You are on page 1of 11

Int J Legal Med (2016) 130:1557–1566

DOI 10.1007/s00414-016-1395-3

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Estimating the postmortem interval of human skeletal remains


by analyzing their optical behavior
V. Sterzik 1,2 & T. Jung 2 & K. Jellinghaus 2 & M. Bohnert 2

Received: 17 March 2016 / Accepted: 27 May 2016 / Published online: 4 June 2016
# Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2016

Abstract The aim of this study was to figure out a new prac- Introduction and literature review
tically applicable method to distinguish between historical and
recent human skeletal remains. Therefore, the optical behavior Determining the postmortem interval of human skeletal
of bone cross sections was investigated using the combination remains is a challenging part in daily practice of forensic
of two methods: a modification of an already established test osteology. In order to clarify if further criminal investigations
(UV-induced fluorescence) and a new method (490 nm-in- by law enforcement agencies are necessary, the postmortem
duced fluorescence). We evaluated the areal extent of fluo- interval (PMI) plays an important role. Skeletal remains can
rescence of 30 bone cross sections with known postmortem either be historical or recent. In a historical case, there will
interval (PMI) using ultraviolet light and 490 nm light. For most likely be no interest in criminal investigations. On the
analysis, the areal extend of fluorescent surface was deter- contrary, further criminal investigations might be needed if
mined using photos of the samples and an image editing human skeletal remains turn out to be recent. Therefore, it is
software. The results prove that there is a correlation be- of criminal interest to distinguish between historical and re-
tween PMI and the areal extent of fluorescent surface in cent human skeletal remains by estimating their postmortem
both tests. Furthermore, the combination of both methods interval [1]. To do so, different methods have been used and
is a good indicator to distinguish within the forensic rele- described so far.
vant post mortem interval between PMI < 30 years and
PMI > 30 years.
Radionuclide tests

Keywords Lumatec Superlite 410 . Forensic light source . Furthermore, methods analyzing radionuclides exist like
Alternative light source (ALS) . Human skeletal remains . the determination of radiocarbon 1 4 C [2–10], 9 0 Sr
Death time estimation . Postmortem interval (PMI) . Luminol . [11–13], 210Pb [13, 14], 210Po [14], plutonium [15] as well
Forensic photography . Forensic osteology . Fluorescence as 228Th, and 228Ra [16]. Initially, analysis of radiocarbon
seemed to be inaccurate because of its long half-life period
(5730 years) [5]. Subsequently, analysis of radiocarbon
content and thoughtful comparison with bomb-curve
values could distinguish human remains from individuals
who died before 1950 from those who were alive after that
* V. Sterzik date [2, 5–7, 10]. The relationship of values of the cortical bone
vera.sterzik@kssg.ch and the trabecular bone assists in the determination of whether
the values fall before 1963 or after [7]. Furthermore, radiocar-
1
Institute of Forensic Medicine, Kantonsspital St. Gallen, Rorschacher bon analysis of dental enamel and different bone tissues can
Strasse 95, 9007 St. Gallen, Switzerland provide valuable information relating to both the date of birth
2
Institute of Forensic Medicine, Julius-Maximilians-University, and the date of death [8]. The advantage of these methods is
Versbacher Str. 3, 97078 Würzburg, Germany that they mostly seem to be independent of external influencing
1558 Int J Legal Med (2016) 130:1557–1566

