Professional Documents
Culture Documents
'
r p ,
46
iris .' rø
,3
r.
10 'I
•w
jf$a
c\
t
.,s
1
it4 •eej
•. 1
1
fl ."
S
.
go ¶..
i' p4.#•;
/
.1
Itl E
S
S
I.
S ing
I 10"
- !P0
I GOVERNMENT OF KERALA
PERSONNEL & ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS DEPARTMENT
I
I
I
I
I
Work Study Report on Village offices under Land
I Revenue Department
I
I
I
I
I
I
I PERSONNEL & ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS (AR-5)
I DEPARTMENT
S
I
I
I
I
I
I
S
I
S
Government of Kerala
• Personnel & Administrative Reforms Department
To, -
•
• Sir,
• - G. mprakash
. Joint Secretary to Govt.
• Copy to:-
•The Principal Secretary, Revenu3amenti
2? The Commissioner, Lftb7thiuiháuáiWT'
3. The Library, P&ARD, Secretariat
•
•
40
- 4
PROJECT DIRECTIVE
PREFACE
Village Offices being the grass root level entity of the State Revenue
administration, are responsible for protection of Government land,
collection of various type of taxes, issuance of various certificates for the
public, matters related to General Administration and so on. As the
population in the state has increased, the number of people visiting village
offices for different needs has also increased. But there is no
corresponding growth in the staff strength of village' offices. The present
staff pattern was fixed almost 3 decades ago. Work burden in village
offices has been doubled over the period. The situation is such that the
public becomes frustrated and the staff becomes helpless. Moreover,
even basic facilities required for an office are not provided in majority of
village offices. It was against this backdrop, Administrative Reforms Team-
5 of P&AR Department has been invited to look into and suggest remedial
measures.
COMPOSITION OF THE TEAM
Shri. Jayankumar S. K. (Section Officer).
Shri. Rakesh S. P. (Assistant)
Shri. Shaji A (Assistant)
Shri. Omanakuttan. B (Assistant)
Shri. Renjith. R (Assistant)
GUIDES
I
I
• 5
S
S
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I
The Department of Personnel and Administrative Reforms is extremely
• thankful to the Land Revenue Department for assigning this important and
• prestigious study. In this context we wish to thank the Commissioner of
• Land Revenue, other officers and staff of the Land Revenue Department
• Officers and other Village staff who have helped in facilitating data
• We are extremely confident that this report would go a long way in helping
S
•
I
• Or. Nivedida P. Haran
•
I
S
I
•
•
•
I
I
I.
Table of Contents
MISSION
CC:: O
Chapter- 1
½ r
Executive summary
1.1.1. The report in the ensuing chapters has been prepared in response to the
request of the Revenue Department to restructure the staff pattern in
Village Offices in accordance with the heavy workload being experienced
there and to suggest measures to streamline the works and to improve the
working environment in village offices. It is to be stated at the outset that
the workload in village offices has increased by leaps and bounds
proportionately to the increase in population and land ownership.
Meanwhile, it is a curious fact to note that the Village offices in our state
are still functioning with the staff pattern which was implemented almost 3
decades ago. Therefore, it becomes imperative to adopt some measures
to alleviate the difficulties experienced by the staff and general public.
1.1.2. For data collection, the team visited a few sample village offices in all 63
taluks. Since the Land Revenue Department is one of the largest
Departments in the state with 1634 village offices having 7500 employees
it required a minimum period of one year for conducting a comprehensive
work study covering all aspects. Besides, the measurement of work load
requires special care and precision due to the fact that the works in village
offices have an oscillating nature with occasional rise and fall that too
depend on a lot of other factors such as, the number of population,
common occupation of villagers, area of the village offices.etc. Moreover,
the problems being experienced in village offices are not common in
10
1.1.3. The result of data thus analyzed shows that majority of village offices in
the State can function with the existing staff strength if a streamlining of
methods and procedures are adopted. The physical inspection of village
offices gives a grim picture of working environment prevalent in village
offices. The report puts forward a few suggestions to enhance the basic
amenities that will surely increase the efficiency and efficacy of village
staff. Recommendations include:
S
•
•
ri
—•
11
Chapter- 2
Introduction
2.1.1. The above quotation clearly portrays man's inextricable bond with land.
Since the Land Revenue Department deals with the variegated issues of
man and land, it attains a prominent position among other departments in
the state. People of all walks of life depend on the services of the
department on various matters. It is not an exaggeration to say that no
one can die without visiting a village office once. The village offices being
the grass root level entity of the Revenue Department, extend service to
one and all in every nook and corner of the state.
2.2.1. The history of Land Administration dates back to the olden days of kings.
Right from the time of Manu, land revenue had been a major source of
income for rulers. During the Maurya and Gupta periods, land revenue
I'
S 12
was collected by paid officials, which resembles the present day revenue
administration system. Later, in the place of the revenue collectors, the
Jagirdars, Subedars and lnamdars came and they functioned as
S administration. -
2.2.2. The system of revenue administration was started by Sulthan Sher Shah
S Sun (1540-45),and it continued during the reign of the Mughal Emperor
S Akbar (1556-1605). Raja Todar Mal - the greatest revenue expert who
started his career under Sher Shah Sun and joined in the service of Akbar,
is remembered even today for evolving a system of revenue assessment
S and survey, a system which drew a balance between the demands of the
State and needs of the subjects. The Revenue Administration during the
S
regime of Mughals consisted of a heterogeneous class of persons, which
included direct officials of the imperial administration, and representatives
of the peasants.
I
I 2.2:3. With the advent of the British rule in India, the political and economic
I system in tune with British customs and laws relating to land. During the
British times, the Revenue Department was the pivot of
I
administration. The Collector was the virtual monarch at the district,
S
around whom the entire administration revolved.
I 2.2.4. After Independence, by and large, the same institutional structure has
been retained with a few changes for better delivery of service. In more
recent decades, focus has been less on Land Reforms and more on Land
I
Development and Administration such as Drought - Prone Area
Programme, Desert Development Programme and Watershed
I
Development Programme etc.
I
S
I
I
4 1
S
13
S (Clerks and Accountant). During the first revenue settlement each division M
S existence. In the year 1984, the Village and Revenue services were
integrated and a common Revenue service was formed. Lower Division
S
Clerks and Village Assistants were integrated into one common unit and
S
Upper Division Clerks and the Village Officers were integrated as another
S
S
\
S
14
2.4.3. With the growth of the state, the duties and responsibilities of the Revenue
S
Department increased a lot. But the department remained stationery for
S
more than four decades without remarkable changes in its basic structure.
S
Several Commissions which had gone into restructuring of the department
produced only compendiums of recommendations which were scarcely
S acted upon. The last such report was that of the Radhakrishna Pillai
S Commission and it contained some substance for action. The report
S envisaged a qualitative change in the internal functioning of the
S 2.4.4. As per G.O (MS) No.331/98/RD dated 20/6/1998 the Board of Revenue
was abolished and the department was re-named Land Revenue
S Department. Based on the study report of P.R Radha Krishna PiIlai
Commission, Government issued G.O(MS) No.510/98/RD dated
14/10/1998 which paved the way to the re-organisation of the department.
*
S
I
15
As part of the re-organisation, a few idle offices including Farka Village
Offices were abolished. The poet of Head clerk was renamed as Village
Officer and given full charge of village offices. Except this, there occurred
hardly any change in the basic structure of the village offices.
V
16
Chapter-3
3.1.2. At present there are 1634 village offices including 63 Kasaba village
offices and group villages. The existing staff pattern of village offices is
detailed below:
TOTAL : 5 Posts
3.1.3. Against this backdrop, the Commissioner, Land Revenue Department vide
his letter No. L.R.E8-51530/06 dated 06/07/2010 requested the
Government to conduct a work study so as to estimate the workload of all
village offices in the state and to determine the feasibility of sanctioning
additional post of a clerk. Consequentiy, the Revenue Department
requested P & ARD to conduct a work study to ascertain the feasibility of
granting additional post of clerk in village offices. The file was forwarded to
this department through the Minister concerned, with specific orders to
17
conduct a detailed work study. The work study team viz. P&AR (AR-5)
was assigned with the task of conducting the study and hence the report
in the ensuing chapters.
Irla
r
F!
I
•t!A
I
I Chapter- 4
I
Methodology
I
I 4.1.1. The work study team headed by Sri. P.S. Gopakumar, Additional
Secretary, Shri. M.Shahul Hameed, Deputy Secretary, Shri.Joykutty.M,
Under Secretary to Government Personnel &Administrative Reforms
I
Department held a preliminary discussion with the Commissioner of Land
S
Revenue and other senior officers of the Land Revenue Department. The
discussion helped the team members to identify the area and scope of the
I
proposed work study. Details with regarding various offices and present
I activities were also. collected for furthering the study. Extensive
I discussions were also held with the functionaries at different levels.
I
4.1.2. Suitable forms were designed for collection of job details. The team
conducted pilot study in two village offices, Viz., Ayyanthol and
I Kumarakom. The annual workload of functionaries, both clerical and
supervisory, were obtained for a period of one year. The base year for
1N
• 19
S
• 4.1.3. For the measurement of workload of various functionaries, the team
• utilized both primary and secondary data sources. For the collection of
• primary data, the team relied on conventional work study tools such as
• official tours etc. also had been taken in to consideration for making the
S
•
•
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
07W
-
nsM
21
Chapter- 5
ORGANISATIONAL SETUP AND ANALYSIS
Organization Structure of Land Revenue Department
4 4
Assistant Secretory
'7
I I
Vilinge Officers
22
5.1.2. Revenue department is the first to rush to the people during the times of
Natural Calamities like Tsunami, drought and flood. The Department
shifts the affected people to places of safety and it provides food, clothes,
shelter and also distributes essential commodities and financial assistance
in the form of cash. It may be said that in every walk of the common
man's need, the participation of Revenue Department cannot be under
estimated. In order to serve the people in a better way, this department
has a well established hierarchy.
