strictly voluntary and you may discontinue your
involvement at any time without penalty.
4. The responses obtained through the survey will be kept confidential, only the researcher
and university research supervisor will access the data.
5. The final report will contain no identities linking the responses back to the subjects after
the survey is submitted. Also, the researcher receives no indication of which of the
subjects participated in the study or not.
POTENTIAL BENEFITS:
TRANSITION TO HIGHER EDUCATION 25
A summary of the results will be shared with Emily Perry, Disability Support Services
Coordinator in the hopes that it can assist in helping students with disabilities transition to
higher education.
CONSENT TO PARTICIPATE:
I further understand that should I have questions or concerns, I may contact: Kellie Durham P:
(734)995-7582 Email: kellie.durham@cuaa.edu