factors like e.g., the climate [4, 9]. Clear disadvantages are high et al., there is a correlation between UV-induced fluorescence
costs and an elaborate handling [9]. color and PMI [30]. However, they could not find a correlation
between PMI and fluorescence intensity [30]. Summarizing,
Spectroscopy methods the UV-induced fluorescence test is considered to be more
suitable to exclude historical material than to accurately deter-
Using Fournier transform infrared spectroscopy to determine mine the PMI [22, 30, 31].
the crystallinity index and carbonate-phosphate index ap- Besides, other procedures have been investigated to ad-
peared extremely useful to distinguish ancient and recent bone vance the PMI estimation of human skeletal remains. Those
fragments [17, 18]. Once you have access to Fournier trans- ended without satisfying results or brought along other disad-
formation infrared spectroscopy, it is a cheap and fast tech- vantages. Macroscopic and microscopic examinations e.g.,
nique [18]. Raman spectroscopy analysis of buried turkey can reveal important information in histomorphological
bone showed time-dependent results within an interval of changes [25, 31]. However, analyzing the microstructure of
12–62 days [19]. human skeletal remains could not satisfy as an only method to
estimate the PMI [27, 32–34]. Analyzing the citrate content of
Luminol tests bone seems to be a promising tool as long as the skeletal
remains were never exposed to temperatures below 0 °C
Inside the bone, hemoglobin can remain protected and under [35]. Besides the temperature limitation, the method is expen-
relatively stable conditions as long as the bone’s structure sive and time-consuming, though [35]. The Combur test, the
integrity is given during the postmortem period [1]. This is Hexagon OBTI test, and the RSID test have proven not to be
why analyzing the hemoglobin content within human skeletal of any help in estimating the postmortem interval [22, 36, 37].
remains can be a viable method in determining the postmor- Analyzing the adipocere formation seems not to be suitable
tem interval [1]. First used to detect bloodstains [20], luminol either [38, 39] as well as analyzing the length of DNA frag-
has later on been used to estimate the PMI of human skeletal ments [40].
remains [21, 22]. Craemer and Buck showed that it is possible To be usable in daily practice, methods to estimate the PMI
to distinguish between historical and recent skeletal remains of human skeletal remains have to be cheap and easily viable.
by spraying luminol on powdered bone, defining Bhistorical^ Both the luminol test and UV-induced fluorescence test fulfill
with PMI > 100 years [1]. Analysis with a photomultiplier these criteria. Results could be more precise though, especial-
tube revealed a significant difference between recent ly to determine a PMI of less than 50 years, which was the aim
(<100 years PMI) and historical bone samples (>100 years) of our study. Therefore, we used a new method: The analysis
with a cutoff at 11 % chemiluminescence intensity [1]. of bone cross sections with a forensic light source of 490 nm
Ramsthaler et al. [22] showed that a negative luminol test and a dark red filter. To improve the validity in PMI estima-
result (providing a PMI without forensic relevance) is tion, the new method was combined with a modified analysis
superior to a positive luminol test result indicating a short of UV-induced fluorescence.
PMI of <100 years. Thirty percent of the samples >100 years
gave a false-positive reaction [22]. Other authors claim that
human skeletal remains have a historical status already up Material and methods
from a postmortem interval of 50 years, though [9, 22–25].
A different luminol test described by Ramsthaler et al. was Material
considered not to be valid as an only method [26]. Cappella et
al. combined luminol tests with microscopically examinations Bones
and had 41.1 % of ancient bones reacting false positive to
luminol [27]. Nevertheless, the combination with macroscop- The femoral bones of 30 individuals with known PMI were
ic analysis decreased the false positives remarkably and there- investigated. Two samples were taken in the context of post-
fore may represent a promising solution to cases where many mortem examinations at the Institute of Forensic Medicine
fragments need to be tested quickly [27]. Würzburg. Twenty-eight bones were collected from aban-
doned graves at six different cemeteries. The postmortem in-
UV-induced fluorescence test terval for each grave was well documented and ranged from 1
to 49 years. There were different burial environments and four
The blue fluorescence has in former years been described as different types of soil (clay, silt, sand, and keuper). Most of the
an indicator for PMI < 100 years [28] and PMI < 150 years samples were affected by adipocere formation. Residues of
[29]. Later on, Ramsthaler et al. showed that UV-induced soil and soft tissue were removed, and the bones were cleaned
fluorescence of a cross cut bone sample can be an indicator with a brush and warm water. Cross sections from each bone
for a forensic relevant PMI (<50 years) [22]. Following Hoke were prepared using an oscillating autopsy saw (Buehler).
Int J Legal Med (2016) 130:1557–1566 1559

