Professional Documents
Culture Documents
0 Executive Summary
(417)words.
Figure 2
Efficiency ratios or asset turnover ratio, which shows how a company
uses its assets to generate sales and to find out how quickly
inventory can be turned into cash and can used to satisfy debts(
Moles et al., 2011 ). In the settlement period of trade receivables
both company have signed good performance. Average settlement
period for trade receivables decrease from year2009, 52days to
2010, 38 days. The settlement period of MAS is reducing 13.77 days
and the settlement period of Air Asia is reducing 9.95days. This is a
good sign as it shows that credit customers take shorter time to pay
back their debts to MAS group. This enabled MAS to have a better
cash flow. As compared to competitor, Air Asia takes longer to get
back its debts. The settlement period of trade receivables is greatly
depend on the credit terms a company gives to its debtors. This
information is important to shareholders as Sales to Capital
Employed Ratio are used to measure the firm's ability to generate
sales by utilizing its assets. Sales revenue to capital employed of
MAS decreased from 2.78 times to 2.61 times. As compared to
MAS, Air Asia has generated more sales revenue in shorter time.
This indicates that the assets were used less productively as
compared to the previous year. Suppliers need to know this
information as it tells how good a company is in turning its
inventories asset into cash and able to pay their debts.
Figure 6
Price Earnings ratio shows the real market value of shares of a
particular company and thus investor can tell that the shares are
under or exceed the real market value. P/E ratio shows that MAS
shares in year 2009 is considered normal but during 2010, the P/E
ratio was beyond the normal rate. The share price exceeded the real
market value in year 2010. As compared to industry competitor, the
P/E ratio shows that Air Asia shares were under value for both year
2009 and 2010. Most of the shareholders will check on Price
Earnings ratio before investing in companies to predict whether the
company share price has opportunity to rise or not. Potential investor
will buy the shares which are under market value and thus it has big
opportunity to rise.
Figure 7
MAS profitability in year 2009 and 2010 was dropping and it was
worse than industry competitor Air Asia. Efficiency ratios shows that
MAS’s debtors take shorter time to get back their debts from other
companies. Sales revenue to capital employed decrease shows that
MAS did not utilize their assets in making revenue. Besides, liquidity
ratios tell us MAS has cash problems as the ratio is below 1, it
means MAS do not have enough cash to meet its short-term
liabilities. Interest cover ratio increase even though it’s gearing ratio
turn worse mainly because in year 2010 the operating profit was
negative figure. Both are not consistent as the operating profit in
year 2010 was negative figure. Meanwhile, the profit of MAS
dropped and earnings available for ordinary shareholders of MAS
dropped from 2009 to 2010 thus earnings per share dropped. Price
earnings ratio shows that MAS shares in year 2009 are considered
normal but the p/e ratio in year 2010 was beyond the normal rate.
The share price exceeded the real market value in year 2010.
On the other hand, Air Asia has a better performance in profitability
ratio, liquidity ratio, and cash flow ratios. In gearing ratio, even
though Air Asia has a very high gearing ratio in year 2009, but it
managed to settle its liability within a year and lower down its
gearing ratio. Investment ratio of Air Asia also showed growth and
price earnings ratio tells us that the share price is under market
value. All these factors have made Air Asia a more attractive
company than MAS.
Since the European governments and the central banks are running
out of fiscal ammunition, the crisis is not over (United Press
International,2012) .The two main factors that may affect global
growth is the oil price, rising since late last year (The Star Online,
2012).Libya, for example, only produces 1.2% of the world daily
supply of crude oil ( Malaysian Airline System Berhad,2010). Due to
the political reason in the Middle East, oil supply has significantly
went down and the oil price has went up significantly. Rise in crude
oil has impacted most countries and it lead to the rise of many
products and services prices. Besides, Euzo zone crisis is
influencing on many countries especially on the trade exporting and
importing and it will affect the GDP of many countries. Malaysia's
economy is expected to slow to a pace of 4%-5% this year due to
the impact on economy crisis (The Sun Daily, 2012). However,
Minister in the Prime Minister's Department Tan Sri Nor Mohamed
Yakcop said that Malaysia's economic growth remains at a
comfortable level when compared with that of the global
economy(The Sun Daily, 2012).
Section 24A of the Civil Aviation Act 1969 empowers the minister of
transport to licence airport and flight services while Malaysia Airports
Holdings Sdn Bhd (MAHB) has been permitted to provide the
services and collect airport tax in accordance with the licence given
(MATTA Kuala Lumpur Portal, 2010).Deputy Prime Minister Datuk
Seri Najib Tun Razak said that a 50% discount on landing charges
will be given to all airlines operating from Malaysia for two years
effective April 1 ( The Star Online, 2009). This clearly shows that the
government’s decision on airport taxes is affecting on the profitability
of MAS.
Furthermore, one of the major shareholder of MAS is Khazanah
Nasional Berhad. It is the investment holding arm of the Government
of Malaysia and is empowered as the Government's strategic
investor in new industries and markets( Khazanah Nasional Berhad,
n.d). Since it is the second largest shareholder after Penerbangan
Malaysia Berhad, besides, the third largest shareholder is Citigroup
Nominees (Tempatan) Sdn Bhd - Employees Provident Fund Board,
it is also one of the government owned company. These
shareholders have a significant authority to make decision on behalf
of the government and thus, the government is indirectly having
control in MAS. In general, MAS is a government linked organization
and it significantly represents Malaysia and therefore MAS is under
government’s protection.
