Open letter to the new Minister for Energy

“Power to the people!”

Dear Mr Ivan Collendavelloo

Congratulations on your election victory, although it’s a pity that the betrayal of your Caesar was
not more “Brutel”. We are somewhat bemused by your new appointment given that you have just
sworn to give your best advice to the President but say you need “technicians” to advise you. What
happened to meritocracy? Perhaps this is an inevitable consequence of a National Assembly over-
laden with lawyers. Will you ensure justice for future generations? We hope so.

Say no to coal

Yours is an important Ministry because Mauritius is under existential threat from the unrelenting
combustion of fossil fuels. How will life be when our beaches have disappeared due to sea level rise
and Port Louis is regularly flooded? You need to get out and convince fellow Ministers around the
world to speed their transition to cleaner energy. But how can you do that if you support coal?

We propose a way out: enact a legal moratorium on additional coal-burning power stations. This
force majeur will permit the CEB to renege on its coal supply and power purchase agreements with
CT Power without liability – and considerably increase your political capital. Otherwise, if we lose
hope for our future, what do you think will happen to yours?

Trash your “technicians”

Fossilised thinking within your Ministry and the CEB undermined the objectives of Maurice Ile
Durable. We were promised a renewable energy revolution only to find that existing strategies were
written in stone. Your “technicians” are stuck in the steam-age. Sack them. We have ample forward-
thinking, under-employed young graduates eager to fill their shoes.

Acknowledge alternatives

The future is bright; the future is solar. The only challenge with photovoltaic electricity (PV) is
matching instantaneous supply with demand. Before too long, cost effective electricity storage
solutions will become available. Until that time, there are many things we can do to integrate as
much PV into the existing grid as we can – along with a few more wind turbines. This means being
able to rapidly increase/decrease electricity generation from other sources – and gain greater control
over electricity consumption – in order to compensate for the inherent variability of sunshine and
wind.

Can we do this at a price that does not adversely penalise the poor? Yes! Here is our strategy in a
nutshell:

 Subsidise flexible, on-demand sources of electricity because each extra megawatt permits at
least an additional megawatt of PV and wind turbines.
 Terminate subsidies on PV because patriotic citizens are ready to install it at cost and it will
only get cheaper.
 Halt the construction of PV “farms” on green field sites because agricultural land is precious
and there is more than enough space on top of buildings.
 Encourage the use of electric vehicles with smart chargers because they can help match
supply with demand and they are the only form of transport that can be powered by the sun
 and wind.
 End subsidised electricity prices to industry because it discourages investment in saving
energy, for example: insulation, solar water heaters and heat pumps.
 Allow people to opt out of having a highly reliable supply and give them cheaper electricity
for accepting occasional blackouts; offer it to industry too.

Waste not

The flexible on-demand source we suggest is bio-methane produced by the anaerobic digestion of
organic matter. We can use the same technology that is employed at Mare Chicose landfill and St
Martin waste water treatment facility. As a matter of priority, it should be installed at the other
waste treatment facilities. With the infrastructure in place, food waste can be easily added to
increase bio-methane production. We will persuade our friends and families to segregate it – you
persuade the local authorities to collect it.

To increase production even further, energy crops – more efficient than sugar cane – can be grown
near the waste treatment facilities and fertilised by the residue from the digestion process. Until
electricity storage becomes widely available, the best place to store the sun’s energy is Nature’s way
– in plants.

Judge justly

Your “technicians” told your predecessor that if electricity in Mauritius were a bed, then the
mattress should be made from coal, with clean energy merely a thin sheet on top. Should we let
sleeping dogs lie? No! It’s already the eleventh hour and time to awaken the dreamers. Wouldn't you
be the first to confess that your inadequate qualifications render you incompetent to judge the merits
of our case? Let us contend openly with your “technicians”. Give us the chance to counter their
claims and we will give you the confidence to develop a credible, affordable and just Renewable
Energy Master Plan.

Accept the precedent

We are sorry if you feel scandalised by being petitioned in this way; but we have been appealing to
deaf ears for years. From the title of your election manifesto: “Gouverner pour le peuple – avec le
peuple”, you have encouraged us to believe you are different. We trust this will not prove to be
electioneering hypocrisy. As you well know, the final judgement – in any democracy – is delivered
by the court of public opinion.

Respectfully awaiting your response,

We are Legion. We do not Forgive. We do not Forget. We Love Mauritius.