One side of the cross section was then ground with fine sand- Additionally, a negative sample (known PMI > 150 years) was
paper (1200 grit) to avoid reflection artifacts during the inves- placed left, and a positive sample (PMI < 14 days) was placed
tigation. Each sample was given a case number and was stored right. The light sources were arranged in an angle of approx.
in a dark, dry place with constant temperature (18–20 °C) in 45° to the cross sections surface and caused fluorescence (a
special acid-free cardboard boxes. The latency time until spontaneous emission of light). After focusing, the room light
investigation was added to the known PMI. A forensic has been switched off and a photograph was taken, showing
light source and an UV lamp were used to analyze the cross all three samples in one picture (Fig. 1).
section’s optical behavior. The results were photographically First, the photos of UV-induced fluorescence were ana-
documented. lyzed as to their areal extend of blue fluorescence surface.
Therefore, the image editing software Adobe Photoshop CS
Forensic light source 5.1 was used. The following steps have been performed
(Fig. 2):
The Lumatec Superlite 410 is a portable forensic light source
with gas discharge lamp. The following wavelengths have & After loading the image by the software, it was adjusted
been used to evaluate the cross section’s optical behavior in with the tool Bauto levels^ for visual assessment. In a first
a pre-study: 415, 440, 460, 490, 550, and 570 nm. Each wave- step, the size of the image was determined. Therefore, a
length was combined with additional colored filters: yellow, square with fixed size (1130 pixels * 1130 pixels = 1,276,
orange, and dark red. The most impressive fluorescence reac- 900 pixels) was used (tool Brectangular marquee^). The
tion was caused by 490 nm in combination with a dark red result was copied in a new tab for further studies.
colored filter. & The tool Bmagic wand^ (tolerance 50) enabled to identify
areas, which do not belong to the sample by simply
UV light source clicking on a black area. The size could be read in the
Bhistogram^. Subtracting this value from the overall size
For the UV-induced fluorescence test, a UV analysis lamp of the square gave the size of the sample in pixels. The
(Herolab) with two 8-W tubes emitting long-wave (365 nm) results were documented in a table.
or short-wave (254 nm) UV light has been used. Just the long- & In a second step, the proportion of blue fluorescent surface
wave UV light has been applied the study presented. has been determined. Using the tool Beyedropper,^ a color
selection in the positive sample was made (red 0, green
Photography 186, blue 203). To figure out how many pixels in the
investigated sample showed the same blue fluorescent col-
The 490 nm pictures have been taken with a Nikon D7000 and or, we used the tool Bcolor range^ (all > > color range…).
a 50 mm Nikkor lens. For settings were chosen ISO-100, lens The program calculated the number of pixels with a toler-
opening F-9, and length of exposure 5 s. To document the UV- ance of 75. The result was shown in the histogram.
induced fluorescence, we used a Canon EOS 600D with the & Dividing the number of fluorescent pixels by the total
standard lens (EF-S 18–55 mm 1:3, 5-5,6 IS II). The settings sample size calculated in the first step, you get the percent-
were ISO-100, lens opening F-36, and length of exposure age of blue fluorescent surface.
25 s. In order to take vibration-free pictures, the cameras have
been mounted on a tripod and focused manual. By visual inspection, the use of 490 nm light in combina-
tion with a dark red filter seemed to show the most interesting
Methods optical changes within the use of Lumatec Superlite. For that
reason, this particular combination was chosen and analyzed
Three bone samples were placed in the center of a box lined using a similar method as described above. The color selection
with black fabric (a Bphoto box^). In the middle, the 30 cross was made using the tool Beyedropper^ (red 201, green 152,
sections (the ones to be investigated) were placed one by one. blue 159).

Fig. 1 Arrangement of the


samples inside the Bphoto box^.
Left to right: negative sample
(PMI > 150 years), sample to be
examined, and positive sample
(PMI < 14 days)
1560 Int J Legal Med (2016) 130:1557–1566

Fig. 2 Step by step analysis (schematic) of the sample using Adobe Photoshop CS 5.1

The overall results were documented with Excel 2013 and UV-induced fluorescence
analyzed with SPSS (statistical package of social sciences,
version 22, IBM). There was a significant correlation (p = 0.009) between PMI
and the areal extend of blue fluorescent surface (Fig. 4). The
linear regression line shows the blue fluorescent surface
Results decreases over time (Fig. 4). The correlation coefficient
was weak (Pearson correlation r = 0.47, coefficient of de-
A total of 30 cases were analyzed. The PMI ranged between 1 termination r2 = 0.221).
and 49 years, and therefore, all cases had a forensic relevant In the following, a formula was created to calculate the
PMI (<50 years). Every sample showed a certain proportion of postmortem interval of each cross section. Therefore, X- and
blue fluorescent (UV light) and/or red fluorescent surface Y-axis were changed, and a linear regression analysis was
(490 nm). The measured data are shown in Fig. 3. used to determine the confidence interval [95 %] improving
Int J Legal Med (2016) 130:1557–1566 1561

