You are on page 1of 71

ASCE 7-10 Significant

Changes to the Wind Load


Provisions
William L. Coulbourne, P.E. SECB
Applied Technology Council (ATC)
bcoulbourne@atcouncil.org
Acknowledgements

 Ron Cook, Univ. of Florida, Wind Load Task


Committee Chairman
 T. Eric Stafford, T. Eric Stafford & Associates
 Peter Vickery, Applied Research Associates
 Larry Griffis, Walter P. Moore and Associates
 ASCE 7 Wind Load Subcommittee

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 2


Today’s Agenda

 Classification of buildings
 Reorganization of wind provisions
 New wind maps
 MWFRS and C&C
 New Simplified Procedure for
buildings with h≤ 160 ft.
 Example problem

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 3


ASCE 7-05 Chapter 6
 Design Methods
 Simplified Method (low-rise)
 Analytical Method
 Low-rise buildings
 Buildings of all heights
 Other Structures
 Wind Tunnel Procedure
 All in one chapter
 Confusing? Yes!
NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 4
ASCE 7-10 Significant Changes

 Changes to Building Classification (Chapter 1)


 Complete reorganization of wind provisions
 New wind speed maps
 New wind-borne debris region
 Re-introduction of Exposure D for water
surfaces in hurricane-prone regions
 Simplified procedure for buildings < 160 ft

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 5


Classification of Buildings
Use or Occupancy of Buildings and Structures Risk Category
Buildings and other structures that represent a low risk to human life in the event of I
failure:
All buildings and other structures except those listed in Risk Categories I, III, and IV II
Buildings and other structures, the failure of which could pose a substantial risk to III
human life.
Buildings and other structures, not included in Occupancy Category IV, with potential
to cause a substantial economic impact and/or mass disruption of day-to-day
civilian life in the event of failure
Buildings and other structures not included in Risk Category IV (including, but not
limited to, facilities that manufacture, process, handle, store, use, or dispose of
such substances as hazardous fuels, hazardous chemicals, hazardous waste, or
explosives) containing toxic or explosive substances where the quantity of the
material exceeds a threshold quantity established by the authority having
jurisdiction and is sufficient to pose a threat to the public if released.
Buildings and other structures designated as essential facilities. IV
Buildings and other structures, the failure of which could pose a substantial hazard to
the community.
Buildings and other structures (including, but not limited to, facilities that
manufacture, process, handle, store, use, or dispose of such substances as
hazardous fuels, hazardous chemicals, or hazardous waste) containing sufficient
quantities of highly toxic substances where the quantity exceeds a threshold
quantity established by the authority having jurisdiction to be dangerous to the
public if released and is sufficient to pose a threat to the public if released.a
Buildings and other structures required to maintain the functionality of other
Category IV structures.
NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 6
Classification of Buildings
1.5.1 Risk Categorization. Buildings and other structures shall be
classified, based on the risk to human life, health and welfare associated with
their damage or failure by nature of their occupancy or use, according to Table
1-1 for the purposes of applying flood, wind, snow, earthquake, and ice
provisions. Each building or other structure shall be assigned to the highest
applicable risk category or categories. Minimum design loads for structures
shall incorporate the applicable Importance Factors given in Table 1-2, as
required by other Sections of this Standard. Assignment of a building or other
structure to multiple risk categories based on the type of load condition being
evaluated (e.g., wind or seismic) shall be permitted.

When the building code or other referenced standard specifies an


Occupancy Category, the Risk Category shall not be taken as lower than the
Occupancy Category specified therein.

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 7


Classification of Buildings
Guidance on what types of buildings might fall into each Risk
Category is now gone from the body of the standard.
Examples are still provided in the Commentary.

Elimination of the specific examples of buildings that fall


into each category has the benefit that it eliminates the
potential for conflict between the standard and locally
adopted codes and also provides individual communities and
development teams the flexibility to interpret acceptable risk
for individual projects.