5.1.3. The Department is under the control. of the Minister for Revenue. The
Secretariat is headed by the Revenue. Secretary who is assisted by
Additional Secretaries / Joint Secretaries / Deputy Secretaries. The
Revenue Department is headed by Land Revenue Commissioner who is
assisted by Additional Commissioner / Assistant Commissioners. The
State of Kerala consists of 14 districts, 21 revenue divisions, 63 taluks and
1634 villages including Group Villages and Kasaba villages. Each district
is headed by a District Collector who is assisted by Deputy Collectors
among others. The revenue divisions are headed by Revenue Divisional
Officers and are assisted by Senior Superintendents among others. Every
taluk is headed by a Tahsildar who is assisted by Additional Tahsildars /
23
SVONA2
VFA2
Legend:
V.0 - Village Officer
5.2.1. Village Offices have close relationship with the public. It is the root level
• office of the Land Revenue Department. It is through these offices
government execute general administration across the state. A Village
• 24
• Office is an important office at the lowest level where people come for
• paying various taxes, for getting certificates of various needs, for availing
Village Officer
• 5.3.1. Village Officer is the head of a village who works on behalf of the
• the village has to do the routine work of a village officer and at the same
•
•
•
•
•
25
I.
Prepare Land Revenue Registers and Accounts accurately
Prepare reports and periodicals to higher officers
S
Village Field Assistant
S
S 5.5.1. Village Field Assistants assist the Village Officer and Special Village
S
28
5.5.4. Even if the village offices are struggling hard to cope with the ever
increasing workload with existing insufficient staff strength, the department
find itself maintaining the needs of the common man. Since Revenue
Administration touches one and all in the state, the success or failure of
this administration mar or better the image of the government. Therefore
certain measures need to be taken for upholding the goodwill of the
department.
Kasaba villages
5.6.1. Kasaba Village Offices are those village offices functioning in the Taluk
Head Quarters. There are 63 Kasaba Villages in the state. At present.
Kasaba Village Offices already have more staff than common villages. So
that Kasaba Villages are not included in the purview of the work study.
29
Major Services available from Village Offices
Issue of various types of certificates
I
Possession Certificate:
I 5.7.1. Application duly written in the prescribed form with a court fee stamp worth
I rupees five affixed in it should be submitted to the Village Officer, along
I with the proof of documents of ownership, possession, land tax receipt
I etc. The Certificate will be issued within one week from the date of receipt
I of the application as per GO (MS) No.300/96/RD dated.12.6.1996.
Certificates for special purposes are to be produced before the Central
I
Government Offices are issued by the Tahsildar. The Village Officer is
I empowered to issue possession certificate as per GO (MS)No. 1 09/92/RD
I dated.1O.2.1992. Separate certificate will be issued for each purpose as
per GO (MS)No.136107/RD dated.27.4.2007.
I
Location Certificate:
I 5.7.2. Application duly filled in the white paper/ form prescribed with a
I court fee stamp worth rupees five affixed in it should be submitted
to the Village Officer. The document of ownership, land tax receipts
I etc. have to be prod uced along with the application. The prescribed
fee should be remitted for the sketch plan issued by the Village
Officers under the instructions stipulated in the No. LRD1-36319/07
dated.20.06.2007 of the Additional Commissioner, Land Revenue,
I
Thiruvananthapuram. The Certificate will be issued after due
enquiry and site verification. The Village Officer is empowered to
issue location Certificate as per GO (MS)No.136/07/RD
S dated.27.4.2007. Separate certificate will be issued for each
I purpose as per the above Government order.
I
I
I
I
I
S
. 30
S
• Income Certificate:
S 5.7.4. The Village Officer is empowered to issue income certificates as per
Village Officer after making due enquiry regarding his income. The
Certificate will be issued within one week as per GO (MS)
No.300/96/RD dated.12.6.2000. The validity period of this
certificate of persons having income up to Rs.36000/- has been
enhanced to 1 year as per GO (MS)No.136/07/RD
dated.27.4.2007. Certificate of persons having income above
Rs.36000/- has only six months validity period as existed earlier.
Solvency Certificate:
5.7.5. Application in the white paper with a court fee stamp worth rupees
five affixed in it should be submitted to the Village officer along with
the document of ownership i.e. title deed (in original), ration card,
land tax receipt and stamp paper worth Rs.50/- The encumbrance
certificate for 12 years from the Sub Registrar Office is also to be
produced to prove the applicant is solvent. The Certificate will be
issued by the Village Officer after making due enquiry within 7 days
as per GO (MS)No.300/96/RD dated.12.6.1996. The Village Officer
was authorized to issue Solvency Certificate for value not
exceeding Rs.5000/- as per GO (MS) No. 567/91/RD
dated.12.9.1991. Then the value has been enhanced to
Rs.100000/- as per GO (MS) No. 391/05/RD dated 16.12.2005. As
per the amendment made on 27.4.2007 as per GO (MS)
No.136/07/RD, the value has been enhanced up to Rs.5, 00,000/-
Valuation Certificate:
5.7.6. Application in the white paper or in the format shown with a court
fee stamp worth rupees five affixed in it should be submitted to the
4)
. 32
• Village officer along with the document of ownership i.e. title deed
• . (in original), ration card and land tax receipt. The encumbrance
• certificate for 12 years from the Sub Registrar Office also need to
• Nativity Certificate:
• 5.7.8. Application duly filled in the prescribed form with a court fee stamp
• worth rupees five affixed in it should be submitted to the Village
• Officer, along with the documents for proof required i.e. property,
• . stamp. People who are residing outside Kerala should submit the
residential certificate along with their application for Nativity
• . .
•
•
•
•
e
-I
33
S
• Certificate. The certificate will be issued to those who were born in
5.7.11. Application duly filled in the prescribed form with a cowl fee stamp
worth rupees five affixed in it should be submitted to the Village
Officer. The supporting documents like ration card etc. has to be
• produced along with the application. The Certificate will be issued
• by the Village Officer after due enquiry regarding members of the
• family. The Village Officer is empowered to issue family
• membership certificate as per GO (MS) No. 567/91/RD
35
Destitute Certificate:
5.7.13. Application duly filled in the prescribed form witha court fee stamp
worth rupees five affixed in it should be submitted to the Village
• Officer along with ration card. The Certificate will be issued by the
• Village Officer after due enquiry. The Village Officer is empowered
* to issue destitute certificate as per GO (MS) 1039/79/RD dated
• 36
S
Non-remarriage Certificate:
• 5.7.15. Application duly filled in the prescribed form with a court fee stamp
• worth rupees five affixed in it should be submitted to the Village
• Officer. The death certificate of her husband, ration card, election
identity cards etc. are to be produced along with the application.
The Village Officer is empowered to issue this Certificate under GO
(MS) No. 391/05/RD dated 16.12.2005. Separate certificate will be
issued for each purpose as per GO (MS)Nc'.136/07/RD
dated.27.4.2007
Widow Certificate:
5.7.16. Application duly filled in the prescribed form with a court fee stamp
worth rupees five affixed in it should be submitted to the Village
Officer. The death certificate of her husband, ration card, election
identity cards etc. are to be produced along with the application.
The Village Officer is empowered to issue this Certificate under GO
(MS) No. 391/05/RD dated 16.12.2005. Separate certificate wilIbe
issued for each purpose as per GO (MS)Nó.136/07/RD
dated.27.4.2007.
• 37
• enquiry.
• No House Certificate:
• 5.7.20. Application duly filled in the white paper/ form with a court fee
• stamp of rupees five affixed in it be submitted to the Village Officer.
• enquiry.
S
• Dependency Certificate:
5.7.21. Application duly filled in the white paper/ form with a court fee
S. stamp of Rs.5 affixed be submitted to the Village Officer along with
S .
•
S
•
S
-4
S
• 38
ration card. The Certificate will be issued by the Village Officer after
• due enquiry.
• - Domicile Certificate:
5.7.22. Application duly filled in the white paper/ form with a court fee
stamp of Rs. 5 affixed be submitted to the Village Officer along with
the records to prove his domicile. The Village Officer is empowered
to issue this Certificate under GO (MS) No. 391!05/RD dated
. 16.12.2005. The Certificate will be issued by the Village Officer
after due enquiry. The validity period of this certificate has been
S enhanced to life long as per GO (MS)No.136/07/RD
• dated.27.4.2007.
5.7.23. Application duly filled in the white paper/ form with a court fee
stamp worth rupees five affixed in it should be submitted to the
Village Officer along with the details of remittance made, the title
deed. The Certificate will be issued by the Village Officer after due
enquiry.
Unmarried Certificate:
5.7.24. Application duly filled in the white paper/ form with a court fee
stamp of Rs. 5 affixed be submitted to the Village Officer along
with the ration card and School certificate. The Certificate will be
issued by the Village Officer after due enquiry.
Unemployment Certificate:
5.7.25. Application duly filled in the white paper/ form with a court fee
'IL
• 39
• in the area under his jurisdiction and protect it for the government.