Fig. 3 Measured percentage of


UV-induced fluorescence and
490 nm-induced fluorescence in
relation to the total surface of each
sample

the formulas accuracy: samples correctly (Fig. 5). Because we only had samples
available with a known PMI below 50 years, we used a PMI
y ¼ −1:046x½0:76 þ 32:651½5:33 of 30 years as the forensic relevant cutoff value. Among the
samples with PMI < 30 years, 78.9 % showed more than 1 %
areal extend of blue fluorescent surface (Fig. 6). By contrast,
y PMI interval in years samples with PMI > 30 years showed more than 1 % areal
x measured fluorescent surface of the bone cross extend of blue fluorescent surface in 54.5 %.
section
brackets confidence interval 490 nm-induced fluorescence

To test the equation, we calculated the upper and lower There was a statistical correlation (p = 0.002) between PMI
bound of each sample and compared the results with the and the areal extend of red fluorescent surface as well
known PMI. With the formula, we estimated 70 % of the (Fig. 7). Again, the linear regression line shows a decreasing
1562 Int J Legal Med (2016) 130:1557–1566

Fig. 4 Results of the UV-induced


fluorescence test. X-axis: PMI in
years; Y-axis: UV-induced
fluorescent surface in percent.
Regression line with
determination formula and
coefficient (R2)

red fluorescent surface with increasing PMI, Pearson coeffi- We used the same method outlined above to test the
cient r = 0.55 and coefficient of determination r2 = 0.3038. equation. The PMI of 18 samples (60 %) was estimated
Like described above, a formula was created to calculate correctly (Fig. 5). In the group PMI < 30 years, 16 out of
the postmortem interval of each cross section: 19 samples (84.2 %) showed an areal extend of red fluorescent
surface >1 % (Fig. 8). On the contrary, samples with
y ¼ −0:632½0:368x þ 33:14½4:92 PMI > 30 years showed red fluorescent surface of >1 % in
only 3 out of 11 samples (27.3 %).
Finally, both methods were combined. Thereby, in the
y PMI interval in years group PMI < 30 years, 14 out of 19 samples (73.7 %) showed
x measured red surface of the bone cross section an areal extend of blue and red fluorescent surface above 1 %
brackets confidence interval (Fig. 9). By contrast, in the group PMI > 30 years only 2 out of

Fig. 5 Results of PMI


determination without cutoff. The
results calculated with formula for
both tests; each were compared to
the known PMI. The figure shows
how many samples were assigned
correctly (blue) and incorrectly
(orange)
Int J Legal Med (2016) 130:1557–1566 1563

Fig. 6 Number of samples with


UV-induced fluorescence above
or below 1 % in the categories
PMI < 30 years and
PMI > 30 years

11 samples (18.2 %) showed an areal extend of blue and red to former works, we examined the proportion of fluorescent
fluorescent surface above 1 % (Fig. 9). Furthermore, in the surface (areal extent, percent of the surface). The second test
group PMI > 30 years, samples showed blue and red fluores- was performed at 490 nm: a completely new method not
cent surface or at least one value (blue or red) below 1 % in published before.
81.8 % of the cases.
& Evaluation of the UV-induced fluorescence:

Discussion Each sample had a forensic relevant PMI (<50 years) and
showed a certain areal extent of blue fluorescent surface.
The aim of our study was to determine the forensic relevant Therefore, we can confirm that the existence of blue fluo-
PMI (<50 years) in human skeletal remains more precisely. rescence is a sign for forensic relevant PMI (<50 years)
Therefore, we investigated a series of samples with known [22, 25, 28]. We were able to show a significant but weak
PMI ranging from 1 to 49 years using two different methods. correlation between areal extend of blue fluorescent sur-
In previous studies, the UV-induced fluorescence has been an- face on the one hand and PMI on the other. The fluorescent
alyzed as to its intensity and color [22, 30]. In contradistinction surface decreased linearly with increasing PMI. The two

Fig. 7 Results of the 490 nm-


induced fluorescence test. X-axis:
PMI in years; Y-axis: 490 nm-
induced fluorescent surface in
percent. Regression line with
determination formula and
coefficient (R2)
1564 Int J Legal Med (2016) 130:1557–1566