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 8


Reorganization of Wind Provisions

 New organization (based on the more


user-friendly multi-chapter seismic
provisions):
 6 new Chapters (Chapters 26-31)
 Flowcharts on how to use in each chapter
 Intent is to clarify the applicability of the
wind provisions

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 9


Reorganization of Wind Provisions

 Chapter 26 – General Requirements


 Chapter 27 – MWFRS Directional Procedure
 Chapter 28 – MWFRS Envelope Procedure
 Chapter 29 – MWFRS Other Structures and
Appurtenances
 Chapter 30 – Components and Cladding
 Chapter 31 – Wind Tunnel Procedure

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 10


Reorganization of Wind Provisions

 Chapter 26 – General Requirements


 Scoping
 Definitions
 Wind speed map
 Exposure
 Gust factor
 Topographic factor

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 11


MWRFS Directional Procedure
 Buildings of all heights (old Figure 6-6,
new Figure 27.4-1)

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 12


MWFRS Directional Procedure

“A procedure for determining wind loads on buildings


and other structures for specific wind directions, in
which the external pressure coefficients utilized are
based on past wind tunnel testing of prototypical
building models for the corresponding direction of
wind.”

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 13


MWRFS Envelope Procedure
 Buildings  60 ft (old Figure 6-10, new
Figure 28.4-1)

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 14


MWFRS Envelope Procedure

“A procedure for determining wind load cases on


buildings, in which pseudo external pressure coefficients
are derived from past wind tunnel testing of prototypical
building models successively rotated through 360
degrees, such that the pseudo pressure cases produce
key structural actions (uplift, horizontal shear, bending
moments, etc.) that envelop their maximum values
among all possible wind directions.”

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 15


Reorganization of Wind Provisions

 Chapter 27 – MWFRS Directional Procedure


 Part 1: Buildings of all heights method
 Part 2: New simplified method for simple
diaphragm buildings  160 ft

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 16


Reorganization of Wind Provisions

 Chapter 28 – MWFRS Envelope Procedure


 Part 1: Low-rise ( 60 ft) buildings method
 Part 2: Simplified method for low-rise ( 60
ft) simple diaphragm buildings

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 17


Reorganization of Wind Provisions

 Chapter 29 – MWFRS Other Structures


and Appurtenances
 Signs
 Rooftop structures
 Other structures

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 18


Reorganization of Wind Provisions

 Chapter 30 – Components and Cladding


1. Envelope method for h ≤ 60 ft
2. Simplified method for h ≤ 60 ft
3. Directional method for h > 60 ft
4. Simplified method for h ≤ 160 ft
5. Analytical method for open buildings of all
heights
6. Building appurtenances and roof top
structures
NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 19
Reorganization of Wind Provisions

 Chapter 31 – Wind Tunnel Procedure

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 20


New Wind Speed Maps

 New data and data analysis indicate current


ASCE 7 hurricane wind speeds are generally
conservative
 Introduction of ultimate wind speed maps
 LRFD Wind Load Factor = 1.0
 ASD Wind Load Factor = 0.6
 Specific maps for each building category

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 21


Facts About the ASCE 7-05 Wind Speed Map

 In most of the non-hurricane US mainland,


the mapped values represented a 50-year
mean recurrence interval
 In hurricane regions, the mapped values
varied from 50 to 100 years along the
hurricane coastline
 Wind speeds along the hurricane coastline
had been adjusted upward so that when
incorporated with the wind LF, produce a
wind load having a consistent hazard level
with the interior US (700 MRI)
NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 22
Wind Speed vs MRI
ASCE 7-05

2.00

1.80
Hurricane
0.97
V(T)/V(50)=0.167ln(12T)
1.60
Non-Hurricane
1.40 V(T)/V(50)=0.36+0.1ln(12T)
V(T)/V50 = (LF) 0.5

1.20 1.112 x
1.00
1.00 x
For Non-Hurr
0.80 Vmap = 50 Yr MRI
0.60 0.5
For Hurr, Vmap = 500 yr/(1.5)
0.40 = 1.112 ; 97 MRI
0.20
50 97
0.00
1 10 100 1000 10000
MRI T

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 23


Wind Pressure vs MRI
ASCE 7-05
3.50

3.00
Hurricane
2.50
P(T)/P50 = LF

Non-Hurricane
2.00

1.50

1.00
Non Hurr: Vmap = 50 yr MRI
0.50
Hurr: Vmap = 97 yr MRI
0.00
1 10 100 1000 10000
MRI T

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 24


Wind Pressure vs MRI
ASCE 7-05
3.50
Hurricane
3.00
Non-Hurricane
2.50
With I=1.15
P(T)/P50 = LF

2.00
1.6
1.50
1.6
1.00
Map V for hurr. (> 50 yr)
0.50
50 97 720 1770
0.00
1 10 100 1000 10000
MRI T

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 25


Why Change the Map?