• When the surplus land is set for distribution it is the duty of the
village officer to furnish a report to the Tahsildar about the
whereabouts of the beneficiaries. Whenever an encroachment on
. the government land is noticed, the village officer should
immediately furnish a report to the Tahsildar concerned which
comprises the nature of trespass, sketch as well as mahasar of the
encroachment for taking action. Protection of government property
• also means protection of trees, soil, pebbles, boulders, metals,
• sand and stone
• Works related to General Administration
5.8.1. Majority of the General Administration in the state is carried out
through the village offices, Village officers are often entrusted with
other duties that normally do not related to the Land Revenue
• Department. Following are such nature of works exercised by the
• village officers.
•
•
•
•
S
S
:4
. 40
• Land Bank:
5.8.3. For the protection of Government land and also to make land
utilization more comprehensive and scientific, government have
• lounged an ambitious project called Land Bank. As per the project,
• village officer has to identify and demarcate the land. He has to
• maintain a register showing sketch and location of the area.
•
Granting permit for sand mining, rock
blasting:
• 5.8.4. Based on the sketch of the site and report of the village officer, the
. District Collector concerned grant permission for sand mining and
• Rock blasting.
• Natural calamity/Disaster:
5.8.5. A disaster/natural calamity is an event triggered by natural or manmade
• causes that lead to sudden disruption of normalcy within society, causing
• wide spread damage to life and property. The Village officer is bound to
• convey immediate information to the higher officers including the District
•
•
•
•
•
41
Election Work:
5.8.6. The Revenue Department is entrusted with the whole process connected
with general election work. The duties of District Election Officer are
performed by the District Collector and the Electoral Regstration Officer
by the Tahsildar and the Assistant Electoral Registration Officer by the
Deputy Tahsildar, Election. All other staff of the Revenue Department
especially Village staff play a leading role in the entire election process
• Rightto Information:
5.9.2. The Village Officer is also act as the State Public Information Officer. As
the State Public Information Officer in village office, he shall provide the
information required for the persons under the provisions contained in
. the Right to Information Act, 2005.
• Annexure. 1)
• Revenue Recovery
• 5.9.4. The establishment/firm who are affecting recovery against the defaulters,
S
o
43
the duty of the Village Officer to furnish a report to the recovery officials..
S The report includes full details of the defaulter, his properties and the
sketch of the location. The services of Village staff is highly necessary
for the execution of demand notice and confiscation of property. It is the
S duty of the village officer to keep the confiscated property under his safe
custody. His presence is also required at the time when the confiscated
Land Relinquishment:
5.9.5. Land owners can relinquish right on their property at their own will to
S the Government for welfare/developmental activities of the state.
I
Protection of Survey marks:
5.9.6. The Village Officer in entrusted with the following duties as per the
I
provisions contemplated in section 17 of the Survey and boundaries
I
Act, 1961.
I a) To prevent the destruction, injury, removal or alteration, of any survey
mark on or within the limits of his jurisdiction
I b) When he becomes aware that any such mark has been destroyed,
removed or altered, the mailer has to be reported to the Taluk
Surveyor by an entry in an Inspection register. An extract of which
I should be submitted periodically
I
rd
5.9.7. If the registered holder of any land fail to repair demarcation of survey
marks within the period specified in the notice, the officer concerned
under the Act shall renew or repair the survey marks at Government
cost, which will be recovered later from the registered holder of the
land. In the case of a survey mark on the boundary between
Government land and registered land, the registered holder or the
owner of land touching the survey is liable to be responsible for the
maintenance..
Cardamom Settlement:
5.9.8. This rule is applicable only to ldukki district. The act contemplates that a
person who illegally occupied government land for cardamom
cultivation may be given the said land on lease for 20 years without
auction for cardamom cultivation. The village officer should prepare a
register containing sketch of the land in this regard and should be kept
in safe custody.
Ponnumvila Procedures:
5.9.9. As per the Land Acquisition Act of 1894 and Land Acqusition (Kerala)
•
Act of 1990 the government is vested with the power for acquisition of
the appropriate land for national interest by paying compensation to
. the land owner is vested with Government. It is the duty of the Village
Officer to measure the land to be acquired and prepare subdivision
sketch for each processions and submit the same to the Tahsildar for
further actions.
• 45
• auction.
•
• Various Welfare Schemes:
• 5.9.12. Many welfare schemes such as financial assistance for T.B patients,
• Leprosy patients and Cancer patients are implemented through the
Revenue Department. Applications in this regard are to be submitted to
•
• Disaster Relief:
• 5.9.13.Disaster Relief is granted in the following cases on the enquiry report of
• the Village Officer.
• river
S
•
•
S
S
S
0
S FN
4 Mishap to Live stock
4• When any damage to the property of fishermen occurs due to
monsoon damages
4 Damage to the tools of Craftsmen
0 4 Damage to house
+ For the emergency supply of drinking water
• Damage to welts
4 To purchase medicine, fàod, clothing for disaster affected area
0
9 To remove stagnant filthy water and wastes in order to prevent
breeding of mosquitoes
9 For rescue operations, search operations
0
Other functions
S
S SI.
Functions F
Name of Act/Rules
S
I
marks, furnish reports to
Tahsildars, collection of
964
S
5 Throtect Government land Kerala Land Conservancy Act
S from encroachment,
collection of dues and
•l
furnishing reports on
encroachment I
[i Enquiry on land Kerala land relinquishment Act
relinqthshrnent
S [Recoveryofarrears !Kerala Land Development Act
S
S
S
a
47
8fFurnhingreport [Kerala Land Utilisation Order
19 ollection_of dues Iseulement scheme patta Rules
[Ti Collection of dues Rules for sale of land for coffee
and tea cultivation rules,1974
11 Collection of dues Rules for lease of land to
Government offices and
Bungalow
[T ñ enquiry reports, IRules for lease of Government
collection of dues and land for tobacco cultivation
maintenance of records
13 [Management of surplus land Kerala Land Reforms Act
jand collection of usufructs
r14 JManagementof receiver Civil Procedure Code,1908
property
15 [urnish preliminary erala Escheats'and Forfeitures
information on escheated rAct 1964 and Rules, 1965
cases to Tahsildar and
.
16
1management of escheated
property
JEnquiry and report to the Kerala Treasure Trove Act, 1968
Tahsildar and Rules 1971
17 [Enquiry and report to the The Kerala Scheduled Tribes
Tahsildar (Restriction on transfer of lands
S and restoration of alienated lands)
Act, 1975 and Rules 1986
118 Report on Transfer of Transfer of Registry Rules, 1966,
Registry cases
19 Furnish enquiry reports :Kerala Minor Mineral
Concessions Rules 1967
[o[urnish enquiry reports jArms Act and Rules
r21 7ish enquiry reports Explosives Act and Rules
fl22 [Furnish enquiry reports Government orders on issue of
S certificates
S 23 [&nish enquiry reports Kandukrishi land Assignment
Rules, 1958
r24 1Furnish enquiry repo rt s Sreepandaravaka lands
S I (
and Rules
[26 Furnish enquiry reports IThe Kerala Service Inam lands
-- V&E) Act 1981 and Rules 1981
S ' 27 IFurnish enquiry reports Ikannan Devan Hills (resumption)
S
. 5
S
S
• 48
• At ct
1981 and Rules 1981
•. 28 Enquiry report, updating of Govt. Orders on issue of Patta to
land records etc. beneficiaries of one lakh housing
scheme
• [ 29 Enquiry and report
• -S&n?&r6viion of House
sites to rur& poor
30 Enquiry and report
• Rules for issue of Record of
Rights to occupants of
• 31 Enquiry and report
iporamboke land
I
45 Updating of land records Ker&a Land Reforms (vesting
•. 46 Render assistance for
and assignment) Rules, 1970
Scheme for providing financial
evacuation, rescue, relief, jassistance to victims of Natural
• shelter, food, clothing, calamity and disaster
S 50
S 63 jEnquiry and report - Evacuees Property Act
S 64 [Rendering assistance lJoint verification of Tribal lands
S 65 [Rendering assistance IJoint verification of Forest lands
66 [Enquiry and report For Coffee registration
S
[ëT[nquiry and report -
IFor cardamom registration
S [ëiEnquiry and report Mental Health Act
[69 and repo rt Prevention of Cruelty towards
S I I Animals Act
r° [furnish report Criminal Procedi.ire Code
71 Furnish report - - - Agricultural pests and Diseases
- - -
- Act,1958 H
r72 i Furnish report -
Kerala Anatomy Act 1 1957
73 [Furnish report IKerala Forest Act,1961
74 ~V6rnish report Kerala livestock improvement
Act,1961
S
175lFurnish report - Kerala Panchayat Raj Act
S Criminal Justice
[76 Furnish report
S
S
S
S
RVI
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
I
• 51
• 5.10.1 It came to the notice of the work study team that the village offices in the
state face not only prdblems related to lack of infrastructure but also grave
issues related to rendering of services. A few of them are given below:
• Tax Collection
• 5.10.2. Tax collection is one of the important functions of Village Offices. Various
• type of taxes viz, Land tax, One time building tax, Luxury tax, Plantation
• tax etc., are collected through village offices. In most of the village offices,
• full time service of a Village AssistantlSpecial Village Officer is utilized for
• each day's collection in the Day Book Register in the äame day itself.
• Limiting of remittance time to 4pm may help village staff to furnish the
• cash balance statement by 5pm and this will help them start the collection
of taxes early in the next day. Hence the work study team recommend
that the time for remitting various taxes may be limited up to 4 pm in
order to ensure healthy functioning of village offices.