Fig. 8 Number of samples with


490 nm-induced fluorescence
above or below 1 % in the
categories PMI < 30 years and
PMI > 30 years

samples with the lowest PMI showed the largest fluorescent & Evaluation of the 490 nm-induced fluorescence:
surface, while the older samples displayed a wide variation.
The developed formula assigned 70 % of the samples correct- There was a significant correlation between the areal extent
ly (n = 21) and therefore proved to be a first approach to dis- of red fluorescent surface and the PMI. The areal extend of red
tinguish between recent and historical samples. In addition to fluorescent surface decreased linearly with increasing PMI.
analyzing the linearity, we considered the blue fluorescent The calculated formula assigned 60 % of the samples correctly
surfaces above and below a cutoff value of 30 years. We were (n = 18). Using the cutoff value of 30 years PMI, the PMI
able to show that a blue fluorescent surface above 1 % could correlation was much stronger than in the UV-induced
be an indicator for samples with PMI < 30 years (78.9 % of the fluorescence test. So, we were able to show that an areal
samples in group PMI < 30 years). However, the majority of extend of red fluorescent surface above 1 % is a good
samples in the class with PMI > 30 years also showed more indicator for PMI < 30 years (84.2 % of the samples in group
than 1 % blue fluorescent surface (54.5 %). So, taken by itself, PMI < 30 years). By contrast, in the group of PMI > 30 years
the UV-induced fluorescence test was only of little help deter- only 27.3 % of the samples showed an areal extend of
mining the PMI. red fluorescent surface above 1 %. So, taken by itself, the

Fig. 9 Number of samples with


UV/490 nm-induced fluorescence
surface above and/or below 1 %
in the categories PMI < 30 years
and PMI > 30 years
Int J Legal Med (2016) 130:1557–1566 1565