 Current hybrid pseudo MRI Map – confusing


 Designers, students, clients
 Most Users Don’t Know
 LF =1.6: 700 yr MRI “ultimate wind speed”
 Importance Factor of 1.15: 1700 yr MRI
 Update for new hurricane model
 Provide 3 Maps:
 300 yr (Cat 1), 700 yr (Cat 2) 1700 yr (Cat 3,4)
 Eliminate Wind Importance Factors

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 26


New Hurricane Model Summary
 New intensity model includes ocean mixing to limit
hurricane intensity (defined by central pressure)
 New statistical model for Holland B parameter
(yields lower wind speeds than 2000 model)
 New filling (storm weakening after landfall) model
 New wind field model
 100,000 year simulation vs. 20,000 in the old map
 Map developed using 2851 pts vs. 208 in the old map

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 27


New Wind Speed Maps
 Specific maps for each building category
 Category II buildings – 700 year return period wind
speed
 Category III and IV buildings – 1700 year return
period wind speeds
 Category I buildings – 300 year return period wind
speeds
 Importance Factor no longer required
 Serviceability maps (10, 25, 50 and 100 year) to
be included in Appendix C
 Find wind speeds @ www.atcouncil.org/windspeed
NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 28
Site-Specific
Wind Speed Example

Location:
New Orleans, LA

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 29


700 Year RP Winds
115(51)

120(54)
130(58)
110(49)
140(63)

115(51)

115(51) 140(63)

150(67)

150(67)
140(63) 130(58) 140(63)
120(54) 150(67)
110(49) 160(72)
160(72) 170(76)
170(76)

115(51) 180(80)
150(67)
120(54)
130(58)140(63) 180(80)
110(49)

120(54) Special Wind Region


130(58)
Location Vmph (m/s)
140(63) Guam 195 (87) 150(67) 160(72)
150(67) Virgin Islands 165 (74) 170(76)
160(72) American Samoa 160 (72)
Hawaii Special Wind Region Statewide
160(72) Puerto Rico

Notes:
1. Values are nominal design 3-second gust wind speeds in miles per hour (m/s) at 33 ft (10m) above ground for Exposure C category.
2. Linear interpolation between contours is permitted.
3. Islands and coastal areas outside the last contour shall use the last wind speed contour of the coastal area.
4. Mountainous terrain, gorges, ocean promontories, and special wind regions shall be examined for unusual wind conditions.
5. Wind speeds correspond to approximately a 7% probability of exceedance in 50 years (Annual Exceedance Probability = 0.00143, MRI = 700 Years).

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 30


New V700/√1.6 vs. ASCE 7-05
110
130

140

110

110

140
120
150 130 130
150

140

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 31


1700 Year RP Winds
120(54)

130(58)
140(63)
115(52) 150(67)

160(72)
120(54)

150(67)
120(54)

160(72)

160(72)
150(67)
140(63) 130(58)
120(54)
150(67)
115(51) 160(72)
170(76)
170(76) 180(80)
180(80)
190(85)
115(51) 120(54)
160(72) 200(89)
120(54) 130(58)
150(67)
140(63) 200(89)
130(58)
Special Wind Region
140(63)
Location Vmph (m/s) 170(76)
150(67) 160(72)
165(74) Guam 210 (94)
Virgin Islands 175 (78) 180(80)
American Samoa 170 (76)
165(74) Hawaii Special Wind Region Statewide Puerto Rico

Notes:
1. Values are nominal design 3-second gust wind speeds in miles per hour (m/s) at 33 ft (10m) above ground for Exposure C category.
2. Linear interpolation between contours is permitted.
3. Islands and coastal areas outside the last contour shall use the last wind speed contour of the coastal area.
4. Mountainous terrain, gorges, ocean promontories, and special wind regions shall be examined for unusual wind conditions.
5. Wind speeds correspond to approximately a 3% probability of exceedance in 50 years (Annual Exceedance Probability = 0.000588, MRI = 1700 Years).