The chairman also mentioned that they will improve on cost control
and operational efficiency to gain more income and net profit. On the
other hand, based on the business plan as at December 2011, MAS
combined losses in the first 3 quarter in 2011 already exceeded RM
1.2 billion (Malaysia Airlines,2011). We can see most of the
chairman’s ambitionis not being realized in the reality and thus I
believe that many potential investors will lose confidence in this
company.
There are long term investor and short term investor. Long term
investor mostly interested in company which is stable with potential
growth, low current share price and the dividend given by the
company. Besides, macro environment is also important for long
term investor in making investing decision. If the company has high
potential of growing, but the near future economy outlook is not
good, investor might choose not to buy the shares and vice versa.
On the contrary, short term investor is more interested in the stability
and current share price of the company. Normally short term investor
will buy the share at a low price and they will sell it once the stock
price goes up without holding the share for too long.
As a potential investor, I would largely depend on the historical data
and ratios to predict on the company’s future earnings and growth.
Therefore, based on a series of ratios I have done, I would not buy
MAS shares. First of all, I am a long term investor and I would focus
more on the growth of the company and I am not able to see the the
growth in MAS.PEST analysis shows that the fuel price is rising and
the instability of the global economy now will affect badly on MAS as
a whole. Besides, political observers said several factors indicate
that dissolution of parliament may be in May or June, with general
election held within 60 days( New Straits Times, 2012). If Barisan
Nasional wins lesser seats in the parliament during the general
election which is coming soon, the demand for the share will drop as
it is a government linked company and thus the share price will be
badly affected. Moreover, MAS did not give any dividend to the
shareholders for a few years. The last dividend payout date was 29
May 2008(Jupiter Online, n.d) . If I invested my money in MAS, my
money will be stuck and there will be no incentives coming back to
me every year, I would rather invest my money in other company
which performs well with dividend given back to investors every
year.
|
(3551) words
10.0 References
Atrill. et al. (2006)Accounting an Introduction, 3rd ed., Australia:
Pearson Education Australia, pp. 243-248.
Groppelli, A. G. and Nikbakht, E. (2006) Finance, 5th ed., United
States: Barron’s Educational Series, pp. 467-468.
Harrington, H. J. (2007) Resource management Excellence: The Art
of Excelling in Resource Management, United States: Paton Press,
pp. 301-302.
Investing Businessweek ( 2012) Malaysia Airline System BHD- MAS:
Kuala Lumpur Stock Charts. [Online]. Available from:
http://investing.businessweek.com/research/stocks/charts/charts.asp
?ticker=MAS%3AMK [Accessed 5th April 2012].
Jupiter Online. (n.d) Malaysian Airline System Berhad. [Online].
Available from: http://jupiteronline.klsetracker.com.my/capdiv.php
[Accessed 4th April 2004].
Khazanah Nasional Berhad (n.d) Khazanah Nasional - Khazanah at
a Glance. [Online]. Available from http://www.khazanah.com.my/
[Accessed 21st March 2012 ].
Malaysia Airline System Berhad (2010) Gearing for Growth- 2010
Annual Report.pp. 1-271.
Malaysia Airlines. (2011) Business Plan – Our Way
Forward.[Online]. Available from:
http://www.malaysiaairlines.com.my/content/dam/mas/master/en/pdf/
corporate-info/Malaysia%20Airlines%20Business%20Plan.pdf
[Accessed 5th April 2012].
MATTA Kuala Lumpur Portal (2010) Malaysian Association of Tour
and Travel Agents- no plan to reduce airport tax.[Online]. Available
from:
http://mattakualalumpur.matta.org.my/news/view.cfm?id=628C4971-
188B-76AA-00929536C9F810D6 [Accessed 21st March 2012].
McLaney, E.J. (1994) Business Finance for Decision Makers,2nd
ed., London: Pitman Publishing.
Moles, P., Parrino, R and Kidwell, D.S. (2011) Fundamentals of
Corporate Finance, United Kingdom: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 125-
127.
New Straits Times. (2012) From Crisis to Mutual Growth
Opportunities.[Online]. Available from:
http://www.nst.com.my/opinion/columnist/from-crisis-to-mutual-
growth-opportunities-1.57564 [Accessed 2nd April 2012].
New Straits Times. (2012)Speculation of GE13 date gathers steam.
[Online]. Available from: http://www.nst.com.my/latest/speculation-of-
ge13-date-gathers-steam-1.61979 [Accessed 4th April 2012].
OSK188. (2012) 3786 Malaysian Airline System BHD. [Online].
Available from: http://www.osk188.com/188Chart.jsp?stkcode=5099
[Accessed 5th April 2012].
The Star Online (2008) MAS to buy 55 Boeing Planes for 13.4
bil.[Online]. Available from:
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2008/3/31/business/2
0080331174948&sec=business [Accessed 21st March 2012].
The Star Online (2009) Najib: Rebate on Landing Charges. [Online].
Available from:
http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2009/3/11/business/3
449719&sec=business [Assessed 21st March 2012].