• 52
5.10.6. Unlike in the past, the value of land across the state has been rising
• considerably at present. But tax collected in village office is very meager
• and not proportionate to the land value. Even though the tax rate was
• revised last year, it was done disproportionately. This causes huge deficit
• in revenue collection to the state exchequer. Therefore, the work study -
•
•
•
•
•
•
• 53
• Luxury Tax
•
• 5.10.7. In addition to Building Tax, Luxury tax of Rs. 2000/- has also been
5.10.8. 'Home' is a dream of millions of people. But the resources are limited. In
this scenario, it is inappropriate that a small section of the community is
enjoying a lions' share of the resources. Moreover, an increased house
. building tax will discourage the trend of constructing huge houses for a
small family of 4 members. Therefore the work study team suggest that
a slab system in the case of Luxury Tax as recommended in pre para
• should be introduced in the state urgently.
•
• Lease Rate
5.10.9. Government Land and Fruit Trees are being given on nominal lease for a
• year. See the Table below
S
Trees Period Rate!Tree
El -.4
Cocunut Tree 1 Year Rs. 50
S 1 Year Rs.25
Arecanut
S 1 Year Rs.15
Jack Tree
S Palm 1 Year Rs. 8
S Tamarind 1 Year Rs.25
S Mango tree 1 Year Rs. 25
S Cashew Tree 1 Year Rs. 21
S
S
S
S
S
'0
54
5.10.10. From the table it could be seen that Government property is being leased
to outside at a cheap rate. One kilo of Mango will cost Rs. 30/- even on
a peak season. But the Government get only Rs. 25/- for a single Mango
Tree. It is high time to revise the Lease Rate. Therefore the work study
S team recommend for revising the Lease rates year by year at a
reasonable rate and the same will be resulted in the revenue of the
Government.
S and focus on other utility job. Hence the work study team suggest that
necessary instructions should be given to the Local Self Government
S
Institutions to make it mandatory the remittance of One Time
S
Building Tax in advance in village offices for allocation of number to
S
newly constructed buildings.
S
S
S
S
S
55
Bifurcation of Villages
5.10.13. Every village in Kerala is different from one another in area, population,
geographical nature, living standard of natives and occupation etc.
Boundary of a village is normally determined by considering the above
criteria. But some villages are remarkable for their wide area or
population. Most of the big villages located in Idukki and Wayanad districts
are with natives of tribal people who are concentrated on some pockets
56
viz settlements inside the forest. These people will have to travel long
distance to get to the village offices. Moreover, transportation facility in
these areas is insufficient. So is the case with the village staff also. They
have to travel deep into these forest settlements for field visit where
transportation facility is inadequate. Therefore the Work Study team
recommend bifurcation of group villages immediately to ensure
effective delivery of service to the public.
Revenue Recovery
5.10.14. Revenue Department also act as a wing to make revenue recovery from
individuals or institutions in favour of Government Bodies or Public Sector
Undertakings as per requirement. Nationalised Banks, KSFE, KSEB,
Water Authority, BSNL etc. often rely on the Revenue Department for
effecting recovery from their defaulted customers. 5% percentage of the
amount recovered from the defaulted party is allotted to the Revenue
Department towards the cost of recovery proceedings and it become
possible only after the completion of recovery proceedings. In some
cases, it is seen that when the recovery proceedings are initiated, the
party concerned approach the parent department where the amount is due
and make an one-time settlement. In such cases, the Revenue
Department does not get 5 % of defaulted amount towards cost of
recovery proceedings. Actually the Revenue Department cost expense for
the recovery related proceedings like serving of notices etc. Hence the
Study Team recommend for inserting a condition in the Rules and
Procedures related to Revenue Recovery that . an
lnstitution!Department approaching Revenue Department for
recovery related proceedings should remit 5 % amount in advance to
the Revenue Department.
57
Contingency Fund
5.10.18. Whenever an emergency situation like natural calamities happen, it is the
village employees who run to the spot first. They engage in rescue
. operations and co-ordinate rehabilitation activities. For all these initial
operations, the village officer always find money from his pocket. Likewise,
the village officer always find himself in a tight situation When it comes to
the payment of office electricity charge, water charge and telephone
• charge. Though these casual expenses will be reimbursed later from the
• taluk office it usually take several months. Against this background the
• 60
5.10.20. But, it is very unfortunate to note that many employees of the Revenue
Department have no experience of working in village offices. Many of
• them are reluctant to work in village offices and they are known to use
• even political influence to escape posting in viliage offices. When these
• employees get promotion as Village officers, only then they come to work
• administrative knowledge of its basic unit?. On the whole, the result is the
degeneration of governess in the Revenue Department. The work study
team took note of this terrible situation and thereby the team
recommends that every employee in the Revenue department should
have at least 2 years of service in a village office and the service in
village offices should be made mandatory for getting promotion to
the post of Village officer, Revenue inspector and head Clerk.
•
•
• . Work Load Analysis
5.11.1. As far as a village office is concerned, the major activity lies in the issuance
There are more than 25 type of certificates are being issued from the
at national level, the village officer has to prepare a report and send to the
61
Tahasildar. Thus, the lion's share of the day's working time of village
officer is being spent for this. For instance, the pattern of certificate
issuance for the first half of the year 2010 and 2011 atChingoli Village
1200 r - -
1000
200
600
400 -.
200
0 L
—t-2010 —2011
It can clearly be seen from the graph that there is considerable increase in
certificate issuance during 2011 when compared to 2010. This upward
trend is applicable to all types of works in village offices.
• 62
• which is collected from the general public without proper enquiry. This
• leads undeserving applicants to gain benefit.
S
5:11.3. Normally there are two posts of Village Assistants in a village office and
the village Assistants are supposed to assist the Village Officer in all office
works as well as field duty. Village Assistants have regular duties related
to collection of taxes, transfer of registry (pokkuvaravu) etc. Hence, in
• most of the village offices, the Village Assistants/Special Village Officers
• have little time to help the Village Officer in processing applications for
• various kinds of certificates. This situation causes accumulation of
• applications in the village office. This may lead to the issuance of
• certificate without proper enquiry. The above situation may also cause
• the defect.
• 5.11.4. As said earlier, the Village officer is responsible for conducting enquiry
• and submit reports to the District Collector, Revenue Divisional Officer
• (R.D.O.), Land Tribunals, Civil Courts, Tahsildar, Special Tahsildar (R.R.
• & L.A.), etc. and even spot mahassar to local police station. Before
•
S
•
•
S
/
4
• 63
• to the needy and the deserved, the work study team decided to allot 3
• hours per day for each clerical staff in Village Offices for enquiry cases(
* One hour each to the Village officer and the other two Village a 1ssistants).
• This 3 hours time per day in total can be utilised for conducting enquiries
•
0
ID
•
S
S
S From the Pie diagram it can be seen that 16% of the total daily office time
• is set apart for field visit only.
•
• 5.11.5. If the service of a Village Assistant is made available for processing the
applications, it will be a great help to the village officer for timely disposal
S
of applications . But the area of tax collection, pokkuvaravu etc. often
hinder the village assistants in the timely disposal of applications. If the
S Village Field Assistants are also authorized for collection of taxes, the
S village assistants will get sufficient time for dealing with the applications for
S certificates received in the village office In such a way the Village Officer
S can spent free time for focusing on other works. Such a modification in
work allotment may help functioning village offices smoothly.
S
S
S
S
0
Other
• Other
Works • Works Duties
assign
ed by
o, V.A
Vt)
n Other
Works •
• X-c---,
•• /lroce
( ssing Tax
Collection
V.F.A
5.11.7. The factors which affect the volume of various applications in a Village
Office are shown below.
Population
Occupation ;-
Finañc
hal •..
Condit
• ton
cast
0
S
S
S 65
S If an average of 10 minutes is to be allotted for issuing a certificate, a
S village officer can issue an average of 30 certificates per day pending
S 300 minutes (ie. 5 hours per day).This means that 81% of the working
S time of an employee per day is utilized for issuing certificates only.
S
S
S
S
S
~Jo
369
S Q
S
S
S
I • Total Time 369 min • Time for Certificates. 300 nun. 83%
S 5.11.8. If the number of applications increases, the situation may become more
complicated as mentioned above. Nepotism and bribery may set-in and
• thereby spoiling the reputation of the village and ultimately may spoil the
S
goodwill of the Government.
I
5.11.9. Whenever Government launches welfare schemes, there will be a rush of
people to obtain eligibility certificates such as income certificates, caste
certificates etc. During school re-opening time, there will be another rush
S of people. Along with the issue of certificates, the Village Officer has to
look after other routine affairs such as Pokkuvaravu, land matters etc. He
has also to carry out the instructions of the higher level Revenue officers
S
with regard to general administration; attend meetings, conferences, hold
S
meetings etc. This also consumes large portion of a village officer's time.
S
As said earlier, the village officer is a touring officer who has to visit every
0
S
S
S
4
I
I 66
I nook and corner of the village. The Village officer entrust the Village
I Assistants to conduct field visit in certain cases. Work connected with
Pokkuvaravu and issue of location certificate necessitate field visit.