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 32


300 Year RP Winds
105(47)

110(49)
100(45) 120(54)
130(58)

140(63)
105(47)

105(47)
130(58)
140(63)

140(63) 130(58)
120(54)
110(49)
105(47) 130(58)
140(63)
150(67)
150(67) 160(72)

105(47) 105(47) 170(76)


110(49) 140(63)
120(54) 130(58) 170(76)
110(49)
120(54) Speical Wind Region
130(58) 140(63) 150(67)
140(63) Location Vmph (m/s)
160(72)
150(67) Guam 180 (80)
Virgin Islands 150 (67)
American Samoa 150 (67) Puerto Rico
150(67) Hawaii Special Wind Region Statewide

Notes:
1. Values are nominal design 3-second gust wind speeds in miles per hour (m/s) at 33 ft (10m) above ground for Exposure C category.
2. Linear interpolation between contours is permitted.
3. Islands and coastal areas outside the last contour shall use the last wind speed contour of the coastal area.
4. Mountainous terrain, gorges, ocean promontories, and special wind regions shall be examined for unusual wind conditions.
5. Wind speeds correspond to approximately a 15% probability of exceedance in 50 years (Annual Exceedance Probability = 0.00333, MRI = 300 Years).

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 33


Wind speeds at selected locations
Location ASCE 7-05
Exposure C V700 / 1.6
Exposure C Exposure D
Bar Harbor, Maine 97 95 103
Boston, MA 106 103 112
Hyannis, MA 117 112 122
New Port, RI 117 109 119
Southampton, NY 120 110 119
Atlantic City, NJ 114 102 111
Wrightsville Beach, NC 132 119 129
Folly Beach, SC 131 115 125
Miami Beach 145 136 148
Clearwater, FL 128 115 125
Panama City, FL 129 107 116
Biloxi, MS 138 129 140
Galveston, TX 131 119 129
Port Aransas, TX 134 117 127
Hawaii 105 103 112
Guam 170 155 168

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 34


ASCE 7-10
Strength Design Load Combinations
 1.4D
 1.2D + 1.6L + 0.5(Lr or S or R)
 1.2D + 1.6(Lr or S or R) + (L or 0.5W)
 1.2D + 1.0W + L + 0.5(Lr or S or R)
 1.2D + 1.0E + L + 0.2S
 0.9D+ 1.0W
 0.9D + 1.0E

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 35


ASCE 7-10
Allowable Stress Design Load Combinations

 D
 D+L
 D + (Lr or S or R )
 D + 0.75L + 0.75(Lr or S or R)
 D + (0.6W or 0.7E)
 D + 0.75L + 0.75(0.6W) + 0.75(Lr or S or R)
 D + 0.75 L + 0.75 (0.7 E) + 0.75S
 0.6D + 0.6W
 0.6D + 0.7E

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 36


Windborne Debris Region
 Current Standard
 V > 120 or 110 within one mile of coast
 Exact Mapping (new 700 year map)
 120√1.6=152~150
 110√1.6=139~140
 New Standard
 V > 140 or 130 within one mile of coast
 Results in less area within WBD Region
than the existing standard
NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 37
NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 38
NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 39
39
Reintroduction of Exposure D in
Hurricane- Prone Regions

 Older research and modeling suggested


roughness of ocean approached
Exposure C with increase in wind speed
 Hence ASCE 7-98, -02, and -05
classified water surfaces in hurricane-
prone regions as Exposure C

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 40


Reintroduction of Exposure D in
Hurricane- Prone Regions
 New research suggests hurricane
coastline matches the exposure
description for Exposure D
 Roughness of ocean does not
continue to increase with increasing
wind speed.

