Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Full Paper
Teknologi
Article history
Experimental study on Single-Bay Two-storey RC
Frame Under In-plane Lateral Cyclic Loading
M. Mohamed2, N.H. Hamid1,2*,N. H. Yasim2, M.A.Masrom3, M.I. Adiyanto4 and M.S. Syaref2
A half-scale single bay two-storyRC frame was designed in accordance to EC8 and
constructed using ready mix-concrete by including the provision for seismic load. This
research project can be divided into three phases. The first phase involves the design of
the two-storyRC moment resistant frame by reducing the size of model into half scale of
the normal building which usually constructed at site in Malaysia. The second phase
comprisesof the construction of the model which includes reinforcement bars caging,
preparation of formwork, concreting and curing process. The third phase was
experimental set-up, calibration of instruments and testing of the specimen under in-
plane lateral cyclic loading. A double actuator was placed at top of second floor to
supply the lateral load to the model. Percentage of drift was applied to the structure
starting from±0.01% until ±2.25% with incremental of 0.25% drift. The total number of
twenty four cycles of drift was imposed to RC frame. The ultimate lateral load of 158.48
kN in pushing direction and -126.09 kN in pulling direction was recorded at 2.25% drift.
Based on the experimental result, elastic stiffness is 4.04kN/mm, secant stiffness is
1.14kN/mm, effective stiffness is 2.06kN/mm and ductility is 3.51. It can be concluded
that the RC moment resistance frame able to withstand minor to moderate earthquake
because the value of ductility is ranging between 3 to 6.
Abstrak
Kerangka tetulang konkrit dua tingkat direka mengikut EC8 beserta peruntukan
bebanan sismik dan dibina dalam skala separuh menggunakan campuran konkrit
sedia campur. Projek penyelidikan ini boleh dibahagikan kepada tiga fasa. Fasa
pertama melibatkan reka bentuk kerangka tetulang konkrit dua tingkat dan seterusnya
mengurangkannya kepada separuh skala asal. Fasa kedua terdiri daripada
pembinaan model termasuk pembentukan tetulang, penyediaan acuan, proses
konkrit dan proses perawatan. Fasa ketiga adalah penyediaan eksperimen,
penentukuran instrumen dan ujian spesimen di dalam-satah bebanan kitaran sisi.
Double actuator diletakkan di bahagian atas tingkat dua untuk membekalkan beban
sisi untuk model. Peratusan drift telah digunakan untuk struktur bermula dari ± 0.01%
sehingga ± 2.25% dengan peningkatan sebanyak 0.25% drift. Sebanyak dua puluh
empat kitaran drift dikenakan kepada kerangka tetulang konkrit. Beban sisi muktamad
ialah 158.48 kN dalam arah menolak dan -126,09 kN dalam arah menarik dicatatkan
pada 2.25% drift. Berdasarkan keputusan eksperimen, kekukuhan elastik adalah 4.04kN
/ mm, kekukuhan sekan adalah 1.14kN / mm dan kekukuhan berkesan adalah 2.06kN /
mm manakala kemuluran mencatat bacaan 3.51. Kesimpulannya, kerangka tetulang
konkrit ini dapat menahan bebanan daripada gempa bumi kecil sehingga gempa
bumi sederhana kerana nilai kemuluran adalah antara 3 hingga 6.
1.0 INTRODUCTION
RC moment resisting
framewastestedusingdisplacement controlmethod
startingfrom drift±0.01% drift until±2.25% driftwith
increment±0.25%.Two cyclesofloading
weretestedforeach driftconsistofpushing andpullingforce
that represents first quake and aftershocks. Figure
4shows the loadingregimefor RCframe
compriseof24successivecycles. Figure 5shows single-bay Figure 6: Cracks pattern were occurred on columns,
two-storey RCframeisreadyfor testingaftercalibrationof beams and beam-column joints.
equipment take place.
Figure 7 shows the visual observation of diagonal cracks
pattern specifically occurred at beam-column joints at
±1.75% drift and ±2.25% drift. At ±0.75% drift, vertical
crack at beam and diagonal crack at beam-column
joint were observed. Increasing number and size of
cracks were observed when ±2.25% drift were exerted to
single bay of two-storey moment-resisting RC frame.