I Activities connected with protection of boundary stones, government
I lands, and implementation of welfare measures, necessitate field visit of
5.11.10. Along with the issue of certificates, the village staff has to collect various
I taxes like land tax, building tax (one time tax), luxury tax, plantation tax
etc. One of the two village assistants is entrusted with the duty. On a
comparative analysis, it is identified that an average of 50 receipts are
issued from a village office per day. If the tax payer come for remitting tax
I with specific details like old receipts, fresh tax receipt writing becomes
I easier for the staff and requires very little time. If such details are not
available, the village staff has to verify the volume of registers for
I
identifying survey number and Tandaperu etc. In normal cases, the village
I
staff after identifying the details in the register, calculate tax, accept the
I
amount, write fresh receipt and enter details in the registers. Altogether
I
this process requires an average of 7 minutes per case. If there are 50
receipts per day, the village staff has to spend 350 minutes per day for
a writing receipts only. This means that 5.8 hours per day is spend for the
I issuance of Tax receipt.
a 5.11.11. As per the work study norms an employee has to work for 1700 man
a hours in a year which includes time allotted for personal and fatigue
a allowance @ the rate of 15%. As far as a Village Office is concerned, a
a village assistant has to spend 1575 Man Hours in a year for writing
a receipts only. See the diagram on the previous page. If the number of
a receipts increases, time required for the activity also increases.
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
67
• 5.11.14. It is reasonable to give 10 hours in a month for all such other works to
• the village employees. Hence, the total time will be amounting to 120
• Man hours in an year. It is not at all an exaggeration to say that nothing
• 5.11.15. As far as the Village Office is concerned, there are more than 45 different
• . types of registers, including Jamabandhi register. The three clerical staff
• and the Village Officer is obliged to keep the registers up to date and
make it ready for inspection at any time by higher officers. According to
•
• the workstudy norms, a synthetic time of 20 minutes can be allotted to
each functionary for the maintenance of registers. Hence total time in this
•
way will be of 60 minutes per day which will amount to 270 Man Hours
per annum.
• _____________
•
mTime for Registers&Records management. 270 h/51 00
•
• 5.11.16. In the case of a Village Office, most of the registers are maintained during
the time of working hours. For example, when the time of transfer of
Registry or issue of certificate is done, entries in the registers concerned
are also done simultaneously. Many Village officers complained to the
• work study team that the registers are not supplied to them in time.
•
•
•
•
•
-b
S they are compelled to function with the existing staff pattern. According to
the work study norms if the total work load of a clerical functionary does
not exceed one third of 1700 man hours annually, there is no scope for
additional staff. The excess work load up to a maximum quantum of one
third (up to an annual maximum of 570 man hours for a single functionary)
S
may well be annulled.
S
5.11.18. It was also identified that the work load in a village office has an oscillating
S
nature. Work load in a Village Office for the first 4 months during 2010 is
S
shown below.
S
S
2500
S
2000
S 1500 o Crtfcts
o Tax
1000 0 PokuvaravU
S
500
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr
S
S
S
S
S
70
S
It can be seen from the graph that work load in a village is not uniform
S but rather seasonal. This workload more depends upon welfare policies of
S Government, General Election and School reopening period
S
5.11.19. During peak season like school re-opening time, there is a tendency to
rise the work load to its maximum (See the diagram. During the month of
May, June and July in the year 2010 and 2011, number of certificates
S issued is more than that of the remaining months.)
1 Noof
S Certificates I
issued
during 2010
S I and 2011
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
5.11.20. Apart from the peak season as mentioned above, the functioning of a
S
village office is working in a soft rhythm. The Department can think of
S
S
• 71
• providing the village staff with incentives, good service entry and similar
• honours inorder to encourage better performance among themselves.
5.11.21. In the case of village offices with more than 60 certifioates and 70 land tax
receipts as out turn per day can think of creation of an additional post of
• Lower Division Clerk. The Department is on the lookout for total
• computerization. In this circumstances, the service of an LDC having
• 5.11.22. With regard to the creation of post, a few things have to be taken into
• account. The creation of post can be done in the feeder category of lower
• division clerk. At the same time, the category of Special Village Officer
• the period of the study, the team noticed certain village Offices in the State
• with the post of the village officer lying vacant for long period. If the Village
•
•
•
•
•
72
5.11.25. At the outset of the chapter, it has been mentioned that major activity
taking place in Village Office is the issuance of various certificates. There
is a prescribed application form for each certificate which the applicant
has to bought from outside and submitted tothe office duly filled. Normally
this activity is done with the help of externa! agencies who demand
exorbitant rates. The work study team during data collection found many
such agencies attached to village offices and Taluk offices misleading and
misguiding the common people. Most often these agencies act as
middlemen and play cunning tricks on the poor people. If this practice is
continued, it will spoil the goodwill of the department. Therefore, the
department has to probe for rectification measures. Forms should be
provided to the people either free of cost or at a reasonable rate. The
officer in the help desk/enquiry counter can assist the people in getting the
forms filled by themselves. Hence the work study team recommend
I
• 73
• 6.11.26. The Village Officer issues certificates to the people for various purpose.
• The purpose will be mentioned specifically mentioned in the certificates.
• Therefore, a person who get a certificate for producing in the Supply
• . Office requires another one for producing before the Panchayat Office. In
• . etc., have a permanent nature. Such certificates, if issued for onetime can
• be laminated and kept for lifetime use. The department may probe for
• some measures in the direction so that the difficulties of the people and
the village staff can be reduced. Therefore the work study team
recommend that validity of some certificates like nativity, residence,
. legal heir ship etc. should be made life time. The Revenue
Department should consider issuing orders accordingly.
5.11.27. The general staff pattern of village offices is one Village Officer two
. Village Assistants. They are the staff members contributing the whole
. clerical work. There is also two Village Man in the Village Office. Duties
assigned to them are different. They are serving of notices, assisting
village staff for measurement of land and buildings, carrying of letters,
• reports and messages to higher offices, treasury duty etc. As such, the
• clerical staff (village officer and village assistants), have to perform duty
• for 5100 man hours per year (as per work study norms a functionary has
• day amounting to 1350 Man Hours per year. If there are 50 receipts per
• day (laid tax, building tax etc.), an average of 350 minutes is required for
• the work per day amounting to 1575 Man Hours in a year. If there are 4
•
S .
0
'LI
Pokkuvaravu cases in an office every day, 3 Man Hours are spent for the
purpose amounting to 810 Man Hours in a year. The clerical staff of the
village office has to go for field visit every day. An average of one Man
Hour can be allotted for field visit per day. Thus total time taken in an year
can be calculated as 810 Man Hours. Register Maintenance and record
keeping are also another major work in village offices. They have to
preserve many valuable records on government land and other properties.
As per the work study norms, a synthetic time of 20 minutes can be
allotted to each functionary for the purpose. The total time thus taken will
be of 60 minutes per day amounting to 270 man hours annually. As the
government carry out general administration through the village offices;
the village employees are bound to do a lot of various type of job like
. Election, Census, Law and order problems etc. Since these types of
S works involve extensive field visits it is reasonable to give 10 hours per
S month to the village staff. The total time taken in a year can be calculated
S as 120 Man Hours per year. In this way the workload in general of a
S village Office can be measured as shown in the table below.
SI. Item
S No ______________________
1 Certificates(30 numbers) 5 1350
S
S
S
S
75
r
nCeritificates UTax tPokuvarau
£10
3%
5.11.29. In short, the staff of a normal village office together contributes a total of
4936 Man Hours per year. Actuaily the time required for the three
functionaries is 5100 Man Hours per year. So there is a shortage of 164
Man Hours per year which is not at all arrived to the fixed time of 5100
Man Hours in a year.
rL
A village office dealing with 30 certificates: 50 tax receipts, 4 Pokkuvaravu
cases can function with the existing staff strength. See another situation
below
S
S
S
S
S
77
El Certificate
Tax
o Pokuvaravu
nFicldVist La
r Register&Records
91
e
o General Works
n Overtime Spent
- U - —0--- -- •0
Total man hour for each funcPthinal Time spent
U Series 1 a Series 2
Overtime spent
5.11.33. In other words, instead of contributing 5100 Man Hours in a year,(as per
work study norms) by all the three functionaries are working for 6825 Man
79
Hours a year. That is they together work for 1725 Man Hours additionally
in a year. This excess workload is enough for creation of an additional
post of LDC/ Village Assistant in the recommended village offices.
Workload
€ 8,000
€7,000
€6,000 -
€ 5,000 -
€ 4,000 - I • Work
€3,000
€2,000
€ 1,000 -
€0 -•--- - _____________________
Work load Work Load
/
• 85
Chapter- 6
6.2.1. Attendance Register is maintained in all the village offices visited by the
team. Casual Leave and other Leave were properly entered in registers.
Most of the employees were seen presented though there were few
exceptions. In some cases though the employees were present, they
hadn't marked attendance in registers. In most of the village offices,
entries in the casual leave registers were not updated. In majority of the
village offices, page certificate , page number, index etc were not properly
entered in the attendance register.
6.2.2. Movement Registers are maintained in all village offices visited by the
team. But it is not maintained in the prescribed format .Note books and
blank registers for other purposes are seen used as Movement Registers
S
S
S in some of the village offices. Uniformity in maintaining Registers is an
unavoidable factor in an Organization/Department and uniformity of
S
S
S
S
S
• 87
ensure that the field visit of the employee is solely for the official
• purpose.