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 41


Exposure D
1.20
Gust Wind Speed Ratio (Marine/Land)

1.15

1.10

1.05

1.00

0.95
Vickery et al. (2000a)
Vickery et al. (2008a), RMW=20 km
0.90 Vickery et al. (2008a), RMW=40 km
Vickery et al. (2008a), RMW=80 km
0.85

0.80
30 40 50 60 70
Mean Wind Speed at 10m Over Water (m/sec)

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 42


Summary of Wind Maps
 Use individual maps for structures with
different life-safety concerns rather than using
Importance Factors
 A 1.0 load factor for LRFD (same as Seismic)
 A 0.6 load factor for ASD design
 The result is consistent with the intent of ASCE
7-98 and better represents life-safety
objectives
 Exposure D must be used on hurricane
coastlines
 Serviceability wind load maps are in Appendix
C
NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 43
New Simplified Procedure

 Applicable to buildings less than or


equal to 160 ft in height
 Simple diaphragm buildings
 Frequency limitations and torsional
limitations
 Tabular loads for MWFRS and
Components and Cladding

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 44


Simplified Wind Design - MWFRS
Chapter 27 - Part 2

 Simple diaphragm buildings


 Enclosed building (GCpi = + or – 0.18)
 h ≤ 160 feet
 Flat, monoslope, mansard roofs, gable
roofs
 Based on ASCE 7-10 Figure 27.4-1 – Part 1
Traditional “Directional Approach”

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 45


Simple Diaphragm Building
 Building -
with vertically spanning wall systems
in which both windward and leeward
wind loads are transmitted through floor
and roof diaphragms (rigid or flexible)
to the same MWFRS

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 46


Simple Diaphragm Building
Main Wind Force
Resisting System
(MWFRS)
rigid or flexible floor
diaphragms

Vertically spanning walls

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 47


Simplified 160 ft Method
Two Classes of Buildings

Class 1:
B
 Simple diaphragm building
L
 h ≤ 60 ft
 0.2 ≤ L/B ≤ 5.0
 Kzt = 1.0 or calculated h

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 48


Assumptions – Class 1 Bldgs

 Rigid or flexible diaphragm enclosed buildings


 h ≤ 60 ft.
 0.2 ≤ L/B ≤ 5.0 (interpolate between)
 No topographic effects (Kzt = 1) or calculate
 Symmetric placement MWFRS
 MWFRS placed so that torsion does not control
(guidance provided)

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 49


Simplified 160 ft Method
Two Classes of Buildings

Class 2: B
L
 Simple diaphragm building
 60 ≤ h ≤ 160 ft
 0.5 ≤ L/B ≤ 2.0
 Kzt = 1.0 or calculated h

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 50


Assumptions – Class 2 Bldgs

 Rigid or flexible diaphragm enclosed buildings


 h = 60 – 160 ft.
 Period T = h/75 seconds (upper bound)
 Damping = 1.5% (lower bound)
 L/B = 0.5. 1.0, 2.0 (interpolate between)
 No topographic effects (Kzt = 1) or calculate
 Symmetric placement MWFRS elements
 MWFRS placed so that torsion does not control
(guidance provided)

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 51


Why is Building Period Important?

 Related to mass and stiffness of building


 Stiffness affects drift and motion perception
 Mass affects wind forces
 Mass affects seismic forces
 Mass affects motion perception
 Period affects Gust Effect Factor, thus pressure p
 Buildings with high periods interact more with the
wind
 Note:
 Higher Period T is conservative (opposite from
seismic!)

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 52


Wall Pressures

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 53


Internal pressure GCpi
• Affects M, V, uplift in
one story rigid frame buildings
• Cancels out in simple
diaphragm buildings

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 54


Wind Pressure Equation

p  qGf Cp  qi GCp   - General Equation (27.4-2)

p  qG f C p - For simple diaphragm buildings


pz  G f qzC pw  qhC pl  - windward, leeward walls

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 55


Wind Pressure Vs Height
ASCE 7-05
p = 1.04p160
160

140
h=160 ft. ASCE 7-05 Exact
120 V=120 MPH
Exposure C Simplified
100
Height (ft)

T=h/75
80 Damping=1%

60

40

20
p15
0
40 42 44 46 48 50 52 54 56 58 60 62 64 66 68 70
Pressure (psf)

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 56


Wind Load Equations
ph
Pressure (psf): Table values
pz = p0 (1 - z / h) + (z / h) ph pz
z
p0