fluorescent red surface turned out to be a much more precise Acknowledgments This study is supported by a grant of the
Interdisciplinary Centre for Clinical Research IZKF of Julius-
method than the UV-induced fluorescence test.
Maximilians-University of Würzburg. Thanks to Katharina Jellinghaus
In both groups there are some outliers, which have a short for providing the bone collection. Thanks to Viktoria Rücker, Institute for
PMI and a small proportion of fluorescent surface. These sam- Clinical Epidemiology and Biometry, Julius-Maximilians-University of
ples are from different cemeteries with various types of soil. A Würzburg, for statistic advice.
reason could be the so-called sandwich effect. This is known
as reduction or inhibition of the UV-reflection in bones with a
short PMI due to remaining saturation with body fat [22]. On References
the other hand, one sample (PMI 28 years) was very much
affected by adipocere and showed very high fluorescence. 1. Craemer JI, Buck AM (2009) The assaying of haemoglobin using
Consequently, there have to be other factors that influence luminol chemiluminescence and its application to the dating of
human skeletal remains. Luminescence 24:311–316
the fluorescence in addition to the burial environment. Due
2. Cardoso HFV, Puentes K, Soares AM, Santos A, Magalhaes T
to the fact that we only had 30 samples available, the calcu- (2012) The value of radiocarbon analysis in determining the forensic
lated formulas have a high confidence interval. To improve interest of human skeletal remains found in unusual circumstances. J
the formulas, a higher number of bones have to be Forensic Legal Med 19:97–100
photographed and analyzed. 3. Münnich KO (1960) Die C14-Methode. Geol Rundsch 49:237–244
4. Prieto JL, Magana C, Ubelaker DH (2004) Interpretation of post-
mortem change in cadavers in Spain. J Forensic Sci 49:918–923
& Combination of both methods: 5. Taylor RE, Suchery JM, Payen CA, Slota JRPJ (1989) The use of
radiocarbon (C-14) to identify skeletal materials of forensic science
Both methods combined provided the best results. Among interest. J Forensic Sci 34:1196–1205
the samples with PMI < 30 years the majority (14 out of 19 6. Ubelaker DH (2001) Artificial radiocarbon as an indicator of
recent origin of organic remains in forensic cases. J Forensic
samples) showed the combination of blue and red surface Sci 46:1285–1287
fluorescence above 1 % (73.7 %). On the contrary, in the class 7. Ubelaker DH, Buchholz BA, Stewart JE (2006) Analysis of artificial
PMI > 30 years, samples showed the combination of blue and radiocarbon in different skeletal and dental tissue types to evaluate
red surface fluorescence above 1 % in just 18.2 %. Here, the date of death. J Forensic Sci 51:484–488
large majority of samples showed blue and red surface fluo- 8. Ubelaker DH, Parra RC (2011) Radiocarbon analysis of dental
enamel and bone to evaluate date of birth and death: perspective
rescence or at least one value below 1 % (81.8 %). from the southern hemisphere. Forensic Sci Int 208:103–107
Our results are in accordance with Hoke et al. who showed 9. Verhoff MA (2008) Forensische Osteologie. Problematische
that there is a correlation between UV-induced fluorescence Fragestellungen. Lehmanns Verlag, Berlin
color and PMI [30]. On the contrary, Hoke et al. could not find 10. Wild EM, Arlamovsky KA, Golser R, Kutschera W, Priller A,
a correlation between fluorescence intensity and PMI [30]. Puchegger S (2000) 14C dating with the bomb peak: an application
to forensic medicine. Nucl Inst Methods Phys Res B 172:944–950
However, our results prove the fluorescence intensity to be 11. MacLaughlin-Black SM, Herd RJ, Wilson K, Myers MP, West IE
an important factor (if the fluorescence is first linked to a (1992) Strontium-90 as an indicator for time since death: a pilot
special color and then analyzed by its areal extent). study investigation. Forensic Sci Int 57:51–56
It is currently uncertain by which component the fluores- 12. Neis P, Hille R, Paschke M, Pilwat G, Schnabel A, Niess C, Bratzke
cence is caused. Most likely, the reason is collagen fibers as HJ (1999) Strontium90 for determination of time since death.
Forensic Sci Int 99:47–51
recently described by Swaraldahab and Christensen [41]. In a 13. Schrag B, Uldin T, Mangin P, Froidevaux P (2012) Dating human
different context, Bohnert et al. showed that collagenous scar skeletal remains using a radiometric method: biogenic versus dia-
tissue of the myocardium can be detected under UV light genetic 90Sr and 210Pb in vertebrae. Forensic Sci Int 220:271–278
because of its fluorescence. So, the fluorescence of collage- 14. Swift B (1998) Dating human skeletal remains: investigating
the viability of measuring the equilibrium between 210Po and
nous tissue can be used to diagnose a myocardial fibrosis [42].
210Pb as a means of estimating the post-mortem interval.
If collagen fibers are the reason for the measured fluorescence, Forensic Sci Int 98:119–126
in our study as well is currently investigated. 15. Swift B, Lauder I, Black S, Norris J (2001) An estimation of the
The results are promising considering the comparatively post-mortem interval in human skeletal remains: a radionuclide and
small sample size in our study. For more significant results, trace element approach. Forensic Sci Int 117:73–87
16. Zinka B, Kandlbinder R, Haas G, Schupfner R, Wolfbeis O, Graw
larger test series need to be performed. In future works, human
M (2011) Radionuklidanalyse von 228Th und 228Ra - Neue
skeletal remains with a PMI > 50 years should be included, Methode zur Liegezeitbestimmung. Rechtsmedizin 21:124–130
and 50 years should be used as the cutoff value. In our 17. Howes JM, Stuart BH, Thomas PS, Raja S, O’Brian C (2012) An
study, the cutoff value of PMI 30 years was investigated investigation of model forensic bone in soil environments studied
since we only had access to human skeletal remains with a using infrared spectroscopy. J Forensic Sci 57:1161–1167
18. Patonai Z, Maasz G, Avar P, Schmidt J, Lorand T, Bajnoczky I,
PMI < 50 years. Nevertheless, the surrogating cutoff value Mark L (2013) Novel dating method to distinguish between forensic
of 30 years indicates a detectable optical change over time, and archeological human skeletal remains by bone mineralization
which is worth further investigations. indexes. Int J Legal Med 127:529–533
1566 Int J Legal Med (2016) 130:1557–1566