.,
General Working Atmosphere and Efficiency of the
• Office:
6.3.1. Unlike other government offices, the village offices are often seen with
. rush of visitors. But, village offices have not got a good working
• atmosphere and sufficient infrastructure. Being the bottom level office,
• these offices have considerable quantum of workload. Even though the
• situation is bleak, the applications received per day are dealt on the same
• day. The want of staff and infrastructure hampers the smooth functioning
• of the offices. The employees are efficient in discharging their duties. The
• attitude of the staff towards the public has to be changed. The employee
• customers. During the time of inspection, the work study team has got
• 6.4.1. Lack of in-service training to the staff is a major problem faced by the
• Village Offices. A new entrant to village service is totally unfamiliar even
•
•
•
•
•
a
• 88
• village office may riot be able to give necessary guidance and help to a
• new staff who is recruited to the village office, because of heavy workload
• and routine interaction with the public. Proper induction training will only
• 6.4.2. The data collected from village offices show that majority of the Village
• Offices in the state have untrained staff. Lack of proper training affects
• not only the performance of staff but also normal functioning of the office
• village office. Those who already work in the village offices may also be
included in the training programme. Village Field Assistants, Village
Assistants/Special Village Officers and Village Officers should have
40
separate training modules. Some personality development courses may
40
also be included in the schedule The Village Officer will ensure proper
training to his staff (VFAs and VA5/SVO5). The Tahsildar of each Taluk
4111 will have to ensure that the Village Officers under his control have
• attended the training course. Proper training at each level will enable the
• staff to render maximum service with minimum effort. Hence, the study
• team recommends that proper Induction training should be given to
• and Village Officers at each level without fail. The Department may
• Maintenance of Registers
•
• 6.5.1. There are mainly two types of registers in village offices.
6.5.2. Thus a Village Officer is obliged to maintain 50 registers in his office. Many
of them are very important registers. All these registers were subjected to
S inspection by the work study team. Following are the main findings.
S
6.5.3. Most of the Permanent and Temporary registers are in dilapidated
condition. Most of them are decades old; dating back to British rule. The
. Revenue Department provides little money for the upkeep of important
registers in village offices. In these circumstances, village employees are
forced to spend a portion of their wage to this purpose or they are
S compelled to seek the good will of some wealthy persons who visit the
office for their needs. Such a situation certainly leads to corruption and
S favoritism in village offices.
S
S
S
S
S
S
I
S
• . 90
• 6.5.5. When registers are subjected to inspection, it was seen that these are not
• maintained properly. Name .of clerk, name of register, volume, page
• . certificate, carry over certificate etc... are not seen made in most of the
• registers. The higher officers may look into the matter personally and
• Citizen Charter
S
• 6.6.1. Almost all village offices display Citizen Charter in front of the office. Most
• often, the Citizen charter displayed in the offices are incomplete. There
• are omissions of some important information like duration of time taken for
a particular activity or service and documents to be attached along with
applications/petitions etc. The guidelines in the Citizen charter could not
be complied quite often due to pressure from the public. The public is not
. ready to wait for quite sometime as they want to fulfill needs within the
shortest time possible. This attitude of the public often make the village
staff under pressure and they are compelled to satisfy the demand of
• public without adequate enquiry. In this circumstance the work study
• team suggest that the guidelines in the Citizen Charter should
• strictly be adhered to and the service delivered in line with the first
• Officers and Appellate Authority etc. dealing with the Right to Information
Act 2005 have been displayed in all the offices. But in majority of the
•
cases details displayed are incomplete and are not updated. In some
•
offices details are displayed in printed papers and these are very difficult
to be noticed. Hence the work team suggest that details of Public
Information Officers should be displayed in board legibly.
•
S
S
S
91
S Steps for Anti-Corruption
6.8.1. Board having name of Vigilance Officers with telephone number are
displayed in majority of the village offices. Yet, the team happened to be
heard some complaints of bribery in a few village offices. The board
displaying the details of Vigilance officers is not legible and very difficult to
be located. Therefore the work study team suggests that a board
displaying the details of Vigilance Officers with their telephone
numbers in legible letters be prepared and displayed in front of all
village offices. The information on the board should be updated
whenever necessary.
.--. --
1
S
S
• -- *ff- - - •. -:.-.,
- ___ r- --•
S - - __ - _____
S
0
11
• 92
6.9.2. The picture of a village office above speak volumes on its harrowing
• condition. A considerable number of the village offices have a dismal and
• loomy look. These offices reflect an example of sheer negligence from
• the part of the government. Through this grass root level offices, people
• some of the Village Office buildings is that it is about to fall on the ground
• at any time. Whenever in rainy season, the roof are leaking and the
• valuable registers and records will get wet. This may cause damage to
the building as well as important documents. To make matters worse, the
• doors and windows of some of the offices are in pathetic condition which
give least protection to the buildings. So there is a possibility of anti-social
elements getting access into the village offices and stealing or damaging
documents of importance.
•. Space Management
• 6.10.1. 99% of village office buildings are below 700 sq.ft and this is hardly
enough for an office to function smoothly. The rooms are congested and
.. narrow that too without proper ventilation. The associated Approved Code
of Practice and Guidance states:
•
• 'Office building should have enough free space to allow people to get to
• and from workstations and to move within the room, with ease. The
• number of people who may work in any particular room at any one time
• will depend not only on the size of the room, but on the space taken up by
• Workrooms, Every room where persons work shall have sufficient floor
area, height and unoccupied space for purposes of health, safety and
welfare".
• .
•
•
S .
S
S
• 93
• 6.10.2. The space assigned per person is one of many factors that may affect an
• employee's safety and sense of well-being at work, productivity, For office
• work, space requirements are listed in terms of the (a) footprint and (b) the
• average floor area per occupant.
•
• Footprint: A value of 5 - 7 square metres is recommended as a minimum
• for the footprint - the area available for,a person's workstation, chair, the
need for• movement, and freedom from intrusion from others.
• meters per person - and this assumes ideal circumstances in all other
aspects. Some Guidelines indicate a larger space may be acceptable in
provincial locations.
• 6.10.4. All the village office buildings should have at least 1000 sq.ft. plinth area.
• 94
• Internal Layout
6.10.5. The internal layout of each village office may be designed in such a way
that there should be sufficient space to accommodate tables and sufficient
space for employees to move around freely. Furniture should be arranged
• systematically so that entry and exit of visitors would become more
• comfortable. Sufficient fans and lights should be installed to make
S working condition stress free and enjoyable.
• Maintenance
• 6.10.6. At times some sort of periodic maintenance is done in the case of village
• that too after repeated requests. But, unfortunately in the case of village
office buildings constructed by Nirmithi Kendra, maintenance are yet to be
carried out. Often, the maintenance is limited to whitewashing or some
patch work. Some PWD buildings become leaky when it rains and this
cause the roof ceiling become loose and collapse. In addition to this, one
further point to mention is the steel network inside the concrete roof slab
will get corroded in the long run and collapse. Moreover, the damp and
wet wall may become a trigger to electric hazard and this will be life
• threatening and it will also damage computer or other electric appliances
• connected to the grid. As this is a matter of utmost concern the work
• study team recommend that secondary roofing be installed in all
6.10.7. The work study team visited some village offices that have tiled roof.
Majority of them are very old buildings. It was seen that adequate
• maintenance was not carried out in most cases. The wooden structure has
• been eaten by Termites. Moreover, the menace of rats and other insects
• is unbearable. Periodical application of anti-termite agent and installation
• of false ceiling can solve these problems to a great extent. Therefore the
•
•
•
S
S -
• 95
•
• 6.10.8. A few village offices are not fortified with strong doors and windows. The
• hinges of doors and windows are loose or corroded which leave a chance
to an intruder to enter into the Village Office freely and easily and
valuables may be stolen from the office.
• 6.10.9. Majority of the Village Office buildings reflect a grim and dismal look for
• they have not been painted for many years. During monsoon season the
• building get wet and moss began to grow there on the walls of the building
''• ' 1
S
S
6.10.11. At present old power consuming incandescent bulbs and fans are used in
S
majority of the village offices. All these need immediate replacement in
order to save on electricity charge and set standards on power saving
S
front.
S
S
S
6.10.12. All government offices including village offices should function as role
models in power saving front especially in a situation in which our state is
S being faced with acute power shortage. In this circumstance, the work
study team recommends the following
S C FLs
Old power consuming fans should be replaced with energy star
rated fans
S
V. Display a board in all village offices describing the ways of power
S
saving
S
vi. . Ensure all the electric appliances bought for the village offices are
S
S
S
S
•1
97
C
energy star rated.
• water harvesting. Lack of usable toilets create problems mainly for women
• and physically handicapped employees. Water from Rain water can solve
• the running water problem to a great extent. The work study team thinks
that no separate toilet is necessary for the visitors. The same toilet used
•
by the staff can also be used by the customers. At present a few village
•
office is provided with a wash basin. The employees find it difficult to wash
their hand after lunch without wash basin. Moreover, a wash basin is ideal
in an office in many ways. In this circumstances, the work study team
recommend to ensure clean.and usable toilet and wash basin as a
basic requirement. Sufficient water availability be ensured through
water connection and rain water harvesting.
Compound Wall
6.10.14. In the circumstances existed in majority of the village offices suggest that
every village office should ensure compound wall round the entire premise
in order to prevent encroachment. The compound wall should be of at
least 1.60 meters in height. A strong compound wall guards the office
against trespassers, anti-social elements and stray animals. Some anti-
social people even throw off house hold waste onto the compound of
village office from passing vehicles. Above all, a mere compound wall
does not serve the purpose for which it was built. It should have at ast
1.60 meters in height and should have a good gate too. Therefore the
work study team recommend that a compound wall of at least 1.60
meters in height with a good gate should be constructed for those
village offices without compound wall.
6.10.15. Furniture has always been a necessity for an office. With good ambience
in the office, employees feel good to work even under pressure. Furniture
always plays a major role in getting your work done. Proper furniture gives
a sense of class and dignity. Office furniture has changed with changing
work style. It aims to save on space, while optimizing on productivity and
playing it easy on paper, which works in-line with the modern work mantra.