Story Shear (pounds):


vz = 0.5(h - z) [(p0 (1 - z / h) + ph (1 + z / h)] vz
z

Overturning Moment (ft.-pounds):


mz = 1/3 (h - z)2 [0.5p0 (1 – z / h) + ph (1 + 0.5 z / h)]
mz
z

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 57


Tabularized
Wall
Pressures

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 58


Story Shear Vs Height
Exact vs Simplified

160
150
140
130
120
110
100
Height (ft)

90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000
Story Shear (pounds)

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 59


Story Moment Vs Height
Exact vs Simplified

160
150
140
130
120
110
100
Height (ft)

90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0 100000 200000 300000 400000 500000 600000 700000
Moment (foot-pounds)

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 60


Roof Pressures - MWFRS

Roof Pressure Zones

Roof Shapes:
• Flat
• Gable
• Hip
• Monoslope
• Mansard

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 61


Height h (ft) Roof Slope Roof Zone V (MPH)

Exposure B,C,D
Tables

Pressure (psf)
NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions (Two
62 load cases
for sloped roofs)
Example Problem

 Building is 100 ft. tall with flat roof


 The wind speed from ASCE 7-05 was 140
mph
 Ocean exposure
 Category II enclosed building
 Dimensions are B = 40 ft. and L = 200 ft.
 Determine pressures at 100 ft. using All
heights method of ASCE 7-05, ASCE 7-10,
and the Simplified Method for buildings less
than 160 ft. from ASCE 7-10
NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 63
Comparative Results
Engineering Windward Wall Roof Edge
Standard (psf) Zone (psf)
ASCE 7-05 73.94 -81.25
Exposure C
ASCE 7-10 83.85 -92.14
Exposure D
Simplified 111.85 -95.82
Exposure D

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 64


Components and Cladding
Chapter 30 – Part 4
ph = qh [(G Cp) – (GCpi)] = qh (GCp)net

GCpi values for enclosed buildings are taken as +(-) 0.18.


GCp values :
• Flat roofs – Fig. 30.6-1 for zones 1-3
• Gable roofs, mansard roofs – Fig. 30.4-2A, B, C for
zones 1-3
• Hip roofs – Fig. 30.4-2B for zones 1-3
• Monoslope roofs – Fig. 30.4-5A, B for zones 1-3
• Wall zones 4 and 5 for all cases from Fig. 30.6-1.
• Table pressures based on h and qh

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 65


Component and Cladding

Wall and Roof Zones

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 66


Component and Cladding Pressures

Roof Shape Exposure C


Height h (ft) Load Case Zone
Effective Wind
Area = 10 sf

V (mph)

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 67


Exposure Amplification Factor

Roof and Wall Pressures - Components and Cladding


Exposure Amplification Factor

160

150

140 Exp. Ampl. Factor

130
B/C
h (ft)
160
150
B/C
0.81
0.80
D/C
1.11
1.12
D/C
Multiplier to
120

110
140
130
0.80
0.80
1.12
1.12 Table pressures
Building height h (ft)

120 0.79 1.12


100
110 0.79 1.13
90 100 0.78 1.13
90 0.77 1.14
80 80 0.77 1.14
70

60
70
60
0.76
0.75
1.15
1.15 Exp B, D
50 0.74 1.16
40 0.73 1.17
50
30 0.71 1.18
40 20 0.69 1.20
15 0.68 1.21
30

20

10
0.65 0.70 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90 0.95 1.00 1.05 1.10 1.15 1.20 1.25
Ratio Exposure B/C, D/C

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 68


Reduction Factors - Effective Wind
Area
Reduction Factors
Effective Wind Area
Roof type/case
1.1

A
1 1.0

0.9 0.9
C
Reduction Factor

D
0.8 0.8

0.7 0.7

0.6 0.6

0.5
1 10 20 50 100 200 500 1000
Effective Wind Area (sf)

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 69


Other Changes
 30 items approved by the Wind Load
Subcommittee
 Examples:
 Improved “roughness” definitions and examples
 Revisions to low-rise “envelope” method
 Guidelines on wind-tunnel testing
 Reduced minimum load on projected area of roof
 etc, etc.

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 70


Questions?
bcoulbourne@atcouncil.org

NCSEA Webinar –ASCE 7-10 Changes in Wind Load Provisions 71

You might also like