You are on page 1of 6

Grid Interfaced Solar PV Based Water Pumping

Using Brushless DC Motor Drive


Rajan Kumar, Member, IEEE Bhim Singh, Fellow, IEEE
Department of Electrical Engineering Department of Electrical Engineering
Indian Institute of Technology Delhi Indian Institute of Technology Delhi
Hauz Khas, New Delhi-110016, India Hauz Khas, New Delhi-110016, India
rajankumar@ee.iitd.ac.in bsingh@ee.iitd.ac.in

Abstract—This paper proposes a solar photovoltaic (PV) fed the pump is not operated at its full capacity. Furthermore, an
water pumping system driven by a brushless DC (BLDC) motor. unavailability of sunlight (at night) leads to shutdown of an
A promising case of interruption in the water pumping due to the entire water pumping system. To overcome these
intermittency of PV power generation is resolved by using a shortcomings, an external power backup in the form of a
power grid as an external power backup. The power is drawn battery storage is provided in a PV-BLDC motor-pumping
from the grid in case the PV array is unable to meet the required system [7]. However, a battery storage reduces the service
power demand, otherwise the PV array is preferably used. A life, and increases the installation cost and maintenance
unidirectional power flow control for the same is developed and requirements [8]. To get over this complications with a battery
realized through a power factor corrected (PFC) boost converter.
technology, an alternate solution is reported in [9-11] wherein
The proposed system and control enable a consumer to get a full
volume of water delivery throughout the day and night
a utility grid is used as the backup source in a PV based
regardless of the climatic condition. The utilization of motor- induction motor driven water pumping. These recently
pump at best is thus made possible in addition to an enhanced recognized technologies, in reality, interface a PV generating
reliability of the pumping system. The power quality standards unit into a utility grid. The prime attention is to achieve an
required at the utility grid are met by the developed control. The uninterrupted and full volume of water delivery regardless of
MATLAB/Simulink based simulations and the performance the operating conditions, whether day or night. However, no
analysis are carried out to demonstrate the applicability of the such system with a brushless DC motor is reported as of now.
system. This work aims at realizing a reliable water pumping based
on the solar PV fed BLDC motor drive through a PV-utility
Keywords—Solar photovoltaic; Brushless DC motor;
grid interface. A unidirectional power flow control is
Unidirectional power flow control; PFC boost converter; Power
developed to enable the power transfer from grid to BLDC
quality.
motor-pump in case the PV array power is not sufficient (or at
night) to deliver a full volume of water consistently. No power
I. INTRODUCTION is drawn from the utility grid in case a full radiation is
As the energy demand increases, the need for energy- available as the PV array alone is sufficient to provide the
saving measures have been rapidly increasing. The brushless power required by the water pump. A power factor corrected
DC (BLDC) motors play a vital role, being an energy efficient (PFC) boost converter [12] in association with the aforesaid
motor, in this trends [1]. In comparison with an induction control carry out the desired functionalities. The proposed
motor which is widely used in a solar photovoltaic (PV) based system also meets the power quality standards required by a
water pumping, the BLDC motors have a high power density, utility grid as per IEEE-519 standard.
high efficiency, high torque/inertia ratio and a high power An incremental conductance (InC) technique [6, 13-14] is
factor [2-3]. Besides these, unlike an induction motor, the applied for the maximum power point tracking (MPPT) of PV
speed of a BLDC motor is not limited by power frequency. array using a boost converter. A current sensor-less control is
This leads to a reduced size and an increased capacity of the adopted for the speed control of BLDC motor [2, 5-7]. The
motor [3]. voltage source inverter (VSI) is operated with the fundamental
Among the most promising and significant renewable frequency pulses, through an electronic commutation of
energy sources, the development of a solar PV technology is BLDC motor [2-3, 6-7], resulting in a minimized switching
reaching its mature stage [4]. Towards an energy saving, this loss and an enhanced conversion efficiency. The grid
technology plays an increasingly important role. Therefore, interfaced solar PV fed water pumping system is designed and
the solar PV fed BLDC motor drive indeed emerges as a worth simulated in MATLAB/Simulink platform, and its
combination of source and drive for an application such as functionalities are tested through the simulation results to
water pumping [5-6]. Despite an innumerable encouraging demonstrate the claims.
aspects, being an intermittent in nature, is the serious issue
with PV generation technology. This demerit results in an II. SYSTEM CONFIGURATION
unreliable water pumping with a PV based pumping system. The schematic of proposed grid interfaced PV fed
In the course of bad climatic condition, the water pumping is brushless DC motor driven water pumping system is shown in
severely interrupted. Moreover, the system is underutilized as Fig. 1. A PV array of 6.4 kWp, possessing a sufficient power