6.10.16. On the contrarary, all village offices in Kerala are sported with outdated,
old and dilapidated piece of furniture often giving a feeling of working in an
office during medieval period. All existing piece of furniture are not
ergonomically in nature and these do not help the employees work for a
long time comfortably in any way. This furniture was originally designed for
meeting the needs of bygone era. Moreover, the old furniture and its
arrangement in no way motivate the employees and do not create an
ambiance of professionalism and success either.
6.10.17. Even with these old pieces of furniture all village office face another grim
reality; lack of sufficient furniture. All most all village offices in Kerala do
not have sufficient furniture to function properly. They do not have
sufficient storage facility, enough seating arrangements and proper writing
desks. All these factors contribute to below par performance of village
offices. So as to bring the village offices to the forefront there is a need to
build an atmosphere of modernity in village offices. Therefore, the work
study team recommends replacing all existing old and outdated
furniture with modern, ergonomically built pieces of furniture.
Excellent furniture is not only able to make a work space look stylish
but can also give it an ambiance of professionalism and success.
-j
I.
99
6.10.18. A suggestion about new piece of office furniture which could be accepted
by the Revenue Department is given below
t.
Modular Office Furniture
• For the visitors, the attractive interiors of the office give it a very
professional look.
6.10.19. An office does not have to take up a lot of space. A modular office
system can help maximize any area's space and affordably accommodate
the equipment and supplies needed to work. Added wheeis on the
furniture make it easier to move work spaces around when rearranging or
redecorating.
o The office desk should provide clearance for legs; standard desk
heights of 29 to 30 inches from the floor are sufficient for most
employees.
• Sitting behind the desk, there should optimally be at least three-
and-a half feet of space. A minimum of three feet of space should
also be available in-between the desk and another piece of office
furniture and in front of the desk if you use a guest/client chair.
• For computer-users, keyboards need to be placed at a comfortable
height. Keyboards placed on traditional desks may be at too high a
height and may result in significant discomfort or muscle strain for
the user. Computer desks should either be equipped with a
101
6.10.20. Workrooms should have enough free space to allow people to get to and
from workstations and to move within the room, with ease. The number of
people who may work in any particular room at any one time will depend
not only on the size of the room, but on the space taken up by furniture,
fittings, equipment, and on the layout of the room.
102
6.10.22. Hence the work study team suggest that the Revenue Department
should prepare an action plan for equipping the existing village
offices and newly constructing buildings with Rainwater harvesting
facility and engage local bodies in the maintenance of the system.
'1 .
: . - a ...
ik . ht'Sth
Drinking Water
6.10.23. Sometimes the visitors, elderly and disabled people among them at the
village office will have to wait for a long time to get their need fulfilled. In
such occasions visitors will have to be provided with drinking water. water
from the rain water storage could not be trusted. In the circumstances,
water connection from the KWA may be subscribed to and an over head
103
tank may also be installed. This can ensure clean and safe drinking water
in the village offices throughout the year.
6.10.25. When people need to visit the village offices, their first impression is
formed by the waiting room. Therefore the work study team suggest
that there must be a Waiting room/area having 7 to 10 seating and a
table in every village office.
Front Office
6.10.26. A p!rson coming to village office for the first time gets confused about to
whom he should approach for getting his needs done. At present there is
no Front Office facility in Village Offices to help the public. Now a days
many government offices have set up a Front Office system. It will surely
help the public from solving their doubts such as to whom should they
approach to, what type of services are available from the office, what are
the formalities to be followed etc.. A useful and effective Front Office
System should be introduced at every village office. The service of Village
Field Assistants, Village Assistants/Special Village Officers can be utilized
for the purpose. Unnecessary rush inside the village offices can be
avoided through this method and effective service delivery can be ensured
through the Front Office. A recommended layout of the Front Office that
104
cz(ssuing Certificatesl B
VA/VFA
ft
Assista~nt
Viflage
After
proce
ssing
&for
verific
9 - Village Officer
Verification
p
[office recordsl
Records - Definition:
7.1.2. A Record' can be defined as information generated in the course of an
organisation's official transactions and which is documented to act as a
source of reference and a tool by which an organisation is governed. The
records themselves form a part of or provide evidence of such
transactions.
Records management
7.1.3. Records management is the field of management responsible for the
systematic control of the creation, maintenance, use and disposition of
records", (NARA,2003). Records management has four distinctive features:
• Records Creation
• Records Retention and Disposition
• Records Storage and Maintenance
107
WIR
7.1.6. The above picture convey the present reality, more than words. This is
absolutely true in the case of record rooms in village offices. The present
condition of the record room is highly unhygienic and records are
accumulated in bundles leaving the possibility of rats and even venomous
snakes making their home..
7.1.7. 95% percent of record rooms in village offices are congested and without
enough room to accommodate daily producing records. Moreover, these
rooms are devoid of proper ventilation and light. In this backdrop the
work study team recommend that all newly constructing village
offices should have at least 14x14 Square Feet Record Room with
proper ventilation and light. Besides, a powerful Vacuum Cleaner
may be kept in each Taluk Office and it can also be used to vacuum
the dust periodically in every village record room of every village
office under its jurisdiction.
7.1.9. Record registers are not seen maintained in village offices as a result it is
difficult to locate record when in need. Indexing or classification of records
• 109
• are not done. The Village Officer confessed that it take nOrmally 2 to 4
• 7.1.10. There is an extreme reluctance to destroy records, even after they ceased
• to have any value to the village office. Due to the lack of rules and
• guidelines in terms of what should be kept and for how long, staff are
• present condition of the record rooms unless the condition may deteriorate
further. Therefore, the work study team recommend that the Revenue
Department should take a concerted effort to improve the record
room and systematic upkeeping of records should be ensured in
village offices.
• 7.1.11. The process of retrieving registers should become quite efficient and quick
• outdated records.
7.1.12. The staff had limited training or experience in record keeping work. Lack of
proper training is the main reason behind poor management and
•
•
•
•
•
S
110
S systematic upkeeping of records in village offices. In these circumstances,
the work study team recommends that the village staff should be
S imparted proper training on Record Keeping.
Active records
S
7.1.13. Records that are in active use generally need to be stored where they are
S
readily accessible to their creators and users. For this reason they will
S
usually be stored near to work areas. Records should not be left to pile up
S on the floor around people's desks. Therefore the work study team
S suggests purchasing small steel cabinets with door to keep Active
records intact Records should be kept away from direct sunlight to
S minimise fading.
S
S Inactive records
S 7.1.14. Records no longer needed for current work become inactive and are
generally moyed out of work areas into storage. Inactive records need to
be stored in record rooms. In this way the office can be kept clutter free
and neat. For inactive records storage areas, consider:
The value of the records you will be storing in the area. Records of
S
S
111
Shelving
7.1.15. Suitable shelving and packaging enhance safe access to records. Keeping
records on floor or on concrete racks would spoil the records. In this
circumstance the work study team recommends that all existing
wooden racks and corroded steel stands should be replaced by anti
corrosive steel shelves having wheels and doors to protect the
records from accumulating termites and other pests.
Shelving Equipment:
7.1.16. .Records may be stored on shelves or racks, or in cabinets or drawers.
Other storage equipment may range from stools and ladders. Appropriate
shelving and equipment should be taken into account.
(The shelves enable the records to be stored safely and also enable better space
management.)
Environmental Control
7:1.17. All records should be stored in areas that are cleaned regularly and are not
subject to extremes of temperature and humidity. Dirty, dusty records
deteriorate more rapidly and deter staff from accessing them.
Filing System
7.1.18. For any office to run efficiently a well organised filing arrangement is a
must. Regardless of the filing system chosen one must know exactly
where the files are located when they are needed. The Public Health
Works Orientation Manual for Public Health Leaders of Missouri
Department of Health and Senior Services discusses certain key filing
procedures that can be followed for effective file management. These are
discussed below:
Avoid unnecessary filing
Classification of Records
• Accounts Registers
• change the way records are being kept in record rooms. It will also greatly
S
S
S
S
S
S
114
7.1.21. A records survey is a complete inventory of an agency's records
management. Survey of record is an essential step for records
management. After completing a records survey, agencies usually
discover that many records can be destroyed or moved to inactive
storage. Empirical studies of record surveys have shown that
approximately 30% of the total volume of records can be destroyed, 30%
can be moved to inactive storage and the balance can be retained as
active files. (The Kansas State Records Management).
S
7.1.22. There is a common misconception among government officials that
S computerizing records- or microfilming them will solve the problem of
S records management. However this is far from the truth. Simply
S computerizing or microfilming existing records without carrying out a
records survey or developing retention schedules will only ensure that a
S lot of the existing unnecessary records will be retained in an electronic
format. This will result in a lot of exsting paper garbage being transformed
S
115
Chapter- 8
8.1.3. Another problem looming large over the village office is the lack of Annual
Maintenance Contract (AMC). Without UPS, the system is more prone to
. crash. Once the system is crashed there would be no attempts from the
part of Revenue authorities to repair the system or renew the existing
AMC. It is seen that the agency responsible for executing AMC does not
•• show any interest to comply with the provisions in the contract. It is said
that the government indebted to thousands of rupees to the agencies who
• execute AMC. The work study team thinks that if the AMC is entrusted
•
of computer systems in all village offices. A team of computer technicians
from KELTRON may be stationed permanently at each District head
• quarters so that the service of the team may be utitised by the Revenue
* Department. Therefore the work study team suggests that all village
offices shoutd be provided with sufficient number of computers
together with printers and the maintenance of the same shoutd be
entrusted with KELTRON.