4M. Mohamed, N.H. Hamid*,M.A.Masrom,M.I. Adiyanto and M.S. Syaref/ Jurnal Teknologi (Sciences & Engineering) 72:1 (2015) 1–6
Kelastic=Fy/y (1)
Ksecant=(Fult-Fy)/(ult-y) (2)
Figure 11: Hysteresis loops for LVDT3. Keff=Fult/ult(3)
Table 2: Displacement ductility for single-bay RC frame 2. The ultimate lateral strength and lateral
Pushing direction Pulling direction displacement recorded at LVDT1 are 158.8kN and
Displacement 76.92 mm, respectively which reached at +2.25%
2 nd 1st 2nd
Ductility 1st cycle drift in pushing direction.
cycle cycle cycle
ult (mm) 76.92 77.28 -62.18 -62.04
3. The value of elastic stiffness is 4.81 kN/mm, secant
y (mm) 21.75 22.04 -27.46 -20.24
stiffness is 0.96 and effective stiffness is 2.06 for the
µ 3.54 3.51 2.26 3.07 first cycle in pushing direction. The effective stiffness
lies between elastic and secant stiffness.
4.5 Equivalent Viscous Damping
4. Displacement ductility of RC moment resisting frame
Equivalent viscous damping [EVD] is defined as the
is 3.54 in pushing direction for 1st cycle which lies
ability of structure to dissipate energy during earthquake
within the minimum range of ductility (3≤µ≤6) for a
and reduce the structural damages by adding either structure to survive under moderate to severe
active or passive damper to the structures. From the earthquake while the value of ductility in pulling
hysteresis loops which obtained from experimental work, direction is 3.51.
the amount of energy dissipated in one cycle of
deformation can be calculated by the area of one loop 5. The highest value of equivalent viscous damping is
(ED) and elastic strain energy (ESO) is determined by the 7.67% from first cycle at 0.5% drift and 4.36% from
area under the triangle at maximum lateral load and second cycle at 0.1% drift. The value of equivalent
displacement. The equation for the equivalent viscous viscous damping of first cycle is higher than second
damping is derived based on Chopra [14]: cycle because more energy is required in first cycle
to resist lateral force. First cycle is implies for first strike
eq =1/4 (ED/ESO) (5) of earthquake which usually is more strong
compared to the aftershock represented by second
Figure 14 shows equivalent viscous damping was cycle.
calculated for every drift using acquired dissipated
energy and strain energy for first cycle and second 6. The values obtained from the half scale model can
cycle. Based on the result, the value of equivalent be used to demonstrate how a real building will
viscous damping for first cycle is higher compared to the behave under moderate earthquake since the half
second cycle. scale model was obtained from a full scale basic
frame design. Therefore, the full scale design is said
to be able to withstand moderate level earthquake
with satisfactory ductility, stiffness and equivalent
viscous damping values.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to thank the Research
Acculturation Grant Scheme (RAGS), Ministry of Higher
Education (MOHe), Putrajaya, Malaysia, the Research
Management Institute (RMI) and Faculty of Civil
Engineering, University Teknologi MARA, Malaysia for
funding and provide the facilities to conduct this
research work.
REFERENCES
Figure 14.Equivalent viscousdampingforfirstand
[1] “Damage from Sabah quake costly”. The Star. 7 July 2015.
second cycle of each drift of hysteresis loop. Retrieved 10 July 2015.
[2] "6.0 trembler rattles Sabah west coast". The Borneo Post. 5 June
5.0 CONCLUSIONS 2015. Retrieved 6 June 2015.
[3] Farik Zolkepli (6 June 2015). "Sabah quake: 23 schools in six
Based on the visual observation, experimental result and districts affected, says Muhyiddin". The Star. Retrieved 7 June
data interpretation, the conclusion can be drawn as 2015.
follows:
7M. Mohamed, N.H. Hamid*,M.A.Masrom,M.I. Adiyanto and M.S. Syaref/ Jurnal Teknologi (Sciences & Engineering) 72:1 (2015) 1–6