978-1-4673-8888-7/16/$31.00 ©2016 IEEE


Boost Converter DC bus
ipv iL1
L1 Three phase VSI Water
+ C +
vpv g1 vdc Pump
s1 s3 s5
- -
isa
isb BLDC
vpv vd isc
InC Control of PFC Motor
ipv iL2 s2 s4 s6
MPPT vdc Boost converter

iL2 H1 H3 3
is L2 s1 s6 6
+
vs vd g2 Pulse Electronic
- Generator Commutation

Single phase Bridge PFC Boost


grid Rectifier converter

Fig. 1 Schematic of proposed water pumping system

to run the water pump at its full capacity under the standard voltage, vdc is compared with a reference value, Vdc* which is
climatic conditions, feeds a BLDC motor via a boost converter nothing but a rated DC voltage of the BLDC motor. The
and a VSI. The DC-DC boost converter and the VSI generated error is passed through a PI (proportional-integral)
respectively carry out the MPPT of PV array and an electronic controller acting as a voltage regulator. The intention is to
commutation of the motor. Three Hall Effect sensors are used maintain the DC bus voltage at the rated voltage of BLDC
to generate the commutation signals. A 6 pole, 5.18 kW motor irrespective of the operating conditions. Subsequently,
BLDC motor which has a rated speed of 3000 rpm at 310 V the output of voltage regulator is multiplied with the rectified
(DC), is used to run the water pump. A single phase utility input voltage, vd to get a reference inductor current, iL2*. This
grid support is provided, via a bridge rectifier and a PFC boost is made to configure a current flowing through the inductor,
converter, at the common DC bus of VSI. The power transfer iL2 as the wave shape of vd, and place it in phase with the input
is controlled by operating the PFC converter through a supply voltage, vs. Consequently, the input supply current, is
unidirectional power flow control. The developed control appears in phase with vs ensuring a unity power factor (UPF)
enables a power transfer from utility grid to the DC bus if a operation. The sensed actual current, iL2 is compared with iL2*
PV generated power is insufficient to meet the power demand, and an error is passed through a hysteresis current controller to
otherwise no power is transferred from the utility. generate a gating signal for PFC boost converter.
The PFC boost converter is designed and controlled to be
operated in a continuous conduction mode (CCM). While
regulating the DC bus voltage, the control decides whether the
power from the utility is required to be transferred or not.
Under the healthy climatic condition, the PFC converter is
made indolent as the control obviates the power transfer. On
Fig. 2 Structure of the proposed unidirectional power flow control the contrary, when the water pumping is required at night, the
controller allows to draw a full amount of power required to
III. PROPOSED UNIDIRECTIONAL POWER FLOW CONTROL run the pump at its full capacity. In between the two aforesaid
circumstances, if a fraction of sunlight is available, a portion
The unidirectional power flow control, as its name implies, of power demand is met by the PV array, a transfer of
enables a power flow only in one direction i.e. from utility remaining power is thereby permitted by the controller.
grid to the common DC bus. The control meets the power
quality standards required by the grid in terms of total
harmonic distortion (THD) and power factor (PF) [12]. The IV. BLDC MOTOR SOFT STARTING AND SPEED CONTROL
structure of the proposed control is illustrated in Fig. 2. After At standstill, due to the absence of back EMF (Electro-
passing through a low pass filter (LPF), the sensed DC bus motive Force) a high inrush current is drawn by the stator
(a) (b) (c)
Fig. 3 Steady state behavior of (a) PV array and (b) BLDC motor-pump, and (c) starting performance of BLDC motor-pump, when only PV array feeds BLDC
motor-pump