19. McLaughlin G, Lednev IK (2011) Potential application of raman 31. Doppler S (2008) Alters-, Aktivitäts- und Krankheitsmerkmale in
spectroscopy for determining burial duration of skeletal remains. der menschlichen Knochenmikrostruktur: Eine vergleichende
Anal Bioanal Chem 401:2511–2518 Studie einer individualaltersbekannten historischen Population mit
20. Specht W (1937) Die Chemilumineszenz des Hämins, ein rezenten Menschen. Ludwig-Maximilians-University Munich
Hilfsmittel zur Auffindung und Erkennung forensisch wichtiger 32. Bell LS, Skinner MF, Jones SJ (1996) The speed of post-mortem
Blutspuren. Dtsch Z Gesamte Gerichtl Med 28: 225–234 change to the human skeleton and its taphonomic significance.
21. Itrona FJ, Di Vella G, Campobasso CP (1999) Determination of Forensic Sci Int 82:129–140
postmortem interval from old skeletal remains by image analysis 33. Hackett CJ (1981) Microscopical focal destruction (tunnels) in ex-
of luminol test results. J Forensic Sci 44:535–538 humed human bones. Med Sci Law 21:243–265
22. Ramsthaler F, Ebach SC, Birngruber CG, Verhoff MA (2011) 34. Yoshino M, Kimijima T, Miyasaka S, Sato H, Seta S (1991)
Postmortem interval of skeletal remains through the detection of Microscopical study on estimation of time since death in skeletal
intraosseal hemin traces. A comparison of UV-fluorescence, remains. Forensic Sci Int 49:143–158
luminol, Hexagon-OBTI, and Combur tests. Forensic Sci Int 35. Schwarcz HP, Agur K, Jantz LM (2010) A new method for deter-
209:59–63 mination of postmortem interval: citrate content of bone. J Forensic
23. Bonte W, Johansson J, Garbe G, Berg S (1976) Die Bestimmung Sci 55:1516–1522
des Aminosäurenspektrums als Hilfsmittel bei der Datierung von
36. Ebach SC, Ramsthaler F, Birngruber CG, Verhoff MA (2010)
Skelettfunden. Arch Kriminol 158:163–174
Bestimmung des postmortalen Intervalls von Knochenproben: Ein
24. Holley S, Fiedler S, Graw M (2008) Makroskopische Abschätzung
Vergleich der Luminolmethode, des Hexagon-OBTI-Tests und des
des postmortalen Intervalls (PMI) unter Ausschluss einer forensisch
Combur-Tests. Arch Kriminol 226:38–47
relevanten Liegezeit - ein Vergleich von Literaturangaben mit
37. Ebach SC, Ramsthaler F, Birngruber CG, Verhoff MA (2011) Die
rezenten osteologischen Funden. Arch Kriminol 221:175–184
Anwendung des Hexagon-OBTI-Tests und des RSID-Bluttests im
25. Verhoff MA, Wiesbrock UO, Kreutz K (2004) Makroskopische
Kontext der Bestimmung des postmortalen Intervalls von
Befunde zum Ausschluss einer forensisch relevanten Liegezeit bei
Knochenproben. Arch Kriminol 228:114–125
Knochenfunden - eine Literaturauswertung. Arch Kriminol 213:1–14
26. Ramsthaler F, Kreutz K, Zipp K, Verhoff MA (2009) Dating 38. Forbes SL, Stuart BH, Dent BB (2002) The identification of adipo-
skeletal remains with luminol-chemiluminescence. Validity, cere in grave soils. Forensic Sci Int 127:225–230
intra- and interobserver error. Forensic Sci Int 187:47–50 39. Forbes SL, Stuart BH, Dadour IR, Dent BB (2004) A preliminary
27. Cappella A, Gibelli D, Muccino E, Scarpulla V, Cerutti E, Caruso V, investigation of the stages of adipocere formation. J Forensic Sci
Sguazza E, Mazzarelli D, Cattaneo C (2015) The comparative per- 49:566–574
formance of PMI estimation in skeletal remains by three methods 40. Kaiser C (2005) Untersuchungen zur Degradation von DNA in
(C-14, luminol test and OHI): analysis of 20 cases. Int J Legal Med Knochen und deren Anwendbarkeit für die Liegezeitbestimmung
28. Berg S, Specht W (1958) Untersuchungen zur Bestimmung der von Skelettfunden. Ludwig-Maximilians-University Munich
Liegezeit von Skeletteilen. Beitr Gerichtl Med 22:18–30 41. Swaraldahab M, Christensen A (2016) The effect of time on bone
29. Knight B, Lauder I (1969) Methods of dating skeletal remains. fluorescence: implications for using alternate light sources to search
Hum Biol 41:322–341 for skeletal remains. J Forensic Sci 61:442–444
30. Hoke N, Grigat A, Grupe G, Harbeck M (2013) Reconsideration of 42. Bohnert M, Jauch E, Pollak S (2000) The UV hand lamp as a
bone postmortem interval estimation by UV-induced autofluores- helpful instrument for macroscopic visualisation of myocardial fi-
cence. Forensic Sci Int 228(176):e171–e176 brosis during autopsy. Int J Legal Med 114:107–108
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without
permission.

You might also like