• Computer Training:
8.1.4. A vast majority of existing vitlage employees except a few newly appointed
** ones are ignorant of computer operations. The majority has not been
provided with training on computer operations. Therefore the work study
team suggest that all Village Officers ,Special Village OfficersNillage
Assistants should be given sufficient training in computer
operations.
S
S .
S
S
•
0.
1719
S
0
117
0
0 Open Source Software:
0
8.1.5. Our government is promoting Open Source Software as part of its IT
S
Policy. But the work study team happened to see Windows software, a
S
Propriety Software, is running in several computers in village offices. This
S
is not proper. The Revenue Department should go hand in hand with the
S
IT policy of our government.
S
AMM
S
S
S
C. 00
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
0
a 8.1.6. Besides, these Propriety Soft wares like Windows are verj costly and
S more prone to VIRUS and Sperm attack whereas Open Source Software
S like UBUNTU(a Linux flavour) is free from such drawbacks. Therefore the
work study team recommends promoting Open Source Softwares in
all village offices as a Government policy.
S
S
S
1/h
S
S
118
S Computer Hardware:
S
8.1.7. Thefield of Information Technology is fast progressing with old technology
• being replaced by the latest ones. But it seems that the Revenue
Department is still in dark about the latest trends in technical field. Out
• dated, power hungry CRT monitors are still being used in most of the
S
village offices. This not only consume more power but also emit more
S
radiation causing stress and strain to eyes.
S
S LCD monitor Vs CRT monitor
S
LCD CRT
S
-
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
Fl
S 119
S Single Function Printer/Multi Function Printer:
8.1.9. Village offices will get a lot of Printing/Scanning/Copying works once these
are computerised and networked. Even if a village office is not
computerised it has got a lot of printing/scanning/copying works. At
present, the village officer is spending extra money for scanning and
S
copying works.
S
S MOOT
S
V.s ..
S
S
S
8.1.10. With the single function printer in the village office, the printing works can
only be done. But, if a Multi Function Printer is installed in place, all
S
Printing, Copying and Scanning works can be done with the help of a
S single unit. This is very much economical as compared to buying separate
S Printer, Scanner and Copier machines to the office. Therefore the work
S study team recommends that instead of Single Function Printer,
S Multifunction Printer should be installed instead of single function
S printer in all village offices.
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
o
120
• .
Issuance of Certificates have been computerised here. Other activities
•• with Taluk and other offices are done manually. As far as the Collectorate
and Taluk Offices are concerned, computerised correspondence is done
S
• 8.1.12. In order to conduct a comparative study between computerised and non-
computerised village offices, the work study team visited such village
offices coming under the Taluk Office, Alathur, in Palakkad District on
17/02/2012 and 18/02/2012. The details are given below:
S
•
S
•• 8.1.13. There are 30 village offices under the control of Alathur Taluk Office. Of
these offices, 17 are computerised to a certain extent. The programme
•
0
• 121
• 8:1.14. As far as the issue of certificates (one of the major services in a village
• computers. In the E-District programme, there are 3 levels for the issue of
• certificates. They are Process, Verification and Approval. The first two
• is issued to the applicant duly signed by the Village Officer. For sale of
• property, the land owner submit ROR before the Sub-Registrar through
S
S
S
122
8.1.17. Therefore the work study team suggest that in order to make the
computerisation a success, all the problems listed above (1-5)
should be addressed immediately and necessary actions should be
adopted to get all the works in a village office computerised and not
to limit computerisation to one or two items of work.
8.1.18. Merits:
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S 124
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S Recommendations
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
.
• 125
• Chapter-9
General Recommendations
•
•
•
•
• .
•
• 126
•
•
•
•
• 127
• 16. It is recommended that that the post of Special Village Officer may be
• renamed as Assistant Village Officer without change of pay or rank
• and to authorize him to issue certificates in the absence of village
• officer.Para- 5.11.22)
• 5.11.26)
• 19. The Work study team found the necessity for creation of one post of
• Village Assistant in 140 village offices in the state. In this
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
128
S
• 129
•
• 24. It is recommended that registers having good quality paper be
• 6.10.6)
•
with tiled roof and the wooden structure should periodically be
applied with anti-termite agent. (Para-6.10.7)
.
31: It is recommended for painting all village offices once in 3 years with
a high quality, anti-fungal paint instead of white washing (Para-
• 6.10.9)
• (Para- 6.10.1 3)
• .
(Para- 6.10.17)
.
•
•
•
•
131
35. It is recommended that the Revenue Department should prepare an
action plan for equipping the existing village offices and newly
constructing buitdings with Rainwater harvesting facility and engage
local bodies in the maintenance of the system.(Para-6.10.22)
S
It is recommended that all newly constructing village offices should
S have at least 14x14 Square Feet Record Room with proper ventilation
and ligAt. Besides, a powerful Vacuum Cleaner may be kept in each
Taluk Office and it can also be used to vacuum the dust periodically
in every record room of village under its jurisdiction. (Para-7.1 .7)
S
S
It is recommended that the Revenue Department should initiate a
concerted effort to improve the record room and systematic
S
upkeeping of records should be ensured. (Para-7.1.10)
S
S
41. It is suggested to purchase small steel cabinets with door to keep
Active records intact. (Para- 7.1.13)
S
S
S
S
132
133
S
S
S
p
134
Chapter- 10
Expenditure & Benefit Analysis
10.1.2. The staff pattern of the village offices in the state has not been revised for
the past 30 years. During this long period, the state witnessed a massive
increase in population, land ownership, welfare schemes, law and order
problems, constructions, illegal mining, land encroachments. .etc. During
the work study, the team came across many villages which are running for
breath for want of additional staff. Against this background the team
135
10.2.1. It is very sad to note that majority of the Village Office buildings is in a
dilapidated condition with reeking toilets, damaged electric wiring and
leaking roof. With a view to modernize the village offices, the study team
is submitS a slew of measures for favourable consideration and
implementation.
136
Cost
10.2.2. The cast needed for infrastructure development is definitely a big burden.
Without infrastructure development no improvements in the village
administration is possible. The price of building materials is increasing day
by day and varies from brand to brand. The price of today is not the price
of tomorrow. So are the case with all other installations like Rain water
harvesting, Computer systems, Printers, Paints, shelves and Almarahs.
Therefore the team is of the opinion that it is not possible to show the cost
of infrastructure development at this point. In this circumstance the best
possible alternative method is to involve Jocal self institutions in the
development of infrastructure of village offices.
Possible Alternatives
Offsetting Measures
10.3.1. It is a fact that the expenditure towards the salary and other perks is an
additional burden on the state exchequer. But there are no alternatives
before the Workstudy team than the suggestion of additional posts. In the
mean time there is still light at the other end of the tunnel that the
Revenue Department can channel more money in to the exchequer by
revising the existing disproportionate Tax rate of various types. See
picture on next page.
138
0
Exchequer
S
S
Gain analysis
10.4.1. The gain analysis with regard to the suggestions and
S C. There will be no queue and crowd in village offices and people can
S
S
S
S
S
S
S 139
Efficient check over illegal activities like sand mining, land filling etc
S
S
S
S
S
I
t .
140
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S ANNEXURE
S
S
S
S
a
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
4
41 130
..
Annexu re
Rate of Basic tax
II
ii. Buildings . . .
100sqmts frJl. .. ..-
we 100 sq mts but 750 .1350 2025
S exceeding 150 sq
a
S '3!
S
)0ve75 square metresb25 Fc2so 4500
it not exceeding 100 a
•11
uare metres
)ove 100 square 2250
S ?tres but not
ceeding 150 square
S
S 150 square
but not
ing 200 square
S
of Plantation tax
Extent rate
S
btal plantation area below o tax
ectars (except areca nut I --
tndcocon)
¼reca nut and coconut 'Jo tax
lantation area below 4
ectares
tal plantation area Es. 100 for each hectare above 2 hectares.
etween 2 and 4 hectares -
0
S
•0
a
a •-: -'-'.
• . '052590
covcRMENToFKEJ&A:
z
• 3JJ,QQ
• - - GnJ3QIGJøW D1Cn, nJfl)( nThB6g)o
• QJj(i WTh)(b(2
•
na€oth §cmmøcI (swcS) 4 ?611 I 1nwm VflLI OJaXTmnJO, 22/11/2011
• mo
•
PJoq ommM 1rM6moos1 aoaMQeJ fl€nfrs -
•
•• 63438/09 mflj&iSZTh\
wflô3cb (arnsrr6
831971tS1M%th.M1?59WW mmit
siijkn3 ordm) nJ.e M1*
NOV
24.07.1000
2 •
• TTh1QT*
&me6fl mbuaiiteeonZ 004 nwrnas
7f)ó5 D3CflEt1Thl1S
amlu6molo
4J0oQQJthflJ
Wmo0(bjOJc6aO OtZtJb
(&0E)W
• Z)1GcTL CN(8&6) OOØO
tt31mY ffll{bâø &61 affl
• - ThmOi38UVo eJJ(TT):
Area Fees
• . 5
2 ofotow
2 6)rincC8 flS(b
•;
.1
C :Oj -) :WOJJ 19T
•
•r --- --
I
.•. s0.. Its..... • ..•-,-#-+-.4ii it., r
_____________________________________ •-.=
_--
Oj©V' cjcfl
#fJ rJDi(6t'Cm(ml%t r?JJfl
f 6a1c936m ( uMcWbo
LJ°)
• C
r4 21
j&O1
- umcr&i6m%
pO4JCO\
ol
e4biW RCflO* qjrjrs3fl2
63 t163%J -
DØ
LD
(1)