windings of the motor which may harm the windings and PV array only, operation with power grid only, operation with
power devices of the converters. To prevent this current surges both PV array and power grid, and transition from one mode
at starting, the pulse width of switching devices is modulated to the another, to evaluate the dynamic, starting and steady
for a predefined interval. This practice slow down the rate of state behaviors of the system.
rise of winding current and hence confirms a safe starting. At
certain speed, once a sufficient back-EMF is generated, the A. Steady State and Starting Performance
pulse width of switching devices is no longer modulated and a This evaluation exhibits a soft starting performance of the
fundamental frequency mode of operation takes place. motor, and steady state performances of the PV array, the
The speed of BLDC motor is maintained at its rated value, motor-pump and the utility grid. The following sections
throughout the operation, regardless of the availability of describe these operating conditions.
sunlight such that the pump delivers a full volume of water.
1) When Only PV Array Feeds BLDC Motor-Pump:
This is achieved by the DC bus voltage regulation. A concept
of current sensor-less based speed control [6] is applied which Under the standard test condition, the PV array is able to feed
eliminates the phase current sensors and governs the operating the sufficient power to run the pump at its full capacity. As
speed as per the DC bus voltage. So long as the power grid shown in Fig. 3 (a), a full irradiance of 1000 W/m2 is available
backup is available, the bus voltage is regulated, no matter and 6.4 kWp power is generated by the PV array. Therefore,
what is the instant operating condition. However, in case the the motor-pump is operated at its rated speed and torque as
grid is not available, the DC bus voltage is not regulated at the shown in Fig. 3(b). No grid support is required in this case.
rated DC voltage of BLDC motor under bad climatic The various motor-pump indices refer to back-EMF, ea, stator
conditions, and the speed is governed by a variable DC bus current, isa, speed, N, electromagnetic torque, Te, and load
voltage. torque, TL. The soft starting performance is illustrated in Fig.
3(c). The stator current rises with a controlled rate which
evidence a soft start of the motor. A small ripple is reflected in
V. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION isa due to a pulse width modulation of the switching devices of
VSI at the starting.
A MATLAB/Simulink based simulation analysis of the
proposed system is carried out to demonstrate its behavior 2) When Only Utility Grid Feeds BLDC Motor-Pump:
under the various possible operating conditions. A 5.18 kW, When the water pumping is required at night, the motor-pump
3000 rpm motor-pump is powered by a 6.4 kWp PV array and draws a full power only from the grid. Fig. 4(a) depicts that a
supported by a single phase 180 V, 50 Hz utility grid. The peak sinusoidal supply current, is of 49.32 A is drawn at UPF
various operating modes are created such as an operation with while regulating the DC bus voltage, vdc at 310 V. The motor-
pump attains its full speed and torque as shown in Fig. 4(b).
Moreover, the THD and harmonic spectrum of is is shown in
Fig. 4(c). The THD is observed below 5% which meets the
IEEE-519 standard.

B. Dynamic Performance
The dynamic condition is created by a sudden variation in
the climatic condition such as the solar irradiance or an
uncertainty of grid supply. The behavior of the system under
these circumstances are elaborated in the following sections.

1) Transition from PV Array Feeding Pump to Both PV


Array and Grid Feeding Pump: To demonstrate this
performance, it is assumed that a full irradiance is available
prior to 0.3 s as shown in Fig. 5(a). Therefore, no grid support
is required and no current is drawn from the grid as depicted
(a) in Fig. 5(b). The operation of motor-pump with its full
capacity is also depicted in Fig. 5(c). A sudden depletion in
the solar irradiance is assumed at 0.3 s. The irradiance level
reduces to 500 W/m2 and hence an insufficient power is
generated by the PV array. The remaining power is now
required to be drawn from the utility grid. As desired, a peak
sinusoidal supply current of 27.03 A is drawn at UPF while
regulating the DC bus voltage at 310 V as presented in Fig.
5(b). The motor-pump operates without any interruption at its
full capacity. The THD and harmonic spectrum of is is shown
in Fig. 5(d). The THD is observed below 5% which manifests
the power quality standards in this case also.

2) Transition from Grid Feeding Pump to PV Array


Feeding Pump: This analysis assumes that the motor-pump is
initially operated by the utility grid as no PV array power is
available prior to 0.3 s as shown in Fig. 6. It is further
assumed that a full irradiance is available at 0.3 sec. This large
alteration is imposed to validate the system under the worst
dynamics. As the maximum power point is tracked as shown
in Fig. 6(a), the current drawn from the grid is reached at zero
value as shown in Fig. 6(b). The grid current reduces slowly
due to a time taken by the MPPT technique to track the MPP
of PV array. Nevertheless, the motor-pump is operated at rated
speed and torque ensuring an uninterrupted water pumping
with full capacity as shown in Fig. 6(c).

VI. CONCLUSION
A single phase grid interfaced solar PV-water pumping
system with a brushless DC motor drive has been proposed
(b) and demonstrated through its performance evaluation using
MATLAB/Simulink platform. The utility grid support as a
power backup has been provided at the common DC bus. A
unidirectional power flow control has been developed and
realized with a PFC boost converter in order to enable a power
transfer conditionally. This control has enabled an
uninterrupted water pumping with full volume of water
delivery irrespective of the climatic conditions. The power
quality standards have been met as per IEEE-519 standard. A
simple speed control technique for BLDC motor has been
(c)
Fig. 4 Steady state behavior of (a) utility grid and (b) BLDC motor-pump, and
adopted which has offered a cost-benefit. Thus, the proposed
(c) THD and harmonic spectrum of supply current, when only utility grid topology has emerged as a reliable and efficient water
feeds BLDC motor-pump pumping system.
(b)

(a) (d) (c)

Fig. 5 Dynamic behavior of (a) PV array (b) utility grid and (c) BLDC motor-pump, and (d) THD and harmonic spectrum of supply current, under a transition
from PV array feeding pump to both PV array and grid feeding pump.

(a) (b) (c)

Fig. 6 Dynamic behavior of (a) PV array (b) utility grid and (c) motor-pump, under a transition from grid feeding pump to PV array feeding pump.
APPENDICES [4] M. Malinowski, A. Milczarek, R. Kot, Z. Goryca and J. T. Szuster,
“Optimized Energy-Conversion Systems for Small Wind Turbines:
Renewable energy sources in modern distributed power generation
A. Parameter of Solar PV Array systems,” IEEE Power Electron. Mag., vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 16-30, Sept.
Peak power = 6.4 kW; Open circuit voltage = 294 V; MPP 2015.
voltage = 238 V; Short circuit current = 32 A; MPP current = [5] Rajan Kumar and Bhim Singh, “BLDC motor driven water pump fed
27 A. by solar photovoltaic array using boost converter,” Annu. IEEE India
Conf. (INDICON), New Delhi, 2015.
[6] R. Kumar and B. Singh, “BLDC Motor Driven Solar PV Array Fed
B. Specifications of BLDC Motor-Pump Water Pumping System Employing Zeta Converter,” IEEE Trans. Ind.
Number of poles = 6; Rated speed = 3000 rpm; Stator Appl., vol. 52, no. 3, pp. 2315-2322, May-June 2016.
resistance = 0.41 Ω; Stator inductance = 2.13 mH; Voltage [7] Rajan Kumar and Bhim Singh, “Solar PV-Battery Based Hybrid Water
constant = 78 VL-L/krpm; Pump proportionality constant = Pumping System Using BLDC Motor Drive,” Accepted for
1.67210-4. publication, IEEE First Int. Conf. Power Electron., Intell. Control
Energy Syst. (ICPEICES), 2016.
[8] A. Boussaibo, M. Kamta, J. Kayem, D. Toader, S. Haragus and A.
C. Grid Interfacing Components Maghet, “Characterization of photovoltaic pumping system model
R-C filter = 5 Ω, 5μF; DC bus capacitor = 8000 μF. without battery storage by MATLAB/Simulink,” 9th Int. Symp.
Advanced Topics Electr. Eng. (ATEE), Bucharest, 2015, pp. 774-780.
[9] Huang, “Photovoltaic Water Pumping and Residual Electricity Grid-
Connected System,” Chinese Patent CN 204131142 U, Jan. 28, 2015.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT [10] Wang Xing, “High-Efficiency Photovoltaic Pump System,” Chinese
Patent CN 203884338 U, Octo. 22, 2014.
Under the grant number RP02926, this work was funded
[11] Chen steel, Ai Fang, Sun Weilong, Guo Jing and Zhao Xiong,
by the Deptt. of Science and Tech., Govt. of India. “Photovoltaic Agricultural Power Generating Unit,” Chinese Patent CN
203859717 U, Octo. 1, 2014.
[12] M. Pahlevaninezhad, P. Das, G. Moschopoulos and P. Jain, “Sensorless
REFERENCES control of a boost PFC AC/DC converter with a very fast transient
[1] T. Maetani, S. Morimoto, K. Yamamoto, Y. Isomura and A. Watanabe, response,” Twenty-Eighth Annu. IEEE Appl. Power Electron. Conf.
“Comparing Brushless DC Motors: A Method of Suppressing the Shaft Expo. (APEC), Long Beach, CA, USA, 2013, pp. 356-360.
Voltage Even in a Grounded Motor Frame,” IEEE Ind. Appl. Mag., vol. [13] M. A. Elgendy, D. J. Atkinson and B. Zahawi, “Experimental
21, no. 6, pp. 29-35, Nov.-Dec. 2015. investigation of the incremental conductance maximum power point
[2] P. K. Singh, B. Singh and V. Bist, “Brushless DC motor drive with tracking algorithm at high perturbation rates,” IET Renew. Power
power factor regulation using Landsman converter,” IET Power Gener., vol. 10, no. 2, pp. 133-139, Feb. 2016.
Electron., vol. 9, no. 5, pp. 900-910, Apr. 2016. [14] D. C. Huynh and M. W. Dunnigan, “Development and Comparison of
[3] C. L. Xia, Permanent Magnet Brushless DC Motor Drives and an Improved Incremental Conductance Algorithm for Tracking the
Controls. Beijing, China: Wiley, 2012. MPP of a Solar PV Panel,” IEEE Trans. Sustain. Energy, Early Access.

You might also like